SelffGovernment ~ In P .13- Island

(ProLDJLHarvsyintheCanadP Historical Review.) (Recent reference was made ‘n The Guardian to a monograph on “Responsible Governmt in Prince nlwaid Island: A ‘niuniph of Self‘- Gevernmeat under the Clown," by W. ROI urination. published by the University of Iowa asone of a scrim of studies in the Social sciences. In the following article in the Canadian Historical Review Prof. D. C. Harvey reviews Mr. Liv-

Eliot flour l of Qours .

BJ/lnes W. BimALD

DON'T ‘II-Y T0 REDUCE TIM- PEBATUBI IN AILMENTB

5.1m: GIIARLOTTETUWN GUARDIAN ti»... t... e. ottet-t-

3%, Of particular interest is an sppen- “u. ‘é T _V,' president-iv. cbeam a. IoLnI-e. n. P. "- Pwllelv-sl- l- "Yl" ’ )I

sisliitollfl-egtlli-L-Cfi: DiiszcllncKlfalilleua-t‘? d“ ‘t u” c“ a cwtdn N90“ Directlless, says the Oltfee Asaoclnrot Elljlltotlillfrurfk warren and u. K. Currie _ 5°“ l“ ‘mm u” pmwem o! Star, (Independent), is Mr. Ben- lior uaiiy ihiilindded llghmlsaldll: oiluiilvollliozgo ‘lair: aching Mount Everest by eir are nQfl/a oggggmqino gnu-ammo; "M '°' "u ‘n ' m" discussed. Be believes the project It is safe to say that Canada has to be feasible. The altitude of thirty u“ loW Public meu- 11 oliv- vlth o thousand feet is now no difficulty 9"”; “P“°“'Y m’ I'm"! “l” Hon. Robert Weir, Federal Minister _ diateiy to the root of any subject, u“ m“ b Omaha to modern high flying machines. miopino “my mo onoooooomo "1 Mm we‘ a“ y They can now also be constructed mo amino mo“), ond viooioooiy M m5 demdmmt and built: in hover almost stationary BBB-inst with the PPobiem. There are time-i, i "s d"‘°¢*‘“°“ ‘mm ‘h’ " ° even mild winds. It would be pos- oi course, when m. Bennett's di-' Sln-Mhy 1 take the liberty of Plovluoeo- ‘The ooeutiutuuo "W" “bio h, believe!‘ p, PM“, o m, roctuess. not to say bluntnees, has thanking you for having published It is not so very many veers loo were unsuccessful, as were previous chino moo oould boo" ‘mom one led him into difficulties. 0n the such fhii details of the resolution: since a physician after takilll $119 negotiations under the Mackenzie whole, however. his to-t-he-point adopted at the Provincial Convent- " nt/s temperature and finding King oovommooo I, woo homo “ma” m" °' ‘h’ “m” °‘ stvls must. have aided materially ion of the Canadian Legion held it Well two or three domes Ibo" inggtnh-g may, gm] pointgput m- however that a consideration oi the “"941 "d '° 111°" l P"- ia his long and successful public _,esterday at Mount Stewart. mnml- imnwmmi’ P'°'mb°d tain discrepancies which will be of ' sensor mm the plane. under career. one 0i’ the great faults of May 1 also ienthe benefit of W!“ drulmmiu“ W °°“P°"‘“"- interest to all students of Island case at the Imperial Economic Con- oomm no“ condition‘ and pro iooomoiioooi oooiorooooo in mo the mom, ooioroooi moo who “to ‘Ihils it came about that patients motor” ferenoe would achieve more sstis- iootod by thickly oooooo oioihioo past has been round in the fact not. present at the Convention make punmmd memmneter“ 1°’ ma” l-‘n studying the origin and nature factory results. That .elll>¢¢i'lii1°n whioh ho oouid diooord ot imdino may yet be fulfilled; but it is evid- oo deacon, by o moo "om one m“

PUBLIC FORUM

This eollll h open IQ the ribonseien b! correspondents of question o! inldnt. . The bherlottetewn Gnsdhn does not aecensrlly ‘endorse opinions of correspondent;

line's i. Hair Restorer

A Willi-fol! Del-lam Plllllllll which, slrollsthens and mo“? the flair. " ltwill restore

its arise-i ennfn’ M’ ‘° o All $001k!" hug o an the '5»? blmuim Ill‘ IIGIVU 0f Chg ha“ ‘no “all will producing . "oh "ll ebullient mwin of nu,

