" \ V‘ i " " '1 ~ .~r~'....., -~i\\’4C»L;.¢\I

. an}. ‘s... 1.. . a l > 1 .i’_. chum-infusion»:-

PAGE TWELVE THE CHARLOTTETOWN GUARDIAN

, . ». -.. . ~ 1 '- ‘ i ' , . 0 whose statements are so iusccifrate Draft QR Ill 1468181311111? ind uni-enable, You Wm 11nd (but ____ _' iny works they have to show i0

(Continued ti-oiii Page 9) The Lender or the oppeeltleiihas noiiev spent iiiiliii: their time W11‘ teiu I15 how he was the great Ap lone with borrowed ‘money 01 Mr, SAUNDERS: Li those state- ostle oi Taxation ever since 1919 11111011 W11 ﬁre 110W liiitylnl 111N119!‘ ments were all inaccurate you will I do not know when. his ides is, bul 111d 8111111115 iiunds. OomIWPQ 111111 deceive those people. it looks ins though, it ever he with the M00111 0! the 114611110801 "non. J. sAmMncDONALDt -Biit comes back to power-Look out iei "ioverninent in biilldlns 8200.000 p111 can the Government. he, criticised taxis! Listening to his speech 1i ltﬁel bridges. and not one doila dor this. Whait otlier._riepoljt ‘was struck me that my hon. iriend must 11 111111110 1110116)’ borrowed. A111

there to oner ,tliem1. . also be the author oi the Llbei-el hose are real-iv permanent work» Mr. SAUNDERS: Was the stste- campaign literature, because a 111M 01's B11 Over I116 P10111109 101118)‘ ment correct or incorrect! great deal oi his speech was pretty 1B a record m the Conservativi d-lon. J. A. MaoDONALD: It was much in line with the type-written 301191111119111- 0111' 09110511101

copied irom the records. and it stuil that the Liberal members had I 511911118 010 11111111611 about thi could not ibe taiken from anything circulated last July. Ii’ he is not: rlnount oi money 11111101090111)‘ t1" else .t0r the pilrpose,-but from the the author of it he must have resc’ l ‘3811 (1019111111911- 0119 “Y8 the oﬂicial statement oi the ‘Province. it very cilosely, indeed. 19110001110 0011i- 19 $143000. B1111 all The Summerside gentleman also The member for First Prince has other $180,000. As ‘a matter 0i criticizes the interest. paid on the related something about acontract 11101. L110)’ 11011011190 $450,000 101 short term loan, and makes a com- or under the Highway Act who Wile ‘F0011 W011i. and that does not cove. parlson not very favorable. lwould deprived oi the money deposited on t 1111- 118 t119 P1111116 Acﬁoiliiis shOW like to ask ‘if he knows that this his contract ior a long time. Ii l Mr- 3111111131011151 W9 W910 1l110t matter is ﬁxed ‘by statute, and that ivcre in his position I would be 108111110 Deﬂslnber 31. 1922. There it is in exactly the same position very backward in mentioning a W61‘? 110 rﬁiwrls isslicii t0 1111)’- as the Poll Tax. It cannot be nd- matter 0t that kind. That deposit 1923.

justed until the House meets, and wins on a short loan bearing ﬁve pei 11011- J- A. WIMIDONALD: Well. then it can be changed by an Act cent interest, and surely that wus W111 1119 110t wrrect 11D t0 1922-

oi Parliament, ii necessary. n'o great hardship. It was held ioi Th?‘ Slilﬂﬂlexlll has sllrev-dl! 115011 . . Mr. McAIVIIHUR: That's all three iiieiitiie, we 111610111. But ii iiin s tint 111s (‘overiimcnvs r011 B right. it was u hardship to hold that 0y is olem- WiLhIN-‘BDQCI to roudiDo and 6 D0116

l-lun. J. A. Mnt-DONAIJD: Yes. of money. why did the Bell Govern- rxlleilditllrs- We 1111101111)’ 01110111 course, it ls 1111 right. ‘The Lender mcnt hold all the contract money 111011115011 Iliﬂdt? t0 I118 111011110 111 what buﬂdingg will you roof lay, gm Iggtingly wcathemght

oi the Opposition speaks about the for six or seven weeks after they 11111. r1110 as soon 111s possible. - -

costs n1 the iiudltor appointed by stopped the road work and refused m“ Spnng-“your housci ham’ 53th: Bari-c“ dcarerin you‘.

