l PRIIJ 11, 192s

We p _ hgoleum fijohtjyloprimatsttothe largest room size. (Inputs. ge pfjtlesigns andznew low prices are sure to _satis,fy you.

" .

I

made to the people

H J __.- _ these beautiful,

l . fin 4 ‘ fbw-priceifl rugs

I

l ' ‘ ‘ -. - " . .| HRIFTY housewives will be quick t0 , recognize the unprecedented xaluep . now ofleredin Congoleuni Gold Seal Rugs at the new. lovver-than-ever prices . . prices that qfler tremendous savings. . ; Patterns . . ahenew-tfiyl! rarvgertow at yourderllefsis the most beautifulyou have ever seen . . . new French rug patterns . . . Ceramic Tile effects and gorgeous Oriental" Motifs ‘are lvell re- presented in theseeosy-to-clea

‘ - ' '- or. r t , , Improved ' The new. lliiilticolevijtiiltfidi BQlio greatest improvement in yeah! . l’ . longer wear is built right into, and throughout, the thick long qjlfellfing surface . . . of course,Co ‘golefiin Gold Seal Rugs are all Guaranteed by the I ‘Cold Sealon rhesurfoce. t» __ l glgalrlcbjlf the"snvlwlflryw?fl_ 9 x l2. ‘left lire Forrrlerly $:!:.0 ' '2 f

the electorate that -he

day.

. some question.

W

91101 .7

i)‘ 7h t. 1| t v_

9 I 6 " " " 7.50 “ 6.75 .~ 9x ‘L; n ll .- r, u 5 o.

. .50 . - Other llzoa tire reduced in proportion.

OLElJM

39th? Rhos

‘ist-___________--__-1‘ ;1270 St. Patrick Street. Montreal. 66B L Congoleum Canada Limited. _ |

Send me. without cosr or obligation, a copy ol your ‘ latest booklet ehtnlul "Charming Colour Schemes That ' | Con! So Little." I c‘.

oi . _ Satisfaction Guaranteed t . . for the Gold Sea! on rhuurfoceflt is your only positive untur- ance of genuine Con. goleum. A i. The Gold Seal stunt]! ‘. l for our Guaruntee of ‘all-faction and the belt value your money can huy.

proposed o,

uolzld- be. l your ago. Mr. Speaker!

‘i.

e‘?

of patterns and sizes in GoldSeai

tile taxes so soo '>" . n.

(liilllhnd pliYottwill-be convinced. M t, 1 gpjlufion m make bomwmgs. c 5E ;BROS. LTD.

14-)! ‘

é

aguixi to deal with

..¢.¢_.-._._..-l---

=w\.~.»...u|t-tVt-. I _-»--v--vvt---..-_.u- -

nuts."

after year; there was

. ' mflttél‘ Of

them there.

debates.

SFACTORYJ

;%i1.t;"'gRfiifilpllsfllNG l I .

0Q@\mthis signzrltmeaue that We L a ffillyililthmized to refints your

ca“. Wm. Genuine Dl_l(‘t)-~und€I-‘ t e com- v

House.

‘M ' 5 '5"Ph’diie or‘ tall and let us give you an ' éstiililélté'<)i“tl1'c cost and a delivery date.

V‘ l .

‘ M061. W)‘ ‘ru d‘

l ' ‘a s‘ 'I).'\*'J0l3|l-"1\I"‘ i" l

‘i a mu (‘E STEWART & 00., LTD. _ Grrxtt-fieorge ‘Tu-ret-

. l r FUN; Mim- i. VARNISI! LIMITED. roltouro. ONTARIO

have used Nervlllne

llllN. l. B.