Promotes a new and mo"; for growth where Lhg hi, i. fallen and ls remarkably m. fill preventing dgniii." "u! lltoirorlo: im-aaiue n", killers. Just follow the d“, eciions carefully and you ‘iii be amazed at the results, Gd a bottle today. Pr!" 50o

sanmnav, aunvsr o. 1982

LEA DERSHIR

It cannot now be said that Pre- inler Bennett has refused to put his cards on the Imperial Conference table, or that he has placed them there face downwards. The ex- piicitness of his statement as to the tariff euacesslolls Canada is illo- pared to make to encourage recip- rocal trade with Great. Britain leaves nothing to be desired. More- over, these concesioris are greater and more far-reaching than any one had anticipated. They involve rhangcs in one-quarter of Canada's tight hundred tariff items, and,’ it is estimated, will increase by be- tween $100,000,000 and $200,000,000 Britrilrfs market for goods now im- ported into Canada from foreign tountries. If evidence were requir-

zd of Premier Bennetts sincere icsire lo promote intro-Empire trade relations, ills latest proposal should convince the most sceptical! But from the opening of the Con- ference there was never any doubt m this point. His most partisan ooiiliciil opponents concede that the Prime Minister does not use ivurds to disguise his thoughts, mid that iiic ODiIIIOXIS which govern his actions arc held with unswervlng conviction.

The fact that there would be no Imperial Economic Conference sit- Ling at Ottawa today if it were not for tile Rt. Hon. R. B. Bennett, should also bc kept in mind. If, as is hoped, the conference will be crowned with success, Canadians may iakc legitimate pride in the rcficcfion that it will have been due, in very large measure, to the brilliant leadership shown by the man whom tlicy tllcmsclvcs elected

BOLDE‘! PENSIONS

Mali Orders Given 2mm“ Attention.

THE 2 MAGS

I40 (ii-eat George Sire"

moved by his brother John. Rirther, in considering this vol- ume as a. whole, one feels that m, movement towards responsible gov eminent cannot be interpreted by, minute investigation of politico- activity in the decade of achieve merit alone. One must look b910,, the settillz of his. story. he has ad fit?‘ Fig; me period mm made many errors of fact and miss- ion. iroggfiiiiéioiay (ololxgilooggzitlt: r: fiii’.‘.“ii.‘ii'l.‘is.ii.“iiiil’iii‘f.?i “we u preach and hisbackground of. com- event's aunt“ °n the pubn" “W! parative ideas. .. but u m what i" “m”: ‘m hem!" ‘Ibilsave space. some of these er- fie “an” h° i‘ 1°“ am"- 711°"!!! rel-s may be indicated ‘as follows: if 3a.": m“ m °°°“°““° m‘ “W” 5mm “d hm“ Edward n‘ sttignobft tleielqgciolaxcgnsgtutxilotieirlxi: t .. . , sinus: Edd??? u. ‘It; uruuu- r mo pooooyoiioo Amooioooo, Scottish’ trace these inter-relations; no;- dog moiiohi mo mm immigrants, he show by any but the vszuest ref- Prlnoe Edward Island was not al- crane” to pxwprmary “mm” Mood to “any "You sooioh prop that he has considered the problem rietors; but to ninety-eight prop- N9 pmmem i‘ dam Wm‘- m” flow“, o“ o: whom were n“ any specific instance of proprieti Boom tho mono woo mooo o ooo_ influence Elven, although side bi ooooo ooiooy not m mo but m moo; side with the political despatchsi the first newspaper was not the which m’ h” Md’ “m” 9mm“ “Prince Edward Ishrld Register," of m“ “mm” “m” by t“ ’°“ ‘on boo tho "Rood American cw active proprietors oould have been “no mo wookio moowoonoor" o! seen. Likewisie, although Mr. Liv- the Island of st. John of 11m; and ‘mm’ “f” m” "m" "W" °' between that year and 1823 five oth- gfmgtfsoaoorzazo gtogootf:

to poivcr in this country.

