A
‘ '-"“‘\"""¢77»§  "p’@?"W‘-"""""`,':‘.7""""- Y " "T ‘ "*"_’ "‘-<" _‘; _ 'i , » ~"!\_i3;'Iii ‘Hn-1 Y _ »»~f;|» -,X  s;.\_» wg; < »...,. ,ww __ V. 1.~.v,gu - - »» » ~ _ _ - _ . _ _
* _  .1 -_ .._\_.~<~_~_._ », ~~ L=_~`;.<~~ '  }§§é: »  ,- ~'»____ ‘_ ~ ~=.:~>;-~_-»~:?"~"» »_ - -_ '_ =,.~'~~t,`7*3iti_~;§§~_:=-  tb _i;f'.~§_i_ _ ;*"f*»?'1¥f--_ "-as “`  .-is-_ -;._f;;1». 1-; si, ,'»_;>;._'v fr' -ti-_.~_ ._ -   
,_ _ _ _ _ _ .__»,,_ ‘_ _ _ __ __ _._ ___.__ ____ _ __ ._ __ ____ _,rr -in ’ ' "1-~-~'  t   ‘=‘*1%‘ 1:- -+‘  "1 '__f'=\= __ - -#_ -fi  @‘}‘m-‘~»‘?lgi»_.i~4’-‘<~‘~ -.». -_'itz   -f,-.,¢~.._e-L'-viii; _ ',».#w=‘_  1~ _-_ __'=§' _-1* "'~~ v 
£~f_, ~»§_ ,\__."'f‘-#_-_ ‘- i ‘ _ '_ ~  1. - . -» fit-'f:~1»~i ‘_ __, mi  'ig ' ‘fe xr. "_-r‘___>.»»_~_<=_  <.f_f_< ~ fri’ yi' _ ;;.:~'¢.;-   _‘<"“».-.;,~ _ ' _ _ fit-¥a_s‘;x€~».» .;._.-'M-_:-e  ,_.»1~.’- _=s~‘§i. *_ 4;  1~ ‘W - _~,
j_ _‘_*__ f gf* _ ‘_ __ __ _ _ f‘,,<_»!»~, _._____  __r ‘___ _-_ "__  ____ _ _.____xT5_.~:,-_________yE.>___ _ ___5?‘__  ________§_§‘______________ __    ._
-» >._ » -   -s ' ' - ~ ~ -~ f “,  ;_.'»_f\_‘-.,;_\ < -< __1'_;_'_.  '» `   _-__ .1»_.:_'-_.,~-fy ‘
_ _ if “ i qv A 1 ~ * ’ :es =
_ _ _ ,___-_  _ _ .~ _ _ __   __ __ _____ _  _._._.Q_______.___?_______ _ _»_ -_ __  e____ »  -._';
' t ~. _ p _ _ _A _ __ _ ~ _,, _ ,.3 '_ __ 1,. _ L- ,_» _...<__.,__=:g__-. ._,*.<,,;._, _ _ _ _ _ _:_ __ '_ 'f “rg -__ -_ 45§__e‘¥,i 
THE GUARDIAN CHARLOTTETJWN PRRTCE EDWARD ISLAND APRIL I8 1903. ' _ ~ f ' '_ ' '
)  `i
SATURDAY APRIL 18.1908 _
1H£ CATTLE-SALE DEBATE
B, g pu-gy veg; which not all the
Liberal party in the Hou=e would join,the
Government has escaped 55° °°“”‘“`° °f
the Legislature in the matter of the sale
of fat cattle from the Stock Farm to $118
D P Company It remains to be soil!
whether the unmialiakeabll ld’°"9°
Judgment of the country can be as easily
diapo ed of The law is plain aS $0 110W
the surplus or increase” shall be di
posed of It seems a quibble unworthy of
serious consideration to C181!!! U59-t the
law only governs the sale of younil Sf0¢k
and that the stock sold was not suriillll
stock We doubt not that nine out ot ten
fair minded persons, would say the Sf»0Ck
.aid io ine Packing company “S \>°fh
surplus and increase stock within we
meaning of the law. And if so, they must
conclude that the sale was ill°RHl
On the part oi the defence there has
been great searching of heart and search
inh of records in this mat'er After the
quibble as to the legality, the Mm sb"
for Agriculture professes to find that
some man new deceased did ell Stock
Farm cattle at private sale fifteen years
Ago 1|; ~ not worth while to ierify Mr
Rogers cit Vion \Ve ci‘o~=e rather to ad
mit tli it .ifttr a search tnrough ti e dusty
fiie~, entry by entry io fifteen yeme e
may have <li.~'c-overed that the lfiw was
violated in l$8. But t‘:at can in no way
ava‘1 for his defence. What would be
thought, if some man in these days
charged with a violation of the Scott
Act, or any other law, were to plead in
his own defence that another man since
dead had broken the same law fifteen
years before ? It was well statei by Mr.
