»»,
‘ri I
if.
if"
_
_
_ _


 iii 1
-T” "“ `:‘:;-#:;..7‘..i.'-;._~

if-ffl.
' ;':-'- .'-'sfcr "$.71-'
l_-_
'.»--lil
1 l
l
i
l
I
l
mg
___ _
.=_._~y
l__.
"li`
I
<
i
Ill
:H
..~
._
.l
.‘1_»vl,£ _ ri
,_
s.n_
v
\ _-1- ..'l_ . _-_ _ ____j _ _- L_" ,_ ._-’ ._.¢;. ._ »~ _ -- vi _f 1.*  1:3,-;, :" l - _- .__ 1- .| _ __ ___  _._ __ j 2,' ' _ _ ____ _ ___ _1. _  _- .__ _ __ _ _ __ _._ _. _  _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _
§__k_,;§ 3 _ _   __ ____ ,__;;~I- .___.¢.{i___ __ . 5,* __ __.§__-.___-M ‘f»g»l§_ I 2.-  _»  _,_ _- _:__ .ml _  ,_._¢ 1 ll..'_-i.Il+2'§¢- .-   _._-,,-,___ __...r,,.__,< _._._,, an § ¢_,____,___,___ __.__%__,,--_____._,,,_..,,_,,_  ____ _ _ _
.:.... - ' `l'\' - . `
 I             inns E   
li ‘ I
af- -ff; - -...-1.   l.:
,if
“'1
Au
-WJ.
_      __       - 
_. ... -
` _ _ t .____.
(Continued) I _
af “‘ ~ ‘ _ " ` " _ '  ~ °1c‘-‘if-5*" ond euibodied t . ‘ ` 'e' ’  __ -_
- - _ 1 . ' » “'- -‘_  Mrs Bell asked: “How many The statuie does not‘ provide 'that t ilrst'-rate importance? “buf .ill hit!
' " 5 ' _ __ _ ure' there wllg"-are lifilicted with tu--the maintenance of that institution ‘_ speech the hon. gentleman started low
. _ _ _ . _ _ ~' ~~ ,_ bcrculosis on _Prince Isdward lslalid?shaIl be provided for out of ii speciul | and descended iowerr and lower, and'
- _ . Now that 'ls*a question which lily hoii.f» tax nu the pooplo oi' the province und; never "l;rappled` with au;-ll;_1g_l_e eau; 'GL
_- _ - . . -- . . 'friend from Clliirlotte'town may pus- that is what the Government is ask- the mighty questions a e e or
. ' 'aibly be able to answer better than I Ing us to du, to provide for the ulaiu-1 this iissembly. I will say this. Mr.
- rail. Iiow many? From the best _teliallce of that institution for itll fn-` Speaker: that in my conception of our
_ " ' ~ ' ~  Iliformatioll I can get. I-he number ture time out of a special tax". duty and of the opportunities and di-
" " 1 ' _ \V\>11l1l be 1‘9l>1'¢BB1\t€*d b a. tliousand; Bebore taking his sent Mr. Bell paid; fliculties -that lie before us, no As-
'-'_"'°' _- _ - 5! __ and I have that estimhlte from theithe following tribu-te _to the memory sembly has ever met in this historic
_ '. _ "  _' ` 2_5 uimi who are probably best capacita-_ of the late Mr. Iticiinrds,_ forineriyiiiail that \vas`charged with matters _C
-pR|pAY, MN__lGH_ 16, _‘l917_. __ _,_eii,_bcu.er crops ure--bcllig g'ru'wn,~u`t\\l ted lo know. At ally rate, that is Leader of the Opposition; __ oi' more grave concern, more heavily
"" " " ' "t1\e'1111@r Of the soil is 1‘\>u1lrfi:"1uw the csiinrala from several of ulel "Before i sit down( i _wind io soy' imllgllt with responsibilities and pos-
llis own. _ _ __ ' _'.lnedIcui‘nieii I have put the question one word on nu entirely dil`iercllt suli- sibllitles of the future;_ and I regret
Souria, in secolldlng the address in
I'
0
ie
til
Bt
G
C
 ‘McDonald »° 010
en!
re
the
rs] ___ ~ . HC
npo)l`e_‘in eloquent terms oi' the privi-
ln§;\  ofthe great British Ellipire
and me priceless gift of liberty wliicll ;
ofqhe consideration and appreciatio-n_
the 'Motllerlnnd hail always given the
Colonies. Dr. McDonald we-ut on to
Member inr-
y to the Speech from tho Throne.
ibrmd. to the deep signiticance of
'advent of the new Govemor-Gen-
to the shores ci’ Canada
" 'which (‘onli.dians had oi' being
enjoyed to the fullest extent and
te that, with veit ten exceptions
t Britain had always sent out to'
nada before and after Cl;~lit`e<lera-
groatlst ability and, wltliout except
ti
s
li . » -
tion, as Governors-Gelli-ral men of the
o
, of the highest illts-grltv ' lu»
n » - .- .
this connection llc rei`crrell pal-ticli-5
rlyto Lord Dui-Inna. the mail wlle;
ls`_
ilrpt urged respc-lisibip i:ovcrilnielit|
lid
tho expediellcy oi (‘olli`clIol'ntioil.
Otrfederation said tho spcallrlyi
B .
ll » - ~ '
' 'ed to be incoinplctc willlout
Newfoundland and thc west. lluIlc_.~
and he showed the great zidvuiiulgc lt
would be t_o_C:ulad.a, und thc llmfll in
tirlsl ovince ikrtiuuiarl_v. it' those co-
t
s
B
vi
oi’
DJ' I _ _
les were a part oi this tircnt llo-
itlion. "\\'e are as ircc ns the nil'
5' great. Dominion ot' t‘.ili.idii <,I`
untramanelicd in work out its
i _ ' ' ' ,
Wjhlcil we are so proud, is l|llt`l_-ttclv-ll
_ii I
0
ll
WD destiny. and it is iii thc iliiel'c.~;t.s
01
every individual ill tho country to
that the lloiicfur and tin- wclinrc
the nation ure upheld. 'i`he words
the poet are cluilieiltly iippliralblc
lou
m ~ .
we 'broatl1e," suiil the i-lpeiikir. “ond
ll
00
l.¢`('anadlt. to-day. ‘i :im al llilligllior
In
my motl1er’s house Init. lnlstross ill
y.ovm.’ The Duke oi Coliilaliglit,
in
continued' Dr. McDonald undoubtedly
won in a great deg-ree the synlpnihy
llildrespect of the people of Canada.
not because he was near the Throne
'bitt because he took nu unbounded in-
tbl'-sst is ali conscious; onli it was
knlariy fortunate thatfsi the out
Freak 'of the war Caliuda should have
ILC
'the head of affairs a man or such
large experience and uiiliillry iruin-
ing as the Duke oi Connaught.
ltr. McDonald then referred to the
terrible conflict now ragilil: and of
the terrible consequences ol war. lie
0
was proud to claim that the grandest
triumph of this war was in the realm
f medicine. "Take away nicriiciiie_,"
he said, “und her lialliilnuirls sanita-
tion and hygiene from thc battle
fields. and the belligerent lirluies
would vanish as tlln dew lll~l‘i»r<- the
s "mer sun."_ ~
\`£e_-,.rc§p,r;ed_ to "l_l_ii\_ _ .i)e_l_v_eiopm_ertt;
Commission and said that even the
claylinder our icet and the sand oil
t
he-'eeasllol'e were gold mines. All
these things could be _developed if we
liad the men and the i-liii_:l'p--i_-rl. "'i`<;~o
m%\y men lczive olir sIlnl'vs," contin-
ue' -.the speaker. “Wo should have
“stay-at-lionie clu_Iil~l. Iiulitlrcils ol' poo
l.
ploleave this proviucc cvcry sulillnl-r
o
como 'buck snddci' hilt wiser lucll.
