m" .1-

‘The Dennistaoun Case The Moot Famous Matrimon-

ial Cue Since Charla it’: Time.

(Continued) l)‘d it remain so until July 102l'.'~~Yes.

date action was begnil?» Yes.

£10,000 Costs when iild Colonel Dennlsto hand you the £5,000 on 11110011111.

cernbcr. added, Lady Carnavon hail

liow much have you hud all gt ther?—l cannot toll you. but should say £10,000 or £12,000.

i have the common expectation the legal profession. [Laughton] How ruuch of the £10,000 b

witnesses and

(Lairghtor)

counsel's

tectivcs?—l irrinnot say. Unless you trad put the pica

{vised tli'it' that pica would ma the pereoirs who had given its t statements on which those char;

fen-re. iidiirnitagt. for Mrs. ilcrrntstoiiu have particulars of the charges

that shi- could meet thenr. Sir Ellis

that sire hail the means. rci-oril. ini-luilliig: that conecrnl

zit-tion to trialitfNtit it little bit.

QQ4A GQO-Q-QO-OO

Tho ill-it allegation of adultery again/st Mrs. Uuunistoun was mail - on January 7, ltl25'.'~l accept that

That is about a year nftcr the

your costsZL-At some dale inst De- Prcvlously, the yrltnesrr pro- vided a sirbstantial sum for costs.

And you are hoping for more?»-

been s-pent 0n (lotect ves? — Th~ gffiﬂlgf purl Rigs ibecn dlsbiriireil o.i ,l'ecs.

How iriircli tins been r-"pent on de-

lhe record that there wus air irri-

IMrs, Dennistinin wllh these cllaig1s ,of adultery, would yoii?-—l wasad- kc

were ‘founded wtnostecs for the ile-

Thr- wltncss said that it was an

lluine-Wiliiarirs.~—'i‘hirri-

r investigate. such chzirgesIL-l think

Didn't it occur to you that,whcn all tircse charges were pill on th-

the mun whom she hopes to nrarry, it might previ-irt her bringing thc

tion ?~—Yes.

“Appltlcd at Vbiubtiity."

The w tness added that Sir George Lewis tnikcl ten times more than he did. lie was appall- ed at his voiuhility. (Laughton) He did not suggest that Sir George Lewis had come purely to give more or less of an exhibition in his room; that purpose developed during the interview.

Sir Ellis Humo-ll/lllinrns. —- You were a witness t0 the marriage be- tween (lolonel Dennistoun and Lady Curnavon?—Yes.

You beloved that the French divorce was valid?—-—Certainly.

ls one of the objects of the de- fence to prove that the French div- erce was a collusive one‘! — You have the pleadings before you. it is a matter ot‘ law.

llo you agree that if it is a collu- sive d vorce the re-marrlagc in Eng- land is in peril'!~l\'0.

Did not Sir (Jemge ileivis tell you over and over again that he had taken Mr. llayloids opiriion,_ and that. was that the divorce was valldW-lli: dd not tell me over and over zigaln.

Whcn Sir (leorge Lewis told you that Ciriouiel Dennistouir had seen Mrs. llenirlstoun nt Lady Evelyn lleziuizhzilnife wuldlrrg rind had pro- mistd to do sirmettiing for her, rlid not you llﬁk what he had promised? ~—No, l traversed the whole thing.

I 2

O-O

31.

