JANUARY 12.1935

PEFMIER SCSYORES g

qurcnaar .._' sAlnsr SUIIEST _ nasa- l

couonsicoms . _ by‘- Ivory rm y,“ BU.€3.'§.':E..Y'S

A. l. l A.» .. HAM. A ‘....,,l,. 5.), pm,“ h

Death of Former P. E. Islander At 1, , Flin Flon, Man.

+

The following news item is from a Winnipeg exchange. The late Mr. Bell referred to lived in Prince Ed- ward- Island as a youth- and was a nephew oi Mr. Arthur F. Bell, and a cousin oi Mr. R. R. Bell, Char-

Man, Dec. 29. - i-iundreds oi Flin Flon residents attended the funeral Thursday a.f- ternoon of Lewis S. Bell, prominent local merchant and member of tho first municipal council, who died on Monday morning at the Robertson Hospital following an illness of sev- eral weeks. The service was held in North- minster United Church, interment being made in the Flin Fion cem- etery. McSorley and Smith were in ch ‘e of burial all ngements. The unerai was held under the auspices of Plin Fion lodge. No. 153, A.F. d: AM. of which the late Mr. Bell was a member. Rev. Geo. W. McNeiii, pastor of Northminsier and chaplain of the lodge, officiated at the church and- graveside. Mayor E. E. Foster and members cf the ipai council attended. ‘ members oi,the Masonic lodge acted as pallbearers. ‘rhese were W. F. Hughes, 5. P. Hudson, i". A. Bchreide, A. Triieyiand, W. Barker and A. Campbell. All places oi business in Flin I'll remained closed from 2 p. m. ti 4 p. m. on lhursday.

BIRTHS

MCGUIGAN-At tie Charlofiftown

Hospital, January 0 i936. and Mrs. up M . a m.

RILEY-At Charlottetown Hoa- pitul, January o, 10cc, m Mr. and Mrs. Emanuel Riley, a son.

BENTLEY - At the Charlottetown Hospital, January 5. 1930. t0 Ml‘- and Mrs. Peter Bentley, a son.

MACAETBUE-At Rosebank. P. l. L, on Jan. i0, i036 to Mr. and Mrs. John MacArthur, a daughten-S

MABKIAGES

BIMPSON-WOOLRIDGE-At Zion

Church Manse, January ‘l 1935. by Rev. G. Carlyle Webster, r’: Woolridge and John Lowell Simp- son, both oi Charlottetown.

DEATHS

CAMPDELL-At Hingham, Mass.

Jan, 'l, 1935, Colin Campbell, age N, formerly oi Prince Edward Is- land. ’

GCULDRIJP -— At Brooklyn. New York, on Dec. 18, i004, John Gould- rup, formerly of 1170B. P- 1'3. 1 Th“ late Mr. Gouldrup was a nephew 0i Robert Reid, of Crapaud, and a cou- sin of J. R. B Iea of nummerside.

mcasssv-sz‘ ohm-r Hill. P- E- I- on January ii, i030. BORN/W‘ Assey ,aged 0i years. Funeral from the residence of D. Lee McAssey. v.e., (merry Hill, on Saturday at 3 o'clock P. M.

MaoLIOD-At Roalindaia, Mass.» Jan. ‘l, i085, Mrs. Margaret M. Minced, formerly of Charlotte- town, P. B. i., wife oi William A. MeoLeod, 48 Cohasset at, Roslih- dale. ~

AA A A

rs ward:

Iplrilual Offosll our iaslu Notices - ward. 0th

Carlin, ale . do

IAIN-dc per word, three llna for Ilsa price o! two, hhbls l.a alvaacc.

H a For §aie

CARDBOARD IUITAII-I IOI lining outbound ate. is pa: shaat. Guardian Office. M.

laser strictly

Central - . Guardian y

a This column u reach-val hr B:

cf lqmi inks-est but advertising

a newer aasare nay I

I seats a IIII strictly payable b

adrnaca. ~

DONFEDBBATIUP.‘ LIE-F. instil- anon _ L-eraa-"l-rz-aw

u

LOADING TURNIPS all this week. J. M. hoop. L-Ziizll-i-‘l-ei

WOMEN'S MUSIC CLUB Meeting this afternoon in the Canadian National Hotel at 4 o'clock. 14-3580

_ POLICE COURT-At the Police Court yesterday a drunk was fined $5 or ten days in jail. The defend- ant in a breach oi the Excise Act case was fined $25 and costs or one month in jail.

