__1>1h>._c;a TEN - r111: 0.0111101111101111 5100.31.11“. i FEBRUARY 110.1938. c0 VERNDMENT BRIEF PRESENTED YES TERIQA 1*; |--_-_ ~ . _ ' 7 r - . _ ,?_‘c""t1""°“ firm“ l”g°—»5)-—- surplus we are sure that if ' 1 1 rod cti f our oi‘ Prince Edward Island to ertab- +1111 viousiy indicated the gaso- becoming more appmeht. Pwvln- anvption: it is therefore clear that W “Bl-it the Commiggio- . , ‘m ' ' ""——' ' they 11111110 expenditures upon .1§.‘.‘I....."... 111111122111: per- lish its public services upon the 1111111121811 has been raised to l0 cents ces are handicapped not only by 1g 011011 10x05 W010 1101151011011 10 possible by oral cvidcngem‘ * 111-WI" ‘lu- 0111101111011. 110111111 111111 011101 . -. 1100000 10 000.000. basis of s m um reasonable 1- 1111011s11ec11ct111v10r11111111111- men-lack e1 revenues. but by the the 001111111011 01111 administered point. "r110 1.111110 101111.11“ public welfare services propor- i ‘.‘5’,.,.f,‘.?1" 17.1.1‘- 110010 1937i standard. the present provincial 360501;: even with this tax.4it is cvi- 1111111011 scope of their geographical on, say. the average scale of rates. W mlfflfll- ” llonaic to that of the other 1‘ 191 '1‘110 Province also 1111110005 sources of revenue would remain to dent that the Province will be un- jurisdiction. This particularly true and exemptions, the Dominion 2 ‘ P10111110; 111 13.111000 1,110.00 a11_ a peysomu road 1m“ a 110,000 111x, be supplemented by an amount not 11,1111: to construct permanent hlgh- of contagious and communicable would gain fal‘ less by 51.11111 11, i ) Public Welfare Service; verse financial results would be ‘ 111111 11 dog tax. m“ “u” 560M!“ “a l" u" '1' ways with sufficient ra. idity t0; diseases. transfer than this Province would~ lfll" Fill-ll" " 1101 Fire Insurance Companies "rmmm ‘he "mm u “m”? meet the needs of the veiling ‘Several pi‘0])O$a15 have been 1o”, a The transfer to exciu_,-1.,»0 . . . . s Do. T110 Jones co111n11ss11111_ 01111111111- - 1 . _ .1 1 t1. 11M rate o; would needtov be relieved o! the 01111110, particularly of touristswho 1» made for the transfer of at least u 1111111011 Jurisdiction 111 1 ed by me Government o! Nova a e expenses mvgllvied lnicertfllfl 0' m" travel thmuzh the Island from 11 portion of health and hos ital- trgsieriugggibgédwgfifiléefézefi pensions, unemployment Al“ . Scotin 111 i034, confirmed the <11» Life Insurance Companies’ "efifi" 9"“ ;’r|“'gh°%p'ifl ‘:20.’ other portions of Canada and IOY- ization services to the Dom nion. (mums to the Dqmmhm would n01, "m" "fl-Dlvylnent servlcr l, _ statement mode by the Dimcnti are taxed, on gross premium» mcficagfelhrfnsy t govmckfit e elzu countries. The Province was 0110 01151111511011 15 111111, 1110 130111111- Imam’ ma m“ which m“ Pnhl V ization and public l1cnl1i1 .101. - Commission in relation to provln- alition inc Prlnceo Eldwm-d 101$‘; induced to embark on a pmitraui 1o“ shuum assume 50% or the cast vmce would sustain by gwmg up U005. will serve w 0111111111110 ‘111; 0101 cXPvlliilllllT-e" ‘Pall? 73) as r01‘ 11°» lv-cflltancc corpflrations are have wad). be“, mach“, o‘. W“! of hard-slurfaccd roads r0111) $33106: of stilt-bu setrvicelaltaiiohherlffusgé-Y succession duty and "Name b” great}? htfirthiofl ttho 01011111111100 ows: T ‘ 1‘ - . ‘ urance o a lrflasure 0 tion s 1a a cer an spec c r- - er o obi" “We “l” sham the °lllnl°ll taififtili ofléi-lldfliittflhoo-and Guaranty llfitiktl°.1ii‘ll..g'ti"tlfil‘.1.i".1éi'éf saslsumce which has not been m“ °f such services shmnd be thirfit vii‘: slgom i611 roéotrlgtsrificnet m“ branch o‘ m‘ publlclfigllihdis c. ~ ~ the Rnyal Com- Companm 01-0 1.1111111 each $100.00. tore qppear- to. 111111101- 1011010, forthcoxxiine’. This breach of klfifitransferrcd to the Dominion. from were to m“ m," the some” tffltloll. ' or. itaritinic Claims .11, 110011111111 11111311111011 Com- assistance fromt e Dominion Gov- ellllllllle °ll the Pa" 0! the Dmlllll‘! the financial point 0i’ view. "M" which we have suggested. The .-.a.-_‘_ ...._ $0 w“ i111: 11H“ illlhll" llP-lllll “Elllfc- Pal“ over the direct administration of .. . 1 _ _ _ _ _ _ _ ti ulzirlv in the (iirvriiflll M‘ "W general education throughout Can- Sundry Rmommmdauons And and prcvenvtr‘ '-. diseases lends it- T°l°~ 3157.500 Vincemil-znwillblgsifjltgi001109110’ to ihe 111, -...11 prevention of fub- 11.111, but. should further supplement h self [imrii1..tl.1rly' lojiutional ad- It, Wm thereto" be clear} seen t" of i d tile on in 1.x: 111.11. rlvistini; rue-HUGS are provincial revenues by B. specific ‘ ' mlmstmtlo": whnc me pwvime‘ that; on 91mg: o1 L115 twp gtgma- noun {n1 ‘Eora dispkuefi" M395 y inadequate to provide the 51111111011111 2111.111, 1°1- 11011010105111»- M the outset of this section 00' can conveniently administer the H ° It lll". End “Orking 0011. . Prince Edward Is- - 1 .1 . . 11. . _ 11101- 1 111111 r 11111111 welfare 011- V’ 9'°P°“J‘- "dltious. on the llhdcrst. 