iur oi

o l‘

is an inaccuracy of his recollec-

_ . " ' THE OHARLOTTETOWN GUARDIAN 14640406090-096004-000-0004

Beau Scjour, Champel-lea-Birlns. Switzerland, was called. lie said that he knew the plaintiff as Mme. llﬂlin and, secondly, as Mrs. Den- nistoun. lie identiﬁed the portrait produced as that of Mr. Bolin. Ask- ed to retu to the hotel books, the wltncsr said that they showed that on ho-enrbtwr 25, 1920, Mr. Bolin iami- alone to the; hotel and stayc-i llicre until l)1“(2(3ill'l)bi‘ l0, when the tpinirrliff arrived. Mr. Bollu had room 117 and when the plaintiff iiruvud she ‘had No. 118. The two. rooms bad a communicating door. On tlu- ilaiy of thc plaintiff's arriv- ‘til the witness wanted to get her llillll‘, so he knocked on her door. but could get no answer. lie thcu iinoi-iicil on the next iloor, and Mr. ilolln said, in answer‘ to his (iucs- tion: - "'l'hat is my wife. You don't rim-d her name. My name Es known." Mi, ilolin and the plaintiff went “Wily on lit (rember 2U, and the wit- Ivlw-‘s next saw him on February 10, 15121, when botii he and the plain- tiff came to the hotel. On that oc- c-risloir the plaintiff gave the name oi Airs. llcnnistoun. The couple 191111311111 tonriiiuniiziitlrig rooms on thc lhlrti iloor. The plicrrtiff went away again on the 14th, and Mr. llolin icft on the 28th. On l<‘c~llrir~ riry lfl the maid, Marguerite, ha'l arrivcil. and after staying the one night ivvnt away with the plaintiff. Tllc witness ilescrihod other visits of I\ir. llclin and the plaintiff. Mr. lloiiii had a photograph of the plaintiff on ‘his ilressirlg-tablc.

Mrs. Dﬂilillt-lltliiii spoke to Colonel Dennlstoun outside: St. Margaret's Church. Wcstniiustir, much to his

O11

l1|11‘11 "1111111 01151-11" 1111111Yi0 111 111‘ annoyance. and he at mice tele- 1131'1‘¢1111111-- 11 11 1txl111°11v V1111 111111111 phoned to me {lllllllil it. iiot havc been u-ble to bombard

Did not Sir George Lewis toil you that Colonel Dcnnistoun had zigreed to make provision for his wlfo?—‘ No, lie is entirely inaccurate about that.

You heard Mr. [lirkett any yes- terday that you feared that if tho (ruse wcre settled there would nev- or be an eni to Mrs. Dennlstounﬁs ilcnrzinds. it‘ it had ‘been settled, would not it have tit-en possible to provide that it was in settlement oi‘ all cizciris past. present, and fu-

iii so

arc chzirgrs zigainst her at about 15 turn? .4); course it would have places all ovrr Europe. ilo you ind.“ bu; i "cypr mmempiﬂmd Bu. think that i-zhe had the means to mpg “n. "CUHL

You do not enter into IIKFPIHIIOlIlS with persons who make such claims. Their assur- ances are t-iiliiely valueless.

11". No intimidation

lie-examined by Mr. Hirkctt, Mr.

I 1112.11.

(1i‘l).w‘H-l*Xllliilil0(| -by Sir i~lllis llume Williams, the witness said that hi- tens still iti thi- hotel anti had been tiicrt- for try-g years. He was then- from May, i020, iintll October, 'l‘lii-u hi- wcut away, but rc~ turned in lirzfl.

Sir Ellis ilnriic-Wllliaurs aslii-d when hr was first questioned about his t-iridilri-e ‘n this case, and thr- witncss said that hc was asked bv a 1111101211111‘ ri-titiut the rrialter a your ago. Sir Ellis Jlirrric-VViIIiaIirS. W- illil not ii surprise you that. when this lady returned to tliq- hotel in i". b

Tiitlfy l0, she gavt- hcr naurc a. Mrs. ili-iinstouni" l was surpris- ed.

Did you put Mrs. lh-rrnisioirrils

name down in the buok?~.\'o, tireri was only one account, and she dld not git/i. the name oi‘ Dclliillltlllil until llll‘ day alter hcr arrival. Tho ivilnivss riddcil that ho rc-- mcmbcrid Mr. iloliu vi-ry well bc~ (tutti-lo hi- iv-zis lllll/“lyii late late for ‘brraliiast and late for lllilf‘lll‘.till'

puts irr ll E-i|ilil'illt‘ill of ilefcrice. 'l‘iri- I

sliy, both

you use thc word “eollus.ve"? -» l should call collusive. (llVllFtJ-l‘ ivhltrh has been oblalni-iid throirghl

Sir iCllls lluuio-\\’illziiris (cross- ‘Xtlilllilllli-Zl. - Aptirt. ironi questions ill collusloir nud pubic policy, Zlll‘ agrccincirt bctwecu a husband and! i wife that irhi- should have a cer-F aiu sum by way oi’ alimony is u‘ (ued agrw-eiricrrtZL-Yirs.