DB. M. A. McGUIG-AN will not be able to receive patients until further noiioe. His office is open every afternoon and Saturday ev- enings for paying accounts.

L-ssffl-l-tts.

TIIE SALVATION ARMY SUN- DAY SERVICES-Al a. m. Rev. W. L c .. I ... .- “The

Spectacle," 2 . m. Sunday School. 'l p. m. Salve ion meeting. Ad]. W. B. Stevens in charge. All welcome, sea/ts free. \ 11-3531

THE BAPTIST OHUBCIL-Jrhe Rev. G. Cariyla Webster, Minister of Zion Presbyterian Church will take tha morning service,~ speaking on “The Proof of God's Love." Dr. Vincent will speak at the evening service on "How to Become a Grass-

, ." Included in the music of the day will be “Ihr-xliord is My shepherd," and "My Ifisther for Another Night."

INQUIRES AFTER RELATIVES -47hief Birtwistle has received a letter from Mr. Gilbert W. Duke. Montreal, inquiring after relatives

Island. His father, the iota Mr. William Duke, was born in. 1880 at Bt. Peters. The City Poiioa will appreciate any infor- mation. .

BONU! DIKJLABED-At a meet- ing of the Board of Directors of the

who may be living at Bt. Peters.» Prince Edward

%ZE3%N€Xii-¢§K

{u} Concert ‘l, zlhn Church Guild,

H TIIESII8Y= JIM. l0, 1935, at 8 p.01. 1.;

m] Admission 25 cents,

ENTERTAINS AT BRIDGE — Mrs. W. M. Flynn entertained at her home on Euston 5t. on Monday ey. ""118 with a mixed bridge in honor of Hon. John A. and Mrs. MaeDon aid, of Cardigan; also on when“- day evening ior her lady friends at five tables oi bridge.

DRUNK AND DISOBDERLY— The 01W Police had to liandcufl a Kiln whom they arrested last night for being drunk and disorderly. Be is an old offender and usualhy 5t- tempts to destroy everything with- in reach when taken to the police station. As a precaution last night iéheelyk handcuffed him much to his is e.

HILLEBORO DISTRICT L. 0. A. B. ‘A. -— The annual meeting oi the Hilisboro District Lodge oi the L_ 0, A. B. A., which was held in Boyne l-Odse Rooms on Tuesday evening, y 8th. was well attended. The usual business pertaining to the District was capabiy disposed oi by the officers oi i034. After lunch the following District officers for 1935 were duly installed by P. D, M. Bentley: D.M., c_ T, M, Manna’ Nc- 614: D.D.M., John w. Dickie, No. 614; D. Chap., Harold McKie, Nv- 104d: D-R-B. o. Arthur cud- more, No. 614; 111125., J. W. Chand- ler. N0. 814; D..'rrehs.,1»r. H. King, Nd- 614; D. Marshal, F. Chandler, Nd. 614; D. Lech, ChrirFord, No. 614; D. D. Iect, Wm. Cooper, No. 1046. Auditors for the year. C. W. B. Bentley and W. A. McCallum. The semi-annual meeting will be held June 5th in Rose Lodge, Mt. Herbert.

Dairymen ’s Assn. Directors Meeting

A meeting oi the directors oi the Provincial Dairymelfs Association was held yesterday in the office o!

P, E. I. Co-Operative Egg st Poul- try Association, held on January icth, a bonus of 10% was declared on the year's business, which is in- deed a very creditable showing un- der present conditions. The volume oi eggs was slightly under last year's, but the advanced value to patrons was considerably above that oi last year. The volume of Will- try has increased considerably this year and members are evidently realising the importance of beinll

paid on a graded basis.

