13f. w ryfr. in»? THE CHARLOTTETOWN GUARDiAhl " T-‘iie ~ Rich, Thick_ “Economy? of H is lltovéh by menu that each . P011114 Produces 240 cups of Liquoriag Tea. ‘ 4v. corner. QIOOI and Bjiclueeua err-main O0 1 Victoria‘ i Hotel . One of the largest and best equipped llotqln, in Eastern Canada. Cont-pins 120 rooms. 44 oi. which; have private bathe- Oqhriitlei-alr renovated in the past two years. Hotels. and-the Uni _ States have its splendid Courteous service to all Guests. phones in rooms. Hates $1.00 to $5.50 per day. Tele- - Hatchet», Ltd. Proprietors , nanny c. aaowfl, Manager. ' I $ Charlottetown j l i OOQ" ‘#000444 Queen- , 7 ' a »Hotgel' Since taking over this Hotel we have spent ma!!! ' thousands of dollars in O repairs and improvements. It is now the finest. Hotel oi its gm in the Maritime Prov- inces. It appeals to those who want a comfortable Hotel and splendid table and exeellmt service at a moder- ate prim. ‘ Bates “from $3.00 to 54-50 nerds:- Charlottetown ‘ Hotel ca, Ltd. : Proprietors I uuss a. McQUAIDrMIMR" O According to recent tests made Bl’- hospital in London exercise after . eals is not harmful. ‘ Woo-o 0|- V O v O Few throughout Canada ~ a , WIESTERN GUARDIAN Q . Brasserie a Come and enjoy a good skate. i 3018 -SKATING at Bedeque Rink to- night. - 3018 Y. BOWLING CIT! LEAGUE \ 7.00 to 8.30-Railway vs. Y. M. C. phone “Co. 9 Q A. X aso to 10—Oddiellows vs. Tele- V 9 a Last Night's Service Held _ i At St. Paul ’s The United Week oi Prayer Service was held last evening in St. Poul‘!- Despite the fact of the large mea- sure oi sickness and the low tom- perature, there was a goodly 61111- gregation. Rev. Mr. Raymonit, the Rector conducted the service assist- ed by Rev. Hammond Johnson and Adjt. Martin. | Psalm 103 was read responsively. The Old ‘Ibstament lesson was read from 2 Chronicles 66:12—Soio- man's Prayer. . » The New. Testament lesson was taken from Eph. 4:146. The Body of Christ. Rev. Mr. Raymond led in ‘the general prayer of Thanksgiving. etc. ' The message oi the evening was delivered by Rev. Bruce Muir on “The Church." l Mr, Muir dwelt particularly upon the Unity oi the Church in the midst oi apparent diversity. l This unity was shown in three particular ways: ' 1. A common recognition of the Divine nature of the Church. | z, A recognition oi the Divine na- ture oi man. 3. The recognition oi the need of Divine help for man's redemption. I Mr. Muir appealed strongly 501‘ the attendance or the reollleilh the means of grace given through tho Church by Christ. | Service will be I held this evening in Zion Presbyterian Church. Thlfi will be the annual meeting of the Charlottetown Branch o! the P. E. I. Bible Society. - , Rev. John Murchison, the Secre- tary of thisDistrict of the Bible So- ciety will be the special speaker. '.:A Remedy for Earache-To have the earache is to endure torture. The ear is a delicate organ and few care ‘w deal with it. oonsideriflE it W°1h 11°;- p, doctor. Dr. Thomas‘ Electric Q11 oflers a slmiilo Yemedy- A few dfgpg upon a piece oi medicated cot- wn and placed in the tar will d0 much in relievinz D111"- .. § Classified Advertisements 0m insertion ............... ‘ Four lnantlonl i Billflinwrflnna - 3 Female H6111 Wanted ANTEI)" ‘_. afar. roll 611N113"- housework. Small ialnily- 11° Q11“; 5L ‘ X 2089-1-5- l harem-dint. FOR GENERAL housework‘. 0116 W119 ca“ d° PM? cooking. ApDIY to Bu!“ Bffmj; rcsIdenccJH W93" 5i" 2m ' ' ' Articles For Sale oa sane-so u. r. non-an AND ‘ engine, rotary saw. B1141 m chine. Apply Bvurtwhzose ° - Bonshaw. -1-5~5i\ l roa sans-cull 513' ‘mus power International gas 01‘ 11111:; sens engine with clutch pulley. iwodas new. Mac McFaIlYw- chm: Covc. _ 30024434’ Nursing rasmmo school. eon W311i? Stephen uenrv GIWQR°°P ‘*- Haverbill, Fmdhidiu“ Hospital and peel-eat 803%- ‘Ihree year course. Aiilliol-W" d Providence City H“? 