Others develop a waililcr-lust und llc-
ver -come back illl they all-u 0-1' liliic
_or 110 use. to thu p"oviili_~c. 'i`Ilo :in_ _
mga] gxlcnpslon to the \\'Q,-,t in n dis. out of ihil ill'diilur_\' l'i'vcllul‘_ lint in
crimlnatloil against this nroviilcc.
The Developnicllt Uoilllllissloll repro- _
sents the cl)-ncelltriitcd f-'iiorts ol' nn,-\'iill;.:l-in-\'_ thc I.lIli-lull iliirtv had :lu-
most progressive citizens, und ii' .it
did no _other good illuil io_<‘:iIl nttcll-
tion to the treasures that we llllve, _tile
gold mines that wp ilnvo ill this pro-
vince, it would deserve <1-ur llchl'il'clt
' thanks." '
Dr. i\’fcD0l1aill thi-n look lip the
question of providiii,=.: for returlicd
soldiers. "'i`(;~~ila_\‘ wo l-:iii give them
our thanks and allow thelu our (lucy
appreciation. but in thu near future
Weglnusl. give- illcnl sonlcillilll: more
silbstailti-nl. \\`l: llllvl- no public do
multi. but/ ihi‘l'n.:lre._- tlloiisullils ill
scales ol` lilliliscll inllds Ill ill.. pl-i-lllli-i
wllicli cull bo \itIl_izcd ini' our .soi-
dlb`rs." ‘ 1 ' 1
In dealing wiiil thc lllillu-:iliilll lie
pal‘tment__Di~. .\l<~Dcll:lIi'I 'silhl llllll ull
was,goillg wcll iiltlltlllgli |l\l‘ Ill-|».|rl-
inent tell, tilc__ fiop‘ll~t.Inli l'l~oln its
ranks owing to th`<~' i-il`li.==tnlr-ni i.<i` lilc-
Superlnieiuicilt :old Loaeiloi-s in _lhc
/\'rul_v to ihzlli. for thi' cllllfw or lilo
ldmpiro'-_ "Afll~l' ilu: will; llo\\'<-vi-r."
slid ihc llprll'iki»l'. "\l.'bi~ll |lt'l|iv_~ will
lll'\*e lhccll rl~l.'iol'l‘ll. illc gllalll wilrk
will he taken up again."
Agr1culi.ul'¢\ was nr,-.\l lli;ll»li..¢.r;il_
The ilpcakcr pointed lllll-illnl lhis
was the basil: industry- nl :br prll‘.'li'l~=-_
lL_lsl under it highly orlxniiizrll li._»,r,|l't-
ment." he skid. "llllll l'xtelld.~' ll livlp-
lng hand in overt- izilnicr in Illl_- Isillil.
Aa IJ result farms :irc ‘lwilllr llli|ll'nv-
__l _ ~1;|_p_1l:1.l_'lmf
 2
A woman never looks
better than her Hair
`¢o|r~tG| ei- mon ooreislli
 Si?/0.?/f
1 ll I. ll vu ua ll. mlm vznwr-u.
of woman owe their
to NEWI-IItO'S
mutter what may
ith nnice
is soft,
looks
0
it ro
[Brill
t‘ouiilluillll_ llr. .\lciloll:iiil said: lo. Now, then, this instltutlon_1>1‘0' ject. Afewlliws ago we heard llbout'lnost sincerely that custom or duty
“'l`lu-ro lu-vi-r was .sucli pro-.~lpoi~ity oil vides for tho care and treatment of the death ol' the lion. John itirilardsf shoiilil render it lleccssary' to follow'
thc lslulnl us ihore is to-day. liar- in.-lplollt. cases. The simple question lp Cnlirol-nln. _It camo to us as ui the lic-n. Leader 'oi the Opposition
_vests halve but-ii ubundallt and lhe pri- is: is that a reasonable nlalllier of gi-ea: sul-pl-iso und a groin, shockl _lt_ iiloili; the line he has chosen. lshall
ces high. 'i‘llol~o is pence lllutcoli- liltclupiillg to grapple with the situa- was entirely uncx-pected. Mr. Ili-,_clidelivour to cover tlie_'groun_d" as
t011111l€‘111 l‘\'\‘1`i‘\\`ilrl‘¢‘. - | lion? 'l`0 lily mind it is not., In il\B chards was o_t` .course fa. politician oif_ quickly as possible ami return to some
'l`h(. Ilai'vi-si ol' thi- _soil hus nlso ui-l iisvll’ which incorporates the in- the Liberal st-noni but its was at lcilsl _uioro profitable discussion. _
.beoii .ibuildn_lii_ li is ull iildilsllyv'siituiioll it is recited that the doors it broaillninded and geuorolls pollti- '
thlll has been lnul-h ilelzlcclell. \\'l~ of ihut illstitutioil are to be open only Qian, 0f ¢_onrno,` lnfgfteil und occu- ' _ _ _
are l-ight lit the irolil door ol illi._lu l-:lscs of lilcipient tuberculosis. \Ve non to httuuk his opponents. but in SOUND WITHOUT SENSE. ‘
gi-cuties! fishing grolinll in lilo wol'ld_`kliow whiit these ure-cases where his attack upon' his qppolleniS`ih.0l'0_ _ ` ' _ ' '
llc urklld lilo building ol' bl.~.ii llal'-,p.lrli.'>s li-.irc just contracted the disea- was seldom llnytlii;,\g_ oi.__tllc__stiug_io_ I rclnelnber, ill the early days of
hors, null the hoilusing or sinuil sc and liuvliig just contracted the di be felt. His political opponents _to-' whbiit growing ill the \Vest, in iiiunlto-
sclioolll-l~s for the i_1llcoll|'ageilii-lit ol” sense would be taken to the institul day giye him C1-edit for that brood- ba, the first steam ihr0Sll'2!`_WaS|11l1`0'
the iisllilil; illduslr_\'_ Less ' tlinllf tion und treated, There is no ques minqerlnes of spirit which churactcris-_ duced by ii half-breed b_\_» the name, I
ten lll<~li.~luil<l dollars comes lo lIlis'tioii but what such patients taken to gn all his qfmtings with giwm as Li.Ui,iuk_ of Gnsmam and ,t ‘ms rega,-_
province in thc shape of Iloulities‘ tho iilstltution would have the best beral Rep;-esentntivg n,nd.ns, Lender oi_ ded us a marvellous colltrivance and
i=.vcr_v _veal-_ llc i'ci`crl'cd also tolcllnilce oi recovery. There is ilo ques the Opposition in this House. ;\nd__i had ii great vogue. Of course it had