the oevei~iiiiieiii. Where did he get io give it at ail? l Ulilik tiiiit is i1 The People Satisﬁed. implement shed? No matter 1

that? complete answer to his criticism. - iwhat the '01) is do“ right Lay town‘ Ask t° We 1115 “00191016 Mr. SAUNDERS: I picked It out liir. McARTIlUIi: He didn‘! hear '1‘1ic Siunlnerslde member mn-kes 1113a J ﬁ ' Th line 01' Barrett Rooﬁngs.

0i the air. There was $535 paid what you suld? 510191119110 “m1 19511901 l0 i118 '1’011| nettRoo ﬁgs‘ Hem em

last November. Mr. J. BIJANCHARDI ls the hon. glillﬁcllhﬂiil. the mariner iii ivhluhlmoﬁngs never rot or rust and ' l; Pay; r0 Find Q"; Hon. J. A. MncDONALD: My 1.1,. ti l ii- tmlkiug to me? Whut 9 iO\'t*1‘111119nt tried to collect. it. ' ' ' ‘ . . .

hon. Xrieiid ‘knows more than I do isoltlii: 11119511011? ‘T119 1190018 siilisct it to be (‘alley-pi never "qum: pamhng’ Writs and t=1111l 111111111 biiiiiliiis you

about it then. (Laughton) The HOII. .1. A. Miieoohvx-xtl) (b0101- “1 ‘mm "he A“ i” '°"°""°“~ H" AndBarrettRooﬁngs si-eﬁi-c- "'1?" '°°‘°' '°"'°°'- wiviiliiiﬂil auditing mid book-keeping are lyl: Why did not your Government 1115's that ii the people knew before; s-stant F‘ in s "ks and YW- Ibwliitsly freqbonklets giving closely allied. Tile member for return the $500 contrlictors‘ money 111E‘ bye-elections ut which the de-i re 1 . " y g p. vﬂwbl‘ ha‘ "i" W111 1111p solve Summensids makes n ibig noise iliirlng the six weeks you were in llﬂrivnlental heads 01 i119 (‘-0\'€r11-l_“m1n§ embers ianmg on a W111 10011111 Problﬂri- Drop us n about the mistakes terms nliieeiii power after yOll were ileteiiieu at iiisiit were rah-elected that the Poll‘ Barrett ‘Roof burn out harm- P0l1lli1081dﬂfbfi¢f1ritcr~ttadnyl

that department. n1‘ the Govern- the election. Can you answer it? TiiX irﬂllld b9 Collected loot ye-‘lrillgggly These tough rooﬁngs '

mcnt. For yearn back I have renl- Y0 were a liiciirbei- oi‘ that govorii- 110111 the Premier nnd ti C - . BemnPmd-ieu en mnJIinC 4 , _ jzed 11m the bookkeeping system "may sterile,- of Agncuhme 231d tixlllsigilﬂfC easy and economical to k . i, Qumhhn. m... ﬂ o! this Government is not, and has l\lr. IlILANOI-IARD: I can't he-nr 1101111 have been Oppo‘ d ..i ' ' . . I10t 119811. good enough; that we “rim; you S“): tented. In nnswer I W111 iigifilthdigi THE BARRETT COMPANY.) Limited are not. safeguarded in many res llnn. .l. A. Mni~l‘i()\'Al.ll: It's very 11 the light of the k ' l‘ ~. .. . . . . . pqqlg 13.11116 any; that these mm ronvenlol" to be deaf at “may pPOpk- no“. Mme on lanlgllgﬂgguttgzlii MONTRLII. IUKONTO wlsulrlto iT.jO}lN,N.I.‘VAhCOU\ElI nmrit/iiciti