Mathieson that the df fence put forward
by the Minister for himself could hardly
have satisfied his nearest friend.
And those who watched the debate
closely could not have failed to note the
very gingerly manner in which Mr. Rog-
ers’ colleagues in the Government cane
tohis rescue. The Pxemier’s brief plea
for him was nothing more than that a
gcod man might make a mistake. Hon.
Hr. McLeod who spoke brieiiy with bated
breath, did not attempt to "defend the
transaction, nor did any other of Mr.
Rogers’ colleagues in the Government put
upadetenee. It is true that both inside
_ 1
lid outside the .House the previous good
._., .
naputa|.ion_ and high moral character of
lr. Rogers has been put forward as a rea-
aolrwhy hid indefensible action in this
ease should be judged leniently. But in
public omce all that is -done should he
jusiiiisbis osiunwn mario, without im-‘
rowinghom the previous reputation of
*he deer. Each transaction should not
cnlyhe right in itself but should appear
right. Itisaweak defence to say thata
certain action is proper beans. ¢ 8-ood
_looiamnggamdn with the evident pu- _ __ ___ _wine can “_ _ _
poseofaesu-oyingiiiegooi eireeeu-our '°’ °°'“ “ '° ”" '°°“‘ °'"'"°1“'°”°`°’
kindly words mt i irony i n_i disgust as
If we turn from the attitude oi members The P&f»l'i0U Writer (i088 APD51`e“l7l7
ct the Government to that oi members of some one, perhaps ieeling sore over the
the Minions;-|,,1 slde what utter and ingior ous failure of the
do we dndi Although the Hiniste Privileges Committee, seeks now on that
thought it necessary to raise the party 30000115 50 VG'-if llli S9190 “D05 Mf-
war ery by pointing out that the mgtign Simpson He was in no way answerable
was one of want of confidence, none of the for that failure He had conducted him
rank and iile ol the party would 1-[sg to self with dignity and fairness so far as
defend him save Capt Read, who appears the Committee went, and it is unjust
Whave the same gon; of ;~¢1a|;,°;,S¢.°th¢ that he should now be alurresl by the
D P Company in Summorside as Hr Patriot because he was the only
Rogers has in Aihcrtm Mr McLaughlin Liberal member ot the Committee to
express=d his objection tg tha private sa1e|whom the Guardian did not obJect.
as he had before done, and as he said the “_”
loss had been sma.ll,felt Justiiied, on party The Patriot has pursued a po icy ot un
grounds no doubt in voting to relieve the himfss 'md S\1PD1`°SSl0D b0f-11 in feglfd
Minister from mngum other memberS__to the citizens’ meetina' and the debates
of the Ministerial pugy outs de the Gov in the Legislature, giving all prominence
ernment, remained grime, Sgme of them and space to speeches on one side Ii its _
of the Hous°,
i>Eai<iNs
LL E
img;-l
voted with a. 51-out |~¢1u°mn e and on readers are satisfied with this course, well
DP c ly
to save the Minister from public reproof 'md 'mod' H they “re mt’ “"7 Wm and
In eloquwh meme Mr I"_n_____ than both sides fair-lyreportedinTheGuardien _
whom there is no more honest or consei ,
entlous man in our public life, refused to Today 8 Pfobabilitiss'
vote tocondoce a transaction which he be T0R0N.r0_ April 17_(Sp°cid)_N°rthel_1’
hevedwbe '"`°°g’ 0°” cr m°’° °the1`|Winds, clearing at western districts
members left the room before the vote] Northerly winds and shovyery on the I, €I!lPl13.S1Z€ 0116 Of the 1110815 110i'1C§8bl€ f¢Cf11f¢S Of th M1 lllefy
the prominence given to becomifg yet new and f
a
children
Our showing of ready-to-wear and outing hats, eclipses
was t-ilien. We believe the country will lima 301| 059° B1`¢f0U~
honor these men for refusing to sanction
a wrong for part/s calie
Not guilty, but don t do it again’ is
therefor= the best interpretav ion that can May Wheat ,nt C0,-n_ 435 Pork,
be p’.iced upon the Legulature s linding H917 90
uiy \Vheat Tlé Corn,43§ Pork,$l7 371 I
CH|CAi:U MAKETS.