1 "l! Mass. Eye and Ear n aly- Eight hour say. alwwwe till-W monthly. Classes admittod Nil-- ruary and September. one hon; --irom Boston. Two veers 0i H"! School requires. lgismalug; fgfttliltiiin apply , ' , 1M_-1_s_“_ _ ..._....._;_;_._u,.-_--l . A tra ‘mael- thaw beulltmd ' ' ~ t socket in an clot Jilhm,“ incandescent lamps um! by 811mm‘ has been invented to 011111" and dentists. ’“ Iloclu-y niapefi all llllfilfll lllnimeutt- __'T~;_. ._' .IM.MI¢J 'I'*."' I ‘. ‘I > H m“ ‘mm ~ n u. .1! "Nil-JV" :f,°$mm“m"fy %’j,n‘l‘ah my.» s mania-mama and M. iiiiltlifisltlvle ..: ‘ma! \ . .,»..~ ,.....A\.- . - s Vi ' ‘ ‘ ""'" h‘ m. our sew- trustees. o-l-v-ai we per line of l word! ' pe yo! lino of s worfll p. p» un- nl ll 1"" ‘lo pIr line el I Iallll oenceelnelu For Sale 1- a sate: 'rw0 FARMS "$335 a: but?‘ 6°‘ App y 2095-1-8-1 wk. F03‘ SALE ‘mun: a‘: Jud- Fqx. pups’ 0:5, dgiifigp-R ‘R ‘No. 1. son. Alexan . é°85_l_8_3f ‘ Wanted I | ' TWO nunnaao with l “h7g3. Mink feed. Quote P1"- es gnu State quantity can surviv- i iownil E. A. Ferguson. Char 47am a-ENGLISH 5211119111"- WQXFQMA in five months old- Angus McKinnon. Albl°lg6ogllgalli Teachers Wanted; rascal-IR W ‘Hill school Countyb Dugiglmig l ' 1920. u P m Aromwgmn m ‘ ' Miscellaneous ALFRED Surveyor, 1N0. Land‘ P. E. I. ‘slimmed nos Bxralifii 1y supplied. Quin-can Job ery. cards at shortest; notice. ian Job Prinlery- . LifltimQWmU-“P wet-mm. v i» -nl-:nsoua Rink opens tonight.‘ no -roa roar istrlct No. 4. P1111” begin ran. m. l MACDONAIQD, Hennan 1 iillt-ll-l-lmo. , 19.1.1: u. Mauoalsu mm uovzuufdq ‘coaaesmivbatlomfltlhl 15"" ‘G . J g - was W .. v , , , Central Guardian POLICE COURT-At the pence court yesterday morning a prohibi- tion ollo was adjourned and a vag- rant given three months in jail. T1111 Fiiiimaelar Edwin .1. Byers takes place this morning from his hue residence. Grafton st. at 2.44 m Saint Dunatarfs Cathedral. thence to R. C. Cemetery. ' THE FUNERAL of the late Mrs. Gertrude. Foley will be held this mor- ning at 9.30 from the residence of her brother, Charles McDonald, 58 Weymouth Street to St. Dunstanls Cathedral, thence to R. C. Ceme- tery. CORNWALL SERVICES — There will be service of worship. Sunday. Jan. 13th in the United Church at Kingston at 11 a. m.; Cornwall at 3 p. m. and West River at 7 p. m. Please note change of hour oi Corn- wall and West River services. At the evening service a special offer- ing will be taken for the mission- ary and maintenance fund. Rev. E. M. Aitken. B. A, minister. ' PERSONALS ‘ Mr. and Mrs. Wllbert| McCarvill, Kinkcra. spent the Christmasand New Year holidays visiting rela- tives in Boston and New York. Miss Helen Purdie, Miss Margaret Joyce have returned to Mt. Allison Ladies College after spending the holidays with Mrs. J. E. Purdie. Miss Eileen Ryan of the Western Union Telegraph Office. who has been laid up with illness for the past three weeks. is steadily improving, and expects to resume work next week. The many friends of Mrs. Charles Boisner, Edward St., will regret .to learn of her serious illness. Mr. Re . Dillon loft yesterday morning o return io Saint Fran- cis Xavier University, after spending the Christmas vacation with his par- cnts. Mr. and Mrs. Frank L. Dillon. Mr. Gordon Roper has rcutrned to Sackville to resume his studies at Mt. Allison Academy, after spending the Christmas holidays with his par- ents, Mr. and Mrs. John B. Roper, Sherwood. Mr. Wilfrid McIsaac left yesterday morning on