on ete. —ai™*- — eee:sss ee eee Spe Vol. XV. “QLD STAND, KING SQUARE, CHARLOTTETOWN. % ° 4 ‘ Farniture Warerooms, 7s E subscriber feels grateful for all past favors, and beys to intimate to his old customers and the public in general, that he has lately added to his Establishment Machinery necessary to facilitate his Business in every branch ; and those whe wish to bay FURNITULNE that is made for use, in the most fashionable sty!es, and of the best materials, will do well to call und select tor themselves, before going elsewhere, from his wresett Stock, consisting of Walnut and Mahogany lrawing Koom Setts, i. e, Oval and Round Centre lables; French, Easy, Fancy bigh-back. Drawing, Dining, Hall and Bed Room Chairs, Green Plush and Haircloth seated; Mahogany Sice Boards, dial! Tables, Hat and Umbrella Stands, extension Dining Tables, French and Grecian Sofas, Coaches und Loanges (ae low as thirty shillings, Chests of Drawers and Cheffioneers, Hedsteads, Stretchers, Cots and Cradles, Leoking Glasses and Music Stools, Toilet Tables, Warh Stands, Wardrobes, | Mattrasses of every deseviption ; large md small Folding Clothes-horse and Towel Stands, Boot- stands and Jacks, Clothes Wringers, and a variety of other articles for general housebeld furuishing. WASHING MACHINES with or without wri erior to any imported, aud warrauted to give action, from S0s. to 130s. Twovery superior MAHOGANY BEDSTEADS, ’ : aud severaui good articles of Second-hand Furnitare, in Walnut and Mahegany. The above articles will be sold cheap for cash [ve Ail orders promptly attended tv in the Cabinet Making, Upbolstering, Turnin, and Jig Sawing &e¢, &e 1 very saperior CABINET ORGAN for sale, quite new, in Ash and Walnut case, five octaves, double bellows, with two blow pedals, tour stops, tremolo aud knee swell, very cheap for cash. MARK BUTCLER. May 15, 1865. Ku ~4 A CARD. fEXHE subscriber, in returning thanks to bis friends aud .customers for the | beral pa- ~_ Weekly Journal of Pol ‘*'This is truc Liberty, when Freeborn Men, having t COLONIAL LEGISLATURE, | LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL. DESPATCH ES—CONFEDERATION. (Continued ) Hon. Mr. Hevxrerson: Your honors, when [ consider all that has been said al- ready within the walls of this building, as well as ovtside, on the highly important question of Confederatien, | would not deem it necessary to extend my remarks on that subject to any great length. But on the other hand, the magnitude of the interests involved forbids my giviog a silent vote on the Resolutions before this House. The | conditions on which it is proposed that this} Colony should enter into Confederation have | been so thoroughly canvassed already, that the subject has become threadbare; there- | fore my remarks and your honors’ attention shail be chiefly directed to points that do bot so directly lie within the trodden path ‘as those already indicated. Confederation has received its guietus, for the present, in New Brunswick, but its friends among ourselves appear to be so captivated with | some grand ideas connected with it, as to | be willing to “ compass both sea and land | to make some proselytes’’ to this their favorite scheme. Aud assome of them at- tribute the opposition which that scheme bas to encounter, here and elsewhere, to| “ignorance and prejudice ” on the part ol | | anti-Unionists—-assertions which it is their | daty either to prove or retract—I, for one }will endeavor to prove the contrary to be| ithe case. It is not only our undoubted} right, but also our positive duty to ourselves | . . i and to our posterity to enquire as carefully | i as we can into the character and institutions | of any people, whether great or swali, with | whom we are called upon to cast in our lot, | i ea SVS Sy Charlottetown, Prince Edward tics, Lit o advise the rd Island, Monday, May 29, 1865. erature, and glows. Public, may speak free.*’---Euripides. —— en aneaeansonanaaoeansnaneanenmsendaneaaaenaieanaaneliinecaetne adie Scene eon ————————S ee ew Series.---No. 26. hononrs, in this single admission and its | the better pleased. The defence question is |of afew years we would probably lose one} corrupt as they sre represented to be their appendix, which is buta sample of the many the next that ells for serious atteution ; and | of our representatives, then another, and an-/| credit would not be worth a rap in England. | modation of a wharf if we did not pay for negatives in circulation, we have a clear/|on that also the Unionists and I are at is- proof that the more positive and substantial |sue. For while, like their protetypes in arguments in favor of Confederation, as far Canada, they represent our American neigh- as Prince Edward [sland is ooncerned, are | bours as prepared to * gulp us up” at an as few and far between as the indirect | early date—unlike Canadians in regard to benefits which that scheme would confer|Canada—they discourage our local efforts |upon us would be. Had the Conference | for self defence. Whether that is true pa- given any positive proof of a disposition to/|triotism I will leave it for this “Mouse to | ° . . . . . . j}make any due allowance, in a financial | judge. Buttime forbids my entering large- 1 oint of view, for our insular position, as } ’ = ly into the subject. It may be remarked, lifferent light. | the advaatages they would derive from the | swick would be the very first to participate | they did for Newfoundland — I, for one, | however, that in view of what the Govern- | would look upon the whole scheme io a very | ment of Canada have lately done, aod what But when the very reverse | they are still doing, to strengthen friendly of this is the case, what conclusion can we! intercourse between the two countres, we come to but that, while Newfoundland was | may reasonably couclude that, if auy serious co be virtually purchased, we were to be as/differeaces should unfortunately arise, it virtually sold, aud made a mere convenience | wi!l be occasioned by disputes about points of for the Canadians. The Hon. George | of international law or policy between Kag- Brown, of Toronto, in one of his speeches | land and the United States. In that case, delivered at Halifax, I believe, affirmed, in | Kogland herself will not shrink from taking most emphatic terms, that it