(Continued from page 1) l might tell you, Mr. Speaker. hS earned we have no ambition inthot‘ I have told this House before. that regard at all. ' the reason why we proposed that re- with these briefs in the way that ductlon of taxation was because we oratorlcal contests are being dealtl were endeavor-lug to fulfil a promise with in these days. in 1923, vand that that our cluims for increased sub-, was one of the planks in our i923 sldy..shollld be placed before the} platform. that we would endeavor to Duncan Commission if we‘ were to obtain from the Federal Government have oul‘ YiEhts. an increase in federal subsidy and came here and the brief was pre- rnore especially with regard to public sented. and you know the result. land; and that if we succeeded ‘ ’ ;ettlng that, we would then give she people the benefit of thht in- crease by reducing the taxés-"Thls measuring the respective ‘value of statement, I believe. has been ques- tioned m the House; someone-raised hy- the results they obtained. me 011953011 Whether 01' 110l- lihdl have-as a result of this brief, or as? was l“ our 91am" m- Bu‘? WW1’? 1S a result of something, the favorable.’ no question about that: it. lsthere decision or the Duncan Commission for anybody to read who_wiil_h0n.~ with regard to our claims. We have estly and carefully read our plat- the whole field- opened up, we have mm‘ °f 19234 A5 1 Salli beiqlfflvlt received already on annual addition was in imnlementotlonol:rupture: of $145,000 to our subsidy. and the. elecf/iflll Pfomlse that W? Wore grey wholematter opened up for investi- ‘111111118 WXRUOH- Whfll @065 my litm- gatlolt and examination. That was friend nay now about this‘ mettorfwthe result of the Duncan COm-l Since then things have happenedl Nemesis has caught up with ‘hlmilf The chickens have come home to by the late Government. roost. I do not suppose he ever ex-I '1 a Pected» when h? made m“ prllmlsellhatter of the Duncan Commission; m °rder m gum m9 mnfidance ("lat this stage. but as referent: to it‘ _ , _ ‘Wuld findihiisbeen lllildt} by my hon. lriend himself m the situation he doesto-fl (gay that it is necessary {or me w what 5°95 l"? Si)’ 110W?" "Bi-shy a: word or two with regard to it, blames usfor reducin taxation nowqMy ha“, (fiend made a Statement,‘ He says hobodyasketl-us tocrfldwfl last night in his speech which in! m9 W-XES- I “HEM Mk hlmYUWunahy ways. Ilhink. did not do him I Who Bslwll IIUl/lfany credit. It is a statement which. "t" mike "W llffliwfill M- tho Just-I believe he has rnude before. and: session of this House? I wan: t0;it is this. that I hud nothing more 59-3‘ m my 110“- frlcfld tint l-vc»hl\tl‘}to.do.wltli obtaining the $40,000 sub-l finruch more honest and stralghtqsidyjn lieu of railway taxation than gmard Tells“) l“ W!‘ DYOImsalthAn; the man in the moon. Perhaps my e had for his. _Wc made our reqlicn. friend is better acquainted dmmm l“ WW5 l“ pursuance of “with, the man in the moon than ll Prfidwl/“In Promise and to keep. am; but I do not think his lllngllllge

upon which we were elected;

in

faith with the people. if I can road‘, was very elegant. m)’ hm!- lrlendis mind arlght, he'wzts logical when used by one who _ reduction because hej is so ready to lecture others. angled to use it as a vote-catclterfi‘ statement makes it necessary for me ' c‘ comes in now and wants Z05“) say something again with regard l-m" Why We reduced the taxes. A‘, to that matter. V911? 1150 he tznve us the reason, that‘ “'6 Were imitating him. Bu’. HD-l never made any purtlctllur clalln. in lmrermy h‘? “mum ‘wt "mm"? him-l this House or elsewhere, with regard >clf today if he had the opportllnl , W- bficilllsc he says that if hc were} this $40,000 subsidy. But I Shflll fillrgfikta d0 "' today he ‘V9915 hill/cl plnce the facts before the House. as duce thlggllfld first’; he Uvouldnkre- I have done before, and leave the around TtilxesL until he had lookcu mutter there. A u e - It e 0rd only knows what our claim for this subsidy hadbeen _t resu of l’llS looking aroundlpending for some years. It was an He did not say that alopen question in the time of

he says. “But how can we reduce that far some of the Provinces had m’ ma h Well, he is do- been getting revenue ifdid "Y t!" 91' things qultc ent-ly. source; that is, " in the provinces‘ uinund It? bulk‘? Film 1mg to Jzelnwhere there were company or COP-t m“ as °1P°Wlflg lllfllley. it islporatllon owned railways. It had rci‘ _* ca”: ‘@9355 legislation to lbeeu before the Railway Board be-

“m lax“ as l‘ IS l0 pass lcgisLt- ‘fore, rind before the Railway Com-

Provincittl claims

l referred lust night for .21 lllQlllfillt fr: the matter of our claims. Iwfln that subgflil- briefly. As I said before, my <1“- . friend has run true to form in this. \ When there was not anyl-hlng ““‘_ medistely in sight he termed 0L1! claims for increased subsidy ‘ He has told us that thlsmnt- ter was debated in the Housefwl‘ not a year since he came into this Legislature that there was not a debate on this increased subsidy- would not like to go that for._ _ 1w"- mend has bee“ a yea" m mo Provinces any money until they harl

- ' - '- I l " {felgll-‘lba? Itilgngrglggx? 152:; yearrlgli’; all the Provinces together and had

which the matter was not tit all. There have been years dur- ing the regime of the Bell Govern- ment “m” whey had one or molmuch they should set.