return to St. Francis Xavier University, after spending the Christmas vacation with his nar- ents, Mr. and Mrs. Joseph McIsaac. Mr. A. Milne Fraser 0i Halifax. well known in Charlottetown and past nresident m‘ the Maritime Com- mercial Travellers’ Association. leaves on January 13th on the stea- mer Laurentic for New York. From there Mr. Fraser will sail ior Italy and Monaco tn spend he winter. rc- tnrning to Canada vi Paris, Lon- don and Scotland. O Underwriters Continued from page 1 Confederation. Life- W. G. Hogg. L. A. Moore. A. F. Gill. , Crown Life-B. R. Holman, Dominion Life-W. E. Brooks. E. C. Johnston, V. S. Ling, Major J. A. MacKenzie, George W. McLeod, Miss B. L. Stewart, C. M. Williams, Empire Life-George Grant, R. H. MacNeili. Great West Liie-Alyre Arscnault. Peter Gallant, F. W. I-lyndman, Hob- ert Hyndman, T. A. Harris, C. E. ~ MacKenzie, H. M. Stewart. Imperial Life-T. N. Donahue. W. M. Fivnn, A. A. MacDonald, A. R. Maolnnis. Maritime Life-T. W. Bentley. H. I T. Campbell, John Simpson. Mutual Llie—C. H. Black. National Life-J. P. Maclnnis. North American Life-Cocil Camp- bell, H. Lapthorne. W. G. Spencer. L. S. Stevenson. Sun Liit—I-I. H. B. Prowsc, H. P. Smith. nmrns WORTFI—In this city. DEC- 27, 1925- to Mr. and Mrs. Charles F. Worth. a son; ‘ . DEATHS ‘Moore. A. S. COMPTON-On Dec. 30th at Belle River. John H. Compton 1n his 75th year. survived by his widow. six sons and two daughters. MARTIN-At Hunter River. Jany 8. 1928, Lloyd Dougald Martin, son of Mr. and Mrs. Peter J. Martin, aged 5 years and 7 months. Funeral Thursday at Z p. m. GB Y-In the City Hospital. Jan. a, rick ol-adv. used B1 vam- Fuh- eral from»A. A. Hennessey's'Fun- cral Home by eastern train. MACDONALD-In the Sacred Heart Home, Jan. ii, Abbie MacDonald. age 70 years: Funeral from A. A. Hen- nessay’: Funeral Home this orning at 10.15 to Balnt Dunstanb athe- dral thence to R. C. Cemetery. GAUDEI-Guddenly at the Char- lottetown Hospital. on Jan. 8th. Mrs. Catherine Qaudet, bged 6B years. Funeral from her late residence; 18 BichopStl-eet. on Thursday morning at 0.45 to it. Dunstan‘: Cathedral thence to tile Roman Catholic ceme- tery. ~ A IVQDMacLeon l annual-Ann manual! Plano m, l l | l l l \ This Winter Keep i 58km; and Vital- Take ‘ l scorrs l EMULSION Rich In All Cod-liver Oil Vitamins Scqttt Donne. Tomato. Ont. IIIBBMENIZ; DELIVERED m SUPREMECIIRI Appeal Dismissed in (lasc of Brown vs. Kcefc Tile following judglncnis were among “I'D-Si! delivered on Tuesday in the Supreme G0urt:_ - ‘ l l BROWN VS. KEEFE Dominion oi Canada ' Province of Prince Edward Island _ In the Supreme Court - Joseph Brown Appellant and Braden Keefe Respondent] Judgment oi Mathieson, C. J. January 8, 1929. This is an appeal from a convic- tion made cn the 8th day of June. 1928 by Wilfred Tanicn, esqulrv, 1i justice of the peace in and for the County of Prince, whereby he con- victed Joseph Brown, the Appellant. for that he, the said Joseph Brown, on the 27th day of May A. D. 1928 at Alberton in the county aforesaid did assault and beat the Respondent and he adjudged the said Joseph Broilvn to pay a. fine of ten dollars together with $5.00 costs, or in do- fault of payment- to imprisonment for thirty days. It appeals that at the time oi the alleged assault the Appellant was acting as police offlccr for the Town cf Albcrton and he claims that his interference with thr- Respondent was in the course cf ills duty as su¢h| oiflcer in enforcing the provisions oi "The Motor Vehicle Actl922" and amendments. j use ltcspcndczlt, Braden Keefe, ls a farmer 19 years of age" residing with m; father at Mill Rivsl‘. 