11101111115 MAXIMS °F * . oi- A MERCHANT MERCHANT. Religion finds in man the purpose of nature! Science finds in man the purpose of man. Faith rules the world more oom- pietely in agnostic today "l!" 1h any gnostic yesterday. “"1 Read byEveryllody Covers Prince Edward Island Likethe Dew W i o .1 I g7:.'.'..°"':t.‘.'i2"2: ii’.°'i'."i‘.“.ifii2° QHARLOTTETOWN, CANADA, TUESDAY, APRIL 17,1928 ' "e-"mh" °'"'"" "" ‘ _' ' 1 Iornlni Glllllllo Iillla Honorable J. D. Stewart ‘Dr. W. J. P. McMillan Replies Effectively to 1 u u . - Speaks on Draft Adress 1 o. ' t _ 001111111100 credit ioi- the gi-onhoi $3.500 to the‘: do not kilo: whether l should was contained in the speech not. h: rtCd Cross Societyl and it was owing make the-suggestion or not; perhaps the Throne. ‘ That was by way '97 5-11011111111111111501 P-W-C" to that grant that the Red Cross the Government is considering some explanation of the securing of the - Th0 11011- Pfemelgfit 5110136‘, have been able to function here and’ pclicy in this matter. But failinfstrvices of the full time expert cheriilt - - - _ - . . . was utterly cppoh‘ ° 1° P that this result oi the examinations the erection and maintenance oi’ a. diagncstician. The Leader of t B sending 1101111; students fi'011_1_ 1he is now made public. Oi course, thfllllprtiprl: sanatorlum. which is a most Opposition drew his attention tothc Ext _ _ _ h P . 'Co11880 who iillleddilll the iltlrléfimhg is not a_ new thing to my honlexpensive proposition, if arrnngc- fact that the Government is ‘oply 1 - examinations; 811 0 We friends in the medical profession. I‘ t: - id b d 'ltl th II -- a ing one-third of this man's sol- t e 8W0 101150115- 1 11911919 1119115 "3111" think every one of us, whenever we.:1‘t1l11ls§whlelrebyet'l1‘eay fiotildhook’ iliiiflgfz: and the Leader of the Govern? ' Allfl Creating‘ a, Very Large . -W11011 1‘ 1°05’ 01' B111 33115 111 ‘he had the opportunity, have endeav-tubercular patients, even if they had ment says: "Well, we were only ' - . l. . . -Chi"istiniis examinations so 1.1181- ored to tell the people of this Pro-Ho build a separate wing on each of 0d I0 PM’ 0110-1111111‘ wmlldnw .15 1 - there 1S 110 01181100 °1 8011-1115 1‘ ‘hp’ vince that tuberculosis is rampant,1the three public Hospitals. it wouldbe foolish to pay the whole thinfl?" _.. ‘ .lomu tol- l1lcelgsebénsotlggvigigllfingh‘; especiallly in certain sections. l But be a great move. They have the II dolft thinlkhthere is Rllyflhie . - . l 111'?" 5 51°11 * 1 it wou eem t ' ins ' rsin - if - , r Following is the speech deliver-ed friend did not do that. Ifle repealed strongly in iavur of an acquittnlthliell much moi-e can he be relied ul-totrif; up to the parents whether they get an ofitsldelffi clgrlrilen h Waflgg‘;1)l(ltra gorge‘ Zltlfcariitglmtghetl”: ruugpegllltbm t“ til: £3211; ea 101° md- ‘l ‘ 111' hohlh‘ Dinstfltvarg Iaehcghlngrl) hhelbhm 511111111115" lhhfihsuhslténutleghagwo 511502115301: ltminmfiisgi‘ yofo coil- no“. ‘Taxation Promises. 151T 1° $91111 111111 hm’ °h151rl hhicfhh: tell the people these things before lzir patients. might be profitable to dence when we consider the rc- t; omniblhon’ n Weedngscllllf eveniina ihew oiyswhhfil 911110;): hsree: few ifl-1hlégi0lla We fig 3110i. know what a1 ‘conegepr “OL- Tlhhhhhhif uittle may begm 1°. whke uh‘ w” hhu’ 1hmh‘ The‘? ‘S hmhe hhhg“ .1 @1'fl111»?11‘.“1"1‘5 ‘f1 hhy h°h' fhehd 1mm m” 1 Wm“ mm o y g" g o - d h l l whcn' thi d tri l would have bl'0ll ht out 1 L, ~t cur he made a promise with 11161111111011 @1105 1° s 0°’ I .“1 l‘ been cndeavoring to do what ivqbut there 1s danger in nursing a11.1""5.1 9'51"" ‘>1 P111100 011 00°11?" i‘ 1- Apr“ um . . . 1518110615’ 1m e-companstl‘ t ' '11 111 311151 110111‘ 1 M 1* reduction of taxation. He a “P1111110” G1 1110,59 wh° . 1h u‘ ' could: we gave the Red Cross thc‘dlscases. and thc experience might sublect, which has a bearing otrthis Mr. Speakel, I am vely soiry that we oblcct‘ to those things, la we if)? raps a can: cmutrior me grown.‘ l-lgarit t; very uppmcm hurry m Christmas are going to faiihatt ‘Al: gram lheylasked loll and we we". be beneficial w nurses m general‘ 1171mm, of Government grants. nut ‘. 1 11111 11°1 111111‘? 1° 11111131311115“? "11/‘1119 1111811“ I I d d I i G _n_ drrcch édmghat‘ misc '1 “h” 1h mat ulomlse, 1t. was made 01101 01 1110 X0111 1_ 115110;“ ldab :0 willing to IIICFEBSCV the amount up.That is one suggestion, Mr. Speakelxlllofl» member touched on a grant of, l 1 hon‘ ‘Mend’ hhseibetiidfrfl?