The Paper That covers Prince Edward Island

Like the Dow i v .__.._

gnartottatown Ouardlan. Three Conn, Morning Guardian, Founded 1801. Evening Guardian, 153p .

lhfsfs. lliggs, Duffy and The Patriot

sin-It is not to be gain:-

Id. 1 take it that Messrs i-liggs and Duffy ave cut a ratlter H011‘)? 11121111‘ in their first session in the Legislature. ‘Not to speak of tlte pernicious tax act, the great privilege or the dpy- light snvittg law was denied its by the government although there was m, good ground for refusing this boon which has been roadily granted to other (Yanadittn cities. I

These gentlemen have certainly proved themselves to be unprofit- able Servants. fit only to be consigned to "outer tlnrkttess."

They ltavc completely failed to tucasure up to the l'Ci]l]l{‘(1n]:.“l5 o! strong influential and independent roptwtsottttttivos.

That they have been badly fuolod by the Boll Govornntotti is plain ottouglt. _ I

A tltrottt itttontittn of in; it out to tax citizens real estate for provincial purposes. Tltis ltluff.

was tutulc without the lcast (‘arty ‘with thc speakershil) thrown itt. did its work anti Messrs liiggs and puffy arc irltippctl ittto line and made to swallow thc obnoxious tax act.

lt was tho. employment of the 01d ticvicc resorted to itt tho caso nl t-ltiltlroti of sugar coating thc bittot" plll—tho odious tax ntottsttrtl which our representatives gitlpotl tlown with scarccly a tnurtttur.

_.\ grout opportunity rsattte to tltost- gentientett to make un ltonour- ublo namo for thotusclvcs but they fuilctl- t0 risoatn tlto occasion.

Tin-y ltavc, by betraying the trust roposeti itt them, altaudouotl thc interests oi’ their (tottstltuottts to the ltoltiticttl wolves and lturpios cottr‘ posing tho Bell government.

\\'itlt souls ltam strung by a narrow and stunted llilftlziillrthij) thcy ltavr» piacotl tltotttslolvos itt the category of sutnll mon, thorc to rotunitt iorovor.

To show tho uttor usolossuoss of those mon us rcprtisotittttivos oi’ tho city road Mr. lligg‘s spccch on tho. Tax liill roportotl in Wotlncs- day's Patriot and then <l‘ocitlo whctlterltvc would ttul, as citizens, ltavo. fztrotl as woil if not bottcr had Charlottetown boon unroproscnlotl in

thc Logislatttrtt? i ' llo says: “'l‘ho citizotts roulizt- tltnt it is nocossary t-lterc should bo an incroaso of ‘taxation but thcy want [0 focl‘ tltnt tho taxi-s will be equitably "and fairly cxltotttletl.” _ llo is quite willing tltnt tho govwrtttttcttt should collect anti bag all thc ittcotne tux. llo ltas tto objection to thc govorntttont gotting and cxpontllttg on thc roads all tho auto tax. it is right enough. he says, that the farmot- should not pay ono cont of ittcotttt- tax frotn the profits of ltisfnrtttttl tho- Saint: 11100 1101115 A 1L is tho propor thing for a town storo koopor to be tatmtpollotl to pay d; the province ‘(O-gwylg-Qhehpieilils of n» omcihiaslnoserv» ‘lie shows his ignorance, or desire to ntisrepresont. wbcn ho states tltnt. under the old income act the farmer ‘had to pay und that tho now act docs nway with that. I I it is all right, lto cotttetttls. to exempt a tfurtner who obtains ztn lnconto front his fttrtn oven as high as $5.000 a year out of which lie pointed out. tlte furtttot‘ can put by each year $2.000 allowing hint tho liberal amount of $3.000 for living oxpottsos. ‘ in tho face oi’ all this ho itttltilgcs in a ltypocritical whino itt ho- ltali of tho poor town utan. ‘llo winds up his tlisctttirso with tho pitlublo roqttcst “'l'r_v 1.‘: llo as lair and equitable us you can!" Was thore over such a weak, wobblitig tlolivorztnctl utatlo ltofoto any logislativo body? .\'o tnan ovor yct imbued with such a cravcmspirit ovor accom- plislu-tl anything for his God, his country, his follow tttan, or ltlutsolf. Tho writot- of the article in the same issue of tho Patriot otttitlod "The Objoct" is even more an oblcct 0f pity lilllll is .\ir. iliggs. 1t ts snroly lii-tlelto the credit of journnlisttt that an editor exists who would so utalign the dond as tho writor has dotto tho lato Sir John A. MacDonald. It is an ltistoricttl fuct novor tluttstiottctl until uow that lli the your 1870 ‘Sir John A. MacDonald was laid nsido for sovoral tuottths with n most sovvro and dangorotts illness. At tletttlfs door his life iras almost doepulrotl oi‘. 1n thc nuntntcr of that your ho was by 111-‘ tloctors ono-l- og"; to [his lu-ovittctr with tlto. hupt- tltnt. its bulnty brcezos and ltottlthlul cllmulo would rcstoro hint. Yct this tnontlttcitttts vrritor bosittttos not to sluttticr the illttstrlotts tloati nftor this fa-“ilillll “0ntensiltly‘ on tho grottntl of ill ltcaltlt ttecossitatiitg tho. sou air, ltc came dowtt to l’. l‘). island in 1571 und spent. purt of tlto summer here. it was time spout not only or .ttOt so much itt thc rowvvry 01

