- -A -_-1.

if I

t ¢

4 ._. v _.

Y _ .-1

, .

_ .

f‘ , t 1_ , ' . . - .,\, _ _i

1 l) | V

’ MARQ_§-34' 1,921 ' . - \ -"_, _-; ,.

. v _ _

T v \

_ F A \\_ -

|’ I, "tx . V . /' Z \

~ ir i ,L |

-I-OM mfr, “U T°°" ' "- ` - . - . in' however m st V --»»-.- ~. :...i.‘:'.

V Y Ti. KE ' PROGRE5" "iii '

_ .11

I to _

t '

‘\` ,' A __ __ - // ._ ,f .- ,

~. ` 5 . . In L... ~.. ,- °.~° .-5 -= -- - ' - COD" " - h ' . " _ / . . 8li‘:"*_`:\\_;=;\"\` I/ isogrit iii: ii ~‘h“y°“' ` _ " " Wh" 'f ..... . -5* 1 .'"°L€:":‘ lf- -.5 f=°--=.~- ‘- --~----- . wwe uf:-and ' u~t"r.~.°..'." 2"" >‘°"*-‘f“l‘ \' Y'°.""°=-sh il-°

- - "' 0 5. Q 3““f|f3'\V.\ wlurh lheu an

gifgéifi-ED ° _ sesame

.°_ .` ..,,°__ o Vnlvcouvnn

~\\\` O

Enoor sun S --"Eli

hatever siv \ ,' mmm .

Wd if' TW \ 1' re manufac

Q WINNPEG

“m“"U“h&N%mdkn&m

Wlss.e‘:|lesesl»toeu¢u¢u\¢ gnyugg, .n "lu

-Bibs toeolttsoevespsne¢s,¢es.

m ?"::£m““m°”“"“‘""*.) Inu- ln no nuuruu ms n- m¢m¢“m '°'°'“'°'¢, losdvsls|u\out|emft¢an¢ocaann\baa¢knsvv|cl¢el.-

CLASSIFIED ADVERTISEMENTS

Fon SALE . ‘

MISCELLANEOUS

FOR SALE-TWENTY CITY PRO-

perties. Also building lots. Apply to Mark R. MoGuigan, Solicitor.

___;._____________._.__..___¢~ COTTAGE -FOR 8ALE`-NEARLY

new. Apply No. 329 Corner of Euston an! Victory Ave.

i_<f

'FOR SALE.-FARM' CONSIBT. _ ing of 30` acres in Royalty 2%

miles from Charlottetown, next to Water Works. Offers will be received till March 81.' Apply to John Saunders Elm Ave. or P. 0. Box 422.

__________.____.____-_-

_ FEMALE HELP " \VANTED

_______-,______,____---- WANTED-A' CHAMBER MAID.

Apply Queen Hotel.

' _

Big Ciearannce Auction :ale at Wnnd ldsndi West

On Thursday Marcin... 31st, at 1

o'olock si\arp_

".1 sm`inst'ru'éted -by J. nl ntcxelii

HOMESEEKER8_-SEND FOR Virginia. farm list, Dept, 275. Emporia, Va.

sans Ms voun naw runs.-I

will buy for cash or handle on consignment for New York or London market. Satisfactory ser- _vice, prompt returns E. H. Ray- D01'. Summsrside, P. lil. I. or 157- 158 West 27th. Street. New York.

Fnsnx. Hurt-i a co, on PARK St, Southwark, 8. E. I London, England announce their spring suis of furs at auction on April 18th, 1921, E. H. Rayner, agent, Bunnmerslde, P. m. 1,

WANTED

WANTED-A MAN OR BOY FOR

farm work. Apply to A. O. F. Gill, York.”

T0 LET -GENTRALLY LOCAT cd large front room on lower floor suitable for office. Apply Guardian. `

WANTED AT ONCE A SECOND _ .hand einpress wagon in -good con-

dition. Apply Postmaster, South-

to sell--by Auction on his pr`emisosv__ l`>0rt.`.- `- j `. -

on above date his choice farm of 100 acres. 70 clear and -in high state of cultivation. Balance cover ed with hard and soft wood, also all his stock, crop, fa_nm_ imple- ments, eto_ - '

SfI‘0CIK--General purpose mare

8 years old, Horse 1.9 years. 2 lililch cows, 1 cow 5 years old to freshen in April, 1 Heifer, 3 years old, to .freshen in May. 1 ‘Helter 2 years, 1 one year old: 25 hons_

CROP-~I00 bushels outs. Qunnti

ty of hay and potatoes.

