If It's Good For The island The Guardian Is For It

WEATHER

Overcast; rain, snowflurries by evening: southeast winds 25, gusts 40, shifting to west. High-low 55-50. Sunday: cloudy.

Wine finoiridlinn

“Covers Prince Edward Island Like The Dew”

CHARLOTTETOWN, CANADA, SATURDAY, NOVEMBER 30, 1963.

Authorised In Second Class Hall I! the

Paul Dfllu at putau h nah.

’voi.. LXXVI. N0. 310

Department. Ottawa. ml for payment

14 PAGES

All 118 On TCA Plane Killeclln Quebec Crash‘

‘ DC-8 Bound

.. ....... ... For Toronto

is out to disarm Christmas I stockings this year.

Nmmggw SEVEN CENTS

COMMUNIQUIE ISSUED

Talks Reach Agreement

{WOMEN FROWN JON TOY GUNS

OTTAWA (CP)—The four-day -federal - provincial conference ended today with agreement on a $10 increase-—to a maximum $75 a month—in jointly-financed programs of old-age assistance

press conference following thelthe total revenue of all govern- adjournment of the sessions, .ments is “miles apart" from -first on fiscal arrangements ‘; the total expenditures to which since he form his minority they are committed. Changes in federal government last April. ‘ithe existing tax-sharing struc-

Meanwhile, Mr. Pearson indl- ture would be mere “juggiing."

Mrs. C. 'M. MacPliersoii. head of the 5.000-member Vow, told the Canadian Council of Education Friday that Christmas is a time for

i . . . The organization is al- By TED BLACKMAN fmti‘ 3- ‘ihuge red ban. n ' O tempting to stamp out pro- STE’ THERESE DE BLAIN O "'l‘l1: nlani: acniia shed just [ duction and sales of toy ‘VILLE. Que. rCPJ—A Trans- about right “‘,ay 8””; that" ‘ “'°3P°“5- ‘Canada Air Lines DC-8 jetf She Said_ '

l“crashed and b u r n e d Friday might, killing 11_8 persons in the izggfithfigfififr m Canadmn av" lste. Therese police. said the

1 The giant foupengmed jethcrashfounded "like an atomic ;.plane slammed into the ground b‘

Constable Noel Aiibertin of the

h k t’ ll °°S_°" S‘°“5 3"“ ""’5°""“ ‘ “I thought it was the end at

to eed as 59 " ‘‘ ‘‘°'s°‘‘‘°‘ aged ‘° ‘lthe woi-id. . . . Idon‘t

rated it may take some time- Mr. Pearson said he agreed and of blindness and disability

' - I N ‘ . ‘.at 6:32 p.m. EST. four minutes ANXIOIIS relatives await the Douglas DC-6 jet airliner miles north of Montreal with hlioiigh he attizciied no‘ time i a hard look has to be taken at‘ ;after taking off

She draws the at

The first to reach the scene, .

I

l

1

line i !

l

l

. .m. . word at Town“, Imemauon. mat crashed Friday night 111 passengers aboard and a allowances. mit—to get “new ap-ifiscal relations. Uftimately. he water pistols. although she ifrom Montreal Internationali‘.’°‘ seemg the ‘’‘a‘‘‘’ 3‘ a‘‘' l crew of seven, - - , n - - - i - .. - . i . . . . Just heard the loud crash. I ran ‘I Airport of relatives aboard near Ste. Therese about 20 (CF _ The increase would bring the iproach’ in fiscalrelations thatgwould like find a better confessed her own children Airport in heavy rain and lim- to the Scene I _ . an cw” Wirephotol which was . .

maximum payments, all of them

he is aiming for and basis.“ What was needed was geared to means tests, in line ‘

‘ played with them. sought especially :.by Premier 5 something m ore enduring-

ited visibility.