was not their! ber proper place ia the quarrel, and these own political necessities that induced them | Colonies would do their best by her side. io desire a Federal Union. Let any ove| Whatever the British Goveromeat may ad- compare Mr. Brown's speech with the| vise us to do to strengthea the many ties speeches of the Hon. Mr. Galt and the| which bind us to old Kaglaud, and to her tlon, Mr. McGee delivered since, in Cata-| noble flag which has, for a ‘‘ thousand da, on the same subject, and they will, [| years, braved the battle and the breeze,” 1 think, fail to discover any harmony be-| trust that we shall do it in a way worthy of tween the former and the two latter./our origin, and of our present advantages. [he New Brunswickers have given a most} These being an outline of my views and sen- emphatic verdict agaiast confederation. | tiwents, how could L do otherwise than give fois is very extraordinary, in view of all/my h:arty support to the Hesolution belore ithe House ? It would enhanes| Hon. Mr. Anperson: Ido not intend to The | detain your honors long, but this 1s a ques- 'tion of such vital importance to the fucure | well-being of this Culony, that L cannot give well as the demand for manual labour of la ailens 450s upon it. Lthink it would be every description. In fact, if any genera! | very imprudent for us to go into the proposed advantages were ever to flow from the con-| union upon the terms which are offered to us. templated Union, which would extend be- | Wat could we gain by it?) As far asl can youd the Canadian boundaries, New Brun-| see, there is no clance of gaining anything, but there are many chances to lose. | think Intercolonial Railway. the value of every acre of their land. price of every horse would be increased, as tronage extembed te him since his comm: cncement | ** jor better, for worse,” before we perant in business, voald imtimate to them and the public generally that be Is prepared to execute orders in tne vanouw ¢ bes cammected with lis trade, ; tial ia to say + Carriage & Sleigh Painting, House, Sign, and BHYAMSURAL PAINTING, Plain and Decorative PAPER - HANGING, Carriages aud Sleighe always.on Land for sale in season, 1@ x 40 WinDOW wile Atso—A quantity of SASHES, with or without Glass, for Cush or appreved paper. for Se.e cheap no UF All orders from the couniry punc-|. tually attended to. EDWARD MARTIN. Residence, Kent Street. nearly opposite Jos | 4 . : Beort, Esq., Carriage builder ; length, after.a suspension of the Canadian 3m | ' Charlottetown, April.24, 1865. | | any sach compact to be consummated. Que | jor two brief extracts from the history ot | |; Canada may serve as an index to that) jenquiry, * A division of the Province into Upper and Lower Canada was effected ia | 1791: Mr. Pitt, the Minister of the day, jobserving that there was uo probability of| jre-uniting the jarring interests of the in-| | habitants but by giving them two separate | Legislatures. For many years the experi-| | ment appeared to succeed. In 1837, how- | ;ever, a rebellion burst forth, headed by | Papineau in Lower Canada, and McKenz’e| (ia Upper Canada.” The historian adds: | Probably there never was an insurrection | attempted with less reason or fewer gricv- jances by which it might be justified.” At| Coustitution, aud the dissolation of the ‘> ss am jwe Legi-latures, Lord D srhutm was sent | a ' 4 | Out to assume the reins of Government. © SS Pro mer | suppose that all your honors kuow something = cp a i jot the eveu's that followed —that the rebel- 5 ise ts ) “4 | liow was crushed, order restored, and the] = Gg = | preseat Union effected on the basis of an | a ae ia Sinenied _ Act passed en the 23d July, 1840, whew 2 oy <i | mm [ore. Paompson, afle. wards Lord Syden- = rane a ‘er | lam, was Governor General—tbat some ol = — A . ‘# | tbe more hot-headed of the Montreal folks, my -— 2 — 2s) ro | several years afterwards, made the Parlia- o ad — _, ww | ment building too hot for thir legislators, | fe ‘~ wv” | 5 = so that it was consumed to the ground with = ih cc ‘A nearly all its contents. At a date still = & rs Rae ts later, Rogulty was so little respected in the yy ~ = - same city, that the Governor General was ie ae =! {> > perfumed with rotten eggs in its streets, and = i gz) ae the * Stars and Stripes hoisted up to the G 2 2 3 ee em | breeze!” The population of Canada West = * @ se SG ‘er | have so outgrown the basis of their present | ~~ °° . 3 oer Union as to have brought the Goverwental | L— 7 os mej juffairs nearly to a dead-luck for several | es > uw a Ee» oom: a years past; so that they bad 10 fewer than | € re $8 | five Administrations during the short space | s =. © Q tol "2 \of two years. Then came to the rescue the | re 3 << | os coa ition project as a provisioual palliative e° a. ae tenet ~ |rather than a permanent remedy for exist-| s <i = | ing evils—au arrangement that may enable | a & - b TJ2 |them to hold together while a sense o!| 2 . = peg = danger from without tends to keep internal - — as pent differences in the back ground, and stil] > ee me" | further, while they are straiuing every nerve "3 t< laa Oe | to Bccure Confederation as a sovereign re- 7 fy p= wedy for all their difficulties, present and eM i on. | prompertive. Bos ia order, co fares [em NOTICE! } concerned, to repel the charge of * ignor- LANDS FOE SALE! YHE subscriber, as the Agent of Sir Samvuest Cunarp, Bart., The Richt Hon. Laveence Sccctivas, and Mr. Enwarp Cunanp, has been directed to diseontinue the eystem ef LEASING LAN DS—hevretciore pursegd. Yor the future these lands willde SOLD onthe terms :—A deposit of Twenty-five per cent. of the purebuse money to be paid down at the time of signing the agreement, and the residic in ten years by equal instalments. The price will be from Twenty shillings (20s.) per acre upwards. Further particulars made known at 4he Subseri ber’s office. G. W. DEDLOIS. Ch'town, May 15, 1865. SPECIAL NOTICE! TINUE undersigned have ap- pointed Mr. H. J. RICHARDSON, of Summer- side, their AGENT, where TOBACCO can be had at the SAME RATE as in Char- lottetown. LOWDEN & RICHARDSON. May 1, 1865. tf RARE CHANCE. FOR Sale, a very fast BLACK PONEY, 34 yeurs old, perfectly sound. ALSO, | set rm ney Harness complete, 1 Riding Saddle and Hiridle,! Halter, &c., &e.: I