11 , _ b‘ l"“‘““<l . fillimyll- ltfff‘??? ofiigfifiiiffii $1011.11“ r?» §§1"§'1l-01‘1’1‘§1r@§s1isi0t1h§§§§§§§1m1§011§1i§i1- w! llel- ll m“ ‘*- pglfnl°d ggi 3110s. 131-11 0.311011101511- 101- 1110111- fill?“ wc°elusfiol°‘°d.l,‘.°“l”f,l},dbygil“: ellflllmsfllefluelde are 130-332 h "p" “r °°°“°§'-.“" m‘ “l” 0011111111. 111 1111111111111 111 11.1011 01- 1011 educational grant 01 subsidy to that the Prevlll“ °l “l sane. aged. and infirm. ‘ y °m l" Pmlevt prevailing t-xpcntl- 1 1 1 _ ‘ , . - . 1 1 _ . t1 11 h9g0 1 1 'l‘h er" we" ‘é‘.‘.‘°t‘v..1ilél‘1‘i.f.f.1ell.°ifi 1e1- we-le em- ... .0... .... .. .1 lwlil-silfi1eé-"é11lllehhfilfil 09010.? ‘$0101’??? . 1P1-0v1110es of No1.0's0011 or St”. 11100111111111 the iimues agreed upon ally be included m a model-‘icllelllig 1m 0,10,, 00°?“ e Ed p’ the provinces concerned. on; by 0 DOmBlMn and adn -"l°l'l Yell’ Bruivsivick u m“ Ne“ 111 1110 conference which preceded °f Keller” lwvemmellt- but it A 11.000 111111111011 out the pny- 1 1E1 Ce fif” wan} 15' instances may ted gasoline tion by the rovinces w‘ "m" "l" ' ' ' ll"- "llw-‘l “l m“ ‘"“°“""‘°““ “f i?” gm 1“ ”h."1e?§b$1s-§§§1"11‘Z“11?§ mefitaor 011love Penueflnnl Pell- 1151103311515? “$321111... “"1111” Z5? lax-eel“ “*- emwment we and work wen. 115110111100. co 0F. fhe “W: ‘B? m“ Swish Nnnh America Act‘ bigdestroilnlclfgases of remuneration slums t0 blind 061W!“ l5 ll "W ernmonts of the three Maritime wccegw“ duty- 55 we" as “Ymn lllld ‘lwlllllllllllt? °l adlllllll“ spoke as follows: w. .1... .-....1..-. 1... 0..., _ _ . elglyeeledglb.”‘i,.ll"i?“lf;2,.l’.ll‘ll;ll1 m0..:1".l1%:;llsl011130012; 1731111155; 1.5;“. ogegwrglllln 1.1g .°1%§.‘l‘.’.2“‘1‘1‘l€.".fii§f1.¥.i‘t?.?t‘“...2鑧§£ 33?. ‘i.’i“§“’1l‘.‘§.“°‘1“..i.i‘°.i1t m“ rkaqmlms i“ Whjéh the 15m“ isilivildi- "11.'1“1011’1‘1‘1‘“1’.i‘11“‘.1°1d b?) fund: fgr a superannu- years, and which lmpvsfil ll llllw maintenance of a standing Mari- gctvifldsl tax. it may be asserted criminal legislation. 110F113’ l‘l‘ ~'\ llllli‘ 1 vard Island has routs? I have searched for the ntion system withoutany further and serious burden upon provin- time Transportation conunwmh at the finely drawn distinctions clai and partly Dolllillloll U. ..n . ,, _ - . Th Prince Edward between direct and indirect tax- n ral prooed f the 1-1 L ‘ W MW taxation and rcwlubilble smut- 01 111111011. and inf (Luv Olllélmlatligg contribution from the Government. £is?a1’nélligl1’i;t35A 8e éemkms Act was cliclpggtiaktgfl tgstligruonlsgign anon have been a source of neat fies‘ o‘ wmlliguiglllcnlmnz“ .1, .111 1 i1 11 V: 1111‘ Is 11. Prime Edwnrd- Island was Tllld l5 ‘msbtlfh ajfinsm, 111 Fisheries passed in 1931, and was agreed to 03mm a 0,10; 11001108 Wm, m, worry and inconvenience to pro- tutes has been along the 11110.- of 1'1 111111-11 me one of the first provinces to im~ ‘1Y~§‘,§'0,§‘§§d‘f.1 31,119. zflficllS prov- l by 1,110 11110111110101 Iggisiabtlre on prlblexm It 1s therefore not om. vincial legislators for many years. the Criminal Code of 61111111111. 11nd llllllllflllll l'l"'l5' 11".". 1 ' 1- . . . . _ - . tht the We th refore ecommcnd that t XV tic-wt’. A ~ ..-..‘1”.~.33.-‘....2’.‘-"’1‘.l‘§ .’..-"‘.1113"‘.°..1‘1’.§?Z.%3I 32255.“. ‘1‘§$°‘€2i§§.1‘<‘f~.12t° 15th.. 0.€.‘.‘1Z$§‘1.£“1‘§§.'.. ‘tttlémfi? .123 fifmdlifiifiinlisfifiéfii 1103p 11w ilfiili‘°t‘..d“?.§mtl.1.f1‘f‘t‘fiili’o Eli m 11111113111011 11301110 111 1.11100 ti“°i’1.‘fi".li0ii1i1’1i’ 01101110331 ble mcas- _ . , . _ ._ 1 11 - N ~* _ -, 1. 1~- prim-mu. atifldjizilrliirl $111111 of the ivmsiaiipn Bmwn. by Dr. Tuppei. by S11 specilncrl budget is the establish- 100% of the amount necessary o Dmlmmn Government m respect to te British orth America A1... prmecutions o! this natuichln] c ~ H sflir‘ the hluli '.i1-~ .- 1- _ o1 - - on. out the scheme. This assur- 1 _ t0 clarify the Jllfifidlktllln 0f DTO- come eat varied. '1 ~ ' -l’-“fl_‘~'“_._"t Pczl- of 0x<~1n11ti1111l111s fcnugg ‘Iifittimbltillllillisllll I biilivy 11111021115 1751“Xiiiffiaglfvfifitilémiiileinséfiiy uni‘? was never brought U110 d‘ geigiitlggies?‘ ri-liilipiiiii"gg vlncm legislatures i“ “we” m COWIWSY gllvwfl <l\lll5l-Pl' . _ . . . . 11.11 111111.1- 111 1111..- 1-011111-011011. ' ' i110 01111011151011 than this \l'°lllll within the Turisdiction o! the Do- feet. but the Dominion Govern- submmm to your Commission by the substantial sources of revenue 011011000 11111 11111110111111». 1.1 ‘ ‘ l l” -‘ ""’1"m”"§ i!‘ ’I'l1v Prince I-Trhvarci Island 11o a hi1" Iimsis upon which to 1 1'0 01-111 01111 1111 the whole be merit subsequentfiy increased its me Marmme ‘Board o; “we and which they 110W 6011665 B1141 t0 B11- followlng laws: The Cllsivlli» ' - - ll ‘l- su mx-sloxi duty i. maintained int-ct the wants of the provin- g1 l1t°011'm11115101ed bv the Domin- proportionate contribution to 75% its Transpormuon commgsmn itblfi them W "19 63W“ 01 Blllih of Canada, The rlxcise Act 0f (7 ~- ' with higher rnics and lower scale vr-s.‘ Tllfil, was thrir judgment. ‘If; Government 11101-0 111-e mrmy orthe amount expended. exclusive . ' taxes at least, to enter into the ma, T119 11131110011 11111110 A- <1‘! ~ ' of cxemptions 1.111111 prevail 111 111111 111 i006 we 1001-: 11s a bn . 