41-1 miles from Alberton. On Sunday ove- ning the 27th of Maylast in a Ford lunabcut he ivzls coming into Alber- ton from the direction oi "The Wharf‘ an tho highway whicnjeuding into the Town, is there called Main Street and intersects Church Street. 1t was dark or almostclalk as he reach- cd the border of the Town when he noticed that onencf the lzczzcliitiighrlg oi.‘ his car was c m or ou was on the lookout fora garage- The lights were both burning, he says ivh-zn he left. the Wharf. ‘ A5 he approached the point 0i 111‘ teraecticn of Mam and Church Streets, Herbert, Brown who 0119111“ ed a nearby garage shouted to hllh that one oi his lights was out. HE then made a detour running 0m blcck along Church Street, then 1:- long Central Street a. short dEihn-i t: McKendrlcks Corner, turneihand came back the same way and alvbboallg pcd near the car injvlllch l-Lr ~11 Brown, the garage mflh- W15 5mg“; The reason he 911/05 5'31‘ W15 d9 W is that he was looking for the If}? convenient place to turn his car. fact that Policeman Brownh Will-I standing cn c :- corner oi C ugodl and Mum £-_;: o‘... hill-Y have s“ some weight. However that léiloybeljtl the Respondent HD1111“ l? Eider Brown to set an cur lights in O - While this 1k... o. ,_ Brown approached ihc car and (according to the - all‘ ci the latter) all hi"- hhh‘: “f” m,‘ door oi the cal‘. Cfluilhi- 11111 lime" shulldcr, 811W Pm‘ fw°bor dnv: t Shams and 5am Youvit E3111 one ing here long enough W gm hi’. t? “Bill/K t: which T-nc Resp 112i’. gone plied that his light had’ aka “m, m“ “mm “pine stleeflxin it but Herbert Brown Wit?» 110W 1g “hook in reslXm-‘W 5995mm“ as“ v '-' would talc: him l“ lib/iii“ ‘Ielxigmsiisqgnhfhe Town MAEBFTW’ and when Geoff-ii? Kmchinwhlltic 2:5. m“ Wm‘ Respond-cm with the sn- came around t; mason _______j__€__-_ k QOO-O-Q-QQ §§§+Q%O§OQ-O-Q§4§§ 4‘ Health Guards i and t Cold § Preventatives i OATHARROZONE VAPU E MELOIDS FORMAMINT 2 ASPIRIN VALPEX x i ans-reams Llsranma THROAT ran- ears. Laxative COLD ‘ran- , LETS. winra rma rsa THE rnolvlr-r nnvoolsrs . t ,.,, a ., i o». Paélifiiliku 33°.’ 411g done Policeman l_ , ‘Crystals Defeat i. Abegweits 2-1 i The Abegilveits oi Charlottetown were defeated by the Cyrstals, Sum- merside sextette here tonight by a close score oi 2-1 after a. more or less listless 60 minutes of puck chas- ing which at times had seven hund- red fans on their toes from‘ period to period, until the final bell. A counter Was realized in every session, the Crystals scoring the opening goal, the Abeflweits tying thelscore in the sec- ond stanza only to be tamed be 2k in the middle half of the last pcri d. Both teams appeared to be more o1’ less timid throughout the game with the Summerside clan showing the edge in offensive inside the blue line. The Abcgweits being content to test the opposing goalie at long range with the result that almost every shot was turned back with ease and prc- cision, The visiting aggregation had the majority ,ui direct shots on the net realizing 3B to 30 in the three periods. Tile first counter came in the first period after a. successive bombard- ment on the Crystal net. The local sextettc breaking away. Montgomery carrying to the mouth oi the cage missed a good shot. He, however. -passed back after ovcrskating Ralph Silliphant who in turn batted. the rubber past McEwen for the opening goal in three minutes. For the rc- maincler cf the session both ienlns battled like trojanr; with the, Abe- gweits having the big edge on ferri- tory during the dying moments of the period. In the second franle the visiting red and black squadron showed their heels of the Crystals for the first five minutes, but long shooting and lack of co