I l | ' . n

i}

~ 9 7 ' 2 THE CHARLOTTETOWN GUARDIAN ‘ a PAGE THREE

ItILI-IAT SPEECH on BUDGET

Y HON. on. w. J. McMILLAN

llolilloisition Leader Fully‘ and Convincingly Replied to an Eloquent Justifica. “'1 I 11511" 9f ‘SWWRN Governmenfs Policies '1 Placed‘ Before the Electors in One of the I w B l Ablest Speeches Ever Heard in Provincial Legislature.

J‘

provluelfl Legislature, Friday sion, or the tenets of the profes: ter.) ‘re lull ll m, Eygnlng, April 1st. sion, to which I belong, and fol says; "l; ll hull no

' that reason I purpose to take ex- $80,004), yell would

(Hon. McMillBn- W110 111111 11°‘ ception to some of the remarks. ilcit of $5,000."

t been for the not like, about those sinking IIIIIIIB- “9111111019321110 V1011"? 301111! settles the matter. ~You need not suit, and we had three Maritime

“m” Wily. he Cardigan, which he evidently (1111 11111111110 A111111°1'511Y55'_ ' “"11 1° swllhw- - Premier of Canada, said: “Now this ment in New Brunswick followed have had a tic-laud he went back to the years 1913 were sold and instead of being rc- Y0" 1100b‘. 1V1!‘- 308111101‘. "111111-110 come back any more; ygu use not Governments Conservative. (Loud

I think that I- ti 1 ' b n and invested in Slnkln Fund ecuri- 1111-0 1411101111 Cflnlmlstllolle!‘ 0i! A811" - id " i ) The Conservatives be- lle “(tel-noun {ol- _ w l B l1- nnd 1J24 when they 8511 I l 9 l going to get any more subs y. app BIIBB. 811111115 “Bach m 1 ay 1e put it, as far as I co ll - 1 ti “Wh t ern- tics th o d I d t “"11"” used i” ‘my “hm” ‘he mm’ d ll d in these Maritime claims. lowing MI‘. Saunders in the Budset correetifiii Th’ Patriot‘ dersmml’ H“ "lillht have exltlelulnclill.digital-bl‘:lgllffwgfixthelflg ‘W: all themreiilrr Si" yiomegeseizgl A:- Jus "'91 A"? m1"- 1119 Yaflml" o‘ And the Baum statement was m“ e we