.see was a mass of fire." ..I l

.—...:___....__j. ' h ' , with this fall's $10 boost to_$75 Manning of Alberta. seniorssome a rr a n ge m e nt that o talI;:eatEi‘fleirifl::p‘a);ts511€d[[).[ll'll]ell)I‘fll; Ivivmskne“ hhere were n° "“" . in universal old-age pensions statesman at theconference. }wouidn't be changed every onejpar minutes before the disagten The'.IlC‘A'Cmgh wag believed ;

paid by Ottawa to all aged 70 Mr. Manning, .who.has beenior two years. i

. . . . hed into an area made to be the second worst single.

and Over» at federal - provincial confer-i e said the desired clement‘ . eras . - - - - ° - ° . However there was no aizree- ences since 1940. told reporters: ‘is “flexible permanency." A 5::/‘;“‘3‘:‘y Hghwg; 1‘1‘°";’:g°l:i'n llizlatne ’cr:‘.:h.l lg‘ clvll gviaitlgf r m ment on when the increase , i However. Mr. earson said lm_ess“,ay leading tn the Lam.e‘n_l ‘Su:‘g5'th 3‘? Qt "°.°°"1 51" i would take effect. A conference SAME QUIBBLIJNG ‘the federal Liberal government. ‘ca 6 “"5 Smg 9'9 ‘me

tian Mountains resort area disaster was the crash of I -three miles north of this com- chartered Air France munity and about 20 miles north of Montreal.

FRIDAY. Nov. 29. 196

NDP and Conservative members complained about TCA president Gordon McGre-

communique said there was "a range of opinions“ among prov- inces on when the increase can start.

By THE CANADIAN PRESS ‘ "M "115 ¢°“‘f°1.‘€11¢.€ 1-here W35 ' couldn't be expected to do much 3 i the usual qulbbllng about in this field before it hears POW [0 C01 0-D 3 Die not biglfrom the royal commission on enough to satisfy ,1; the anpe. itaxation. He said it may be a

jetliner at torly Field in Paris which killed 3130 persons June 3. 1962.

New Tax Formula By 3-1

- - - l . - . - , When the disaster area wast TCA said there was no ques-

...5.2.“:..“l::‘;:::2.*’.:ar::..°“: or messw-mmenw ll";.‘" °.:.'":i:...““‘:i:.*‘.”u.:;:.- :‘::::..:..:':t"'"e"* '° floodlishls ; or he no

, ‘ . - » -- . ' ‘ .. . . ‘ _ . . ' 0. he C,-ash_ nor was ere any con rma ion

By DAL WARRING-roN “But we recognize me dmh has never seen so much hath ifederal Treasury $18,000,000 a_sa'jI;1hem Solfia: Creillt Paemhelufhhproaufih would_l}i1e a difficult gegntte ;.Vlinifster Vllellyer a5):§l:;‘:lahdui;: raeftgih ahge werehof an explosion before the m.

OTTAWA ICP)-—The four At- cuity of working out such a many at a federal-provincial year’ ‘ 9 359 PTO em 3 ng accomplis. ‘- an _xe;na Af airs ilinister strewn Over an area at least fated plane hh the gmmd_

lantic premiers left the federal- formula. However, I hope the lconference. CITES AGREEMENT i Mam“ ‘ ended ,0“ queries .1, mile Squa_,.e_ Bits OLNORMAL TAKEOFF

provincial conference Friday federal government will try: Shaw also testified to The communique said there about Canadas stand on Wreckage and t0I'S0S Were‘ “Ta“°°fi appeared L“ be “°"‘

giving a 3 to 1 verdict in favor seriously to do it." l“t.he good reeling of friendliness NATO "Se "‘ “‘°"““ arms" ‘caught in trees and in low-lyinz lma‘-" 5P°‘“’-Small Said in

of Prime Minister Pearson's new formula for sharing tax i-evenue\ with th provinces. Liberal Premier Robichaud of New _Brunswi_ck . was almost

NDP Leader Douglas said the government broke an elec- tion pledge in its latest tax- sharing formula offered to the provinces.

