.R1;_‘,-.:25,rr0zis.s nus ‘ ' s 1 THE CHABLOTTETOWN GUARDIAN 87,000 and 819.000, totalling $10,000 of last year's revenue, which must be taken into account. Those ltsins, on this, was‘ that $4,000 wss held over which should have been cred- lted to their year. if you will turn iiilli. llll. MBMliUiN‘ ‘ ‘“ iliiiiiEi iiPPllllliiiii lEiilllR (Continued from Pses 12) added to our ordinary lncomt/ loaves a surplus of over N00 on everything, capital accounflnclusr‘ ed, or something over 53.800, ex- cluding csp-tsl account. All you have lo do is iusk ‘the Auditor; | Mil. SAUuvIJMtS. We have a- :eudy done that and he tells us that Lila statement is just. about what l said it was, ‘iron. tut, McMlLhAN: The Auditor never said that the deficit on this years’ transactions min "oouAli/U. ‘ MR; SAJUNDERS: He said the amounts of $1.000 and $19,000 have ulwitye been dealt with an the same way. “ON, ‘DR. McMiLLAN: Does he say it is not legitimate revenue, ‘that it has not accumulated on the business transactions of the year! .tllt, J, A. MODONAMD: it is not uii "l. O. _i;." either. i vn Lin, MtL-JiLhlhN: We have bet-u charged with being poor bus- lncas inen, but at uny rate, we have put everything clearly before the up the rublic Accounts for 1020. ivlr. Speaker, you will lind on page 31: "in thq hands of collectors, vZlJW." The ‘very same item that the Leader oi.’ the Opposition com- plains about nothuvlng been col~ iected last year. 'l‘hc practice they followed in 1920 they are deploring 1111924, ' MR. SAlUNlDBRlsI Do two wrongs make a. right. , . iHlQN. DR. McMllbLAN: ‘They were both wrong, were they! lyllR. SAUNDERS: l would say so, That is no way of doing business. uhd you know it, HON. DR, McllliliLAN: l am not the collector; i am not responsible for making returns to the Govern- ment. Brill. l claim thut the Liberal Government did not lose anything on the transaction, because the szlme amount which they should have paid under their regime has been curried over now into 1924. ‘lhey cannot have it both ways. ’ihey have not got one word of complaint; it is the very samc am- cunt and it does not alter the fin~ arlclal record of either Govern- mcnt at all. But i will tell you what does ulter the record oi’ the Govern- ment; it is a fact that in their first year, when they should have col- ltcted the income Tax, they neg- lected to do so. and carried the ar- rears of that Tax over into the next year, and the Public Jiccounts show it, ii we pursued n policy like that what would huve happened‘! We would of course have come out with.u large surplus. ‘ No Vacant Schools Just ‘ii point in pilfiiilllg. J. duy or two uilcr i spoke on the liruli Ad- hiuBB i wus rcniixlded by my iriend inc 1Alll0l‘ oi the ruiliut, ivilii I'L'l- iLiFlX NIIRSEI ' ‘ \ Willing to Answer ' ' v had never. ‘lcourred ‘before, ‘but they must admit ‘that it was qoI-ym few yams ego‘ when there will discover- ed an error ln their own lPuhlilic Ac- counts of 8125.000. We ‘know that mistakes will happen, ‘tbotgh it is no‘. veny pleasant to have "them oc- cur. A mistake does not necessar- ily mcan that ‘there ‘is something wrong with ‘the finances or that the dubt ls some