THE BEETLE BOGEY o m “Mum ‘m P“ Y to "W" Clnrlottetcwn

Oile- NYB the Spectator, London, 5.3.31

Whatever attitude the British tho oh m2 t’ e c m“ °l the °°um7ry W° "That the Pension Act be amend-

rielcgrites at the Imperial Economic and a large crop is reported in Brit- Conferencc may take on the sub- ish Columbia. The proportion of m ‘me dam Mwntameeri- 011 "l9 lect of the removal erihe British the total supplied by the latter is “h” hmd- 1"" l 1W1’ hundred embargo against Canadian potatoes, however not larse- In "Si"! 9° mu”, journey on mot Into the

that the conferences were inclined a few remark-I of explanation re- “Mb ‘m’ "l"? “h” m‘ “ m“ of the British commonwealth. Pro- sicl: or out of sorts and had a slight . to toy with the subject, instead of guiding the resolution bearing on ' (Q591- Li i g h mtg ggd sow“; down oo bros in“ n mo oh A i com rise in temperature, would send to V088 vin as res m" "m" ‘he “mwde °’ m’ chine w the around. The shape o! present Conference at Ottawa sllc- 3...”? the Branches sent in a m” d“ m” 1°’ 5°” median” w m {fist-t “timid: Ems“ PM“ “Mme” a‘ "m" the summltoi Everest. so far as ob- coed-o the result Wlll hove been due resolution asking that the Appell ‘cinch? ‘W: i? “$.”°'§§‘v'.'.°v'n "Wmnt-“lii "Wmmmi- "u" by the Slwlwsm“ °’ m’ “m” served by teiesco hitherto, seems i" m ma" ell-lure» We think. to Court be abolished and that the ihgzwg riseoin izmpe ..nn-e n, Booth and lfrinoo Edward Island: Fa"“°’5' Pam’ m" mum‘ Cmw“ to offer sufficient space, evenness “i” b?“ “d vigorous lemmup d°°3l°n °' u” “lbw”! 5° mm‘ little ‘fever’, is simply Natures wu "*4 11° h" ‘mm! mmUlPh-l °n that there is still a determined mo mo" mooring o0 nuke ouch o fiigen hta bg lgriilizeaillloloett. On the The Resolution Committee beer- o‘ flooiino on ‘imam, m“ m, flleee, prior to his investigation of 9 . 0i>l>°51t1°ll w Bu!’ sugwwm‘ °r ‘ landing lbie. although there expétatigns no one xirzzhtlg: m‘ m mind recommendation Ne. 4 mm “m” me he“ Th” m“ u" Autumn 001mm w m’ “m, removal oi‘ the embarEo. ' °l "it “$10M” “W” lub- that within eel-tan limits-even rein- sod. or necessity. his studios in the would be little chance of a failure was due toany lack of seal, mm,“ to the Dominion qovei-ib or mo“ dooiooo ooovo oomoi__ qmggim m]; m" been hug-rim; plane itself landing or of leldolshlp or frank and above mmi, u, ygnggd-y 1“; by mg givg moi m, potion; ig pump; up g and while this may have contribut- evea- taking of! again, or of 2°“ d°’““‘ '°’“ ‘hi’ 1"" °1 the Associated Veterans Organization-B, good nzht, is showing good resist- ed to the visor oi his narrative. it CROP PROSPECTS oiokioo oo ii, omoooeo To“ midis" P111" Mini-im- decided that it would not be well anoeito the ailment. oloo hos mode for inaccuracy in __._ wonooom o r id mi to piece before the Convention this Heat, as you know. ll mo: and dotell o-od hos diminished the Rtvlewins the “Bflcumlml mu" g ‘id o u] id ‘e we“ ' w oiinwa, n, mm, p, U, i, m, w resolution asking for the pbllgh- physicians are now actually in- strength of his conclusions. tion, the Economic nnnaiisi. issued 2 V‘; <1“ wit" mew"!- cgnnn m; m. plagg o, gg-Qudgw merit of the Appeal coup, but that creasing tho tsmvoroturo of the ‘lhlsototemootlonortloulorlv true by the AxricuituralEconomicsBranch P" ‘u’ m?“ flmud° "cum" the at Plesent paralyzed body of it would be better to endorse the bi’ V5110"! m?!" 111 In 93°“ “i "Rfilwllliblo. Giivfmmellli. ill o; me Federal Dgpaftmgnt o; Am. the "l as the c vvenith o; grimy, N“. recommendation made by the o‘, to make the tissues put up such a Prnoe Edward Island, which Mr. far as the East Rvongbuir Glacier tlons with a. brain which can re- sociated Veterans. This commen- 55m m“ °ld °hr°m° “Imam m“ I-lvlosstoo h" be“ the first. i0 culture, reports that crop conditions d be driven o“; 0g flm system. gflgmpfl in g detailed manner Re- wmm“ t° b° samumy‘ Wm‘ when another suitably constructed tlliiittnfle Dfli-lglnitrorimat: n. mum‘ ebbing‘: fiiimfrlfeafinttflnih” I h" "Wm “m” “m” m’ wins. as he has 00119.01! a very 1o- thé possible exception of Quebec “wplane could easily land and cur aglain in tifils ageno); y" ‘f the resolution 0f endorsement w: “u” °‘ pfiflyah which we“ cured adewu“ 59°01'45"‘! 