*

Sp vases «ast os ante —e Wie ;, EMRE FOL IG ee cat i t t The Lates t Libs! Suit. have étated the law- succintly thus: 7 : ‘ When there is a fair occasion for mak- cf ; THE STIVENDIARY MACISTRATE’S DECISION. ing the statement complaine d of it is i he 4] pot to be taken as. malicious though it —— mee ins ier 1} «2 , ik : } so , the : " — —< h mY *? Par 1 tlt is the pan texh a imay turn out to be unfounded ; In other i A Kt {) VA‘ ARON] . decision of the Stipendia ry Magistrate | words, that the inference of malice can- JAIN vi) . . : F ° ' P Lea the af — 5c a in the cise of Smyth vs, Lawson :— not be raised npon the face of the libel INY2-LB. TINS. it if ae it ther cases it might be . but : ee . Lael wv inh Lilet Ua 7 se a ee ee ee ee ee ee ee a — a : The vords com) sined of in this intfor- ee { “i Ovi : wie e ie i eh omanen : : that tnere must ve ) o}

‘ea contamer : ‘le the . * . ™ 4 5 | a , mation oe a es — ree | | plaintiff of actual @eXpress malice indepen- ri F 3 : VT; if -Of} } : . t aoe . ‘ . : a - mm’ Ee -

) manageine ntotfta publi institution . ie tle ntly of the evidenc of sucha feeling i. i babes O22 | ig t. VW id y : ~ ON 7 ar , A inca . Lunatic Asylur eevee e oy which the paper itself would seem to ° yun Pe ‘ utriment : ticular sitention is directed to the con ses Big A ; CPCI VEER eau t ' > . . : a typ | SUpPPly. of one of its offictals, the prosecuto . : ai a : ie da i ee rATU?T ' 4 wget ‘n | ace a ic! ' if this be What evidence of malice has been ATW i Kor INFANTS, CHILDREN & INVALIDS, | om auen caae, 10 ee i i in this case ¢ Positively none, manufactured in Switzemana, not a privileged com: nunication, I* have| proved in Chis ¢ . singer a 4 i The nosupported testimony or the Pp SC- no doubt is libellous. It is spoken of The unsup} truthfulness of the of IOT’S | him in relation to his office or calling,|Cutor as to the unirathfulness | JACQUO ¢ ; a Lata ar ») pre- 1 and, if crue, [ must presume would en- libel is att L bas heard, — Am I to pr - 3] ure his instant dismissal. sume malice from that} The authorities DEAL mPa UTA ; _ ara! aie | : . th if | cannot The anestion | a tte ey LAG ai It is contended that this writing may }ate Clear toatl tL cal oh as i | os anf uD L.: “yo? i a hether there 1s evidence of matice or Count a tel be divided into a statement of facts, and | WHE “ty herve Bip: ; eo the jury ] s ‘AR AHEAD OF AMERICAN AND — on . iot is for the jaage and not Jo ; 7 | a@ comment on these facts ; and inasmuch | no rr. ‘ M ‘ loch vs. McIntyre, 13 CANADIAN BLACKING. | as the facts stated are not libellous the] to Gecl le. MeCalloch vs. Mein Py ; ry r ‘ ’ > ASS is s coress decision —_—— 7 3 comment cannot make theui so. Phe v. U. r. ; gs he s a +t of Lord — “TS % : ; » judgment o words, “It is not likely that Dr. Blan-}upon this point, the J Ratt . 4 ' i RR, 7 j ; : cr. ie th ; yX 2 . ant . | chard was informed of this act of brutal- |‘ ‘am poe ‘ll in Cook uae ’ a | ity,” : loubt covyment on the fact |B, 326 being “ ‘re commente d Upos ens or | Tht y, are no do co : o ter of law for BHEIR aS i + ie “a? 3 ‘ at i ¥ that the prosecutor “ ill-treated ” the}contfirmed : t is A a ' . Liv i F | a rare aia ; he judce to determine whether the occa- patien Pineo ; but they are aiso, in my} fhe Jus i ig Maia oe ia Daina 880. opinion, used in a much larger sense asjsion of writing or repeating ¢ 2 7 i shite setasiincialaaitias descriptive of the indefinite term “ ill-jlanguage, which would ¢ itherwise be ; 7 le, , f . i e, 4s treated.” and must convey to the mind actionable, repels the inference of ae of the ordinary reader the impression constituting what is called a privileged <4 ; ahhe d : : : oe i rad | that the ill-treatment in this particular (communication ; and if at the close of instance vas brutal. It is not contended | the plaintiff's case there is no oe that such a charge if untrue and mali- evidence of malice, that it is the duty i cious would not be a libel on the proseu- jot tie jadge to direct a nonsuit, or a - . 1 f, <7 . : ;verdies for the defendant without leav-