tollowing | Of Canadian affairs and character as that Box Sleig it, 1 Dog | | ance,’’ and to cast it back injthe face of thos: ; who prefer it, 1 may state, at this poiur, | that [ resided iu Canada from the latte: end of October, 1838, until the first of August, 1848. Duriog that time 1 was in positions to make fully as correct an estimate | wuieh some of our Delegates occupied dur- 'ing sojourh in that great Province in the month of October lust. For, while they jappear never to have looked beyond the | sunny side of any question or prospect pre- ;sented to them, I could and did examine facts and events, so to speak, from Groflin- |ton, as well as from the lowly mountain ; | from the lovely suburbs, as weil as from tic \QJuebee citadel. And well do L remember | some of the more prominent scenes enacted ia Griffinton during an election that came off in the year 1844. Ou that occasion ihe ‘leading rowdies of that place attempted to! ‘earry all belore them; bat when the 93rd Highlanders, then im garrison, Were cailed lout, they very soon compelied them to | draw.in their horns, but vot uusil they had | succeeded ia thoroughly smashing tbe win- | dows, ete., of a Wesleyan Cuape! in that | section of Montreal. These hints are cal- culated to give us a bird's eye view of Caua- | dian polities aad their general proclivities The way being now clear this far, it may b: asked was it wot right that the able siates- meu of Canada should seek a safe and suit- fin them. ld sadvantages, to accept the terms cfiered ? | But I suspect | called * Correspondence relating to the [n- japon the subject. Ina letter from Governor } the follawing oceurs: ‘approved signature, is to be regarded as a | thing of no weight, what Provincial obliga- | tisn may be looked }cannet suppose your Excellency’s advisers ‘can be iusensible to the responsibility at- | taching to the assumption of such a position ; | ;uor will L believe the people of Canada— even those who disapprove of the engagement | of 18 i risk of | injurious—tat, in that country important | much | fixed principle, but are taicen up, trifled | plain fact is that the peopie of New Bruns. | our independence Now, if it be still admitted that the offer is something like this: if we will other, till, in course of time, we mighs lose| People in England know the standing of| it. them all. I have heard it argued by a good politician, or rather one who [ thought till now was a good politician, that five repre- sentatives were as good for us as fifteen ; but 1 cannot see tie propriety of this argument. It five are as good as fifteen, then two are as good as five, therefore this reasoning is false. [ would oppose Confederation on the proposed plan, because while it might be a benefit to a few, it would be an injury to many, and we are bound in justice to support such mea- sures as would be a benefit to the great masses of the people, and let the few do for themselves. It might bea benefit to the few who would get into office, but it would be an injury to those who would have to pay taxes to support them. ‘Therefore I would oppose Confederation on that ground. In regard to the tariff and taxation, we would be put upon the same fvoting as Canada ; and we know that from the circumstances of the people it would bear very heavily upon them—that it would be injurious—and not only so but positively ruinous. It would also be unjust, for it would be taxing our people for large public works from which we would derive no benefit. Those railways per- haps be a little indirect benefit, but not such as to induce us to support them to the ex- tent which we would be ealled upon to do. And besides those large defensive works would cost millions of dollars, but they would be a benefit to themselves, for the works would be going on, and the money expended ameng themselves, while we would receive no benefit from thea in that way. ‘Lhere- ! fore I believe that, while we are in a pros- perous way we shoald try to keep so, and not jump into Confederation, which we would repent ail our days, and our children after us. I do not like to give a silent vote upon this question, though Ido not profess to go through the whole subject in ali its bearings as some do; neither do I think it is necessary to go minutely into the financial part of the scheme again, as that part of the question has been so well explained by your honors who preceded me. : r > . ’ give up one-half of our revenue to the Cana- in this the New Bruaswick people have not | diane, and allow them to tax us as much as acted contrary to sound reason, | ask would | they please, they would then take charge ot it not be perfect maduess in us, with all our/us. We fought hard and contended long for Responsible Government, and are We now go- ing togive up or constitution and say we are not able to govern ourselves? Ido not think that any man or any body of men in Canada can know the wishes aud wants oj the people of this Island as well as we do ourselyes. Ani are the people of this Island, | which is marked out by the great Finger ot | Nature to bea separate Colony—parted trom | the other Provinces by an arm oi the sea— and bound up by ice for a great part uf the year, are we, I say to be called upon to as- sist in building every mile of their Railway, and contribute to the opening up ol their; Canals, which are more than a thousaod miles away from us, and which can never be any benefit to us? If we had been tuld that they would not ask us to contribute towards their | Railroads and Canals, and lor opening up the | communications to the North West Territory, hat the fo lowing extract tercolonial Railway,” will throw some light (rurdon to the Governor General of Canada, ‘* If a solemn agree- ment, deliberately made with two other Provinces, calmly considered, voluntarily entered into, coufirmed by your Excellency’s l upon as secure? | pene es dst si iad | but that they would expect us to contribute J—uavsire to see it overthrown at the to the ceneral defences uf the Colonies, the spreading abroad a suspicion which, | scheme would be looked upoo in a much more I, tor one, would not be so even if unjust, cannot fail to be generally | favorable light. opposed to it. I heard some of the interests of a permanent character are| triends of union say that, if the Colonies were a ° . oi ki all-n . i é icles ‘ id \lightiy deakt with. and grave questions of | ited, all productions of, and articles manu . , > ; , ‘ Fl tek t sighbering Provinces would inter-olonial policy decided, not on their | 'ctured in, the neighbering Pro = w seréie c. sondance with an} be admitted here free of duty, and that, they ow ’? ai . dan . a _—, el tag Be agains re ¥ | thought, would be an advantage; but if it ' . ; J“ | would, why could we nos admit them tree with, and abaudone, to suit the political | now, without going into the Uaion? Can ecigencies of the passing hour.” The| we nothave tree trade without giving up ? Look at New Brunswick. 