SUPREME COURT-At the Bli- preme Court yesterday His Lord- ship, Justice Saunders delivered judgment in the appeal case. the King, respondent. vs. Harry Thom, appellant. The appeal was dismiss- ed wlth costs. In the appeal case. the King, respondent, vs. Edward MoGuigah, appellant, the appeal was allowed by consent. The case was an appeal from a conviction before the Magistrate for unlaw- fully driving a motor vehicle on the highway while intoxicated. Mr. Alban Farmer appeared for the Grown and Mr. R. R. Bell for the appellant. The court adjourned until ll a.m. Monday.

lvir. Byron Grant returned to the city on Tuesday after spending a. Christmas holiday at his home in Montague.

__,______.._____

Mr. Adolphus Kelly, Yonkers, N. Y., arrived in Charlottetown last evening on a business trip. Mr. Kelly will visit friends and relatives at Belkinir, Bear River and Souris before returning to the

cl Thanks and A Iraeiatiol. 70s. III ~ rr rates ca application. lslaiaaam Charge In any adunlumas sweaty-Ilsa nah.

U. B. A.

Advertising Rates-Payable in Advance

Central Guardian locals, 6s per word! announcements and Cami | In Ianuriam Notice

Western and Eastern locals, le

oi‘ Condolence 10c incl or so. Its

vi>w v v w v v v

roa BALE - HARDWOOD AND Kindling. Phone ‘HO-J. h-asea-i-e-ii-ia-ls-ie-la

To Lot

IIIATID BOOM WITH BOAID- flll Grafton street. L-SATII-l-iil-Zii.

the Secretary. in. J. w. Boulter. All the directors with one QXCQp- tion were present. Arrangements were made for the holding oi the annual meeting on Wednesday 3,1. ternoon and evening, February aoth- The Dllry Superintendent, Mr‘. W. L. Brenton, and the See- Egzryéo-I. W. Bouiéelr, were author-

, prepare g

that meeting. e pmnam or

A markfllnd’ scheme, prepared by a committee that had been ap_ pointed at a meeting held 50mg time use. was Presented by Mr, .1, A- new". New Perth. who is a me ‘ oi the committee and a director oi the Association. ‘rho Rh was discussed for a con. siderable time. but was considered by the directors present to b, 1m- Pdssibie to get the idea oi the scheme properly before the dairy- mm "1 "H? Province so that it could be intelligently discussed at u“ ""1"" "1""!!!- On motion, therefore, it was decided m m; the mdzrllsmremain over for the prgg-

Matters- of general 1 g, will come "before the hghlffftmgif lug were iscusaed. The Superin. “mdim- MP- Brenton. told the dl. rectors that he will have a copy f,“ “mill! resort in their hands e ore the meeting so ma; 5; m, meeting they will b, m l poflum

t0 discuss dairy u _ "any. ma ers imam The directors felt that some

Rood practical dairyma h 1d Vmvmed V! Rive an 11.13;‘; us: lead in discussion at the meeting.

hn om

(B! The Canadian Pleas) MANCHESTER, 17118.. Jan. l0 __ ‘M111 15115858111. Poe Laureate, says he is working on a special poem to

celebrate the Xingu jubilgg m]; year. Humble Guest: "Er-have you

ever walked in your sleep. Sir John?”

Vefy R1611 Mimi "Certainly not; I may have motored.”

IN MEMORIAM

In loving memory, oi JAMES A. MacLAUCHLAN Who departed this life Jan. ll, 193d Tlma has changed in many ways

But one thing changes unvar- The memory of those happy m.

2c lb. small Smalts for so: Feed‘ 8c lb. Earle Fisheries Co. ' L-Sbil-i-il-Ii.

. Maia Help Wanted

lIlllNfl

~ issm Barber Trade. short Course. exam trsinlns. Molar Barber Cei- lsss. lsitfas. a-ass

cl: warvrab Qo~

taking Chiropractic Adjustments. Dr. canon. Mil. L-MOO-l-ii-li.

dead or alive. Gtorle w}

, aw . . . {film mu vl r s I L-ssoi-i-u-al.

oru OILLARS Arrroma-r- ‘ieaiiy drained. so 1y Twill" Asolaserias. 30244-1941-

roa- saui‘ - scones roan- _._ m", u, - u, _ PM. Bridle and Whist 8cm r a 4 run so Ever glusnxrliinred by h: listen. Cards. Guardian Central Job fgqyng. hangar, 117 Kent 5t, Printers. Nor. i-u n-ssoo-i-li-si L-' -i- 2-11.

roa ' aarn-oausaan auau. a - ' 1e.- Poultry. Ode dollar per hund- M15°°|l3"°°“' I-IN. o 1AM red pounds. Rock Bait for catua E EEPVWELL ______

In loving memory of ARCHIE COUBINB Who died Jan it, rm Safe in the arms of csus. Safe on Ills gentle breast. There by Illa love cur-shaded Bwoofly his soul shall rest.

