a cen t; cisiolh 1i I . .1” ‘ *3». >5... l 1Q Idw .1. still/sinuses " ‘ Sports Writer) l’. By Guardian's ivpccial Wire) , YORK. Jan. 2B--Ali sorts réliédies. ranging from pun to ' . were sugectgd today for rst headache boxing has - -- ‘- here in years-monument- ‘bad officiating. , As a result of the bculng com- - - ’s rreversal at the Madison. of a decision originally _ - -» to Babe Risko over Vince * - ee, all hands have been sum- i- “to a clinic in the commis- srrjugo, when, as head of the omfnission. he passed a "no foul" s to end ‘an epidemic of low "Iilsjmorp rabid today were for i118 a "no commission" , v tomfitlcally voiding General shun Phelim, chairman, Bill. Prom. and n. Walker Wear, while BOWLING HOCKEY WRESTLING In Boxing .2? Lead To other if? Drastic Ruling l-l- H ll IN E ll ll NT IN A 3 U ll lllN ll ST Leafs’ Brilliant Marksman H eld During Past Week. (C. P. By Guardian's Special Wire) MONTREAL, Jan. 2B. - For the first time since the National Hockey League season opened, both of To- ronto Maple Leafs’ ace marksmen, Harvey Jackson and Charlie Con- acher, wcnt scoreless dur- . . more thoughtful s esled a m‘ m’ ‘Mk . complete overhauling u?! New ‘mud 1m _ Berks staff of judges and referees, fight’ t“ 1w a: ‘f allowing fighters to agree on their momma‘ i“ _ , own officials. setting" up of a small crages _ ; .but efficient group that would JaQkgonrs Worlcnii fights, or the bringing in broken “b, referees of known abii- g empox-ar. Col.'“.l'ohn R. Kilpatrick, pres- lllrigwririifi idenirof the Garden formally rs- his big right quested the commission to name wing team- ack Dempsey as referee for next ‘ mate and by’; ls-round match between _ -_ C onache r ~41’? Minneapolis heavy- ‘Bum-ii l0 Bdd - New ‘c. CONACHER 313.3”; ‘i221. " "Qgjfthg d5 a; _ w" 508N517. however. that the two l Nubile gIrISuEiOSlZ iii Cglkllleldglelli; glyfigrstztm ‘Enjoyed 5 wide margin tho- ent staff I hav ed’ ° p ° the ma“? “Sui cm‘ 1"“ » B ask acher with 1a .1, 17 » he commission to name Dempsey, 5° ' ml-M- 36 whoscabiliiy is unquestioned, and in whom everyone has complete Onfidonce," he said. However, the faithful recalled - that Dempsey himself in two up. it ances in the! Garden has _ ambled Just twice. y We Hooper’: Tonsorials hoc- hey team challenge Holmens City clipping of Detroit Red Wings into , L1H? Aurie still hol 5 gquivalen Poinhycnd Jackson with l9- m the United States Sec n40’ tion the ll fourth-place tie With New York 3611801‘! is reflected in the loss of dominance of the list by 118mm Players. True Cooney Welland and d first place, tied with 26 points, but Frank Bou- cher of Rangers and Marty Barry, Bosionhhsve taken thifxi and fourth. Bed Homer has now served the ime in .§.§’..2.’.‘l‘.‘ bmdib ,8 73 minute‘- Y X- score (B! The Canadian‘ Press) b! ue team to an exhibition game _ Jtsitable to both teams. Please ac- ' ‘iiept through this paper. ‘ liblflowing is the lineup: Goal. H. Molhnis; Defence, Donaldson, Macklin, Purcell," Fvzrwards, Acorn, yfimdiey, Cudmore, Sentner, Rob- mscn,» Saunders. ' ‘ 13m Mcnougell coach and man- "Fyc smoked .i. ll’ ‘POI’ u i years . . if’ . and l'm silcldng to ‘ . MASTER MASON . . . 1f . "smooth smoking, cool, .7 satisfying tobacco u over fiijccd c pipe: long luilng foo, will! [flue Il¢ll lull (ism ol ripe rr-"ilsw" i -.'.,. . the way I Pith. tobacco should be. You'll hockey at the Arena at a date Ii" 0f Ifliiw. who was born at 011%., 29 ant playing, heavy checks and fast skating noticed and had to be sounded a second time before the play ended. showed great catdiing a rebound the clover "Tid", exceptional stops and only once al- , lowed the rubber to pass him. The . Abbiss displayed a good brand of L.