‘ uie Gov“ Mat hon. bren b21111 edibs thtvegcu Arrhrhthet- case was the Byers and makemogl improper time; he lnaocmhhhhce chhh1111h11°thlf 1’ 1:258 Lfioge to $5,000 for_a period of five yeorsqwhich the Government might con- $5.000 which the late Government , cmnltlmon m u e on nmakv ‘nan 111118 Peenic gith y pi G l- c se in connection with- m u clamtttion during the de-ld1mch111hh1 °h°° e111 bl um und to work in conjluictloll/tvith the slder. I leave it with you for whatfhfld Voted 111 011101‘ t0 0101/9109 011.11 l mg h Budget speech’ To copy his me of t S my ncevow- prehar~ng'. the": cyl 1.1 ' l ll‘ v slum ime pm ll i prait Address when the‘ and 801111» 111°Y111e 191mm“ Y 5 Canadian Anti-Tuberculosis Assoc», it is worth. One of the hon. meni- l11'01110t0 another line of buslneqsf- ' own plirasology. he is running taut: introducing iillldkllitib-SIIQE ggislaittiizan.‘ Trtfewcllfvg die/man cgf thgeueuily bate on‘ the Province ‘Vere not‘. of getting their licfenses I side alum [o]. me betterment o; public: hers of the Gqvemlnent ls a medlcnl llle lux lndustry He sald ll w“ , I 101mm n has 0mm been said t at They do mlt W1 tio i? ' ghost! (111 the ltri imbut in the metlntiuie more nmmhefiiiscusslon at all. Why the My hoh‘ mehdf 131m 1:l.11l?:r‘cx_ hehhh 1h1h15 Pr°v1h°e' B111 we were mhhi and he 15 as 9017111111111 °f 111° Just $5900 whsmd- 1111111 1119 193?“ myl1o11-111011d15l1- wlwd at 111111101- '-° P1155 111° i?“ a 3"- “ ‘i; l? :1“ ewdlngc-hns Con“: m‘) ‘ossession of ""92 1 “M; new, been able u, a... ; spoke about one 9d t; 11:11:11“ ‘M0 hm ulragllllist the very same problem facts as 1 nlll. - lwere no good that were there 1111191118" 1111111111‘ and 5115’ 111111111111 °1 1h” G°ve1hh1°h 1 h‘ f1” a 1 “ . . ‘ 1 ' _. 11111111 I l“ to say that ll animations sai a - which this Government is up ilgillilSt‘ I hope. at any rate, that the time experimentation and, as I mute?- mhihn of his seems to he a sol-t of they are there fol, and that ls what‘ UICIIIOgICC ivhlchd hi) gglnkfllgtlllltél‘ ceiluin. But LO 031m reports of mm‘ lnuuly uuuogglhle to do, 1_would biz new’ and mal ls‘ mm m order llhifl-llypnfltlSm with hum-ho bo- my hon. friend is paid his saluly‘. gfilietuiwaisivgrgivné; t-ogims o. la ‘gcbwtleillfétlxevlm find ma‘ he dld nulllilcllncll ttlo agicgti \V1tl'io1;l2:)u?;)é)UI get anywhere‘ canal“ (ll mesa uh some way out‘ we used to he able expenditure. Now I do not 011m“ so Bummypnotlmq that he fmh it i' l to ho r I sh ll not o1 Now I wonizllier whois scventv~fi ~11 L- [lliiy ills oiitlcnlclit in any Wal/"home O l fulpmelfigshld and ruéty berculllr cases must be isolated. We t0 send our tubercular‘ cases over W11011101‘ i119 11011-8611110111811 133W!!!‘ ' “.91 ‘my 105,135 hhhseh but everybodh i ls b: tnid “an f thc1 er cent away from accuracy" 1i‘hcs~11q111ddid not shy mat he would make shhhoget fuse?‘ to fnow_so‘nethlng 11'1"“ 1111“ $01110 1113001" Wmhh 1° 10-0110 91 1h“ . Shhwrhhhs 1h 111C U1 11,16 history °1 1119-1 B35111- 117.119.19- : 1 within healing of him becomes lost 111 0 11111’ 1119 f fiuhho . ° L 12m u“ things that m hmu lrlulull h“ _ ducuull uluu- he examined the how} ‘h ‘l .' mi aboul'cxalmna_ 10°10 111101‘ them: some sort of Silll-lllmgilbflfllig provinces. The cost was It is quite true that thc in that bewildering maze. He int-it" finances, oi any o 1e main‘ llnaé‘ knovw wou‘ and c‘ 31m Wm [nuke the 1C _ ‘mom was no rider w abou Cvlll. ling a_ c mmlems that ulol-luuu 0lhel.wl5e_ you may g0 on very luglu ulolllblllyc ln uumy 111-. Government voted the monalv, 11g- 0d 1110 0111105111011 1-0 111110 dOWH 1118 1e“ 11191111011911 by my .h°h' 1 eh ' n ‘t fl {l fl f u ._ hhhhhhh ‘ _ mm bald Statenlent ions. ‘There are 501111 l d _ ‘and diagnosing the cases and telling stances; but even with the high cost "@1159 we had ririlresentations “guilt/ix Q1 m: not adshorthuiildl Wm- 131111111815 ilkighhloiclfgrcotigicolxlll? frzfn I-Ihiljcathrsttnpefiglc fro ‘Jilofiillostmllills ihcdlicc taxation. 501a“? cemumy dlmcu 1 w u“ ms I thcmwha‘ to do’ and 11 Wm M’ "f more came a who W119“ we could me 10x breeders M 1h“ er. r. epca er. an cveli were ' l ~ ' 1 ~ : ‘ tdwill soon come when we shall see stood him. it was an urljustiflahle . I See that £11010 1110 $01110 1111101111- little a ll. Th ' i i t .- .- .-t not get then th .. th t that the i ll r ». l uuuul ll I could keel, pace Wm] u, llme and which‘ ll, seems to hie, to discounting what I say by sevcli- will find that statement on lecorrkmems proposed to the School A“, va e inc p en cases mus 1 erc so a we were oca on of that .103 1 1 1 _ - ‘ _ be taken charge of somehow. iic- absolutely dependent on the charity 11011 Should be shifted, and that We 1 hilii. And I think it the nlost mer- 51101114 110 (101111 W1111- ' . “"11"” he? hem‘ I whhdcrowh” 1511 he 100K511 hp‘. ghhhgfi lffiffljfll I 11°11‘? 