-lhipbuilliilli.: and shelved what Uuiloilnltioli about tllnt. But; take a case out think I am voicing the sentiments of li. good nlltny defects. It required a
und all ixri--.it collutrios of thc world ill the country; it small country home both sides oi’ the Ho-use limi of the small army oi people to feed it and it
owcu io tho llicrcuiitiln iilnrini-_` hc rn- wilero till'--rc are perhaps two rooills peonlc of the iprnviiioe w`hcli I say that did not turn out il. v_cry large pile of_
'T111' f11l\1\‘1‘ I1C‘1`|1lll)S 11114)' U0 33110105 we all irrespective.ot' politics deplore llraili wilcil the days work was
with till- iii.~'e;isc :ind It is in the nd- his loss, .Besides that llc was n tllrougll. llowever. it was wonder-
vnlil-cil st:ii;c. (inc OI' the cllildreii genilnmnn \vh0'took :L deep interest ful, and its owner was ;l mai1_ot vast
is ui‘l*e<~icd in thc ilufipiellt SlHi§0~ N0W~ In the ziiinirs oi this colliltry, ill ngri- .inipoi'tailce during the tllreshlng sen-
ll 5-* l11'Ul>0S<’<l by the G0\'01‘11Il1€11l1 10 culture ‘especially lil, the importation soil for ft llumber_of yenrs. But as
H1141! ll1i\t i1\('ilJi1‘11l C350 10 U10 1105131' of stock. llut in everything llc did, thc crops grew larger and the demand
i:iI lol' trcatllleut :ind lcnvo tile ad- it was not dong with nn oyo to his gi~cui.er, rivals entered the field with
vliilccll misc llchilid. 'l`hut would mean ne;-spiral interact. _lt was done with better equipped machines, and years
lcalviln: illc source oi' the disease there in eye ri0l01v 411111 singly 10 the better- uftcrwnrdsi heard this Sf0'1‘y Ol P001'
I0 ==l11Ui1il lo U11' I1'll1f‘l’ 111C1I1l>'~‘1`S Of U10 'nent ol thc cc-nclition of ugriclilturnl old (lasnlnn, that he held on to his
t`nlnlI_v. it would be ulorc _iiiiportnni 'ntgrgsts in this province. He was a uluclilnc. Ile would not bcIie_vc tha/t
lo vliilcllvollr to dual with those nd gnntlnninll ill o-vol-y sense of illo wol‘d any other could -compare with the
vulll-otl clis\~s_ was it iloi unwise in ntl his, dtntlingn with both his qualities and virtues of ills, llllti_i nt
wus it not. looiisll cn lilo part, oi the 3,-ininln und his oppollcilts; ii perfect last his custom passed entirely from
L_iovcl~lliilcuf. to olilcr into li contract =_»ont|<nnnn_ one of Nntnl-(vs gg-,ntl@»|n¢n_ him. lie still, however, cherished
w`iiil~ll pl~ovillcd that lllc only cases W0 do-ploro Ilil»l_loas, :mil as I said lil-S i`1\ll\l_I11 lllri 0141 l\11\f1\'lil1€‘. 111111 1114
tllut would hc ll-olltoll in thc iustltu before. i think tho nlmnuol-_s of thin llc grew older and his faculties became
tion would bc incipient cases? '{t,.“,,-p_ Ono and nl|_ will join will; me less under control he >lt_artcll_ ollt with
it is il lllulicl' nl’ the utliilfst loci n giving ‘this zulprcciaiioii to his nie- U10 <‘lil I\If10llll\_0 I\Hi1|11- N0 D01`11011`
i_<l|nfn,n_'l _mm-y_-l _ ` _ would i-.iigngc hlnl to tllrcsll grain, and
‘ ~` --'~ '"1'-.i\‘_\'|~F I _ hc llscd to go to the old llcups of
Mr. Hi-.il l-olilinucll: “Another ina _ h'l1‘11W H1111 HUl1'l-`11i>- 1110 0lfl_ 111iW11|110
gi‘clicil the incl. illil.`t. till' shipping
loiiliulgc oi Uuiialla to-day is loss thun
il wus lor ilu: l\lui'iinic I'ro\'lllcc.<-
lliiriv rc-:il'.< ul:i;~_
lil coll(-illsioll lic spoke oi the |li'o`o-
It-ins that would arise lifter the wlir,
zlllll lllc sluildilll; llli- liolilinli.-ns bc-
_\'oil-_l llin scns would have ill l‘cl.:zii‘ll in
illc illolllci' (‘oulll-i'_\'. \\`c-uid they be
lllllii-ll togctiicr hy stronger bolltls
than sciltiluclit ill one l.:l‘unll iillpc-
riul uillt_\'.". -
_ =\
MR. BELL SPEAKS.
.\il‘. llidlii. .suid lic \\'oulil deul with
lllc uliiludc <il` lhil l.ilic'r:\l pnriy lo-
wul'-l~< thc vote ot' $30,000 tow`i|i'<ls till'
Pzilriotif-_ l1`uuil. lie thought. that
lnxnlioll lvzis 'both lillllcccssary und
iiimpcliiclll. I~`ir:;t. it was unneces-
sary Iwciiilsc tho province liliil iwo_
:fr illroc yours uno, rolnc iilto posses-`
sion oi li large iilvrease ill its ainiluiti
subsidy. llailiclv one liuiillrcd thous-
and dciizirls. lil the next pincc, thc-rc
wus nn ngl'icilltul'ni griilit oi' some
bwciliy»ci;:Iit or iliirly illousanfi dol-
lairs wllich cunblcd the Govt-rliilleilt
to iidlliill~istoi° or assist ti.~ administer
the i\gl‘ii-.llltlirzil Dcpai'tnic-nt. Also
that thc prcseill tlovcrllnln_lit hull un-
der its control some $71,500 oi taxes
over ond above what thc Libcruis had
when they were controlling thc ud-
ministratioll. _ ill other words,_t_Iint
_thc t`i»llscl'vntivc Party of this prov-
incc haid ilnrirl' their control $200,000
lilorl- ni lx-\'i~iilic-_ than thc l.ibcrnls
hurl. null tilcrl-i`oro out oi tliul reve-
llui- th<_»\- iiligiil, very well be nlilc to
atiorll xi pn_\illoiil_ of $20,000 townriis
the i‘ulriotic l"ulld without the neces-
sity ui rcsortilll: to direct illxlitionf’
Ile coliteudcd that this ilovcrliniclil.
