PAGES*s`”°"‘ oRNiNci Daily- _
,i 4
. "1-
'$7'
_~g§\,?`
. Q rr [_ Q-if-_
|15 .gigs
_ - » l '
D A
alll “rage of* ‘ MCa.tches All Early "
O72 f , 7 or 1907 l Morning Mails- .T _
THE CHARl.(lTil5IllW GUARDI
i»_-- A . 1 __ _
Mon\:i\'oiii\ii.\'roi~v|ii‘iin~ii i I -_ | 1 \\WG`"H\ “ I ‘_
ii _ ‘
,,,,,..~.s;,.;._\-at..t-...it~...l,-,.\-,~...ne A CHARLOTTETGWN, PRINCE EDWARD ISLAND, c/iNADA, FRIDAY, JANUARY 24, 1908. ,,_;¢,,,,.,_;,,,».',._,,,,,',
'Ji --.> 2:: r-I.. »-'/. ~/.. .»
DVANCBT AD\'ANCl
isa TAE MURDER
0 THE BORDER
Near St. Stephen, N. B., The Victim
Being an Old Man Living Alone in
a Cabin==-And No Clue to the Murderers.
ST- STEPHEN. Jim- 23--(Spcclnl7‘ 'i‘he body was face upwards witl.
head terribly beaten and crushed
A brutal murder has been cominit, the ted near Woodland, the new paper apparently by a club
An old man named Andrew Higgins investigation tomorrow
__ _ '__ __
THE KI G VERSUS I EDW 0. BROW
Evidence Touching The Sanity of the Accused Concluded Yesterday===Dr. Hattie, of S t H
town ten miles up the river on the The autliorities at-Woodland were N . Mllille Hide- notified and a coroner is to hold an
Q- ii II Il
lived alone in a log lint on the As yet there is absolutely no clue’ M M L ’ Uflileyville Road. to the murderers and it is hard toT r’ C S
He had not been seen for sonie_ascrihe a cause, though it may havei
days and this morning the neighbors been robbery, for the old man is re-i
Siliffeil W invilfifiiéutc- ported to have recently roceived al
Just outside the door of his lint small sum of money.
they found two ifols of blood and He has one son in Everett, Mass, a following n bloory trail, they found daughter in Calais and a daughter in his body in a clump of bushes two Little Ridge abd they have been no-
liundred feet from his door. titled of the tragedy.
_TTITIUNS TN NTW BHUNSWIEK
-.___..
lllllllllll Tlliliill' T LUWTTTS ITS llili
()f Diswuni io Tmee aid The Legislature dissolved, Seven Eighls Per Cgnl N0fT|Tl'lEill0l1 Oil F8l)f‘Uaf`_Y
for Good Reaso_ns.~. 251 POTTTITE March 3-
LONDON, Jan. 23, irlpecial)---'l‘lie
rate of discount of the Bank of Idrig- .FREDETTTCT0N» Jan- 23_(SlT°°' land was today reduced from 5 to -i i“T)`_TT1“ LcT~'TT"1“tuT'0 WHS ‘TTSSUTVMT Im. Cent this afternoon by the Lleut. Gover-
'l`he reduction of the Bunk rate was '"°"‘
a foregone conclusion owing to the N0TTTT'T“tT"TT TS to be Feb' 25' rapiilly iriiproving liuaucizil conili- elections March third, with the ex- tions prevailing everyivherc, which ception of Gloucester County, where caused the market for discount rates the election, will be held Monday to fall to 32 per cent. March 2nd.
iii fini iUH“ii§iiTi§§iig
ni niiiiiiii
CUNETTTSS lliill
CAI.Cll'I"l‘A, .l.u». '_‘l--’l‘hc iiiirniinir-ii
],,(|i,m ,\‘.,¢,|i,,p\\ (jam-|~i-_~.< -it Sur it cami- U to grief as well~infni‘n.e-l r.-r°i'-oi\.»suppoa-ml e I
ii would ln-cause fi. was not rt-.illy ii con- "" ` ,
. ‘ ' . 'e_. l
gross, having no ther rule-io( procedure :ITAL[§::“T)T;:1E:;;°£;:;?:gm;‘o;;;i|3::ef’: nor fixed represeritriilon. _ __ t h
A" mhmm to elwt Un “hom “wmv biuindiirn waters, the -Gniisnrnen HI as
paratively moderate man. ns pri-sl.'lent. pusgml an Ord". In mmm BDT" ng
. - . r ' - s.