5Vth9Y1iY\!°1‘ who“, growth h“ been boiow ooh Dick him up to fly back to India. oo tunnoiio Today we poooooo’ but odooio¢ following an attack of malaria. mal. some lodging of grain is rc- Th‘ dwlellt oould be made in two one piece of Imperial’ machinery, As the Dominion President said Th“ gmieime PM??? $5125: oomo and o m, dismoio o, m, days. using sleeping bags and food an heilioom of the War-tile 1n.- last night no one just knows which 22x3‘; in“: £32m ootoznmo oi wosi have boon vioiiod by hoii dropped in a suitable place 0n the Peililinl War Graves Commission, a 0i’ the several bodies dealing with ouoo whon the moioxio w“ iiooiiy The preliminary osoonooe 0o the movmgoin during oiovioiu iiiohio cy cal reminder of the fate that the award of pensions is wrong. It cured by qoinino. io woo ioimo mot Tho m hi, o i in N i awaits this greatest o: the Great is known however without a doubt d g m, u. commercial apple crop issued by the should l; Imagp ii oe suizcests. mpiros’ “moss we also establish that we machinery a not working igllzoosoiiaatlent was cure 0 p Fruit Branch of the Department of e ° in l “Wtma-“ETIY an Imperial Commission for the right. Major Ropq- ggid 5,139 lggt Aiioi. oomo oimo it oooooied in Agriculture indicates a predueiion|d“°°“°"- "W" u hose on the plains living-Everyman, London. night that hefllllwlfid thot Within some pnysieinnmhat it might be equal to 90 per cent of the 1931i“ ma“ wmhwut °7 m"”t- Th‘ 5 "w d“! l “mmilnm 0! 11" the heat caused by the attack of mm British c‘ iumbio win have oieviaiors should reach thirty thous- ‘n33’ gefilwsmlii’; 22W???" ""14 b9 lPilllillioli by the Govern- paralysis that cured the paralysis lorsc crop estimated to be 25 per and m" ab°v° m’ PM“ “d n’ found giving vigorous battle to ti: tllzililtilétohlilgqfit 1Q? exnnwfi 1e mThisther i‘: ptrozefilatiarflblsi true and direct to Ev r t, th d , ' ° l" oono ooovo mot oi o yo“ on Nova pockets 9 68 us avoi ing air Noioi secessionist; within his South tions of this commission would be so safer methods of creating heat Scotia reports production equal to ' African Party. Prom being a vlgor- followed. ‘ in the system are now being used, 8o poi. ooni oi i931, while oniofli, The Felt Idvalltlge of the flight ous and resourceful foe of the Em- Atachcd hereto is Riecommenda- not only for cases of paralysis, but will be 64 per cent of last year. The 131:“ t" u llwulltoioeerlnc ex- ozhiioorlllllioélsttlloe; iconic-soon: ticoi No. i above referred to. for 0138c"? l: lilifilimliilm °l‘ lion reach the summit is that "no up o ers. a I am. Sir, tc, "m" in " a‘ 5- total crop is estimated to be 3.411.000 Everest is so i“ to d! Lo o oonoroi rooun o! British ad_ summon moo tho high frequency‘ 91mg”. barrels as compared with 3,793,052 c e In 3-919 ioisi oi ' ioboiu “no m ho m ra on. convention noooioiiom static or radio wave g . in 193i. 3 m“ m‘ “we” t“ 0'1"‘ commiiioo which is asyet cumbersome and ex- The beach crop in miter-re is es- "4 “m” “m!” ti" “View” pooslve- Hot bot!"- Wllioll ml? l” timated to be B per cent below 193i cg’: “orb u“ mwmam md 09m- 3“: ijzgzgeegeomvi l" t e motor port of their feat m - live in should, in the bgqgdesr, od oo u to provide that mo o i i raise the temperature .of the pat- sense, seek earnestly the be5tih1g pension Appeal Court and the mtg] atihglalzle? vlltsd gifted-qt’; mtg; of having noted the significant fad m?“ and culiivuie ulcltwusly o Pension mbunain be combined in- y that in was and 1m ctl ei K ood results; Severe headaches start the forum of the popular "5" V Yi taste responsive to what makes life do one Court, the present Chair- Eimoot oiwoyo ooooi. “in. ihooo hoi oouoo" but during tho “m, “my the local assembly had passed twi