takes xare being made and then Lilli , _. . l “"1 1051811 my sen .. “m” objection m changing the ltnorsiilf“"mzr mlsxultiiilrgbjeri for Suui- statement before ‘iiieFi-Zﬂ:¢,t.§“§,",:§l system under which they can he'll) saving tlvul ire did rn staated In Wm Ms“ "will" ""11 1111i 1111s nintlei-" made. An auditor wins necessary lulk ‘Ismail politics“ h ot-“Mn to l“ 1119 People's linnlls ut u ‘bye-ehlc. for several reasons. Irlrst. of nil, iiesi with large ‘ﬂf1"lii‘eﬂ“unted&o mm’ ' any person who remembers elec- afraid lie wus hi... ye;- s] l M“ Mr‘ ATCARTHUR? T111108 11 Sheri-l 11°“ ‘5011111015115 101 years back will He talked iluring ii y“. ‘ttcessflm 10K liriillosilion. I ill-Wm i; ' remember that the ﬁght on the the cvcnlng session tﬁtdathpart or HEWI- J. A. IirIncDONALDJ Am platforms iii connection with the lng session today and wh e ‘morn- right. lam satisﬁed. And l know‘ campaign was largely on the iin- deal with‘! ii you look tnltl d he m“ 111B ‘lillblic are sallsﬂed and nnccs. nnd our book-keeping was iirilitioe out you would 1.31.11: ‘rial; that they Wm vote now as whey

in Such a condition that the ac- nllltiiy-ﬂve per cent, m“! vnieil before. (Applause) lie has ' '

. . tl . . , _ no nor - no RUST - no mm- counts lent themselves to dliier-diill-illt be ﬁve per cent that illkul ubolli. his own mnjorliy in . em 'h‘t""1"°"“"’“" “m1 1110111111118 1110‘v\'0riil something. Thiit ls my ‘he “1""'1°“- P9111011“ that. is not

.. , 1 my H .1 _ _ . to important‘ — ~ ————-—-—-- -~ - ~ - tlon of ﬁgures. 1S0 we decidbfloiesti-mntc and l bclltve U“ kmpuﬂm" 1'11" T1 Se! a iirni oi‘ chartered occouni- is fair, He did not eviin §[f}..,‘_.““,° 1m" 1*‘ "m" a "1011 nets his major-k Hon. J. A. MacDONALI): I mu lulou Government. 'l'l:ii 11=‘lll1lllill'l

6111s t0 mukc ztn audit that would be 11K! text. but wandered nliltis l -. u-IRY 311d I am pretty sure that If the. uiitkliig u true statement from the Government engineer iaiiuii hcre iso clear, impartial and correct thiit1from the Speech in discuss Ihllyllguleoph? Ofbummersldc knew somfrccortle oi the ilepnrimeni. and l uml did not ilnd nuy _'-ll'l\i'1 nu i110 twould give o, showing that mum matters not nlenmmed at n“ "Lint the things this gentleman put would ituggcst that when the ineul- highway. This w-n i114‘ lii<t 1111111 not. lie contradicted or argued discussed very largely [he Glécuox] over on them just before the elcc- bur sins I um making n iulsc that the Provliiclul i -r iucw against. In doing thin. we umugm campaign of Inst Mmmer, Pspepim‘ tlon his majority of three wouldistutcnient ho is making a stnie- that the gravel wus l 1111101101- lt was better to g0 outside the ly his own port. in 1i; how he visit. have evapwakd‘ Xniint tllut should he relructed. od. 'I‘licsri people liuil illl'1lil1111l31‘ iPi-gviiice. A Liberal Government 9.1 the (“Harem hmmes l“ MS (‘w Mr. McARTHUR: That's the Mr. hieARTlIiLllIt: Ii it is unpar~ ty to send in s bill iii |1ll‘1il\\’l‘1"11' 111 MSW Iifruuswlck did the some lrlct. wlint he suiil to the illffeireiii 15'1"!“- 1-‘1 ii? llnnienbury i will retract it, but tho meiit for the Ollﬂlllg llllli lmullni: tiling. going l.o Quebec for a higli- People he ins-t. and how lie got his mm‘ '1' A" 31“°nON-‘\UD5 YQS- $t11t8111811t 1S illlitr 111111110- . oi this stuff. Thev soul 111 1111111 “m” "ccillliltiiilt; we considered it “b]g" majority l w“. "y this Ilrlrvcl is rather o serious com- Hon. J. A...\incl)ONALD: Imust bill on the instructions iii .\ir. W011 ﬂ R0011 thing to do iind we iiol- the; i have gag in gm, House M: 1110"" W111i 801110 liwlilr. (Lnugh- ask lliiit the lion. member retract Mn/tithur" ‘ “wed we" exiimllm- seven eesslonsand l never heard a w“) that statement. Mr. .\'icARTilUiIl: l but! .\'11\11l\1\1‘- speech made In this House com- The 6'3"‘ c°m7"“'"‘ M1‘- $PEAKER5 T119 hm‘- m°"“ 0°"- V But" om" 515W"- posed so wholly o1 petty penile; ber \\‘111'1li!\'E to retruct tliutstztts _ ineii, J, ,\_ filul)(),\',\lili_ Tliiit ls

