i

l 1

' » cntiillotwnrown ‘aluminum

u.

l; o! aehdivcaee ueqt-‘lnome our deer, you wlii

‘omellittiep round gray Jory jar! which come to glclllna.

- There le a touch of Orient- l n: lnthedrab color- q e eaeeoritllnere. a hint ( the Eastern ideal o! oer. ice in their ealidity. The con. an“, ginger preserved in "yr-up, has an elusive, haunt- _ nq flavor that has escaped he western manufacturer of ' eepice. v Mliieople l-ea’ ‘that the rfgeiy bullneee ix humdrum, hen a gllmpep oi’ little ings like theee can carry e to a country where the heel and progress hae not .1 ppreclabiy moved in 60 cen- uries?

STORE CLOSES 5.30

ellkiusp & Son verything ghffs Coed to

>11: his l:l:nr'z,l.- to thc (lrllrli Jury

‘ indininll-ut will ill‘. pi‘L‘!~‘flllt'(l, and ‘in llllliiiitlil llll-re is zlnotlll-r cllsn

(ind sonll- oi‘ iii"iil oi very‘ conrl l- ‘ arable lrravily.

Tlll- flirt ca:ll\. ill "lVillCil Hi1 Lordmlp llirl-l-ll-ll tilt‘ attention oi’ the iir..:::ll Jury was that of

' .,Kenul-il: W. hlcllinnon. l-llzlrlzl-ll

Will brl-a il:::,.-; null l-utcriul;

_ BEAUQY‘. b HINT FOBJfO-DAY

“flmfijgvllll out cleanse l||.: >~l.i:: With lfieile cleeneinu’ creun. lllll: flvDiy dcrwllln and you will have a "Ullllllcxilln an beautiful as a. rose. Til-ls combination b8".lllifl(‘:l wllm: fivvrl/ll-Illg elee tells. Over 500,000 d ncl-ilslluatlng girls and ‘Vfllnrn .._.-..

nntlllnc. rise. Try ti, 10.5,» H ., don't illrc it. take it haul: w

Hughes.

A man's tendency to give advice is in reverse ratio to his ability

to mind his own business.

____._

When a man is continually talk. lug about his troubles ‘ills nolgj].

burs never trouble about ill.~: talk,

/ ::lREDUCElD BY ABTHMAA-The constant strain oi‘ al-ltllnlal. brings the patient to n dreadful stale oi’ hopeless exhaustion. Early w... rillillllii ‘be illttlii‘ oi m;

J. ‘D. Kellogg's Autilula lir-nll-d; wilich acts quickly and surely Q

the air passages and brings bllrasl-d help and comfort. No llonll: “dlflfp asthma. is presen: i:l tile least dc- grce should be lvitllollt this rcnle

d)’.

the i‘l:il‘i' Jluliicle snill that till» {Jwfllmlllili list this tern: was unior-f ' tllnzltciy tolvloliiz. Four bills of who“. u“,

‘lint was trirll. will: rngllrd to| was ruvorab]

hicl: ille JUi‘_\’ liibilgl‘l“l‘li)ili. lnstl ternl, so that.‘ tlil‘ full criullnzlli docket will conlllrisc live 01:90PM‘

>!'|1¥'|"‘l.':":' l - I l l

tiiliolilifiiilllnlll l‘ l0 {lg GRAND JURY

‘sufficient to maintain a (zliusfl ml] where thc statute requires co-opur‘ atiou. ln . this pnrtlcuillr cllsn.

accused \\'iiS_iill0l\'li to

bu alone will: the child, till.‘ oppor-

tunity for committing‘ thc l.-:-i:::l-

c, and while this dolls

not go very fur. in evidence it is

an essential elnnlcnt ll: :: c

Tllc condition of tlln child illllllPiii- ntcly following the alillgl-ll girl-n... will ho cvillcnce of lii!‘ grgaiogr possible wright; and this jolncll Ill ’ lill‘. other circumstances, cxclulliu; itlll- possibility oi’ ::n_\o:lll chal- bur. lug colnuliticll thc crinlll. niillrlll. ll-vidcucl- oi a. sironr-tcl‘ kind than

Rgddin’: llrllg Store allll Flmilmiiitllc mcrc WPTlin‘ ol’ thc witness.

I nlliililvl‘ oi‘ ariiclcs. ‘lic Ti‘\'il.'\\‘ 5d lilo particulars oi‘ this case which (li‘i'lll‘l'i‘li 0:: Ocl. 15th. The mp9.- ii"‘liil5E ti. |~"u r nnli l}. Essolyv. llllrucclnupllclx oi .\il'i\'in- non in illl- l'iiit'iI"ti burglary. 1il'(' of prnciicllll- a .-'i:::il=lr natnrl‘.

Thl- foul-ill lnliicinll-nt ll ii ohargc .::‘ indliccni liafillllii nlll-gl-d to llnvl» been Cfllllllliiil-li by (ieorgo

- . Moorl- uplln liitn l\'l:lt--. ll. clliill

about llvl- _vl~::r.< old. at llurlii‘ Point lnl ihl- 23:]: oi‘ August last. Lin rclzalrll tn this lnsl: ills Loril- sh-llp poinlcll on: some points to wlllcl: ill‘ ||t'.'\‘il'l‘ii special attention t0 be drnlvu. 'l'lll~ direct cvilll-nlll is ‘girl-n by thc iittll- girl ill‘l‘.*ll‘ii who was cxnnlillcll before .\lal:i\- trutc Shaw, hnr stall-men! i)l‘ilI}: taken. ‘but. not noon until. in this illStilnl-c lhl~ nlaglstlinil- cxl-rcised the poll-l-rs l-lmicrrcd upon luagls- tratcs by the (‘rinliuzli Polio. ta hear illl- cvidl-llcl- oi children l:::ll- or tcl: your,‘ oi nlrl- not upon oath. provided ‘they llndcrstallli illr‘ lilli_\' of telling the truth. llut. wililc the law ailolv~l such silltl-lucuts to ho rcccivcd ill l-viill-ncl- ii docs Jlol. give to .<::l.-.i: n stntl-lllont ille ‘Slime wright as to one nlallc under oath nllll no court lvill l‘\‘l'i’ col:- vicl. upon ll, hul. will rl-qulro nlllt- erilll coroborotlon Or.lt5'tl‘1‘l1,~. Ex. dept. for thc llpnl-inl provlsiorl nl the stntull: no llulzl: cvilil-ucu could be nlluliticd all. ::ll. it la 0n:- Of the luany cases \\’ill‘l’l‘ ihl- ('\‘iii' once or ll slugll- \\i'.llL‘!~'F i‘l not

. V \ ‘_y , ¢ BlaluTY or 'l'lllE sum I ll lilo ::.li:l:-l:l l""i l-|‘ l~\:~r,l' won-nil.

fllllli ill .-l.:.::ll.l:.:.. ‘:.l- nl.» l...» l»: :»:-. . ‘oi...a-‘llollllllln-ll. l-.l..:.:.-..:.:...-l:...».

ill lti ll-l I \ ‘ :-:-'. or lalllllunllln. lull-a l‘ Co. m)“, » ; , l _ . .. .‘,I.:...l:.ll. awn-lull». slllllllll-r-lllillll: l _" " ‘i .\l>u: iiihlluhlli. .\:::: flilliillc" lhbl l'='i"‘l'- " llvilli" Ion illl\l‘ ii "\'l'l'l1ii\'t' power

l

D1: Case’ Wilda‘;

t wo Hundred Silverl

|“l-:- i|l_\ .\'l»ll- Yorll- lillu>l> in:- 'nil~i_v. \\'nnl lncdiuu:

l \‘-il'l- rllnrll ll: .-.l:ippl .~ 'llli‘il('1i prl-pnili ll’ pricl- not sails- “lllip ll. :::_\' lvlllcl- ill Silh- ~ ll: ii. ii . l‘\\‘l-|:l_\

E. H. RAVN ER. lHnuunl-l <llir

ilgP-lllllC-"l lul-rclgu Wlllll

After referring to the duiivs oi - the (i-rund Jury oi’ visiting til" A3)‘- iiun: and Illi'ii‘i.ll.'ll'_\', the Chil-f Jua- ltlcl: cautioned ilifi il"ill‘t‘l‘.\‘ lo kill-g: llCt‘ cl‘ nlnkhu: il l-nrcful (‘Xiillliiliiiiilll oi this in< stiiutious il: which ihl- uulllrtllnnl.‘ llcopil- llrl‘ t‘ill't‘li io:'_ Till’ inaprr- tlol: oi’ HIPS!‘ illsiiililiulw illlrl- bcl-l: Ho wcll pl-liorlnl-d by Gran-Mitt!" l0 H" “all”? iii Jurina in illl- past il:::t pvopil- gen» l-rllliy li|lill'>'iil|lill_‘-{i_\' rl-ly-upn-n thc l-x-‘lm-llieslly lhcul of a curciul sup

in mind thc lmpor

l?'l"\'i.\‘i(iil. '

it is thc linly o!’ tlll- tlrnud .l:lr_\~|i" “Mill i‘ 1"" |llii;:ill llnvn juri»li.rl.lllll to prolli ‘t iilt’ lllilllllitltllili: ‘ villcl- of iutoxil-nlin: liquors null Hum" "om till.- ilnporllltion oi such llrillili‘! ill- lll illl- i'rl:v'll:c:~.”

up, lut-h-l- lilUiil ::.l'l' illu~l llirlvos»

ulsn to look lllicr llll‘ conditions ill ihl- jail. l'::l’ol"t::::::ll-ll' civiliza-

tion cannot be l-llrrivli {My inr

willlrnll jails. Will-l: il::- population oi‘ lhc lslnud was only L600 inl-

iiirst (lovl-ruln- clllllplainrll oi‘ iho

l1i‘l‘i‘-<~‘il.\' 0i‘ n jail. nllli (il‘(‘ii|i'l‘li that without such an institution the KlYVl-Pnnlcnt oi‘ n community‘ Wu.- lull. l: shadow without substance. Ilia Lordship would not l-arl‘ tu no that far but there is no doubt. h" said. that our jail null nil l.l:.:t i.‘ lrfiilllf-Clcli with it is untnrtllllalcll‘ necessary. lint ii‘ we lean too i:l-.ll'l l.v upon thc. cnforcl-nlcllt of ihr‘ penalties oi‘ tho law lo:- advancing our iiiViiillliiilil ll. “lii not go v -r_v iar. llo fcarcll till: couunuulty la too murll lncliucd to rely upon till-

\\ l! u: ust rely upon lilo ngcuclcs of ulurlll npliit. Jalul null penitcni ill rics n re protect lvl-

agzlrncico. What ‘we llllit-i rcly uplnl

ltlle ilGlHtJfl, the schools and tlll~ illrvflS.

l liernl oi a 301mg boy coming ll]: hr flow us as l: crilllinnl,“ coniinnrd - liiiifi Lordship." llllt Wu ilavl- ilnl: till-u: in numbers. null uulvulll we llliikl‘ special provision ior then: i\\‘l‘ will have tllclu ilgain. Till‘ quvs iiiou oi‘ loolrlug alter our boys who llulvo not been properly brought up iis one that will rcnnliu in ill.~i.~i- {ant proincln until some provision in mlldc null l um going to ‘Hill kcilillullcu .~:- rrprlwlelllzlllv .~ llll‘ ihc lligill-sl i::I:-'ll;.'l-::l-- l“ t.ll» mlmlllrllll lllbli l |lil‘*"4 _l~: iii!‘ lilll‘. _('ou::i_\'. iu L'i\'i' :i:i.~‘ l::.:::l-r \:ll:: illliihllllillifl\I'|\l'i\. ;"0ll.<illl"":lloll ari loll can .:: lul-

I.\'cl l-‘lnlinc f- wlltil n i"li_\'. you: rl-l-on:l::l»:ll.|':"lus will il'l\I' ll-‘icllr. Hull int‘ (‘ollrl will scl- that lili‘) "F" [lTPSGhilHl l0 iiltk" v. ill cill: "l"! "viii ill carryiliti’ ll ‘.'\\‘.ll'Ii illl lW-vcnll-ntll oi this kind.

Bone-rill lilifllliitlll l-l-lnilllg lo lvidl‘ ulna-rill evils. thc Clrand Jilr)‘ "light think it well in rl-fcr to t.lll~:::_ lii»: Lordship, had liitlo faith. il0\l'\'.\'L'l‘. ill gcnl-rni t'lil1li4‘ll'l' F ‘nnllmnl, "I have sel-n, ::l:li you lulvl- Illcliu. that iilt‘ world's work I24 llonc ‘h? luv-u and lvonll-l: will: i‘:‘l‘l till-Ir SH“... responsibilities null their own “Um, mm. 575m, 1., q;;.,.]_l,q_ SiNlPi-Clllllillilri. so lllllcll, li:l-_v have . livll-Pverl" lillil- I‘llt'l'i£_l' to spare ll: rim- ulenmlng olhl-rsl. (iPIlPFitl cllulll-Ill- _ _.|_\._il:nt.lou~1 are usually lii‘ \'l‘i’_\' ilille pn- ‘or lli‘ nu vnlnc.

for our advance i< the churl-hlvl.

“lVo have only one cusl- ihi~

ll

if 1114i" are mattllrs fiitjllifilli,’

.:-

l‘l:l- crilicleu: ihul i-l vnllulbll‘

i important l Jllllgenluli

. f“... wglCcntluued ‘From Page 1)

(il-ueral for hlaniiobl: to -\.\' Council and reversed in

.orli lllat-Xaugllteu, delivering 1b,-

_“'liil flDi-irovni t'ro::l ‘the Judgment 1" "fir"! General for Ontario vs. ‘Attorney General for the Dominion U39“ as follows: "it .l.,- my, fliilliielclli lor the Provincial Leg- islature to pass ll ml;- vl‘ cvel: for llle ltotal ahollllul: l::' llll- liquor trailie with- ill the. lH-llillcc. provided the sub- jcl-l is lii-nil with as a matter ‘o1 i '"="¢'y local nature‘ in the Pro vlnl-c and lllc Al-t itself ls not rc- Plll-"l *1" ll: llur ac: of tile ‘Pal-ill:- mcut oi’ ifnuallll.“

. . if 1"" ‘Vi’! like it. tekt- it ban-l. l-llll uvt your name.“ at U-llot .-.ll.l.l¢.-_.. everywhere. J. G. Jamlesllyl. ljl-ll. |-;_

Al‘! “Th? l-"lil-l-illlil" nl:l:cl-li~- tilt‘. introductory recital dl-clzlriuglllat "it in expedient to Suppress liquor trallll: in Jlanitoba by prol llibltinl-t Provincial transaction; u: liquor": itilli i-iltl (liillff, Sfifiligl] 11;: oi‘ this Act, which is as follolv-l: “lili. \\'illle this Act is intended to Prvillhli, and shall prohibit. trans- actions in liquor which lake pifllffl wlloll ' within tho Province oi Man- itoba. except under}: License. n»; oillcrnrisa specially provided by liiitl cknltjaud restrict the consump- lion oi‘ liqnoravlihin thl- 1imi:.~: oi ihe PFOVEIICL‘. of Mau-iiobn. li shall is not lnleudl-ll to affect bona illle

l'l‘b\'ll::l*l»‘oi Aianltoba and n pcrson il: iulolhcr Province or in ::. iorcign country. and the pruvinillllllnlllliw .-\l'l Filiiii becoustrucd

Lord ..\i::c.\'l1::',:illl*n ihli-u coll- liuul-s: "Now. that provision is as ::::ll-1: n pm’! oi the Act us. any 0th»

empliln: iron: :l::- opr-rnxiln: of lii:- Act nil lmua lilic (TlillFilViiUiR lillunr which cnnll- llnlilil: 11>‘ l~'i‘il‘i~'. ll i< l'lll)ll’,Ii'i ll) say that llllgv nrl-

than nnyiilillg llln: is lo iH‘ found iu nuy ll-zislullol: oi L'::ll-~'.~; thc Act he l‘t)illl'.~‘ :: dl-ad lr-ltcr. it ulus: lull-r- il-l-l- lvilll ille rl-vl-uula l,::’ tlll- llonl» iuinl: \\'iili Jll-l-ulecd lralllw‘

cl-tly nl ll-::<:, will: bnslulnss opl-rn- 1il:>::.~l ili'_\'liilli lhc liluils oi illc Pro-

Soull- l‘\'i\l‘i'\.*€liiil.< iron: the ill:-

General for Ontario vs. General for Cnwarlr:

“For tilt! purpuscs oi‘ iill‘ prcsr-ut qucfitioz: i: is inlnla- tcrial lo l-uqnlrl- lvhal. those

'l‘l:l-'.<l::l»:l::l>l:l iron: the llcport nllovl: qlloicll is Liul rclllivll tl) 11.11)‘ lacloi‘ in llll- altnlll llctl-rlllluntilill

' Britinll (Tolnluhllt upon which illl‘ jlwt ul The llllaniioba Act w fll;;(|t'l' of nlcrlllv local or liri" lilo l'rl"lvi::<-l- and

ill" -\\'i- iliwuig “mu “it.” ‘but guarded challnl-l through which

prohibiiury larva. bccanlo thc. pattern lvllici: iilt‘ Legislatures oi tile othl-r i'l"\)\ill\'('l*' avrlcrlllll‘ llil-ll dl-li::ill,-l_l~ that the lllr-

dcclaration contained ill Scviiv"

sides.

hlnaiioba Act.

'vide:::—-

(3).

port from lilo Province are llcpll

Province is carried on.

.~n:-':: linnol-

part oi any liquor \\'iill'(‘ii(ill>‘i' and

A“°""°Yiio nlalll: .‘~‘i‘zil‘t'l.lt‘rl iii \‘\'l‘i‘.\‘ liii-"l Anm-"eyitlllvrcoi and of llll- llflidllirivtl ncl-tcd lili‘l'1."v\'iti.l as ho may think‘ lllt'l't‘i~'.“a'lli')' for the pllrglose |":"\‘ll|ll.'4iilill.‘t'$ Sawf-

..'..‘_

a \\'il0ll~.<.':ll\ Warr- ilOlldi‘ to :: pcrsuu ill the Province. :':: violation oi tho provisions of

the Lnlv. 'i'bl- wholl‘ siorli ‘iiliiill that. right is co-cxtensivl- only ‘lvitl: illc nvlpll. lore. seized, the .\l::gistratl* iiOiIi"

liquor ill iilt‘ wnrl-llouil- was. iilPTi“

ing that by" nirtue 0i the offcno.‘ it Wilts‘ bring ill-pt till-re :‘l:r nl: lul- ialviul purpoeli. ills IIPCiSiOIl was" nphcld by the .-\p.pl~n.l Court oi’ llrillsi: Columbia: and. "i101! llilW-i tu the Privy Council. the Judg- nll-nt was couilrlncll.

Tho essential dliicrl-llrcs h»- llvccl: tile lc;:lsi:::.iou of this l'ro~ \'il|i'(.'- and that oi’ Illuuliullu. mill

above liCCiF-illllfi Wcru based, ill ihnt they eXl1rf'-'=-l.\' ‘l"‘"\'i'l"‘| “'7 ihu Export '|‘r::do llclrplllg an rliilf"

l: was to flow. whlll- thu legislation oi this Province. wiill which lvl: [ml-e to dcnl alimnpt-s to cxtinlrll- “l, 11m l-jypgrt Tradc. Even the

lii) oi The hlzlnltoba Act and Scr- iiul: 5T oi The British Columbia

|\\'i rcpudizltlug any luicuiiun 0i‘ Iinillrillring will: the EXPO" Trill"! |is so ulodlllcll. in ihl- lorn: in wllll-ll it appears ll: Section lIiL‘ m‘ our .\c: illnt its nlcaniug l< cnrril-d into a circle and lost.

iilll i'l‘i)\'iili't‘. lo cunl-t

$0.1M: p3 ‘Mailers oi‘ nlcrl-ly local or privntl- nlltnrl- in lhc Province’ null no: on $ilb~>UGLiU1l l3 ‘Prover- .'_v null Civil lligllls ill 15:02 and Hi2! above quoirll llllvl‘ ell-tiled conclusively lllul. a. Proyia- cial iaCgillilllllfl.‘ is competent lo (‘illi ltrollibiiulgv Lcglqation is Can- lqplct "legislation llblluln:cl_l' prohi- bitinl: the liquor irnlllc Willi-ill ill‘! proyiucil, provided the subject is (l.\'li0il nrlm: out oi’ tlll- seizure >!',:ll\.‘:li with as "n. mllii"i' 0i‘ a more- l_v locnl or private nazuro ill illc Province."

’l‘llc lull-st. decision oi’ iill- Privy (‘ollucil on the Validity of l‘roviu~

adian Pacific Wine Company, Ltd.. ve. Tuley (i921, 2 AC; 417.) 'l‘lic

‘ llll- poiicl: for a iJFUiUJiI

lion .\l‘t oi liilli, i‘.

.\:::l-:llll::,-< .\.-l n]. I919. (l, U1), ']'ll|-' l" ‘his vim“. ml_rl_,-0n,, m .10....

"'l‘lll-. Prohibition .\cl" deal with ‘illl- SiliXiFCi as “n mailer of a lnnrl-ly local or private nature ll: the Province," or docs ‘it. l)? Vi?" ll... n: thc DFUTiNiODtl oi Section 52.

l.‘:l~ constitutional validity oi’ ii:-i'i~l: Columbia Statutes lul- ‘I: the plllil-l- purplmcll

Sl-cllun lii of iili! .\l‘?, llliii. ‘pvlr imam). irmuih hlblierl ll: lill" usual il‘l‘lllti the sale

oi’ liquor within lllc Province. _ l _ Sl-ciiol: ll proiliilitl-d the lu-cglqnriugh North Amerk“ m‘ “with

nulst be interpreted ill tllo light oi lilo purpose which it was intended lo serve. nlunely to evolve ollt oi the Seli-novrnlllnz tlulonlcll and. llll- urlenuizell territory it lluiloll (‘oun- lr_v with n (‘chiral (‘lovernment having cmdueive ll-gllllativa con- trol ovcr all snnljm-la of l-nlnlnllu inn-rest. leaving i0 the provincial ' . vlrlvllrlll l:l~»n legislatures ccrlnln spl-clllcll unil-

" _it‘l'i.'l and CiflHriPrl oi‘ snlljl-l-tn null urllgulllt lllll] “gent-rally nlli matters oi‘ 4i lnllrriy:

llonlilliol: Zxclulllvo Jurisdiction?

lug. lluvlllg or uivln: oi‘ liquor in

Willi

llhlnllnluil-i ‘on Page iii.

'l‘l:c tllrce leading cases oi’ 1596.

The diylljPlllillillg cousiderlliilln

upon the lilelli oi

Tho answer limo be round in The

any place other than the private dwelling huusu where ll person re-

Seeiion 57 contains provisions equivalent to Section 119 o! The

Section 1!: oi‘ the Act oi‘ 1916 as unleaded by lilo Act of 1919 pro-

"19- ill Nolllinlz- 1:: thin! Act llilal: prevent any person from having‘ liilllor for export sale in ‘his liquor warehouse, provided lHllCiI liquor warehouse and the business carri- ed on therein eouvplieu with rc- qulremeuts in nub-section (2) mcll- tloued. or from selling from such liquor warehouse lo persona in other Provinces or in fomigl: ‘Countries, or to a Vendor under ‘this Act. (liilii) but. no vmreholl-lc shall be deemed to be a liquor warehouse within the meaning oi‘ this section it the person having liquor therein has ‘iallcd to comply with the provillionil of sub-section

(Li) Tho liquor Warcllousl» il: this section mentioned shall bl- snit- nble for tho said business. and shall be so constructed and equip ped as not lo facilitate any viola» tlou of this Act. and not. coulll-cl- ed by any internal wily oi’ colu- nlunlcaliot: will: any other building or any other portion of the some building, and élhall be a wnrcrouu: or building wherein no other con:- modity or goods than liquor for ras- solli to sill-ll Vendor, and lvllc-rviu no other business than keeping or ‘selling liquor for export from iilf‘

1919. ill) livery pvrfiflll who ll'i" ims or hcrclliic-r brings to or h. - liquor ill n. liquor warehouse as ‘.. ‘this section nlentioncd shall forth- with furnish tile Commissioner will: correct written information as to thc location oi suchwarcllonse. tile amount and description of the liuuor thcrl-ll: contained. tho place frlnn lvllil-l: ::.:lll the date when a..~; brought. and its inronllcll domination. lie shall al- wit illrlillvill: iron: tiull: to time fur- ::i.~l: to the (fuuuni-ssloul-r correct lvrlil/‘ll iuillrulzlilon as to all rc- nlovnls oi‘ liquor from such liquor \\iLi'l.‘ilUUh'l‘, including the amount. liUNC-Viliiillil, liatl‘ oi rl-nlovall. and domination. ’i‘llc Colnlnlsslonclyor i“ nwlhls agent duly unlhcrrizl-d in wril- ling, shall, l‘or the purposl: oi ob- laining or cuutlrming any such iu~ ilklrnlaliou, at any iinll"ilfil'\'t_‘

fright to cuter lulu any null l

llll- cvl-lgv

trade barriers DBIWCPII the (‘alon- ics should be swept 2l\\’l\_\', so that. commerce might have an uninter- rupted course tilrouzllout the Do» uliuiun. This intention should be constantly llcpl lu nlind as a col:- troiliug ‘principle il: thc illtcrprcur tiou oi’ 'l‘l:o British North America - Act. ll was ill furtherance of this intention that the regulation 0i’ ‘Fradc and Conlnlercll was as-"iullcll to the exclusive legislative jnri» diction oi‘ tile Dominion Parlia- ment. 'l‘llo l-‘uiljcct o! thc prohibi- tlou of the liquor iraiilc is not ex- pressly assigned by The Britlsil North America Act. to eiillcr thc Domlnim: or Provincial exclusive jurisdiction. but it. was decided by thc Privy Council in Russell vi. The Queen that thc Doulluiol: i'ar- innlcut. had cxt-lnsivn jurisllil-"llll: ovc-r thc sllblccl. io cuaci pl-ollibil»

ity to legislate for till,- pool-l‘, orll~-r and good govorunlcnt oi‘ thc lion: lnioll; and by lhc Ontario, Ainui. loin: and Iilrilllsh Columbia ('u~l~-- above l‘.il('l1 it was determined tllnl

cllcl: Province in the nbsrlnrl- o: over-riding Dominion lll-gislalilol: had the oxclusivo right i0 leuidntl-

upon tho subjoc: as .1 nlllilnr {Y merely local or private nature in the Province. As lbcrn is no .<:: ~i: liunlillion legislation on llll- sub jcct. in cilcci in this Province, iii" ill-ill in l-lcar in that. respect. 'l‘hl.- conflict. that docs arise ‘is hl-tlvl-cn lllc iiouliuiol: exclusive control ovcr tho rugulalloll ol‘ 'i‘r.llll- null

limits of its exclusive jurisdiction on thc otlll-r.

it has been fouull, and llollbllc-"s was anticipated. that lilr llolninioll. ’ il: icgisiall-ng upon 0hr‘. oi‘ iis l~\' l'iil:~‘i\‘i' snbjcris. lnl-illclltally ill~ volvl-ll one or lllt)l‘t‘ subjects as .~il:ul-li i'.\l'ill.~‘i\'l‘i_\" to iili‘ Prnvlu.‘

.l.;

il-cll-li a suhjcl-i falling within liil‘ ilonliniol: jllrisllil-lloll.

’l‘llc guilliul: principle in >nl“: l-nscs cll-nrly i.~ that lll‘ii.ili'i’ Kilt‘ i)Unliilil!ll nor tho Provillcl- :::::_v i:: vadc. ihl-. ll-gisiniivl‘ I'll-id of 'ii“ otlll-r lurihlzr than is ncccssnry in orlil-r to iL‘,'-.'i$iilll* l~iil_~l-ti:'l-l_v upon Iilc principal .~'ll.iljt‘I‘l. I: l» n full ll

nml-nlal ll-lrnl principll- oi‘ lzl-ul-rnl

(.'(Ill~

nlurc- l‘ |illtl-rmrllvillldal lrndl- ill liquor

'i‘l:l- “(film-e ml- ll-ult-ll Ill!) _\]lpi'i' llllc nxlcu: liliii. it is r-ill-rlllnl

\\'ilii.ili iili} i'l‘i:»ii‘l.ll‘il.~i lrllrll l'0ll\'il'.ll‘d was ml- .~‘l'iii .2!i"i'dli\'iil.'l the l-ollslunuilon lii liilllli

dzl. lvlli l'\‘h'llil. while by properly >:l.i'l",§ll{l-l‘liilli.{ that cbnuul-l ull r-x»

proper ('llt*lOli_\' lo uudernllul- anzl lii,‘$il't)_\' lilo l-flI-ct 0i the .\I‘i. Till‘ <u.[l-_;:larll.-l thus llupuncd by Ainui iUbJ. and iriii<ll Columbia. nbnvl- (|lliJlL'l.i illnstrail: ihl- convcplilul whirl: lhl- ll-1:1.~lailll'<‘~' of iiitli" Provinl-lw hold ::~' to :l:l-. iilniln-

é bani]; null cheaply llrrllnrell. <§®©®®®©€ ®®®'%©€Yt

llnll i'tll‘l'_'il 4':'lll i)!‘ l-ouqul-rl-ll. nlnil ll-u try till‘ famous lllli llllnll-qnlllll‘ I'l‘"ll‘li\', Anvlllll- who ll-l. .~l:l:--l::-.i nil (luv lnlll all ui _ ilnulrdiulu rl-lil-i‘ givl-l: i~l iiii|lll~i llkll nlugic, ii, lnlclw hut :: IllHIIIPIIi in

holler for cm _l:~'.

of Pinrv; till-l: lllili plain szwlnllillll-li nlwnr l-vl-nll in makr ill (lllilvtvi. lii‘ y»: .~.:- l: l‘ llnriiil-li n:oi;:~~n--:_ hourv, n!‘ corn llvrup. in~lcull of ~=lluar Wrlii‘. lllllllq-r lvllv. till“! lniflurv save‘ about. EWlI-"lifiii of illl- mom-v ul~lnll v sill-lit. for conch prl-llllraiilnl-l. and ' _ n more plwifvl‘, ciYl-riivl- rl-lm-llv. lii keel-f purl

1v. imbibing anll lll-nlill-g llll- nil-m- brnncw in nil il-l- air pin-inure. Til prnrullilv lltltiflflrl 1| drv. ii--I::. cnlnsil. and won _\’\\\I will noiil-l- thc villa-nil tllln out. llnd til-n: llhnlgol-llr nlill- Elna-r. .\ ll‘:v'.~1 u~r lull ::-n:ll‘:r

rolll. null it. i-l ulall solo-ll-iill for brun- cllitls. (Ifltlnl, illlill'*ltlllil.'i“. all-i bron- cl:ia_l aflllllull.

{mil-ll rllmnllnlpl llf "\‘l\liii!“ .\ llv ‘lino otlral-t. llll: “iiwi rl-linllh‘ rl-ulcli! l

:lrl:--~l ll iii

local or privnir unlnrl- in lii" l'l‘o

thin: oiw, Qnnrllntnl-li m t lute llulillfn _ 4 Th“ Pipe; Co.’ 'll:l'l-uil:, Ont.

application that rights extra viam. .<i:::li not ‘bl: pllshl-li blgvond llL'l‘f'.~’ l eliy.

The llrl-sl-u: legislation .':i:'l‘l-:.~i llli

ilnporivd iron: illl» other l‘r:lvl:::~l.- 'l‘l:l:l is n crulsl-qllclll-l: illCltiPlliiii to iiil‘ cxl-rclsl- oi’ illc provincial riuhi

it’ it were absolulcly necessary‘ lo till- effective l).\'|:l'l‘i.‘4t‘. oi" tllcpro- viul-inl right that the export trade .:l:ll iii" transportation of liquor lill'uill:‘il the Province from n point illli-Sltii‘ lo iIlIOLilP-l‘ point. outside lllc i'l'tl\'liit‘i‘. should be absolutely prollibill-ll, n question would a . .:< yl-i unlll-lcrlllluvd by nuillorlly and \\'ilil.'il could i)!‘ conclusivlliy‘ lil-tcrnlinl-li oilli‘ by ill-r .l::dll-l.:l l'l:::::::l‘ll‘l- oi |.l:l- Prily Couurll. llut till: quc-ltiol: in that. t‘.\i.i‘i‘ll|'.' Turn: l:::.»l not Il.l‘i.\‘l‘ll in this Can't‘