different total that it is represented to ‘be. For ‘instance, l hove the report of thetilzternal Auditor for 1922. At page 5 ‘on one report .it siiys: Accrued jlnteresl Dobenfurof, 810,846.08; and in the other report: 8Z0,402.07,_;_l8o,§- Mr. Spesker, if a mistake haélocotrrred, is -by no means ‘the first gime. Now about this Debt business. All one has to do is to take the statement of the Provincial Audzito . That is the only way by which u . can arrive at anything. it time ’ fps: uudlmeygdu fluflge ‘gdtlsl not do, Mr. Speaker, to bake my w: ,_"“““’_”°“' n pd“ Q l l’ staiement, or tire statement of the m“ L Acmunm yo“ Wm B” u" Loader r the opposmonrqxeoause amount of debentures we sold and he can - roduce one. ortwo or even "fhm- We rnflvflh- Noemi!“ t‘r..rt‘e different statements as he has $550900- recelpl“ l33b~l’“4' um“- l“ do“; ‘um-me on the 5.8.“, Public u ll$.l.l8 diiferent to the lfllllllt‘ Act-aunts. All one need do, is sim- “Wm-‘lll-ll "l lllY lwll- lllelllllli lllBY‘ qyiyio 18119 the 39818111,”; 0g [he would only give you the not amount Auditor. The Auditor says that the "l3! they received. ’l'lwy Wlllllll lllll deb. last year was $1,939,081. l ‘ml you they will y-tbullllv deben- do not think lhere can ‘be any mis-iturcs and received $330,000. 'l'net ol t-akv. about that. ‘ Now take Jhetourse gives the Patriot the ClllAllCa deb’.- at the end of the year 1923.,to conic- out. with u statement de- 31-714-909. ‘Illll yllll Wlll llivfl a dlf-‘cnu-ing tlmit here was u direct loss fercnce 018224.000. THAT l5 THE c‘. 510,000 on that trllneaction..—u olFFgnENcE l“ 053T 0N LAsrrllilUiii iooiieh statement, ill view oi 1,150,: l: T;‘:gafl?‘gl°"$- Tlllll PSI-tuc- iuct that ills admitted that the Now what has the ‘Leader of them“? o‘ m“: jump“) and timoécot Opposition been doing? lie llasluvhenguras a“ ye,“ w“ e a betn linking‘ another‘ slllatenlent alto- Fa": t a "us gm‘, "c: or any Fwy. “knee w ."'Y remarks in“ um“ 511b,”. He 1,3 takygimlo account re_ llllifi 9V" "li- 9- (AiJDlll-UBBJ) lllfiy were nuw ior the iirst tiiiic no vul- venues which ore due and which My ma‘ Wm!“ w” ma“? one“ m“ 5““"°l”' m“ l‘ Sumgdnem “p, ma), bewoncctablel bu, wmch “ax-iced. they hzid s-lllld libs“: jlJflll (if: puufqfll ui the Governor's Spcqch oi h“ should know’ that if "In M“ era"), are M: couectabw He is henturiel: git net! y pair ‘all; t tulle! 1.1.4.; to tile VtJry-l-iltlllc ciiecuziiiu llc had been dealt with, there would bclbaflflg m5 calculallml m‘ u“? "l" “w” {ale a on! p“ " t éflumed m“ l cunefknly Hufleulunl’ ‘ a wcmd to that effect i" the mlm pdrbliiflll that if a men is worth liltl not tcl you’ is: mole impel 1 whm w guy" Myygpoukep m,“ i ‘ I - ND m“ o’ ‘he Execumwp counc.“ and $1.“.l)00 ‘in cash, and he has $15,000 l-llll lllllE. l-lllll- l lfi '1 "ll llllfillllllell lldVvi“ nnikc u liaise stuleincilt F” PERFECTIONJRA of the bill had been considered d ' ll Jock (lebrs, he is acltuu,1ly.w.o,.lh iwlll were ‘all your debentures on knowingly, because l believe it in L- CREAM we hi", a131,. "hated, as he “y. n was’ i. woauqdfilili l)0ll0.