. , , the Premier They believed in Maritime rights, Debate’ as“? ‘,’,',’§,'.'l',‘:°'3,“’,,,lf,‘,§§,r, 1t has been said that the 5101111111 hi?l1n-¥qn1fillt u “m” “"1101. and know what government was in fww- 110""! if 111B B31111 01 M°"“'"" me province and the taxpayers gau- lllbs $211130‘: ttlkllifi wenneed not they prepared to tight for those melting a 18W 1° - l 6am“ Gdvemmenl l, l, government u; l... ‘m " ‘It " “u” ""1 "'1' 11ml flux-h.- in 1m; the Mathieson Goveru- in the same way, during 1922, the 011110 wsht iv be taken by the g0 m 0mm, looklng lo, any more fights, and ll l, llms genllemm the debate 11111-111111’ 9V3“ "5 a t u m i we have been drum“; 000 you would have luui u dcllcit tiffinont was In power“ the government Sinking Fund levy of $10,470.00 “a” am‘ have the M“ PM dwm I ims because we had got ail as the uns ndence and tele- omng to an emergency can‘ jug Pcdoifh t a did ‘Othin exce t fol: “Tumoy why “MM 110 11111‘, “llllhat was able to ‘increase the as- and $27,978.41 0011001011 ""19" ‘heir throats" That‘ was the way flat u; \\'6I‘8 801118 111 Z111 Th3‘ 3mm” ‘and 1" ‘M5 House cmafly received. which 11911131111911 111B 51-‘ {Iii 1 lllhwemotslle a o? the!) Be“ you had not collected your lncoutclstats oi‘ this province by $100,000 ‘l1. ' Motor Vehicle Act went to the Mr- L91‘ 1111111011911 l0 flilllly 1110 lflXli- ‘yrs alfiml the yam. 1908 d]. 190$ Show, who succeeded In getting oui-' tendance. This request was grant- 8w n Bet ‘do 1:10‘ one Erma” Tax you would have added that Ioyear for all time to come, on tho credit f General Account. To “(m nwdicme‘ Now m“ do“ is Au one can figure out for himself claims recognized, and the first of ed by the speaker‘ l“ the eves. lolvem? tnthe sa about thpis Gov. 1'01"‘ Ilollclt, or subtracted Ii frmulvery same basis and bu the very 111F100 i H 110W" 07 111B 5111111110 very nnuseatmg mo’ ‘mu h’ wom’ with was the Premier of the Pro- them is Premier Stewart, the man ing, when thedebste was resume . asglggvlta but yherg is one thing l WllfltcVel-Iflllrplllii you had, uudlselllu claims that the Stewart Gull. Fullu up lo m, “qulred amount go down very well. The nauseating? “me at that mm, Th,“ w“ allel- will, w" lllstl-umentsl In nsvlng the Ml, Saunders rose t0 01110013 e m ' e t I d n,‘ know whet“ 11111110 h 111K201‘ deficit?" The ldennrnment is realizing on today. (Ap Government of P. E. I. deposit re- Pa" °f 1‘ 1' that m“ mm” "l oueloi‘ those Inter-provincial Cou- inter-Provincial Conference called. Mr. SAUNDERS? M“ spwkelr’ ‘o; lfgqxextxvlllobe acceded w m. °‘ “V0110 Dlfliellllliu: to have unylplause.) He goes on to speak about celpts were issued and a corres- “m1” m“ ‘M mind l" ‘M day‘ ferences from which this Province (Loud aplilllllBfi-l 111151"- ‘ state m“ nude“ our n“ e fl ll] wqould ask [he Leader o; the k“°“’1°11,l11‘» 0f Illlbllc ucrhunls lzet-llltose deposit slips to show that in pending liability set up in Loan °f ‘m stiwa" Gmwmmm“ (Au received, I think, $30,000. They rev And that was not all that was 30. the 0111B!‘ 0! the Day, which we op bum)" and the editor 0f. The ting up III this Ilouse and making u. 1923 they amounted to $2,702; in Account. The Payer and Payee Dumas") "m" ‘a m” Pu"! ‘Mug "o celved an increase of subsidy stone done. From the time that this Gov- Me nofw ratummlgitlgvixlabdtitgrrliefiin Pgatiof. never to say again that we Etrgilfinfiltaltgil 95km: “"3 lm°i11011h1914 10 $15335 1“ 1915' t” $12330; f; ‘Q's’, depus" receipts being izszllletellyvofatxlsa Jllllggaltlllbliifilfiiililltlfe “me °‘ $7090“ am‘ “i a"°'~11°1‘111110 egilinill" clfmfliillilil Iaflvtlgf I has: this a ternoon; - f m‘ B." _ . m or er to get the lulu lu 191i; tn $1,396. The Les. e1‘ e rov nce of P, E. I., such ls ' of $30 000- and my hon. friends have t a Ie rem er i! B 0!! under this Rule all orders of followed In the footsteps o _ financial stsndlho of the revln ' ' ' I o endeavor Sues were of no value to its ‘"5 1" Bu‘ 1‘ 1m“ brmg“ W‘ ‘he ' -' 0 nt of mind all the time 11B 111111 l1 0°11- flilgday wlllcll by reason of anydadli g°rggilwgrsté ‘zgfsgustehxa_tita‘ég‘léggi‘g we should add deficit and ‘bash giilglifghtylulllglg lx/lvats that dlf- Sinking Fund, excep‘ as lndlcst. £91150" ‘i110! merit auddlard work §m§f§§0°f§§§°‘;,,'QI“§,§h§o§§‘ t‘; the Ierence with the two Liberal Pre- journment have not been 0N0“ 9t "mly my about us I d‘, m“ Miller- (Applause. It is cerluiulyn ference between $12,890 in 1915 and lng the liability of General Ac- ling “‘°“'1°w“ TeYWML _ W111“? lyrovlnce n5 the wlnolml wlllcll pre. miers of Nova Scotia and New upon shall be considered as ma" {wink w have demanded w low l" 11°Ve1111m11°11 111110011110001115! $1,396 In 1916, or why the $14,691.38 count to Sinking Fund, which it they ‘Vi’? 1‘ WW9)» deahng M11‘ mlel. Mlllllleson l-eeelvelL They Brunswick and negotiations were 0011011 “M11 01° ""111 d" ""11 B11“ m’ ‘m: "m w‘ dun" we“ W It is quite n simple thing to take in 1911 was dances to $131 in 191s. will be seen at Sept. 5th, 192s, i “f fh“ m,“ °""‘_' ‘he’, ‘m “°‘ were both subsidies of $100,000,but entered into and invesigatioas were stand first on the orders of the robfluml (Applausa) the Public Accounts which are pre- Ido not. know whether he knowsor amounted to $148,125.79." ~ Sig‘ t less‘? ‘agave?’ 1111:11- My the met ma; dlllllllglllsllee lhem ls made by a legal expert; and the day. That is the P05111011 we arrrhn P The water or "ha edumml in pared by that auditor) n1‘ whom we not, but he has been told often That is what. the Auditor says, My or h-ialglie Illlillm t“ "5 1 e c0111" lhls’ llml when me $70,090 ellu conclusion that that expert came now. The eleventh ordel tiiit 3 The Patriot goes o“ m say mm we iililVtllllfiilfil so much III this Ilotisu. enough. that this tnoney was taken hon. friend does not have to take thing wgfleiloneaolfvargsye“; 50mg $30900 were lecelued every pl-e. to was ‘that ‘the claims of tbie Magi- day was called and my lwh~ _ are n," a comm“ condlllonwlhu, ° 11"» Pwbahly received ‘morolitintl invested in bonds, that the my word for it. (APDlauseJ ma, every y“, he bade fjffm‘, vlnce in Canada received the same ‘"1"’ Pwvlilw" h“ N0 me,‘ ‘~ ° the senior 11181111101‘ "1"" Chan‘ he we are nsunerlng ‘rum human“? euiouies flom the Leader ot thelslnking fund wasproberly 111011111‘ n"! ‘$111051 1111110 1° ‘quell mat 1119 11mm“ “"11 B11111 g $1 u. pro ratio. and, as the Leader of the 1101111‘- 10 11w “"11" cmwhl" l): s!‘ town had an emerEelllly 0511- l“ '3 “on! and delusions n 1 sulmlll; the; o‘)pn“n.‘°“ °“1'e'~'1ll11y,_tiItu1any oth-Icd for, and that those deiwBli 0110B i119 Leader 0f the Opposition says about them I mlnk the 121?,‘ m} 000011111011 1B 5° 1°01‘ 0‘ "Ymgtwe pressed i“ [he “on” Mhme in er said, and that debate was fldliillfg‘ we have 1,10‘ yet refined ma! stage. el official of the province. We are were there only for the time being. about this transaction is: “Well, the House {ml Show ma‘ c] 1 5 0 would have received ihe- money 011110 QDIIOBIl-‘lon. that tne Mgr t ed. Under this rule 30 It standsa -I bell“ I mm diagnose m“ as 1111110 flflllBileil l0 take his audit. We Mr. SAUNDERS: .110! ho! two wrongs never made a right." during ma "me that the 011v)’ 01199 whether we had presellled om- claims were chestnuts. T o‘); journed until tomorrow. - we“ 880mg gentleman who wrote are satisfied also to take the out- lion. Dr. McMILLAN: Only untll That is as near as he can get to it. power was ‘here even a yacafieemlilé claim there or not. It was an in- W519 lfirmemg“ Wm‘ i“: "318 e5- Mr. SPEAKER: The hon. mem- ‘ma. l m" 8o further and my that side audit; it does not make any a favorable opportunity arrived to But all he has to do is to take the ‘Emission o: this ma"; o“ m lelnprovlnclal Conference; ll we! all But a er a‘ ‘0119°1“'111’ Vi‘ ‘"3211’ ber will understand that tbephoui. we {lever suffered from mo“ dew dsMUTQnCe, they both tell the same buy bonds, which