111s ltealtb as it “was itt stdtcntittg ltow to brhtg tho island Into confcll oration."

The writer knows so llttlo of tlto shovel he atttompts to tloal with that. llt‘ (lung no; m...“ know m.- yonr tho tllstlnguisltod invalid Wits ltero rocuporatlng.

if it was lit 1871 the railway bill ltuti bcconto luw and the :‘.tllll111‘l“1 tniscltitet douo with which ho attomltls to tatltor Sir. Joltu A. Maclton- tdd.

‘llut it was not in 187i ho canto ltcro. This is only a trlilo how~ rvcrctnttpztrotl with tho roinaticing intlulgotl in by this ltyslorical writor.

‘1111 chargos tho tloztd stutosinttn wlilt both fraud atul coitspiracy ln bringing about. the building of tho ‘island railway anti our aiiogott "tllncrtut-ttt otttt-attco into confederation.

110 goon on in this semi-idiotic fashion: "But tho 0nd cuttto utttl "u" 1'1"‘? soon. The lmnkg hem tho govcrntuctttls lands but thc KIW- ernment had itself gono beyond its depth. and the ‘bunks were unable 111 Boil the lands. They were unable to uteet thclr own utcvrllillt! 11111111- itles. ltnnkrttntcy and financial chaos lntpoudod over botlt banks nllll island." ,

711911‘ ill ttot n word of truth in this statctnont.

. The blinks held no government lands neither ltutl the govcrn- "lent any lands to give the banks.

T118 statement carries absurdity and falsehood on its very 11101‘- nu

1t the banks held the land; what prevented them front soiling them.

1t. only Keen to show how hard prensed the 8011911111101" 11‘ "he" u

it driven to the necessity of refurbishing in a moni exaggorntotl form . l am sir, etc..

t _ i"? Blunders of nearly fifty years ago,

CHARLQTTETOWN. CANADA.

u uvt nnmisnnlur u Pun m lllttilll

Two Battleships Acc

Land.

(Special to The Guardian.) lll’lil.l.\', May lei.—"i‘\ytt Uritislt ltattltlsltilts oi‘ thc Qucott lfilizdltoih cl‘ ss, thc li.ll‘llill1l and tho_ . ‘ at otttpaiticd by tlcstrtiytt

Kittgttnvtt today with stvoral thou-

witcro partlcs ot‘ thc marlucs were iautlotl and’ lllllftilctlt tnrttuglt ifto .*:ll‘l‘L‘i;-;vtii' thc city ‘..n(i rctttrnctl to thc ..tip<. it is untlors-tsotl tltai this dozttottstratitttt by tho llritislt