Iwi illcreaseil -the .expenditure _on , nyc
s'c-vr-_l"lll" df=pzli‘llilf=llls ` di” illc' plllilil'
si'l‘\'ico :=rlli|c ioriy ill' lll`t_\- Ilullislllld
ilollnrs ol' llloro ovcl' null ul\ov,- wll;ii
it ilzill taikcll the i,lbc'l'ni l'ni'i_v in ud-
iiiiilislcl' tllusri scrl.‘lces`.= 'llc .said thc
i;ovel°llnlciit should retrcncli. und that
tlln (lovwilliielli coullf very propel"-
iy, ill the exl_-lwlsc _of jiitlicious rc-
irl-lll-illlvolli. llulc llvf-ll nhill in snvll
I-‘1ill<'l' b'.I0_000 or li large-llorlioll oi
it on th.. public sorv`il'les, and there-L
iifrc ll»‘l‘ll noi li:i\'<» wsilrtcll io dirol-I
tnx.iIioll.' 'l`Il.-\- sllollid have lllild il
_order that lhc :inlollllt for this pur-
posp _should llnl t':iiI ulldcr ull_v_l:oll-
sill.
of tllc_
matter
tho
it was
O
lilo,
(I
i in the statute Liberal Palt is concern d. i speeciles that overlooked matters of I' “~ ' .. - -‘-
[)l'0i)0l‘ ' WBSG,
and `makin|;
at tl|Gir own
_would have a
conmm to
wo ' brace
people of the Drov-
tllst’ docs not deter-`~
nmttor so for nil tl\e_'
TUESDAY MARCH 20. 19l7.
iliivllllltioll oi iooiislllicss is this: ' MN - ~
- ~ ~ - ~ ` I _ ii , . le would hon-r this riltt-
llcli-_ we lllldcllakc to llirilingc .in in _ F lllttli _lc lN‘0P
stitutioll :it Il1"0 000 al ycni'-l aiu :ls The H0115” "itll 1'! _-H-1 I1- 111-- |11' ling noise. It wus old Gasmuli tllrcsh-'
suining that ici' thc prcsclit. (li lat' Wl1f‘l1 H10 I’l~en‘ilel‘. ii0i1- -i. A- ing tho straw over again. Now, l
,-Um-..,.__ wp ,_,l,“0L -,-ww it from \i,@_ 'I/iallliesoll. took up till- lleblltc oll_tllc folt on l-nailing ovor- this speech of
stullllpoilli. ns it, is io-iIu_\', -because thc edilrcss iii reply to the Sllcccli il'oll.\}tlll\_ lion. Lcadcr of the Opposition,
.~o»,l_ or lui- liisiitlllioll io-lilly is vol-y ‘11\l'F11f<lIle~ Ill <I0Inl: so Ilia I‘l'v-luwr
lnl~gcl_v puid and borne hy thc llonli ‘ ”41\|i|1 -
illou Govcrilmelit. 'l`licy pay for ull- M11 -“5i1l‘=1k*"1`;_ I Wad 1101- Dl'¢*S011l 011
tllo costs, und pn_\' gcllcrollslll, I un 'Sntillwliiy lust when thc debate wus
zissiireii, for the nniiiitfmnlicc oi such 1d.l0U1`110d U11 111y 119111111' iii’ U10 H011'
patients ns ure l°cllii'lll-d soldiers lilid M1* A"5°`“‘"‘“' l "UW liikii UD U16
who urs llcaii-ll lu that ilistlilition. -111051100 bcl`<>r<= the liousc, the Conai-
'i`llul. is not it guide for us in thc ill ”1&f=1l'i0ll Ol U10 I‘€D1y 10 U10 9-P08011 Of
tliri-_ \Vc llnvc to gl-npplo with that l-lis Iloliour the Lieutonuiit-Governor.
_nllitti'i‘ to-iliiy as If that I-ondilioil of 11111 01| 1'i~fHill11l.i_l1V.-<>1‘, \l\"»‘ Hi1€“‘Cl1 1|12\'l
aiil`nil~.<. did inn o.\‘ist. \\'c linvl-_ to ‘las Ilccn nlzillilliy _t_h'l_~ Lcnilcl' of the
l1,l':ippIi-. _with tho iluestioll: Arc irc ")Dli01'iiU01\. 0110 “'0.Ui<1 11“\'0i` 0‘/“U
Ill'ciiurl‘ll iodaiy' to pilv for till* cost of ‘lucas what »iilc‘.i‘cui_ 1l1i.¢‘sli0il llciore
that illsliiuiion hy sprrilll lux llllon '-ho U0115i“\\'i1r'. llcr wIiut'colisirlcl-a-
lm. D.__-0},|(- of this .-"uni,-,, fm- its _snp tions 'wore _involved in thc discussion.
pon .ind lui- wliolo frost? Now, Thru hon.l:<~llli<~11ull1.=1\`11-'l'1u»1l<ills =1
then, wllili is lo be ilu- cost oi tho in V0l'y_-l`|2W l'f‘nlr\l'ksi ou H10 SIN 0011 11110
sllitutiu-l\'.’ 'l`llt-.rlr is Iirsi Ihr' lliicstion i‘€1llill‘l£ii rntlicr lleI‘0Ktiillr_\- oi' lii0 I\1”0¢l`
oi`.._llc},l_i_‘c'lr§uii_i _i. __ f_l`_iiul buildilli; i'list` pority of t`nuzidu _;_tlld_._ol` this province
rlluooo' _ ~~'*rll2:-#ili-pl~e<-liiiioil- ol lilo: and illdllllzcli in u mllaail of ileriy llc
lluildlin_-»-li wooilcll bllil<Illil.:~~is going iitirs null llc-voi'__i5ci¢\il‘llc1i`l0 thc dis-
lo llc lit ll»;i.~<i 10 por ccllt p.»|~'_yi»n=- clissioll ol’ the ililp`oi~lnlii qllosiiolls rc-
'l`ll1i|_ will llc at cost ofsollic $6,000 ic .l`0l'l‘l‘il lo ily IHS l1§l`1110l11`» l il0l1'i
si;n~|, _“~ii_3;_ _-uni thc-n _look nt the beiii-vc flint the ll_oli. gclillcllliili would
lnrzv oxtizn iillll llllllc;cc.~l.~lz\l~_\~ cost roll- be wilfully discollrtc-c-lis, .hui his llllm'
lim-tml with tlln collvcyillfz oi' coui und lS\101'111i-Z 01' ii10=i0 illiI1l!S lliut were rc-
supplics oi' nil killiis. l'os:~'iIll_v the garilcd as lining oi i`ulid."i`iilciitul ini-
pot,-plo who null,-l-tl-il tin- _lilnhtinn may portnllcc. while llc (icuii with his own
_j|n-,~,- _“_-_li-ll nl-.roi-illlig to the Ill-si jiidl.; petty \|lu»stio_lls_ wollill in lilo oi‘tlilllll°\-
lllcilt. but 1lllt'ui'tlilinii~l_\-_-for ilu- tio conrsi. bl: _<'onsilll~l~ciI .is li`l'<-lllliiilllioll
v.~l~llln.-lil. ill-`~ posliioll or lilo ulsiitli- of lilly illi,0_\'csi ill"iIa<-' i;l'c=`lt_ llllbllc
iloli is sill-Il Illlli the i-ost oi colil zilld 01il‘sii0IlS. il 1'0l111dl11ll0I\._0f fl"l\_v l'i‘lI1l1`|i
tlle'l-i;-st'ol` l~oll\'¢-_\':lill»c of iloi‘c.~'sh'l'l<1s l`0l' ilic Sill-Ztrlsiiolls that \\'l‘1'1‘ Illilllii
will' ln;l‘mlol~lnol|s_ And [1,.n~,. is uno _ by ills llounlir for the roll;-llllclvilioll