‘ 1dbt,lditisqultc . . (lny (luilnfisfriirlrid took part "ml the suuatmn m 192a Th?" mllney

those. because that was the custom in those days. to discuss these things ' in an academic manner and leavc

‘ ' chest-

My

‘iscussed 1

honcfrlends proclivity. I can \v believe that he would not lose th K opportunity of taking part in those;

Kmwlng “S I d‘) mylsethet" in order to‘ make ~l- dviqion-

A cor ago my hOfl.lfl'l-Qnd.be¢t1.ll3 .. - _ to that perhaps there might he‘ i “m going w mm [ms credit‘ be " ' sornelthingdn this matter- of our "I claimsi that it would be, to his pollta ical a. vantage to espouse, thcm; an coniereme o; “mi The conespolh so hebegnn to take a more, active. dance Ivsublmtted ilartdn the mutter. Just about thfltlsho\vs {hm i had bee“ writing rm- tlnrevdt. was that we were coiled upon pmcucauyjpyeal. m the Prime Mm. m gram“ a brief or argument miisters of other Provinces, and more ‘ _. be . resented to the Duncan Com-mspeciany td-‘those of Ontario and

' -- . mlsskm when ‘he Qmnmlssmn waslQuebvz-c urging‘; conference because Llcgtlly ‘m (ltg mung of the Mamlmq. cusst-tl between the Ft-tleml Govern- ‘ I‘ smmg m this Province To” ‘hep-In- it had been “agreed that any Inter- representatives and they had to do pose of taking evidence add obtnink‘ ' ‘ l ing information with respect to ourmaucd by £11.05‘: two Premiem right to increased subsidy. Another < ~ - - brief has been presented recently by wrow m them “me and “mm “um Mo“ this Government M. the Inter-Pro- vincial Dominion conference. held n

I anrlcnd the conference. _”_ ‘reply. and that also was published. They agreed to attend. and as n re- sult of that all the parties got to- ‘ MUS. Carp€l1ter|gether and the division was made‘ 0 d0 this mm“; a ma“ of u“. Lyn? l land that subsidy was made available who’ “men he 59y his hang to m.‘ fmd WM D8111 0V" l0 this Prmlmcfi plough. did not turn buck. I refer to ' Tllflt i8 the BWTY- A5 1 5am helm?‘ Qlr Andrew Roe Duncan. We hntl I the result in the Duncan Comlnis- Blmllly did Whflf- 598mm t0 be m. slonls report. and ns a result of thnt t we obtained the interim pa); $125,000. That payment was ed by the Duncan Com- made annually as

til such timeas. lwholc matter could bethornugll- investigated and a final ntljtlst- it and adjudication tnudc with urd to subsidies between nll the

amt" --’~"’"'“"' i '- "plel;/e.,.D.LTC0 System specified by Flint . Paint -&-=Varnish, Limited (Sole Cana- dian Manufacturers of DuPont Duco). . m‘ ‘ f e ui ) ed‘ our Work_ tlt this conference is better or worse‘ glltjeitsiir l’ iris gilt? workmanship l” ‘h? ’°"“°"_°fff”°'"m°"‘~ ‘iym N h@Sl)H(3:Q-)1V1’§PPI}‘I()VC(l. ’ ‘Testimony Of

-,.., Tolls now She Remedies ColdStl Chills and Cramps

Rothesay, N. B.—For the benefit of mahy mothers who don't know just what to do when sudden ills overtake the children, Mrs. H. L. Carpenter gives good advice: ' "For the last three years." she states, “ll have used Nervlllne, and I flnd it a, wonderful medicine. In our home we; for neurnlgltrj colds. chills and cramps. In each‘ mac Nervlllne has given wonderful;

CHARLOTTETOWN_ GUARDlAhl“ W

PAGE? THREE

rllAllT . touts T0 suntan

qultesure that so for as we are con-, We are not dealing;

_ ‘ Our brief was prepared because ll. was necessary]

The Commission

Thc Real Test. l submit, if there is any means of

the briefs, they should be measured We

lssion’s report after an examina- on of the brief that was presented‘

id. not intend to go into this

l do not think it‘ His

, I submit, Mr. Speaker, that I have]

Ask fol‘

’ ' gentry

- -i-=..