10cm condmons ‘which do not lend o; adm1n1S11-011011 00.1, T11» Gov- succcsshm Dunes and Income T“ field of indirect taxation. 1,110 911111111005, T111- 11110 -- ‘ "lmt llllllllllPv-‘i. of .iu<i1z1nP.lib\'>l “l0 M " themselves to management by a cmmcnt of Prince Edward island Liquor Acts of the Provii '3‘ ‘Th0 Pi'0\'i'.l(‘l.‘ colic-is m1 flu- :;r-\'1-1-.'1! province. distant’ Central adjmnmuau°n0 W118 111011 1111101111 111 11 dllcmmn: n‘ may appear that Prince Em Overlapping Des nsliiililiaa 10011“ 11110 11111111001- 01 1.1-. . fl" 1* "l" lib‘! fit u. lwh n r1111: - “ll” mm l m - ‘There are several rcspcctsin which provincial revenues were lnadc~ ward Island is 55km“ m, 000000. N"! 5°" c" arising out of offences 1112.111‘- cnnsldru-crl 1m: twins: routine‘: to their vvucri "' _' it 1s 1.1.1.0111, 1.1131; the Provincial qilate to moot. the atldcd burden. 110.15 1101111110 1300111110,], wuhout o1- 911101- 11f the 5111111105 y .. .. ,. . The development of Dominion 1111101101011 10111.5 0 v01... 1...,- . . b t, t] tax uyvrs of this Province fly < _ 1 . _ Govennncnt should make some u 1o p on‘guise!lanybociafircgsgonéhgfrggél and Provincial departmental nd_ proportion or Hm ma‘ it. rair- prr-vqilin-r in . ‘ m‘ "w". Wm“: provision for aissistnncc to the were obliged io contribute iowarrl '11 11 i211 11-i.1l 11111. l1 t; ' ' m‘: W’ "mvr him“ l.l i110 Dominion contribution for 1m. m“ is obvious. m" “mu need ministration 1105 nwffififlflly 1'0‘ procecutlons. and i0 illf‘ 111L111“ Xiluolnglihc Provmcc has during the pensions in the nthrr lll‘0\'llll"-‘- is such that. :1 balanced budget on “m” m a Germ!“ ammm" “I ‘W’ double the lulmbvl‘ vi PW“ ‘ LMHFP‘ bran": m" " ' 011' hcrclnbefove past two years entered into an Prince Edward Island was HWTP- 111111111111111 rcnsonuhie expenditures ‘lllallphlg selvlcgs- I" mllllY “"585 tinder the Criminal C010 nulls‘ per 111111011. _ " ‘ ‘ I . 1 ~11- ‘ he D0minionGov-__fore forced in self-defence to ndtjpt 01m 01-111. 110 1101111011011 b (11) 11 "ll-s has Call-led“ 1°55 °l emclellcyfl- tilnatcly lhc Criminal L (lame 1? “E3815; v L-’.'*11*1T1§§“11'i"i0l-v'i1}1‘111t1 contribution to- the scheme. The hardship ‘axhirh transfer o1 001mm r0sp0¥k01b111t100__ 11nd l" 0th" C5595 all inertia-s‘? °l these sevcral i1r1n1chc~ “U-oi w Lp wards the relief and reestablish- this situation impflwfl "Dim "l? to the Dominion; (b) 11 special ‘warhead ‘Hpenses- A study °l the criminal iegllntion. v;i fl ~ D01 111- mcnt of necdv fishermen. Such a finances of the Province may b9 educational rzrzmt to the Province; “mus °l sum Wellll-Pplllg sen/lees u a more or less unilo 1‘ .,..7¥1....-m 1111112111101 101-111 011.111.010.100 will no doubt inferred from 1hr‘. TM?» "Wt “l” 1cm n. fnrihcr additional subsidy Wm ll° ‘mum llldlclne m“ the“ 0 1'3 11l1 1 Q0‘! 1111001 continue i0 be necessaw from were obliged i0 arrauac for pnY- for prcvincinl nitblic services other Wmlilete elimination is lmprMl-lv- 1.111111, 11105001111111; 11 i‘ " ‘u.’ {11011-‘01. 111110 1o 111111" ment of pensions on the basis of ma“ 0.1000110". 11 1,. 1110,01,," able. But there are certain res- 0110 31111111101 c0110 11111 11111011 ‘by "Al? 1b) ‘The Provincial Government a maximum annual P011!‘ ll "l vicar that if this Province con- "W's l" which "lldmlhl-edl? Bmlt‘ ably under most liiwhuu .,..' .1 ..'..1-1“0f 011011111 111111- some part in schemes $180 per annum. us ilfllllllst $940 codes to the Dominion any of our cl‘ emdellci’ and e°°ll°lllY Wmlld Acts, the prosecuting nut lfrtriilil! Do- for the training of fishermen in in other provinces- prcsent revenues. the general ad- lllsllll llllm l‘ lllllflcllllml °l 5"‘ vested in tho Provincial . 1" the rrlzlltrnlion of “'0? vrhlcles is i111- 0f 71f) cents 1101' irWvfh-"r Will‘. r- 1'1 1.- m: 5 O E- =1‘ F Q ‘ii ‘i “up .. . . . » . 1 -1 A t aitovether from the Ob- 111110 1 11.111 r 111 n 1- "lees 110W Jointly Blllllllllstvlell by 001101111; 1111110 1110 01-01 - l-m" ' 'l'l1e (lll1*~il1\il“l4‘\f 1'1.\1('gin110c<i. on lgrodriizgulslrllg 11085251 0T m“ D°mlm°ll l“ Y“ 1...1§'Ji11"1§'1.'1i.. llilcmincrzasedmptto Dllmlllw“ "mi pr°vmcu1 depu" N10 P-‘(Teclltlllg lllllllllllil’ ‘ "m" Iilw 111111-1- 111.11 dmu; 11r1ns11i1111it1i-l 111 1101101111 educational work. with spent to old Me P1019005." l5 tanto. ' ments: ed in tho Minister of » ”“"" .11. " '.1- umniiml. bllt Wl- 1111111011111.» reference to the condi- evident that the pension scheme we 001.00 11,01 11,010 15 11011111 Revenue, acting through illl 00.001.11.11 factor in tlons of the local industry; could be more efficient)’ Mllllllll-l‘ merit in the contention that suc- m Agflwuu" “m! Fmmsm’ mlssioncr of Customs: H114 .3 _ ,.