lines collusion in France mt-au ' something which iiffccts the evi-l '|t‘il('(‘ that has bi-cu given lwfori-i lic (‘ourtil-ttoiiusiiur js zinythlng1 l','l]ll'll aruoirrrls to dci ~ptiorr ol lll . Jtltliite. l

'l‘alu- this case. A wife who has herself committed fl‘lllll-‘7'_V brings l .uili for dlvorcr ilLitlillii her hus- band. The husband has cournritlc-l irlultcry and cviilcncc oi it isgw- n Iii-fore l-lrc Court. The husband . has lll‘l‘ll summouril to appear at 1. hc hearing and h s l‘t]ll'l‘..‘l(‘ili1ttl\i'-"

'1 ills Lorilsirlpf-ln what S('l1.‘~l01l01‘\:-j1]‘

' PAGE SEVEN

llFCiaiys .1 SUNSHINE FURNACE

Installed to meet the exact heating requirements of your home, no matter what the

conditions may be.

8 HEATS NO MATTER HOW THE WIND BLOWS

CURRIE 1& MURNAGHAN

Charlottetown

Agents for McClarys Furnaces-

agreciucuts would b..- my]; ||tl'|' s UFICPANS ile, but si-litoiii the scclrlltl- l1lzaiiist public puiicy‘.'~~1\'es. i _ 1 gun“. prim; iziiﬂiigi‘ ('(llt7l'.1l11'1111*1 M11 1111'11°1~1-*1111"° W111 Hut any Kwp on hart in y kl t'lI1'li wv- lli1"|ih[ hind \\"is uu~stilisi'l<'101_'.1‘ 1'_‘1111v111e111- 11111 01111111111113 111V111'1~'U 111 i..ii .,ri.u;,.lr lllill|\\‘t)..l bo. .ds on 'i'hi-. tlillllr‘. iiiey sit out iu:i)'1'1' 1111‘ 111'1111CC?"NO- i to p‘ricc hot sriitcciriirs

Easy Place

1 "l'll liki-

111ml wiicrr they don‘: have 1111)’ an iruilcrstunillng bctwccn the par- Q",- gum), (if lnvi; iiioiiiis all lawns tlo i-irt." raid a wcary-itioking ties to tlltﬁttlVv tile Judge reg:ii'ii-,h,i,;,_,,- ,mn,-|m~,-,i,1_ liiiii- ma" ii-iii-u scvilti of V"ii"-i- lug the rcni grounds, ‘ ,\'|ti|lt'y tiiti-u W111i; liii- ilirsi bat-i \\‘li - shown m a llll)\'li' tb titre.

\ . to the Automotive _ Trade:

t ‘

ll uiosll (lhllgllildll to a pair oi‘ low-rs. 1 .nl\’l' ywz-irr" sink and your kite-lb, - - ' """"" " Ion tiilirfi‘ llIllillPliSllrililll)’.

t... c. . i) llVt‘ in n town lkl‘

in 1.19211? ruest on of

you know what Sir was coming to see ()l'li‘~1i(‘l 1U?» Yes. \Vlli'l1 Sir (lcorgo do _\oii really mean

inarriiigoiw-Yes. ilatlic-r an odd wa

before or since. S r (ieorge Lewis

Why did you have bur Wlilvlllkl l was adviscdtbut th- hcr ]ll'l‘:<ll‘.lil chastity

thing he said was‘: “When is the

interview?» Very odd. l have 110V"? tirii] an ipterviisiy’ ilegin in that way

time to waste on futile interviews? ~—H(3 knows about that-l do not.

Do you say that you then raised some (iuest n about the marriage

Fryzer said that there was no in- tention, when the ninrr' - settle- ment between l.a ty f‘. ‘iravon and (l0lﬂillll ih-nniston was t‘|ll.l'l‘l‘tl iii-

and whcn one was

Josrphllri- Fina, (‘lliiilldlllflllllitl lit

(ieorge Lewis

to the interview iii-tween him and you about on

$11‘ (lﬁﬁrgn Lewis on October 10th, 1023, Mr. Fryzer said that he hail given in evidence what was his inmost anti his clear recollection of what then passed between them. Mr. 'Birkett.—~Slr (lcorge Lewis said that there were lies illltl inven- tions in your version of the inter- view. Have you departed ironi thi- truthY-l have not departed ironi the truth.