4 : a ee a Bie ol : Sak ; wick have no covfidence.in the politicians of | Which stands es ges eee .. erive Canada. And when to this is added the} for going into the ; —. oe “ i. Bcitich baste with which it was astetant. 1°" advantages from it which we would - British haste as attempt- v rey =r ae : tie. not, being bounded by Canada, they can ed to force this schese upon these Colonies, | carry on their commerce and intercourse by aroused to no ordiuary degree. | their own constituents, maintained by some which saw wo immediate necessity for 80} railroad, in winter as well as in summer— radical a change in their constitution, as it | the question has been brought fairly before was natural for them, their suspicions were | the people, and, as far as we have heard the I would re-| result of the elections, they are decidedly mark here that the autagoaisin to the wishes, | #4ainst going pte the Union. Some of the aud | would say to tbe best interests, of | @08t popular men in the Province have 7 y F jrejected. Why, then, should we go into the | Union when they, to whom it would bea | much greater advantage, are opposed to it? i shrewd thinker suid as illustrative of ine | We had better act cautiously, and not take gratitude. It was to this eff-ct: ** when|astep in haste which we might regret for you band a ladder to 2 man to go up, he years, and which might be a misivrtune to . . | - 7 . " «9 fe unmediately turns his back upon you.” [f | those who will come after us. . . Mr. *‘Lraren: This, your honors, [ were asked to describe a consistent re-|, [on Ir. McLraren: This, y aad ae i ceee. deal is an all-important question, but it has been a ee ee thoroughly discussed that it is one reason he should be a miniatzre of bis constituents ; . why it is unnecessary to Say much upon it at or, in other words, that-he should reflect the | the present time. Another reason is, that lawful, constitutional, and weil ascertained | we happen, for this once, to. be all of the wishes of his people. it is true that, in| same opinion. It is well known to your ho- these times, important changes take place in| Nor’ What brought this et a - the course of a few short years which ma-| Phere was @ delegation authoriged ag ir . Bet by a Legislature last session, to conter with dele- terially changes peer SPOR = piace ea gates from Nova Scotia and New Brunswick the aspects of pablic affairs ; but still, under upon the subject of a Legislative Union of sach a cuntingeuey, the poiitician’s path of| the Maritime Provinces, and out of that eeu of our own politiciaas, reminds me of what | for their heavy taxes. duty is a patient one. He should use the best means ia bis power to convince his sup- porters that his views are right, and condu- cive to their best interests; or failing in that, he shou'd either keep bis owa views practically in abeyance or leave it optional with his supporters to ¢!:oose another repre- sentative. ‘The * glory argument,” as it is termed, is largely dwelt upon by our Uniouists to a man, in pressiog the claims of their hobby. been well answered by his honor the Attor- aey General, in his address late'y delivered in the Temperance Hal!l,iu which he showed that, with an independent gentiewan from Kozland as our Goverver, our young men of taleut aud education find a more direet motion than they would under Conielera- tion, when their chances would be, at the very best, but equal to 5 in 194. ha fact, those who lay uudue stress upon such arguments in so far as [ am concerned, may just as well try to make us believe that Jonai's gourd at Nineveh was superior to the palin trees of Paiesiine. Now, your hvoors, | lion. Mr. Lory: For my part [I am not prepared to make a speech, nor do [ think it 13 necessary, four there has been such a great deal said already both for and against this scheme. However, I will support the reso- lution before the House; but still, though I have heard a great deal said, and a great many calculations made, [ consider a great many of them to be visionary ; for mstance, the expenses of supporting the Federal Go vernment. The caleulations respecting those expenses are mere supposition. The best statesmen in Eogland could not make such calculations with any degree of certainty. It is all well, however, to keep on the safe side. A great deal has been said about the heavy taxation of Canada ; but see what they have to show for it. It is not a few bad roads and rotten bridges. None of the Bri- tish Colonies have improved as much as Ua- nada has within the last few years. If they are heavily taxed itis for the purpose of local improvement. I have a brother in Canada, and he docs not complain of paying heavy taxes or assessment. He says the advantages of the climate make up for all their disadyan- tages in that respect. I merely allude to this to show that there are none of the Co- lontes which can compare with the Canadas in permanent and solidimprovements. What was Canade a few years ago? Why, before the railroads were opened up, and the com- munication on the lakes, it would cost emi- grants more to go from Quebec to Canada West than it weuld cost them to come from Germany, or wherever they came from; but now they can go from Quebee to London, Canada West, without moving their luggage from the ear. There is not a word now about the debt of this Colony—no, people’s minds are drawn away from that; bat 1 maintain that, according to population, the people of this Colony are taxed as high as they are in Canada, including the rent. And where is the money expended? In Canada they have many noble public works to show We bear a great deal about the