and ilitic thin t Sh“ M has mLmmmMJ i‘ I m’ nieiii; it is iiiiiiiirlianieninri’. i1 tiiie stiiteiiieiit iii uiii i.i--i<. Tliii In °°“1“n°“°" Wm‘ n"! ""011- Wi? anything-a pig's xgﬁiglfnfiwvieg: m“ know hm mm‘ n ‘mum l” a hlr. M<'.~\R'ilHUR: I! that is the Mayor oi SIIIIIIIIPIHIUQ is .i1lill‘lly lnsve endeavored not only to got of this Hougg! Ami m; gmtpments gm“ we“ m (“Wmm “methmg ruling I make u. retraction, but i ror u. s: the pooplv m" Hllllllllﬂl“ the accounts started right, but also were m); even correcL He aya- "hm" mm‘ u might b?“ 5mm time‘ would like an explanation; 1 have gldﬂlkllﬁw 11;! much ubiiul llii-si-uu-l to devises system oi’ keeping the the“, are only two returned m1. m expmi“ h‘ The B9" (mwrwlsnnie rights in this House. boinre the election {is ll: lilllllll accounts ior the iui-ure that will be illcm employed here as door-keel)" my)’. 1m“ yea" demded t" 1"" P101111’ Hun. .l. A. IiIncDONALD: The lodny. ii they kuciv tliut i" safe and perfectly clear to the ere and n\esg(.ing(irs_ Th“ is not 5'11"‘ '3" ‘slime 01 1110 Tiiilil-Wﬂyﬂ- hon. member will huve nn oppor- be obllgcii to {my [ﬁr ili‘,= "i weenie and the members or this even any iit-r ceiit correct. Ii he 191M" ‘mmhe’ "1 “"11 “'0” “1- Lillllly to exerviﬁe his riill rliriits. later, Mrg sie.-\rtiiiir'..~ iiriiiilty House. We needed the assistance iloes not know it hc should not say ‘elm m g0 on u“, ‘wads "H" 311m‘ but lie must comply with pitrlia~ would be small indeed.

oi‘ an expert accountant to devise , mersme “M °th""1’°h“s‘ Th“ 1"‘ iiientury rules. I was merely glvv lMr, Mmvgqiiilln; i (1\*lli;l‘.ll1 n11 this scheme and that was one of llvir, MoARTHUR: I was told iby mngenuin‘ m“ made hem" 11"’ ing an oiileiul statement. Since it lnqillry into this.