-1 111\vn1~1ls_ a rcazi- 1o) A provincial officer or ofli- fered by the Dominion, as this 005510,, dunes and 111000“, m,‘ can . - ~ 1'11<lst111c1:-. of 1111- oustilutioxuil sct- CcfS should be appointed, whose would not onlv eliminate ovcrluli- be better and more equitably ad- I" 599ml‘ “levlmblg/hafilémtlzggfi w‘ 1 up 0i 90101111011’Plovilllllll “m” duty it would be to maintain oon- ping administrative costs. but 11111115100001 by a S10E10 10001-011110 Dominion and e 0V es U‘. .. ' s ' - ~ h n lstln would obviate many Drflblems l" isdici-ion. rather than b divided ctlntlllu” t9 admmm“ 59mm” I . . t11111h1ns. _ 1.101s with the fis erme . ass t! Y d t’ w‘ v1 m 0mm? Iv 0.. T111 11.1 1 .\;~z1>'r11A'1. .1\ _. ctr»; 0011- The best. index 0011111 ‘nctllfll, its-r them nlonz the lines of market- cases which affect more than one 0001.11.01.11 _1..,-10.110110n0_ M 11,01 uegarwrlrzfin Canrsggscggsmc lcldum? [g1 1.1.01.0 11.11. 1.-1_-1_1\;(111 _ 1c 11 -o1111~. nmi c111 need ni 1111-. (mrwinmctio o 11.g_111-;~:1nlz:1fi011. the ourinz and prfWlllCt‘. sight. this Province would appear ° m 01‘ ~ 31F 11 ’ " F‘ l" i c-i-es P1111!“ llilwlllll lslllllll "d" "c W" processing 0t products, and gen- We therefore mrommcnd tlwt 1o benefit by such a change. But 0i WNW-we. and consequently ' ‘ }-|1\:.1Ll_l -‘l~- f 11.1 ;vlnl\mé'~l-tl 1,0,0‘; 1,._. .111. ..-111~_11=1...~11111 01' 1111119 cm. éaucauonal ‘v0.10 1110 011111-11 jurisdiction and rcspon- m analysis of the 0011101 118111.00 operate concurrently in the same M“ j. frpfm‘ _ _ WM l1 .- -.~:1~.11 1-.1 11.119.01.101. 10': 111111 ‘111.- termed‘ 1t mvdtl lflllllllbl l All these services would require alhllii. for the payment- flfllllagq‘ will indicate the necessity for the flllldiv mulidlllxgalléialgall-lhljlllitimgcgx‘ gueation. The result is‘ v M, 1...... ‘a vnlzcr: . n11 r. ,1 1,_}~l"1"l111_ 0f nrr 01ml prcpcriy 1 lllllllllllllll lllelll-lbll} $119115.- 1. .- 11 1.111101110111110 11111011111 01 11101111- 1.1111111111111111 0r 11w are 11cm eh- 011111011 with 111111011 Prince Edward all-sue“ um‘ _ d‘ by “l: 11110111111 111111 confusiolilh-m- 1701.5 to. . 1.10M, 11s 17.11.71; 1,1111», W l »1 ht‘ pun:- _ _0\v11~.-.1 1o 1110 yljlllll ‘l. fi .» , cial expenditures: as the matter is and pensions to blind. per-Wu! -» @---~-Is-land approaches this question. 9Q f _ in The minds of acc 1 v fl m f '19 5 . . . 101 /\ reel prr-var-ri 1"" " t“ "Wlfllwlill" l" ll" llll*“"l’°"‘""'* -' ' l D ' l iurisdiction veaieil in and assumed hv "It 9°‘ For us ccession ciut. income mud“! “udll-‘mn °l m” Pr“ and of the public but also 1. . "" M’ 1WD T" l ‘if-wk T" ~ .57? is iI111>~=1111v 1.11?- 1~1l01-1I"K»°f " " 13.1 110-1 0r 111. 111-111 111 01c bell’ .“"I““.1‘-‘°1>$022?“ 0'11 1111011111? 11111111111 0r 011111111. ' 111x 11014011111 111000111 ytax 111-111 low Wit-Ill lllvellfl" llltelfll" W‘ 1101100 111111 01-00111 011011111. 1'1" ' GOYERNLIEN r 3.9V 19111.7“ in I onfuric" i110 111v 1151;! an "l "llh ""M' “m” Fm" i" ‘m m” l1|l‘1,1(\u'11I“l1-iv I110 111...... ‘of raisinii v 111401.11 corporation taxes 1111 lieu “"11"”? °ll m9 “h” hmd- u“ most obvious overlappinz nrrh‘ '1"'"" 31".“ A FA} 1611111111. 1r "d 11111-11... 'l‘l1u 11(- 1111».§?:,'1 nrmlix. ‘r110 bndzc. oi vXll°lllm""°“ 1110 1.11.5110 funds 111 feel that (BI of- income taxi are closely con- llldllfltl’ 0' flllwllllllle "l "ch intoxicating liquor cases. l" ' gdgi/QN/ilrdmr; ém- "l ‘al will" bl’ lll" 01151-10l35;.““.E..l"l$,"§l5;},.;§.€? §‘1'.‘0“.t.°f}.'1.‘,3.‘.'.‘,’,§ 1110 P11011100‘ s11011111100e1v0 a spe- 1110111010‘ Ailnwall"! nected 11110 interwoven, and at "tic I1‘ WW1" h" l°°lll lll‘ a particular 1101 of 011011111 ,_ . . 1 - .~ 3., 1 _ .. -. . . crests and local problems which 11 ~- 100 “WWW 1%]? n] 131:0qbtfumiilft§i)'l11iv1till;- "l "lllllllllllllm-‘l ‘Vlllfl’ “'°.“‘°' m’ ilihgliixi; (goniinigiodggvezrwgg: P111100 Edward 111111111 11011 110011 '1’§fi,'i,,“1tn§"}lg,ef,°uefllfebfjgg'“o°fi ‘J11: 010 1101. 111111 11101110011100 w 0011111011 '§}§1‘,’0,°°{‘1f§m.‘,','§,v’},'.‘01§1 '1‘1‘§1.‘10,. gfipfigngolh (‘,1 Jflmmr1.‘ 19111 flirovliw-lnl 1.11111 fax ie. in zicirliilon 1llllll;i1>1‘~('_1'"iv uor-crsarv to ill-Ill! the r01. 1110 01111-111111; of such fishery and continues to be unable fln- pubnc 11000111115 10.. 193g; by a centralised and distant autn- m. the Dominion mvcnuo 111s" , ., . . _. -~-.~ 1 "1 Pmvhw- 11p _ . _ _ _ t .1 1 m” mum’ 8mm‘ o! cann‘lar~w"" ‘b31011. hold-ll T511110" 11i"1li1(1!i‘-'1.- in 1v mlivllinilrn ‘.\)“lli(igiii. ‘it \\iil b” QH-iicgi-"s11i:1‘§11éi'??!§' 11v$h'§"1§0°1'i irlwtheg- Lii:§:1'1§1§ 17535:‘: succession duty ~~~ »— —- —-$ 43.000 grelittfllieiflagilgun ‘mltgigliletorlbilf ‘m0 mm‘ The dmpofi“ of N“ f“ i" directed (‘Q1151mlltjkiltlllllfggfunwfI‘; 1 1.1“ 11,01.‘ Qumflpyllmfis fill!“ .11”). 11.11011 11111;. the {llfirlllvlu gfflmmilvflt hmimg ‘a .0010 11111. 11111111111111. The growing necessity of 111001110 1.1-1.1 001001101 1111,11. provinces can retire from this field , . -‘._ ' <' ~1-_ - ; ..1 . __________ q l‘ gnmetalgntnble nficssm ‘w n, H“, i ill.il‘l(l. rind inx ihsrlssnlciif. 1: .1! .’;.','(.“L,,.“L" u..(_')_‘.11'1 1n a 51.01,. 00110111. mate contact with the problems of a service of this kind is becoming arty tax 50000 of administration, we must eon m, f“; 7M .1110» or 1'2:1.