was ahonied down. though it was sup. Lokstirii:cpi`l:riic‘£f;i;;ilHfox-iipn;/Eazerman, p ~rtcrl by Mr-Siir.'ririr,»i Nriih lliiner_ii-o, _ ' ' ' '
. .. N .i. l |. S 'd . Norwa Austra-
izlg m‘;'mT hum if the Mmlownmg TW llTi!iil;iTr;tHl`;‘eiiiiih'iik?nBi-lgiunif' and the c 'e it itt a moral an ii vu-ir ago. _ _ Tiie rirplanntion of the uproar was that A'T"‘°“L'"“ R‘eT’"l'fH°Cm"’ ;mmm's: no Th’
i- uma on e unna-
i.l e oxtrauilsts ot the rent ri'-ss ii-.fl utter" §::_T|;L::§\,.| l,,\L:|;Jd|;o,,3nRs ,ue ,mu|;¢,,},|e L, mT""'T L" T'r_lmz up “ EIITTTTN Uf_vmT°"T' (_Ziuia'l|uii vesii1»ls. Au order in oouuoil
iriilnrlouiid:r~eil;-iill;c:liili.irIl1{::|-.H31|: jus! llaqsell m_“,MeM ,hut ,~,|t.,._}'M,u,,_,~y
anpr(-iireto ers iv '. `, |
li il the hi\r|i~ter who was |iei;U\`lv\l i-srli' ly mmf' Tm gut",-T0' Dt>\i`i;c:::tr3ofFl(lJrhIihnil:
. eirrici iy wa er tom
lu the! yanr friiriiltlie lL’|iinj;ili‘fnr tnmuthm. exL.,,,,l |,y Bripinh ming,
wasgven a w i you iusns ic r ii- t r.
by the mob of Surat.
llfllllllii llNll lllllNN EHiNliT lil PiETllHiS
i
'l‘l‘A\\'A, Jan. 22-With s view to ouraiziiirr Canadian sliippin|1,antl-.neat-
llTl`.ElPTS TIT THT
lNlllNTl lllVTNlli
rir'i'A\\'A,Jimimry 22--\fi1llT"1 °T'f °
upwards of $40,000 is rcportedl lt:
_ _ . ~ t reue
Gfalld Pe|f0|"lTlaTlCe Gllarafi inland irvenuc depaxlmtn P
December, coiiipnrud with a IMP 03°
' - 'f‘|i¢~ figures are '£1,400 305.01) for Diceniber
teed by Fairylind to Um md M gh, __,;_____,,,_,,,,.,,,, ,,,,,,.,,..
' iiiioii si.441,r»<ii.:i<i. Of the wi" "W TT T g TTT' °,,v_,,,e ,,,,,,,,.. ,,~,,_., $i_:isz_r.ii7.eii.
.,.. ---~ "` ”‘”‘_"
inard's Linimeni Cures Gargefin Cows
'ranigiit time wiu be another M
ilrand performance at “Fiill'YT"f“T_ by llouldan and Quinn WTT°*T° T"T""' nuiiu nets are being richly eril~>Y@‘T by the large audiences this week. Aa uianipulators of the bells th0Y °‘"mdT ian Corn 00 supreme in vaudeville to-day- MT" ' ' 10-gi llouiiien in a born comedian his T' Wheat.............. .. . mm witty sallies enliveninfl th” "“"‘T°“T i»p°,g_____,_,... .. 0-:'- program. In order to give H" °T" M, com..." .. ‘M iiortunity for those w_h0 Wi“TT I" M' (Y:vhiint......................- 98 tend early it has been arrniiiicil to Park .. .. -- bring this musical Y-Bum DTT 9TT°T"~Ty _________,.__._-»--
before eight o'clock tonight for their
first act.
The new pictorial program to-nfllhi
will be up to the high standard that has made "F'airylnnd" famous. 'If will include: A Little Jules Verne » depicting remarkable adventurer-I hi' sen and land. "The InnkeeD@T'T'l D“"'\ Khter" and several others whose names will appear in the evening
Papers.
'rim illustrated seiuier was by Mf- Maiiairen entities "oeoéih biie
Marie", will be sung wi PHD _ cnrnet accom anlment thus mall!!! S an entertafnmgnt in ltselfm .nd to __--
The admission for to-n iz B ‘_ --f-- ` pm morrow night will be ten cents f0T`,‘ T"° T“°° 'or l adults and uve cents for children. l r»\ori_f’__"'f§_'I;€.~`._.
_ ~ -r ’“‘ fin a ernoon a
___________‘.*___- | | °“°"0" Tgiliiiie y but Finder
. 1 “'T‘“° `1-siiisi <1.
|linard’| Llnlmenl Cures D|sleii‘P°" ‘leave nt. 26 Gt. George Bt- P
cpl-ITE/Tr"i`ii`T"tTAFi<'i-;is
osroieojhlhuarr 2 ~' 5P°°'“T"‘
_ A “ml ”_'.,"|,~,¢_ n-A -trier thvvll liuiiss: are qiiiclllr l'°“"`"d bf U"’°°1°"° _‘mm ,__ , ....»~-_ ¢\\drnzzi~*°
Pii.r<:s 'ciiiiieh-TIN s 'ro 14 DAYS.
PAZO 0[NTMENTf lLtchignugnrlT3ITTTT:Td
to cure nnxy Pigigllgng P"es*m 6 to
liatledfihtig of money l”°T““'T°‘T' 5° cw'
,=_-L-.===--=--' " "“"
__._.--- -1»mr~-l
Th ~ i
at 15-aosgillirnclmc Court met yesterday
‘Tl - ' ‘ . .
ic examination of Dr Goodwill
‘VTTWUTT T~>Y the prisoner to the wit- ness were handed to the cum-t,m,| T'0fIf;1’T>Y 'thc clerk of the Court.
il. (/HIL? JUSTICE-Had you
any conversation with the pi~is0n9r about these letters ?
took him two hours
.,__..‘,.N__‘_:_‘n, _ ,. ._ . _:--.,....-~_.._.__.. Tl
lirown’s request. When I went to see IT:UHI_ _‘hc asked me to give him some iericinc for it stomach troiib1e_s,,mc ‘TYSDUDUC symptouis.’l‘hc visit was riinde Oct. 18, and lasted nearly two iiours. I h..J prescribed for him lie- tTI0.A_ _On the occasion of my visit to _lc Jail lie ‘talked a lot chiel-y about TTT” UWTT lTTl1TlYY~~I understood from TTT3. C0Il\'ers:i.tion that he coiiaidcrcil himself rather superior' to other menibcrs of his profession, He find an abiiorriial opinion of himself Alter a long conversation on his uw"- legal ability he referred to the diffi- culty between Mr. Bentley and liiiiiq self. I tiiouglit he had an over ex- alted opinion of himself. He had ii very contented satisfied air for ai man liiider the serious cliargcsi illiilillft llilii_._ 1 don’t know that ati that first visit I formed any opinion
us to his soundness of riiind.
I made ii second visit at the re-
was concluded. At the request of pm- _ Ui' - '. 1 . _ _ -~ laguiiist him to be able to mukc ii
iief Justice .Sullivan several letters ' pm
DR- GUODWILL-Yes he said he ri C"lTT‘T 0XPlain in five minutes; brit itliifi
_ , , ' l con
Di. MLLAU(fHLAN-(examined for sei
iicit-nee by M-_ W .i _ ' -, llrown’s auiliiohity ttpois) (lililillmlt be dropped from the case went down to visit Brown in jail' ntl an
l
do not think it is it trick. I do not think that the prisoner has no\v s
per understanding of the charge
per defence.
(Yross-exainined by Mr. War'bui'ton.
lirown wrote me a long document about his defence-it was very long and < Ihsked him to write it down so as to get the idea in one sent- ence. In reply sent to me another
ciinieiit. (This document was nded to the (`hicf Justice. After sideration and coiiierring of coun- it was agreed that the document
-)
iwn did business for me-drawing deed. When I first went to nee
the prisoner in jail he appeared to he sensible in describing his trouble. I could not grasp what his iilca was in asking nic and not the Jail phy s|ci:in._ Un a subsequent visit hc coiiipiained of the fear of being po- isoned througli his riiedicine. I ask- ed him on a later visit why he did not have the Jail physician prescribe for huii. He said he had every con iidence in the Jail pliysicinn, but was afraid lieiitlny would find an op- portunity to tamper with the medi-
Ucritlcy when the latter went to th( Jail to visit hiiii he asked for a guard, saying he was afraid Bentley would fire the building. V Mit. WARllU}iTON-llloiild not the i|iipi'cssioii conveyed to the public bs placing a ,guard ovci' hiin convey tire idca that lic needed to be protected from himself 7
lllt. Mein./\U(‘Hl.AN-Possibly.
quest of II. Ii. Ilrown to forrri an opinion ns to the sanity or insanityl of the prisoner and to give a candidf opinion. Un this visit I noticed hisl egotisni, his extreriicly exalted opin- ion of himself. I noticed also thatT he didn’t seem to realize the gravityf of his position._ When referring to` his position he claimed to be able tol
clear the whole matter up and tliutl he could justify his course, to whichi
He appeared to he perfectly satisfied with his own reasoning and conclu-
term delusloiis. They were largely' along the line of perseeutioii by Mr.j Bentley. He attributed ull his trou-‘ hles to the treatment received nt the hands of Mr. Bentley and while in Mr. Bentley's oilicc, which troubles had forced him into his present posi-T tion . On other lines of talk his niemory struck me as very good~as‘ over n.cutc. I saw him later, on Dec., 3, 13, 21, and two or ‘three times inf January. (ln Dec. 3 I was in coni- pnny with Drs. Goodwill and Conroy I had then come to the conclusion' that the prisoner was not sound mentally. One visit was in company with Dr Henderson and one with Dix! Johnson. As ii result of my visits, I became more firm in niy conviction that the iiian was insane. The ques-l tion of the nature of his iiisauity,! and as to whether he was feiguing, iinturnlly occurred to me. Duringl these visits with the other doctors| he was often subjected to ii fire of: questions. I observed Brown nt.| those times _ Ile was always rendyi
to reply. When questioned too milclii he would weary. I would occasion- ally ask n. question, and froiu his- auswers I did not think he was feign- ing. I am firmly of the conviction that he did not deceive the doctors. I watched him in thecfpectntlon of seeing hlni trip himself. If he hudi been feignlng it appears to me it would have been such a strain upon' him that I would expect to scc ri physical breakdown. Also I noticedl the irogress of his delusion the only
paranoia. One thing he did notl feign his abnormally clear memory. Another point was that if he was. feigning _he would try to show his insanity to those close about him, and that he would have tried to show himself further removed from the bordcrlnnd of sanity. From my knowledge he has chosen the most difficult form of insanity to feign, On several occasions when we visited Brown he was nskcd for his defence, and he always spoke at length u- bout lt but we could not make any- thing of what he said. Dr. Conroy asked Brown to make out his de~ fence and some time afterwards I re- ceived two copies of the .document which has been read in Court and has been called Brown's defence. I con- cluded that the man who wrote this document was insane. In this dc- fence he claims that he was impclled to his course. He stntes that he was to receive a certain amount and that his brother was to provide his clothing, and yet he says he was compelled to act ns he did because he was forced to for want of money, The whole thing ls irrational. The document is n crystallization of the prlsoner's form of defence. lf it isa trick to impose upon the incdlral men it is very cleverly done-but I
I
disease I can class it in would hcT‘
Mit. WAltliUIlTON»-How could lic
appear so szitisiicil with his condi- 'un if he was afraid of fire and poisoii?
llr. McLi\ll(`l'[LAN-He did not
seen to worry, except when roused about Bentley. I cannot say that an JU ‘73U‘Tl’!.\o uu sr pniui oiuou .ioao insanity .'ilwii_vs.
ll. H. Ull(JWN testified to having
had liiisiiicss tninsactioiis with the
he had been driven by his ciieiiiics.»npCu<,.,| to whom at vmious tim”
- - V .
,ire had loaned sums of money.
(r'oss-exuniiiied by Mr. Palmer he
sions. On this visit I noticed what Ilgaiii he (im not jend the mmley be.
cause he tliought the accused was sane enough to be trusted with loans brit because he was his brother. I-In said that Mr. A. J. B. Mellish had spoken to him about his brother he-
ing deranged.
(In this connection it may be
mentioned that A. J. I3, Mellish was a witness ou the previous day in this case. He had -testified to being associati-d \vitli E. 0. llrown in thr- lcgiil case of 'l‘aiiton vs. (`ity of (_'.liarlotteto\vn, and fi‘oni his con- nection with Brown at that time had come to thc couclusinii that he
his iiiiud. This was
y ago, and he, Mcllish,
had gone to lli'own’s brotlicr and told liiui what he tliouglit and thai he tliuuglif it advisable that E. 0. Brown be given ri rest. Otherwise Mr, Mellish feared he would break
down completely)
Mr. llicI.ean risked at this point
that certain life insurance policies taken out by IC. O. llrown be pro- duced. They were as follows: Sun Life (‘o., $6,000; Imperial Life $5,000; Mutual Life $5,000; North American Life, $5,000; Sun Life (2nd policy) $5,000; (‘onfederation Life, $5,000; Manfacturer's Life, $1,000; (‘rowu Life $5,000; all these policies were taken nut between Dec. 1005 and
Jnn. 1906..
This closed the evideiiice for the
defence.
i)n bohnlf of the (‘rown tlicre find
been submitted the cvi<l<-rice of Drs. lolinson, Warburton, McNeill and of Jnilor Hamill already briefly re- ported lin The Guardian, The evi- dence of Dr. Johnson it will be re- membered indicated nn opinion on the part of the doctor that the pri- soner was of sound mind hut under cross-exunilnotioii ne had stutcd that he was not sure Brown was not insane. Doctor Warburton had testi- fied that hr had visited the prisoner in jail had noted his actions and conversation and had come to the conclusion that he was sane and understood his position. There was also the testimony of Dr. McNeilll who gave it as his opinion that- ilrown was in complete possession of his faculties and knew quite well what his position was. .Inilor Hnnilll, too had given strong evi- dcnro for thc (`rown testifying that to the best of his belief he thought, that Brown was only shammlng insanity. Thr-rn yet remained another witness for the Crown, who might have been examined before# but who was kept till yesterday, because the counsel for the Crown wanted to know more about the line of defence
was out of nboiit ii car
eine. After his encounter with Mr."
for the defence have concluded with their witnesses I would risk your Lor~<lsliip’s permission to call another witness. In adopting the line they did the counsel for the defence acted to our disadvantage. They have put on/ witnesses whose, evidc-rice may or may not establish the insanity of the prisoner. Now having found out that they have diagnosed the prison- er's complaint us paranoia, \ve ask to bring in our expert witness.
Mr. Mcliean objected saying' this
course was not usiiul~tiui; r
should have been heard before. i
to show that he had a right to
I D 4 'Phat the liritish Governiiiciit iiir-:iris
Hattie (the witness in que-stiou\ L"
His Lordship quoted an authority Hong Kong home vm Cunmiu, is grant the request of the Crown "mc
test the Caiiadian route by sr-rid
Ui-Z the regiment now on service in
ial information received here.
WILL TEST THE CANADIAN ROUTE I
British Government to Bring Home Regiment of Highlanders from Hong _
Kong By Way of Canadian
Ports.
-m
HALIFAX, Jan. 23~(Spccial)~ Just. wliuri the test will be made is
noi. kiiowii but it is believed the reginient will be the Cameron High- laridcrs.
It is not known whether they will
enibiirk at Halifax ar St. John.
counsel and gave permission to call
DR. HATTIE-examined by Mr. I
the institution lieforc being appoint- ed Superintendent. I have been ri ‘ little over thirteen years in the No va Scotia I-iospital for the Insane. I `
.ire admitted we make uri exaniina
l went down with Dr. Johnson to
see him and stuid three hours and ii ll half. Found the prisoner pale brit [Tre] in general health, The prisoner did Ile niost of the talking. At first dis hi
:ussed things in a general way, and f noticed nothing unusual in iii.-.
l noticed the prisoner became una- ls sual; said l\’lr. Bentley was ut the .iottoiii of his troubles and iiiciition.
I was a doctor; he asked the ques D tion. He seemed anxious to talk, H was certainly very ready. He talked
in Saturday last. I noticed no
fiiiiri c in him iliysically
quite reasonable. There was not
of talking. I thought from the out-
ilrs. Johnson und McNeill were with
second visit, I found hun in about
lniit time of seeing him in inil. I ‘
rriiicli importance to thai.. 1 have
lstudied this case; ha\e lieiiril the Su
evidence given here, the let‘;f-,rs rind pr?
ststenierits read. I have not drag- _
habits are secl‘ii.fc sh ' ovei'sc:.si TTT
tives to otlicrs; all ..lici.i nvoiilfi mari.
__ ‘ .~ s; .' -
-ipi. to liccoiiic unsettled in habits;
niisiiiterprct motives of others; not S1
cions crystullizc into delusions. In a_lL‘
fulsc belief wliicli cannot be correct- .lc
l‘liysically the subject would prolmb- lc
anoiir---halliicinntions of touch, taste, w
selves usuallyi 'l`he subject does not suspect any one nt first--speaks of
prisoner uppcurs to have u bniiis of u fact for all his ldcus as to the mat- u
tisation of these ideas is scarcely as c elaborate as a tliorough delusion
progresses vcry slowly. I cnn't any il
recent or otherwise. I ilon't reins-in d her one instance in which the pris- il oner mentioned Mr. Bentley. t
of an ordinary paranolc, who usually F
in authority, governors, judges etc, li and prefer lo write in colored ink. c Brown stated to me thnt at some time past hc was insane but that s recentl he was better. After the
not detect any hnlluclnntions in this n case. Delusions are found in other i
three struck me ns ri rather fantas-'
U16 WiT-l'\€SS- to eat his food. 1 hardly think it
l’almer- L’
I am at present Superintendent of the V _ _ I
Nova Scotia Hospital for Insune,nnd I cannut '*'h”TT"“"'“` f°T’~7nT"t5 TT"‘TTT ’~T‘T”`i have been for nine yEm,S_ The “_ case. Brown showed upprerdiition of' sident number of patients in that “T5 _ V huspitul have ,lvemged 400 I was pearcd a rational nianncr to nic. I-le; Assn Iihysiciun ,md Asst sunt in Itold me what the charges ar:iiiri:it‘
li. \ii'.
_'ini ucqiiaiiitcd with paranoia-have wh! patients suffering from it. They are ‘Tim not a nuuinrous class. When patients
tnlk our those subjects, Uri the sub ,gui icct of Mr. Bentley about whom fi ments mmm in this dncumenb The are returning and who are l medl-
oner knows that the dcfi-_use is life relatives of those already there.
iuestion was asked by Dr. Johnson HB
T10 D100 UT illfiilnlfy- _ you and ask you to judge. Di
_ _ _ _ _ . . I . I _ I A A T, icry H1111-T1» I TTT"f- “TW Tuul In MH infer tliat you are not iii :i position an
to ' t
K T _ _ ' wh
()n my second visit. (ln other sub- H
very iiiuch difference in his mnniier “V
the some couditioii. I was looking for signs of feiirniiig. That was my
have seen liim since iii Court litre. I Hr" trial the reflex test. 1 iittiich not 0;’
nosed his case. I would not put t",T him in any cla<s. 'i‘h..-' wo'=Iil not fr' to ii typical i‘>i.~e of p:i|'.iiif.-i.~.. '."lie- TTT-T5 early syniptouii; if i'-'|".|.:io'..i :tru cc “TT ccntrictics ~.~,vil-fit in curiv youth TT"
i li
tiveness, apt to iittiil-ire \v.‘~»ign-o- TTT”
. . ,
paranoia in its curly stages. As Tl"T paranoia progresses the subject bo T"’T
“onies more su iii-ious and irritable; Til" _ _ V
witli rcspl-ct to the criiiir- with \\'liii‘|i l
l is cliai'gcrl is before you. You arc thi- order.
('liii-f (iuiincr’s l\lalc Myers, from
usually coniiiiiinicativc; very sensi- fllillk llilli iliS1\"l‘ UF mil iliil =_\l'l‘ fri the l-Icloiia, was thrown into the tive to hints, insults. These suspi- uivc thc vcrdict. \\'c are wiilini: to
dissatisfied; und more inclined to ll*
iy complain of obsciirc pains and iiicn who liiivc lireii `cxariiinl‘d as it syiiiptouis of that kind, which he is to
smell und hearing. These sliow them- lic
ter of Mr. Bentley. His systemn- could conduct his dr-fence with dis
r ' . `
as to whctlicr these delusions are the prisoner and jiuluc liiui by biz-
As to the letters they do not strike ing out of the or<linurY- F‘T"T‘ 'Ts T"
me ns being like thc letter writing an insane man you would exl‘0°f»
address their letters to persons high ly, and all th” Wufilfi T“` TTTT-‘ -“TWT
ting up for nie. I say 1 nm not
Y
delusions about persecutions, it is these remarks are evicienccs of snr' commonly the case that delusions of and you will bc askoil to dcclnrel _ an nnibitioui~i type appear. I did srinr. and able to Judge of the nal -
diseases. The mention of the figure he
T’TTT tl* lliiiilliosc on these points,
prisoner`s trouble as par‘anoia.
case ut each visit in what ap-T
iirn \\'crc. Paranoia is not tlii-iiiosi. lifhcuit uit-ntal disease to siiiiiilati-.|
would be very difficult for'
ity nt the present time H’
is not usual for pnraiioir-s to rc-
nion of this writtcii ilefi-nse is
tors to understand his condition.
arnnoic. I think Brown kiiows why Th
's here, und think he uiidi=r‘sl.arids uri nature of the cliargr-s against H,
im, and think it appears as if he ' us instructed as to his defense. "TT C
aid Brown had instructed his doc- ,vm 9 as to his defence from the state-
‘. Hattie ivas closclyeross-cx- ned by Mr. i\l1-liciin and admit-
‘d several instances iri which Mr. mm , _ _ _ _ _ ,
Bentley had acted in a hostile man t;:_%\ST)Tl:"‘l')lI‘(f',r I t
“cr wwurfls Tum' FTW” ""5: “ t°n‘_T' ,if iiisariity he had also rciriarkr I .1
racy to ilifiiiseriess, to elaborate his HH -
itatenients, but no real incoiiercncc, (im I really could not say how long hc .L_ :iilkcd on this matter for other sub- :dn iects were mentioned. If the prem hm iscs were correct there \vus no appur~ Ur :nt fault in the reasoning. He knew hm,
t lic olijcctcil to that plea: not approve of his counsel ii: _ and thai. that war; the only r
he had for saying that he km-\.'
wri was aware of his position, Hattie adrnittcd that he had not opportiiiiity enough to form ri
osilive opinion about l3rown‘s
The CHIEF JU@’l`I(`E--T ani to -
inforrii the Cour and .Inry f
ether the patient is insane or not. °
.~:oiier was asked ii fcw days ago, this (‘ourt to plead to the indict-
ted to his Lorilsliip that the soncr as not in :i fit state by son of the fact that lic was in- e. His Lorilsliip asked nic to ducc to liiin evidence to raise a iibt in his iuind as to the sanity the ucei|scd~ because the law us- mes every man to be sane until
iiiply to pronounce wlictlior you)
ave this question to any t_wcl\'c
u rallcil has broil to the i'fl|‘i't. that
is insulin.
not iiiioiiijli that hc has the rapin-
rii to soy, gentlemen, wlicilii-r he if ndcrstands his positioii so that he lt
ction
oiiir-ii|ioi’_ 'I‘ru|\ while he lias_bcon ay after day in this Court. NT'-Ullil here in thi- dock he luis done noth-
in has sat flu-rc quietly, and silent-
avo linen: "l do not agree with my oiinsol in the ilofeiiru they are put-
iino." ‘ lt will he snid,l pcrsume, th -
f the proccrrlings of the (‘ouri, I , i do not think His Lordslilp, win-. comes to nilrlrei-is you will telll
before putting him on tha stand. The permission of the Chief Justice how:-ver was necessary before this witness (fir. I~lnt,t.ic) could be heard.