“"3 “"101” i’! the 111101101‘ t0 100k the door-keepers that there were election’ betvmse ““'“'Y'~h'"i§ 111* is challenged, I am in this position. Piugivimu srriounun‘: Ynii ‘t‘§‘:‘;c%‘;fn:°1‘11~ T110 11 11111111 <11 inst two. ‘ _ 1"“? ‘*"~‘°“ "mid 6° ""11 ih-iit I will either liiive 1.0110111! uiioii shill] have u. sir. gin-Iii. A

111's not completed yet. l-ieii. .1. A. MncDONAIJD: They ,1 m‘ ’° “ “"1 “"1"? 1"" 11*“ the enii-liils lii the Department ns (ceiiiiiiiieu Oil riiini 1-11 "iillgcdliéigieig gétgiigsehigiiiititgg: wlgi be were pumng aomemmg over your i334; toegeilelcltlilog-nlcsitttziuiiuzyﬂlrgiglf; inwking false stuicmetiis. or some ' . ' i e rses. 934m, ‘meme;- wmu or "o; 1 don-l ' ' peuion else. liiowcvcr. the incl-s . i

iirmlii 12113251111; iikéﬁﬂ ::;::."~.:"“"l:'"-’ hi" 11110111111”? u: 'i';..t::'..":.'..i:i.asters:Relief Came A0" the“ discussion just now‘ and ‘lzbovévtsboailizio alt; hutoe bxfotflaig; Ivmirvgnentlon his name because he on my gvnmnmrekle suwets’ i‘ and Using TWO BOX€S '-*'r—* ici- tempted m 1'00] [lien-L “'8 did “M agﬁﬁteﬁt1n:l'atta "gfnger 01' 11115 the Muyor of Summerslile is nutll- _____ .

lend them to believe, no our I.ib- e o t e epmtmemo’ 0111-‘ m1‘ ‘he swiemem ma‘ n “m” Mrs. John Meir“ l; Very satisiitd

Public Works und represented lhut - iirnl friend. did i 1919 ti t ll - ._ . through the good niliccrs 0i the i W116i] would one: themnn $2.00i1“bonltft1l. ffgf,'ll“n‘lll§‘l"‘ilf“ indliihui we menlbcr for Summorsidc that they Wm‘ Dow's Kidney Pug

‘ e q“ ck Y- were getting the gravel from the c w”;

when thcy knew they could not M V] “n. y , sh H a n d? Th"; give ii. to them and never expect- gvnirlxenzaf“ mnglﬁgaehal: ash‘? 81:330- (ioricgltiiriicgittiorv:litt;ilr Btlggﬂtirr-uzgi! n“, aiouﬂdaunela: in guild's ' F1 gt‘ l 11 C

Miistereleiseas ton l e d’; i “'1 "“‘~".“"‘"."- , iiiviit v1 111 -1. . . - . . Kidn Pam. inits E0011 W011i 118111113011111-[100881111 refil-iri'eibAU'\'DERs' Th“ is not “m” l lmwnoN-‘mn- mm‘ iiloiﬁllnseinitli»: tiigtrgild ﬁranriyPiilioii. Que. 11111111 m" “wet a 1d; - - ll »- ' ' _ docs tliut menu? . ‘ - 1...}? ll i1‘1-' 111 i Si‘ pnzusmofioiﬂ- ﬁligitgglityghrdhztcgtge non-taillAﬁnltilg“ggggli?-m1)tsk1ﬁ M“ McAR-miu“; [g he milkmg 1)l‘iles1'(11(hdh11ly1‘d11?gﬁ traits‘: 0229:1520 ihteorshniio ‘L131; lliliul-‘ﬂi - ‘ _ ' ’ lt. as n statement oi fact’! . l I l | sill- méizhshhféiinsiehergsi 3l‘...';‘"'""I.'I." i. i- i :::::::..::"'.:":r:.-...".:“c.1122.their;sill‘: 112125.22‘ .:.'.".>. without theblister. p ht-nrd’ lt.n(Al1ll111»ii‘ili1g.l ohfdain 11110 llmnklng ‘m1? guiwmen" ‘oemmﬂy [my the 111011 101 111911‘ seivkei- ‘W951i 110111‘! 11111110 strong illlli limi- 1- Musteroie isa clean white ointment in liussliig their Tux Act my hon. m?‘ m“ "5 i" “a “ "m‘?‘“"“' °' 1111s ivaﬂ all aiiiiiirciitly enslneor- thy uiiid oi the good work ‘will? ~ uiiy 1 -

ed by the member irom ‘Summer ibeliig done by Budd's Ki<

madeofoil oimustai-dand other-home friends tried to bake credit ior ex- Mr. lvIcAlRTHUR: It is absolute- m“. m, a {we gm m n“. tow“, “,1 PM!“ are now learning U... ill].