“ b“; ,y and good sportsmanship, “w $1M}, ,, andtbough defeated this time by . . . an is mm w! m intermediate ~ we be- lieve they will go far in their own " clan. The Primrose forward lines arc lbowing a decided im To Joe Primcau. playmaking Toronto Maple in the Notional Hockey seam tod Lindsay’ 9-80 ay. Bin iolninfthe Leafs in 1929, Joe hcaes made a name for hixrwclf as one o: the cleanest and most gentlcmanly players in the N. H. L., and at, the end of the 1931-32 season he wag awarded the Lady Byng Tfophy go,- his clean and effective play. HUBKEY On Friday evening the Montague hockey fans forgot their sores and worries and were carried into’ the realms of thrilldom when they wit- nessed one of the fastest and most exciting games ever staged in the Montague Rink between Lou Oamp- bell's "Red Shirts,” Maritime-Que- bec junior champions and Bill Ger- "cklfl " ." Island intermed- iate champions. The some ended in a final score of 4-1 in favor of the Primroses. From the face-off to tbs ma: gong, with the exception of a. short lull in the second period, both teams were on edge and exhibited some brilli- Bo keen were they up to the last that the gong passed un- ' In the opening period, the Abbies skill in combining although their attempts RouLwcr always frustra- d by the heavy c ecklng of the defence. Realizing the uselessne-s of trying to penetrate that stronghold. the rubber was usually shot from the blue line and rushes followed in the hope of and vuv ng who made some their play, to plant s. e provement Scoreless, However, NEW llPElllNll IBE RABES Four Classes T h a t Should Provide Stiff Competition Arc On Card. The first ice races of the Victoria Driving club will be hold tomorrow. Wednesday afternoon, starting at 3 o'clock sharp. There will be four classes as follows: Glass A Pace '-- Vcio Rico, 2.04; ‘Winnie Winkle, 2.12%; Hush, 2.10; Because, 2.12. Class B Pace - Rosebud, Baibo. Miss Al Worthy. Three Year Old Trot and Pace- Worthy Mac, Bonnie Britten, Leta Kalmuck, Cricket Be Sum. Colt Race-Worthy Guy, Almcr Worthy, 'l‘a.xi Jim, l-iolscy, British Bel e. Starter-Doug Mcleod. Judges -- Dr. H. McIntyre, Neil Walker, W. B. Brown. Announcer-J. A. MacDonald. Timers-Russell Abbott, Charles Snow. The track has been measured and will be cleared on‘ on Wednesday and will be in first class shape for the races. umvnuiu sm“rtimt (0.7. By Guardian’! 5960b! Wk!) MONCTON. Jan. 28 - Ill luck stalked the Saint John Beavers here tonight and the Moncton Hawks continued undefeated in the New Brunswick Big Three Mercan- ‘tile League. A first period goal which Ray Getllffe, starry centre for the Beavers slapped into his own goal in an attempt to clear was just sufficient to give the Hawks a 3-2 victory. It was a close and thrilling game all the way with but few dull mo- ments. and ended up in a. real he- man fight between Len Bmragc, husky Hawk defenceman and Bay Getliffe. fearless centre for the Beavers. The two had been carry- ing chips on their shoulders throughout the evening and nticks around each others cars. About two minutes before the final gong they tangled in earnest but Referee Bail- or Herbert, tossed his 200 pounds between the bellingercnfs, separated them and waved them to the boote- gow. 0n the way to the penalty box they tangled again. This time they lsid aside their sticks, threw down their gloves and exchanged blows in real earnest, finally going to the “toot Ross Successfully Defends Junior .Wgelterweiglit I Title WEDNESDAY unvms DEFEAT l; Iaal Michelson, » Associated run Sports Writer (By Gcarvhn’! Special Wis!) MIME, F15, Jan. 33. -— r. . From the second round. when tbs champion floored the challenger for s col-int of eilht with a bard rigbi to the jaw, the result was in little doubt. Ross was the unanimous choice of the two judges. On the Aslociawd lkmess score sheet, the champion won eight rounds. lost one and held the challenger oven in tbs other. A crowd cf 13,000 paid an estima- ted total of 186,000 to watch the battle. Klick was willing enough and gave the crowd its money's worth in lively exchanges with the Junior