> ‘. crui- itt "H's and Ilgluor cr»i‘t, arrirotl at

sanq ittarittcs aboard. 'l‘hc floor lcit uni Qut-c-ltsitttuut btn stoppctl at oaclt ‘liritislt Ziavy has tiiwttys boon ln-ltil utvtho imputiatit ports on tho lrtstt ;1i| high cstcottt this is thc first big toast ltottt fluocttstoivtt to llublttt,iticutottstrzttltttt ‘lay tho British Navy

ompanietl by Cruisers,

Destroyers attd Lighter Craft have Ar-i Mr. a .w to...“ o... rived at Queeustowtt Stopping at Ports En Route where Marines Parade on

.\ vy it ltocn urruitl-icti for two lliifpttsl ono to imptoss 1‘l“l)l‘llltlll |r.tr|ics tn lroletttd that. thc ilrttistt tiorternntcttt tnuy uoo naval foroos tttlditiott to ntilitztry I'm-cos to At-stort- ortlcr in lrolatttl, tho otbcr to tlisplzty nrrinos utttl big navti to t-trzist towns. \Vitilte tho

|.:lottg tho Irish (‘(111571 anti itttlicat that tho tizlyorttttit-ttt inioutls to itso all its force's l1t)\\' il\'tlil.=l)l(' tn lroluntl to support thc ilt'llltll'lllll’t~_.l polico anti crttistultttlttry.

(SPecial to The Guardian.)

l.O.\'llll.\‘, May 11l.~-'i'l|t- tlttcsl- ion \\'ltt~iltt‘t' tht r1- is to bo a con- tinunitco of tho t\llgiu-Jtlllititcst- ai-

liuttcc is bcittg ltrougltt ilclofl:

Australian t‘ottttttottironltlt itt litig- laud. .\ir. Wtttt. at-‘rivotl itt Lottdon this wcok and ins girctt out a tillmbor of itttt-rrlouxs iii which he urgctl closot‘ tzo-tlpcraititnt ltciwoott (trout liritaiit and ltcr lmminiruts with rcgortl to foroigti pollcicfi autl cntpitasixotl .\u:~tr1tli '.s tlotortnitt- utitm to roittaitt a whiio aunt's cntut try.

which" was‘ uttontiod ‘by Viscount Mlluor, Su-crotary for tho colonies utttl numorous other tttcn in public

W-QVVWQQ~QQ-OO9O

i-connnlsut stratus;

~ ».¢“»++“+»+»”»+

‘JNO- ALFRED lliutJOldALD, Latid SIIVBITCX‘, lltrrttttttivillo.

(Souris).

‘GIRL WANTED —FOR HOUSE- work. Apply 1'14 Kent St.

' May 11 tf

‘WANTED A MAiD FOR GENER-

nl ltousework. Must be able to

do plain cooking. Good wages.

Apply to Mrs. Bruce Stewart, 14

Water Street. mtf "SALESMAN WANTED-—FOR

roofing. paint and pltstic tromont. Salary (‘ommlsslott and oxpc-tts- 0.. for l‘. 1C. l. A-pltly t‘. hlattscttu 570 Laifontaltto Park, Motttroztl. 8842-5-115-111

"LOST.—-0N 0R NEAR FITZROY St. unto book containittg ac- counts of tttilk sales. Tho nanto Frank llit-(‘ttrrtttt writtott on cov- cr. Fintlot" kitull-y loavc at Gusrtl inn Offitto. tf. “WANTED AT ONCE MAN TO work on farnt, l". Parkman. iflast ltoyaltl’.

85102-5-1511 EERM w?) RENT—42 Acnzs 0F

land at l'ntou. Apply 20S Grout ~ (loorge Si. t S8118.

“FOR SALE. A WNSHING MACH- inc, zilumst now. Apply at ll llishttp 91.. ('iiy.

Slitill-fvifvfii.

"‘WANTED — RESPECTABLE tnitldltr-agotl wouutn as ltouso- lioolwt‘ for sittglc young man noar city. No (lli,1“.t'.iltiil to ono child. A good ltttiito and good wtagos to tho. right. party. llox Z354 cil,\. ' 3.11115» ‘i

*AUCTION -— l WILL tSELL BV tutotitm on tho lllarkot Square on 'l‘tt-:sdtty tho liilb tiny of May at tito hour oi’ l2 tfcltttek noon. ono good fnrtu ltorso. l1. lloairsit) Mayil’) Iii.

