Proposed ,Bill Of Rights Said OI Unsound Concept

MONTREAL (CPI—Prime Min- ister Diet‘enbarker‘s proposed bill n‘ rights does not put the Iiber~ tics of Canadians on a secure foundation, an authority on con- stitutional law said Monday.

Only a constitutional amend- ment. s.milar to the United States bill of rights. can guarantee these liberties. said Profcsrr Frank R. Sntt of McGill University‘s tac- uIty of law.

In an address to the Canadian Club, he said the proposed bill cannot bind future Parliaments b;-ause of'the notion of parlia- mentary sovereignty.

“The instruction to the judges to interpret all tuture laws in favor of these freedoms would have to give way before aity later law that in fact clearly took away the freedoms."

FOLLOW U.S. LEAD

So long as jurisdiction over human rights is divided between the federal and provincial gov- ernments, Professor Scott said, the only sure way of guarantee- ing fundamental freedoms to N'Cl‘)'()llf‘ equally is to amend the constitution itself, as the Amerio cat‘s did with their bill of rights.

Such an amendment would con- vert the natural law concepts of freedom into fundamental con- situtional law which the courts would thereafter apply.

“Short of an amendment. all we can have are separate bills of rights for Parliament and the pro vincial legislatures," he said.

“Mr. Diefenbatker‘s bill, being in the form of a federal statute, and applying to matters within federal jurisdiction only. has the advantage of not requiring pro- vincial consent. 0n the other hand its ehfects are necessarily limited."

MERELY INSTRUCTIONS

He described the bill, insofar Is it commands anything, as "merely an instruction to judges; It tells them to interpret all fed— eral laws in a certain liberal way."

“A heavy new responsibility is thus placed upon the courts.”

The constitutional law expert said that. apart from the bill, a great constitutional change will come some time for Canada.

“‘We like to think that our na- tionhood ls cmnpiete, but from the point of View of constitutional law it is not so.

. “We are still in a pa'fitly colon- tal relationship to Britain, for we still have to return to the British source of our constitution for its major amendments." NATIONALIZE CONSTITUTION

Canada's constitution eventu- ally must be "nationalized." This country must get rid of “the m. maly called the British North

America Act" and replace it with the Cons.itution of Canada.

"A new attempt will have to he made to complete C‘t‘ed

sovereignty. however much politi- cians may shiver at the thought of calling another (:deral-provin-

' cial constitutional conference."

Backstretch

(Continued from Page 8) mancnt wave carton. a syringe and five vials of drugs. one of which was adrenalin. a powerful stimulant. '

Trainer - driver Carlton denied any knowledge of the ownership of the illegal equipment. All hors- es owned wholly. or in part. by any of the above mentioned per- sons are also under suspension:

The above is taken from “The Harness Horse" for November 5.

At Sydney Sports Center la 3 t Saturday night. Rajah Hanover, driven by G. LeLeoup, won races 1 and 4 in the Classified Trot and Pace, with Alarm Mine 2-3, Dusty Bars 6-2, times 2.20 3-5 and 2.19 4-5. Rajah is owned by the driver and was formerly owned by Myron Bell of this city. Rajah was a great favorite when he rac— ed here some years ago. .

WON THREE

Worrell Ler 'is. one of the top.

drivers in the Maritimes some

years ago, who now confines his

activities to Catpt Breton, won three of the eight dashes Satur- day nigtht. With Shining Hour he was 1-5, in races 3 and 7; Sil-

:r’s Pride (R. Wludylra) 5-1, times 2.18 4-5 and 2.17 3-5.

In races 5 and 8. Long John (W. Lewis) 1-1. Head Chief. 4-2, Elvira's Dale 2-4, times 2.21 2-5 and 2.21 3—5.

As a bit: of a compensation for his disappointment in New York when Meadow Al made a break and lost the Empire Stalke, purse $103,000, at Yonkers Raceway, Joe O’Brien flew back to Ingle- wood, Cal., and won the $75,000

American Pacing Classic with Shadow Wave. defeating B elle Acton 1.58 3-5. and other great pacers - setting up a new world’s pacing record for three - year- olds of 1.56 3-5.