did not always Public Accounts of 1920 and Iookmoor of the House‘ m“ M" 10L adluslmelll ol pl-ovlnclal Bulmldle,‘ fiat game 51o powelinaN or; o. member for Charlottetown his“: Mons or grandeur which characwlfi story. They tell the story that the present itself at the time the Public up the sinking fund and he will not quite true that {he speech ‘from end we reeelved our amount like wicgiaalxa i‘; ‘lggnjuncgxn ‘:3: “‘° 1‘ h“ mum adjcum the d“ a a Izod the Bell Government. debt h“ Ne" 9"“““‘"Y il"°w'"9 Acummis we“ ma“ “p- o“‘“'w“°' flnd ‘my depmm an” there’ m" 1" the Throne every year had some ‘he “he” provinces‘ Bu‘ Pram." our Government-then we were until he came back to the House, A ‘Hue further on I have been under both Governments. because It those amounts would have been will flnd flood bends in every _one reference m the matter. but that Mathiesoifs subsidy W" "“11‘°|Y bl t t“! I l l l l n_ and I granted that rellllu" n - h was lust the same when my hon, greater year after year. But they of the sinking funds. We believe l h ' ulna-em, been" the" w" m, l", a e o 80 e a er-prov aca c0, M SAUNDERS! 1 51111111“ “m1- caued the “met “pomgm of ‘ e friends were in power. Although were reduced in 1916 from $12,390 that if unfortunately he should ever s w c" It ended’ I d‘) not‘ know tor-provincial Conference on at the term“ MmedI and “m” chm” r‘ bound by the Rule. Under 9°VBP111nB111/' 111111 111979 15 Home‘ they clnhn to have reduced the debt t0 $1,396, and in 1917 irflm 514.591 001119 1M0 DOWBP-Bi. 1888i 118 W111 that the debates of ‘he House Wm time’ there was no general re-ad- were an“ ‘mu’ Th“ w“ “m” we are I can we proceed now? 1111118 B8111 about £11111- 8000011 011 111° the puhue Accounts never showed to $731. ln 1919 they were $29,384; not be in a position to go back and “WW ma‘ the Lead" or the opp“ IUIQTIIIGII! of subsidies and Prince ‘he R°"°‘“"‘°“' "M" ‘t w“ ‘Wm ‘V1113: IQIPQEAKER" The rules can be 13m"- 5111110115 1:11:31: 1 11111 "m-hnni lt_ Tllev cellllnt null it ill the pub. in 1920 they were $51,943; and In practice that same deception on the :23?!1evalfpeneilhhlfsdmtiuthtg“ ‘:8 Edward island was the only Pro- m“ ma‘ m” Mmfllme Hume“ - ' ' ‘ . . '. now a r - suspended. s_ T‘ _ was no 1:38 amelkal‘ ‘wil: gecgfiaggiigrab‘ Li? (Aéilftcmunlttsw that boast-ed PQIlIIClIOIII 531:; lzglfylawtehr: tfinfilwénallfilgbilgg: 1620.133: glgitille-‘giivggitcewoiAvpplzuse.l bale whlch dld ens‘; ‘gm: use vince that benefltted. (Applause.) ggifilfgl‘;eaiggstbuzgfnreégsxiaz?gfi M“ SAUNDER I ‘ma “my ‘ m“! ‘o0 much’ But ‘MB was son tll aralrlfeveil ‘append’ t ornament. If which m hon friend believe in the the i,‘ ' “ite Io not some speakers mentioned b-ut "a" A L051 °PP°"‘""1W- w“ appomwd and they “medown mono“ toiiigwifiitqeitilave given my 9999c“ l“ "'°““'"‘°d Wm‘ “nmmr told 1111111?! eugl-nlllfuztillelyleillfg; was a suhportei- sawythe posslblii- legal, but it may beoggdd buslgesrbo" to find the Mme °f m‘ HM‘ Mr‘ am‘ wok °vm°"c° l“ ‘he “m” 11m‘ Mr. SP t th ‘hon member af- 1 11111110- My B06601! 111 i110 11111111155 $353 0m) ‘ullll-ll lllul; luullll u-llull ties of this deposit slip system and My hon. friend criticizes the first A‘ c‘ Sunder" (Apphmm) We say’ further’ that m“! our “ma” l‘ w“ a very ‘°“““"“° daemon ma’ a ' ‘use “"1115 ‘lever be “nmhed- "- ‘5 mm" ti 1- i t’ 1' 1 19m '1 the took the ood Governlnent acts of this Government I will t ll 15am the other day’ m ‘mcusaing chums bee“ prmmrly presemed ‘Mm; m“ ‘he 9°"”°““°‘ °1 m“ ter leflviilg 011 1"‘ emarsmy c ' uunlefls Th, Gllal-dllm pllbllelles ll "my (“.119 '1“ WW9‘ " '- Pm‘ y 9 9 om h, ' e this matter during the Draft Ad- when those amounts of $30,000 and Commission was constituted as it has perfl11BB1011 1° 1051111191“ like m as ‘mended’ a! n did on another o0 rlieiltdtA vanished also when the sglzdstggrfil" 9&5??? gys 5;” :01: Gxegggugftqlgrgtfilllx’!eillrstviactilaghg“ dress, that my hon. friend last year $70,000 were ‘received, we would was. The Leader of the Opposition Mr, SAUNDERS. 