ther l-our l pul infoi~|llod,_which is of this ill;-usc. ’i`licr¢ were sonic ini
_ eq\l;llI_\"scriolis. zliiil iliilt is tllc- rust D01'li1i1l li110¢='1i011S1 'l`l1C1'0 WIIS ilu'
tilol'i.-l-ll thc (lt:-vcl‘lliilclii to borrolv of olltuilillig li supply cf wnicr, ililliost 1I\1L’Stl011 Of U10 f.'0Ullili0l1 H110 I_l1‘11i-f\‘€‘-SS ' _ ' ' ~'
ill cxlsc oi ll<~i~r\_.~'siI_\'_ lilly sunl lvliiilli ns scl'iolls as the lillcsiic-ll ol` thc sup- Oi' the \vi\i‘,-ii. innttcl' oi thc iirst i1ii<[H"“ "Hegm l“‘m"‘iS° “S "~ plank of
llliglii bc ill»i'es.~lirry to .nilikc ull nlly lllv oi' c.oul_ ll' _von bclrr lllesc things n01'iul‘-cc. 'i`herc was the question ol' “mf i?‘“"°"‘"' 1*- "Eve" wi” PM i“w| . ~. \V. l
tlcfllzticliuv. The tax wus also incx- ill` niinil. and ii' you lllahe eii<nlii~li~s i»1‘1l'\'1‘l_i11l< 1`01‘ S011liC'1'S l'0ll1l'l1iliK fl`01\l 0m.pT“u°rm.' Always] Dutfhc case clam' Stands unmumucd' L' “we
pediolit. lici'liil:=r= tho 1\l't`el~t of it as to thc cost ol' silililui' iusl_ilutiolis_»-- thc \Viil'.-nlloillcr mnttcr oi' very “aft lS_pu.L lu that speedf: 'nat wliell
would be lo del`l':it the vc-i'v purpose zilul ll' you be-.lr ill nlilld also Illht. so gi'€i\i l‘011f40<ll1<!1\C0: and there was the Hu” .movliwe e_"te"9“ (’°"f"d‘*m"°'“
for whit-ll ihr- lelrislntloll wus iilsti- ini' ns the rl-venues are ci:-iwcl-lied the worli of the l)cveiopniell_i Conllnis- me mmmmn Q' h0th.p8m.es to the
'llic<i_ 'l`ii»_‘ D\ii'llo.~'e wus to lllci‘cz\sc“plior ns well ns thc rich lluve n right Sion, a body oi` inell selected at ii commct was "10 MARE SLCH PRO'
thc c0lll'iI>utic~ils io lilo l’litriotii~ to bc lakcu into tllllt illstitutioll_- provillciul nleciillg and comprising ii |,,._._ -
I-`uilll_ 'l`Ili\.el'l`l-l-t oi' the ilitrolilic- ii' _von boar nil lllisc things ill »ill‘ind llulubel' ot` the nblcst und most pro- ' l ' - '
tion ol lllnt ic;;lslntioll wlis that the and llliike eliquIl~les couccrllilig the izressivo citizens th_ut ollr country coli- _ _ _- _
llcollln oi illv l~oulltl'_\~ who paid tllcii- cost of sinliiul' illstillltiolls in_,otllcr Iuius. Their work has been i-ontlnu - _
taxes io\\.llds that plilpu.\i» uolild le- plo\lll<i_~. _\l.li illl|.~t ionic in thi. coll oil.. :ind on ii. rccellt date. ns it is C ) O' 4 ' ‘  F ' ’
soul tho ;lppIil'ulii.~ll ill illvlll for vii- I-lllsioll Hilti lilo l-ilsl ol' tllllt. lllsiitll- i<1i0\\'li lo the public. lllrry have sllllllil- n   0 t e  ’
lulli:il~_\ l.lllli'i~blllio.'i ' ` iloll will Il.-_ ui Ioiist $`.’il.000 ir _vi-iii' oi' ell up _unix pill ill co_i_ii~ri-to l'oru| lilo - “L I
_\ll' Ill-ll llilillllllllu; shill: -- l_I liloril, 'I`llc qucsiioll we nl-o if;ii'l. to l'e.~'liii_s oi' Ill-__\-_l:;il";'i luln;-nrs_ '|'hnl . - - . _ ` - _ 
\\'{is' u.l::`- to illllloso P tlfoil i`n`l'i' \\'llh is: Ari- \v__¢-_ |ll'cpni'i~ll lo \\'as llot__\\'ol'lll 'ai i_llu\u;lli_ or al pzlssilll:  R .‘ _ `
lux hui it uns ll <illli<-ull. ihlln; to rc- vote lor n slim-l;ll tux oi' solilo $20,000 \\'o\'d iroiii till-_ ilcnller of tho Opposi-   i  Pordinal.-_y
nlllre -ii., 'I`Il~-_ lui~rl -\uIll\_ i|lllli.'-.<1-ii-thc.-_or inol-l~ for till* llllrlloso ol' lilo inalill-` tion. _ l_I_o__li:_td sonic igljicvullct' nhollt ' _ 
ilu. :mill ill`<'oill'sl I "Oli, lIli.~; is only- tl'll:illl»<~ ol' illflt illsiilllliolii’ » sonic il;-_.$n.~1_ s_o|ul‘- p;il‘l»_ics 'wllo wulilll _ _ ' ' _ ' »  SEPARATO i-_ 5epHf`aLOfS
'tl:lu|liil‘\li'_t»__ |l|'l\l'.l‘l‘lliu;:. '- 'I`llil~l not ll-l___ "| :illi lmiiii; ill plll Ilizil .sullllw l|lll~s- Iwi _july ll|l"ll' l:|xr'.s__:l.llll _who _“""`"  ' _ " R ‘- 1 Se 3
onlv ill irirvl- lllltil'Illl" iicxl. nl<"r~fiil;; iioll ll/ my lion. l'l'i4~llll l'l'o|ll i'|lul'loi~ S110-ll _lfc_|‘ illclli ull hull lo `[`lny ' Illc'1J» - I   b ff O _ _
or lultil thi- l-ll¢l_|1_l` _thc llc-_\'t_l,,ogisll tciuwll. Sllpllosi- lilo (lovlwlllilt-lll nl’ costs. ' 'I`l|ni wus ull vl`ll~:ll_y lnilrll ilnl ‘ G Ta _ UL _ Whglc
iu|'f'. li is only i<~'lll|llll'ul‘_\‘.'you hood tll|-‘culllil_1‘_\- hull lull llliifllls llilllils slly porlnlli lo ilil: l.gluiil_'.i' oi' the ()|lp'oi`§I-` ' ‘ ' 
liol ln- :ll`l'nill." And so iliul was thc $150,000 :l _vl‘:ll~ lillil said I0 hilil: `l'sl_> limi illnli this ;:_i'l‘:li 'ltiusillills _iiizii ‘
pl'llllll:1itloll plli \`¢ll~w:ii~il ‘I\\' illl: (lil illzli ill llll- lll'-'l lllll-rl-»=|~< ol' illis pro-‘ wel-i-_ bvilil: lllzlllt \\'_ll_il ily lllv. l_lt>ve|i;~p-
\'i‘l`lllll4-lll :lu :ill illdlil'¢~illf‘l`l| ill llll- vinci- lol' ilu- l>lll'|u-::~- I-l' llll- vlwullc- illclil i‘olilulil<.sit`ili.-_~»llucsllqlls :is wide
pcriplrl |,, wiillllillli lllcil' l»ppo.~liiion Io- tion ui llill0l'l'liloslll_ Ill \'.li;ll main- its lull" lll'll\'l'lll'l:ll l'r‘.lsolircc:~'. The
til»~ I:l\` l"'>l' illvsv' l'l-lluollr-_ -I»l- lli~-~ uoillll till- llllu. l:l>n|l»-lllull ilppiy l'il:il'||-l‘ Ili this I'oiul\llssiuil vlluli Io vil-
wilisf- lilo i:l\ uno lllllll-I-¢~;l:1.l|‘_\‘, und ihnl ll|oll<~_v‘.’ I Ilslvl- llol lill- Ii~:lsI i|llil'l~._;llili i‘r_‘.plli‘l 'llpoll null iiivcsiilgiilc