Guy Mai-coux (SC—Quebec- Montmorencyl and Creditisie Leader Caouette backed Pre-

3 Premier Smallwood said hei lcontinued on page 2, col. 1‘ _brush covering the muck)! Scene. .M°""°a‘- “T“°1'° W33 "0 C05‘

TCA officials and Quebec pro-J-'_-ct by the company with the vincial police officers at the i8l1‘Cl”3fi_ all-9!‘ takeoff- disaster site said they did not‘. "It ‘l153PPeaF9d ‘mm 511’ "8' expect no he able to bring bodies ;dar screen and ‘ has been out until morning because of the l°5t3b1‘5h,9d t“3i_ ti‘? Crash °¢' mire. Bulldozers were cutting a i¢“”“~’d “V9 0): 5”‘ m‘““t°5 3"“ tough road into the area. §l3k€°“

I I I was agreement that the two‘ levels of government should ‘i 1 improve methods for “close and ! continuing consultation."

lS week's fiscal discussions:. will resume at a ne ssio i I

w se ' ii . of t-he conference early next year. Premier Lesage invited} W n the conference to meet in Que- I bec City.

Mislecl, Scisk. Premier Declares Of Proposals

foundland euloglzed Mr. Pear-

;on_ conservative premier Stan. B ALAN D . ‘ mier Lesagt-.'s stand for a big- ‘ Allan Be_rthiaumc._ 21. son of he” said the formula 01-fem 0.1% Aw A (CP)(£‘C‘:_l.';:i‘;%;:1 by ifigfigdflghggnsigflfifal rg:£’§l1:' A Study of pmgrams____such as i ger share of taxes. h‘LIKE ATOMIC BOMB’ .MtS.“B€rthlallm‘P'. said he heard -‘substantial asajitancell to some provi no i a] premier: formulas . m g’ 1:” S 3‘ hospital insurance and wc;_t-are h_ M(')NTl-'tEAL_t.CP) ‘— Follow-‘Baxter. 29, Toronto . S State Secretary Pickersglll Eyewitnesses SPORE Of heal'- lthe“ swooshing sound of the Nova scout mounted Friday against the fed_ other provinces and‘ do doth; 1,1ans__wm he carried out at the _‘lllfl is the official list of pas-3 Purser James E. Zirnls. 24.3 appealed without success for 1ng_a tremendous eXiplf_)SI0l'l“8'!1d‘»]ei. before it hit the ground and. con”;-nafivhe P3-emjef Shaw em‘ govemmenvs new tax Plan for EC ‘ 3 official ievei in preparation for lsengers and crew memberslToronto._ I ‘ prompt passage of a bill to 8661112 3. red ball Of fire-—1lke_‘,«.e,XPl<3ded Sendlllzfl huge 5814 of .of Prince Edward Island was undo; which the p,Wh,ces...wm» ' . \ . .~. ~’. . . . the. Que -conference_ in limited in‘ the TCA DC-8-crasii: I stewardess’ Lorna Jean Wal-' cover the government’: De- all atomic bom . one 5 -1 fire lntofhe all‘. e lone dissenter. He BOBICHAUD PLEASE!) study also will ’ C E '

include the main ‘

was I Capt. Jack D. Snider, 47, Tor-‘ onto

lh

"frustrated and discouraged because his province did not do as well as some others.

He contended that the island’: $5.56 per-capita boost in 1964-65 equalization payments is too little and New Erunswick’s of $8.95 is too much. Nova Scotia's lestignate is? $7.50 and Newfound- an ’

. fore or as the giant four-engined i _ Most of the industry depart, jet hit the ground.‘ _ i rst to reach the scene and "I men;-5 1963,54 spending esthi Mrs. Aime Berthiaume, living Ilsaw that the earth plowed up mates were approved at the [in one ‘of a row of ‘houses which-by the plane had fallen back night Sitting. lin_e Highway 11 in the’area. onto it. _ MONDAY Dec 2 sa she was in her kitchen,l ‘All.I could see was a hit of

The Corhmoné meets at 2.30 "when I heard a terrible explo- l the tail. The rest was burning." p.m. EST to continue debate

on an interim supply bill. The

K S t t Prominent N.B. Engineer Rm “av I eria e mee s at 8 p.m. ' . _ ‘ l ‘ Was One Of Crash Victims

cember expenses

share —unequally — increased federal payments of $87,448,000 nex year.