tor.

The law, as settled ia the recent ¢ ase | in & the que ‘stion of malice to the jury

would be contrary

INSURANCE

AGRICULTURAL

£3

a TS,

| : i 5 Them 3 : oS F WATER? { WH, i. i

ORG SANIZED 1853,

oo for Vrotection of Policy ‘Holders,

t3 $1,137,549.73.

Deposited with the Dominion Government for Security of Canadian Policy Holders,

$100,000.00.

LOSSES PAID 5 To! DATE, OVER

$3,000,000.

arties desiring Insurance on Private Resi- dences and cortents, or Farm property, had better find tes, ete., of this Time Tried

DN

™ ; :

out r

), EY] é Cc n, r ents me {as ua dif rent course -- re ; of the Quee VS. irden, prev : a hoe ae A fhe me aud fire Tested Insurance Company, su? rane ae tr . nt rimece O WD? NCIC Ute oOuid ¢ prive l€ hot recelving evidence as to the tra hfaln f fo pl ; VW. R-C ted a . ‘ Pe ° > * e ari t eoci: id. — l Steers W2 od, of the libel. My jurisdiction is confined jest transactions of busin: = a2 ) a ial } anvassers want ; to the enquiry, upon a proper review of intercourse, of th ) protecsion W hich they . iR Angus, Special Agent for the Maritime the whole evidence, first, whether the;ought to enjoy. ' ae EEN S HEE Provinces. . Pn ' ‘ “malice is : scessary ingredient la ; se matter complained of is 2 llous, and it - on ki : ae ss . ae 5 JAS, DESBRISAY, ; »ther the ication of it}this offence—a Seamething nicl :us maoondly, whe on eee hee lie ol ist in the mind of the OR ar Agent for PL. EL has heon brought home to the accused so} be shewn to exist ia tke ming oOo CPtiuin au Ch town July 21, 882m te. ee ; De ae Be Z 7 } Un town, —3 far as ‘hat there ought t> be a commnt-} prisoner toward the _ pros —— bow 54] 4 sah 5.» dis dhe echt tical ae = Can the erime he } hi bad to have been co'n- Oo, Hou iv i ah ; z tal i} » tl t tjmitted if no malice be proved. Tn a —_—-= ~ Yo 1 te sttling es o! THE wuLY i TIRECE LINK Though I am fully aware that it is not) mitt , We hi Visi bes ottiing stores o} itty) Uijbd wv the province of the magistrate to deter- civil action for libel the judge is bound | { i others, and have aoe . . . . . ' | . ' tr ;f Ls of 2 :} > } s ry i} ’ ts Ha ples oO Hel i rane mine nice points of law, or to balance/to direct a nonstit if, whe ee libel | ye ‘ea ee aa ‘or * ‘ . . : —_~ toinast af ha alaariv TY awed ere | Pwehniana yy DISK 8na Rave 8UvjeCcte the evidence and decide according as it}complained of be clearly priviteg d,ther aE Phe Oe aR Ta: iti. oe O Os On. . . . | ‘ rerun . te MS _ . ~ tw . Se “>. | et os : Usk ‘ eUlilavivs 7 1 preponderates, it is his bouanden duty to/18 ho express ewdence of malice, Sure) . a. a, es were very frag- : > ° rf ¢ ; ruriat ee oa sa) va} ] j re 4 “et = r N's) - € > . orne e : : TS; a ia seal a — be satisfied that a crime has been com-|ly a magistrate cannot call that a erin | AVING on hand, and ar- ri mellow, & ant ax nd AE ss ! V4 ee ; 2 aaa et Oe i ne 0 seni “ . . , ps sed all the ara ristics ; pure - Z 7 ; ty mitted before he commits for trial the | ehich the civil judg propounces no} riving dailv 4, well select- p BEREOC : ~ na 3 of se ‘ Da . Fish! 7 ? ' and Weli-Maturea Scot Whisky of the} person cha irged with the commission of | !tbe!. ; JENERAT DRY Cont eratits : ~ TIT j 7 law lncioned!s th, x eneets -ed lot ot GEN 4hbdd 4 ! ut UU asv ys : + 3 Ny z : the ott Mice, Li bit 4¥ gesrene tanh tnro WS S Sp cial ei : . ; oe ‘ ru 1LT, ALY M D Ni Ba IMeTs aly S HP GBS ' ' Is this, then, a criminal libel ? Li protection