1811011 m Casio“ when reporting an lmaglnary l1 1 1'1 J10B1l1lt1-‘l_ W110 1110110 llll- ltlthm“ becaafle It was good business borrow $186 00° m u"! M: u‘ ° termed the presentation of these have benefited to a much greater in speaking ell this mutter gave a glikhsoglltyugiiigxerawwicll?yngunggenots BDQBCh 0f i116 B01110 30111101111111 111' 1:03;»: oefhc otllliyliexlstidhaii $1,‘. (jprezzllTll/OEG bonds were good bonds, evi: sinking fund's, and frat, Mxspeoalf- hgclgelfrlilllztlfl-‘(Tenlsletgteme3; ialftent ‘vle Qfifflumggllfgsxiglniritl: lilreliltuiieal ol-tl cd-edlt m Drl. Cyrus " . . . . . ‘ e case o . c . proceedlns- ll says that in explain- Cgrszrlngalrlke m go back to ancient manipulated and brmlabl 11110 1°l'm."‘“l""" Fr?“ ‘"28 Qmfgafgfh i’: 71;‘ 1B the of 1:: reasons why 111° course, I did then what 1 izenerallylPremier there was not satisfied to more .31‘... t: th::‘s:r?tls:\:: - mg a point o! mhs “Millie tilt“! fipehlil history. but I have here a. verbatim u} anfwmtiitoéry and mnke M] ‘hilowcrlentdv {nit ‘ills lenglfhngt "u'§°ss.t’i'1'§'i>'sn“sf~'§n'1'l'§.'1' “°-‘—‘ submmed 1110 D1001, takeuiitake his allotment at that Confer- we do en this side sf tile "so", - e‘ “mm flfam. L: “'31s: rlmylllllilfi l report of that speech at Curran Ban 313°, 921,9.‘ f“ fllveflnmemlll~°r ‘Ylm.’ their term which would be lnioza Hon n1- McMItlLAtv- They had m" "t Tie Pam“ °' h“ °“"“°“°°' H“ P""“‘°“ “d ‘"'°“°‘“°d ("°““ “P1"““‘°-1 I “ms” “° w" 51,11‘; i: the‘: 1111s hon, member from from which I should ‘like to read {are l1, llelllevs m‘; orgiisstlzitlghtleiilse ~iust one year to run? It was a an I. '0. U. there—a deposit blip. ,‘I§,',‘l'§',,ofi“‘l°",;,",‘§ "f3", gleFltlel-fia]; hlil cl?” as n illllulddbfi presented E05,: lgstrumentt? i“ 8M" a m" Charlottetown simply sot up 1h 111B “fa 1“ which “ °°""°"“"°“ ‘wk-trim no Inelm follower. bul one <11’ S“‘*"“"~'F’ "““g' Wm‘ ‘he ‘“°“°" "m" I“ “h” "mm ‘MY h“ "°“""° he replied 12".»... eby “(lfli-rglllfllllilllg illlicreazegotl? 3e ti‘. 2t “.13.? pgiltatioizmgililgblifittiz: if 32:11:55‘: place and moved 111B "dl°"1‘"m°"‘ ‘lf;“°s“lnbf‘l“'_°°“d“‘° m1?‘ Mazhfmlflllw uwsl prominent supporters- ke‘ “m” ‘mam’- “mi “w?” "°“““ "m" m" “'9 ha“ i“ 11"‘ 811°" that I am not act fairly with him—- men st blew. who believed in the chairman Sir Andrew Duncan‘ 111111 1011 "111101-11 00y V011‘ 119113 wil t clue‘ 3:18 uayisaé about? ';,That deficit was made up for the ‘V810 1111511191 l‘ w" 3119331‘ why {fgslsiihefe and pal’ ‘m-ere?‘ o“ that I should have quoted his state-mar claims as Premier Mathleson and if those transportation diillc ' (tlilrglas; llfillfingle thing’ a mo“ iiugted 111mm Tile Patriot a ‘state lfiflflfifff, Zgfiflffflfl 1):; wserll-Rlfcslit; ltgtlecythgldnzllcitlllejd iliatezlfegltatttgoreczfxtralibl- vestingnpllllfiiclz‘ $1; fizigalgltllfltllllg tihne lnfllllé zifihfinilgilflufffqulg{g ilpfalfer’ ‘wild w°luld "lave W‘ a" were“: gen CM" hi‘ sglfifiilomtled ‘In benevé ML SPEAK R: He asked my ment of yr. Sinclair's respecting pawl“ two lalhem (Applause/J Tlll, er year. But no; they were sold bonds of this province. That ls lrlenlws speech fight mrou h (mil “zile hggfifiajuvs Bald from the ma“ ‘gimme: w ‘m l: 5 ‘mu uermlsslon firs," llle get-lam Msegent t}! 3105a 11°‘_ Leader of the Opposition was one, 111111111911‘ 1110086011 put into current thek difference, Mr.‘ Speaker. I19 just wanted to quote enougsh of it Premier down, that it did not mat-iCommissioner, luflligeeti Wall-tiling: Mr, SAUNDERS: But having B11 B army 0 Oers n e use! and llle gel-mel- Allul-llelnGeuel-al Icveune to ieduce the overdtaft in tal s about the gloat increase in to mo“ ma‘ ‘he ‘filament l had ‘er vet much w “a whelher we Haul,“ should be we m f n done that, and adjourned me de- Mitchell matter. This is what I was the on,“ Th“ w" llle only the bank, and in place of the bonds interest. That is one of the rea. Y 1 5 n 5 l‘