J,-

x

SAVE THE“POKER HANDST j

o my right to credit for securing

lt 1s quite true that

the Bell Government. because even buck

from this

mlttee of the House of Commons. jThot is perfectly true. Everybody ‘recognized the claim. but nobody in

any concrete endeavor to have that claim realized upon. I submitted correspondence a year ago and tabl- ed it in this House. That corres- pondence is still available; it was published at the time in the press of this Province, and it showed that the attitude of the Railway Board wasp-that they were willing to pay the Maritime Provinces the money. but they are not willing to pay it until till ‘the parties interested got together and came to an agreement. so that everybody would be satisfied. They would not [my the Maritime

"l

the Western and Central Provinces. which were already getting mQ11cy_

should also get. this money. and how That was

lhad been available for many years but lb W118 not paid because of- the fact that nothing had been done to Ect all the parties interested; m.

elgilllld appropriation of it.

" ‘The Conference of 1926-: kcause the correspondence clearly

shows that l um entitled to it. Thnt

to this. Hottsc

these Maritime Provinces had made

agree that the Maritime Provinccsl

is, that I was responsible - for- tho|

. Give them all they W811i. i

VIOCOANUT

Delicious, wholesome, pure and satisfying for cl1ildrcn——

Ch“ tithes

In Hu- llon: or t on‘ {be flibune‘ alwayr ask for

of flooring the sthtement reiterated that the subsidy was granted upon the recommendation of the Duncan Conlmission, was a free gift, and came from the lntmificent hand oi the Mackenzie King Government. That, of course. is not truc. Thc truth is. we got it because of our own struggles in these Provinces ta

of right that we should get it; be- cause we were legally and equitably entitled to an increase. That is the reason we received that increase of subsidy. The Mackenzie King Gov- ernment was driven to? take this tcottrson Why? Because-flirt the cam- paign of 1925 welntow. what their heir 'itt__tltude~ was

' éncéf "Ilicyilever cx-

. cssed sympathy oc..cven know-

ledge of our situation down here.

But. the results of me election of

1925 opened the eyes of the Kim; Government.

in thatclectiott from the Maritime.

Provincial conference

. I am not claiming credit for it. duty to the Province. and I am quit

lfor what they have done.

' . .. in‘ the stomach. f live ln the coun-

WR-lllorfinrvvr-"Wlreuh. "er t»! rue-radar. . .

y}

many mitt] in the Irm-

'~' »‘"‘--l‘"“~“- ll" ’ try and find Nervlllno hheeessltyhtlll l. The“ is only 0N5 W°~DUP°NT 9"“ o» l? " » ' lly/K-Mrs. H. L. gprpenler.

i1. _ v w.

rt--

The Duncan Commission. l

l

theyfound a convenient date that ‘would l"? “liable W a“ ‘he Parlles- House of Commons have been blam- fcw months ago. and the mutter (flags! tgfgeggggggirggengagrrxl; 0323s,? both briefs has been discussed in the m“ that conference was called n newspapers and on the floor of this my repeated requests m ma“. other My hm‘ friend "m" wlthPrelnicrs It shows that after llv ms 5pm‘ M k“lght'err“““y' hasldatc oi [the conference had been ccnccivcd the idea. that there is a-fixed and after an the represenuh Scmfi‘ between ‘he W“ pmfiesl “Sltlvcs of “the different Provinces had o w ch party presented the bettel~agr€ed w nmmm I wok It upon m),

l

- tunlty of huvlng this mutter settled. ‘than the bnef presented a year ngolmld I0 5118865“ m!“ "163! Sllollld "l-fficvernment chose as the ehairlnan‘ T llfld the" l that Commission a mun of ex- who

willing, and everybody ls willing. to, w“ give the Government of Canada and lthc Railway Department full credit

But, you can see lust what the mo-. uve of my hon. friend was. and how_l mllchmlnrerll-ymnd fairness was in; hint, when he made that .‘ temcnt r last night on the llmr of this House.‘ tthat I had nothing whatever — no‘

fwd’ n" my children I empwylmorr than the man in the. moon-lo‘

N°"""'° “r Qhms‘ “l” “d W“ do with obtaining that subsidy.