mcaco, April 17 -(Special). -
order has the personal attention of our head milliner
in this case T*ieGu:irdi<in greatly re 1rct=_
itbat llr R-gers li. placed h nself in .ig
p sit on sauufo tu ' Ve 'I'i.1~_]ournal .af ../
beenfor yeaisuiost frwndl, toliim It ix
»
‘ »f;~~4 _
_.game-’_;‘*
. _*"5  .,;‘.._.>; _
'hull even iecamniecflecl him for the Prem §       l:  If i '  _ -_
I '~ ‘ " "i_’.?';` _  
._ ';~'_ _- _.___.. '\-_,_,\;\'- ‘ "ff7_".“"""
E
?

iersliip at the time of the last vacancy in ; _~  I l  l V ` _ .
that position. \Ve did this because of the; _ ' - ‘  ‘ _  |‘   _
Bbilit which he ss s<= ' ' - il
` _ - _ M fi ‘~ _ _
2). __ __ _ :__ __".`_ ____._ 1 _ _ _ _
 . __ t-_‘,~ ' '- 1_
-_ 4-u _
Y po..e.._s, his long ex
perience in public life and and his mainly _ -V' 7-
_faithful public course. \Ve cannot, how-l
ever, because of such considerations re-_
frain from condemning his recent course f breathing by d§Sease_ The mood
I
i _e- __ _ »~'_';,____ ___ __ _i L..
when we feel assured that his action is it SS it HOWS in and Out Of ll1€ l1\l1gS` _ _ _
indicates the consumPiive’s pro- _ \ "5 ~` " »  ' = 1 _
--n?i_l‘*; ll
'~ __ :ll
i, wrong in principle and against the public f " ww V
interest. It is only because wearefirmly less oxygen is inhaled and the
_ convinced that the sale is question west blood changes from scaalfet ti; pur-
_ _ _ - ple. Oxygen is the 'e o_ the
illegal,unfair and wrong that we cJnd,mn _ Ofblood as tie blood i’ the me of
it. We doubt not that had the Conseria- the body, * _
tive party been in power, and had a Con- The e_ffe¢t °_f Dr' Pi°f°°'S G°1d‘ ’
ti M_ _ _ A en Medical Discovery upon weak
serva ve ii ster of Agricult re done lungs is to Strengthen them to en- '
'the same thing as is now charged against ‘ able the' full °XY8°nati°” °f the
blood, arrest the progress of dis-
House would have honestly recorded his I _ sues. Lung diseases have been
`protest against it. But the transaction is QE and a‘r§I2§;2§1 curnqd b{;_??,1d‘E§
one not likely to be repeated in the face of i msgs when d gated » - _ _ - _
an indignant public, and if the repetition  *__
isprevented The Gusrdian’s purpose in ' ` "‘.`;..
and get iirst choice _ ' ‘ ~ ~
cough, frequeniepliemor
rhage, emaciation, week
_ _ ` ness, and night-sweats
performing an unpleasant duty will he whaveall pointed to’afatul
__served. *D <=* \- ' '°°°"
1 i
/fi
_““ __;=  _=".;»`7L"__ _
in-__ ~  _._ 'LI
~§_t5,_\ E11; Wal limi ml? D fi’
. _ - _ _  __ _  _[___ 8   ____ i.. _  ,{a_____j£;__-r, .1?;';- .,. _i,»..,;
_  
Some ill-natured person who evidently
___ _  ltldvidimbiihil
~~--a - "` " -'
3 . _~_:.. .' 3-~
mfy friends and neigthlbors laid givfep al_i_ ligpie
m ,un i one a a n a vi _
kindly words. We congratulated Mr. :re ;dx§:i§;yri;r::_e's coideévi Medical Di_ge¢:_v- _
Slmnwnill hearty hlhion; referred' to T¢6§fi'i»ai§'xi,¢§in‘d»'i§i' io$°‘.°°'iiii'li°i§kiu° - - _ _ - .  ~_ 
D ` botti I I honest? beiievekieiiveres » ' '
_I the tact that promotion had come to him Qu n,,°;,.,,,'f,‘,‘,¢ ¢,,,i,¢1,’,,,,,,¢_ I m no, . ' _ _
atrong and hearty man.”