il.-onli <_- it wil. illvxlll-llil-ill, Illi~ liilwr- dnllbl lllul olll- |liil'Ii<_-ll nl' il ll-» uillllvi into vi-lllillliills ;l.l'.islllg ill collscqllf_‘lll'o
ul.: :il ilu- Allliilllll ..r-.=siull volfvl rr-i-oilliiiclili»io bf' npplli-il l-xllilly ill ol` the wnr und i__o mlikc prop-,iz-sais
alziiilllal Ihr. ilnllllslliilil ol' lllll lux ni' :ici-ol'll.'il|1'|‘ wllll th,-. lillr- lllllt lil- nlivo- and |l|ii|l.~l 'lo lllcci rolldillliils io tlrisc'
$;’1l1.i10‘1 lo iw iii-\'ol~*ll nr. ll l~l-llli'lI»lltiolr- tcil :it thc last lwseillli ol' this llllllsc. pi‘os|li-cilviyly :liter tho war. No more
I.. Ili-_l l‘liIi'loii_<- I"unfI. ill' ill|l‘oilli<~clI ii llli»:linll~i~ Ilrri- |`l~r the inlpnrinnl, lllicstlonu were ever assign-
.\" to lilo :§'1_0ilil wlllcll who io 'bc plil‘|lol~'l- ol' cllallllllllg illn t‘il_v iii l'Iilli'- nd Io any Iiod_v DI ‘mcll lvllllin this
dl,-\'ili»‘ll illwi_ll‘ll:l lllc i'iinlllll‘ll:llli'c of ioliciriwll ill lluv" nil lllspr-rilml of provlilce, :lurl lio_ll_>0ll_v0i`u1c'l‘liolrllom
ilir- llillion :~l.'ln:ltol~llilll. tho Illhlllulis its sl-Ilrlols_ 'I`l;:ll was li vill~_\- llmpl-r un lniporlillll workflins hctlii i~ilIrllsir~d
vlmd ;l',:uiii.~=l Illlll lux liilll Ili order io iilo:l.~llll'c_ :ind I l'l‘|lll~iliI>i~i', ill- support- were over lnoro i'liiilii'lli or more sili-
uil'll~z‘:<t.ill1l ilu- posilioll ol' limi. lllzll» lux: ii zli lllc illilc, I wus olll_\' sorry corn lil Illn prosel‘.lli.loll oi illeir ziims.
ti-r il wlls llc<'l_~.~lssl'y I., rcfcr Io the tllul lli,- lilcais-lii'l» wus not 1llilr<~i~xicll- \‘VJlut. did Ihul. count for when lilo
stllililv ol itll!! iillilllr lvllil-ll the Ilul. slvi-. ll' you had ii portion of ihiit Lciiilcr oi lilo tipposltloll wanted io
Ion Sliliniorlliin wus lllcol'porulr-ll. $‘._'|\,000 lr/ spl-llil, could you l-lpciid ii. in tell wily ho voicll agaillsl. the Patnlqtlc
Sonic lllsililiuiioiis had been illrown any brlter nlallncr. lil nny inol'r‘. ci`~_ Fund iiild against. innklllg provision
across thc floor of till- Ilolise that with t`e<-.tive nlanner. than by' devoting a In the Dalton Sanlitorlunl for soldiers
respect 1,, Mr, Dalton. hc (Mr. lleii) consldcrwbio portion of_.ii. to the rigid returning iliilictcd with tuberculosis!
wus lliiingoillstil- i_o lllln null tllzit Ile nllgl l'ri»i|ilolii illsllvctioll 'til' thc colin- When Ile wanted io ndd lo his excu-
wlls _trying to throw cold wnlcr upon' try 'si-Iloo-ls ol` this prtlvlilcc? I sub- nes. all Illciic ollicr dues-lions sunk lil-
iho lllll|lt||tlnll_ 'l`llcl~o was no pcrsull init, ihut. no cxpciilllilirc ol lilolloy we to ilisiglllilcuiico before Iillii. _
ill the llouse wllo had a higher and could possibly make ill this country _ |,,L0,.¢-at
ilccper appreclutioll of tho contrlbu- coulfl be devoted to hotter purposes Educutioll was supposed to bo iz ` ` Add pep,-;,t,|at|0u
lion which Ml-_ Dalton lliid llliillc-tllun than the illapc~_clic»ll of our schools, question of some importance. Not Add L03, in ewan, `
ho hflil. lla l'ccc~gllisclI that it came ond il' we had $20,000 nt ollr control one word did the hon. gentleman lllive
out oi al genorolis Ile'ai~I. null what- it would not bo to put it io the main- to say about thot. Pfobably ii _tho
The whoio -question of agriculture
and nil that that h1e`aus'to‘tllis pro-
vince never called forth 'one word of
comment fremdiiul In that speech that
occupied tho talking part ot tllrcc iles-_
slons ol -tho House. _ ` _
'l‘ll_o flsllcnnen und' what their _for-
tunos are and what the duties of Ca-
llnlili and of this province are to thorn
he never tllouglltof nfentloliillg in all
tile throo hours oi°'more that ho pour-
ed forth his oratory. Tho prosperity
of this province and our thanks to
l’ro'v`Iddnc'e"I'or all the' good things we
have enioyed_.l_lé Ignored! and when
I re¢_ll_hlll this .morning l must
say felt I ull( a “letter note and
kept s lower level than anything we
can possibi mid in our time. Some-
'or nine yours Ergo. failing -lliick into a
l throsh tho straw' and lllgbl. alter
when I ic-lilld lilln gottlnz hack into
spcllclll-s ihut lic ulicgoll I ilindc cigiit
discussion oi' things no loliger matc-
rial and no longing- vIt_ai.~--I iolt, I Huy,
that iilcro was ii pnrniioi boIwcc'li'ihe
Leader ni the Opposition and pour old
Johnnie Gnsmnll tllreshlng liver the
old straw. lnakinl; u tremendous rac-
ket und lloiln: uoillllllz_ Tho llilli.
gclliloilizill. il: sccllnl -in inc. hits plit
liinlse-ll` in li llusiik/ll cxui-ily on ull
fours with .this liliforiullziic old half-
brcl-l|` :iliil his worn-out liliil riisl-zirdvd
illuctiinti Wilell you In-al' in pr-rson
innlo- staiclllolits which you know are
not i-ol'l'cct,.-tlivl'o is at strong tempta-
iiuil io follow up null l'.ollii'a<lit'i ilir‘lil_
lu yicldillg lu tl\at'te1npi_nlioll. I will
cleul with iiic lnlsr¢~pi‘es¢-litatiull ol' the
lion. ircntlolilun as brlefly`:is I cull.
A FALSE STATEMENT CORRECT-
_ ED.