“‘:;‘"%1.'“:.¢.:1::11"""r l" 1w»- "w ‘M’ 1'::.':".'.-..:"'.'..::1"1:..':.'..:.'1:. .1; l" — — — —___"*'-'“ t’: 1:11:21" >1 weevrtmmsrlliszz-l; 211...:- 91€QJ11°1°1‘.”“"1“.°.“"B'01.'.’1Y11.‘"i11R‘""1l.'éloci-h P"".“l'.“"“l Gminmnlavlul. lml °“.‘1"1§-JZ.'§’.‘.’.'"°§T1.1 0111011111001 for Illrhways same- We tllwilllfd TOW - —~ +——'- ‘"53"’ gflwbflmllllfurelllzlggmuclifpggggf lJloubte pmsecutlonflanodrtig 11iirsi1l1. Audit 5mm mlfuvglfgggfl’ .'.~1-.'.3§'.’1'. 1"1'Z'1§"§1.l‘ill“1?§§§i°?11§“10@1l‘f ".99" “i mhflmgqifwodglliklilldizzvis Nor docs the specimen budget. '11"1‘1'.'1..9t.°..1'1'11i.. 111115311111 to Those forms oi taxation are manta of the various Provincial $u'§‘c,:"l'.'§l,§“155'§;01010.. 11nd Pro- Govenmient o . . 111011 n iqbloiul o1I-1111115rv101-e1111e contain anv reivrencc In the con- the Dominion. closely connected. and none can Governments. in filéiiifl‘ that e vlrwm mmmuflom "e 611100.11 m - ~ . - rt. ciiiiirulfv in coliectin thr- land . Ihirh the Ivlllllvlllll l5 "ll "xlf-‘ll- ° . ._ .. 1,. . ., f‘ . 1 1, 111 m, 1 b0 surrendered without the ions oi realest possible e cncy and t s ~11 1111i 4 "The provincm of Nova Sco- x :1..~z-.\~.m.11f. i111.» is not i0 be 01 gr. 11517 11,-1.1 1111111 ..1-<1ln111y cx- structiou o permanen my. M v m l‘ ‘at m,“ w w o‘ m d the “me m o’ ma“ C0111. c . I I .1 1.1, 1 110111101011 111 1 1' 11 1.. .. 1. - .1 _. . r1111 matterisireated by ePro~ (C) uraetie l.v all. Further. e e vflfl- - M OM!’ In 1111111 -:§.’.,.t’..'hd1?1m1v1'i§11 P1131112 crease in fixrilanvclfg oreiiiriis (far "‘»iile".lfi..l’.f.1gv.ti1lin1ii1i1l11 10 be M" vlme 08 00B 0f Oallttll emeudlt- liulllltllllltivn and Public lllllth mount of revenue derived by the effort may result. It is not pr0~ uncertainty result. {it g . . . . - Province from thus sources is in posed to embody ab stalled .. ~.~~. Meow“ 10,. 1110 1100111 10111, 1111111 protiiicisqin Prince Edwmnli Is- 1.0011 111 111-111 the foregotnr bruiret ure- “d stinking idlgdmfrm i111 The national aspect 0f theta iarfzl Dart due to the 111m rates of lest-ions in this kl ul our 5W . . ' ii Col it 11d (he Province of Now 1am] from $3,530,000 in 10.1". to 10 11 1111111111111" alrfivli of 8111111013.! tended to e Dr0v 0m u _ mo“ v u m, 10001101104.” , » " rtmsvvick showed a slirmt. $7,704,000 in i035. The vllm d h other words. for the Province tax on rasoiina and motor-vehicles. branches of the public service relation and the low soaiu of ex v a Department vi Iideavo 0 ~11 1.11:. ~.». . .. .. ca...” -<'.<‘l'{ . ‘.,.....1,1.11»¢11 f i i P\'l‘f‘ll(ll‘lll‘€S cf Novm - 1 W01 00011 $75110 0111mm; ion has alrefldv 16d 1° the flddlllml two suggestions would afford 11p- (3) Fisher-i ,-~ 1 .. - ._ , result nsci 111111111119- - l‘ 1» I ~ "W be“ kept ‘Ylllllll ‘M21115; giiiirltllty’ Compflrlies are There are certain or the Provhn- 05 9- "TY 1"" llllwllm’ l° ‘he P“) DPD-Ylmfltely the $8019 PlB-‘ltllt Ye- 1111100 “$011101 §,0r:0e1011%w0 11,020 _ l .- “lb-l “llll lllllllel" llmlls- 1111011 01011 $5000 0101 public services. Which. 101 rea- vineial debt. and 00111011110111111 w; 1101 t0 Prince Edward Island, but on m, mum Momma M, 1m). The control and 01111111111111111011 I “l ‘llllll "w Plmllwe ll“ W101‘ 1§11110=‘11'10'1111111o 011 1101- sons 11010111111101 set 101111. 01101110 our annual evwevrletloi“ l" ill-r the second suggestion appears m - 0r 1101101101 1s 1111111011 11 .1 1 ~ reached the iimit_ of age‘ 1001.0 111111 depdsirs-i-o of 1%. be taken over by 1,1111 13111111111011 terest and sinking feigldh rghefxf u; to ‘have grenter merit on gen- Old age pensions - -_ _ _;54_1m ininion Jurisdiction. _Ir. 1,1 1011p - I uc timt 1s rnailable fiom 1171 111w companies are taxed, uovemment. The transfer of these matters 8W mm 9n t! 1 eral principles. We do not. approve 5111111111011-011011 0; madam 7,000 iowaver. by this Province 111.11. c111- . i0". “V11 OXi-"fiilrsr resour- Each $111900 public services would relieve the order that it m8? b0 11101119 B-bllllrg‘ the extension of the system of joint 13119111 r0110; _. __ ._ _ _ 32,000 1008-1 fisheries. as Our 11 l l 111 11100151111 rind twplllfitlml» 1181 1.111..‘ Companies are taxed, province. on the basis of the esti- antly clear that. Prince Edward] ‘ :1 00110110111101“ 0s 10011110011 1110 D0. Provmcml sanawflum __ _ 277100 - ".' 1 12121112.: ere“ 122:. .111 1;-,,-;gg;;;.=;s.,.-;.=.1..1 011.11 10111111 —, ~ - ~10 ' ~- J ~ i011 l‘('l-“5£ " 0 or~ 1.11 1 - ' I 1.11 1y - ea servce -- -— , f 1 it ._ 1 11111101- for the Diirpnse 111' l . f}? T°‘-“l’§800_‘53¥“l’i19§f§ 111%: further substantial contributions: gency ca.“ but 1t 15 bud 1n pm.“ 5 _________ _ _ ‘ 1 ‘ hvunl‘ "' m" ‘)“"*“*‘ “lllllg l '90‘1§1‘.1'1111L1‘.§§“111~0 111011 on pgross Dllwl Relief"- - -—-— 3351900- tOWB-rds U18 COIl-‘iullcirlilll °l hllld" lple, a: it loads to the penaliz- T111111 _ _ _ _ ._ _. 41509130 would b1. m?‘ l‘ '* w,‘ , 1111‘ old 111cc pension m-ngsml 1,30. C,“ ‘and E100, Old Age Pensions and surfaced or permanent highways. 