Senators Defeat _

Calgary Tigers

. *___ -CALGARY. Alto. Mar. 22.--_

Performing before one of he larg- est crowds that ever iammsd into the Arena. the Ottawa Senators. world's pro-hockey champions,

Ili/lP'LBl\iEN'I7S--I driving wagon,

2 carts, 1 truck. 1 driving sleigh, 1 wood sleigh. 1 box sleigh, 1 gang plough. 1 single plough, 2 sets -liar ness, 1 Gerri -hay mower, 1 binder. 1 hay rake, I seeder, 1 cream sepnr ator. 1 washing -machine, 1 set ot driving harness, 2 sets ot work -heflleee. lr#-098. 1 cross..cut saw (DOW). 2 axes

FURNITURE-l ra-nge heater,

dresser, iron beds, 1 parlor organ, chairs and tables, 1 sewing mach. ine. dishes and ri!-l household ef

_ facts, toxether with lots or articles

too numerous to mention.

Sale positive. No reserve. Terms

of farm made 'known at snlc. Teruis 12 months on all sums over $1000. B per cent off for cash. -If stormy first fine day.

J. A_ M¢DONALD,

Auctioneer.

.d\feuted the Tigers, Alberto. cham- ipions two- to nothing, Saturday in an exhibition game that terminated the season hero.

lt was a -brilliantly played game

in which the Tigers had it over the N H L in speed; but did not possess the necessary finish to beat out Benedict, although they had far more chances than the Senators had against ifhe Calgary goalkeep- ers. _ '

i -----¢o>-----

Sweet women and clever gamb-

lers have winning ways,

I Ono seldom meets another mnn that is smarter than himself.

.~_-=u~ - --< -

’ - t ,haf

Dominion .Income Tax Returns

This year the Dominion

Ole-o-o»q~¢

C0-DO-00°#-

Government has imposodpery

heavy qpsnsltles upon-persons sendllns in incorrect returns.

For instance:-if the income is understated up to

one-tenmh the real income the fine ie 10 per cent interest on

the detlciefwnr.

. If understated by more than 10 per cent but less than 20 pen' cent the line is HALF THE AMOUNT OF INCOME

OMITTBID.

If the deficiency is 20 per cent or more, TI-IE WHOLE

OF THE UNREPOBTED INCOME IS TAKEN.

A false statement may

fins and six months In jail.

be punished with a 810.000-00

If lake in sending in return 26 per cent is added to tex.

You must -not wait till asked _-for-tan. nor leave the '

' osiouiation of its amount

Dill!! IGH f0l' l)i'0D&'~ f0|'m

to Government' officials- You

All returns must be in by April 80th next, accompanied

by at least one-fourth ofsotusli' tar reckoned liable tor. ‘

Take no chances. Your return must he perfectly ao- _

- curate to avoid HEAVY PENALTIES. Do not delay. Ab

tsnd to this important msttar at cuss.

Big. J,-__l_l Stevan s

1 .' (continued nom Page 2) *'***° 01" “ddltlonal taxation. They in- °"°““°d the Hisilre-gate amount _of the teachers' salaries by about $57,000. According to the gum. ment. of the Commissioner of Agri, °“’i“'° thi* Sovarnnnont increased it. by $86,000. '.Now, in pi-apo,-_ tion to the cost of living today as ¢0I!1‘I\ared with_1911 which is the greater increase? The Leader-sf the Government has said the cost of everything has doubled and trebled; has not the living sg-pen. ses of the teachers doubled and trebled sl-so? Then, if that be true, the increase given in 1911 was of much greater value to the teachers than that .given now. Nm- has the government yet satisfied the teachers. They -have Conrpromis. ed and temporized as they have done -in everything els.;

ado

Coming to`t'he matter of normn1_

trainilllr in the schools, [think we all understand that a. .gr-eatnr amount of this training would bs of benefit. In our time we m some advances along; this line; there were only two teachers in Prince of Wales College in 1911 who were in any way connected with the Nonmsi School staff, and we increased this nurmber to five. What have this Government done? Has any gentleman ou the other aide proposed any policy? Wo have heard some wishes express- ed. but is that going to bring about improvement? Is it the duty of the Government to see only the neces- siyt of doing things and then leuve‘ them undone? lt is all of a piece with this whole ninladministra- tion. There is no policy-nothing