Canadian politicians being a cor- rapt set of men; but I just let these asser- tions go for nothing. I am not afraid to assert that the morals of the leading states- men of Canada will compare favorably with those of the statesmen of Prince Edward Is- land. Iam willing to let that statement go abroad. But withall! this Lam not prepared to go for the Union. It was not the delegates who made the great mistuke, but it was us who voted for that resolution last year to authorize the appointment of a delegation. Give these men aa inch and they will be sure to take a yard. What has the delegation done for us? It has cost the country up- wards of £1400. Those gentlemen pocketed a nice sum of money out of the public funds. [ have not examined the public accounts very minately, but [ suppose they had six or eight dollars a day besides their expenses. ilowever, though I do not approve of the de- legation, [ will support the resolution. fun. Mr. Beer: [ think it isa pity that i sprung this question now before us—a union his honor would vote for the resolution after |with Canada. A delegation was asked for iby the Governor General of Casada to con-; speaking the other Way. |fer upon the subject of a Federal Union of; Hoa, Mr. Lorp: I did not speak in favor the Colonies, and that request was granted | of confederation, but | spoke against those l by the Government of this Island. There | gentlemen who make assertions and allusions ‘are some who blame the Government for| withoug foundation. The subject has been taking this step without the consent of the\torced upon us by those famous delegates, That argument has) and sure path to recommendation and pro- | | Legisiature ; but L cannot see that they did janything improper. Before those who are }inclined to censure the Government would i say much, they should apply the golden ‘rule, and ask themselves what they would | do if they were placed in sidilar cireamstan- There are very few, L believe, who | would not have acted upon the same principle I must confess that [ am not favorable to Con- | | federation, but, at the same time, | would! | not be very bot against it. I would take | . . . | the subject into cool and calm consideration, | ces, jand weigh it without bias, and with a desire todo justice to advance the intercets ofall par- | Ges, The Convention was held in Quebec, jin October, and the result is before us in this |Report. It is an able and statesman-like | dveument, and is worthy of recommendation, a3 lar as those who drew it up are concerned. il do not think it is right to censure those genuewen who represented this Culony in ithas Convention. I caanut accuse them ol but af they bad to pat their bands in their own pockets te pay their expenses they would not have gone to Canada. Lion. Mr. Hznperson : Your honors I have no desire to aet the part of a resurrectionist by exhuming anything that should be allow- ed to rest in oblivion; nor that of an ** Old Mortality’’ in chiseling afresh the memorials of painful events any further than to deduce from them the lessons of caution and instruc- tion which they are well calculated to im- press, in regagd to present and future duty. Bat if his bunor from Prince County (Mr. | Lord) chooses to question the correctaess of | my remarks in regard to Canadian politicians | and their proclivities, | beg to assure him that | haye more facts in etore than I intend to parade this evening. I may be told that ** those who live in glass houses should not be the first to throw stones.’” [ admit the axiom in all its force, bat would add in reply, that the less we multiply such political must covfe-s that when the “glory argu- any intenuon to injure this Island ; bus oo | Cart, will be sold — a barwain. scriber at the ‘ Examiner’ Oilice. : F. W. HUGHES. May 15, 1865. ctr enen STELLA COLAS. Rimmel’s Stella Colas Boquet, dedicated by permission to bis taleuted Artiste “ Her beanty hangs upon the cheek o! night, As wrich jewel in an ethiop’s ear,” Perfumes for the Handkerchief: Alexandra, Guards, Fragepane, Prince ot Wales, Rimmel’s Lilly of the Valley, Jockey C'uh, Wood Violet, Milletleur Easence Boquet. Patchouly, Violet, Weat End, New Mown May, Love's Myrtle. Tie Bard of Avon's Perfume, in a neat box; Sydeubam Eau de Culogne, Treble Lavender Water, Extract of Lavender Flowers. Verbena Water, Tercentenary Suchet, Perfumed J ereenten- ary Souvenir, Shakespeare Golden Scente! Locket, Extevet of Lise Juice and Giyeerine, for making the Hair sott and ylosey ; Rose Leaf Powder, an improvement on Violet Powder; Bloom of Ninion, for the complexion; Depilatory Powder, for re- movig cuparhoves hairs without injury t) the skin ~-Napoleon Pomade, for fixing the Maostacheos, 4nd jastantaneous Hair Dye, for giving the Hair and whiskers a natural aud permanent shade with- out trouble and danyer. : em a Rose Water Crackers, a new and amus- ng device for eveuiny parties. me WM. R, WATSON. City Drug Store, Dee. 19, 1864. Apply tw the Sub- | able way of escape for that Province from} | its internal, aud of defence against its ex- iteroal troubles? It is right that they | sbould do all this, but we deny their right | {to seek or obtain our huable assistance to jany euch objects without our receiving good security tor a fair and just equivalent in returu. Does the Report of the Quebce Conference secure t@ this Colony anything able to do it with impartiality, fairly weigu the sweeping powers which the new cuu- stitution would place ia the hands of the Federal Government, for the imposition of high tariffs and every description of taxes, and theo, as a true patriot, affirm if be dare, that the terws of the Quebec Keport are * just aod liberal to Privce Kdward Ls- land.” Some of our most ardent Unionists do acknowledge that the Quebes schewe “ offers to us nothivg that could, with avy show of reason, be refused to us ;” but they say that, on the ocher band, we wi rive so many indirect advautages frow the Union as would wore than make up for the like justice in view of our peculiar position | and circumstances ? Let any one who may be | would de- ment” as itis laced by afew of our Unionists, and their other tactics are taken together, they bring to my recollection the kite in tne fable, which reads as follows : *«Onee en a time a paper kite Was wounted to a