“This conference and country has been misled," CCF _ _ _ _ . , ‘ Premier Woodrow Lloyd of Sas- equalization and death-tax pro-lP“"“° M"“5”~" Pears” "‘ 3‘

In C Wkussianslind Glass

But New Brunswiclds Prem- gtstcal arhahfiementsi between Lo ' R b‘ h d id; " ’ 8W3 an e prov nces. , .

this :;?fhp]yu‘:hrh‘i’e:f fghghtefifil. This was hhe main new de.i~ First Officer Harry J. Dyck,i ‘ That was his reaction to tiiolvelopment reported Friday by.35- T°’°“‘° I

Second Officer Edward B.

dngton, 21, gary. I Stewardess Kathlee Patrlctai‘ Ore’ too, 23. Veteran. Alta. I Stewardess Linda Slaght, 22, Tor to

on . g PASSENGERS: f T. Butcher. 800 Lakeshore« Drive. Dorval. Que. N. Tomingans. 18 Thirteenth; Ave. Roxboro, Que. D. O. Turnbull,

provincial conference‘: tinallphovincial conference Thursday‘ day_ .night by Prime Minister Pear-l Conservative Premier Waiter 33”‘ i It

Shaw

- - of Prince Edward Is1and.l . _ _

in to .. lP'oi‘ce Veteran ‘um .53” ‘the ‘ast.s“8“ be “me keel’ a“°”‘°" engagemenh i°‘d ‘the ‘conference sa in he w Ave London Ont‘ ‘ . but m this case ,3 seems mag reporters he had protested thew d_ _ tlhng b 83 I D-- S H - - 101 Mt ' u" -_ A k SAINT JOHN, N.B. (CP) —- Mr. Turnhull. a former may- thc last shall be laster." small increase for his province IhY°1'y ;58PP0lll 6! ectause "V S‘- St "’$l,°h"ma“' om e ' iKl eC r WOT One of Canada's best known con- or of nearby Rothesay. had been

The estimated hmem 4599‘ _ an said mereh; rplrov ncet can expecf in “I .1311 i. t ~h d°’“f5-be ~ ‘ .sulting engineers. 13.0. Turnbull.‘ closely accosiated with air tra- llext Year's eqllalilailoll P8¥- «hasn't been proper considera-i noeah Fans t bl £03‘ H e ‘IS a "no ‘ en com- HALIFAX i(_,Pt _ A, 49-yeal‘-l of Saint John, was one of the. vel all his life. ments to the Atlantic provinces non of its fiscal nee.-]5_ lfimggof lfglicaccfpia ° 5 “ ’, peed 3 press "“°' i°,‘d Veteran 0‘ W’, Halifax 90; victims of Friday's TCA crash‘ A son of the . . _W.R. is $15,131,000. with Nova otiii Mannobais Premiel‘ Duff 30”" P“"°°p Edwzidv cfsland has‘ WINNIPEG tCPi__A federali mass beer homes would be -1-—-—-———-———"*' lice _depari_menl died here F“-, at Ste. Therese de Blainville,‘ Turnbull who was _internai.ional- 3°““‘3 ‘5'742'°°°' New mun“ lin described the new federal‘asked the federal overnment °“‘°‘3‘ 53“‘ Fr‘day R“5s‘a“‘ca“g‘" up and fragments sem‘ADB Piannln day immedlately an-er “E was ' 9119- The Crash. shortly after, ly famous l.n aviation engineer- wick $5,558,000, Newfoundlan tax deal for me provinces as E") raise 8 uahzationg a menu inspectors have‘ found giassithrnugh the cargo_ l 9 struck by a cor Wlllle he W35 the plane left Montreal Interna-i ing as the inventor of the var- m“2’°°° "““ Rm’ $599'°°°‘ "3 Short-Sighted and lll'f°l‘tlm- by basins them on thepp‘<‘er£ap- fragments in Canadian whmivurir TO EAT ‘2-DO)’ Meeting du‘Cet)crilsri§blt;aI¥(]l§’. lennex a mem “W31 airport’ claimed “8 “Vii” ‘ il;“)lle'pitchdp'ropifi1l1qI§CIx[; ‘Tull:

- - n - - . . . . ' ‘ - - ' ‘ 1

i1;X'l‘REMELY HAPPY’ age distolrtiotn of i‘li1€fPI‘lnC1lPle|lla direct tax yield in the. top ::e1‘1'lSe‘:'ivi;’tYUSnei\‘I:‘l1 frelghters to; The contaminated gram. re. HALIFAX (CPHA two-day; her Mme force for 21yea1_S‘waS§ofMh.e ::1.l;lilrl‘Jglel:‘inV;a?n safitllfilgm 3". S;ic0nsa=.ri{;0r‘idn W; H Mr:'w}§;‘;fkh§lf(‘,’°;‘;f(‘,‘_’ ..}‘f.‘§"’{.;e' 3eai“i§;a,',:':,v‘.‘i.‘Lesa:“ or €55 ffi‘{§.‘L‘;°o5}e,§.r,°i‘.:‘°,;‘;§e"t‘h':,‘fi,"°:,; Frank Hamilton, chief com.i-ported unfit for iiumai_i con- closed meeting of the Atlantic‘ hit by 3 cal 3* the 00"“ 0" Canada and served as president‘ Born in Rothesa.vln1905 he

be“ formuh V" devised Premier w A C Bennett of me top two provinces missioner of the Board of Grain i sumption, is part of a 3:00. Development Board will open‘. 399011 Street and QUlllP00l R0314 of the Canadian Council of Pro- attended Rothesay Collegiate e . . . -

. .. . . c ‘ ' ' ‘d s ' t.‘000 purchase made by Russia here Monda ', chairman Ian? at the helflhi the SUDPEF h0lfl' fessional Engineers in 1959. e School. Bishop Ridley School at .. "°“"mb“t° we f‘“"“f';‘3‘ 7°’ B“t‘5“ .C°“‘mb‘a 53"‘ the new hhM‘;xS‘;fYd aggowjgufihtam nah‘: ie‘ii;‘§"‘§i‘°§‘.f.i..5piais,?i‘ clgimsovtllfeiin September. MacKeigan znnounced Friday. ‘Valli? l‘“5‘l- The accldenl ll-"ID" headed his own consulting firm,‘ St. Catharines. 0nt.. and was '°“‘°" °f ttl“‘l’d°°“‘.‘ttl"yl“ mud :x's‘:“‘;“‘ga ‘°r};‘;g‘aQu‘§be‘:“_aa:lt& mg base‘? hmadehgd ‘zoyzifvel. wheat was "littered" with‘, Mr_ Hamilton confirmed 3 Mr. MacKeigan said a state-V llelled W'l_lhlll 3 bl0€k Ofhls llomei D.O. Turubull and Associates.‘ graduated. from Royal Military h sum ‘’ "‘ ° W hf“) °. ‘tpe ,1 ‘e -d th t -other revenue sources beside, glass. .1\/iontreai report that Canadian ment may be released following i In the CILVS West elld- _ l n two occasions he served as; College with an engineering di- allies "L“°§udau"nb'3$‘§r' E£':t :‘(:ur:i!mu8:3si)€8aSl!i.ensi.misn'tad income taxes death duties and “We were absolutely fl0ored‘a"d Russia" Officials 3” dis‘ '1‘“°5“ay'5 5°S5‘°“' ‘bCfi"s‘ab}° “°§“.°" ‘S S“""“'°“i P"°5‘d°“‘ °‘ ‘‘‘° A55°°““‘°“ °‘} "‘°"“" ‘“ " f