” ""*\ ,

seo, Dr. Johnson originated his famous household midi- -

. eine,-still

The old reliable

' in thousands of homes for

eonghl, colds, sore throats,

.- cramps, chllis,_ sprlIns,' __strs|ns, and many other

` '-DFIIENALIMEXTEBNAL'

ssbsmlnd ills,-qflppe and .

Joimson 'S A nod y ri 0 Ll n I rn C nt

songs is very general in the p lic schools now,-there are fe schools in which such songs .are

know that the singing of ostrle_t_l: ,nys-slug we say anyway. so wher

Over |00 years _ -

1" _

were five of us and twenty-uve of tihem. _ But we expressed our policy, and all the quibbltng the Attorney General can do w1l.l not change that foci., ' `

We inve a greet fanny 8

of taxation among-' the members or the Government at thd 'present time. but I think perhaps the chief ‘of them is the lion._!tlinilter oi Agriculture (Hon. .W. M. Lea.) I-lo has given us a Iongiooture on tho benefits of taxation in general,- iihe necessity for it _ond the neces- sity for this particular bill. We had itll thot- _last year. It isn’t new. and' ,lust why it has been delivered. alloys; again I am at a

ing vote at every step. wihere there

postlea

-loss to. say, <'I’he gentlemen on ‘the other side of the House mal

n- ~ * _ .1 ~ -J

tain that we were in favor of taxes, - »

-why should they lecture us. ,

then’ their own followers are _ _

. If ‘

so hearty in approval of th measure, why lecture them? The hon. member for East Point (hir. D. C. McDonald) says that they nre some to turn a-deaf ear t

us? ft seems to. me that thi

umssgus tm uses asuvsreu oval' why it does them so much good -- whether used 'ai' A

not sung, and sung wail. The init” for their own particular bene_ Premier gave an instance of this ig¢_4qh5; “my-n, just wmsmng to h|'m’°u wh” ha “WM °| '~`\\° keep their courage u-p. singing in the “-brick school” which 9 rf ht ¢ 'pam|_1°,n gs 8 most

'Ph S o

he had heard. (I presume he m_,p°,-tan; mm .R 1, the bash, 0

meant Prince Street School; they are all “brick schools" im the Ci-ty.) This matter ls not of very much Importance. or a very great departure from custom after all. But it is one of the few matters

‘people have always claimed dh

me cnaanofrrntrown consents ____

, _ _ _ _

fn 2-, 5- and W

”The Great Swcctencr"

2 t°.its capacity. There is some vital need' of chiidrgg

.0-lb.fb\¢ -

IT IS the children who taxthe Crown Brand factory

is the sense in trying to convert dnt it satisfies better Il anything cue That ‘_

- l

¢Pf¢H¢i. as a table syrup, in baking, cooking or candy.

’ THE CANADA BTARCH C9-.°L!HI‘l`ED

Government. and wherever we find UONTREAL

the British Constitution its prln

cifple .ls one that has always been S .Scndfar copy o/Cooklooi FREE

Jealousiy guarded. The British

Of Dolicy Outlined ill thi! 51106011 “Vox populuv as the Leadér 0

from tfhe Throne.

Agriculture: One of the princi-

D0-l matters referred to under this heading in the Speech is the Tech- nioal School. We all agree that tlieorltically this Technical School is a splendid thing. As to whe-

ou remembe Mr. S eaker,|

of hope whatever.