I will fir.-li tllko up lliie =<li-llcllleilt
whicll I. iliid-ill his spnccll-iislntulliont
nlalic ily other inclnhcrs oi ilic Uppr/
ieiiioll who piwllilps bcliovcll il wus
trilc-Ilia-t i hurl |lrolllisl‘tl. ns pnrt oi
our pIuti`orlil. tllui izlxulioll should bc
allolislll-ll, lllllt izlxaitillll llpoll i`lll'lll
luiid slli:-lllil bc :lll_olisill\ll. _-lull thc
lion. gi-lltlelullil luis hccn gnull cnougll
to rcicr io ll snr-evil oi’ lilillc nt George-
town in 1008- ill whicil I sct forth vii-
rious planks of the pliiti`orm ei’ thc
('oilsel‘\'nt|vo pnrtv Ile will not find
lwlill molly people eosstioiliioowié'
olnes a habit. And it is a dangertlus
abit which is certain sooner or later
ll
to cause serious disease. _ _
the first and most important rule _of
health. When~i.he'iiver becomes .tor-
pid the flow of bile into 'thejintestlnes
is slapped. and' the bowels become
constlpated. But you ,call readily
_overcome this condition by using Dr.
Chasers Kidney-Liver Pills. There _is
no treatment obtainable `whieh so
promptly awakens the 1tctivlty.oi the
derangements of the digestive system.
  I  '    liver]
THE BOWELS BEOAME' GONSTlPA`l'ED`"_‘ND Tl-lE_ WHOLE-__p|¢;E3~|-|Vg
__ __ _QY&TEM_ U¢8_E'l‘.' _ -' '
T°.l__l1°_1l¥li¢I1". __,;_liut` not i.of"°_ using .Di-il
Chas!! Kidneyfloiver Pills-and was sd!
benefited that I began. to study ting-_
lllllltuly- _ l found that tho.indigestion‘;
resulted from_.a bad ¢aaé“ot inactive-
_“Daily movement of the bol\‘els"' 'is iiver._ and as soon ae I got the liver?
“'°1'kl11li.1'il¢l1¢ - l_ l_iidn’t , have any.
stomach trouble or iniiigestlon. I
cannot praise this medicine too
llighli'. and would advise anyone. suts
fering from -indlgesiion or _constipa-
tion to. use Dr. Char-e's Kid`rle'y-Liver
Pills, My hnsballd also claims that
these pills _have done him more good
than any medicine ho over used. You
liver and bowels and thereby correctsare at liberty to use this letter." _
Dr. Chassis iiidriey-Liver 'Pills pow
Mrs. Herbert Doherty of Beaveritively relieve and cure torpid liver.
Brook, Albert Co-., N.B'.. writes: “iconstipstion, biliiousness. indmestion
can truthfully say that Dr. Chn.se'sbackaclle and kidney disease. Put it
Kidney-Liver Pills are a great medi-to the tes_t. One pill a. dose 25--cents
eine for constipation. I have suffer-a box. all dealers or Edlnanson, Bat~
ed from constipation ever since I canes & Co.. Ltd.. Toronto.
VISION, BY WAY OF SUBSli)lES,i
FOR 'l‘I-IIS PROVINCE TllA'i‘ l'l`
WOULD NOT IIE NI~)(`-ESSAIIY 'i`O
RESORT 'I‘O I)ll`tE(".’i` TAXAIONN
That was the keynote always nild the
foundation oi’ the cinims which we
on our side prcpai'ed fc-r preselitatioll
against the Doininloil of Callnila. it_
was the underlying strength of the
clninl which we finally presented with
success, that ill collsiileration for olir
giving up coil-trol of our custonis and
excise, li suillcient provision should be
made. by wily ol' subsidy, to ellublc us
to direct illxntiull. i<lvcryoiiu oi ill-
tcliigencc. l`ollowln_g the poilticul his-
tory oi' our province for the Inst twen-
ty years, can verify what I :ini saying.
There never slloulil have' -been ii tax
Imposed, and tllo iuuli. began very eur-
lv with -thu iliipositioll oi' thc ilrst
tax. instead oi' ilnposinl; tluii lax.
they should iinvu rc-prcscritud our case
to llniinda :ind said: \Viicll we cli-
tercd tiolifollelatioli wo were subject
to at duty oi only 5 por 1-cnt.. We
went in nlld liccuinc _rcsponsililc for at
duty- of uwro tllull iwivc that ninount.
Ni;-lv you have raised it liighcl' again
and we ilnll that our iil_colilo1b_v wny uf'
subsidy und otherwise is not suillcie-nt
to livc upon. They could have pre-
sented their claim. und Drcsciitnd it
with oiicci; but tlicy did not do it.
Thcy put oil li tux illstcl-id. \Vc :iced
not follow that on stage lhy stage. ll.
twas taken oil and ulit. oil ngaiin. it
iigrcw und crow, lultil, when wc took
_ cli:il'l;i\_ oi' ;lft`nil's iiorc, wo I`oullli oil
tho cnc hand at _-tax lillll oil inc other
llnliil it llciii, nllil thc yield irniit tho
lltutl lux _wus not. i~'uIllciont_ und has
not _proven sliilllciclit to pay the inter-
ostnn lhilt_ debt. 'I`llc debt. that was
,hanilcll over to us when we callin- into
ll powi-r has catuii up vastly lnorc than
_ the tax yielded by Lilo land. Always
wc colitcllliml that ll' thc Opposition
‘hall duno their duty they could liuvc,
-oi' sllulllrl. ilzivo, obtaiilicll :ln ilicrlllisc
`oi allbsidy that would lluvc prcvelllcll
thi-_ piling up oi' tiuit dt-bt. lint now
thai. the debt llus grown it lnust -be
icll. And how is ii. to llc foil? It
is illcii' debt; they llandcll it. ovcl' io
los. lt. is their, tllxlliioil; they hun-
_ ,|041 if (,\'@,- to us. Wo put in ll ciuiill
~fn\- nn ini-ri-uso oi' subsidy which, if
iuliv incl, woulll lllivc eliillllcli us to
provide for thc debt ulid for our pull-
lic services ns wcil without n tux. We
.put in it claill_i for $200,000 and wn suc-
ceeded in izceting $100,000. We got.
li subsidy wlllcll we consider only hall'
'oi what we are entitled to ill full. Our
pllt lil other violins ns well, and-'in
better times-if it lvern not for this
.war--I have no doubt we wc-uid have
‘carried our surccss iilrthel' tlniil the
l
securing of thc $100,000 ofauincreased
subsidy. But it carried us -this far:
that for the Ilrst tllno lil the history-
oi' the province since Confederation.
out ot' our orilinliry revenue we were
shin to niake both ends meet.
THE OPPOSITION AND THE WAR
_ TAX.
Why the Ilon. Leader oi' the Oppo-
sition should think it necessary to go
bin-_lt_ I0 the Georgctowii speech of
1908 und misrepresent it in the w__ny ho
to run our local uii`nIl's witlitnit rosurtl has done is one oi' tiiosn uiliatlioinltblu
mysteries than even he cannot ox-
plain. Tile" llc proccclls with dre-
hurili di thn road tux and the dog tax
_and thc old nlaii's tax, and comes at
jlast to thc Patriotic Fund. Hero he
starts to tlircsh ovcr thc whole of
the old straw of lust August. At
that time he went. away from this
House, I know, feeling like a mall un-
der condclniiation. Ile had on oppor-
.t.iiuit_y oi rising to higher things. but
he deliberately i.ook tho lower ground
und lilduccii iiioso with him to do the
same, und lic cnnliot. keep away ironi
the sccno of that crliilooi? Ilisi Au-
lxusi.. Iio irresistibly comes bark to
it. Ile ‘knows he ulnde no suitable
lor iltliug explanation oi' his conduct
then. lie knows ho slitisflcll no per-
son and thinks "l will try it again";
and what is .his tlcfencc? Ile says
tho Patriotic Fund is not ii porper
tax, und tho only taxes imposed for
purposes oi' the. War should be tlioso
imposed by tho Dolniniull Government.