ordinated attack spelt their ruin when glowing and what looked like sure chances to score failed mis- erably in the pinches. Had they gone through, the Summerslde goalie would have had a less easy night. On the other hand the Crystals had the punch when that ‘proverbial adjec- tive meant counters and no matter what McEwen in the nets tried to do he could not turn back deadly shots well timed and directly cn the net. This period although slow and list- less, something similar to‘ the open-- ' ing tilt, had its scintillating moments. The Abcgweits determined and scent- ing a. score after five minutes oi play pcliant. the latter lunged at. Klnch and, still grasping the cloths-s of the Respondent, tore his shirt from the shoulder down to the waist. Then. the Respondent says that Appcllan: came around and got ill the car with him. told Herbert Brown net i0 mind firing the cal" and ordered ihc Respondent to drive the car to the Magistrntefi; residence, The R3- spcntiint obeyed and with one head- light operating: drove through the Tswn and when they reached m0 lviagistratefc residence the Appellant 120k the Respondent in and said to tllc Magistrate “Hue I‘ve brought this fallow in. H: L: driving around with cniyl cnc light." The lviagis- irate film told the Respondent ‘.0 gs bark to the garage, get his light. ilxzcl and u: home and Come back Monday or Tuesday morning and he would lcck into the matter. He mct the Magistrate on the Monday oi‘ Tuesday following and, replying t0 the Respondent's question of what he . was going to do, Mr. Thompson said he "would look into the matter and try fliHLiiX it up some way." Tlicn, as appears by the record. the Appellant on the Wednesday fol- lswing. \'iz., on the 30th day of May. i928, laid two informationp, against. the Resilondent’, one that he did "zirivc his auto through the streets cf Albzmln as an excessive rate of speed contrary’ to laws mode 8111i provided" and the other, that he dKl "drive his auto through the SIFEGIS of Albcrion without. having silfliciezlt lights contrary to laws made ufld provided." ‘ On the charge of driving at m1 excessive speed h: was tried b61011‘ the Magistrate, convicted on the 831 day cf June, 1928, and udludked 1.0 pay a fme 0i $15.00 and $11.55 ‘fol’ ccsts, or in default of payment 1m- prisonment for 80 clays. And on lhff same day and by the $111110 M11115- trate on the charge oi having in- huiflcimi, lights, he was fined i110 sum 3f $5.00 with $2.75 COSLS, 01‘ m default 20 days imprisonment. N0 appeal was taken against either con- viction and, Resilondent paid ih? fines and costs. Mr. Tantcn, who 1P3 both a Barrister and a justice <11 the pracc for Prince County, acted as Counsel for Respondent in till! .tv'o cases above mentioned broilgilt against hiln by the Appellant 1'3"‘; and after they were difilwfieil 1’!- triocl tit: present case. _ The Appllllnt attacks the 601111111‘ tizm in this case on two 13111111155- _ 1. That Magistrate Tauwu W?“ disqualified ircln actlnii as Such "1 the premises by reason oi his ilosi- tion in relation to the two forum‘ cases, and , 2. That on the merits the con- viction was wrong 111111 5111mm "c est aside. AS u, m; fn-sv, ground, viz, dis- qualification of the Mflgiwfhlfi’ 1°‘ hiss. Thai. is a contention which plain. be made ii this were an n."- pucaucn by way of certiorari l9 quash the conviction and the Ap- pellant had been ignorant hi ‘he facts or knowini 9-1191" m“! °b5e°tf ed to the Magistrates jurisdiction. but. when. as in this case, tn? m)" pellant with full knowlediie of 11:0 facts tack his trial before Moll-W" ° Tantcn without 91119011011 he “pm” now be heard to raise the °bl°°“°“ m “ppm, The case thus resolves itself mm a trial upon the memh, The evidence oi the 3651191113911“ has already been suificicntly refer- red to. Several other witnesses‘: also acre examined on his behalf, e. — l) ert Brown who 09911191111 h Pmmc" garage testified that. on tho 3731 ‘all; or any last about. 