Y r, p

that the Leader of the Gover - ment vin the course of his address made qulte_a. noise about an omis- sion made by the Leader of the Opposition in HIS speech. Ons very important matter, he said, hsd been "pa-ssed by on the other side." After elaborating for some time in a mysterious way about

ther this particular sdhool is pro- perly loonted is another question. is it the best place to have an Agricultural School in s. city where numerous distractions will inter- fere with the work of the stu- dents? But why, in any case, should so many bouquets be thrown to the local government for s pro- ject which is being financed by the Dominion Govern-ment? _

this matter of policy which -the Regardmg me grams w ,Choo

' h Le d o

Leader of the Opposition had kept clear of, we were finally informed that -it was "the -medical inspection of public schools!" Anti what was it the Government had done to- wards the achievement of this in- spection deserving of so much em- pliitsis? It seorns tlhat a lied Cross nurse had come here--sent by some outside institution, and, I presume, financed by that institu- tion-and that the Government HAD EXTENDED A XVELCOME tn her! We dou‘t. suppose -they would have turned her away from the I’rov<ince! 'They pentniiiod her, we are al-so solemnly inform- od, T0 ENTER THE PUBLIC SCHOOLS! Tho school trustees would have done that. _I-‘iuallY. they GAVE I>IEl't AN OFFICE in

fairs, 'these also, as t e a er f the Opposition has stated, are nothing new. They were inaugu- rated aud carried out most suc- cessfully by the Conservative Gov- ernment. I think it was the Gmnmi-ssioner of Agrlctilture who explained that the grants in this arise were for the purpose of pro- viding prizes. Now, there is a question as :to the eicpediency of this. Wo all know nihat has lm/ppened repeatedly at our city, and provincial exhibitions-we all know how anim-uls have been bor- rowed for the purpose of the ex- hibition, and how vegetables have been -taken from other peopie's garden-s and exhibited under false pretenses in order to get a few cents iu prize money. The ques-

tns public building. . - l - _ ., 1, , . h 1,1

twedlilil iui).iitlBlipe.ci.fiI<i\iiii`f¥i"‘:hrt;`ex;;<‘:,l?i1?l; -"t5i0i1‘:t xs¢i'\1r}s`cii‘ild‘r;1ti ~;lc‘ing“ fb; (lixne °me at B- . - ` -1"-` 'lil l“l".""lfI.h The present Leader ot the Gov-_;‘_;‘_‘;‘_;‘°hH‘f‘\};’_§’;e‘;° miffwge-fum,,“§ emma” was very msimem' dn me `rIed on without P11168. “"\1y.iS B10'

subiect when- he was in opposition. and we all agreed with him. But his whole policy seems to consist in expressing the necessity of im- provements. As in the. matter of Nonmal sollool training, tho policy s-tous with that expression.

The lion. Lender of the. Govern-

ment is essentially s. gcntlman of

ney to be expended on them now? This is a grave question. i A great denl ot credit has been when by tus government for the establishment of d 1im9S10l\B crusher at Mlmlnegaah. if this turns out successfully we .will Sli/6 them credit for lt. But thore is another matter <‘0rHle¢\0d Wm* i-11°

hobbies, I remember three or' ‘ _ _I B mussel four years also he had a hobby that ! ¥_?_‘_3“’°§!,\;4;";_°(f:1'fngBmf;‘l‘:1‘;n on me he want a gram' dw” ot the uma -other side, though very loud when of the House in elaborating upon- ____ Wpo5mon_ me “ow as dumb

femng ug 9ch°:l.§li3\da‘;_el:_-,:'§ 3.2:; about this as the proverbial oyster. re-as 0 BTS ' , h '_ Lead. :":’“‘“ ‘:.° .““fi.“:.i;f‘:.€:.“t.s°2s.i'-i.'L;1‘erl:°a;‘t‘§.:.s.2'2:sl .. . “V5 an ‘““ 'I 0 t d l of time (whn he was .dren would he encouraged to plant-3; imsegfme of the House) m m.g_

them. If he had his way then the whole Province would be a forest. I-lie has forgotten about that_ I -pre- sume. ' lie has got hold of n new hobby now, and we are to have music in the schools.

it has been said that this is not

a new thing. My friend from Souris (lilr. H. D. McLean) has told us that his voice had been spoiled by music lessons at school. I am afraid I had no voice to M1011, hut I remember the theory of music being taught at Pnince of Wa-ies College in my student days. Rev. Mr. Lloyd was the teacher: I do not recall that anything very much ever cwmu of lt. I suppose it was not taught when the hon. Leader of the Government went to Col- lege-t'ha.t would be n few years before my time. Rather n pity. too! I-Ie might have developed into a music teacher or a band master: and what a great thing that would have been for the Province.