BAD WEATHER

Page 14 The Guardian

and 2.14 1-5: “inning owners:

winners: Donald Ratchford. Newport. and my path (w. Carr) 1.2, Aileen:

VVcdu Nov. 12. 1958'

Dashes l and 6 v .Iol-i

Donald Grace. AIIIIQCI11>IL .\'. Statue (D. Queen» 5.1, Duke Aloft“

Race 5 . Colonel Hanst’ord Clark Smitl.l 1. Ginger Will ‘Cyril Smith) 2, Royal Budlong IBalIochI 3. five other starters. time 2.22 2-5: winner owned by Cyril Smith. Hunter River. P.E.1. Race 8 - Feather Duster (Clark Smith) 1. Mount Carroll (Bur—

-bine‘| 2. .Ioppa Maid lE. Shaw)

3. five other starters. time 2.21 3-5; winner owned by Stanley M'ayltew, Kinkora. P. E. I.

.Iollity Leigh and Peter Feder- al‘l combined to pay a Daily Doub- le of $89.00.

At Saint John Raceway Satur- day afternoon, the following were

(W. Birt) 2-3. three other start-I ers. time 2.17 2-5 and 2.17 25. Dash 2 - Leen Ben (M. Coutghlan)i 1, Lady Flame (W. Carr 2, Val- uable Doc (H. Jones) 3, Reytnib (Armstrontz) 4. four other start- ers. time 2.18 3-5. |

Fire - Auto - Casualty I Marine ‘

G. G. K. PEAKE LTD.

78 Great George St. Dial 4311 Charlottetown

Dashes 3 and 7 - Oliver Chieftother starters. ttmes 2.19 and 2.19 ing High E. Wilson) HI. Daniel Hal SCCIJ. 2.19 4-5. Dashes 4 and 8 - A. MacDonald) '4-1. Josed a 1 e‘Michael lDouble Hal v.1. 1.311th 2.2. fivclBrooke c. «w. Carr) 3.1. Flam-

Bonnie! Pizicy Lce ' other starters. times 2.14 3-3. Dash 3 _

(E Kirkpatrick) 4-". .\I, taunttlan fl-J. 1 21-1 1-3 and ‘_\

.\t_ _‘.

Gordon's TM) (W

W (‘srr‘ ‘ Ho'o Volo 'L. Que... ' Unit; 3_

\ II B.

\‘

<.I'H‘

I). Ilalt‘iciti n time 2.15 1-5.

Bad weather has hampered the

racing all over tthe Mamitimes but a good card was run oflf at Sack- ville Downs Saturday night. with Island horses winning six of the eight firsts. and Island drivers taking seven of the eight firsts, also other placings.

Here is a _brief summary: Rac- es 1 and 4 - Jollity Leigh (C. Constable) 1-2. Tribune *Clark Smith) 4-1. Eddie Hoosier (Cy- ril Smith) 2-3, Haley's Alpha (E. Haley) 3-5. four other starters, times 2.15 4-5 and 2.15 3-5; win- ning owners: Mapco Stables, Sum- merside, and Stanley Mayhe'w, Kinkora, P. E. I.

.t GROWING GIRLS

Theme— The Rural Church Servan Its People Under auspices of P. E. I. Presbytery,

The United Church of Canada

BEDEOUE UNITED CHURCH Thursday Nov. 13th Sessions at 10 A.M., 2 & 8 PM.

Morning 1: Afternoon—delegates from local congregations

Evening—open to the public Meals served by Bedequc ladies.

Races 2 and 6 - Peter Federal

(D. Constable) 1-1, Just Verdict

(Clark Smith) 3-2, Jolly Castle (E. Hailey) 2-5, Jean Clegg (J. Mathregor) 4-3, three other start- ters, times 2.15 1-5 and 2.15 1-5; Peter Federal owned by anco Stables, Summerside.

Races 3 and 7 - Wayichatmp (D. Ratchtford) 1-2, Laurel Henley (Cyril Smith) 5-1, Miss Wilma Dale (J. MacGregor) 2-4. three others starters. times 2.14 4-5

CUDMORE‘S DRY CLEANERS

120 Kent St. Phone 08

Towing Service I Day Phone 9722 Night Phone 8048 - 885!

Music by the Blue Cuts

DANCING

at the

ROLLAWAY GLUE

Thursday. Nov. 13 Dancing from 9:00 till 12:30

Admission 50c

Member D. A A.