His Lordship interposed to say that. the quest on was whether the memory of Sir (ieorge Lewis or that of Mr. Fryzer was

CHISS-CXZIlllllllilitlll, us to when she was first asked about thc case.- The hearing was adjourned.

it-rirss-iyctl Lewis ("imi "n 111101/‘111’ .. -

that the first The French code

‘Yrs. is it tli

I l I M. Jacques Quarticr, a member Y 1'11 “P1311 11c of tlrc French liar, an avoctit a la of the Errgllt-Jh liar, and a Lcgiil l\d~ burst)" w ms not “Inch veer to the British Embassy said that tircrc was no provision 1 in,.the French Code which pre-

ventcd Illilflitfil to a divorce sirit

a ﬂ(,,,r_w;lii,._,-,(‘ourt Izlvi-s its jltllglilclli eiti-r cou- -. one rcmcriilr-rcil that. tilaliithtizrJ 111;'11‘1‘111§ 1111‘ t‘-V111"111'1* 1'11‘ 1111‘ W11‘ tlouc: and thc argumcirt iu- tlri-il' -

if tho husband hnd presented the ("Lﬂfi of -hoth there would be a decree in favor] of car-h of tlrc |1tli'll(‘t4'.1—Y(‘5l.

The divorce would lilkc, placc?—; Cour il>'l\]l])t‘l ilc Paris, a nrombor (‘our-ts not to give the name oi‘ a in liPPil rommlttiviit~wn

Paris, giving ovldcnce on Friday. sorts of ililillllﬂlly. (To 11o (‘ontiriireill

Here is something to make

.- .. . . - - l? H. our customers lad-a trans- was lutitrrial. to, that tho foi'nicr‘s'iiioiie.y should 111111 11111111‘ 1111 ‘1 111111 1111" 1'111311}Uli7.t*.tl hm 1_1I1l‘]'\_‘1;“i‘]1] N1"‘lb1lﬁ'l;t “H1111, y. . . g . ’I‘lii- wlliicsis sa‘d that. Colonel i“, so ma,“ Wm, H,“ Mrs_ Dlmnhk tlic portraits hzmiied to liPl‘ asthosi- ‘NIH-Hwy ‘nrdi-‘lhitm H-w Rprlhwqmlv‘ mission lubricant that is ilciinisltnin iiad never told him toiin would not be able to have any 01 M‘ ,'1.1111.M1,111_" 11111111‘ S1111 111111111 “w, u} ti", hmqnhti T)“, h,,_.,i,,,,,,]-_.;l 100% ¢ﬂicient, Longer lit; -'ibollt the Yltlcil-‘H! 01' 1111* 111111 ~11“- 01‘ 11- "m 1111111111" "s Mnm 11mm’ M. ‘tiiiltcrv rrovi-d and "idytirc- i<1 - IMqHIiSHHIH-s lmemsm “mim- mdh» The witness mm“, mm me cost. "Olly! askcd ‘for a fllilillll‘ bcd to tic ‘lmnnnl-lpp-lll “Yong! no‘! m“ n“ l.‘ for gears-less trictlon— marriage settlement hetero the lu- of the witnesses for lllc ileience 11111 1'1 1111' 11'1“111'"'1 "1111" 311111111. 110ml divorce Ii l"l“lllt'l"1**li\\"I1ll11l1 more POW"- 511°W5 1111111151 lCl‘Vll‘\V wlrch hi; (the witness) had had been enormoirs. The pleading was 11111111’ f", -, "Om; divnzqm (mp4; H“, hut}. ‘V1111 511111011139 11'1"“ 011 0611111111‘ 111 1110 "1111111 1111-1111" 1111111111.‘ 111 £110 Tht- witni .~'e‘s evidence was trans- lizinil bmiight a I‘ tress-petition bc~l heat and lowest com 1c5ts' 1tl,‘1ti23‘l.) l 1111951111 11117901119111 11111101111 11111119 10 luted by a barrister,- but she could fur" the rlircrce was made final. 1 011191‘ 110111‘ 503501118 51-11101)‘ S11‘ 1‘*1115 11111119411111111111151 '_ D111 11111111111111" 11111 01111111-11- Riffeffllll; not. understand the question, pirtiri

a‘

tion at the llt“tl‘llll{ and now and be prepared ‘or a spouses were big demand. the result would -bi- that! '

Good Openings in the Lubricating Business

Now is the fimc to start, if you are going into

the luliricatinj b .. nsss. How to quality as an oiiic.