131m of those 10,01,010” 0,111,011 1.1.1.1111 011004111 11000 50,; 10ml ‘n I . X “JJ0'UU‘ “ll-ll ‘his. ‘hall's lll“ 110.1..- Coiiipmiios arc tuxcd P e“§1°“5 l° Blind PM‘ 7 The fereiroiniz coucllusionls ég} specially emleuvour to curtail ex- 0r, i! the alternative suggestion this submission. We iiierciore 1'0. _.. . . mcinpinu: 1... 01-11»- 0... = .- 1 1-22’. - “ll-l. '- .- — - — ~ 6 ~5°°- the fiscal Heed 0f t"! l°l ll. 11011111111111. 11111110 the less fru 1 were adopted. the Province would commend that the 00111011011001. l .. no.1.) 1.‘ m1 - 1,» , M O m, are Acimunstration of Pen- lead us to a consideration. m provmcm 20001-00101,“ 01-0 0111 be relieved fiscally as follows (ao- eminent should inaugurnn- -_ 1__(l1 511.111 1 C mpa s G101 _ n 750 , t d t u o! the , . . p s35 ‘ l -' in. xi. r-uch s 100.00. Y t 1 Pgovillii; E8515“; _ 48-006 gggmfitcxizailegegrmeflltmhcml u“ tlizrgctlnfggctilglétigirfiuafileithn: to the Public Accounts of wag; tgodtifg gilasgfstgooizhc pro- ~1 1 1 v- 1._1.._ "u; , - ' ' . ‘ ' . - - ‘ .‘ , ‘- . 1d actually bnfg/ ,};,i“’,...-L‘.§ fihillhégaoi11in Gmm51t° ‘Hllspltlllsl '— '_ iationships between the Dominlivll mlnlon contribution. up a limited provincial 11.1fm”! countries." .. 131-.) '11.1'.-0..1'1_-.01}.0110 01011.. 1110 Pubhc m“ m Se” “s _ 1 ~ and this Pmvlllw. llllll ("7 0"“ We therefore propose that the old a" Plililmlls -' — '4 541900 "$311011 810M the lines which w‘ 0 ‘ “to {the H “Tlywvl w; “Hod m‘ as nigh n Tomi {Po possible liltififalézizllfilltgngi ifiifialiigill‘; Dominion Govcrnmcnt shouldda: glllrléclinfiil-fgatgon of pensions ZZDOO have sulzizest . .11 rom ,'.f",'_‘ 10-. '_""""'_"“_ ' ' rs cons 1 ~- 1 d -d ii d “""—"'—' . 111-01-1111-0 11111 - “F. l3?‘ _‘T".‘"""-‘.‘°d ‘Ymdfffl,’ 11., get-up 0r 1110 001111111011. Thesv 30111-100321: tiiempzifiicr limit; 111-- 5°% o! other public welfare (41 labour Legislation 1% 0m‘, W,‘ liu- liuumc Is 11011 u11c Q3. the assumlll-llill “l” the D0‘ matters will be dealt with in the ‘.1 m“, n H1001 1, 1h 1.00- services — — — — —- -- 84.500 K "“’“ “"'""“"' ""“"“"‘"" “t “Pam” mlmm‘ G°"°m’“°“‘ W1“ m” “k” concludins: section 0f 0111' Bllel- 1155-»; 111'» 10in 0r 0§111111§111E11111e As already indicated, 111s r10. eeurzlcti as .. coznmiwn - ._ .- ward Island is strongly and llll‘ WXW- Well 1f the Frown" We". provincial conditions. I111 01 .11111.;10-s-.11011 10111- ffifi-‘Qllllmllflljllf; ,f_',‘”di'rf.ijf"‘§fl§f1ofl m” P’°““°°' 111101011111 11101101100 10 1.110 111111- (p) rellieved 01 the s esfed 111111110 :1 11101: We b0 101-0 that 1111110 "(gr [mg “ma, ~11 1, m1 5,111..“ The 111111111111, or 1,111.11 3111111, ciple o provincial autonomy 1!; Unmphynwnt Rene; we are services. T e reason why (5) 1111011101,, u“ ‘ms true 0f the time at which 1 n] l: , ‘ suiflamial Mm 5119111111 be 1110 dflferencg the 0P0! 5119181‘? 0f Pmvfllcl“ 5 91 QIIBJKB i 50nd"? GU19!‘ 1111» c11111.-111;\;11111 .011 1.110 1.0. P“ "d a a ‘l’? ." 0111,10 11 111 m uni; ro- uris iction, and would be umvill- Th d “s! u 0 n _ Pmvlneefl. Wt in H" Pr!!!“ Ed- Whllc there is a certain ~ . mint can be raised lIi this man- l? 9 e 5 ° D t l e a m“ m o" o "em d Isl is i th f 1- ammm‘ Wllfll 1= Sllbslfll .' IP00 w- 1 0 11, u m0 0g 11,0 011. posed for educational to consent to the forteiure 0 pmymcnt relief, either by way o! w“ am" imply 9 m3“ 0! OVBTIIPDIHB in the ndmlnfs‘ - my. with the 1 crence that no“ m .901’? Y1 1m s1“ expenditures in the mln- any 8901110913’ lmlvlndal fights‘ direct matcrlni aid, or by way o! my Wm‘ which m“; Prwm“ ha‘ tiOH 0f Company law, we 11o 11111 whereas in 1W8 the condition "n 0P1“? . F“; ‘w o p01 g illlllm 111M181 blldllet -— $530509- COIIdmOYl-i- "OWN"? have arisen pubic employment projects. has b-een "med to manage l“ ° n‘ I091 that all)’ added or 111111005. 01 industry 01111 trade was sel- - "." M.“ Mm,‘ ’“"‘m‘s°1'""t u’ and the amount at. tresent in the development of Canada as prwcn- halides‘ In the ha“! of ditures in comparison with t ose 001-11 0111101150 15 101,011,011 1,011“ xl-vt-ly eutisfnt-tory; m. H111 1110. - P H‘ H 1px‘; fmoffl“ “l” c" i’ expended by the Prov- a nation, which have resulted in nlunmmntles bf provinces. mm 0! 093191‘ PYm/lllcel‘ The suggested Other hflllli. it uppcars that there rnt time it is under the in- rmtmam l“ 3 5m.“ ' m“ on edllcablon u“ demonstrating the inadeqllilcy 0r with the assistance of rants and chm?“ by 1mm would meremm 18 I DIODEI field f0r Senor-111- tui- ‘l. g 1,11 .01 . Prom "Ill "5"" “Sb u "l" b‘ l1 h Pubil A - - I titution in ccr- _ ' 3 mer y result in. an. added deficit 1 10 1 ‘1 ‘ iqgllcince 0 e \\o..d depics- 5cm "mt (he 111.01.10.00 h.“ 1111110,. 303K’; ‘Al; lugs Corgmé tOLllT preagengtscofihem has “risen suhvenuom b m, 130mm” Gap m: Prince Edward Island ftnunlotragxzliét of.’ companion oy Do. n» were 0111101111. 0 22.: *2".:f'.':"1‘:::1.1': 110231.11 111111111 Que- 11lékiief11er 1 e 12:10:01.‘: .1. 121092". 12.1.‘! 11111111111110.1101 0.1111- .1.11.2... tfiliSiiit1fiiflff°lfilil inve-eugatmg this same mailer 00mg‘! gm”. 