arcund persons mi: iking ors GOODS, which they hope is “OD 8 ve. ~ LC e of ) idi whether it is x not it will|/ publishing statements which vices > l A +. ts (tae : San : decidi: g whe ~ r tt is 80 or notit wil ees sci aa i tha taste of lar ge enough for iy family to fe 5 . td 4 pote STEAMERS are fitted with . be necessary to deter nine, ™ CoM a . ae in th f chose from, take this ‘opportunity MISS ; CON Lae mas ft superior ‘assenger Aecommoda-e Ist. Is this article in the nature of yamanity, and for the good of society ; Ct ttetown, P. '} tion arranged for every convenience * . . ‘ i e I} + ; , 6 : what is termed a privileged communica- | prest pling that they are inade witho été to inform ‘their friends and th Feb. 24, 1850 | comfort, and | fitte Lup in elegant style. tion ? imalice and val ure intention. ‘ ‘hese | Clothes-wearing community that |- 2 : oe ee ere! re i 'Reient carried at moderate rates, and ag. s , P : “ , ‘ : ’ 1 10W @S by any other route, 2ad Lf 80, 1S it shewn } 0 be ri ali cious Is! fatemnents u ay be \ holly untrue, they | they intend to sell at lower : Nar ae ; Eaas, in boxe: 2 and barrels, handled with } i ; ; ) vat trhollane ? et GOLv i s, Box } f as wei! as untrue | late, nevertheleag, not libellous. Bat Te ‘pri ices than ever. Their New) } meoa:, 1878. | the greatest care, a1 r it be si ni that this privilege has been | . . ; t Campbell ws. ee ae ¥ éarcit 7" ee ie ew wkd oh ee j " 46 4 ° i N. 1077, a debian i: j rye, “ Ti babu d has been x -d tor inalicious Dress | Materials, in BEIGES WAVE ¢ ‘EE tRLoarT TETOWR . , wes Be . : ae | 4 hr. i ae, pi \ tlece’ Sign fies tha >t = { +6 wf fi nrvetivesa and 1 ALLLIY iis protection 18 | and CAMEL Ss HAIR, as well Steck Th sanarlactr nine t-aay 1} is af, 5 m. . rivi we ' a i ye : eit rs ~ = : it ' Liilitd BUG Fe tS ue } : sity attuel ‘who. by | Withdrawn, and the offender comes with: as other Dress Materials, will (aVoly Thubocey, BUNCCUAUY ab oP immunity attaching to a person w ho, by |" ’ ik : JOSEPH G SILLOTT’ S . ar re . i am ve oO Qt) ‘ ‘ ‘ ri iibal AW } . | 1 '? “ay =P 66 TEY sy sac reason of the circumstances of his posi-, ' vA grasp oF te erimings | eek i be found to be the Cheapest je ares Aue . ELAte BOSTON (196i 4 . : : : : 2 he euett oat t é nagistrates adu.y li Cases OF LbIS} * T nT, Sats oy mnnoatne | tion, is justified iu uttering or writing of | *) OBB eee lear is no (and most serviceable in the) | STHEHL PENS. | Lvery saturday, ) punotnally at 00m er, matters which, if uttered or) Sa 38, to Oly Uitue, Cear, He Las HO! ee : rt : a4 anoth do hemtper >» Cigd tent wae . vie teioht tovatanip tiie. tieark. of Crime’ on the market. | | BY ALL: DEALERS THROUGHOUT. THE ‘SRYELL BROS ai written by a third party, would be libel-|**>’ eed j cee 7 y WORLD. Aaa ¥ B48, o 5 . : . t ; hie : ters un SS [ie@ 18 - . ‘ } i lous or slanderous, as the case may be.) CICUSSION OF pubic tg S Gpitze © ? They call especial attention | Aczura. ‘ 7 : ry . my ri ist fier he buslce Ol ti e writer, an¢ 2 iY CO ave 4. ; V1, 94 0 any , < at} Po wy And Sir William aoe In eee bit ie a es a roe ; ' 7 to their WINCEYS & STAPLE ; Ch’town, June 3, 1550—2aw mW, AF. Re « . ~ . Stn bieet t Ot mole Cgoot wu - . é aa SEE Bird, 2 F. & F., 503, says, “The law is ee oe ee cn Thos nor en catig.| AOODS, of which they carry o| semsemesanm sere. =| ( doteh ’ versonal defamation. [I am not so satis- v é e | IMPOR ¥h AN = SALE that a mao may publish doled atory i: at | , 20M lete stock. 