Dr. Pierce’a Pleasant Pellets cleinae
'early in hispolitical career, ind intimated ~ _ _
man Md it. Itia hir to ask how the same
__that_h_e might _expect _further progress the clogged ,ystgm f,.°m_nccum“1¢ed_
,and advancement. Nc one but an enemy = impurities. `
l -s 
s
A 5
~ __
f
1
l
il
’ i
~<
'i
*-
5
3;
- #Ei
51;?  H I
__f‘_._ »
_: *'
_if 
 if \ _ .e
\~ } ,Q
' ._
_ _ 1
*` ' ,L .»_r;» (_
_ _ _-.af x i- "  fs: ~ ~ _ ._
.'    ~ If  5-~; _ = _ _ - _
' . ' ' ='.." ""  “ ~,>_.`-'C-‘ 2,, i,-;~"~i"¢:.; i - ‘ ‘ _ - '
'- . _ - -_ ‘- T' ~i- L_ »_-' ` "»‘_‘;-.4 .cf ' _ V
_ ~.\-. -_».,.<_ _i ~,~_. :1_,_. ._ ._ 1 ‘,-.7_ ‘ y_- f __ <9 i 4)
A- 5, _, - I-‘ -_“"“f__ 15'; lg-'L I --' , ' a
.- - -  ,eg »_"r\~_» _ :_ . - ~
 “ ‘I "»rf~‘~ ,~;:$_ i ‘ 'f 'fri 3-. :,~___;f- E157 _If ’ i -
,__ _§~_"_\_*E°,-_, _  i,{,_ _ - K 5
- .
A _ an-xi';.~¢
GRRNDMILLINERY UPENING T Y
_ _ _ __ _
/ ' _ < _
, _ _ - _
we cofainiy miie the iaaies of chews io an may and f¢mn¢w___w see the gems   S.r_ri==z
mists-  and h1=@=f v=f=_iffii=1_m°<io_i=1 Pos, me  
in New Yea, has out were eimsneal isilsgaon, his uni 1i¢r_etff_iiius¢_ii inf    D  "
 A    i= ~=11 morn fe he =_\=i11 ==5i_e_1i¥=”f   V
_ _ ' ” __ ___ ___ __ _-__ _~_,__.___.’¢\" ',» ' _"_ ' ¢'{_' _-“\‘ __ _ ,r-_ -_,,- ~__ ___" ._ __»   _T
A  _~¢.-~_i;. \¢vij=_» ' 7 ' "   .iff "'_~"_='1‘) - .r-`-"'.`
- _-__ 1 ` » 'rs ._ _ lift >"is_=f, r =f`-*tif-~
U. ’ .`. _ 1 1'. - 1 _ f ,, i- __ _' "D 1 ~__ ' _ -,_-I _ '
e mm  _'~g-:T P. M"   : . . _ _ _  ii _ __ _ _ _ L __ __ __ 
'iris nii.i_iNERY LEAoERs
Thei°e’s no mistaking the fact that we have the mnlinery tlie
admire l\ever before have we hwgy stylish Hats and
time has the assortment pleased o ves so thbrpughlyil We
Niss (G Helen l/li/'anlim
gf” AS *h°1“”gS gf” “wk” jd ` _` ' ‘ Wefare, showin g ,this seasoxrliani eitraordinai-'ydarge_1ang§
up-to-date and high class dress ni'-2ater1a_ls.‘ ‘D ` . We have _
iselections, so as to secure the most desirable weaves  cokgngs, our 
pecially being to please you and secu`:1‘iE“’_' your entim"° connde’“iiéf.;g.f_____oi our
confidence _of our steady growing supremacy in this department; ‘~‘-  -A e- = -et
!-.
A
i
D 5 l  
others
other large shipment received yesterday will get iirst showing tfolday'
‘  _ '_" -_` _ t  ` _.if-‘ 1.._> '_
'_  _»_~ "_"_ -1*,_ 'ff '~ *rf-___,_..__ __ __ ___
_  Today we place on our centre table 40 pieces of Dress'Goods to 7
Mr _ C1 ~_ sell at 47c. per yard. V In this lot you will iind some very 4 _ o
'R°g`"’ °v°" L‘b"“1 ”‘°mb°' °m‘¢ ease and heel the inflamed tis- ' _. plain _goods in the new shades, and plain and iigured _black goods. Come early
-i ° _wi
fi’-T-~”
» _
K
\
1 '-
A .