wonderous height, When, giddy with its elevation, It thus expressed self aduiiration : * Bee haw you crowd of gazing people Admire my flight above the steep.e ; Jiow would they wonder it they kuew Ail that a kite like me can do ? Were I but freed I’d take a flight, Aud pierce the clouds beyond their sight, But, ali { like a poor prisouer bound, My string confines me to the ground ; I’d brave the eagle’s towering wing, Might I but fly without a string.” It tugged and puiled while thus it spoke, ' Yo break the string—at last it broke. Deprived at once of ali its stay, In vain it tried to soar away ; Unable its own weight to bear, It fluttered downward through the air ; Unable its own course to guide, The winds svon plunged it in the tive. Ab! foolish kite, thou badst no wing, How cuuld:t thou fly without a striag ” The elevating “string ” in those lines I take to signify the peopie’s suffrages, which will not bear every degree of violent force without suappiog asauder ; bat if it shuuld | disadvantages complained of. Nuw, your be a cap that will fit no one , 1 will be ail ‘the other hand, [ believe they did their daty | ‘+ glass houses,’ the more we will inerease the general safety. We all know that party those men better than we do. They have borrowed about two miliions of dollars for public works, and pay four per cent. inter- esl for it. That does not look like losing their credit. Let poor Prince Edward Island ask for a small loan, and the answer would be an emphatic no ! The House was then resumed and progress reported. The Militia bill, and a bill to authorize the appointment of Clerks to Justices of the Peace and to regulate proceedings had be- fore them, were read the third time and pass- ed. On motion, a bill in further amendment of an act to incorporate the Royal Agricul- tural Society was read a second time, com- mitted, and reported agreed to without amendment. Adjourned till Monday next at ten o'clock. Monpay, April 3. APPROPRIATION BILL. Hon. Mr. Lorp: | object to the ar propri- ation of £60 for wharfage for the Mail Steamers. ‘Those gentlemen are very accom- modating to themselves, indeed. One of the public wharves was reserved for the mail service, and now, because certain changes have taken place, the Government must pay this large sum for their accommodation. f consider it one of those party jobs which are tuo apt to take place at present. You will also find charges in the accounts for travel- and perhaps we would not have the accom- I do not think it would be good policy to question that item. But there is another item which calls for an expression of opinion, and [ must say that there is great force in the remarks of his honor from Prince Couniy (Mr. Lord), that it would be an improve- ment if the Appropriation Bill, instead of being eent up as it is at present, were sent up im separate or classified items. It has fallen on me to speak on this question before, when this house was not elected, and the period of our political history, it was, per- haps, well to advocate and adhere to the principle of the House of Assembly having control over the expenditure of the public money. At tha time it was, perhaps, right ; but there is great cause for consideration now, when the members of this House are sent here by the people. It now becomes a question whether it is right that this branch of the Legislature should have some control over the expenditure of the Colony, because, when we are sent here by the people, they will reasonably expect that we will exercise some control over the appropriation, other- wise there would be no check upon the ex- penditure of money which the country may think unjustifiable. As it stands at present, it is useless for us to seek to check the evil, and I do not wait to canvass the propriety of certain items, for the {principle is of ten thousand times more importance to the Co- lony. I think is is a very proper time to express our opinions upon this subject. The House should wake up to a consideration of ling to inspect the building of one of the steamboats. What have the public to do with the inspection of a boat for a private company? [ have travelled on a similar service myself for the benefit of the country, and I never received a shilling for it, nor looked for it. Hion. Mr. Beer: There has been a grant of £40 foe wharfage for the Mail service for yeers past. Now there is additional accom. modation for them, and, therefure, the sum of £20 additional is granted. The wharf waich the steamers occupy now is more cen- tral, and they require additional accommo- dation, for they are ranning more frequently than they did formerly. Those steamers are a great advantaze to the farmers in sending their produce to market, as well as to the people generally, and [ do not think we should grudge this small additional sum for wharf accommodation. It isa credit to the Colony to have those boats owned here. lion. Mr. Lorn: { know some would like to bolster up a transaction of this sort, but L, for one, will not dv so. There were great charges against the late Government for ex- travagence in every sense of the word; but now, the very men who made those charges will stand up here and muke an aplogy for such transactions. It is not the amougt we are to look at so mach as the principle. Hon. Mr. Dincwett: I wish to call at- tention to the improper way in which the appropriation Billistaken up. Yourdhonors know that this is a very important Bill, and it is commonly taken up sv late in the Ses- sion that members of this House have not time or opportunity to let their wews go to the country. Your honors cannot expect us to support every item in that Bill. Many items in it would be considered objectionable by the country if they were seen in their true light; but the want of time prevents us from exposing such items of expenditure as we think are not called for. I merely call attention to this so that a different method may be adopted at a future Session. flon. the Presipenr: If your honors think the time is too short, i will notify His Excel- tency that we will not be prepared to be pro- rogued this evening. Your honors may dis- cuss this Bill till Satarday night if you like ; therefore it is unfair to throw any reflection on the Llouse of Assembly, for they cannot be prorogued