I ial Alcrnitc Service Station is told in our booklet on the lubricating business-send for It today.

l‘ practice 'n tho Frr-nchy

ith whom zidiritcry’ has

avoid all

I the more ironi nikli r z .‘ l~ r l --'- 1 1 settlement, rid said that it was accurate. men, J11“, 1:33;“ gihiltu$gflng ; ) ) w si|ltl1l0$I1°11 l‘ 1-1;11t11111'1t10_;1n_1‘]1111111 ﬂ-Stirhhlitlyvalrd Marshall-Hull said The witness ailded that. if all \ l" f “mm H“ ~H H no re cos ier n ores s. It I10 la e at ten witnesses from ll sti f -. ll s10:- li "-.- - ‘ "1 M" '1 ‘ ' "I" ' Si!‘ (“Write 11011115 111W that the re- abroad. To reduce the enormous glifnlngltlctll], {d11- uagreleliiggttildfiigdrll h" l“ (‘Mmy 11mph“ Umo" and Peal sweets st’ John’ N' 5' JOHN BULL: “That's a fine horse you're 100M110 filial 11411" lease tiailé» been -~ effected? ~ Sh‘ expense of the case ire would call by Mrs. Domilsttmn would he cir- i\|\\'ll,\'l fful" |Il iiiitiiig , Marin-m: Distributors for Churchill, and he ought to do well this year. But I dont I e 2.1!: (aver-gr; L Wis said no such thing. them ﬁrst. forcmrhk, in the French Cour“; ‘ i look o‘ m: "How on his back_vv y i_had never heard of the release at Arguments eovirriug the rulmis- His Lordsh'p.——li' the agreement i ALEMITE PRODUCTS 00.. OF CANADA, LTD. TRAINER CHURCHILIKJNo- HE'S til‘ 100 "BEVY- 111 11° m)’ i-li$\!”]l;'l:l(‘l,]e tens us ‘leﬂnnaly that glen itrlfecerzgin evlcigncevwerggctnvl}. alilegoiil here were eiotsaefiy tronniltct- 1 Bctlevllle, Ontario 1 f - h; imp - ' MRM i . I sa o w i an agreemen or a co u- , best m a“ a b‘ o wug o London Opinion. 11m did tell you 0t’ the release that Schaubhut, secretary

at the Hotel slve illvorce, l understand you

l0 tinny — pleuiiuiif -—- i'frl‘l"|\'l‘——‘lllly 21w.