1h“ W111 he 1h 111° ‘hhereihs cause there is a chance of curing of other institutions. We know, Mr. 0011111 801» 1t down into this cllul course for all concerned that _ best entitled to the discount. land because ‘he iln s w mo“ mm; of education, that they will improve "mm The hopelessly lncurflblc cases Speaker‘ and llus l5 the Suddesl um; lncc; that therc was do ' 4i t 1 l‘ I should lcavc him to his figures,‘ A 911111101130 1-0 Mr- $0l11ll10f§- 5111c", I 11h‘ °h 11115 1111111‘ I ‘V111 0115 1110 01111111111 hmhe _ _i_.C0l‘idlLlOliS; but I have no faith in Slluulu be lake" care of also, humus‘, of ll‘ ‘lull l; those cases: u“. lulu.“ being elsewhere. and vgl-y nggmg - 1." 111111.") I attempt to deal with some ‘ 10119“ 11 h 111111’ 1117111913 1 hm 5°‘ 1900111150 110 1111115 111111 the rehhohh lthc Premier's announcement that . < ‘ _ _ . _ . __ _ _ ‘ . _ on me A _ A they spread infection among others. 111 time thtycan be cured. Thom 11111114111‘. Negotiations read-heel of the iniltters referred to in his F1151 P11111111 1° 1113111 1111111 51111‘~"{:l1‘1)1f]q1° égzhegzehlzgq1213221131113“:01 lfzhtif1llghgov1ghrilmcnt Ol the‘. itheueaéltléuisnlhlcllllltgf $51201?“ glniauggil} 1h view of these facts it does seem 950F110 1110 "y"!!! year afItt-r year, and lglultwhcre it was necessary forthc 511'-°°h- ' 111mm whlch .1111: Leadel o! L- c Gov-i ihepnrdoninil of Prohibition 0iY0lld-1Z have "allcli upon his own. e1 “s11 L u I'm)‘ g I cannot we ll Ml. h 1’1‘y'Mr' Sheaher‘ mm me Dalton fir-e h‘ h" he?‘ of '.1' T11“? are ofmgnlh-nt 1° hm‘ up “'00” 1” w’ " . _ So far as the Budget is concerned, Qrfiflwilfli 111115 11\l1011;1_<1°1100{1\111ll lily-l l“ w" my hon ‘Mend “y now‘ an before- mis House this lame exJgaeikgr. haw had- mspéctorg tslnnigtorllljiln was allowed to g0 _b,v settlltllins of this Province winch I 3111'!‘ tdo site. We believed that Wail . lFlwlsLgéltnllstvfiiymllixmisihgc i;nlsglhgh:vtglaltsécgilécollgiitgzin:5l hut the“, have no] been suvlmleeuiggsé m. Cxulauulluu; ~Qll‘ well‘ éhc bust‘ as ‘narny as therc arlglolle “ugh brxlalfotnfideiiltelilneu speaking coil unmo, bfftélll-SL‘ we see 1.1111 hoo thing. and wc put it in the! h Qgflqlt; has bee“ ‘loTgcnslfd lu o2 to discoliilt what I say in this House‘ 1111111111115 51h“ h” “m” lhh’ 1."'w°r1"11111°11d°°1 1° ‘X11111? this‘? jlgghgf in operltion now. I_ might say that “welh lphhlcl speech lll this pl-oyln¢e_ l to thc tune oi seventy-five per cent. H0111 MR» 55111111353351 l 001"'i1rst 001010 1 11°11 m“ tho K101 did 110t originate W111i my way. givc lily hon. friend credit for hi; That is rather n serious statement‘ 11111113’ ‘1/111- ductioh. 411d 11 1 110111111 I °°1ha ma“ hon. frond; that we had made lir- ‘ have said; cases coming into the ‘hospitals and 1551111111103 11nd I do not think thc it was not nluch good‘ guly- we get the family history, wilcrc thc 119111 W115 qllefitlollcd. But afta" thlt ‘ It was too big and unwieldy‘ people coining in are almost sure to 1110110.)’ was voted negotiations wiljl, R ' ' -' - id" That is thc 1 IhQIldltWFtS a mistake Lilli-Lit was ever have a illD0rculai' taint in them. h" 51111 111111191‘- B-lld 1111 056T 1' 1 cullllul»; bu; for nolhlnk muru ‘luau. for any hoil. gentleman to make: b11301. S'!l‘€liWAI=t‘T.f‘l_‘iic_n_ I ii. pelhaps I “goal ‘m. bdweel; pm_.rarigcirclilts_ whereby _oul stitdlr “r; lululcd oyer u, llu. Douuulou gov. That surely is a matter in vrllicl-l from thc proghuxfiive fox Dr ‘, i“ hlgll-ulu hls speech lunlglu, uuu lmlu One would assume that when a hh¢l|°1'80__ ounot to tn llfihllll dltrercnec. Mr; - 9011mm» Th“ h the‘ inspectors. should be inciense . m: elnmenh Bu} we know lllul llu-yl- we are all interested. 1PF11100‘ County to. ll“, we“ .11 his olller 5lulumellls_ l very much member of this House. and more es- ‘i f‘ 3115851 I 04V“ 1111 ° 111,1! vlhh-‘nlisc and per orma than making Thad infidc arrangements with I was a possibility of having that There are u good many matters. 11105’ 1111111119111 11D 1110 $5.000 ' '1 1m‘,- lllhl the dm-el-cnce bclweeu pecially thc Leader of the Govem-"meth 1 "1 _ gohg 10f )°1:°";1d‘11""h°° hewhhhfh a“ responslblllly.9111111111“ G°V°_"‘""0111_ 111110110113’ 1110 building changed. and that some l11'0b1'1bly._ which would be better 19F. "qlllplnent if the e ' ‘ -~ “" ll his revenue and eXpeudltul-e will be ment. makes a statement oi thatflhs h! V}??? 130G111? 0m“ he’; ‘stutcmvnl Qihthlhg“ osuiion and thJsalol-ieslof those additional inspleot-‘nrgotlatioiisi went on about it. It handled if kept out of politics. It 10X station would be built in Bog‘- . l considerably...grea.i.eiz_tlian he» has 1111111 “@111 “u”: 1°. “fh°1'h"i"m'1‘“1'1llu1' 9| ~ “l b} “him. h!“ W“ 1036f" ° l e EH15 the Lead" o‘ 01's could bepald out o1‘ thl; tlcc 1161- IS quite true that during the war it 15 luird to keep them out of poli- 1110011110 Now some difference; ‘if 1W esunmted‘ ‘hm whlcll l; he put mm othcrworuu, ‘Cllgl. "hill to“ i; n?‘ l.