‘lAUtCTl0N BALE OF FURNI- turo on ‘Fuonility thc 13th tiny of ‘May at 2 p. ttt. on lite ltrctttlscs known us tho Mttclllaclttern pro porty No. 127. Witter Stroot. The lot consists of about twonty iron boils. ‘tn-only flvo burouus and about twenty ooutntotlos: also so. vornl used ottrltots; lot of oil-- cloth and other urilclcs. R. lleuirnto. Attctloneor.

Muylftfili

‘WANTED lMlMED'1ATELY.—-SE- cond ltttntl upright steam boiler front ten. to 75 horso powor. Ap~ pl-y W. A. Agnew, i710 lllchuttzttd

TAXPAYER.

‘St. lFbzirlotteiowtt or llhone T-lb.

' had cottsitlorotl thc tnattot" at allqtll-‘rclllctl, it ‘W111i; 111B 101F081. The 11...“. “mule My is. "’l'alte that itt-tottly other tender was from the _ fornal fox tax off." Tho ranchersllliafitinte Stationers.

lifc, .\ir. Wait, itt an iltlllross said tho dotttinattt tltougltt itt our tnitttls itt-s boon that itt soutltcztstcrn .\slu livc Plglii,ill.l11tll‘i*tl tniilitttt colorott‘ ircopitl and tho Attstralian pvopit- say whatovot‘ can ho tlonc to koop

dono. \\’o know that wo could no: rclvcl an arntotl assault by iltu

Kroat _\’|-lit1\\_' or hr.‘ vn ttzttions bull

w." ltoliovt- tltatlitt the fulncss oi‘ limo tltt- stw-tostttcu of thc lfitttpirt‘ will uutlt; .taud our attltutlo anti u>sist to onforco it. 1i‘ tltcre are ictvtivorsalittits in thc uoar‘ fututc ibotwcott tho ltlntpirc of ‘tho ‘Mika- do anti "to

want their vit-ws rcgistt-rctl ltoforo the rcspon~

siblo tltlnltors tn thc Home oi‘ our l-hnpiro. .

Wheat Director Fears Fluctuations

(Sliecial to The Guardian.) \\'.~\Slll.\1G'I‘t).\‘. \‘iuv 14. 7.1 liarnos. witcat tlirocttt . totlts, askol thc Govorntttottl ottiltcittl 3 itkitlor- of Utntgrosst and roprosontutivos of thc ‘Fruuk lino railroads to 111W‘! hint in cottforcttct» ltoro Ally 10th to t-o:.si<it-t' .pl:l1ls to ststbilizo titt- worltl grain ittarkct, tiftot" tho tor- unittatiott oi‘ tho Unitotl Statics grain torportttiott on June first. in a tolo~ grant sent frottt Now Yttrkhhlr. Bur nos roferrotl to tho tlttttgor of a violont ltricc ntflttcttiztiitttt.

u'o.<

Noozic Tltc Stutsltittte’ Kill.

YOUCANT KEEPTRPCk OF THE PRESIDENTIAL POSSIBILITIES NlTHOUT A ‘SCORE

CARD.

rim wr-zzcrutsn , rnnrcnnampnn TIDE. moon nro

'l‘t)ll()N’l‘0, Muy 15.—,—Not'tltcast to ltnrthivost winds local sltowors but ntostly fulr.

‘Fido will be high this tnornittg at 7.‘f1tl. totttorrow at 8.118 und Mon- day cl 9.20;.ii. will bo high tottitllli ut 8.319. tomorrow at 11.37 and Mou- day at 10.31.

Sun sots tltis ovouing ai. .26. toutnrrow at, 7.27 and Motitiuy at 7.28; it rises tomorrow ittorttiug ul 4.26. lliontlay at 4.25 anti Tuesday at 4.24.

tLast quarter montt, May lltlt. 1.51 a.tu.

New utoun, Tuesday. May 18th. 2.26 n. nt.

‘fucstitrv,

'2'. ing

SATURDAY, MAY 1s, 1920.