830 D. 111- _ Respondent cam-a up Main Slim-W)" Church Strict. Onc- 1199111181“ “£3 burning and the other was 011i»- ~ nqwqn down his car as ihfihfli h° " i tweet» 6000 e00 o,» o‘ ha, ibis-illicit to 11°11 hi’!!! Wm" m?“ w” s l l realized when McLellan breezcd through to overskate and luicr pas". back to Gordon who bent Coiiings for mer Abegweit goalie to the corner of the twine. The final score in the last period came when Mountain, forward ~ub., playing a. great game for the Crystals broke through to try a shot and then catch a rebound to pass to Danny Gallant who demonstrated he was all there by bee. ing McEwen ior their second and wi i ing counter. A collslueruule nunluel" of needless penalties were handed out by referee; Diamond and Church last night, but in the long run said penalties may be of some help in curbing the tripper who not only hinders and slows up the game but helps to kill himself and his team mates in general. Too many penalties cannot be handed out by 1e- ierccs for tripping and tilis goes for every team on the Island. The Abegwcifis showing tonight was more 0r less brilliant considering the amount oi practice they have had. However, boring ill on the net was con spicuous by its absence and had they done so, a warmer reception would have been given the homz-stcrs. Schurnlan, Montgomery and Silli- phant ulerc thc brilliant lights of the winning team last night not forgett- ing Collings in the nuts who turned aside 38 shots to McEwcns 30. Saun- ders, Prowse, Gordon, Spillctt and Cox shone on the invading lineup with tho remainder of their team mates assisting heads up and pretty. Manager Fred lVIool-c of the Abe- ‘ gwcits czxprcssed himself in glowing terms on the showing of his team to- night. and looks forward to a great season for the aggregation. Penalties were_ evenly divided last night, both teams drawing; a total of six, Linc Ups:- i‘ “Y "winaa zeal; C. Montgomery, J. Grady, defence; J. Schurrnan, R. Slilinhant, C, Perry, W. McIntyre, J. Mountain, Gallant, ior- wards. Alvqweiis - W. McEwen, goal; ll. Spillett, W. McLellan, defence; F. Cox. J. Gordon, E, Prowse, H. Saun- ders, J. Murnaghan, U. Blanchard, forwards. Referees, Dr. W. G. Church, Sum- mersidc, Spul-geon DiamQnQ Char- lotictozvll. not rooln for him to pal-k in ‘iron’, of his car he went up Chluch Street and Central Street and in a minute or so hc was back, parked 111s cal‘ across the street from Iirownis and asked him i0 fix his lights for him. About the same time the Appellant came "aver to Respondent's car and while Iicrbzrt Brown was working: on the light. The Appellant told him that he, did no‘. wish to wait till the light was fixed, ihat- he could finish that. after he “was through with Mr. Keefe" and Respondent. went away with Appellant, having first anazlged to return and have the work completed. Ge ‘urge Iiinch, wilvm Respondent ljlCiiTd up on the road as he came into Albcrtcll, testified that Respond- ent was driving slowly as they came into the Town. l0 or 12 miles an hour. He noticed zlczhing “T3111; with the lights until Respondent said he must sr-e I-ierbctt Brown :1- bout. fixing them. After making .1 .