gimpleg, It i5 [gcgmmgnded by many omitting returned soldiers. but I t] _ H doctor; andnufya Try Mustard‘. f0, their iict never contained that y u 8e and 139k Mm m ‘Emmi u‘ 11111111111)’ @101!’ 110111011 111‘511111111@1'- penance oi’ keeping the lililiivls in

l . . _ ll ..iii= "Oh, hi. n - 1111111“

$3.9m; °°'"lzs.t"e'im~ 3115.233"iifii.il‘i°i'.l'é‘l..iiiif’°' . 11ir11131111erm1111

. com m nee .bron- iivir. SAUNDERS: That is iioi 11a iiiiist have iii-em. ‘Iflﬂuencg win. ‘he’, mm m on“ to DOM! “Mm... Beec '

chm!’ ‘auhnm’ neuralgia’ mgesﬁm“ the Government! We must vote ior ping, because they know they 111110

ﬂﬂinsﬂnd iieiieeet the back and joints, “"9" °'.““"- _ h, .-. ,. , y 19mins.soreiiiiieclesbi-uieettehilhleliiii. neii. J. A. MJICDONALD! in is . 5P1 91.51"" fa"? 111i- Mennrriun- wit! tliiit iii “ '°“‘°°" “h” m” m“ rltifgéie -‘. 7 ailigigffeeﬁmgghigﬂlhgiéﬂsd%zimn certainly correct! My hon. friend tnal- Those 1173135 1011119515 the report‘! {ﬁnggﬁgxgl °§.§:f'§'.,1.‘.f§iiiiie

. m draws“ an .at ieiifiiighineaaieoliiiitig tag; govg-lr- ,wl£o hfalvie used them long} Ian. ii‘ A. net-Donuts» i am a much remade‘, mph...’ 113N198 i ; 1 v en _ _ o n- g9 g a n o mo. ng t esta emcnt, ' v t tnmmlds .7‘ L; The Multcrolc Co. Canada. Ltd; I11 r91. ti .000. Does he - D . _Mi'. McARTHILR: It is hieemet. fg"_i"tf‘ilgg‘l:hllft'f§°gff,“efu, Mini.

return. eotiih h 1 .. 911- _ ,

that?“ Thgir owl: Fbliglirdl ieyubhigha- Proved a ‘over ‘worms argon; w1l-s QutLormNhh 211311110‘: 3‘ d "o my kidneys ~ under his srrangsine t with llnlgupigm" s" y: for some

ad Docent-her IL. 191l- nd Decem- ‘ hei- a1. 1m so not t the lame eitrtliili took the wo ei the-heir, WI" 1 '5"

Than s nothhg In:

pnlnevemviunln _ W Story-HIM. wltinii 350.000 or the . 1 nrber for Bummsrsldo and‘ is. 11's" slay-nus. rliiiy hind saint storm 11s ll only 056.000 rted to Ottawa that the grave‘. iisllml me so miieh thin l 1111;’ astray in that statement he made was duly placed on the lilghsuy tﬂllﬁhilﬂli 081111 l"? sly: m,

yesterday evening. i do not know and that as a oonseq en w w re 111011!!! N111 1110- 0 W11’ lhht it is worth going on to enm- h entitled to lino iortuy xi- Qglilfﬂl hens. and l have iiet itieeu triiiilr lne the remarks or n;entioman the cost reimbursed by the Dem-led since."

'“""" ‘ "" ‘ rm am. -rwr< -. Q. “H, .. -. ......, , ., m ,1