I am not just clear whether it

is the intention of the Govemment to t/each the theory of music or the singing of patriotic songs. I

“They W O R K while you sleep”

@u|i

ATN! W if-Bd°|1|¢“°d ‘W W”"“"""°° md “d"°°' ' You are hiltons. sunattpeteu

lusdsohy. fail of mid. unstruns

W. HARRY IIDMARSH A if;°.r.'..r.:°:l:_L.:f-t':;._j:-:.5-;.-_*_._.;:_

Csslsreis night r y lr and ‘bowels sud wats up alter

Oni 55. water street. my -led sverfvl No lrislns--I-~

M inoonysnisaos. Children love Ons

/t *ww

_ vt snr: at-.1l»','_'.\ _.»t’- '

I ing on the Government the necessi ty of operating the mud bed-s of Richmond Bay. He Wen! B0 fl' as to propose a railroad on the ine. I think. But now he has dropped the idea. I-ie has done away Wm! the dredge constructed by the late govern-men-t. which, when in opera- tion at St. I‘eter.=i_ did so much for the fm-mel-5. ms government has disconftluuod it, _and they W9-"G “ll” parently ibrgoiten that tihers S ,mussel mild 'in all? 0'! the Uihef bays or harbors of this Province. i And now in regard to taxation. I am not going to follow che ex- -ample set by the Attorney General and go into figures. because that is a matter to be discussed when the Budget cornea up. .I will take up for the present the general 3.-.~»~t of the subject.

What mandate did the (lovem-

ment nave to impose this system of taxation? I want to refer to some rsmarlcs mule on the other

Leader o PWS! reference to taxation. The atti- tude of the Leader of the Opposi- tion is tus mnetodsy-el it vw- When we went to the country at the lost election we admitted and stated to the people that the rove- nue was not suificlenft. for the pub- lic servdco und for t.he additional provision -for she necessary remu- neration to the teachers. Our

it has always been upheld by the Lender of the Opposition and it .has been referred to by him on the occasion of this very dlsihste. Yet the Attorney General has at- tempted 'to quibble on this point- though I do not think he-wasin earnest when-be did so. I-is tried to show that the Opposition voted for this Govermnentis taxation measure. Ho knows that A vote is not taken on the first reading of s bill. Wo expressed our views in no very uncertain terms in the -general discussion of the measure. More than thst, we expressed our views by proposing sn smmdinsnt to the whole Bill upon which we voted. mt they had the ltiori- ty in -the House-4 isrse meiority --and we d‘.i not consider that it was necessary to wsst ti e with

-was um of msn s rind susc-

sids of the House as to what thai

f the O tion said with!

the Government would say. Look down through the history of ou Empire. Wihat brought abou the rebellion against-the Stewart monarchy which ended in tho bo- headim; of that unfortunate Ising Chas. I? What caused the Empire to lose the fairest of her colonies if it were not that Great Britain at tempted to tax the people of those colonies against their will and without a mandate from them? And I say that any Government - that comes with false statements before the -people and are elected upon these promises and af‘terwards.le- gislates in direct opposition to the pledges they made--I any these men are not the true refpresenta tives of the people- This is the condition of affairs in our Province today. -We have taxation imposed by men wrho were elected to carry out an opposite policy. -. - -

The present Government have

tried to quibble over the question The Leader of the Govemrment hiis made statements-tihat are unwor- thy of him. 'He has said thn_t_the statements _of the Government pre- sented beffore election do notfblnd him or hls~party. What is it that is binding? . Nothing unless it be set. forth in a resolution _-moved by himself on-the floor of this House?