’ \\ a1 mg . or, ome mg o urn p - , . . - 1 y. Both Florida and California have been transformed Bcsid th l - Ft’ 1.111 . i . r i t’ t - ( lgtlllSifltﬁlullgilgffg-‘Tll 1711111111111511111151115111113 101' 11161‘ 0f f [MEI]? doses]: wastes into rich populous countries bursting tiaiities of the“ 11115111311130; allgiaerlllgt-‘Sﬁlllgllllll: ‘H1111 11111 110i 1 - ‘ A - wi wea . orange groves o (lalifornia. and Florida look sick. 1111351119111 11mm)’ 111 1116 (3 11' 1.1" 1101111111115 that 91111’ . . . 1 What California and Florida have done for them- more people on the soil can bring ( zinadran prosperity. the £2101(gfgllgifgélredgéllkltglligiflolllgfg zllﬁtfllvlllgglifllllﬂlia): Selves by attracting ‘Wrists and wealth’ Ottawa can do S11‘ H9111?’ Thomw“ 1111111111116“ 1'1111tunt111mm1g1111' pie who have gone out and circussed the attractionls of for the Marit-imcs by using Prince lgdward Island as a 1101115 S11111111111°11> (11111111111 11111151111111-1111511‘ -_ their States to the whole North American continent. $111q1éi11ttr11c11o11 t” draw far 111°“ and Sewers 1111" 1119 Premier Mackenzie King and his advisers, day 1n _ _ 1111111193- _ ‘ _ ‘ l - _ _ d d_ "t mjqch immigmﬁon 6 These 11111110118 of people and these hundreds of mil- (igilrfernla and Florida may be qreamlng North ‘m 1411,01. (k1,, "the m my is the 0m, remedy; in fact 110m? of wealth that have been drawn in, may have been {Xmvrlqi v1’ its wealthy class- Canada, with the colorful, ‘h 01 1“1 ' ‘ d’ f .y ‘ ilflﬂliion has, bocmne an axiom in creatures of a boom, But even though a certain percent. irresistible Maritime magnet, can cream the world for '15,? 011111111 1= ‘ ' “ ” ageof Cztillliforniis expansion has been of the mushroom thti short-legged, broad-backed fellow yiyho digs into the 1 f - Y ‘ . . - t- t b variety egrcat balance has been good solid perman- soi with his horny hands and creatcst e only real per- ﬁftlidhvﬂw, 1111011 M111 by W11°m 1S 111111113111 1°11 0 e em ‘g-Jwtﬁht d b h 1 1 marilcgntt QfRPOSIJQBItY for any countlry. _ I _ _ '_ - \ _ I .‘ ‘i d ﬁ _ - ' y w a ever means an y w atever devices (‘ali- 11 Q 11- 111 11X “f1 110W!‘ 000111‘ $0 0118' as 0 10111 . 11‘1v°_‘t111y 11f 111115;; 110mg‘??? ‘ﬂfi‘,1§d1"t{,,f,fs1a’,,d§ :0 forlllﬂ and Florida have been tremendously sticcesgfui in Ottaur-a sits, back on its calloused haunches waiting for t“ 111W“ 11 1mg e11 _ attracting wealth and population. California’s popu- 501110111111810111"! 1111- . . A‘ , ' ' . . v . . _ _ - ‘ b r latioit is half that of the whole Dominion of Canada- Her 1'1'11111°111’11_°f 111° 11111111111115 15 Canada's 0110 1112’ 110110 - '] 111s hing‘ 1st 11111161112112‘: ﬁfildtetlkwfllnlglltvillwgr’ glle 11111111111 Production is actually greater than that of the for renewed life- Such legitimate advertising promo- 111111111“ ,f1’11lt.11s'1'f1a 1m‘ tiﬁn to tum “p3: Meanwhﬂe, Dominion of Canada, __ tion would inject the same new vigor into this Dom- 811111.) y - W111 11111 dot “Te f Cgnqda like the children of And what has Canada been doing whﬂe (japfomia mron ziswas injected when Sir Clifford Sifton threw the 111411811308 11“ e 05M; in ti“, elbows ragged at and Florida have been turning themselves from desolate 011611 111111 1100111911 1119 llfﬂirie Drtlvilwes- _ ' mg-xﬁggnsrﬂiii1agé smnfachs_ ’ camps into rich teeming cities, by their own promotion 11nd what Srfton did for Canada with the prairie 1 1 Promotion of California as a national Dlﬂygmlllld, and salestnanshm ? 1 . 1 provinces c?“ be renamed today’ not by 10111113’ back m d . th t 10 q hi“ Taiqed the population of Nothing. an easy chair and waiting for a compassionate God to Inrilx; r 0 Pa? . 31:11:21,!) 8 t-o a -mund million people _ Whﬂe California and Florida have been creating send down population, but by actually turning loose -. L0? 1126‘ es- Arum] k todqy are $780 000,000 of the" own fortunes, ogﬁcia] Canada has been sitting, one or two real live colonizers who, with Prince Edward 11112111 10S. I189 99 1.111 s 1' ’ vaguougly, Migawbgﬂikg, “waiting for something to Island as their drawing card, will sell Maritimes to the 1118191111101- t. / f“ id,“ charms during the turn up.” . f farmers of the world. _ _ 111511111115 111x111” 195123 the“ ‘ulation of imam; from And yet Canada has the most wonderful latent ﬁeld The_way to bring those ‘people in is written in the 1213311110 itilsflldadthef citizpand towns‘ of the State fpr promotion that the work! lwspver seen, not for re- recent 1118101‘! 0f 111111101111”- fmd Florldﬂ- I1 is a rsimvle ﬁr; on 3w mbve» F-loﬁda has just commenced, He, cyck tired piutes,but for {pang vmle soil-workers who are the reciig-O-AND GET THEM 1 ! ' . . " of boom will last another ten years. backbone of any “a on‘ ' ’ _ ~ ‘J