‘PRUGEEDINGS IN THE PRUVINUQLLEGISLATURE

THURSDAY EVENING. MAY 13. (continued) '

tho l't‘11|tt1‘kS of the previous speak-

crs it would ultpoztt‘ tltnt tho fox ltusinost; was an industry of no ltrofils. Evonvitotly knows tliffcr-

otttly. and that it is a business of ' s it was impossible Lu tuak. an at, to moot all tho conditions whit-l. had boon outliuctl llo tltoitgltt tho pros-t. t act would i provo tluito mttisfacto _ llo would lvt-nturt- to say that hull‘ thc stock

itt tlto inland companios was own- ,otl altrozui. llo tliti.nut think thc ismall 1.1x to be itttposcti would ltlrivt- toy ono out. 1n otltot‘ pru- vittocs tltcrt- aro. many taxcs anti about. |‘.o only cxcttptlun.is tho

t t

w 4 ,» , ,. a‘ w w- e. . w ~ , ,,- , .- 1" .- r '1 ' _~ '1 I " m».-_-..Q~ _ w...

started to got a copy tnade out | and oxpcctod to ‘be back with i| I $0011. ‘ '

The llouso wcnt into committee un a bill "rospcciing tliscasos xvi lllllllk! lice-s and instruction in bee- lreolting." and a bill “to furthor tttuond an act to encourage agri- cuiturc." utttl also on a bill “lo atttontl an act to incorporate the tntnisters and trustees of (‘olontatu (Iapc 'l‘ravorse and Dt-Sablc in. cottnootiou with the (lhurclt of‘, Scotland" oaoh ltasstetl through socotttl rottdittg. '

1111115" lHLlottrnc-ti at 11.50 p. nt. MAY 14.

llouso moi. at 11.40.

HON. A. E. ARSENAULT asktnl i110 Lcltllri‘ oi‘ tho Govorutnotti tut tablc a copy nl‘ n1] pmq,-_ql,.,lu|,.llc,. l

cxctttptiutt of fuxos. i HON. Mr. JOHNSTON said thorc.

iappcarc-l utttiue agitation rogat' i111:- Act. 'i‘hcy proposoti pit.- valuatiott oi‘ only ‘mo! lic utttlt-rvi 8.000 sll<

| ting on a‘ lhalf of ono pcr cont. lsttmtl tltoro worc about

rot‘ ltlack fox,o.~ on thc island. tfiiililk 11p tho corrcspotttlvsnxo.

thoy valued tin-itt at 53011 cacil H1

i , . thc tlndtatts and

including SHliUIlWIIiS ltctwiott titt- luit: (tovt-rittttcttt aiiti tho Solicitor tar Solicitors stato cottcorttlttg tho ltcqttost for tho lloztf and‘ Dumb. 1

HON. J. H. BELL ltrotttisctl to

a.’ f» 1 l

Worth Printing- All the Ads

Worth Reading iii-J

r

By Mall. Canada, $4.00, U.S.A.. $4.50 Annual Subscription. delivered. 55-00

11111111111515 run lHttilll

lilllil [Nil lAWLESSNESE

Proposal t0 Erect Hu

ndreds of Fully Equip-

ped Houses Similar to those in South Africa t0 Quell Destruction to Life and

l

Property. g (SPecial to The Guardian.) l I.().\'l1().\', .\la_'.' 14.’ Tho pl n}

"t which wcrc snbtttlttoq by Sir .\'o\‘ilit~ .\t...-.-t-io1yj

for‘ putting an cull unlniylcsstiessg itt lrolatttl 1ti_t'llitio:~'. i1t‘('lil"llllg inf tits-Daily lit-raid. tho o~ iablisltntottz, tltrngltttttt tho cutttilry tti ltuntlrt-ds-i of blockhou like tltost- put opt tn South Attica during tho lioori

'\'.'ar to bo tttanttotl by t‘t".ltn N0 tzti 50 stiltliors with nrtclttitt- guns lttttlbttrrztcits wore attacitctl.

bntubs provltlott with atloqtt..tt-t

with wit‘ -loss sols.