SERVICE STATION

W000 ISLAIIII - OARIBOI FERRY SERVICE

Fall Schedule * 8—11—1—3 Oct. 20 to Nov. 30 inclusive STANDARD TIME

For daily report dial CFCY on first weather broadcast Cross early and avoid delay. No Reservations

NORTHUMBERLAND FERRIES LIMITED

Charlottetown, P. 1:. Island

TOOK WIN"

PRIZE WINNERS! WELLNER’S ANNIVERSARY SALE

2 Omstvvmd Dr. City (watch)

First:

Second: Third:

Draw By -— Mr

Mrs. Iva-n Pickering Clinton, P. E. 1. (silver tray)

Mrs. Janie McAieer

207 Water St. City (dessert set)

. Ralph Mclnnis—Henderson 8: Cudmorc

W. W. WELLNER LTD.

JEWELLERS SINCE 1868

103 Grafton St.

Dial 3788

Black Patent

i YOU WILL LIVE IN THESE ' SMART, COMFORTABLE FLATS AND CASUALsg"

Black Suede

Black and Brown Leather Grey and Beige Bucks

Slip-On and T-Strap Styles

WIDTHS AA - B . SIZES 4V: to 9 '

‘ only 3.98 and 4.98

o

MOORE & McLEOD LTD.

E CHRISTMAS CONTEST 4

NOVEMBER 12th TO DECEMBER 23rd

p

Roulette Stripe . . . . . . 5.95 Tookella Twill . . . . . . . 4.95

REMEMBER!

, A SHIRT FOR EVERY OCCASION

by "TOOKE"

Clubman, whites and fancies . . . . . . . . . . .. . . _ 3.95 Flight, whites and fancies . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4.95 Town Talk, whites, wash and wear . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5.95 Life, white . . . . . . . . . . . . ........................ 5.95 Executive, wash and wear . .. ................... 6.95 SPORT SHIRTS

SISdCO Dsoh......, :25 Drip DI'I 5.95 . aow een ..5 . . ' . Madi Gras .. . . . . . . .. 5.95 Yard Shelf Gingham ' 6'93

Sport Plaid . . . . . . . 6.9-5

Chinook Checks 7.95

BEGINNING ON THE OPENING DAY, NOVEMBER 12. AND FOR A SHORT TIME AFTER WE WILL FEATURE THE FOLLOWING TOOKE GARMENTS AT THE SPECIAL PRICES LISTED BELOW:

OPENING SPECIALS MEN’S TOOKE DRESS SHIRT (Town Talk)

Finest English broadcloth Wash-N-Wear, Mountbatten short point collar,

dual cuffs . . wear either buttoned or linked .

cuffs. Sizes 14 to 17. Regular $5.95.

SPECIAL $4.95

MEN’S TOOKE SPORT SHIRTS

Fully washable. roomy make. in a wide range of shades and patterns. San- forlzed. 1n sport plaid. yard stick, etc. Sizes S. M. L. XL. Regular 6.95

SPECIAL $4.95

THIS IS YOUR OPPORTUNITY TO PURCHASE TOP QUALITY SHIRTS, PYJAMAS, ETC. THE SAME TIME MAKE YOURSELF ELIGIBLE FOR ONE OF OUR THREE GRAND PRIZES.

FOR THAT CHRISTMAS SHIRT - PYJAMA - SPORT SHIRT FOR THE MAN IN YOUR HOUSE -- BUY T

lST PRIZE: GIFT CERTIFICATE OF $300.00 -'- VALUE -- FOR MERCHANDISE. YOUR CHOICE} 2ND PRIZE: 12 TOOKE SHIRTS -- VALUE $5.95 EACH -- TOTAL $71.40. ’ 0 3RD PRIZE: 12 TOOKE SHIRTS -- VALUE $5.95 EACH -- TOTAL $71.40.

BY ANSWERING THIS QUESTION CORRECTLY: "HOW MANY YARDS IN THE GIANT TOOKE SHIRT, NOW ON DISPLAY

IN OUR WINDOW?" A CONTEST ENTRY FORM WILL BE GIVEN WITH THE PURCHASE OF EACH TOOKE SHIRT -- SPORT SHIRT -- PYJAMAS.

. . fused collar and

, FOR THE MAN IN YOUR LIFE AT THE ABOVE SPECIAL PEI

'I‘ooke Drip Dry at .

0 Sizes A to E (36 to 46)

O Coat with collar and pocket.

available in

no...

IDEAL FOR CHRISTMAS

no...no.-.....

TOOKE PYJAMAS

Sanforized Broadcloth in Solids and Fancicx

O Pant with waistband, draw string, elastic insert.

to

Tooke Restwell at .......... ......................... .. 4.95. 5.95 6.9?

O-v-nnu

6.3.

CES AND AT

9:00 TO 5:00 P.M. FRIDAY 9:00 TO 9:00 I’..\’I. SATURDAY 9:00 TO 12:30

"YOUR FAVORITE SHOPPING CENTRE"

MON.~T'.'I‘.S 'I'IIL IIH.

.3177“

.32333211. MOORE g, MCLEOD LTD.

0-3.0» Int.

FRI DAY 0-9 : (III i‘..\I.

SATL'R DAY 9-1130