welterweight and lightweight king, but each time he gained an advantage, Barney slowed him up with a series o. lefts and rights that took the sting out of his punches. ‘l-‘he only round Klick won was Ineligible, Is Gilroy’s R a l i n g (c. r. By Guardian's special WIN) PORTAGE LA mums. Men-- m. za-Three hockey players M- merly with Maritime teams were officially Prohibited wday from playing with or against Ontario Hockey Association players or ill any branch affiliated with ti"! Canadian Amateur Hockey AS5001‘ ation. Art Whittaker. Hswse Mil-rm w‘! "Bred" Farrell, have been declared by I‘. A. Gilroy, President of the O.A.H.A.. ineligible for petition with Ontario's amateur hockey. players for infractions of the res- idence rule. ,Whlttkaer had been with Halifax Wolverines and Marsh and Farrell with Saint John Beavers, but; on breaking up of that league all three moved to Toronto and Marsh and Farrell signed with British Consols and Whittaker with MoOoll r. ntenac of the Toronto and York Mercan- tile League. Their registrations only permitted them to play in Us Maritimes. ENlLTEAM BEATEN (C. P- Cable B! Guardian's Special Wire ) PORT OF SPAN. Jan. 25- Ficiding brilliantly after lunch to- day, the West Indies cricket team ice in. a wrestling grip. They were still in the penalty box when the gong sounded. Marshall was credited with the first goal of the game which Clet- liffe accidnntly slapped into the 8t. John goal. and about midway through the second Mcdinski put the Hawks 2 goals up when he banged Burrages pass from behind the net past skeet Kuhn. Less than a minute later Getliffe, Ar- cher and Sherwood ganged the Moncioh cage and Getliffe took Ar- cher's pass for a neat goal. After seven minutes of play in the third session Monty Muckln raced in fast to scoop up Knucker Irvine's pass and give the Hawks a 3-1 lead but Crcssley Sherwood put the Beavers quickly back in the game with s. clever individual cf- ivrl- Picking up a loose puck in centre ice he tricked the Moncton defence, stepped lightly between them and blasted the rubber past Jimmy Foster from a few feet out. c Jimmy Kelly turned in a spark- ling game for the Beavers tonight, although Skeet Kuhn was o. out- standing star. In the opposite end of the fink Jimmy Foster turned in one of his best performances. DOWN THE ALLEYS cmrowu mm I169 Victoria; l". Joseph high single 804. W. MacDonald hi!!! time B81. scored a thrilling victory in their second test mulch biflihst the touring Marylebonc Cricket Club ending herc- today. West Indies won by 21a runs. _ The Colonials outscored the vis- iting Englishmen right through the four-day match; piling up a first-innings score of 302 against the 258 compiled by MQCaWcst Indies declared their second in- nings at lunchtime today with 2B0 for six. while in the remainder of play, MOD. coubi only get 107 runs of the s25 they JTQUIIOG be- fore l0 wickets were taken. Fighting to outlast the sensa- tional fielding and bowling of the West Indies and thus create a draw, the tourists played too cautiously and most of their wick- ets fcll cheaply. "MIKEY RESlllTS (O. P. by Guardian's Special Wins) ‘IRURD. N. - 5., Jan, Bil-st. Francis Xavier University lost an A. P. O Hockey league game here g to Truro Bearcais 2-1. Harold Patterson, flashy right winger for the local team, mashed a hard shot past J. M. MacDonald in the University team's coals with but 20 seconds of ploy remaining. to prevent the gum going info ‘A "lilm" like It. in tactics this season as well as a great improvement in speed and ac- curacy. They played a splendid: gains and kept it clean throughout. The lineups: l Hibernian-Goal, ‘Tid" McEwcn; defence, W. Watierworth and P. Mc- Oarrnn: forwards, A. MacDonald, K. Boer. Ir. Poole, N. Grunt, s. Vick- srs W. Landry, V. Grunt. inu- Abbie: -- oral. u. Price; defence, l. llackiin. L. llathicson, J. Omuinr f , onwards, I. narmh, K llc J. madam,‘ it. nu- . ' smash‘ I l llfl (£0016) 11.10 ' _ Ilhlrt s. succ- FORUM 'BIG' mo. . SKATE ‘ m. ‘rrouicur aucoan none 8 to l0 P. Mw aura Attraction .