-.1*.;rt diffilil‘ they stopped tha cal- opposite the cal‘ where llerbcri Brown ivas. Aim-client came to the C111‘, caught the Respondent by the shoulder and shook him several limes and told him he was driving», long enough without lights. He was balding Respondent for about ten minutes, pulling him backwaYd and forward forcibly 11.1; illustrated by the wtncss. Meantime Herbert Brown was working on the lights. Gwrgc Purdy another witness tes- tified aha: he saw Respondent will- ing into town driving slowly-about l‘.'. lfiiii“; an hour. One headlight <nly “'11s burning. When the car had sioiapcci the Appellant put his hand over the door, took Respondent by the shoulder and fiil0iik him. It: shcck him several tunes. Elvcry time he ixould say anything to him he \'.'0u1ci rzhakc llinl. All this time Rx:- spondcut was sitting under the steer- inr, wheel. The ear dzrlrs “TIC shut and the engine stopped. Tilllllliis Larkin was present when RPSPCIlLiCXIL stopped ills car 111111 cullid to Hirbdrf, Brown to flx the light. H: testified that while 1h" illliil‘ "was locking ior the trouble" tlr- Appellant cameo over to the car, cllilhili, Respondent by the shoulder and held on to him ivhllc Herbert Brown was trying 1-9 fix We ugm- H3 shock him‘ 3 or 4 times and said he was gslng in take him up to Thomp- il-‘Jikli and he told l-lcrbnri. Brown n0 would wait, no longer. The Appglluni‘ Qn mp other hand. toslificckthat when he saw Rxrspond- ent coming info ‘Town one light was dim and the other sui, H0 turned up Church Street and Central Street‘. In :1 few minutes h-z- Clinic back m» 53mg way and parked. He was 00m- ing pretty srviit~abollt 20 miles an hour, Then witness said "I nut 111i hand over his shoulder alld said ‘Bind. your light is out’ and he Sold ‘l’ am gzing to i221. Herb Brawn trail-X them.‘ IIe-rbert Brown w? v."_s.lr..l* . 1:2 zaid. auaut twenty "idiili-s i191’- haprl. lie continued "I did not as- swiv, Kr-ofn, I did not 111i, my hand on his. shoulder. I deny 1""- I Sfwfk Mm.’ I to.d Keefe (i‘\"~‘"-l’1°11d‘~"_"~‘ '7' come with me to Thomp-‘iohh- I pun ;1_v he iruspzndcnzl was sllfcil- mg aim; Central Street over lg llliii§ an hour. Keefe was, away "flllilliilfi ion the 063M117 ‘mil "he? he came back. On Central-Sire! nnm he came to Church Street he . . w-"wfl oq miles an hour. H9 might poi; be going that fast. I did l._'. “Assure the distance. l. 511i!‘ pfisr it was between cne- 1111111191‘ "d one-half mile. I taldhrad bchwflg under arrest when I but m! h" cn his shoulden- l woulchnot M“? an oath as to how fast the car W“ olng." ' g From first w lost in ma Ismail" able series of cases the evidsnce bo- y fore ms showed the Respondent us- l l l . years JQ Dirhiblal?!) "l JLALLEIL° ii g all reasonable haste to have the chm 1h 1hr headlights of hi; car "llmhed. and ween: rul- the contra- Qlclfiry and incoherent statements of the Ailpellant the whole testimony shows Respondent driving carefully at a rat.» m; exceeding the statut. cry limit. S. 96 cf the Motor Vehicle Ac; 19%, lllxvideshas abgllide to all courts. " s ctsall e constru _, n reason and 1n a mannerto oegfllima undue hardship to any person who is mt wilfully or knowingly guilty of n violation thereof." For the wilful and reckless violators of the law there should be no sympathy, but m arrest and submit to [humiliation a man who, accoldlng t3 the evidence before this Court, was in the very act (‘i Ci-‘llillyilifl with the leqilirements " of the law. to obstruct him in that Mi- 10 requisition his car and cause ii to be driven with defective lights through the streets of the ‘Down was ccnduc; that cannot be justified or crccused. The evidence afforded no reason. able ground for arresting the Re- spondent without a warrant nor 1115. tliicatlon far the control which Ap- pellant assumed over him nor for the foic: which he applied to his per- sch. The offence is substantially provell as charged and Lhg cnnvic- tion should be affirmed. The appeal is dismissed with costs to be paid by the Appellant to the Prothonoiary oi this Court uritilin thirty days from this date. BRYAN VS. WALSH Dominion of Canada. Province of Prince Edward Island In the Supreme Court Edward Bryan Appellant and Edna Walsh Respondent Judgment of Maihieson, C. J. 8th January, 1929 This. is an appeal from an order o.’ Affiliation rlatcd 31st May A. D. i928, made by His Honor George S. Inman, Judge of the County Court cf Prlhce County. Th1: Chief Justice said: "The hearing before me was in 0i- fect a new trial upon evidence which varied in material respects from that presented before the learned trial Judge. "Upllll ‘inc evidence as presented before me I have no hesitation in allowing the appeal. The said Order of Affiliation is therefore set aside and ordered to be cancelled. The reasons fer judgment may be flied (l1 :11: npplicatirn of counsel fcr either party". ' No ordcr for casts will b; ill the circumstances, . made Monthly Board Meeting YJW. CA. ’fllv reg-ills‘: monthly meeting 0i the Dnurd cl‘ Ilireciors cf the Y. M. C. A. was hc-ld in the Association iicarcl Room last night at 8 p. m. with Prcslclczlt J. A. Clark in the chnll. Other members present were W. A. Stewart, J. L. Douglas, J. A. McMillan. Dr. C. C. Archibald, J. E. lililfili, W. M. Rowe and R. A. Pcndltton. h-iinutcs of last meeting were read and adopted. Business arising out of minutes. details of camp committee ilaylnents. REPORTS Mr. J. A. McMillan presented the report oi the Physical Department. Mr. J. E. Harris gave the camp committee report stating that the building at Canoe Cove had been financed by the camp committee and that all details had been completed. Financial report was presented by its chairman. Mr. \V. A. Stewart. This w» "r was moat encouraging and : v that a great deal oi work ilflt‘. lncn done by the commit- ice. Outstanding pledges of over $21.00 were reported and the neces- sity of securing (hr-ac at. once was stressed. Fxiucaiiuz“ commit mo. —'I‘llis com- mittee w: "lied or. by Dr. C.C. Archibald, .. 1. " General Secrets; '.' report was presented by Mr. Pun ...c-'.oll. It dealt with in detail ilviih moat oi the ac- tivities of the month of December. On motion these reports were duly nditnicri. New BILQInPRS-Ufliiill‘ this head the annual /mcct1ng of the National Comcil of the Y. M. C. A. to be held in London. Fab. '7. i1 and 9 was dis- classed. Charlottetown members are J. A. Clark. iVicc Pres); W. E. Bcnili~y' and R. A. Pcndleion. Upon motion. duly seconded Mr. Pendleion was granted leave nf absence to at- tend this meeting. Ii. is expected that all three representatives will be able to attend this national gathering. Meeting was brought to a close with przrvcr by Dr. Archibald. N. S. EDUCATOR DIES WATTTRTO\VN. Muss, Jan. B-—-Wil- lianl Mortimer Macvirar. a native of "art Mcdwey, N. Spdied at ltis home hero at thc azc of 77 years. For twenty hfLWiLS the principal oi the Roberts School in Cambridge and his cduraiicnal work covered more than a hcli n. rcntulgv. He graduated from Acadu College in 1872 and wok a post graduate course at Harvard. Ho was a farmer president of the Harvard Canadian Club and a mem- ber m‘ the Canadian Club oi Boston. tho Intercoloniol Club and the NM- sacbuaotts Schoolmastem‘ Club. lyir. Macvicar, who was a widower. leaves two 5011;. Jolfilmaliflownl o: Montreal andfiuy ,_ _ oar'_ 811.10!!!" and two daufhtizva: Maren-oi Marlow": of ‘mu-o. n. 5.. and Mrs. Emma L. Blenn o! Wit!!- town. ' sights-l. inadiva tidings». .. .5‘- "H7413; ' 1* "' ' --.-_ r i ,4: