macmiiirsorrarowaouziiinizin

“('19s by the way 1 ' ’ 1 who!‘ THE cgioRfgi/ioniiovv

.___. ,

0N. RICHARD B. BENNETT Isl V h C ed I —-—S-—- M I

-~-=~- ~==-~-=-~ we B P -.:.':"'..".i::.r...:*:.'..r" the columns of The Toronto Globe in Nicola Tesla. by Paul n“! its leading editorial artiele on “The l HE inventor of the alternating, ‘Conservative Leader.“ The tone of‘ ‘ elfctric currennfial-(cl: lighiiting. thl; 1th? article is discriniinatingly laud- gtahng 13352:??? h; do??? nfuglcimgo ‘story. Wc ouotc a few pessages:~, h ’

Qualifier!» 440 a ALL KINDS 0F FOOD NECESSARY

FKGEFOUR‘

i lit llllllllllllllllll intuit

lords; Dali; uouilni iulm IBM nu you (ti: ulvuoo) bunni- IAJI Ill In: (In dunno) nnliod in Cumin uid Ulllod am».

President-W. Choline l. Italian. vltl-n resident-J. B. BIIIIOB- revolutionize business and “vmg com "Hon. R. B. Bennett has many of

aim and longer-H. n. BIIIIMIII- ldizlodus of hunganily. 13o; at eotius .. t ~ - ~ - ' ' v‘ an an omna ing Hunters-Lion. Uni. l). A. bluelilnuoii. Ii. a‘. 0.. l 1119 111311951 Quahtms ‘equugd fo‘_ mm ls as x r l _ "leadership and has other BCKIIOUIQS‘

as one of his great electric trans-

, _ _ , mitters. - .41 §"WhlCh place him in a posltlon to bc_ "cf- real service to the country. eith-

“When the telephone ivas intro- . - duced 50 years ago." he said. “rneh _ "cr as Prime Minister or as head of‘ It is certainly praisetvorthy when looked upon it as a_ miracle, and , an individual finds him or herself Raul’ klreflused t0 believe llayosslblc; . . . . . . ettin overwei ht to attem t to re- 81 1 9 1111mm "M? 9°" 9 m1“ Liberal Conservative party when it [Wsed imam“ hm‘ Ls’ t1?“ he Ism- guce tghis weigtfi tdsoine exgent. fled 01'“ a ‘V110 1v‘? know n?“ ‘haf! “ ‘~ ' O detailed announcement hag t 1 d with Ovemmenxall clined io be autocratic in tempera-l A few are brave enough and wlspthe human voice can be carried ovei Mg t 15 e“ m5 e 3 “men! and it has been held that hisenough to take exercise. which notla “1119- and 111 111B Item future wire-I‘ - Yet be" "W" 11y 111° G°v°mf authority. is assured. There will beluamllallon Wm, ]afge corpqmllnngbnly takes of! weight. but gives lélsligrigephglxng bjtlllfle“ rfigxlfirflztgxzf}. l .1 ,. k ‘i; ti 2.4!; "191" 111 T991? 1° 111° d°1*3a11°“ Qt no tinkering or adjusting of policiesfmight interfere with that broad and m??? Qrlfioflttrl?nggrsvelzfigssdfliclde w ‘ 1

points, will be a common occur- " . ' the Temperance Alliance, but it is to n16“ 56mm,“ denumdg Ea“ “sympathetic point of view which a m, down on the“. intake. nghuylrengi; 11111118: Qmtd‘? rlglnngngl‘ .3 0 ~ 9,. .. . , ~ v - I - . - _ ‘. " L’ ll E‘ l5 211' 1S Ell \\' (‘I ' understood that there willbe no Fall came and we“ have agreed on; 1:41 elem?‘ gehmim 1104' "Ward 111 feelillgfthzziat il titifii clot not lgkewve ma“ have wireless televlslon Hl , _ "C 35S S O OD Q. [HUG OO Ill 0 C 5Y5 em. Cy , - .» ~ e lo“ of [he Le lslalure as me Al- . , - ,~ l __ _ _ i _ y . vhith means that it will be possible 2 . - s‘ ss I 8 l _ lines “hlCll will meet the commonl n ls doublml ll “mag palms w“ Camlol pul on much “elghl: “or a ma“ m New York not umy m p 11am“ 111111°1Pa1°d- and “111911 we“ necessities of all and N01” m“ "'°*‘n5 Se" dem“ amiltalk to his friend in Paris or Salt - . . ‘ S U P P 0 S E your children that, but; enough life inaur-__.

the COTIICI‘ --l;,' -g Cl d v l ~ l 4 _ _ _ _ _ ' Nor . - ti‘. 1e e ~35 .“n mramng {T012 m“ tmlnmg "1 5°11 ‘1911131 15 ratheflFrallClSCO but to see the face and‘ speakers promised the electors. 5mm and loundauoll o; all our 3gp. his llltlll. His so-called autocratic a good wing [m- an o; u5_ ‘flpressloxl or [he friends as he tam“ . a were calling for you like ance-and again," the moot --.' this. Suppose you hadpassed suitable kind, of life insur- ,"' _

is the Government prepared. we wines is agrlcullure_ Th“ develQpJfid15D04$1Y1Ull ‘is probably a demon- I-Ioivcver. as certain articles ofiw mm will, as “me em,“ as ll.

have reason to believe. to accede toled’ all other [mugs Shall be addedlrtrzition 0l an mdvpelldgllcg 01 lood have been given a bad namelmlvi feqnlfg-y, lm- a buslmss ma“ w‘ on and could not help them ance. any IIIOIE. ~

Anocllln Editor-D. K- Cliffh-

TUESDAY, OCTOBER 18. 1927

A GOVERNMENT CRISIS.

lull measure o; allcnllon by ‘h@:"‘l\e Opposition. The only criticisn

_ . “cliaritctet: which lic undoubtedly m" 111311112 13'" mdwiduam “h” metlemlllltllli‘ §\'<>11l1\15 031% t0 hi5 b01119! all the other requests of the Alli" '.,p_ 5,5958% n Came m “gm when‘ lediliciifig try) to_ cgitn thgni‘ out en-lhe will pliable l0 [lying himself (ace ance, tle majority of the Goverii- .. ,- "By 10m Wu H l’ fle- to_~ face ivitli a. person thousands 0i‘

1 _ _ _“1°11F “1111 11°11- w-R NKHQ» 11° Now foods such as milk, beef fat. miles away. and they ivill conduct a inent being determined to cut adrift ‘declined to support his party in ad- butter. and vegetables including conversation as intimately as though! altogether from the Alliance. This. a Government

..._..._¢oc»——- KIPLING'S VISION.

‘ii

A policy that will. guarantee, ,_ your family}; T r eaao n a b l e- ' monthly income should you be taken away, or that will afford you m; excellent in- vestment should you survive,

"‘ ND. minute by minute. our

lumncmg leglslallol, in behalf Dime potatoes. are absolutely essential for both were in the same room.

.MaCkenZ1-e A, Mann railway Emma preset-vigil of the heglth. g! b"Titie iiadio tisilonlyln itzllinfzmcy~ . . , . l _ , . y are cu a minimum ell-t 9 a ou w icre c aii omo ie or mo- fmie‘ “m” i“°_"’g_“‘d°‘1 “S ‘mmflbody gels "run doivii," and it is not tum pictures were 25 years ago. We- : 9th; pliblic IIIEGTESL This liiflidcult ‘forminlfleiations m lnakelflgcnilgllllgtul“W219i: wte lilstend t: all _

' ' l ie grep, nlomgms cl lea titay in e 0 y. s c .' l' a rc res ra iun re s o '

qlls Bataan and his speech in me One of the fgodg quill; nalumlly miles away. But the time is coming Would YOU!‘ Wife have t0 avoided or reduced in quantity. is W119“ “'9 511a“ be 051° 1° $69 111K", out t0 WOFk P WOUId Shfl

flouse of Commons on that occasion l . _ _ _ ~ uptake. m. owl e l“ _ _ ,d.l , ,_ po atoes. It is llllt that they have,» 1 1 * 1 “"34 1 Y ~15“ have to live with relations ? _ p‘ is the wisest provision you

atamped him as a man who refused a large amolml of Starch in themlflOhi hcor them. ‘to sacrifice principle when ir was but on the other hand they are richl "ThPS" 5101911191115 31° 11° 1110191111 “lo-uld the children be prop. ‘ can make. * *1~-'~‘1~ erly educated? Could the "- ~-

_ er given by The Yorkshire Post. Thursday iuslu. when =1 11a Comes, between prlnllpll. and in vitamins. onc of WlIiCh vimminf"(‘j4“"° ‘if’; ‘1 ‘wscfllléifin °1 :1"; l 1'3 1U \\'OU 13V!) scenic U IHQS U little home survive? “ ‘ Don‘t putlt off. Let us tell you now, "how easily this

public _ _ , “This story is included in the _ meeting under the auspices of the _ I “l)3l~[ly,;lllghll)_“ B. actually stimulates glandular. __, ,_ , ‘volume called Actions and Rezic- action. 41nd it "is often because llml11$~9.\'_¢'1\l-‘i<1L!0-_ We have done lllDfel ‘ itn annihilate distance in the last 50; great provision can be made. Use the coupon below.

How would they get along without you?

silent clock gives us a lG-sec- of course. means

crisis The Alliance h no‘ preparedicnd mile.‘ Thus wrote Rudyard Kili- ' “ . . " i". r ~ .~t wwii u» to trike this volte-face of the Saun- 1mg m m anmub S on ' e

_ Night Mail. describing a journey 1v ders party lying down. and a call to b _ t u 1_ 1 ‘ ' ‘ Tl. I it.‘ 38H) ) flI i? arms has been sounded. The first Que 6C m a m s3 a] 1

". h ‘ r 2000 A.D.“. l n ‘ud- rally will be iu the st. Paul's Hall Oil “ ‘ e 1°“ '1 ‘ 1° re "

Women's Christian Temperance Un- ion will be held. to be addressed by _ , —-thc yieor when Bleriot startled the the Dominion President, Mrs. Gor- _ _ world by flying for the first time don Wright. We have further rea- sonto believe that the Temperance

acoss the English Channel. Perhaps

, _ ii W115; tlieii possible to imagine that. Alliance. through the branches of the W. C. T. U. throughout the country

Hons‘ which “.35 publlshed m lglll, ‘lglands in the body do not function

“N v_ ,_ ‘fast mm ‘l I U A l,‘ _ l . lyeurs than was clone since history‘ or should his wealth be lookedlme bodyigi Y1 .i accumulates lfhboganl but we have only Shownl

119°" 11$ i"! Obstacle." The Globe _ _ . . . livhat run be accomplished, what 1 Thuwmr‘ m0 f“ mdvAdual ‘Slwill certainly be accomplished with-I

There is but one solution to

"continues. "He will. of our», l. - _ ,- _ _ ' -

mmged m Sever acflve Zmmiauull‘ (éliklllfzicfxbtlhmtxlxtnhultiiaffflzlltllgtbtlfillllfltéhIm the mes ol- many now living. l IIIIS. VIVA! problem and that

“m, hislargepnmwhltereslq m“ A, 1., “lulu. j, file, alum, loom,gyzlliiitulilelfsfhciilhiltzcuutlui,“H I is life insurance. Not only ‘ ~i ~ ".0- 1" . ‘ieoa 10-‘ -

. .. . '--- i .~ ~ “sit-l ‘sir-z . "t , - - Mr- Kuuuurs vision uueht uOt be an 1" (-111 do so without ruuflPlY 1°‘ lflllLltllllllltllfx: 111111111“! thcgilfe 031111110221: abut m“ ti!“ public tlmllks or [he 297 " c --‘W|l't‘t‘§.S on y as a ve iic c of‘ cum- . ‘ . COUPON .

‘his financial status leaves him free 1 --: y ultogetiri‘ funlautit: forecast tor the . .__ ‘_ valid yet Intuit is a favorite fo d wth "- - » ~ ~ .l ‘ . intend and carrying c '1 1"‘ 1-~ 3° dwlmseti-io give all his these fat reducing folks ‘ o l ' w.‘ ’ ‘ ‘time and mar i ' _ ' - i - i. H - “ ‘ I‘ ' . . . t 2

‘ 31’ ° 11"’ P11911111" l0. b0 mi point is that while foods: llf‘. ltlllttlltllltl. The wireless trails-l _ ' _ ,

through F n m _ n i‘ your 2000, but very iew people would

a. a co pt1\g,ll$SOOnS _ _ _ , -

l _ have hula-veil the speed oi liir. air- which he hm: been elected." Fur» lulu-u! be fvtillt-cd by avoiding C0l‘lall)1llll."..€|0ll of lioiier is certain to be a‘ . .

the main work of the haivest 1:. ovu. lwl- W. an, Lola mm “ML gonna“ urtirltaw, iii-calm; they are fat form-ldvvvltipiiit-iit of the near future. and 0f '_ - HEAD OFFICE z: TORONTO, ONTARIO ’ "

. Q I I

organizing hhallbeploued to receive a copy - - - V klot ntail-wvlurh wiorks out. at 225 mile~ °1 7°“ b°° \_ ‘liiis an abundance iii energy," ll) m“ m" -*-ll't‘lll=,'tl_l 0t the body is. li-si-i it will murk tlic most important ail-l l 10°11" 1°17" u" 81"‘, zin hour ~would he costly beaten 0H ‘ha! he Owes "mm m, his suwpss Tenet]. and the individual is going to- vain-u in industry; auncc the (liscov- B “m, r mod P l S nd _ a long-distance seaplane flight in ma his rm, from Colmmrflllvliul) llllg dlack oi Llicselfiljlfmjill 9% c! I u es remier uu ers l1} i -= - '" g o s. _‘ ‘iimmi- ies dong 103th less than 20 veors. it-urity to the place he has held for‘ The lesson then is to rcduc ‘1’ “1 ‘ " ' ll ‘ ‘ , , - . i _ -. . c llle nits iaic occupte inc almost exclu- fgiflklyhharissid m: it)?‘ “m5. "Yet in i925 Lieut. Doolittle won wars in public regard. “His legal vniire food intake by fifteen mlslYfilll uvvr a lone period of years! rigs ave a en. an i is care the Schneider Cup for America at

to compel the Gnvei-inment to make

good their pie-election promises. It

“CV

Branch Office: CHARLOTTETOWN

..u._."fii .9...

i} (it

Royal Bank Bldg.

unum iiu

.4..*-rr=*'" IIIITY Hiur

Putting Up Pickles ?

1f you

GODFREY coiiroiuiioii T’ 6% First Mortgage IS-Xear Sinking Fund Gold Bonds ‘ ‘

Owners of Confederation Building, corner St. Catherine Street and McGiII College Avenue, Montreal.

1281.49 miles per hour»a speed that _ ,___ would enable him to flash past Kip» HE National Liberal Conservativnlllngis air-mall lllle an gxpl-egs imp;

——-¢+>___ THE BASIC INDUSTRY.

arc putting up . Pickles you need German Brand Essence of Vinegar- the original German Brand of _ which there arc many imitu- '

Convention placed first thiiigsiqvqrlalllng a pedestrian," first in recognizing Agriculture m; —--—-o0>--—— ' the bzisioindustry of Canada and iii‘

Cleaning Painted Woodwork an extensive SUM? has

Tb 't' for thesejlonds is exceptionally strong. Th1 lanfi valued by Ernest Yitt it Co. at $933.5!!! BB4 the finished building byvkbss and Macdonald at $1i433i4mi

a total of $2,371,850 securing u First Mortgage of $150300)- Net Income, allowing 10% lor vacaritifii 15 ¢5111111111°d *1 $l9l,00O~morc an twice the Bond interest. ‘ l ~ Ready mui-ketabi 'ty i; assured by the operation of the very substantial sinking fund. ' We recommend these Bonds for a safe invutinent at the‘ attractive price of ,_

98 and accrued ilaktereitpyieldiiig over 6.20%

Writ t‘ 1dr descriptive ciiculof:

w. A. Mackenzie & Co. C. S. Petrit, Member, Toronto Stock Exclilangc- v 67 Yonge St; "- Toronto. " ‘ "