He -is, then, a. free lance? \‘Vhot;

‘ i.

his party goes to the/rountry ‘ sunpose they are.toid:' _“Wo-wnn you to win thoelection--v1i.n it _any way-lnrake what tprotmi-ses. ‘yell pl¢ase:.t'hoy arc riot binding if they .aro,uot. puviuf the; fern; lot,-"a reso- .lu1»l¢‘>.I\-"-" H0 says -new 'that ‘ his govisrumont .never 'stated itx- Wa _

ation, lu many respects this gentle nnan is u negative genitloinan. is that the way policies are formed? Did his zoverlrment ever -state that they' WOULD incrnso the _tu- ss? (ian faith be placed in any body etnies whorormtuats it unli- ey in such a fashion? But let us

t e statements he did

B I

._ ~\

MY. those geutlmen are fairly and squarely as being op- i't0S0d. up to the time of the elec- U°“- £0 any further increase in was 'Hwy stated emphatically both in this Hou-se and to the peo- ple that the then revenue of the Province was amply sufficient to D85 the teachers what was requi'r~ ed lf the money was judiciousiy ex penned 'I’hn‘t was wh-at they 9186806 on public platforms and ihfossh their press. that and nom ini: less and upon that they were elected

Well, we had the election and

we know the result of it The Lender of the (iovemrment says that chickens have an unfortgu nate fashion of coming home to roost When when 'he visited hris new office after the election and found the desk “empty and everything deserted--he must have found a great many chickens roasting about! He found_ for one thing, u tlireatened Strike of the teachers on -his hands: and he knew that Phe had not sufficient ro- vonue to meet their demands-(we

” Y' 1 _

of what the Leader oi' the Govern- do ~'

1- . _ u-bt the most important commit __ ment or the Attorney Goneml miiylteo in connection with the Legisia

viwedgturs. 'mis duties they have ts

perform are vital ones, and t e amount ot good they can accom pllsh is very great Tho session last year was a long one and the reports were brought clown early A good deal of time was spent out side the House in connection with lother business so that the com mittee had large opportunities for performing their work And now in the first place, let us just lock st the report which was brought down by Ehs committee

"Your Committee spent some

time examining e Public Accounts.

il E are not at the present time able to make a full report

lily information is that compnra

tively early in the sitting they ob tained from tho public auditor a statement oi' the-ilnon<_:i_al.,condi tion of tho' I"ro\"l1lce‘ nvhlch really is the wlhoie substance of -the min ority report; tln'1.t-that ,statement was handed to ltheitn tit ,least bd fore the -Budget was delivered and

told htm that often enough..-.arid his spec-.chr>.s.on the floor.of,this House prove ' that _ho heard _'_us\- and he mad to find Lbatf»'reven_ue somewhere. He had also to',iInd an.excusr.i for imposing that reve- nue, and so wo get the story of the piling up of the public-debt by the Conservatives,-_'and`.the build-_ ing- up of indnenso`\`9.gures. ~..’I‘he

when wo came lu wo found a tre- ttnendous deficit." .

‘ Let us _assume érbr one moment -that they were'x -t-it-'will be .amply proven that they _are-_ far .from being right~,but.let us ns- ‘_‘s'ume that they were; ls..1;hst a boun fide excuse? I think wscan

come to li ` _ ““'k°‘ H “'°“'d b° “mmm 1°' iprovo from their own-mouths that

deed to decide or iudgevl' IUPUI any opinion as to what DOUGY N10 Government has adopted by any- thing outlined regarding it by the Leader of the Government. They have certainly never made nn? statement, either on the floor of :tibia House or to the people. to the effect that if placed in power they would impdbe additional taxes. or

"that such taxes were necessary to

carry on the affairs of the province. As I said before. tho A’i10'\'D°Y 0611' eral has ouibbled in this mlllief- He says than what be emi-ed in Opposition was “if wo HAD HAD tus rt-venus that you .HAD -Wg wouidhave been able-to csrfi' 0°- I want him to refer to his party paper, the l’at\_'iot, and read their report of the-same statement as made ln this House in 1919. They do not report it that way- li quotes him as sayinc: “lf We had the revenue that You have we could carry on the affairs of this -province and make revenue and expenditure meet. and pay I-he teachers su that they reuuiref' M that time tin 1919) the hon. mem- ber from West River (Hon. Geo. E. Hughes) said that: "there WM plenty of money if lt. was properly and iualsiously npr-lied-"