_ 'I`h:-it is his view. Now, in regard to
this Patriotic Fund, tllcri~ ure two at-
titudes adopted by ill., siiiiio class of
iicopic. ll’ they lvcrc applied tofor
ii subscription they say: “No;' ici,
tho Local Governllicnt pay thiti. Loi.
illein but on a. ilix and pay t.llat;” .and
so they sliirk thai. slibscrlption. Then
when it is put oil as_o_tux_aiid the
tax is put up tothclu they say: "Tillie
sin;-iild ilot 'bc at tux. This should hc
at voluntary sub.~lcrlptioii." lt is tilc
enllln sllirkcr, tryiill-I in sliirk boill
ways.
1 A PARTICULAR CASE.
i. I could toll lilo ho". gi-lltlcnlail___oI`
li. lliau of wcetltli. ii nlun treo io give
and glvc largely, wllo ilccds nothing
hlit tho patriotic spirit and the gene-
rous heart to give and give as largely
as any other many ill this province
could give. iilld he gave A SHAME-
FUI. TItil~‘I.E, doubtless saying: “lt
will be raised by ille tax." I know
that same nlan. when his tax bill was
sent to him, swore the taxable income
not halt' oi’ what the popular estimate
is believed to be and in his defence,
I (Continued on Page l"ll`tecin) »
“ Y* =»-1
I _ - f _:A1
l-mils. say. 5.50.00 und loses il lv
i2l tu iiivcilt lil illo _
say $75.00
'l"llo answer is iliul wiili il S
Mc thc'_llgurc_s: _
`l"lrst coal.
dlsary ‘separatorai 1 _ _
_howi,__otc-._etc._ _ _
times we have had strong partisan
llpogcilap; momentum we have Ilml
' separator? _
l _ l~r<_-ailll to every 1.000 pounds ni llilik skiuililcd, or
_~~illo llcilurlitci' llnlt gets :lil hui om. icuii, nf n |,Unn,| ,,[ C,-L-_,m
ilolo pound of
per 1,000
iiliidurii you snvo lil uno year.
$7.’».00 _ ;55_pn
71|. 4-.. 7|1.c. --»- fp..-
3.75
5 li. c.) 5.50 (10 p. c.)
30.00 $70.00
$12 00 ` $Iiil.25 $70.00
_=°
:-1-15;
of-".
¢__..
-.- -» . lc , -~ _ _ l intoil, sch lla ha ' s l ~ ` "‘,_ ‘ _ ‘
talilsr  |]z,Icv¢mMl!iNiJ‘iiii.d,|i nxiidilloildhii;-lziillioit £:g’tIler-iiferrililddi, In i.)Ii,e pagt _\'ga|l-wv.yl¢‘l  il(iili'cwlilatd _- _ ggvllai gc; :,);‘_i";2:_yBl':f_'_)_"::_‘_"'°"“ _ $27-25
credit for it, lrl-cflpectlvc __of_how it and rigid lllspocllon of tI_l__o_ comme; Smother llolir‘s speech upon the sub-  _ __ _ _ __ _ _ _ "5 m“u‘°" 53-0° _
stood irc-in a pollt cal stan pont. Bull schools of this country. - mt wou ec. _ ' 'rho Stan ai‘ri's cone ski' mill I il ‘ .
they hail to view the matter not from roach lint 27 por.-ple but the whole of ` ` m g B “bstanuamd by lest" "ml" "L W’
Mr. i'lalton's standpoint alone, but the people of this province And then
from the lltliudpolnl. oil this provluqc _,there is another luicsilon l will link
slid how It iifioctcd lilo reveilucn oi lily lion. iriond fi-oln (Yllnliottetown to
this province. - nllslvcr and it In Illia: Suppl;-so you
Ii Mr. Dalton had ostahlislitd tim had this $20,000 :it_voiil~ i'olltrol.wouId
Ilistituiloil ailll had .nialntaluod it and-`it, not bc wills In rokpmid li portion. o_
lilo olllcrt was for tlln purpose oi Inrgv llortloll ci that nlollcy. ii you
il'crii_lillz cuiwk ol illl-lplcllt ilillei'<'.lilo llkr-._ Ill ilu- l~lllplo_\'ll\nlli_ ol' district
aliralile up ifllelfliliilllln =nurllos. -giving thcnl li l'l>i'tilili sec-
ailll adlniratlolll. But. lion of the country to trcnt. giving
tho interests oi Ihc_ tllolll powers to enforce their direc-
vor ont Dairy schools. 'rho st ll d . `
llnvdg 'crenil'i`,'but b‘y_il_s‘ longet_serv‘i;1oai:xapl1ifii,;/1.  if,:"yvi,t;e,;i{| my :Tye bt’
15' ff§l1l'6<| 11l50V9 T01' depreciation in the Standard llnd I0 per ivzcntl.) io? gr-
- . ’l'tle.Sinndorrl_glvelunlorelyoarv of service due to its selfolllll
_l - - _ - . ig llylltoin
.;~_ll_f_g_I1 g_<§'_§°ll#_9»;_.v_°=1_\ f;“_l1 t¢sr__<»l\l -Imm-Ins ron in fi-...lil or om, niinilio
. ll, _ 00 ww H sv ~_ll»wlli_o_fordlnary cold _rolled stool contra mllsiicoll
Tile-Stands:-d heirbonn i.estci|`~ror I5 years rnrlll ll-in wulnnn n
_ _ . - - _ _. ppitrant
“'°m"_ Wm i§`"°i my W" ‘§““‘|501¥1°|y to have the up-to-date; close -skim
- -mfillilalldurd -Det us send-you ii Standard so that you ma test it In your
own dall~y.__ _-Ciita_iogus_ri-i_l_o on l-sqn,,,¢_ _ - \ Y
1  
I .I . _ ,
.semi mm°§§¢§"s"‘ ”"N»'-°‘- ..__. ` `
0# _ mevqrsiiiiuioossus..
_ - _ _ |» ._l,
» -- _. -_ ,M .
%° Pound ' .Gund -'
 
__ _ _;oi”qrearn'n~, . - _
_ s l yl.>lll°scll’ this question, “\\*liI\'h will pay mo _  Pound .
,,.  __ _ ._ ____ _ __ _ _ I S filT\
I ilti (ll I bu: nn nrdlrllry _ .p.il.liol that  ___(}_OO p_iu___dS
I ~ ‘ -io _ml
‘ S mmcd '~sl$il_nmeci~
I T ' 1
wllll twvni-y_ pews. llc lc-sa tulill $21.25. iioro
_,_
v`
`°' \
l
ir  1
. /I77/"_/‘Q9 y
\
.
\
Vi.
"ter/loo'
poundsoi iullk skliililicd. and costs