‘ I ,1 would nnl an into this discussion b l-Itnny further. but I nm rnthcr tirctll$l2 .000 subsidy. Well. if that was:

Provinces. As my hon. friend from‘ of "ml? Souris has already very well stated hot-c.

l llnued? lrltliculotls. when the present Gov- made. M

get. it. and because it. was rl mutter-crnment obtained power that was the was done,- _ v ,situntion injwhlch we stood. and There was n0 fB8°luu°P~ 5° l" as '

They bud practicullypcgard to st _ _ l 'u solid phalanx of Maritime Rightersi fcrencc could have nccomphshetlqnrc rest-iv n5

t. . < ' . -; .Th ..-f' i.'. ill the do any- llflym?“ Sen up as representatives to Ottau l I ‘hifizqliatzvgtllttls suite taccorylnlishmm “m? step or one inch nearer‘ an“:

nb/o the formal rcporfintljuslment which will‘ glvo us titted-t

. ____:______ the recoinlrnendation of the (‘om-‘ mfilll» and U19 vYePlTFfinl-a-liilves‘ 0i m?‘ mission that this should be paid an- different Provinces. T at reiigl!’ nually until a more complete ztntfsltmvs i115‘- m‘? 795981“ ‘h? wagemwn; final odlustmem was made. and thelccl diglcusggg E3‘: so far - ~ ‘ - rou - King (xtwefflmflll accepted that re 2:5 the agenda or the re-pon which

commendation why should there be _ _ any doubt. of {he subsidy being‘ con- has been tabled in this Hose is ca: The suggestion is simply corned-rm" FY0055 "l" V"

ulith regard to- subsidy.

lthat is the situation. Mr. Spcakelxllllc 11300115 511W’? the“? was not: m which wcjstill stand. There wnsyfvfll n suggestion that this ""1"" only one elfbctivc thing that could \'~'fllll'll_ l1}? dell" Wm‘ by "- Special lhavr been accomplished at this ln-.C$»mll'\\$5\°ll' ‘Vhether M the ‘nous? ltcr-Provlnciusl Dominion conferenccnlol commons or by a commit 6v 0 ‘and that was‘ that the arrsngements- We“ Mimlunisilnl-s» °r bYme SW ‘might have lbcen agreed upon lrvllffmfl COW‘! 0!‘ any llld-lflfll 5°58 ‘which this final adjustment woul<l,l\'<>l'\\iX\E “ha-lulu W“ 1593mm“;- be consumm ted which was rccom- ‘ ‘upended m 1 é Duticmt rcpor_t-.-allcl-\ll¢;'~}ll “ll-h l“ um" 9°m°nu°e Wm‘ ‘by which av cry Province would hnrorvgflrd l0 "N". 50 "I89 $110.11“ 1'9‘. on ndjustlncnt- of subsidy. I my; was the. my effective [hing with stand exactly on the some busls as

t of $125,000 and we. are not

I l (he ngtlrfla of that prmfoy-‘illcrl-uscd subsidy which we are still

it. they were driven-they were prnc- t-ncc. the precis of the tnnllcrs tlls-‘llflltinfl fllifillv“ hill“! WY-

Slitlllld bcyus the Maritime Provinces dictated; I and so they proposed that Commis-

The Conservative ed because they opposed that Com

an investigation of the situation; what they maintained war

that the matter could be better mid dealt}

lnore efficiently and quickly with by n committee of the House

‘was intentional or not.

iérlence, ability and energy. was not tainted with Canadian pol

Cl

l t

l 4

t‘

O\lllC(‘S and the Dominion.

The Net Result of the i921

. I.’ Conference.

l0

‘l

tmrty in tlr.

mission. But. they dill not oppose Warltimcl

and in view of what hud transpired‘ previous to that. when matters had be me F?!“ s???“ 5° his m?“ “flsell to notify the Railway Depart - been referred to Con,- ‘ggigns, tho-y. not h“ s}, f f0 men w‘ “m” or m l merit that this conference was being veers not far astray. Fortunately fOfl

' re w c was presemedlhcld and that there was on 0mm!" the Maritime Provinces. whether it. thc King

t hns been said that if the con-l lice of last. November had not} l held we might have lost the‘ vor-