l d l m :_ l , ml l m _ ""110 W" 001F001, that that was the bad a deficit or a surplus, but that credit, too. We say it was an honor beta. that matter. according‘ 1-0‘ its: “mi-liluf’, newsl- w". demand Mada purpose served by that so-called de- édfiflspqieguasfn 111,22 ‘zflifrlnkgfi 5°“ m‘ ‘he increase 1" 111101051- term he had applied to our cIaima-- we would run the affairs of the pro- to those men who acted on that "ulei- o‘ ‘he House} 828:” an“, for me thstlsnould eneesvel- 1e us. 3f‘? 5mg "llwa! 1-“; m: a”: is Public Accounts IPDesrIng at the T110 Railway an"; CHESTNUTS! But both his friend vince Just as economically as "we Commission. But when it comeeto untulhmbrmw‘ m ‘ list in recovering this amount!’ e r re W o" o’ e — ‘flip-End of the Yber Preceding the elec- . [he 9am“. of The Pym" and mm coma’ °°““°m“‘t Wm‘ emcm“ ‘m!’ ‘he presenmtm“ o‘ ‘he c555 my rule o the colltrlry- ' paired. it was lost, In the Pub lc My hon. friend went on to discuss self have referred to my leaving out lie service, |¢ we cgmg out with one who set in this chamber sud