-€lV8ll though u ‘Mtge p311 which we were llllyllllé 5MP" "l" u very poor policy on the purt oi shed a Preetlllo in Charlottc- m-ver have come before this Gov- Ofvxhtsc book debts m” be m’ goml- and the debelnuies “my 5"“ ‘my 9mm“ "mnl “s “mm” m‘ “u” wn and viicinltysnd If is ‘emmeml- Nllw, E iliut 513161119111 7P“ l“ llle Process oi’ my’ ‘hon. lllwVB lllll‘ ‘W678 lll-lfidll yelll‘ 11¢ it 1s going to be analyzed and found __ ,,,,.,.,,m._, My ha“ ‘friend does not lilcnds figuring, is i1 not? He ‘is lituturcs, on which we were pnyiugwu, “m, bmught mm“, w 1mm u“, “w °“" duw‘ t9 “m1” u‘ answer 1111.1 1 @111 ask mm flgnln. lllllllllts’ llll-l Pevfllllc due ‘und collc-ot- Jyg per cent, And they any tliut we a mun nuiy {nuke l. l-it,41[¢|11g|i[ "tit-- nd this business through- WAS THAT mLL EVER pEAL-r ‘Mu-'- lllivc lulled to conduct our ilehon- ligving 11 1., 1,851.11. wlflgh m...‘ ut the country districts, WITH sv ‘m: BELL GOVL-ZRN- M"- SAUNDERSI lam taking turc sule in the best interests 0i uihy show td-bo not quite‘ true. i ere is an opportunity for ut-of-iown merchants fo Zllidlg a produce which will ring excellent returns for Ittle trouble. . harvest. it i-s a falling owr people -have ,aild if it ‘were remedied we should have much ibetber roads. ' lgnpred B-lis of the Bell Guern- " . menf _ Theheader opens Opposition has. nigh’! went ‘back again lo the mott- tcr of the $2,000 paud by this Gov- E» erllllielrl- to Lieutenant Governor _ d llfoldinuon-anditried to justify-there- _niarks he had made last year about the lental the inference being that the SE00 ‘yeaul-y ‘rental charged was exhorhlitaut. ‘His statement ‘last you-r was that the Governor's house l‘ lvfl-s onily worth from 8250 to 8300, lll-ll We ‘Du-d at an exhonhltlim rave and moreover, he made ‘this slalemenl. ‘lust ‘the bill was dealt will‘ by the Bell ‘Government and I lll-llvll (i0Wll: that we therefore should never ‘have touched ‘it, is ‘ that correct? MIL-SAUNDERS: ‘Perfectly cor- rect. ~ - andtneditbocsnsslwsnfsd “ HON. DR. lMclyl-IIJLNN.‘ That lllllll-lllllellt is pcnfectly correct he I hsvol good results ‘skid srn bod ' Sllys, notwithstanding the fact that v the than Lieutenant Governor ssld he could never even gct an answer to his appI-cstion; notwithstanding till} fact that the Hon. Mn. Bell, in going out of office, hqldbd over ‘to lllll Government a handful of bills and d and said, ‘Here are __ things that I have left for you to deal wlth"—-and in that llot was this bill from Lieutenant Governor lltlllKlllllfifl. which was ncvcr dealt lllllll.‘ (Allow-use). ' »MR. SAUNDERJSI . with it all ‘tcglh-t. HON. Mn. McMllJlnAN: Th0 iituiisi- of llie Opposition knows, or T» Com muhulkl , 24 Ufish ‘Street, 1/ (/1 *0 4'\ 4 > ~ / loctsrsintho ‘ng. ‘You lgoxwmofhmufgl-“F Y-ou deal-t y o l 4hr“ yononosaycnoyzoworrouramwmmowomomeuoi/tomomen/mm .f')."’c‘"-:@'»l@l"c)s@’®' l “so INSIDIOUS EYE STRAIN We use this‘ adjective sd- lscdly. Sufferers from Eyfllfll" ay have perfect vision and hereforc do not suspect the rcscnco of sny eye defect- MENT AND TURNED DOWN? I evfgglllfi (iDIIlIIJlGIE. Lil. ‘rroviilce, no-lwithstanding tho may ndil thut i have submitted tig- ‘MR. SAUNDERlR: They pru- _. H ' R" llllzMll-‘LNN: Tlllll- ‘l5 fact that our debentures at l: anJ uires