1. “jd- muhoa from M01111!!!“ Sell-up) —- - 3351703- iic services. oppflifillf-ly n05 Um‘ 010mm,; 10 a 000101 00,0100 0g m. P" lll'°P°§ll h" I- t'll-'ll“? °i and Dominion-wide business 10111- afim- referring to the increased 1~;1 b1’ . 1, i‘ tempiated at the time of Conicd- “anal Cantu“ and ma‘ m“, m, 11001110 “X88 l-llfl 8116095510" all‘! tions will normally find a 111011 public debt of the Province stated. 31:50:01?" ’ "1' "‘ ‘flmues m“ e or. an additionfal increase eration, which under the trprezrrhlt Imumm, government 1, 00,01,010“; gogfilsgcllllgilllgc-lwlégglel" ‘gig-g: suitable machinery in Donmuon M Rflbotlfooofolr“ it???“ 01 51215151‘ engfirpcggs eflllgg; teimszlg: a2‘; athii/Ezifiskt pljigtriv wiih- ‘° “fill “ml m“ l"°h'°’" l" ‘m!’ ‘ . ' ’ 01- 10 gygggixetglnpelvgggleee;.111“- 111s \r.1a cxcn - .1 - erza _ w ' _ -' ‘ - 1 e - tures the ritlminisptratlon 31f all Th‘ I “ndfifizilxllhgceguesmln o‘ Flllflfiufiqlll! tarelt-Lg-se-cur-e 8193-792- in provincial jurisdiction, gzmierfmwglztgfllcirorz“"cumin"! also‘! nan-Eng: file's‘; manage as; provincial objects linayymogc c012: three afar-mine Provinces ap- ‘Qubyi ‘foe?!’ bud 6t on which the Provinces (pnr y 101d that 11.110 rmponflhuuy Sh," b, n “we h m!" "l"! and“? °| vepiently beincorporatcd 11nd reg- ntlop fiigdhflfflnbfTil qluife 1110111112 established that Prince 11101102110 0g 01100155011111,“ iimittlzalticnfrriolclf liilrixiirt-mtlrncvcnugi. tgcir ‘lennncly and cxdushvely assumtd 003011119’; .111-e:1111§'011111i1e11 11g ha“; glhaeteixisli? Déovérlicial fuuthigrlity. ‘l ov0.asc1nr- -. ' - ‘ ' - ‘ , r 1 _ v on 1111- “Metbizpd Pv lhqDlmcan Cmll‘ fifél-ifiiillailéiii$0035 “lE/ultllz-nufiaéltllz Prigngiigngyesthfhefolgggg: $100301 action) cannot 1111<if§§k§ by ‘he Dominion “and b7 m“ ma‘ "flld- tlon and ayninistrationoinlcozmai '"l¢“"1°“' llllgal- The Balaries frugality 111 0.111011111111105. coupled 1.101.000.1101 .5111 “W,” or administer efiectively- C (111 u m tion with company law 0001111 10 Duidto their ministers of the 10-1111 the oxpoluation of every feas- further 1.0110} 01- 055151.. Edward Island feels thattl theemggfllyl: Labour Legmluon ill!" "m"! be working satisfactorily 11ml with- m1.- 1-101101111111-111011 “f8?” o-fflcmi and “he” m” “m” m "°“"“w' we ma “ow m“ "m" m“ D°"““' mo“ c“ gm t“ p111“) 1191-1111 1111a As a matter 0r r001 111 view 01 m" ‘my “d” "Elm" ‘l.’ °"°"‘l‘l" i ' i this p‘ m. ltlllllle “d m“ lllllll‘ WWW 10 the Pllllvllllfi “lllc. has ion Government for 1°“ G°vemmen e °1 =er-w This headllll h“ l" 5° Wm‘ m’ the xtremel restricted of ping Voluntary commences o‘ If? ll _ ed ptovHon made for social fl1\Vll'S been regarded as funda- Dubuc 5801,1005 011101- jurlsdiction to carry out suci .. problems of employment “Bub e y sources 10.111010111011000 0g 1110 110m 0,. ‘l-x-lmfllille‘ services are on a much lower men i in the (ltlbklfllllllililml of M. an educaflon. am_ vices. without in any Way impair-r 5mm health insurance’ hm“ of revenue enjoyed by Prince Edward 01101 50010000 1101.0 1000.111.- 1,00,, ilricmryholmlt 50.1.0 1111111 111111 prevailing 111 111101111111 11111-011011.- 111-011-0011 the 011,111.10 10 _ _____ _ 190,411. ing the fundamental principles o mbolm “Wkly N51‘ mmlmum wak Isllmd. 1t is impossible that the 1111111 101111 11 v1.10; 111 0011.11.11; .v V“ _‘ V rtors 11.1: the other _provi11:cs. Every lyimlmtm and lilu provinces. We Adah“! to these addmonnl 000111110101. autonomy, v u‘, and 00h“, kmdred toplcs_ Prince Province should give up any pres- 1011111151 0n 01105110115 0; ~ . .. .11..~-.\1n1.. cxllvnh- other provincial gormnicnt 111 ref ' to 1hc_ 1:111.- coirsidcrutioil of 5110010100 1110 111111111111; bv 0n the other hand. doubts have Edward Island has bee’ unable ent 8011MB 0f WWW"? Without 59' law, particularly with rrl ‘ V _ _ Cflllflfifl. 111; . 1nd 111111110 ~- ul norm. 11111011 1111s recently which the 1111-0111000 wlll arisen us to the technical juris- to make my expenditure on s0_ curing a fully compensating fiscal 1110 01110 01 50011111100 11 <-.1,<r.Q‘.n vlrglrovince. 1w1>11t 1cm heavy budgetary 1‘t‘C1'l\'(‘(i 11111c1ul_ rcc.u:.\11t1o1_1 in the be 1.0110100 through the diction 0t‘ the provinces to collect UM Services or this nature, and advantage from the Dominion. A 01901011 11101 11101-0 0011101.; fef- Jib-J» fiefiriis. 1;. was 111011101110 tint. memorandum 111 111145011‘. iilcd by transfer 0f 011111111 vvel- certain taxes which they now im- bumds to benefit least or any BIXEBBQUOR hi5 been made l" 5°31” result in an improved ell ..'.. Wlimwfi“ ' l"“‘.’ ‘llllllld 1W1‘- Ouirur t0 Clll“ Jll-“ll” -““'ll1"$l‘ll. "5 l‘ "all fare services to the Do- pose and to carry out certain ser- provmfl, 1... 0.1.1.1318.“ proposed quarters that the revenue derived 001110001. 0<100101,1,0110,._ - -1 1111... ihtli!‘ 1.1.11. capital (‘Xpviliililirog oi 11111 n-nort <11 the wlntc Com- _ 1,111,100 _ _ _ _ _ __ ggz,g.l1o_ “ca; 01.11101, 1,1103. 