My friend the hon. .member for

Sourle _(Mr. H. D. McLean) has nl- resdy quoted from iihe Journals of this House resolutions proving the attitude taken by the than 090084- tion regarding taxation when the War and Health Tax Act came up. The Attorney General will soy -this measure was but u “subter- fuae." But t-ako the context it- self. What does-tho aunondmeufi. say? '

“ry no _

That is what the .resolution says

and that is what it intended to convey to the people. The point Iam making is this: that in spite

Where' there is s persistent cough or \. general run-down 5

*it is _not_ They knew from the public accounts” when _their _-own

party went. out og power in 1911 the debt had reache the million dollar _ mark-. The Mtorney General has calculated to his own satisfaction that the debt had been _'increased in-1919 to $1,500,000. Of course hlis contention is absurd and ridi- cuious,-<but give hhn the beneht for the present of -believing him sincere. ' 'lihey went to the coun- try,'thsn, knowing that we had a 'debt of $1,500,000.. and yet. assured the people that-they could carry ion wfthout adddtional 'ts:rat°lnn,- all that. was -necessary ~,wsa_eeono- lmy and good management. After the election they found as they claim a deiioicfor the current year of some _$232,000. wh~loh_the_y pro- sredsd to add to the_permsnsnt debt and this, they say is therrea- son for _their change of policy. In other Words, 8. public _de_ht of $1,500,000 could be-'paid off with present revenues administered with economy but a debt of $1,750,000 required the _most burdensome and obnoxious system of taxation ever heard of.

'Of course we can readdly see that this reason was false. abso- lutely. It was not u. real reason at r.-Il. 'rho real reason was this: they obtained powerby deceiving tihe people of the province with false promises: they fouud vlroir task an impossible oiw, und instead of formulating a new policy and submitting it to the people, they, without any mandate from the

took to lelrislate the most intri- cate. and. _to the people of this 'province the most obnoxious sys-

policy, which was to impose a tax' nl 1 M we ,went ummm. _

that would be used for educational mm; 'qfwour I-,mvlmm snbsmy :gist ¢gx_:__x;;§io;_ which we _hsve purposes alone, was clearly stated and of me. increase of our ¢@v¢v._ la it any N556” than that we to the People. We told the pe0Dle W, from Omer mm-cu and in vigw pmpm of ma Dmhnce 'Me mm?

that _if the burdtan of the increusgg of the practi-eability and striving mm? _ _ _

salar os to teac ora was remov _mt M a ,-Bd»\,,c¢_|0u |n wr Mm

we would have sufficient revenue_e“,y°°d“_urN_ me reenwnmwt “_ mgtiir _l_\;1y__\_:_t_7;ldt:)\;”:I_1atcil‘i_dt.ié;;1ati<>_r; to curry on: that was our policyuyw "Wm, “nd “muh Tu A¢¢,__ uw” my uwmmy why we _C-“___ ‘ww md it ‘S umhmgad mu; uw' " m°“°b°1°“" ‘md um"-’."°`\°°"°D"i"° i“'°‘"- °" th” L°“°'-°-gi; notspornnt s`r6P°rt what old not is not permui

’ ' ‘ if-5° iw” °" "U "WD" suit them to be engrossed on the mm M tm, 3|

his party should stir'up indiana

been plvento stir such indignation in the mind of any honest elector! 'It just comes _down to fihis that the govern-ment have no' authority from the people to 'inn-pose a taxaf tion measure which'-is eminently and exclusively the prerogative of the people themselves. And thii mes-sure is being imposed not only

tion, when sufficient reason h_al‘|t,|m-,L ~ - _ _before the

_ _ _. __

-that ltwas -liwtns mods et 'tits Leader of the Opposition before he ‘delivered ‘his _.speech dn_ che* Budget and was, then quotedin the dehato 'I nm further _ infonmed that - the Lender of -the Opposiitloni who --was a member ounhat coiumittee. lished tue, , gentleman.. who' prorated the. _ re-port,to-,lugrostyt is statement on tho'Comniitteea` re1iort‘and' wks ‘giv

5 wus; "gay Zgxffd mn wus- mfg _en ,to ut1dens_tanti_thnt-'itfpsfouid be. came to