in thin liouuo lit-torn, showing lmllly ignored it, _ ffjbl_l'llevc‘rtl;thmg comply“; “very 'l'/~ i" V")! mllcll lWl-lel‘ billlaino that there were vacant schools in -ii‘uN on. ‘MCNPUIJLANI Like I l’ m‘ “V”? "llllel- than theirs. sold at 0' and 5V2. the Province from the year ‘IQIZ l Vlly nt-hci bill ‘they had before ‘XHLASALJNDERR. The same “suuiult wllut the saving on these down 191351 yup, 111,11 111m 51,119. Jlelll-“llllly ‘llllltl n0 lrttclrtinn u‘) n, "r “(mm ‘I083: vllilufUSl. charges will lll0€lll l0 llld nleiit has never been clinll-iitrt-il. w-lnitcvor! (Applause) ,, hob," ‘m’ VMUMmLAN: Nol ‘the Province fur twenty yours to some‘! ‘lhnt statement is furnished by 111,11 MIR‘ SAUNDF-‘llbs? ‘will! SlIOhlilIJ-une ‘is our Auditor’ "lliut is the kind oi’ burgliin We l-‘duciitionui ilepurtnicnt and il Illley ‘hay any uttuntion to a bill of‘ llama.’ SAUNDERS: Mr‘ Blanche‘ mude Among all those who tender» ciinlot be challenged because it i~: lhu‘! kind when he hull Govc-rirmcnt l ‘ffllfgye '11)“? yo" impormd new‘ ' u that waif milliion of dollars true, The year 1920 ahowitwenty he ‘ice-cream supreme, The .lllgltfginrgflcupxitloil. _ ,, ma“, '15 PQpIiIO-l were afterwards received cnewacan‘ schools; 1921, sixteen; eople want and demandwlf- iev,_l,‘;‘lll'lall lnwhjvsgiltlffksfibrovflrlnfl 31c hos book debts 10111111“ $25,000 from a great many, congratulating 19:2, four; 1923, four. I say now, as ‘ ‘ ‘~~ " V“ ‘ V‘ I f?‘ I i"; mink m‘ M" “m, “y 1° ham“, and ca” 1° knows H", cunmflo“ m, Government‘ zrnill he myg u, m“ worn, $300003. this Government upon the fine prlc l saiid before, that my hon. friends gene in“, 111p", 1hr. _, . uuj." llaivi‘ dill: ltxll.‘ izilllllhilllillll“ wlltififulidtitilmil “Inyflm MW U“ 8e"_.rhn,‘ why n I. to your “owe when M M b I ‘suppose he goes .1‘; {he Lead.” or 1s we were able to get. You hove never had an opportunity of put- 0mm. External _,\,,,ht,,,._ ‘any you won i _. . _. .. . .. ‘ . . _ i. _' 5 “an cmgwl the Opposition, am] Wong 1 g only to go out and ask the business ting into the Draft Address the 01R quipllildits" 'l‘ll‘ll doesn't with llli! l‘l'l)Vlill'.lUl Audit. iliis side oi tin. Vliilllbli. ‘ Interest w Mock m“ pm‘ nlifillillklwlrlllcwlftluk“ ltulmled lush!" 3590.000 un hi5 assets ‘lblatluioillrl-lilay "W" wlllll llley ‘llllllll 0i ll~ Ul $816019"! ill?‘ will‘ l" "l" Will's mnkelil right Jvhnr is the sense oil .\llt. SAFNlJl-IILS: i would Yllilltl MR, s.\i“N‘l)l~7ll:‘-: in u ronpii‘ ul duct. n, -1{,,,sp-mu ‘gslithinlafihfzgzgeggg Egfllflll- lrlfllld give him. that ‘loam course, so fur us my hon. friend that there were no vacant schoolilnwtitloning that’! huvc it. yell“! n“ ‘T r l" I ‘v """"l--""'-' " I‘ ' ‘ ' s . ... . ' . -. .1 ~r \ ~ ,. : '2 '1 . ..t"“~'--' GET INTO COMMUNICA‘ ‘Sick Sonnets’ and 8,1108 Um“ partly lhnqflzniun is worth 830.000. you any. from ‘buinmerside is conccrncd. In the Province. (Applause). i did HON. ll“. xh-MlLbilN. iou stud lino i lihlrpllli \l\]l_t ‘Kill y!