‘ ca, as?! ofif same m-tn W10]: t. ‘cal grai t. Thelc is nospgcizft or; h-hs turned into some sort of r5001» tics: but I think. in a matter of such opinion had existed on thin; n. - l I l I inlglit begin very close to where WW1" 11° "11P"11“"1°“1‘1"1' ‘mm heiufnrhi- 21' o. lh-lholllhlr? 9131' m d 1h.” “‘."“"."f'°".-, . mallet. um l 00111111210 my lion. 1110111 o1 nth vnleslecnt l-Iolne mid that in uni; vilol 11111101091100 no this. that any ha“ 110011 Bpplicatioils and negotiii- my hull mend lull all‘ He has un_ would have very good grounds for‘? _ "5 ghhf‘ Y. 1 *1 ~11‘ 1"’- “h . 11119? h’ “ho m M hon friend IIIOVEIIILIIIZ. _ I believe tic nllllvOlililbr condition it was not suitable for U14‘? move that will better conditions will 11011:“ 191' 5°11"? 111110 115141118 that tho 1 uullakcu lo lecture myself wllll re_ maklnir it. The ground which tnylwfigbz” RZ€"ERLLJ'IVDERS_ I ‘m b".1111l£11l_10g" 11mm‘ hgd a véry dip THERE Uikltddltlgllll-fll liislllectorslvll c purposes or a gahhlorhim, 13m, so u- be rcccninlhndcd and supported by §1h11h1111°l1111¢0¢1 1'11 Summer-sigh b5. gum w some remarks I nmdu‘ my hon‘ “loud ‘gave lul. muklnu lulu‘ Tmd w. do i.‘ . 1t o‘ when ill _ ppofs these iclmms wmcn .1 1lb1l1a1liittIb efsievctili‘ Sixbflhbere lino: llrlllrlgcliicllt inlglit have been iLl-1-l\_._ everyone. The appointment of an i0agst ill-hi,- thc centre of thc fox pnlaglngly‘ he sum of the hmLMiW slulclnelllvwus lullul 1 lulu ‘Sula mull. HON MR 1STEWARYT_ Very Wennfflylillit ‘Llttu/woanly my or hope‘ me pgllhtowaeu b efigeéh eiaucaflon cm; ed I I. titllsl. ltiifti’, we shall hear ailpcrt chest ‘diognosticiail isagoozl lilclustly oi the world.’ 11mm ism. of Agrlculturu l lllluk that l“ he had discontinued criminal pro-lMy ho-n “lend had m; .01‘! Stellar?‘ llfit of “a “gm the only imam“ g 11C I dy. ‘Lyle n ointment of ‘I Rtiilllf!‘ 1 rig f0 tll s matter when the v inil- _ Houlll bc able to give us m0 l ranches m pnucu oounlm m“ as l“ 0mm. thlnus’ my lmu cccdings in the Supreme Court on m“ he gwver mum to mm“. with on J01!’ thyme m his forecast ti“? llc . q _ tap P me of Wale-s lillistfill) o Agriculture comes tn eouud information until I think thc o‘ rslproiiicss in the industry going mum‘ ls dreaming u muc‘ I did uclmll of me Crmvn‘ ngalnsl three B.“ Lhoél terrible hm“ 1min. Md innrlyq It Thai is mg hope of Eu“ ilnlzulnallé; aericflltugal acml speak. bccauic I understand he was 310st sctlitical ll'i tnc Province will nllnggre. thairclseuhel-o, and Bum- not make any disllarafiillii remark“: 0,11 [our persohs 1111111114 1h” 185'" been paid vby the late Eiovfiflllllifllt 91.1: hoe: oubsidy from thc Feder511 lthoseavould lie a ITIEOVO in the right i} 1111,01.“ gtto 11203131811111111111 um” e Conunccd’ 11110151) 0111,35» fight m me mhthh or “b01115 me 1111111151" or Agillculture-kl t1; 1111211001 itgcdgggulttl-lislgii1tzhlvyligig1x1when iu llolvvr. and which hud bcctrgltliyghlimcihit. Otherwise we arc ZO-1direction I know that thc man tign with tisrafillll-isgllisisllitfiifsllhiilgleégs-l “hmflh” 111511111105- ‘the I mmk those we“: wou not ave any sucl rcmar s ‘ 1 » l C l~ .,‘. . i‘. , ' - - rumor . ' . . - -. - , . '_ _ . ‘ " _ *1 I w‘ "m 111511961101" 111° 11411115101‘ 91551111111‘ ~ 1- ma er “hthe returned soldiers llv shed many‘ l limmhent tonight‘ that is thc “Young the w“; h mid willlget rc- ortunit n ti t i i b 3-1 01119111“ "Stitutes are ntercste 1 _ 4 0m '0n vernrnotit tum and 1 behave he appreciates which my hon. friend has made. ‘ . .0’? ~_ ‘ of “n51 _ , "l _ . _ 11‘ y ° 1“ we“ °hi ‘ecahfo greatly in this matter. I forgetlcsthhhshcd i111 E-‘lpefllnental farm ... M‘ ‘ 153313;‘é2é2.£i.°‘;if.;..€'i1§12F‘i.§.%“"ii£E5l§%2i?§‘..‘£f..“f.%‘3l? also, "l; '.‘..;=:*::'~..".'; '3.Z‘;..‘;""3§.‘. Zlfiiiiifi-“Jifiihfiihili?"iiiifgwiiiil“in; 1.1.11. 111-11 1,11 tillers’ "i; 5.21M 111.311 such criticisms do not colnc with ii - ~ 1 1°11 - - - - - . ‘ he is ‘ - . ~ _ ' . ‘lnien 111 1v omens nstitutvsi - ' . an ey decid Lo to... grace from a gentlemen who. mend 11111111110 k111i" 1111111111 m"Eiiéifiioi‘.i'...1§°“i“§o3§..§§°i§§§‘ti:°iiil°?.."‘3.‘.Z°SZ...§.%‘1Ziy1§§»L>o1v.31116311111’ili"li’.‘i'if.illii“el'i.ofiii'iiéfhiilflo?§si1‘§‘i”lZ““i‘“i"3“o ‘“”i‘“'° i“ “m” °"g“‘““““°“ l" ‘h’ °"°“3 11"“ °"“"“"" "‘ °"°“"“ whhh‘ h” hhhhws "1101" ‘eierheh of Order m rcrcrflng m a previous 115110111118 1-0 111050 510F105‘ I 111111 bwlhgwogcl-gthree years azo "chCStnuthJh-dllld least in the Prince oi Wales e1: ert in that artic Te-efiie y 1m Prcvnmh I agree heartily ‘vuhhmh m? fmpenmentfl] fox smuoh‘ HOW“ 1° 111° 01111115111011 as b91113 11111111111?’ dcbnte‘ 11101111118 1110111 110m 111y1110n- 1'1‘1°11¢1How' much sense of responsibility. College a ‘love for the-land — whv might have askgd IOTurICI-lfillilofizttl‘?Bcfore I g0 any further I “um 1011111211 when this Om" mme ‘mm I do not think that any remark I E ART- l 0g 1S0 1011B‘ "1111 11103‘ 1100111110 \1’0111'15°l110-‘then can my hon. friend be ci-edit- thev cannot be persuade-i to stay at ment at that time and I believe tlf-Jhxpress my personal regret‘ and I‘ g“ me“ wh° we" Prepared, in lull... ever upulled‘ not only w m” HON. MR. ST w i in fig! $1 ‘use when ‘mother of the alleged crew,“ “uh” “ow much sincerity in honhe. I believe also ma’ the sum- nonunion Govemlmnt would h ‘l-lhhlllk. the ligzret of every membell gr or to get the station in Prince Minister oi Agriculture but to any hhh I "my shy 1h“ 11ml clallltuhlee litors of the Bell Government camc1tlie course which he has steered in mu- schools for teachers are agood given it to him 111011“. 1h“. hhhse‘ 1° the h°h" M1h1s1eringulfi1hlto p111‘ hp 111° “iooo- 5111110 511211311111? 131211? Houfie, ha; exalt: gghlhlgigggyhgiagh/felhegd dogs not dejnlcng I suggested to him that he reuclllug llle seal l“, now occuules? thing‘ A‘ any mm the Premier. - oi Agriculture. on the fact that that. 80 at ons went on and the o9. qul e a ar. wou ' . . . . , . ._ t; " ‘ tuhity was given tn i ~ J .. Jshould bri an action a alnst the . ll in . if h t M any F1110. i110 51111 I11"! 01 11- 1111 hlchdhhy mlemed aha hahhlhe nor e 1”‘ "1 "*1 hm ‘hmhd 1° 111°“ hmehhhg” 511G110 111.111.1111 tthlblibuhetg?tiihirxfigihs1o°v0fnnlchlg and I €11V0g111m 1101- What Premier Saunders Promised. hvéttcrlgducatifmrlnalfiiiilghfonzlhizihlg "I111 we had a Sanatorium. unit il1-Y"““1='1“‘1-" “’1‘°‘~" a1 1”°:‘°“1 51'1"“ gracing e11 mm of me mm” in the House except that the matter trmlfh '7’ dust he dslhh a erfeuki‘ mlsslou lo do ll_ l thought mm the Province’ m“ we ‘vm gummy‘ hmuwas allowed to x0 lnlo dlsuse and iiitcildent of the Womeus IilStltlliCJi ofierel y 110i,’ "11ilht come up to that “'11$1'010F1'0d 00 by 0110 11881101‘ 011110 m 1 e B“ he an ave p ‘only safe place to scttle that matter 1 Rggumlllg ll“, debule on Thurs. l“ ll _ ‘neglect, and that it is the institu-1d 11h“ Provhwe 15 "1 V011’ sreious h Md" 10 relieve the Gm- Govcrlimcnt- And why does he call “gm 1° her" 1° h‘ 1 1 ' ‘ , . . ,, . 1, ~,1hCfl1i.1l. I have learned of it w'it.h1e1'hm9111 '31 any financial 1 . was in the Court. because if wc pnld i it . ll l. Mr. Stew-ax P l,“ u ml, 11°11 800W all others which this P05901181- it idiotic? Because forsootha ncws- HON" MR‘ SAUNDERS‘ Yo" d“ a cmoon o! 1 u c c“ 1 . . - . - bllity. Those . ‘ _ , . ‘ Mu Gurdlnel. u. would Curl -nl . , . Province wants today. It would al-‘huh huh“? we hh hohc 1h“ thc.‘ . 11880115110115 "11 111111" 111 11115 Provillfle PBDOFtS W110" b23311‘ anhgfgfiflcglggllenliludllnlé have this‘ mntterewvci‘ ilgaiil rflionyihwallcu the dcbhlc adlohmcd 1115i ‘Fhtrc is another matter which ifmost seem, Mr. Speaker. that there lsfl1hr1gnh1h3f 11°1j he t? 5111113115 as “'°1_§'l§fl§f,"w§:f ugh; hxherhhehhhl 193 has happened in this Legislature and c y .,“ L ' not refer m my huh, friend, on llle other lluult mum I ‘v98 referring m the mm wry Closely connecled whh cduch. was misirianagclnent somewhere. I ‘f, ' fchh“ h” 1°“ of 1h“ “r9111 Prlnce c “h” 0°13"!!- The mnkcs some comments thereon. the h°hhe1hd L“ tyou can ‘if we refused him, we might be re- lullc 10l- lllu Lwdcr of the Ggvcfll- tioil. and upon which I wish .0 lnakc‘rclne1n1lcr 1110 rciolollig when Sii"f'§'h1:‘-w110n .5110 has been 110mg *1 to thou 011ml, men ham 1th“ 051110115 tllhlv-forc. thc 0l1i70511i1°11 15 161101161 a 12110011110321 CS'1I“E1‘WART‘ I am not 11151113 h 11151" 111111 11011651 b111- T110 mcnt regarding the matter of rcduc-‘n few remarks. That is the matter Charles Dalton made his Elllll0llll(.‘C-!Jh'en 11111110111" Wham thahrhcgt. 11nd they dill betwl‘ 1111111 511101111101 YEHSOHUIB! I 0m . l ml .0'u "eulous debate-but proper place to decide that mutter “on 0f taxation, Ygil will remem- of public health. The Spcmh froillllllCllt in this House that 1li.“\VOll1£1 111101111011 “'11s ‘11"‘“”h 1° 1h°_1“°11llc dld “l” firehhc has 551d 1113.1 80111;: to refer to some oi those {c ch Slgtémenl} ‘vhlch my ‘hon . was in thc Court; soiwe gave per- but‘ My, Spcakm‘—flt least those who‘ the Throne has rcfcrencc t: it: “ftglvc $20,000 to build that Saualoriillnlthnt some reference to the woik of‘ that cheque r ow what happened things. and I think I am safe in‘ [acid his nmdtv and I have a flght- ‘Ilission w Mu Gnrdlnel. w Sue‘ of were l“ the House last YUM. Wm rc_ ls m be real-clued lllul so lime l; and $1,000 n ygar to maintain it. wotlic Womcns Iilstitucs might well. 0r $5,000. that he holl- saying that if it had not been that _ ' ‘. _ _ , "u. Ouuoslllon had earned out "5 to say this. tlint with lespect to my course. ch the condition that it mcmhel~_lhe almost Slarglllll; glaLg-‘gilillli! done for publiciilllzallfai ill till; $311811! ‘that: “a: ‘htlld made gaczit £1,121‘: ‘lllllgctlrhlgzlllge ¥ii]p:h€nv§p§€g1; S?