Mr. Palmer-Now tnut the counsel
tic delusion--in a pnrannfc the de-
heing poisoned as a reasonable ro, l iult of the delusion would be sfraidi
I,
lg- »- ---- -
las not the prisoner rurricil out
these symptoms to the letter? Hint Qgntiuugd gn page 4, _
xiii;-(l\lviIis tt‘>,\vnSililli`i\i|i]iTiliii, of Order T5 to be T
s he is sane nt the present'timeT' CheCkl'd After Flrsl Of
NUT BTTN Still] i
iippciiraiirw- does not indicate one liiini: or aiiotlier and should not be
You arc to proiiouiicc whr-ther ¢`\‘H>`l‘Tf‘Tl‘il-
llrown is iusoni-, or wlivilicr he is
his pcrsecutors in it vairiic way. czipablu of coriiliiriiiiir his :lofi-iiri-. lt
The actions of subjects are largely is
controlled by thc delusions. The citv to conduct other iiiailcrs. You
(To be concluded tomorrow.)
.\ii‘ i\i¢f.<-iiu spoke ut considerable -
longtli, making a masterly address, he buluurc of which will appear ln
omorrow's fiuardinn.
At thc conclusion of Mr. MeLean's address ns the hour was late it was
Ipi`e.~uimr~ the roiiuscl for the urrnnirvfl tllllfi thi! u<ldl‘0S8 Of U18
would bc. Ui-iually systemnti'/.ation ('.rown, wlivu it is their furii to nil- counsel for the Crown should be
rpm, ym, Wm ,wk _v,,,, ¢,, pmk ,it postpone-ii till this morning.
~ <'ourt was consequently declared
adjourned till 10.30 this morning, when it is expected the Crown will address the Jury, after which they will be charged by the Chief Justice and then retire to decide upon their
verdict.
ld. (). BIl()WN‘S DEFENCE.
Herewith is it copy of the now fam-
ous document which has been alluded » to during this investigation as ELO. \irown‘s dr-fence, which was written 'ly him nt the suggestion of the doc- 'ors, so that they would be able to -idge what his idea of his defence
ould be.
l. Hereditary predisposition. _
You that such is the fart T T 2‘ Gmeml honesty and can w -A
vl ,I I J ` iprovlde for obligations Y
(lent omcn i tie ary, this mnn ‘
lusions are not npt. to be of this is not a maniac Dr. Hattie has toldlha' Long, T1eri;dw°T(§T°:)dst:1‘3}1at
- 1 , ' _ i (imc. srioo,
kind. A pnranuir who thinks hols you of the symptoms of paranoia. Famed vmnminmy entrance at 1|
lil JllPllNTST
i i
tion, as tliorough as possible. I re- Cogize “Then they *TTT Hilne- My Ftbruar Nf'XI| :eived ii letter from Attorney Gen- "IT" _ _ _ _ cml licwrsl ,md in consequence of tint it looks like it guide for his
that came over to see the prisoner. [,130
could be classed as iiiiplYinFC to a HUNOLULU' Jun' 23"`(Sp°CT'9T)`_` it J
e .lapniieso Consul Saito. has re- ii Ti' - ' ved a cable from Foreign Minister -
iyashi ridvising him that begining T l ' .T Feliiiiiiry lst the only Japanese
ross examined liy Mr. lilcliean- laborers who will be permitted to
igrnte to Hawaii are those whc
_lt_ _
._,_.._.
‘ LO.\`Dl).\'.lau. 22-Apparently ii hiicb
ilmty' has occurred in the reorganize!-lon of the
uies which ou January fi, ir was ’ f 'I noni-cud, had pu~i.~erl from the control
l3ie(\\'iiAlxii-'r fainily to it new company,
_ tht U . ., w i 1. rthur Pearson as r T ;i- ., Tens Um" the Bentley mutter he wus Dr.l lI'i.\'lT}l`ll<lT;P\'cs. dmlcmr' A hiii~>¢Hi~alili i\Dliciir.imi'ii“Rlh§ T
l\‘lr. Mcl.l‘lAN Al)I)Rl<`.S-Sl-IS JURY Tiuius this morning ileel/-rluiz thai ao
l'1(‘lil<l.-UN' ADDRESSES Jl.Tli.\'. salrhilrl. been i-ffcciicli :inn thatlhe ur- V
_ . . '\l ~. lil ',l.lCAN--Y . ~ sl' i -.. ._ . .
jet that possibly he mlght he ‘mgn Kmit:mmlnlUi uw 0`]ll‘§`mT_‘11‘e\`j}]1(l_i; ious..tntei|ir_i.t only icfi-rreu to 1.05(-ti
ing arid I was watchful for that. My Wi ' ' ` TT
second visit lasted two hours to in
two and a half. On my third visit ,,,,.,,'L__,` f,,,,,,d ,,,:,,i,,St him ' by ¢1,,. U Q mc' It was the (my fouoiving my setuid Jury, I as his coiiii:-ici sur: | I I
Dua that were in i»rogi'0.~4,
\.ns_
1
“ .