‘ b o“ Wm Guy" um Over ha“: 1,31,1- us a Technical school. BM - ‘SAUNDERS: Thai "has who advised us to speculate. in not say that they didlit malfia the yo,,w.m|.1.ri b1‘, sutislioil inlioss }'l)ill\\'illll(‘.li an lcxii-lliui Alli‘ . ovvy .. e c I H I III-WNW) T|°N wn-H U3_ WE 3141p Itho He" ‘Govemnwnt cooly Sam w rolfjlgtyyqt nnvylhlnilf to <10 with ‘l-t. those bonds . , statement, becuuse the statement ilud the EXliivfllill‘ Audit. Now you have it and you are not satisficd (Loud ldllKlill um .11 t‘. . To AN‘ PO|NT_ _1,1,,,,1,~,,,an¢ Governor Mcmum“: it i; McMIILLAN: i know MR. McARDHUR. Spcculute? Did is right hero. in the Journals oi . . - - " - "Thor: is Gqycrnmgng Hm,” “m: u; ‘h’; gllfillmext y°ll "l"? lJnt- l soy speculate?‘ ‘I923, where they suy the schools CENTRAL 2° and take It." Why 01am they “k, ,0,“ n Y“ ll-lllltl I would non, on, McMiLLAiN: The hon. are all filled. u. the very tlllillll| ‘ ‘ , {put 11 1n a condmon m ‘m. the mm wul_th"‘éao'ogél;werell- '15 llllil member for ‘Summerside, who ad Journal you can turn to one oi‘ the! lisovernor ii' they were doing things M,“ M w , .vlsed us to speculate in bonds , . ..School inspectors repoits and ‘lind , . l" ‘ll lllllllllm like Way? l hops we .501; 5,,‘"fi‘j,{},',,,fl°", MlR. McA'R’ill~i.UiR: I say 1 didn't. this: "AT THE PRESENT ‘nun . Lnnlted. shell have heard the last of this bill. h, wan,“ t; borrow N“! "l HON. DR. McMiiIJLAN: i say he FOUR PRIMARY SCHOOLS Altifl Plwy lsnored it and we dealt with it ,,,,,,,',,, o, "m- , - °" ll" cannot deny it", (Applause) coo-son." ‘The very same Journal! CHARLOTTETOWN and cellist! ll- ll W“ ll llellllw friend OULD mm m’ "°"-1 u-n. iubuitmuu. Mr, ‘Speaker, (Applause) On the other hand, the - given to ‘us personallly ‘and directly (L8,, '11“? | HE GET W‘ a point of order i want you to give statement in this year's Speech gr); Rgilillalggfiggidivrgélfllld the bill ggnfuai|ng )1,‘ “wtgthlzc ghgrmpztt: this your-oer ous consideration. l from the Throne, to which l reiierr- ‘ W” l‘ "'3' statement fth did not sa "speculate." 'l‘hc lmnfled in the debate on the Druit Aii-. m“. Yuma o c financial condition y . . _ My mo" idem “poke about other s‘! she Plrovlnce when ygu n, m gentleman can 1gb that tword lat‘: dress, is perfectly‘ corgeclt, Tiber: bu“. Mr comm", ,1 think [HIM is u n?‘ n that statement Fdvonug llley cannot uttr. ute o me. I are now no yacan sc oo s, ant! w about the m" “Imam unymibem‘ you w l probgmy "Qyer u", Wm“, said i did say it, l say l didn tqhavg that statement fnrnis e us nwmbm. 1,1,3,“ Housemhwqd m _ has been on the book; for yosrs, and ‘when the time comes 1 willby those who know best what they “on. “they have ‘my my“ ‘at ‘:31 awmctlmcl decreasing and "n". show that gentleman the differenceiure talking about l do not know for the .1,.,,,.|nm name o; m9 B1,“ ,‘|"l‘y‘l:itll"°""lllll- We increased the between speuiiarlng and legitimate whether this ls an apology or an ex- mmlnlgurm1on, o," corona" um,‘ es’ by $224,000, and ‘we saly trading. l would like a ruling, Mr- pinnation, but it is the best explsn- ., ~‘_ have ‘to. ‘go miles out of rhetilrfivmd :3“ “Fabolllt Whlatmoney comes in Speaker, atlon l can give at the present . . . j _ ‘V’ .. 