4 eo femen 4 | P x fat ter of anether holding any public em- ied oP a eee e ‘ 4 mac § PSS3. | tee 3 Lie points raised by the defendant's The Mi hi j tme t : ! i ployment if it is a matter in which the 10h, on ir iviillinery depar n ounsei i 6 th section, 20 Vic-{.- i ity pen — a re A how: Ags i avert. 25. . i t neces r r for mat 18 replete with ever + novelty 713 VALU ABLE PROPERTY, : | ‘ cs di iii Ww oria, cap. tis not cessary tor me R i { w : mae asses. ‘ei : - > _ =. “. 8 Soe — a ai its Jaid do nit dec ded case Every aE Mig cath ienaRatent heii Ge Me PROPER PRICES. Seek RD RET RCRA FF person has the right to comment on the} er et af . ’ ee : ti , - . a SH u ier” bes, i 4 G pa a SS El . : E : ‘s ) tties by o' her at iigher autbor-} r te ‘ i Ss Pee © | Ss 6 aad agi : . acts of a public man which concern him} | be settied : - 3 ~. e 7 ye They feel that all they need ine G 8 Ee p & Be O& fey iP SXRE Directors of the CHARLOTTETOWN i J te decision is e hoped | | “ a TOMAT NT 1 asa subject of the realm if he do not |! LY, ene os es of . sty say about their MANTLES is : “B) & wo LEN . \UFORY COMPANY offer for, i¢ wiil ensure a untform practice : : L RaAS ass nf - itor Sale their Valuable Property situated e * s 2 vehicle malice ar ' . A heacicmne, ret 4 rink, perty = eer er eee er , fin soimportenta matter as the taking of that they are much superior in E fe MCCICINE, EOL & LTINKs, H Spring Park. ‘the property consists of One inder 3 hi ie com- : ‘ : ao, } oc Sie, eh teee na , Cc. heaper in: ei Acre of Land, with the Buildings therees, ments aie justified provided the defend-|° - al evide ere eee Style, = , 2 ge aa NTAINS Hi Eugine & B iler, Shatting, Boltwg and.com- > accused Must de aiscuarge AS 2 as ; 3 i Ba } ant honestly believed that the y are fair] - eo —— eT pais ae — price than last a l this et ij| plete Heating apparatu s throughout the whole he information iaid In this matter, r i tay rg] ; : ; 1 and just. With that limit siion the law fre information iaid 1 bis matt saying a gre eat deal, iteeat it 1 18 EGG PS, BRE EE, MRANBRAKT, m{b building. 2 he ize of the Main B suilding is 80 | , ee ; 7. . acer meemens ennmencomeany meen DAN BERION bs | X 50 feet, three storics hi gh, besides basement, allows the publication.’ The American People. known they were at least 10. i Poe ory eee ee if | Engine Hoase of Brick’50 x 30 Yet together Public attention is ith this article | a } 1. 1 suffers miuel per cent. cheaper than any aA eH UREST AND Brest MEDICAL QUAI Elw with @ large Building attached and used by drawn to malfeasance in office by a | abel ae eee in. the.world suffer ry eee : . fF 1ES OF ALL OTHER BIVTERS. _ i the Company as a lychouse. The Engine lic C hi i i il a } al li institution Is! with Dysj epee - a i‘ a Aithough other House in the city. B is 30 horse power and was built by Messrs’. Tcia 1 pubiic ~ on, 3 5 a a F Te powes od ag oa years of experience it 1 medicine had tailed to ‘ ee oe se 2 2 Oe & | Montgomery & Softs, of Hialitax, in 1871, and this wrong in itself? Assured!y not. The Aecomplish a certain and sure ice for, Lhe Subscribers are confident IEP Cr IT eR: Biecct there about. 