Inserted b‘ 1h Famib. L-SBIS- -lI-li.

._.__.______._._______.

\ asssox non "m: m.“

Mansion-Ba a Civiiflervant-

Personal

"m" ‘IWW "mil"- rarvan nous ' uranium:- °,,‘,,°;*,,m §§.§'""Ph°'- ‘W0 9"‘ teas par. We start you. The oeu- \' ment Job." C‘? $13.1 Barrio; am‘ ‘fimamrm m“? ' gchw‘. Tum” “on n w w“. 5"!“ (0). PQIIK- é- ' ' ' ' Boarders Wanted "svlfilflimmmblu “no. mo‘ Aosroovroaar. arca- smmltvu ems a undated.‘ ammo

rmfiar v. strut.

| . i

N. D. MacLears

UNDEITAKII IMIALMII

OIIIIOUIIIIIIIG

Nari-b Wiliehise IkcneiO

view the whole case for

THE (BHARLUITEIUWN uuAnuiAn.

OPPOSITION

(Continued from Page i)

have really tried to make these. bluinela talks. To tell you the truth, I am so gripped by the neces- sity for action. I am so anxious abouttha development of these rc- forms, that I~hare little time to think of politics.”

Policies 0i Par-flea

He now proposed to ldisouss, Mr. Bonnet stated, the policies of the two old parties, that which he headed and the Liberal party. He first asked the people to judge the actions of the two parties during the depression years, declaring that though out of office it was the duty of an opposition to either have constructive policies oi its own or support those of the government. The only policy of the Liberal party was "to oppose the govern- ment in its forward. constructive measures." Mr. Bennett declared. He proferrnd to "measures now in most successful operation," which had been debated in parliament, taking up first the Ottawa Agree- merits.

“I mention them (the Ottawa Agreements) as one unquestioned IIIGflSUIc of vast benefit to this country. which came before parlia- ment and was opposed by the Lib- eral party," Mr. Bennett crmtinued. “Why? Because, presumably. thilt party thought it good politics to oppose them. If they had it to do ail over again. would they still op- pose? I doubt it. But ask their leaders. I think someroi my "Lib" oral friends, if they are frank. will now admit that their leflderfl guessed wrong. But never mind thgt. The point is. that at a time when your government was fight- ing for the life of this country, we were handicapped and embarrassed and opposed by a. pdfty which seemcfl to think fa.- more of get- ting book mm hmce than it did of

ou." ywuming to the Marketing Act. "One of the measures which com- prise the first stage of my reform programme," Mr. Bennett spoke oi the "fury" 01 opposition from the Liberals to a measure designed to help the farmer. “which is already helping, thn farmer." and which would continue io aid him in an even broader way. He recalled thB support. given the measure by One Liberal, the err-minister _of agricult- ure (r-ron. w. R. Motherweli) "whom conscience and experience would not huow him. to relett it."

“What is the likelihood that. if m1; (Liberal) party has the chance again, it will do anything to help you out oi the depression? Will it say to capitalism, the system is faulty? Will it say, the system must be reformed, because the people are the victims of the inequalities and the injustices and tha hardships which its defective operation per- petuates and increases? Fellow citizens. that is the question and the only question before you. You are entitled to an answer. In a moment o: two. we will consider what that answnr will be."

Greater Iieasolu For Support

On the basis of its past policies and the effectiveness of their re- sults, Mr. Bennett questioned if there could be any doubt that his government could continue to serve more effectively than any W118 that might replace it. But he would add an even greater reason. a con- elusive one, he claimed, why the government should be supwfifid- ‘Iihis was the programme 0f le- form on which he had embarked.