‘ thgoprfgén§iotliilficglfiafilw rm.“ , . , . would be without cost to the Gov- ~ f . - id on ml o1. 1'01’1100- 111010 05110011 y 111 10881‘ =10“ 11 10 81 1181111151 111 01- ' 1 ' 1 -- _ _ , 1 '. ' 110 ' dull. “ml polmed om those thlngs, hon. fiiencls administration thfiltfllctnmont‘ The mutter was ‘medulla grglélztaiowllllciiv; llolzagilfgt very fittlnglto me prcvcntlon and Lrezlnncnl olluulusls u; llml‘ l-lluu gefol-p lllu moi-o to bc-ttoi- school conditions ilhyxmsc off‘. The money il-as‘ new,» “'0 would have on the Statute books were three or m“? cases 1nlwh€f ‘strange to say, Mr. Gardiner wou null he Should "lake Such a 5mm. the dread disease of tuacrclllosiihlbuilding W35; {hushed ll Co“ Su- tho Province than any other 0rgall-' Tlfcghed- 111M 15 the history of u; 01 this Province legislation thatlhc dhcohhhhhd plocecdlhgs n lie thc suit. nnd the Court decided that luenl__durluu llu. debule on lhgnmv so prevalent here; but I ailvCharlcs Dalton $60000. but he pnid‘1lflt1011 that I know of. You have“ goo 011/111‘! Government saved that “W111 17° 10101101‘ 11 1711581000 1° 111015111111011“? Con” ngnlhst 13111150115“, w Mr. Gardiners bill was a Just one Draft Address. His statement was 81110 t0 1111110111100 that 11' GOVBYH- 1110 11111- “(M01100 5°. 1111' 115 1110 ‘my 1° 11h“ 1h‘? 116110111“ of their M’ but 1 wq had voted ‘he 1111111115’. fair name of the Province. 15110111171 have hhch 111m‘ I hm hhhmld should bl, ualdu Thule l5 m, verv clear and unequlvocuL lllul‘ merit is making h step Jfwflrd lh treatment of tuberculosis is concern. tiviiirs last year. which shows that m “I” 119101‘ “pended it. I sol» 1161811111118 u? ardy Mimi“ ‘heebarwthh. doubt in thc world that if all those the‘ policy or the tliienil liiiity would 5001111111; the services of 11 11111 £11111‘ 0d» 1t has not helm-d 11s ally. 510-1100 who $110111, 1“ 1"‘1"°"h‘1‘ shmflly My m“ me Pram!“ hm” h°""‘1'“°“' ‘lolgizriuinwlflxlugivo 11112.5 l: nu: nmmh" 11111“ 1W1 110011 1101111. W111i 111 be a downward revision or time oxhert chest dllagllofstlhialifl b u l'\1‘ill‘tmllxlgtSllé1uzltiizh h»! TullcrfulosisuE2110:of:lfiltldalitgflngfigfif; 1:21;‘? when ivomgochlgegezpoegg “hm . 1 _ _, ' ' the same way we would have liod . and more cs eciall with 11111 \'01'y 8a o int: e cvc 10 0W 111 01111 i1.’ V01111¥ - ‘*1 ' ‘ 1 " ' I may say thllt I have been in this1hhs 11111159“ hdcnwl 10- one lT. m? thc some result; and so we have my Efaflfilllf, the motor ‘lolhlolh leyos, n it is a move in the right direction‘ advice. If thcre is any in which l 1111011 110015- hllllplyihfl 1118-115 811d 31111115’ 11011- Mend from the First House for ten years. and have beenhmmhchd Case‘ “nhd 1e in“ 1h hon, trio-ml qulgt on ll," “Dump w“ absolulcu. unquallucu um; humid 1 will glvg the Govern-mill full can help in this fight against tub-llllohvfi 811d 111111111110- 1111114111115 °111' 1315111" C1 P111100 Says 1t W118 lio moi-o or less closely in touch with “h” "m1 h” mu“ dh° lhrmwlw 9 Faleonwood. um...“ “l, up, s¢,...,.,..,,i “hi, h...“ credit for it. They arc (lo-operating crculosls l will do 1t, nnd I hollove111ousvs-_ robin-inc fioglioles. and good inyway. He said some other "1" lellisliition that has zone “s” “emu” 1h” “rhehhl p200‘; :5 words: "l make this statement 3nd witll other organizations. and we every member of the House will domork n1 that naturc- Anything that 1101111110 11111181- 111110111: them the fuel. tilrnugh. I have taken part in put- hgh1hs1 h1m' ti‘ dnt h e h l 13 I notice another matter on which repent l‘ w "u" mu". Wlll he m, hope thnt the result will be that the same. It is a ti-ohlcmloug ‘pl-Willie Womcns Institlies undertake that therc was a wonderful m! ting thrcugll a great 111E111)’ P1111510 hmvf that t e ‘éhlloz- 1w“ uh my hon friend is silont. Speaking mlslakc about “u. 1.1mm are hlslthel-c will he ll full llme expel‘; chest position, ‘I have given the Govern. they (lo well. Now. it is said, they at the Victoria I-Iotel on the 15th of lluuxurcs mysem and I have never fully 111111011051 a ~21‘ T“ i iii the Budget debate in 1926 he words as quoted b‘, me palrlOl1diBQllOSt1O1i1n.I do not know wlleth- mcilt credit for wlilit it has done h, have interested themselves in this M11)‘ last year, and that if it h“ sccll legislation introduced in such a 111111 1“ 51111-11161 1° thmeh 1115"“ _ said: “Too much money is _being newspaper‘ ' er that means a full time health f- procuring the services 9f h ¢]l(§5;[1il‘fl!i(‘l' of public health. and that "01 hcch 11" 111111 hlllqllet we would disgraceful state o; that introduced "hdmshmd 1111:; If‘ 11"”: m spent cn Fnlconwood Hospital.