. , _ -_
“nn-“ - -L
SAN FRANCISCO, Cnr, Jam 22_
ved otherwise. Thc United 1 Si.-ites aruiy traosport his prisoner is indicted for for- Ullfvrd arrived today from the Phi- ie a person is lirouglit up for lippincs with u number of returning nl who is incapable of iindersi_imd- troops and otlir\i'.~:. lt is reported , his position the (foiirt iuay oriler- that duriiii.; the trip trouble was .; iiivr\:<tigatioii to prove wlietlir-i' or caused by an order that marines, t he is of sound riiiiid and alilc to liluejackcts and soldiers alike comply ‘
iderstaiid his position and to iriakc with an arrny rci.:ulution which re-
rlefoiire and stand trial. riuires an inspection of the men ns to 3
'I‘liis pri.~:oocr is iniiictcd for for- pi»i'so|ial 1:lcaiilii\i‘s.~x every two weeks. `v, but that. is noi thc i|ui>stion No such ri-glilution obtains in the
orc you--llie i|ii<-stioii is wlii-tlii-r' navy and the iiion lioniu\\ard hound iwn is insane or not.. Notliini: ioi iiiscliai~ga froiii the ships of the
’hvific flciit di-cliiicd to comply with
brig shortly afti-r the Buford left Nairasaki, it is nlli'-god, 134 blun-
,:,.m,,~:,| wuy ,, ,|L.i“,.,i(,,, is ,L kiwi Ufijiirors in the lunii, \\`c look no ob- ’i`lierf-upon, it is alleged, I34 blue-
ction Lo any jurors as their naiues jiickcis and uiiiriues, as ri lmiiy de.
ed either by urgunicnt or experience. were called out. We are willing to ,,mn,\,.,| (img ' ,\]y,.,~:,- 1,0 I-,.|¢.,,,,,.d and
uve till' 10-`lili\UllY UT ilu* Iiil‘ilil‘l\T thai tlir- order bc rescinded so far us _
applies to them. After n demon-
thc sanity or insanity of the stiwitiiin on the upper deck and an
apt to attribute to persons hostile prisoiicr. Wc, as his coiiliscl, l'i‘Si iippcal to thc marine ofllcers aboard,
to Iiiiii. 'I‘lie siiliicct of paranoia is :<iiiisficil that you will li;i\'<~ no otlivr the iiiou carried their point.
apt to be self-centred. Hiilliirina- opinion but that lic is iii.-uno. All
tion:-i are it couirnoii symptom of par- the eviilciiiw- of all the iiioiliriil iurn _
.»
una-, ., _,“
-' fr- '
ll
-i
l' \
ig.- .
1,5. in - - _. ._ ."‘_
~;»:f.- __l‘.'._\s.;tJ‘a\iiL9‘.=i`i:_
‘ -ea
.
. 3'*
. __ _
'.5;l‘..‘
_pp -_ -, 1. iD
A, -up 1-4--»»;
-we-.¢____
>
_ V . _ _
_ ' -
. - a i .\
, .
i _ .
.
I, fi
`.:
V
, - _ li
s.
i . `
if ~
-»»
- i
*~;.. ir‘\
.>,
`l
---
i
i i. . 4 ._ \,;¢ ¢,>`,__~\\_ -`~|_:`\_ rx
._ - . `
-- P \~_ =
` xx` -- .'
52;
l 1 . _
\ .- .. rw ,_ _-,~..~=;.._.~ ‘
c- --'»:°-
t
"
l
i f `
|lllilEHiTlliN f
~ -vt-<~ ~;~¢ g ____ ::.._._-f.-. $5
i ij
_ .,
. r
, u . ..
,_ ' ., Ti, .
_ / ~." 1,
4
t
gl
li’ _ é
~»
,.
.i
_,..
1-an ~4-\.\ "f"1‘° '°“_’ ,_,_ ..~=--
u
_ i ,vu
_‘.-
v'
-ii- _.
ana...
._ .._¢~ -;~ .- _-11""
, ,.l
W _
.i
i i
i
, - , ar f -\,-
.. _.-5,-.<
,_
I
l, _ ,QE . ._,
.ii ` __-
° ' ".>`|",'
Iv -M.-_. .. r-_-.
_X1
...-.
'A `._:\», si-
. "~`
1”*
5*! :_
,_ , ».
_ ""»1_ »
$131-r
1_» ¢‘_
i i `
rf : \ \.~»_'2* ` ' .i"‘i.1`-fl" `
-.3--T}.\l?'
._ *M ,V
i foci? -
T'n`.\‘~. \ ‘iff
. .,,.-gg. \.~. fl '.-‘*~~`i"‘ sg-T9;
“" e- ‘ 1:. ~.‘-‘?~i:'._'=ii.s-i f~t.n5- ,_.i;\‘=,‘ it .
_ xg \
». 3- \._ _.
L, T
. sl*-£11 `Y\i`:
vi ._§,€:`§_“"` 3*.. .1
I \'¢';
2' . ._.,,_-_~_,-,f_~_ ,gt ,_ .- _-a-
. ` . \
I 1
» 4|
1. f -f.
.`... _ _'.
_~.‘. \_--- r _~,'
ij.
-.~...-,‘ “ -