1n 11,6 Wrmrmunce o: the“. wubuc "K ‘llle years collections, lbe-i THE SPEAKER: A ruling 0n time and J hope it will satisfy the - l" duties throughout the Province; and to think that a Government would repudiate and not ‘pay-whose bills! We bad an example of that when they drove the Coroners ‘to such a course that they refused to act ‘in their official capacity, and the result. in one instance, was that the ‘body of an unfortunate laborer, the ‘victim of a fatal accident on , _ In: ‘ gilfzgiszguggtfl It’ ‘liinvlazruiow inuch what? l do not understand what Editor of the Patriot. t“ ~ lllf. I3! k ....u.....s.. t. t... tiffiii°iii "'° ."°“~ m°m';:;',,;',':r=“=~,.,, ,,,,, "y “"3" 3;,,,",;:,,,,,?,$P1; ‘ggg ‘ r.‘ the ‘Public Accounts 1 . Mlt. McAR . e . too exoep on l; expended $237 “Y “ml W9‘ member said that 1 said that the External Audit. ‘He says it is no hzig-bwnyfl‘ thaltiooo on "mpmved Government should speculate in good. He wants the Provincial of iprmqécln, w“ our 5mm m“ bonds. I never used the word specu- Alnditor brought in here, notwith- wholg grlnuch-oreveme‘ o" M" late. The hon. member should re- standing the fact that this audit flcil of 0224000" :1: h“, Md . d‘. Yacl- has been made up in the very sli-me ' ‘ ' ° "'"""“'°' " non. DR, McMILLAN: .1 have way as every External Audit, But The motive power of lbs ntiro human organism ls ‘ crvo Energy. Normal eyes, if ls computed tllizc about 20% 0| this Pllllllllllro-of titan-l ‘ crve Energy, hilt when Eye- train lls present, a much larg- r prdportlon is required. Hence defective Qyemthrvlllll heir consumption of III ex- cesslvs amount of Ncrvl Ell- crgy. may seriously affect tho luncllonln of other organs‘ ol the ho y,.snd produce Iii“ health. , ' ‘HAVE voun EYE exmulueo ' " 0. l‘. ||Il0|l0S0ll Optomotrlst ' 0-0 rofessional Cards "Donald a McPheiuB-A» . murmur.» II. I. Infill! Ilurrlntors, Attdrnoy, lie. ,v Ilullillhhzna? n. c. o unomniinn Wllll-tl‘ or it, v. lion Grails“ u n ' m _ tlo-“llls-"il ‘lpllsu sod . 1...}, . .- . Barn ,-IIIIIIII * "not doom Tblyp LOIO q "l llonIb-O h ll lfIll T001 f. h‘. u“ . ' .- \ ... UIRIHTIIK. HOI-I-‘OITOI, ITO. . i friends‘ charge against no for inst ark n. Mcfinlganyl}. 1i‘. the Marine ‘Wharf in Charlottetown, was loft therefor hours, because n0 . Coronerwould act under the Bell Government, knowing that his ‘bill would be repudiated. albout the ‘unpaid bills 9f ‘she doc- tors i-n ‘regard to the ‘Summerside Billress older of their own Attorney General. and certified ‘by h-lm. aMlR. ‘SAUNDERS: I deny that ab- solutely. , HON. on. ‘newsman; heudwrlllns is on the bills; centiflcationrls tillers. MlR. ‘SAUNDERS: "Not to ‘be op- orated on uniless 'l‘hc mwnthly physi- cilan was ln change of th eopera- lou." - IHON. DR. MoMlUIlmN: Tho At- torney Generals initials ore on the bill, and those doctors ‘had the authority of itho iAvtot-nley General to go and operate 1i! it was necessary they operated and those bills came ‘book from the ‘Bell Gov- ernment, repudiated, notwithstand- inn that the chief officer of the Crown was the man who authorized the work. ‘But we know ‘bow much hnnnony existed between the At- torney. General’: department and the iPlomierw olllico. Tho Public Accounts Oomltg ‘to o d-lgtgont ‘matter, we mllglst ooh ous de- flolt of 0810.000 which our Illbaral ‘his your. it. is very much like the lbog- us dofloit t found ‘when they cams in, ‘in l ll-tliot 8855.000. ‘In ‘both clioes it ‘has ‘been built up tin - q“). ' “"31 .4‘ in . oootlnts thithid so be mode. ‘mist I. l-Qtflbligtlilng, sail ‘because _ ‘ of collie ocou ‘all \‘\‘ ill.