EDITORIAL NOTES such legislation ‘as. >¢>

recommending ____ Now that. we have practically fin-

niay be necessary to further and de-E velop the industry. Tariff and trans-‘lihmi Potfltfl-dllgging. we must begin

portation. in the Liberal Conserva- 1119 11111 P1°“'11'1g- The" is always

bl. I "B h ' u, something to do. and then some! y Sm a meuwd not 01111’ W111"

tlve program must be so adjusted Automatic Stirring 3nd sohregsmwd as}? give agtncfn-‘y "The terror that walks by night." tire t e est possibe oppor llIlIl) docs “m wink new‘ He drives an for development. The making oil _ _ C“ d. d d m fin lautomobile. and is even more of a na a e n ~u o n pe S _p n e 1 g up terror than when he walked. He of the vacant agricultural areas andl may be a bootlegger or a common to this end every encouragement . _ 4 _ thug. but the streets are rarely, if that legislation can give will be ac- _ l lat all. clear of him. corded to farming. The farms oc-l curled. the farmers Prosperous. ev-(l Weather conditions m Great Brit- Efl! 0th!!!‘ 11M 0f bllfiiftfisfi Will be ain this year have been so bad that TO-‘ilered- Wt? lulvfl IOOm f0!‘ many there is a move on foot advocating millions more and these millions oc- government help for farmers whose 1101134118 the farms. Dfmlllfilug food crops have been damaged. for the industrial centres. making people should come to Prince Ed- "WQSSBYY and mullilllyillt; industrial ivard Island where there are no

centres throughout the country will damaging weather conditions.

. . . _ _ twenty five pg)‘ gQnl, be“ . ll l ‘and we have conducted certain start-l _ acumen and hrs business ability arc. - . “m” a t 1° - . .< . ~ . he may have another break-down in‘ . . ‘of a high order" we a ~ - ‘jhqtqexnitypes 0f ‘God are “eceylhflg Lxpcfuncntb m Iilmgara Fans’ 232.5 miles per hour; in 1926 Molor , u ‘ re ‘mdt 315° 5111i‘ W 1-16 llefllttl 0f the body. “mm Ifm‘ m“ yet “may m an‘ health unless the crisis passesquick- that he has hail long Bfiperienlgp, ‘pounce in detail. But I will statei ulmmum Hmmh" ,, L“, u... m r _ ‘ HBernard won the cup for Italy at m leglslal-lve halls,» mm “he pussesl , lthat it is possible to transmit. elec-' Ltififil-llllllllllllllllll-liillil-ullliiiiiifijiiiiilit 1y‘ A5 ‘he poet suplemh remakedfitc miles per hour; and recently at ‘ses culture and the fldvfll‘! - ",,, " l I 111w] 1’°""§1‘1°‘1“Y by ‘M15955 1° ml .__.. w“ Wm‘ langledweb we weavudveniec Flight-Licut. s. N. Webster ‘gained by much travel." 1 agL . ‘".“ ' l2"E§§‘..‘é?‘$3?§§§..?“%‘£°‘§i?“§..lvm‘ When first we practice to iicct-ivcfiwon the Cup for Great Britain m l uxibefie‘~el m,“ tie Chile‘ acppllzmfyl Th‘, uhigh note" struck by Mr‘ ,_tion of such ii sifsteiti for some time ’ " Bennell l“ relumlng thanks to mo‘. B a; lcasllivill lililin theftl-lmsmlssion _ . ._ '. y o sina quan iics o energy to l gnvemm“ ‘s, ‘wmmwded 11y T11“; s ROBEE-l-A L55 places now inaccessible. Perhaps the >1 lobeh and this passage from hisl 1 ‘Q’ ‘ ““"“*.‘H.‘ lficlld of aviatioli will profit most dir-Vl ipeec is quoted: "Whether w '*‘ ' * " ecty and quic ly. One of the mos , ‘achieve Dowel. means lime if “i1 jstrenuous handicaps to avvioation onlll .. . l , . . U , ‘ I _ ecn the dale‘ we to 0,1“ cofnllcuons‘ EV“; v _ . u Flquestion of fuel. I bclicve that the: en ly the chief oigon and expoir. 3°11 ""1 °1 111100 P111011? 1° lcompurativcly near future will see ll ml, Ql Llberallsl“ in Canada hasdoughly. and the water in which thcyilhe operlmon “l almlunes by wmkl. “mm for very goQd reasons“ gal-med q m b11119 110119111 W111 0191111 P11111100 “(wdfliless power. and the establishment ofl opinion of M B __ ‘ _ g iwork very effectively, leaving the a series of central pfnver stations German Brand Essence oi‘ . , " “mil” "mmmdlsurfnce clean and close-y: no wait ltiwhich will make air-travel univers- l, Vinegar is preferred by dis- lualifications as the leader of tlielrequiretl. ‘ ‘ cerning housewives and leail- , great Conservative party in Canada.) _ 6 lng cooks all ovcr the Prov- . . For, l0 “ihlll 0mm. man in the public. lfar grealciuspeed be possible but the lnce. A pint of Essence makes ‘ me of Canada and belonging to any: wh k t d liiirplarlie lvillr be itrllide virtually inwi, 3 quarts of Vlnezar. . . ‘ en o0 in sauces. cus ar s.‘ epen en 0 ivea er co d't' l - political party could :1 higher trifland the clike. dgirop a large, clenn‘it could rise with perfeg‘. L383» (i322; / Gm"! 1°’ Pickles ‘"111 Chm”

f Chow.

The 2 Macs I)RUGGISTS f

149 Great George Street Phone 315

Charlottetown, I’, l5. 1,

Wchéknow that the riiost valuable

fertilizers are compounds of nitrogen ‘ _ and‘ that the atmosphere contains has lately come about, lhe malnlmh, lhls kit bag an equipment enabllnglan inexhaustible supply, but no a“ce o; plolecllo“ as a necessiwl By ROBERTA LEE lhlmhitsti ‘glglltgglllléltflnt light and power means has been found to oxidize it gag“; en‘1n°yn1en1_1°" ca1md1m1§ 1“l 4000000000oooo-oovosoooada “The fllgCtlFiC‘ lighting of the fut-mlfzctttgieitnsltwllfiasgccgfite lggzfiléliluiielgi} worse: ti“; u? lllnfiuce Canaduml Q How long should '\ hosties5‘:l'iscpevngiili); lawfflliy ncililglclwtaulbpsf lIlwzPQgEIIiI fielmnwrslrroln the-atmos- k C h .‘ i . yin us country rath-~ l y ' v‘ _ “ _ v 111w y 1e simp est electrical and ma e anada t e great country its er than join tho exodus. Cicngl-apll-vait for :1 guest who is late foillnmps oi IYlCfiIIdChLPIII. fllafllflllfisnflllt] mechanical apparatus, and m such wonderful resources entitle it to be. 1y we believe the resolution‘; d n: dinner. _ ‘perhaps wit the tise of wiics. at quantities that, the world's harvests w h t I _ _ conservallve lender, lhe Ho“ RI B * l i ~ *1 °l A. Not more than fifteen niinu- least in the interior oi buildings. will be revolutionized.

e ave un 0 d wealth in forest. sea led will meet the hearty approval oil les. The generations to come will sec not "Another thing: There lg no dqlibl

11111“ be 901d? lmarble into the vessel. It will rolllimy height desired. The time is not ‘and bob around, keeping the con-liar distant when a New York-to- iii

The platform adopted at ivinuipeglteuts thoroughly stirred- ‘?5‘"°1’° “m1 *1 N” Y°"1.‘“°“.1“*‘Pa.°‘ is not so highly praised “or so e“, , lifio pfisStlilgel all~ service will be in a _ _ _ _ - . ldaily operation. l, _inpt from criticism us is the leader} l "In certain other fields, for in- who iras chosen by the convention} A pogslble awldum, can be avoided‘ Slitnce- 111111 01 11111111108110“. Wireless It is criticized mildly an “dealing in by nailing strips of rubber to the1p°wer W1" be 1'e"°1‘1t1°11_‘11'3\ I11 111° ‘ ' genglallllse-i but me l. . l f four feet of the step-ladder. Theselfifst place ‘L w“! make P51111115 ms"

I i cs0 u ions _, In d. _ d sible on a scale that is practically

embmlled l“ ll Sound a Clem, “me strips can be cut 10m a KlSCBIGE

‘unlimited and over vast areas oi1 in favor of the maintenance of Brit-iautolnobne me‘ IQPYitOTY- T111‘- 11111¥111nati°n of thvlj l

The Step-Ladder

i511 connection, me plelerence all --~~ 1 Jltingllje willt be ays practicable as that --- - < . t Fboomoo 649004000000000 0 e 11197019013- 31111511 lmmlglfltlon rather than the‘ ‘ ‘sible for the explorer, hundreds of

increased imporation of aliens that) Modern Etiquette ilmiles from a settlement. to carry in

It will be pos-

. Hit»

Hui». - u Every harvest must pay its tithe. Before the grain Iii

converted to the use of man, there must he kept back “so __