Fifi y lnllit-o bat Fuchs wt-ro (ite- ittunntl, tax offt<t=.-‘ and st-vcrai tutti’! ll')l|~i‘>‘, wt titaokod last

‘tight :li,\:~' an ofiit-tzti attontttrctttcnr. from llublltt tktstlt- itttr‘: today. 'l‘itc tlorttttciloti of ifltiicc barracks, as altowtt by tho (‘astlc comtttttnicith ion. Wits‘ itltttost on us‘. grout utttl or" ganixctl u sonic as Hllllllllf‘ pint-its lust iftstci‘, When tttore than sixty Most 0f

tho case

ho .l1’l'2lt'l\s‘ 1n pvt-sort!

"i 1119 1-1111)’ “T1111 fllliltlliitllillt‘ transport and oqttipltt-dit-zl boctt abandouotl and no loss 0t‘ lilo

\\‘.\< otttttilod.

ct‘ Sctwlutttl upon tbi‘ tnnttct‘ it ap’ pom-ct to him tltui tltis lcgislututw-

rshottltl tit-for action upon it until

HON- F- -1- NASH l‘“llot".otl on ‘tltnt decision h;tl bet-n tt-ooivotl. llc

Wonk] only brim; mo,“ in $1-‘1’0(]U;'it’_1l(l(*|‘s for printing tho jottrttals a yem.;___if M $300 u would l). ot tho House and recommended $8.00. llo tiitl tiot think thc people 1117! i111‘ i1‘l1f1f‘l‘ 1J1’ i‘. 13- 31111193‘ 11B

clalntoti to he reducing tho capital HON- A- E- ARSENAULT uskod

hold that tho ostaltlistttttottt oi‘ a 1ll‘<'fi1>.\'tct'y for the few who ‘tvorc

‘asking tor it would bo a grout in»

by lnulnplkqng [he foxes Th.» can Qvllon the budget would bo bruughtf

_ _ _ _ Llrttislt Government,‘ At a dinner givoti in 111$ lttttrtrlghe A-,;,m~,,]=;,“. pump.

ital had novcr tboon rcducoti. ‘fltoy ‘down. l

sitttply took tho carttings which] tlts- sharcltttltiors should lavu had utttl put it into thc rc.“ ‘o. This ‘,\\'u.-; not roducitig tho t pttai. Tho way to roduct- it was to hand lmok

1111‘ 151‘1i1>‘1l 111111111‘ ill’ tho l11"'5p"‘“‘1tlttt‘ coutttry‘ for such its tho llri—- i" li‘“-“1"‘i“'1i"1d“"“stiwmffonilltip or w_ ,\_ |\\';|1l_ [_|‘|\l|:-,l|]'(\]' m" moms], and 11...“. chillhm“ Should m.’ ltottvoon $ii.(1li0&l.1‘ltl$20.00l)ill\\'l1|('l'

foxcs had boon capitalized. Tho ifox bustnoss ho said, was boint’! ltlttcotl on a ‘41111111111’ basis to all othot- busino s. Tho ntncltors bad boon so busy rctluclilt; 111*‘ 0111111111 itt tho utanttot" stated that as a rc- suli. tho Proyitict- 14111 11111-111111?! 111 rovonttc. “\‘Ve‘\'o ltcartl quit“ n ttough oi‘ this privilogetl class ‘ (he Spnykpl- said. “’l‘ho principle of the present act is that every one. who is bit- to titty taxes tuust pay thou. according to tizclt‘ utoans." All should be willing to give some- thing for tho ltrivilegt- _uf citizen- ship. ‘ i‘lte ratc- of taxation in this Province was thc most oqttitttltlo in (‘anaria today. An attcut-pt was boittg made to stampctlt- tho» ,poopie. The Province must be [kept up. and all should be willing to pa_ tvhat is oxpectotl of thom, llo foh sure that in imposing this taxation, they wore untitled to twrodit for their courage in tloing so thcy were only carrying out their full duty. -

(Strong applause front mont bonchos.)