65600: : Pea journalise has no hi gher duty ; ; sone this cisease and its eflects, acs as Sour they can please, and therefore , oe | Boiler are in a complete state of repair ao: more necessary for the well-being Stomach, Heart-burn, Water-brash, Sick invite the public to inspect their 4 Aut Disea es of tl stomacl Bowels ei almost as good as new, ‘jt here is about 60 feet of society Through the Press the peo- Headache, Costiveness, palpitation a the a iood, diver, Kidneys an d ours Cr be of 3 inch Shafting together with the Han \é learn of the os ane of their officials ‘Heart, Liver Complaint, coming ‘nai of the Goods before purchasing else- svans, Nervousness, Mleeplessness, Female®! The Main Driving eit cost about $300 and is 1S Cc , i elr © Cla 8. ! ¢ - <2. ee oi : : nilainte « : bs | .: Tepe ; a re ta . 8 my 7 lay will argue that the public food, low spirits, general debility, etc., yet where. ie. Oui} laints and ERrURBReRESS, Bt uilte aS goud as hew. The Steam Pi for lh ye wi “ 4] Pp puMle’ since the introduction of Green’s August 9 ‘ae baat: ds ole oF ene ravens throughout the entire build- . - ‘ * . rece ih . ° . 9 5 © n st it us s hav ono right to Know, or the fress tO’ Fiower we believe there is no case of Dys- ' S$i6eG iti COLI E me fail i nee . cot te ret yg sa = inform them. pepsia that canuot be immediately relieved. , a oh ake notte roi oY n uiticlont ae eee 4 : q 1B r } ‘ Tes ry ne i Wil i Pai for case tv! r vill 1 t cures} } , ri ac vagy « __ can Iticannot be contended that this writ- 50,000 dozen sold last year without one > | aot "s oa aap ph emu a triacs ne ‘ari be obtained for any purpose jauieel, : case of fal e reported ‘ ; , “ior. (mor heip, or for anything imipure or myuri-gi ~ ‘ : < . ing is not fairly warranted by the occa- aie ve Pa es ae ican — 'Bous heaped in Shes - ; : is tor further particulars apply to either of the oie * ‘ , a “¢ BY ‘ . H . . Ad sion which calls it forth, or that the sab. = get Rete ne te wore \@ Ach D 5 Bee Ke eee ip | Undersigned. ‘and try it. Two doses will relieve you. im 488m your Drugeists for Hop bitters anck | HENRY LONGWORTH lic have no interest in the iInanagemebe | Regt ilar s size 75 cents. '@iree books, and try the Bitters before your | akon reece Presiden: of the institution, — lt is, _to my mind, | a ippleep. take no other B D. RK. M. HOOPER, : . . . ' | , ae = 4b ED q Uuee re st +4 shi be | ay >IT ‘ yr its utterances on behalf ot * the most! copy 7 i f bed-rid- on co — oe au Hani ALBERT SIMPSON, . +9 7 ‘ * > sun ) ng y ELettref ts the Chesnest. “yw: : helpless of God's creatures ;” in its pur- Se ee eee fetief 's the Cheapest, Smrest®) eh Secretary. port as drawing attention to that which, | ~ on nd sefiening, ues = + Fm act ee ee : BY rom tota 200—all which was stoppe< ee See —ssineaiih titel oa if true, most assuredly required instant, 2 Si leo ee aa —_— a ee 2 . |! | ; oe eo by three bottles of Hop Bitters taken by For Save By W. R. WATSON anvil pens. F. Gaarrox, Srone fi. Eade action at the hands of a christian people ; my wife, who has done her own house- APOTHECARIUS HALL q Haserr E. Paine, as containing nothing on the face of it, work for a year since, without the loss of a [mar 5, S03) peel se 5 teat . 5 ee ce a ae le lalla atin . which destroys the fair presumption that day, ee i want ev erybody to know it tor = PRs i G sabe Gowniiesroner oO aients, e * . = ayy : — Tanke FS Mn “eo cede Pin fie it is written honestly without were theit mo : . > Menno _— ee Bi > : : sé a. ul > ; ee acne ' ly . and for the public good, oun Werks, Butler, N.Y.” a : j 5 A es AS to the second point the law ap: | sOUT and I Me al. ° ars now to be well settled “ that when FOR SALE on 19 LET, ee zt }