- autumnal .. ‘- "";:_. OYGHMDO P181. I-I Win I'll! (iauuinl Williams in a Valley Hockey league fixture ban tonight. Bill Bmitb was outstanding for the winners, scoring time goals and ulistiw "in woman. Challenge f» Hockey Practice c the sixth when he nailed Barney with a series of rlBhts and lcfts that had the crowd in an‘ . But beyond that round and Ross‘ attack in the second, it was tbs old of a hard battling but out- classed cballengcr vainly attempting to best a better man, who beat him in timing and ring tactics. ~' Ross weighed 138 and Klick 137, Buddy Bear. the heavyweight chunplonk young brother, scored a one-round knockout over Tommy Davenport, 199% pcimdor from Lit- tle Bork, Ank. Buddy, weigluig 236 pounds, knocked Davenport down four times with a series of wild swings before be stayed oh the floor. Max Baor and Jim Malcney, for- mar heavyweight contender but now a Miami traffic cop, clowned through four rounds as King Le- vinsky, a knockout victim of the champion in another match that had been labelled an exhibition, looked sadly an. Maloney, rcmcmr bering what happened to Lcvlnsky, merely held on, confining his “at- tack" to ~_an occasional nudge of Max's ribs. muummus PRUDEBUT lfliiifli Former Hawk Ace To Pivot Smith A n d Northcott. (C. P. By Guardian's Special Wire) MONTREAL, Jan. 28—Montreel Maroons of the National Hockey League have signed Alex Wood. former goalkeeper for Cleveland Indians in the International League and with Philadelphia Ar- rows of the Canadian-American League, as a spore goalie, it was announced tonight by ths Marconi-z management. _ Bill Miller. star centre of the lfoncton Hawks, Canadian ama- teur champions for the past two Y9K“. will make his Drofcbional debut with Maroons tomorrow d; centre man on the Msroons "blue" line with Hooley Bmiizh at right "i123 II Blldy Northcott at left w g. Tickets on Pro Tennis League Is » Organized. (A. P. by Guardian’: Special Wife) INDIANAPOLIS, Jau- 28-01- ganization of a profemionsl tennis league with teams in eight OM68 of the United States was an- niyunged by William O'Brien to- day. The League will not begin func- tioning untii June. 1935. 03149" said, Cities in the league and hold- srs of the franchise, he added. arc Philadelphia, Bill ‘Iiidcn: Boston. Ellsworth Vines; New York, Bill O'Brien; Buffalo, Charles Murray: Chicago, George Lott; Cleveland, Tom McKee: 5t. Kori Hodge, Detroit, Dave Cole. The league will be divided into two groups, east and west. and the winners of each will meet in s. tennis world series. llllllllNli An exceptionally large and en- thusiastic audience gathered at the Montague Rink on Wednesday even- ing to watch the cream of Prince Edward Islands curlers in action. To accommodate the players, James A. McIntyre prepared two curling rinks on the skating space. and pebbled it to that degree of perfec- tion of which he is capable, The P. WC. Hockey The P. W. C. Commercials trimmed the Fourth Yosrslnafast ‘and rugged Game at the Arena on Monday afternoon. The Commer- cialshedohceqe on the play from the first and Whelan star Winiiirr slammed the wafer past Boothroyd three Limes in the first . . .. m p , of e cials also beat the Fourth Year Iiialie in the second stcnnmon a Poss from Nicholson from behind tho not. The stars for the Fourth Year were Bennett and Gaudct, and Ling 0n defence was the bed man or! the game as usual, ad he handei-Lout many stiff checks, The final score was Opmmqqiglg 5. Fburth Year 2. The lineup was as follows: - Fourth ‘Your: Goal, D. Booth. MN; defence, R. Mathieson, T. Ling,- forwards, I. Stirling, R, m- QIIBITR. G- Gaudet, G. Bennett, O. Reilly, Conmwrclals: Goal. defense, K, Blrtwistle, A, Gfludflf, B. Foster: Forwards, A. Ollfklll, R. Mvlienlie. A. Yco. O. Johnson. W. Wlhelsn. R. Nicholson Referee-J. Kenalow. llllllllll HDNURS J. l-iornby: i play for the MacArthur Cup took place first, and three of the Cap- tal's crack teams met three of Montana's suns shooic in deadly combat. ‘This proved most exciting since current rumor had it that it was the intention of the-city team to take back with them that most coveted prize, the MacArthur Cup, ‘that they might use it to beautify the interior of their club room, not taking into consideration the fact that the Montague curlers might feel that the cup would be eon- ‘ usby its ‘r ,and there- fore decide to keep it-which they did. Montague retained the cup by two points, and did some very fine curling with the exception of Mac- Gregorb team, the "Big Pkrur", which suffered a severe defeat at the hands of the keen, calculating McLaine quarigctte. As the old say- ibngflgkocs, "Too many cooks W011 the r0 .' After this play, the Bohspeil took place, which was very interesting, both from the game and the humor- ous standpoints. After the Bon- apeil, all the members ‘ to the clubroom, where a bounteous tabla awaited them. During the supper, speeches were given. Mr. W. W. Ircrd, on behalf of the 5t. Lawrence Flour Mills, donated eight bags o1 flour to the Montague Olub for competition. This generosity was ‘Q, u- rcciated by tbs Moln- taguc curlers. Some excellent vocal- ists wcrc among the visitors, who favored the occasion with some very fine numbers. All in all, it was a rare night and Montague looks for- ward to the return of such good 0APTUREm BYLUGAN (0.7. B! Guardiani Speck! Wire) SAINT JGHIN, N. 15.. Jan. M — Willie Ifllan. Saint John, Oana- dian indoor spcedskating champ- ion. captured major honors st the lllritimc indeer apmdskating meet . Elizabeth Flemming, Nova Ecotia champion, led in the ladies’ events. ' - . 1.08m plucd first with little dif- ficulty in three events and was dil- qualified in the half mile. He came ceomd to '1'. White, Saint John. in the two-mile recs. m accumu- lated 110 points, clnu tho We yard sprint in H seconds, the 440 inua-sucondsbudtbsmusm 8.10 4-8. I. third ind? sports, who know how to iolc like Reserved Seat gentlemen. The lineups: MacArthur Cup Play ontaguc (marl G. A. McIntyre H. McIntyre McKay O. M. Williams W. A. MoLaggan J. A. Fraser H. L‘. lifcGrcior F. 8.. Mclainc B p-A kip-ii G. W. McDonald 0. D. McGngor W. B. Garrick A B. M. Mcloan O. H. Black 0.8% Wigwhtman 8. O. Moore p-—1 9-6 M. Reynolds W. Davies L H. Poole B. Winchester R. W. Beck H. Bpillctt J. A. Mclléityfc W. ‘Igzwnscna mum-qr TotaL-bl It 'J. O. Watson J. Hewett. A. A. Masher Bywcrihy Dr. l’. McIntyre l‘. Oordwcil . J. Magoo . W. » Yountor O. D. L. H. Ooiflu ll. 5'31". mm 3' ‘ii Black . A. J0 . fldp-o Skip-o J. Annui- . Henderson J. H. blcGrcgor B. Dadicl Ocl. Woatbcrb H. Iomtyn R. . McDonald . J. hilt’ - ' B00!!! ~ In a league game in last Milli! Binkwlt. Avarda nova: ‘M!!! 1.3”“. W"! i IFIJ scam-i some _ ti» first wig.‘ “" "" ‘flit. "d? i loot g pier. ' i noxuvo assume/lit. _ oiiuuu seam‘ WEDNESDA Y NIGHT AT 8.30 Big Maritime Play Off Game .4 B B IE s WOL 112R INES s 40d, 60c., 75c; Gallery, 30c. Morning, 10 A, M., Forum Box Office Sale This BE6WElli iumuvrnn SEtllNll GAME Determined w got back on even footing with the Wolves. Abcgwcits held a fast workout yesterday af- ternoon at the Forum. No casual- ties are reported from the game in Halifax and the boys are all anxious to est into the fray. The playing of the "rookies" improves daily and now that the first game is history, nervousness which was apparent is doing c fadcout. Much interest is being token in the coming game and the great showing of the team in Halifax has made the furs realize that the lo- cal entry is still very much in the picture. . Wolverines will likely arrive tonight and they loo will be lust as determined to get a NIIEFENBEMAN strangle hold on the