i. i, ,0 be hoped they w,“ oooo, pears, Ontario will have a. 1s per W“ °f Tibet. with enormous lm- worth while. not w "h" "M" "i man to be the head of the Court, who to o m. it irevenlle acts, which, by putting in i ioos oiosod viewpoint mo“ is oo cent larger output than in 193i. The Pmmmts 8nd I Oflfllvoll 0f one ma" imd 5411mm The silrdid ‘idesiand to permanently reside in Otta- no boot method oi, iii-um; is by w." o‘ 1 ‘ppmn c“ p w“ PTWWd-l 11190 tho 111N148 0f the 8W"

_ - duo or me an y, be a; d_ _ the tool of factf used by Patter- narentinacommellt byospolresman Elms“ c°mmbia ‘m’? 15 “umawd mm mm’ The “hm “cent o’ eratioll igxrllxdil-iint Cfwlnlileid (awillAbeglg-iw" “d ha“ the direction o’ the ‘fliiithem? ‘ “wtfimy “ 3mm“! 80B- Flllllllll. lIld-Dtobi-Troe. alikei m); d? (ti: 3113:: iii-tiara; its:

. i _m the mountain from their bqgg 1g g whole Court and to provide for an h tigg o1 the body u’ the Empire Farmers‘ Pony new.“ 87 P" “m” °' 1”‘ m" m" capable of facing facts. But there ’ ‘m’ m” ‘ ° “°‘ ' 101‘ their own ends‘ the petitions a i, m, ‘billing Canada. According to thcvNova scum‘ where this amp is not mum‘ o: some ‘even an‘ Dunn: Mm!!!“ Division cumming o! the without injuring or burning the and plans 0f the assembly were not reipiafaattiilsuzieiliflvebflusaeeiznttrhge act:

is all the difference in the world oanadian Press, this gentleman ‘oi maim- importance’ the production this time they are dependent on between a plain record (ranged miccgitiim: if“: two melt?“ o‘ t2: 5km‘ . o ‘id in oii_ “flfllmbd b! the Rdvernment in rooooioo. omi mo; during this in. . "this ear i estimated to be 54 per the weather which th c rm t the service of objective true 1 c we mam r5 to He“ is Nlmms ‘N’ Iiondon" but were examined, dls- ' ' ipczlklilg on behalf of the English Y 5 ‘ e’ “ ° h “d chooses! every three montl-is- the menu. if kept within safe limits. terval, the British aovemmqnt hail cent of 1931. Plums will be more ’°1‘°¢3-"- xebjeubem“ “mung up M mud blance of the Court ot be divided ' - fined’ modmw’ ma’ “mam”: more than once discussed the P0!" plentiful than a. year ago. The task of even descending mi iooidlzgilayed spairetulbi’; spgldfiilnto Trial 'I‘ribunai.s and. to sit at gzitoiozatoofizffono did dm.enxfubtufi 51mm’ °r plum! "ummthao If: Present mdimtwm “e that‘ the Even“ “m” landing ‘m the mm‘ should be overlooked. 8° much “m” “d place‘ u m“ be Feet Fortune law allowing the tenant farmers t0 31th:: llrghxtsof tifeee ‘facts Ontario grape crop will be Iorsor m“ by Bllplene would require enor-I _ i “dfled- m u" "mt °1 the “m” ' my m, ind m fg.gonabla ggnngyl 1am Groom action in moo woo ooi ma“ a ye” as” “M m“ pwvmce m“ power‘ o’ mdwmce" n 1° T!“ Um“ “d” °"“‘° °"‘ “"2: ignnppetcaikhbemg very l"? the orthopedic mm“ n“ m] m‘ M“ 1mm“ °“'°"°d " l" the logical outcome ofotwenty fivl produces the bulk 0f the supply. deubtiui if the feat would add 011g the War enormously aggrandize loo: $22M “s: sxywzomg; fortunes by studylni: fest lnmohl- oqmpfllln‘ m. proprietors to sell you, nggoflgflflflfl and, therefore Prospects are for reduced BCNBB- iOto to scientific knowledge. But igvlngosuppned the Allies illrilulhiof any two members or ‘the Court caghbrtttn ttliligtkcaxisudetioznliethargy ma” h?“ to tmtuvurzenbtltwig w” neither Mnfchmveluan m’ m e5 (if “mam”? “inner” "m" ‘m’ “yum” m‘ i" Owll like has al- priog. rigiofmsfihgt meliiogwntmlwith s. Judge as Chairman such and feels of imagination m: ti: 3:66 no ‘in o mo“ ii sighted‘ to ooi . - Y Wile c ' ‘ . o r exampes o Both the power of e purse mgh‘ The acreage °I mutm w!" “ercmw " mwerml imlna‘ hands of the rest of the world, plltiJudge to be co-opted a‘ provided m“: we‘ ma‘ In! "at mun may be noted that William Cooper, the question of land tenure weli planted in i932 ig placed at 543,100 tion, and what greater thrill re- up fences about their nmrketg, mg bY "dot-ills loslollttioo in cooo of temperament. mo.“ nomioo mi Mo,“ mm. viioi oiommi, m flip Island's his- os oompulod with 553.925 ill 1931- "W"! llllfilrporienccd than to be let the cash come in—and it came. “ram”! of iabsence of any womb“ m“ "ch" me“ ‘haoiuxjeczh’: can appear simPly as Ooopol‘. torv: and, until their influence rel- The report emphasizes partlc- the first to stand upon the world-o F01‘ ten years all went like a fairy o ofhhoe 3:: be o glljktzcroggc; not: on” s ‘Ihornton, and Dimes-n: that Des- ggivg so the pollflcfl and personal ularly the need of strict attention highmi; summit? Below the victor me’ and m“ "l9 diseases of a _ ' i brisay is written as Dee Bressy. elements in the strusiile has been oi i 0d‘ ‘or or this H oii-ioiion oiviiizoiion boom to difference in salaries among mern The bigger the feet. the prett er mom" Hum nwiimd or" u woiohooi and moioooodi tho onion, to the prepare on o go expot would extend two ooiood in ibis boo oi piomio Io hers doing the same work might ap- the woman. T. H. mound. mo mo n Ion‘ choooooor of ooooonoioio oovommooi market and close study of the dis- thousand miles ofgiant mountains- time o oooniro ioooy more duo pear to create some difficulty. It worm io moiiod with mo orioinoi in Prinoo Edward Ioiond oonngg be I trlbuilm of supplies. the Rleot rouse of the Himala a serouslv disor nlzed or on l‘ m" h°w°"'- “m m‘ “mm which was Y 8o . e which Inngwooth ammdment revealed. that bounds India on the north like "time 1w “bit to cope with its b‘ ‘“'°‘°°d- Th‘ Fmnm“ h‘ q“°*". o huoo n“ and Show“; beyond own disorganization?‘ n iooio io_ tioriodwere appointed for a specific to the east and west: one hundred deed no menace from Outside’ but p" ' M a ‘puma sum‘ and

members of the visiting party, said fl6 had seen evidence 0f the Col~ aracio beetle in Canada, that the pcst must be guarded against in England and that for this reason lie would do his utmost "to move the National Farmers Union of England to object to the import of potatoes from Canada under any Empire trade scheme."

Since practically the whole op- position to the importation of Can- adian potatoes into England comes from the Natonal Farmers Union, it should not be difficult to per- suade them that a continuation of the embargo would. be desirable!