the libel is clearly a privileged communi- cation the inference of malice cannot be raised on the face of the libel itself, but extrinsic evidence of actual express malice: must be given and it is not to be taken tobe wialicious; although it may

must’ prove the statements to be false as well as malicious.” Robinson, C. J., in Melntyre vs. McBean, 13, N.C. Q. B. 534, in giving judgment is reported to

| }

/ ee ABLE i ituated Dwelling House with large | yard, Sead stable and coach house attached. |

Also to Let, near King Square, a Dw elling | House with outbuildings in good repair, | suitable for a small family. tent.low. For

and conveniently)

turn out to be unfounded ee: plaintiff particulars opply to

# LONGWORT Sept. 28, ’80—1m

UY the DAILY EXAMINER for the! latest news—-iocal and telegraphic,

H & HASZARD.

aT Ten eee a On ar Ta

!

(DE RS wii be received for the follow-

g Brands of Flour and Meal !— (Pa ten ** Alabaster,” “Golden Z Pg “Extra Family,” ‘“Warcup’s oe. perior,” ‘‘ White Kose,” ‘* Florence,”

? 6. ft. A eud ¥ .

and ‘‘ Amber,” and keal—‘‘ Golden Star.’

** Beaver, choice K. D. Corn

Ch’town, Sept. 22, 1880.

Quotations ior the above Biands of Flour and Meal f. o. b. at Mails, or delivered at

Charlottetown or Summerside, . J. R. POSTER Millers and Shippers’ Agent, May 6, 80. Moncton, N. B,

PAINE, GRAFTON & LADD,

Attorneys-at-Law and Solicitors of Americas and Foreign Patenta,

— : way

412 Firra Srreer, Wasnrtneton, D. C.

Practice patent law in all its branches im the Patent Office, and in the Supreme Circuit Courts of the United States. Pamph- iets sent free on receiat of stamp for Postage, septa — (UBSCRIBE for the DAILY EXAMINER” the Cheapest and most Newsy a published in the Provinces,

ea