‘ That ilcci‘ or not. but I think. with t e dlosilostlclnn: lt is a step in the lhei- have already waited upon the 11¢v<i iliive discovered the hon. '1' 11115 5h551°"1 MY 11°" 111°“ 1'1" are nmendmen henlgdm 1e p l. 1s i1 wry clisy thins to say 111 Oli- Afterwards, when thc 11101101 111110,1~¢-venue M} the disposal of thisGt right direction. But we are in tl1is“1°"‘1'1"“"h" 1 ""1 _1'@1".v glad to 11101111101" from tho First null-lot, m, fcrrcil to one or two o; thggg time- 0115101115 AC1’ by 1' le are‘? d 8181,12; P05101001 111119 my 11011- 11101101 111111 come, when thc finances of the Pro- crnment, and with conditions su 1h position today that we must do 1011f" 111111- 1100111150 11 1110f’ E00 110- ""1171 1° 11111150111 "lf 1t hadn't been ulw He menfloned the smtum mm mciit. 1 Dirlid mgél wghdfrglil Parlla- qulle a finger l“ the exuendllure vlnce were under conslderutlon ln m; they Mm that lllul would be lllu sonlethlng hl the ‘val,- ol gl-palllllol-llillllld.l1l_l5‘lli0\'Clll(‘i‘ll, if they sup. for‘ that bnilquet he would nevi:- vlulng rm, the borrowm‘ of monay think of as ngi I5 Le it tum m‘ lusl year‘ anullu. "em was very thls “Gum the Govumlmnl made loglcul dlrecllon ln whlch me Gqv, o; lllese case‘; 1f we cannul do any. pol-l. ‘it. it ls n fairly good Rllarillltt-o hint‘ l-iin an election. and looinvint for tiic gravelling of highways which ma": muhhfi“ d “Noll “.02! on thb‘ much greater than it was during its gnnQllncemcllt with regard to rc- crluncnt would devote its energle . thing. we had better get out of thoi that something will br- done. “'0 would have lost! ~ mmle me bonowlng u m.“ charge P5101111, lo? ur e l wthc preceding years. The average ductlnn of t8XRLi0il-——th0 reduction On more than one occasion int a House and let someone clsc tryfi l nm sorry that my‘ hon. friend He doesn't agree even with his 311911‘ the automobile license fees. l ° ifs‘: “KR SAUNDERS‘ He d“; lfil-“ghgdtggllgouaiégddéiféngolvhlgglm loqtwlllgllt ugyhlilohéegfingn rallérhléd slollrlggfimléagnthfiisqlzlmlalini 12:?st-gllglzruihhnllliulresrnon‘lilo llltlglbgl‘ from Eustifit: lismhozvioll own t-itidfini the House. salve do ‘n2: om ed - ' ' ' ‘ 1 111. - - - - ; l - c are.‘ iii; sea. eclluse c so - cxpcc 1m o a i-ee wt us. he knowgutittzsmzehohals riled“: 34,3110 exactly thllt- [to $110000 p01‘ your» I 1101-100 my solution now before the House. Aftcrpoint out and to give figures regarlzg Export! "0 00111111! 11011‘ y?" 1111101? g V n _ _ ‘lneus Instltucs. of this Province found fault with the Bell Govern- them was “heady a n"; cl-lul-gefl I-ION. MR. STEWART. Very we . hon. 11101101 151101-‘111111801-1118 for any we hnd made our nnrkluncemeni lie lng our public health condition : 3'01?» 1110)’ 01'0- BXRIINYIIIIK 001111111011; united on the Government the oth- mm; {m- l-hlslng mall- ow“ “lulu and how could there be two first Why did not my 111"‘- me‘? 9°51‘; less this year. _If what lie said was chided us because we were poor imi- and it is a matter which will bcn ‘lfllltl they arc telling the same stor charges on theunme “ma, He pcnc the case until thednoXmCourtfi trlic then it should be true now. tutors; we were simply following hlsrcpctitlon, because our record in W0 know that "lore are one hun- Stewart Government on several or-‘agtl-hl- hl thug‘ hul, when h, m” knows ma; when he u“, out lnm when he would have a V1111 I0 0 Why zloeslh: not put his precepts lilutloi-ln, and that he had been the this respect is not an enviable on . drcd of our people inid away cvcr)"(-a5l(>lls, l would like to correct my, to blnlnc the Opposition of that day o money markets ol cum.“ m. that amendmentUNDERs_ w c n into practice. If he was not talking first to announce a reduction. He‘ I gave the result of the figures of Iuear in the grave from tuberculosis. hon, friend from Rnstico. I do lint for voting with the “h”; mm.“ elsewhere to borrow money, the“! HON. Ml-‘t. 5A d‘ . ndetfliketo the country, if he was as earnest had done this. he_‘said, for two reaathc export who came here under thie fly hon. friend the junior mcmhcr‘kll;lw ‘vhhlhl-l- hp Said m,“ hllell. I u.“ lusl a lmle Om I m" aw“, who wlll laud ll“, money wlll ll"; start other procee n58 a land sincere ns he pretend d to be, sons. first, because of the increase ‘auspices of the Red Cross society rom summersicie told us just what.‘ [lmlnlly or not. but he gave the au-Jieard that there was a vote to in- exhmlne llw vulldlly o; m, ulnlulle; him up again. I ‘why dets he not reduce he esti- revenue that would accrue to the and who examined many Ttlfllbertllllfl it meant in dollars and cents. Prince thgl-lty or n citizen of Charlottetown; crease the session“ 1 4 wln and ll m“ luglulullon ll“ ‘um HON. MR. STEWART. Have youlmntes for Falconwootllrd He ‘gays Province beclauoe of the irlifireaacdlomses in this pgozirhce. e resui ‘Edtwlil-d Island has the highest death ioi- his statement. and I would llkelwhich the Opposition conuihiil through l! lhtroduqlq m”. would done it‘! ‘ , _ ‘llthings are on a dowmvl tren. , it Federal subsi y, and sacon y e-iwas very muc e same as yoi rs e rem‘ tuberculosis of any Pro- to linvo some further expianntlonlwlth me G°vernmen‘_wem“t have found l; llllul dag”; Th“ w“ HON.‘ MR. SAUNDERS- I WBI- is getting easiei to finance now, but cause the Liberal party. of which hclhave heard it in this House, that. th vince in Lanadn, and we are spi-ml- from him. y. or night as they had wniimd on the‘ (ll-St, 1 do m“ llllnk he w" “l. to et the amendment first. 11 notice he is not putting it into was the leader had a tradition iorilast examination revealed seventy in! the least rnone to ii ht it TI t 1 Even munbel n1 11111111118" was a W“ m lacing.‘ m: fifntmsmki Wm‘): the opphhi.“ ' HKON MR. ‘STEWART' But W11Y1Practicc economy l-Ierefei-red to the Belkactfve cases‘ that for every active is the position wey are ixn ‘T112720 Sihtrrihliwhvhfiriifirhf‘ 2511110111111 1ndemm1gd ‘Vlliitwh-{ich- ou, an a resu e - - ' - - . _ . . - . ~ s s on concur .- stetule w“ umendeas 55o to ‘that expenste? 61g?’ not have! In apzallinfl {on ‘the toflllgzctulltlg: Ggvl-zrnnlehg: lllowvfihg hitaiiidleg‘ tfriefétllfi ten €0IlfRnFtS—t11e re- Wgstcrn Prgvinces. blessed by Pro- ivaltul on the Stewart Govcrnmentlcl-‘iihhcnt. We kntow this: ttlfe ihad t ehréililseslzosasu The caselytlil, n igaelrail‘ n he de l d l’: s: rs on ee ‘bl-Ion tlhe WGOVBSOnmeHf-‘h to ac lla, pic erl 7501:5135, so v once wit such healthy climnte.;lii regard tn this matter of puhlicjsionnl indemnity was raised, flfl- ' _ The", we" cum. lmumu My HON. . .. l gptlrl ‘its: to u . a“ ep ore t: rllve u M m r I m ‘t a you ruaiy 12001:“ cases of art; euend ng the most to light tuber~ health. l can say that with the ail-l the Government that was in pom hon‘ "lend mulled w 5M", m, is Pviwhhed- 1 ° “c '- 0 1' 011F011 "r08 were lcn n power. a e genera - urmu 011s n s v ce. It isall cu as s. and yet their death record t.hority' of olic of thc members ofliake‘ the credit of iti They ‘ name in two "A1111" °1 111° A"1'1"1 hoh- MR" STEWART? Will my mounting upwards and upwards. putat on which Liberal Governments vcly wcli i0 have an expert chest is 44 to 1.000. where ours ls up to thc Stewart Government. Probablywd it. It. did not mat ' ' Int Provincial Secretory Treasurer. hon. friend kindly keep still? I never What does he do howl’, I-le has just have had for economy. On thescldiagnosticlan, but these cases have 128 or something like that; I do not the hon. member was just mistakeilz1wheiher the Dlibodtionwrqmto! to m“ o; Duuuly Auuluuul pr°vln_‘ll~lgql-l-llpg¢d'|lllll_ w; u; not going told us that his estimates for next two grounds. having the increascdlhcen diagnosed already. The proh- emember the exact figure. but it is‘ but he should be a little careful iiilincroased or decrdalodp ' '1 cial Treasurer. And what did he to have a dialogue. My hon. friend y011r ore 8830,000—-over 8100.000 more. revenue and hBVmK P180011 119011111510"! 1!- Whfll "0 W0 loin; in do with esperately alarming. smoking a statement of that kind. Stewart Governlllit tn ‘ do? Any person iii all conversant is ve fond of the dramatic; but I They m surely r0111: onwards now! shoulders the reillonilbilltv of 11v- them? ere is one suggestion that1 because he will be corrected evcry of having deemed all» ,. ~ . with or havingariyknowlflh What-Hm n t going to assist him in ale-Jo you see that is the amount of lng up to the so-colled Liberal ti-li- Need of Sanatorlum l ight be given; it is something thafitlme. and we did not 1 ' 1 .1 ever of ieliahtive draftill would veloping his talent in that direc‘_tzri.'1'05l>01111b111ly with which my hon. diticn. he was going to reduce the It has been said that the Stewart. 1M been talked of recently and of Government Grants what the Upped‘: “had o. g »- ." hue u“. mmwhi ‘- "n m“; ‘no u. c“, w” lhe Mann eyfriend spoke when in Opposition. I taxes, and we were simply imitatorslGcvernment did nothing in respect l y hich the members of the medi l '.I‘h tatcment f th Premier silo titwlun lmtndment. simply theone tri twice before. On the first trial wonder how much more sense of re- of his policy. to public health. The Premier no ~~ fusion are cochlea-lit. nepotism the sflblioot of puglio hzalth did n‘: I n’ ' .- ' J/ord for the other. ut my hon. the‘ majority of the jury wag vol-y sponslbiiity ‘ho has gained? How (continued on page 3) n little more generous; he gave us t one connected with the hospitals. give us anything more dcflaitlotitan IIQIIIIQIIUQ» g1 o; _ 1 l i - w i.» .