PREMIER STEWART: If you _ "111 M" 3|"01l1"- "N0 "I"°'°"“" Accounts. So we need not .pay 11°" °f 1923 \1'°Y-Wi"‘°d 1° 11'1"“ this grant of $80,000 In lieu of raii- the rest of that paragraph. wil] permit, me, Mruflpeaker, I sub- 3;“: slfgr'h"dagv°'"m‘°wg very much attention to it. amemxg'fvllgzsae‘po°mlti‘ilw P°S'"“‘l:: way taxes, which came to the pro~ not see why I should have quoted did not intend to make a surplus by that If the case was not presented mitthat my hon. friend is entirely mnwr" P0 0 l 0 0n - _ er when We came mt - 1- dffffi‘ vlnco during ‘the past year, and for It; I got enough out of his speech gqlng to the taxpayers for more properly It very likely would have misunderstanding the rule. The rule Hui"; M d u‘ ‘ ‘ H What the External Audit Shows. igqthe reason wh W0 émwfii- t '1 which evel-yelle is entitled to some to prove what I was saying. melley, we mu we plus glplm; st fallen to the ground, but it w" is_ that all orders of the day which or ‘vlcgm a ‘a , on. am not have they m?! "gnarl d"? credit with the exception of one It‘ l quoted the whole paragraph (mews upon whlgh we ‘ileum reel. properly pl-eseuteu sud we hue by reason of any adjo lament have cmimfl r l" ‘Id? 3"‘ "Pa?" .'I‘he record of the public dab!» “mo” mat [unlous “mar whlclftkg man. There is one man in tblB 1° 11W ""1. 1i WWW Blmply hlvfllze some day, as we are realizing realized on those claims. I do not not been proceeded wthl sbaii be ‘Mr aMYI Iiggl‘ B II 0 s I‘ 0t, lake“ lly llle Elllel-llul Auditor, be- ‘Baher of the O came“ is s r a House, Mr. Speaker, who is entitl- shown the Leader of the Opposition now. And I submit that It was a care t0 whom the Leader of the considered as postpofiedfffhlb order 0MIFSINCLAI _ 1 ginning in i919, was $125,275. Let o} weak!“ abglllt and WM‘) 0E ed to ebselulely m) credit on uc- in the same position he always ls vel-y fortunate gmllq tel- thie pru- Opposition wants to give thecredit; has. been pTDCBOdGd with, and the ' ‘HW- DY-M MILLAQ; 1" "Bil- me show fllrihol‘ how It lltlfl stcudi- S“ Blwas 815m out b this 61 r 1’ count of that $80,000, and that man lh-ihlt he spoke on one side of ilvince that when the opportunity l know that the people‘ of this rule does not svplv- (Applause-i m °"' t“ ° r “T - W°"- ‘fly increased Illlllol‘ bolh (lnvtlrll-ltngnt u has been ix lame "é Is the Premier of the Province! I-Ie qvntlvh and ended up on the other. was made we had at the head of af- Province will place the credit

Mr. SPEAKER: I wil now csil w B i193‘ 0015M . there nevel lllellts, ln 1020, it was $1,202,7ll-;la"d Again that that letizer was ‘I; had nothing to do with It at all! (Loud aDIJluIIBeJ m" u m," e1 the eeusl-e er p". where It is properly due, and they llll u the hon, member from Ghar- . rgllloandemlsai; made prime‘ that ll, 1921, $1,323,461; in 1922. ll.4ll.l,-,pu‘_od by the Asqlsmnt Proving“! Everyone else had some share In Now we see, Mr. Speaker, that mlgr stewul-g, will, w" ems te ul-e. will ssy It Is s remarkable thing lottetown. l ‘ ' ' ‘ covafln n" “V” ":35 s‘ 1‘ m‘ 069; in 1923, $1,710,766; in 19.24, 31-, ' ~ it, but Premier stewult! The; is, that was typical of their altitude. gem our slums bevel-e the Dulles" that we secured an Increased sub-