“ ‘diy-VY" \' the some way» You ‘have only to npltiils ‘records of che Auditor. however, to discover the actual vs- hle of those statements. ‘Bu; odlum has been thrown on the Govern- ‘ ‘moat bqslloo t! odrtaln corrections u» advance maples of the Public ‘in: l-‘hwve spoken alliresdy, ‘I think, W111, m". Wm, Jail, for. services performed at the m, conmuons His ‘ not s vsry bsd showing, M‘ ‘SAUNDERIEI: I 1 sbmild tzhihk it i . HON. DR. Mqmpuymq; Not on 116 - l.) . proved highways. ‘plus meélllgisilgf 1923- W° 1""! l0 elven in» the mt- o . ‘s .:.". .:.':..:;."::;.":s'z WO-llk as we could to ‘take ‘ilulil m1. ‘llle grant that wag 119a,. That is a ‘time state- ment of our debt as l have given tit, 10y homfrlend ‘may bringuqnhe pm. galijéalthilgggll-itor and ‘he will only ‘the ‘ ‘R. ‘SAUNDERS: I financial statement do; owls/utilises: man not take his asserts into ac- count. Diiln’t you take ltlwm last year and tionfit you always do ‘m HON. DR. MCMIIJIIAN.’ my own ‘books some 825.000. In: my hon. ‘friend give me $6,000 for ‘them find he can ‘ v9 mam (Laugh-tor). That lshlho expat-l: once of every business man, that you must discount Ilflh of m“ kind very materially. Th3! mg no; worth ‘half ‘their face vmluo in 11108! C8998. dWli. ‘ssunnsnts: The ‘Pray-In. obey were worth cial Auditor said ‘within $2.000 of the most amount, 191d us 880.000 in ——Q82,000, and he actual value. ‘HON. ‘DR. MoMILLAN: That is ‘this yea-r? ‘MR. SAUNDERS: Yes. ‘HON. DR. McMlliiiAN: wou. next year we will ‘be in s pogitjgg ‘accurate or not. way to do it. It ls only sh ostlmot not ‘take any man's statement we ore dealing with actusiilfilcts. The W9 fly ‘ti!!! the (HCICOMO ... “M. f ordlnsry [Ql/gnuml to know whether that statement l; Thad b theonly and in a case of that ‘kind d would= Leader of the Opposition ltllllllll"! llllllll- h“ '° “M” ‘w’ said we Jmd s deficit in ordinary menus and expenditure of 085,000. nothing to retract. True, you never used the word "speculate." You ad- vised the ‘Government to buy bonds and loll them to make money for tho ‘Province, and I sly that the right meshing of that ls to spec- lulate, I am not putting words into the hon. member's ‘mouth; I am In- iterpretlng his remarks In ‘ plain English, and i know that if he |were on this side of the House he would probably give that advice to, the Government, I know too that the record of the past Government bears out the supposition that they took that wdvlce, in part, 1'0!‘ ‘WROTE they had good valuable bonds in the sinking fund they decided to do something with them. 'l‘hc)’ will those bonds and sot 800d Drill“ 101‘ them. but they forgot to put them back. That ‘is the kind of speculate lng they um in bonds, and um 0m another mess we hsd to chin HP. the Deposit Slip mQs that they mt. The ‘Leader ‘of the Dorsal- tion says we were all Blllll-y l!