Some reform measures had been inaugurated. Others were in pre- paration. Coilectiveiy they would comprise a scheme more wmvm- hensive end far reaching than any reform move Canada had ever known. "It will mean a new re- lationship between government and business," he said. ‘The govern- meht will have a new function to perform in the economic Syd-WW The government, under his plan. would be w. perms-vent guide M“! regulation with the right and pow- er of correction" with the duty °Y maintaining in thg industrial and capitalist system a more Willi?‘ able distribution of its benefits. 1-115 government had started the vpolicy of reform and it seemed nat- ural that those People who 5W- ported this policy would also will‘; p0,; m9 pgfly which conceived an develdbed it-

"But, let us dispassicnately Te-

and against my claim. Although. as I say. We decided on this policy of "Wm and introduced it and have made a fine beginning at it. perhfllfs will“ people may maintain that the! other party is equally 9595b“ ° carrying it through. That is a W0- pogltlon info the reasonableness of wnloh you are certainly entitled to imuum m; u; do so. Suppose that i have the honor oi dehatlns 1h" queatioin with the Rlsht "WM- able the leader of the Liberal party- hnd 1 Put it to him thlt "me °l his friends claim that this reform programme already “"5" ‘"5’ should be turned over for mild‘ m“ mg dpvflopment and corn; pistion to him and his party- N"! ask him what he can say to sup- port the fairness of that sunbl- tion. "r ask him if he ever proposed such a scheme o! R1011“. "id h‘ must answer no. i‘. ask him. did he not. on the other hand 09PM“ Vi‘ oiently cu:- pfblflmlmfif Takfmé which ma its hummus in the “s, oossion of parliament. And he M115 answer yes. ‘i ask him. if this 9"‘ nuns should be turned owl‘ t0 im for control and deveiopmtm- will-ho dul faithfully and intel-

afraid you cannot de-

Nl. l!" fond him. for his answer is one dictated by wilt 1 swell-

coherently. thinks still. as he did in the days when re was in power. that ail is wail with the laud. and that gov- ernment intervention is wholly superfluous.

"lot if the bales at the 0990'

Min.

sition has changed his mind-and l; may say that everyone is en- titled lo change his mind-if he has changed his mind and says he will support this programme of reform, he will. I am afraid, be faithless to many of his protestations and those oi his lieutenants. But that may be rig-ht if those protestations were wrong. And he will be faithieaa w his own declared doctrine of Liber- alism; but that may be right, if that doctrine is meaningless in these present circumstances. '

fippoaod To Reform

"As a matter of fact. I did not BXDect that the leader of the op- position will change his mind. I say this frankly and in fairness to him- Because. if his actions in any way reflect his convictions; he be- lieves in an economic and politi- cai doctrine which is forever oppos- ed i0 the changes of the character and nature to which i stand com- mitted; he is forever opposed, by profession of faith, to government regulation of business: he is for- ever against intervention by til: state; he is committed for all time, as a Liberal leader and a believer in the doctrine of iaissez faire, to do nothing. He is condemned for all time to stand on the side-limbs, and cheer when his country prosper: and weep and hide his face when it falls into adversity."

In the beginning, when capitalism was young, Liberalism had been in good circumstances. Mr. Bennett said. Then its doctrines were based upon capitalism that practiced in an open market-place with com- petition unfettered.

But in the changing economic picture of which he had spoken in previous addresses, developments which he said had destroyed the open marketplace, the Liberal party had not altered. "In the crash and thunder of toppling capitalism," Mr. Bennett declared, “it did noth- ing. It seemed to hear nothing. Lib- eralism was asleep at the switch."

In the pld days Liberalism "had a great plaoe in the scheme of things." Mr. Bennett said, "and had leaders who contributed might- ily to the wall-being of their couri- trfcs. They were patriots first and politicians afterwards." But the party had not kept abreast of the times. and seemed properly to be- long to a world of business and politics generations old.

“Liberalism is- toryism in the re- actionary sense of the term. just as present day Conservatism is progressiviem in the best and most constructive sense of the term.”

Listing among the faults and in- justices of the capitalistic system, "child labor, sweat shops. slave wages, long hours. inequality of benefits, low pri:es to the produc- er and high prirns to the consum- er," Mr. Bennett said these evils flourished and multiplied in con- ditions of unreguiatm business. when capitalism ran itself, the people. “and almost ran the state."