HON. MR. ARSENAULT said ii was_wtttttiori’ttl what itpplttttso scu- littionts oi‘ this kittd could brittlf. from ntembors oi‘ the government while only a your ago’ they could hardly find words sufficient in tho dictionary lo denounce tho small bit of taxation which thc (‘ouservativo govcrntttent ni that time tntposotl. “'l‘ltc_v' talk of cnttrago." said ho. "lt is tho kind oi‘ cottrttgr- displayed whon tho ltcat" was far away. Whon tltc lwar. ttho oloctitmi was near. tltcy showed a different uttitutic.

'l‘lto sticukor trout. on‘ to say that ho stood up to rcpudiato a charge itgaittsl lhoso who worc itttoresiotl itt thc fox busincss ltt-rc. Wltcu tho. pruviuus spoakot" chargctl tho run- cltors of this island of having grown rit it at tho cxpottso of oth- ‘t-rs, llo was nutking a statoutont

which would not stand. though. oi‘ course. ihoro may havc ltovtt ox- ooptiottai casos. 'l'ltoy had soon that in ovory country. whero tho tloutatui had boon grotttor than tho tsupply, oxt ivo prices followctl. ‘As to tho ins nuations rogartlittg tho tliffcronct‘ lbetwocn $6,000 and $20,000. ltc thought tltcro wcro men present who should havc stood up anti roputliatcd that charge. Wltilo. thc ranchers may havo what roprosottts money, in a grout num- ,ber of‘ crtstts, thoy were not much »hottor off than tltey wore a fow years ago. In any traso lto dotthtoq lif tho principle was sound tltnt you ‘sl-ottitl tnx ltoyond u tnanfls incotnc. it. was tittno In ilrltlsh (‘uluutltitt ilfitiilllflt‘ thoy had a forolgn clo< mont thorc. A provision was put in tho law in order to gct at tho Ju- panosc. ‘filo spottkor tloclartrtl be had no brief from tho runcltors but was simply speaking in tlto intorosts of tho fox industry. it was going rather too far to accuso tltoso who have some -wett1th. of dishonesty.

Govertr

under tliscttssion was agreorl to. The speaker took tho chair anti progress was roportctl.

HON. MR. ARSENAULT asked

if the estimates of rootiptos and expenditures had becn tabled. The Premier had been away till (lay and it was unjust and unfnlr that they should have been kept back

r-l 3 t-

"tei-HNOLE MACHINE. (KECOND hand in good working order, want ed. Reply stating particulars and term-n to J..C. Clo Guardian 0i‘-

‘atru. r155 _ ._ -.'

so long.

HON. MFl. JOHNSTON said it was pr , .3 to bring down tho budget. tomorrow. but the Pro-

mior‘s time had tben so taken up with del-zgation after delegation

HON. J. H. BELL said tho bud- got was not tluite. read-y but- ii‘ cott- sidoretl necessary it would bo brought ‘down that night. It uutultl probably bo atlvisttblo to lcavo it rwot‘ till Sittlltlity night,

HON. A. E. AREENAULT, con- sotttctl to this provided other logis- lattott was brought down to fill ttt . thc limo. ilc furthor offcrctl it] uaivt- tho usual 24 ltours ltoticc to fitcilitato, ptwtgross.

. HON. A..E. ARSENAULT thought tho ainouttt oi‘ utoney tho Govortt- tnont would get out of rho 'l‘ltoatrt* '1‘1\.\' bill just tabled would be "hurd- ly worth wltlio. 11o said wo aro tlifterotitly situated from big cillosj whore tltoy have largo populations and largo incontcs front theso sour cos. The fornter govorntttettt bod gone ittto tho matter t.'11l‘€fllll_V-il1iti uftor-givittg it duo cottsitlorzititizt (liq not think it worth wltilc going ttltoatl with it. He had also offer- ed to tho Mayor and (‘ity ‘Council of (‘ltarlottotown power to oxtct tltoso amusement fixes and use the proceeds for the benefit of the poor but litcy. after looking into tno ‘utatter. did not think it wurtn uhilo, it was too sutull to bother" with. llo was giving tho (lovern-i ntcnt the ltcnoflt of his experience' in this and (iitl not think it would bo wise for thom to proceed with inc bill. t’l‘lto Antusotttcitt bill pro posed a lax of otto cottt por lltlflllrr sion to all places of itutusettttettt.) l MR. B. W. LEPAGE believed in