‘ they, because Conservative govern- ments did the same thins l0 "l9 9X‘ tent of,'$7l..000. Over a period 0' ‘how nihny years he did not m: but he should have‘ ssld that tho Boll Government did‘ better than that, when lhoy"'trsdcd In thcss bonds to thrsmoullf of $140,000 In one yssr. ‘He says now that the 33mg system ‘goes on, out 1 shy N0. It is not going on now. Under form- er Conaervatzlve ‘governments there ware deposit receipts for small om- ‘ounts when it was expedient to buy bonds, but my hon. friends saw itha possibilities of that method In an election year. when the! lie: ‘plated the sinking funds and left 1_ 0,_U,'s, which we, in order to put our sinking funds on s. business to the extant of 8180.000 VIIIOII l" cums into power. I think 0116? should be ‘the lllfto talk about this year it is no good. Why’! Here sis what he objects to: The Auditor states that it ‘is his belief that the figures given are correct. ‘My hon. friend tries to decry ‘that. Why‘! He didn't tell ‘us wily. Let him turn to the audit by John H, Malcom: he will ilnd the same language used. i1 have not the least doubt that ‘if he takes the statement oi’ every External Auditor. he will find the audits made llil ln the very same way. The ones l have exam- ined show the very same langualtl! used: they have hnd to talie the statements submitted to them by the Provincial Auditor and_the var‘ loos heads oi the Departments. and upon that they make up the Extern- al Aullit. This year's audit, which was prepared and Higlwll lly Ml‘- Miles._ is just as good an ‘External Audit as has ever been made in this Province. To decry ll. l" "Y up that way, is simply ridiculous. whom or; vvo going to helluva? The ssms figures are thorn. 0W Provincial Auditor's figures veri- fied by tho Ezohslrnsl Auditor. My dross he would he satisfied with llle tor alone. MR, SAUNDERS: l would much prefer it to that. There wa some sense to that. but this lornul Audit is no mod, The man hasnt llnne into the accounts the same u! hi! would in a Bank. ll ._..,., _-___ w For Fire insurance consult IL/ilf, SIMPSON ‘m Richmond smut that any school-boy could make it ' hon. friend told us on the Draft Ad- ' statement of the ‘Pmvlllclll Aulll‘ _ HON. DR. McMILLAN: He hull - oooovooo6oo-o-oooooo-oa-wv i s Ilhono ll! 1 7 h.‘ v . nod mluoigisq ‘Sow heals -_ should be . ‘I ~ Ono m @131 (a; mm‘ ‘y; ‘flgmfl’ 1;" or statement msilqmssrlul ‘ ¢ P0011331“ v ,1!’ ‘W ___ sinusitis Bye gourNexfRof HEN you lay a roof of Bird's Asphalt TWIN Shingles you not only provide the best protection possible against fire and weather, but their permanent and attractive crushed slate colours-red, green or blue-black, will enhance the value of any building and at no greater cost than ordinary shingles. The TWIN shape, which is‘ an exclusive Bird feature, enables you to cover the roof in less time and with lcss cost than or- dinary shingles. You'll have nothing to rot, nothing to rust, nothing to paint. Write us for free booklet ‘“ A Roof flie Owner is Proud 0f. ' ' should have a copy. Evcrtyone infkrcsfcd h: Roofing Made in Canada ~ auto-s; sou, tmmao, Hamilton, our. and Pom Rouge, Que. . ‘rgnneu s. ' ‘PZWJ m‘. . .__..._.. B R ‘S s ASPHALT» will SlIINGLES FOR BALE (Ihagdlgr Charlottetown. mourAaui l