. Q, i T g
* vowii nsoiisdsiniinery aiming isnefaiffom ni overlies' ' -   TM Ceiidisi ~==d'_'M°°fi°=°  j
: __~. \ __.,_ __ i _ , _ _
'V ~_-;:- _-__1'-A __.» _ _ _, , _ _.' .. l
were personally selected by Miss Rendle and Mr. Prowse :~a_t' the big wholesale miilincry 0P¢11mS3_ W‘h1°1_¥ th! 
f.l1lSSP1’iI1g, 1 i_ - _ » _f_ __~ _  t
Come today and we’l.l'_sliow_ you more pretty millinery than-you ever saw in  city. before. _
i
_.1 _
M \ i
i
_ .
  _11-is _,styiisii`5aiiiiiners. _ ~ _
___
 " ` _ ' .I ;__
~ -  _I-i~_'»»  -  ‘ . ' » '
~.. \ » so ‘»~;g-'§"2.- & ‘ 1'-,_ _ _ ____ M _5;__;__}_Q__i ____~__,__ _ ‘ -. ` '
1 o
_ * `
‘ ' a
\
women most
The diver dies without air to S D - i f ,w _ A'  `  ' 
breathe. The consurnptive dies ‘ , ' _C ’ ‘_ ' _  _.___
without lungs to breathe the air, ‘ _ i __ _ '   j ~   ,gi ‘
or of lungs rendered incapable of i. f __  '_  Ifj _ 'i' __  /___ _ ‘ _ _   _ff
_ _ g _,.§..,, __ _ 1 `__,|__<_
_ . _'_ ,<,,__,: \i,§.f_,~,y:f i$’_fI_‘
F  ' _ 'CC_ ! .--<- ~ - _ _ r' _ - Y _ _ Y Y _ _
transaction would loakif done bya man__‘of Mr. S‘mp=o1 wo li nervert these - ~  _- 1 - ` .
who isnct good. ' _ ' _
. t ° ~ f _ 9     _ ' s
_ l »     __  .      s     _
I - _ " A. “
a s _ ' i I _‘ " d "`  V
_ _ _ . _ _ _ ,
'a e ` ' H - ‘ ‘ i®x  
_ _ _ _ _ __ _ _ _ _ _ _
u S' ` _ _ _ d  ~ ` v x
2 ' I ' '
_ I ‘ , - _ _ . v"v` ' A' ' Av' ~
° ‘ .  _ 'g ” _ », ,_1. v  w_» _
_ \ ° o _ . _ ,_ y _
_ " ` n e _ _,=_ ,Y Ii: f »' ¥ ’
° _ a  - _» - " ¢
- . e - ° ' ' e" ia ' _
' A el e V o 1*" » 'r' o 'Q
_ _ _ _ . . _ _ . _ _ ’   _ 
. A . ' A
` ‘° ' ‘ ° ' 9 -_ _ - e U a '_ I e I I 14 0 e
- _ _ - 5 _- C ' _ ' _  l ._ ~_ .
_ v‘ " v i »`./ I _ _ _ _» _ __ _ °' ` ’ ° _  __
N " ` __ . ._ -i . 1 ~ ` _ 17;* ._ _ v
_ _ :.‘ ‘ . _ - _ __ _ _ ._ _ _ _ ,__ J ___ -__ _ T __ _ _ _
 w' _  - _ _ _ _ _ i _ e » _  0
. - _ i ‘ ' "` ‘ 1 "A ' ` 5 v","_` ‘ `
_ t‘ ’ ' " ' -  _ ._ _ _ _ 3 _ ~.-?;.i_ _ ‘ _
_  - ~ =..‘ . _ ' : in   ~_~. _ '
' _~ - 1- ~  in 3   ._  ‘ _ '1 0 J. '_
» ' L " ` A ` 1 I I -  - 1'/  <§’>`:5:"i “ __ - 5 intl V
l _ \r __.~\ P` _ _ vi ,
_-t _ _ ls ii
1-,~_
` I
4 ,
4