title with a winasthslocslsaretoclip the claws of the howling Wolf pack. The largen. crowd of the season is expected to sit in on the gflme and from all sppearan it is going to b0 another 0f Q1058 bltflfid Lhlli keep the customers talking days afterwards. Mounties Defeat St. John’s Team for (OI. Cable By Guardian's Spock! Wire) s1‘. JOHN'S, Nfld. Jim- 28 — Mount Allison Universityh hockey team defeated St. John's 10-4 to- night in the first game of a series against Newfoundland linc-uilc- TM visitors arrived on t\e liner Novi Bcotia. Bllilllllll TlillllNAMENT Th, big prize tournament at the Sunnysido Billiard Parlor got un- derway last Thursday when W- Lawlor won from B. Ryan by I margin of M points. H. Redmond won from A. Peterson on rridsy by 2B points in a close and excit- ing match. Two matches were played last evening. In the first l". ltanaban defeated W. Plneau by 73 points, Rlnshan showing remark- able form and finishing his mulch in a little over an hour for 800 points. In the. second match Ii. Stanley won from A Doyle in an excep- tionally good match by 80 points. Stanley showed marked improve- ment in his game. while Doyle ap- peared a bit unsteady at times. ‘this is an elimination tourna- ment and when a player is defeat- ed he is out. ' To date i0 players have entered. andanycneclsawishing todoso please leave their nausea with dis management not later than Friday. Ojimcsrflundcvtoiadit. mum's-neonate withblmmmthaumcaJ-ledcluftrnilnflast an uubidylppalonclll bchgnnnwltha mltdmboradcsqdcm No l ration. Try FGEIIQ-iic- - Allan l/Vins BIn Third (0. P. By Guardian's Special Wire) NEW GLASGOW, N. 5.. Jan. 2! -Bobby Allan of Wcstville tonight began his come-back for the Marl- tima professional Welter-weigh! title he lost to Bobby Orr of Jog- gins. The Westville battlcr scored a third-round knockout over Earl Kinsman of Berwick in their scheduled ill-round fight. Kinsman -W8l$“ .1 I47 pounds and Allan 147 1-2. IS AFTER NEW YORK, Jan. I5-Alcx Smith, lanky defenceman, formed a gangling question-mark over tho New York hockey marts tonight. Earlier in the day it was art- nounood Binitb, along with wing» men Deed Klein and Eddie Burke, were to be released by New York Americans. The Americans have not won a game since New Year's night and Manager Joe Simpson threatened a number of times that f beads would fall. Word got around than that New York Rangers were looking for a dsfcnceman to take the place of the injured Ohing Johnson. Eye! tinted in the direction of Alex Bmitb and Ranger-manager Lester Patrick was reported, in the grape- , vino, to be negoiia“ with the Americans for his contract. Smith's disposal looked like the last piece falling right into a cross-word puzzle, but- ' Tonight Patrick still was tryins to land the big rearguard, while the word from the American head- quarters was that the A's didn't want to dispose of him after alL Manager Simpson announced “Bod” Duran. defender for Quo- bec’; Canadian-American team. had been recalled and would be in an American uniform at Boston Tuesday night. BASKETBAH following are the team standing! " in the men's and ladies’ leagues of the Y. M. C. A.: Man's League G. W.L. F- A. _ Grads 4 4 0195 81' Senior Y 4 2 ii 115 14f P.W.c.. 40491171 G.W.L. I. A." P. W10. . . . . a ii o if i4 Abbie Sisters .... 8 2 1107 33 Bluedots 3 1 2 50 50 Nyodas .. 8 0 s 2312i’ HOCKEY 8t. Avsrds Manic: Beavers played York Junior team on Saturday af- ternoon in York rink. One goal wls scored on each sidi I'll. NEVER co our WITH HIM AGAiNI can offensive mcuwboioohbsif-ciaavuu. Adailycbmlovkaiiuwirmiog and balding ciuavlfll EI.'."‘*£§."».‘.".."£3"'..'?£°.&"'$.»..' 'r..s"'l.'r"rl ‘cram-s. new’ Blue Blades " ‘:4 Now.s ~2s¢.- 1os ~'s9( . l d h 0d. The Belvfll uring t e 1st peri played up and slammed in goals in the third. will!!! I 9°“ of 4 to i in the Beavers’ favor. tbctuuncndidibo the isccmfcrtabii .4 -4