110w administer. along this “m In m" the result by the provinces from the sale of 111 1110 ~1100111- 1001s 00.1 0011,31 mission. . , -———- This Province does not regard of mm legislation wifi probably alcoholic liquors should be receiv- 1 f9‘ PlQVlfiW? necessities during the period of N‘.““"1'°“5 mmmm“ ' gr°vmmal we arrive at the total by a5 important the question whether be '1‘ financial 165s for the w,“ ed. and administered by the D0- " “llvl-"l-‘éh- cicpresion. We should, how- ?°11c"°“°°“'h"“° Md Sedismlls du-l‘ which these. various future amendments to the Cnnnd- ave“ M. Prince Edward Island lilillkm UOl/Bfn-mmt- F01‘ FEB-Will 1r" t’) fill-V 11d ever, under this heading con- m: m.“ m“ "umbu" .1‘)! yea.“ m 011811888 Will ellllble the ian constitution should be made gm ibis Pmvhlée does not desire" which will be set forth under a 111clusivc——$1 11' sicler that inability to meet (“m “m1 “llllllls “l "mlml? plfvm‘ Province of Prince Fld- 101111111 Canada 0r by the 1m‘ to 1171111 111 the way of any neces- later heading’ we believe that out of their 11.111111 revenues’ c“ “lllll-‘l. l.hc.mlllm“m' “Vfratl ward Island to balance perm 11001101110111" 50 fgng 115 the V"; flmql lenlshmon of eat n” there is considerable merit in this 1 a Sh?“ Servtifmg 0f ‘m’? public’ ‘Qlilaltméiiiilllllv? -l1|iiix.~ti1.fk‘\kv"hligii ilsbmlmmmn nmde] mm“ $605 513 machinery set up for deciding up; 110,301’ ?,{,p01.0‘§n00 we 0g ma? Plageinclel-Iflglustillregélaii m 1's ' 1 c. .1 n11 their o l1 r" " f, "_ . -. - ‘ 11c ~ — — — — -— — - - niendmens mrves amp _ _‘ _ ' . _ 1 . 11 H’ l" "W" cX111~111111111-0.~. 111k.- °'171.°.~‘.‘.‘.‘§.‘.l °.““"“""i“ ‘l".-D1"“‘m (‘ni-nnléwii" w 11 11 ‘e the Commission will -.(1’1I1Eo1§1il<ig11ar01- the 111010011011 0r f§§§,,.l§’,f(lf,§‘,‘1§f, '1'.’,,“1’§;cu€11il1 1a l?’ “d” “m” ll" °llllll°ll "mt l" W1 0f the Organize lop ‘WW MUN“ P"°"lll*'l‘5 "l" lllllllllfliilpcci 111 we fxmtn’ 3W1.“ H}? Nita v61"? "if it? 511111111010101111111001- provincial rights and provincial me Dominion of m 19TH “"5 c" ° - cannot live 11D this, 0r any Other sets oi’ Dominion-wide l 1"‘! ltrlllliPlll-fi ilv- 00111111111115 to which we Jymh sJ-Oxmmfidtul:figdcl ‘$010035? m“ blad F11“... been very rcason- viewpoints. iho subiccte menfiorietl c on oil” Dresent source o! revenue to u“ wmpames should be ‘rm H M (a Tvn1nw:‘t' MW nlludm‘ m‘ m‘ l-“lllflm fO-lmnlfdoln‘ 51p Olin-ll“ Lrfllifi-‘Plliifis "an “deed and that ii. is beyond Tilt‘ Pmblflll“ WM?“ w“ mumd undci-“i-iiidiii that ad tuuptgn fie Dominion’ without B‘ wmpensatmg Dominion jurisdiction‘ ‘ ' """" m? """".“' “"“llllllll~‘ Dmiiivn with respect $711“: 'E‘i11---11£1’1.'1-.1111 1'1 common a elbxlliifc to rovldc from Pro- i0 discuss tinder this section d0 mard_§"“.111 1%.. r1010“ f‘; ‘saf- flxlll MVEMBBB- 11081110 and effects 0f i-h 1”"! P111168 lflfl" tn the rest of Canada. a stn- wiiiqfeoflic-rhmpvliicrs‘of the Do- p?“ i syurcespthe additional rev- not lend themselves to any com- if,“ oondiuunsr“ hula‘; “fir”: (“we cuntrggf; are obvious l V‘ h” Shim‘ Gt “m”? “r illmll-llll‘! iblpira- nnnion ‘iris rcpcutcrilv muted and vmm ‘etch... to balance such a prehensive classification. it will hi’ mention m h m5 ° b g1 h‘? Validity of Certain ters o! evmluslvfi 111ml! - " ma‘ W bormw- m“ and l?“ Pl‘? “ll-lilo Wvulth e‘ub<)r1icti(l1ei'm2‘iriv 011111111 88310511 elm-cs “bl budyct probably be most convenient in ti“. inrrensc a; 1f ‘am a 65:1 ' Pfovlfldll Tl!" 1N1. and the whole (lllt-‘ilwl ll . biw- ‘ 111119 13°- mni taxable cntmcitx’ than mnst the Dominion Government Yet ransom; c g 11 1; 5 eci- to deal first with those ivcom- ' t.) '11 .d o m en res‘ “g probably not so much 11 0010x1111- :11 1.‘. 111-muss to 11 1101 011v 0; 11... 051ml. pwvnp mli1er1v1ll0 1110 110170115 cluimé from 11 W11 110 11011100 s: olurwpa mendauom 01.111011 are necessary m. he. ‘mm “Gal Sewn” ‘The various provinces of Canada tional matter as one for 00-011»:- Iuuu" l" lllP-"l" ce; of the Dominion." ‘ 1.11.11- 11. T1010 urged 11v provinces. m": .1€“€“ft 130851111; Gfivgmmefil; 10 1,110 1.1111101110111111; of our pro- mind"?! '11‘! srlemllld t‘? Fm!” l-ll have for many years been coliect- ation between the Do1ni11.011 111d *- "l l"‘lll‘l~l' 1'1"“ A comparison of the public ‘ao- there persisted tiic 111.410 conccp- gm‘ K615“ I015“ ymnnuagion 5111131111; posed minimum budget, and nfter- nnhncjnll “arifan genitals“ “m? 2h“: imz taxes under forms which have the provinces. 1i 110 11111111111- pn- counts of the three 1141111111110 tion of provinclaliiscal need. igyulubnfi 58395111“ (with the ex_ Win15 to c1001 Wm‘ 0111010 11111051115 Dominion 8 n w ° at least bordered upon invalidity ‘ "l L.°'.‘.““' mlllwes will Clearly 11111101110 1.11110 1o 11w several levllllll‘ ‘ll ‘W’ c 112111 01 11 few 1101111001 00001 01111 1000111111011110110110 scr 1.111111. - by 100.1011 01111111100111” 01- other- (a) Administration 0r Junie "-11.9059 the expenditures of- Prince Ej- fiscal need was clearly the starting sggcimauy dealt Wm.‘ by legs“, 10011500110110“ and 11,01,110 m“. wise. Some of these forms of tax-