tillwe are prepared. The item which is objected to isvery small. Formerly there were £40 given when there was only one steamer ; now there are two, and a por- tion of the wharf is nearly all the time bcca- pied by them. When we compare the busi- ness done at the wharf now with what it was a few years ago, I d> not think it is an un- reasonable increase. llon. Mr. Ramsay : It is only the difference between £40 and £60, and I dé not think it is worth while to occapy time in discussing it. Iam apprehensive that there are items in the Bill to which we will have stronger ob- jections, but we can only express an opinion upon them. We must either take the Bill as a whole or reject the whole. Hon Mr. Pincwati: It is very well for those who receive the benefit of those large grants to support them, but | represent a people who receive no benefit from those grants for steam communication, and there is no compensation made to them in the shave of grants Jor roads, bridges, or wharves. I do not think it is fair; those who receive no benefit from the grants to the Mail steamers, should receive an equivalent in grants for roads and bridges, or for sume other service. flon. Mr Loav: The next item is £20 for wharfage at Point Brule. the inhabitants of this country to pay for wharfage in Nova Scotia? We have no right to pay that item ; and this [louse will have to take a stand against sending * the ap- propriation Bill in this shape. Why not send it up in separate resolutions, as they do in Nova Seotia and New Brunswick? | pre- sume that there is independence enough in this House to take a stand against this Bill coming up in this manner. Here is the Re- enue Bili coming up at the eleventh hour, and it is unfair tu have it sent upin this way. Toere are many objectionable items in it, There are hundreds of powads going into pockets where 1t should nut go. It will be cast up to us bye and bye, that we are cor-| rapt like the Canadian Government. Hon. the Paresipent : The steamers must have wharf accommodation, and if the publie do not pay the whartage, the owners of the boats must pay if themselves, which, 1 think, would be a great hardship. To say that we should not pay for the use of the wharf at Brule, because it is in Nova Scotia, is absurd. Hon. Mr. Lorp: Then, by the sare rule, we should pay the disbursements of the steamers. | suy the public have not a right to pay that whariage. 1 suppose we will What right have its rights and privileges. But the remedy does not lie with ourselves; it is with the people. I think it is a fair subject for thenr to consider between this and the next elec- tion, whether they would trust us with the exercise of a reasonable and salutary check over the expenditure of the Colony. If it were fairly and fully brought before the peo- ple, IL do not think they would withbold that power from this House. The only remedy is to have it brought to the notice of the people at the next election, and eall for such a mo- dification of the constitution as would remove the obstruction complained of. 1 did not rise to find fault with any particular item in the bill, fer i really do not know what items it contains ; but I think it is a fair and pro- per time to have this question discussed. Now, when this Hoase is differently consti- tuted, and possesses a diferent power from what it formerly did—a power emanating directly from the people—lI think it is time that a different rule from that which has long been acted upon in this Colony, with regard to money bills, should prevail. If we are to do nothing more than to vote for, and approve of, every measare which is sent up here, let it be known, and I for one would not desire to have a seat here again after an- other election. But if we are sent here to exevcise a calm and deliberate jadgment upon what coneerns the interests of the people, let it be understood. Tuserefore, I would have the questicu thoroughly agitated througir the country, and I would not fear the result. [f it were explained to the people, I feel as- sured that they would not hesitate to confide to this branch of the Legislatare liberty to have some control over those itemsseparately ; because, as the elective franchise 1s now con- stitued, | would have conSdence that no gen- tlemen would be returned to this House who would be s0 thoroughly carried away by party feeling as to vote for merely party purposes. Hou. Mr. Lory: I am glad to hear the sentiments of his honor the Attorney General upon this question. It has always been a source of annoyance to me, since I had a seat here, to have the {ppropriation Bill sent up here in this way ; aud I hope that, if we are spared to meet here again, that we will take up the question and wake a determined stand against having thie Bill sent here in this manner. If at were sent wp as it is in Nova Scotia, I would not compjain. Hon. Mr. Dincwsit: As it is a question of principle, [ think it is well for every mem- ber of the House to express his opinion ; but at the same time I do not think it is neces- sary to say much upon it, and I would merely say that | agree with the sentiments expressed by his houcr the Attorney General. lion. Mr. Anperson: I always thought this House should have more control over the appropriation of the public money, and now, as we are an elective body, I think we should baye the same power ag the [louse of Assembly. Hon. Me, Henxperson : ‘Lhis is a matter of principle, and no varty or Government ques- tion, and I think { am fully jastified in af- firming that, all things eonsidered, there is as littie of the partzan i by this House as by any legislative body in North America, I think we are desirous of answer- ing the purpose for which we were sent here, if the people will only give us power; but it is folly for them to expect * bricks” from us unless thay give us ‘‘straw.”’ We have no power to reject any item at present, except by means which would be more injurious to the people than the misappropriation of any item, that is, the rejection of the whole Billi. When the present discassion goes to the country they will see our position, and they will pot expect that from us which we have not the power to accomplish. The people should consider whether it is an advantage to them to have us an elective body, and at the same time to have no power to check the expenditure of any items which we may think extravagant. It is vain for us to seek to ex- ercise power which we have not obtained from the people, and if they wish us to have the power they musttake the constitutiynal way to vbtain it for us. item agreed to. lion. Mr. Rausay: [ observe that thera are £2,500 granted for a model farm. Now, that is a large amount, and | think we hays already bad a tair trial of a model farm, which proved an entire failure, and was a great loss to the country. Weare new appro- priating this large sum to try the experiment again, and it is @ question in my mind whe- ther the country will receive.a curresponding benefit from it. I am of opinisn that they will not; and I am also of opinion that if you go through some parts of the country in the wonth vt Jane—Crapaud, Tryon, and Bedeque—you will find as well laid off farms as the model farm will be. [am persuaded people had no control over it. During that ° have a bill sent in, bye and bye, for brandy | that Judge Peters’ pamphlet bas done more 'so far that they obtained the best terms fer|Governmen's have often a hard task in ‘this Colony that they could get from the | Striving to steer the ship of state safely be- | Canadians. But even supposing they could | tween the ** whirlpool and the rock,’ and 80 | get more, or could get better terms—suppose | much is this sometimes the case that a piece | they cuuld get double as much for giving up | of doubtful expediency has to take the place our Constitution and fevenue to Canada—l | of sound and fixed principles. But for any | would not consent tu it, for it would simply | one to turp round, because lesser points are | be selling ourselves fora larger sum, and || yielded under great pressure, and justify ex- would not censent to sell ourselves at all. | tensive corruption, is just as much as to say We have a good Constitution, avd let us| that ‘ the end sanctifies the means!"’ The maintain it. Gur revenue is increasing at|Canadian Government have lately been | the rate of upwards of £3,000 a year; but if charged with the bribing of their own press | we enter Confederation we would have a cer- to a large extent ; and some of itsown mem- ‘tain fixed sum —a sum which would not in-| bers or supporters are represented as de fend- and wine for those steamers. Hon. Mr. Rayssy: His honor says we should make a stand against the Appropria- tion Bill being sent up in this shape, but it came in the same way when the late Govern- meat wasia power, andI would ask bim why tuey did not make a stand then? Hon. Mr. Loxp; Well, I can tell bis honor that ** two wrongs will never make a right;’’ | and if the late Government did wreng, that is no reason that we should Go wreng, too. | I was in the other branch of the Legislature | then, and this Council was nominative. It) was crammed up with the friends of a party, | to establish well conducted farms in the country than the old model farm did, or the next model farm willdo. It might possibly be some advantage in the rearing of improved stock, but [ would ask your honors if you cannot fall upon a cheaper plan to raise stock which would answer equally as we!) ? A few days ago | was in conversation with a gentlemaa not far from this town, who took me to see his stock, and I venture tosay thas the model farm will nv: produce finer stuck fur some years to come. Le told me that he had orders coming from Nova Scotia and New Bruaswiek for stock by almost every lurease, no matter how much our revenue! ing, apd even justifying the conduct of that| but it is not so now. We are bere to repre-| mail. more than he could supply. Now, I }might increase. That sam would not besul-|Goverament. If all this is true, the con-| i ficient for our necessities and we would have ! clusion is, that the less we have to do with | tv resort to direct taxation. [ oppose Con- them the better for ourselves. federativa on the basis of the Quebec Report | sent the people, nota party. I do not say_ am of opinion that all the model farm is ‘that this House should have control over the | calculated to do for the benefit of the county lappropriation, but 1 would have this Bill, is, to raise improved stock, and I think that Hon. Mr. Lorp: Lis honor takes exception ‘sent up in separate resolutions, and then have if you would encourage the gentleman to because | believe it is uDjust to this Island. to the remarks which { made relative to the it framed in the House of Assembly in accord- whom have alladed, he would raise stock jlo the first piace, representation based on good moral standing of the Canadian states- | population is an unjust thing to this Colony,” men, but there is nothing which will prove | because it is a small country which, ia the their good standing betier than the fact that _ course of a few years, will not be capable of | their credit is good. _increasing in population as it does at pre- 4 sent; but Canada has a large unoccupied dollars for Victoria Bridge, though it cost a territory, and will probably increase for million and a nalf, it was loaned by capita ages tv come. Now, I find in one article of lists in England ; and let me see that the like the Report that the representation is to be of that bas been done in any other part of readjusted every ten years, and in the course the British Colonies. If those men were as W hen five or six years, ago they required a loan of half a million of ance with those resolutions. Hon. Arrorney Geverat: I do n@ rise, | your honors, for the purpose of pronouncing wn opinion on the items to which objection bas been taken ; but in referenes to tie small ‘appropriation for the use of the wharf at ‘Brule, [ think it may be fairly justified on the ground that it is advisable tu encourage intercourse that way. ‘Island to have communication by that route, is isa benefit tu the which would anewer equally as well, and at a far lees est. Perhaps your honors will think it strenge in me, being a farmer my- self, to this t, but I do so because i believe it will be little or no bevefit to the cvuntry. Wiat bas the eld model farm, which cost the country so mach, done? Go, for instance, six or eight miles owt the Mal- peque road, and you will see that the great “majority of the farms are Dot in more pros- ole 4 ~ na en