111°" `P°"°Y ‘NUT-'° ‘°i"i’“P° .'-““’ ¢ne°nu:n=;Jkunt|1 1719: fiinfigt-ig?-.w<§""°“”' ‘ M My "-“° °° “'°»“‘. "°“‘-" “wif °W°

thought thuywcro all righ~t,_ mm -the afternoon before adjournment _to lah,

under the impression that this M meh. ow ‘would be done. And when was the the minorni report submitted? 'Iihe Attorney gm-ery, if ¢

General -takes the miinority' mein- “wld have be béru of the committee to teskfbe- h0'w many mo,- causo their -rf-port wus not- _pre-_ru-mm be in-the sented until the- _clpsiug hours of How many mis the session; ‘When .was the. ma- made md- cm, ,iority -report submitted! After wmmmed mu

. . _ _ Us

1'( si r V4

right to 'mx runnisntvns.

._ _ ______v _

- I. _ ._

_ .

_ _ _ ._ h

. _ ' .ln - _ th

. ' ' "‘ _':b\|1.

__ _ _ .. _ . __ _ __ ____

01"

eight o'clock,-_ just ' 'the night be- _“gm-_, fore! The llou-so was to meet In. wnélugo the next morning simply to $5 oppqme haw q _iom-n and the minority- report was _,they have Uh

submitted- duririg the very- few moments

dn__so. The niaioriiy report. sub- H 0, gh 1 mmsa ans sight uslere. was not wiywm ‘2h'\,“§ shown to the minority members qt Govemorm ,vo t'hs committee. The hon. mem- of what .h

bei' for Sourls (Mr. H. D. Mclmiihl

hold of it

Mit LEPAO-E--I had that report

owing to the continuous pl-as ___ um whom s re of other Lo islntive duties we Tm, Almmpy

that it was possible to wngrmmuory

- 2

i sg’ bt

usi

i it

in my .possession when I_was in the House, ` The gentleman from

Sour-is did not neil to’ see lt. ,g,m}\__.,m,| the, MR. H. D. hlcbl-IAN-'The report mst is mx9s_

- - . » 1

_ s

was ro ered only the evening bo-

P D L sa o fore-next morning it was pre- of ' h;,,‘ epwu

.- 'ees‘lt? I ~ -

sented. How couid_I_ _ _ cyatmefp vu; - .'needn’t

.MIL STEWART We _ .trouble a‘bou*t. that point/. It was the dutv of the member for West River to .show that report and have the members sign it-mot to -seep

it- in _i_\_ls pocket. ,The Attorney- Gene: ' says that our minority .re-

thtrt it should have been submit ted as an amend-ment to tho main

rt I would ust sdk him to

port was not properly submitted- ‘gut-,.04 tus' ‘ J I _ ; -I

read over the journals ofoin and way to better i he will and that the man reportl -__-1 was not adopted There is no re-

in? _

solution on the' ieurnais' _for the

'a-loptlo-u of the report. than how

could .in amendment be brought York W1

THE ATTORNEY GENERAL

meiit___i;h;i;\id have been made in 'gussip in Lon

people who olocted them. undei~` .lH0N_ '_\'_ E_ ARSE:N_\Um._._ n_.soy-Cnnpen»tier

(I-Ion. Mr. Johnston)-The nmend~ LONDON, M

was novor in committee. imelli <\\U`ibl“i‘<i

Mr. STEWART-There was no

report unnll the-night before and .then it was tabled without notice.

How could they amend the Report in committee orfouts do commit- tee when they did not know there

The minority report was tained

but the Government members ex- _ ln, d

Wasil report? _ _ ' mm,-, gum”

sr-cuss their umm-1 and would Sf-4°* “°U°°¥=

BI th dw tn

'records of the House; so they kept I

Further than that my hon friend

from Souris (Mr. Mcbesni in pre- senting the minority report nisdq s motion that it be adopted, and the motion of the Leader of the Govemtnent was that it be N01* adopted or printed in tiiis journals. It all comes down to this, that I-h0l° Sentlemen onthe other side

» » ' Wilhoit! tllell* llftlsbrlny MB--lil G16- wigh' to |‘||`/'_ fm- md, ,Wu pm,

condlhqni 'Nt GUWIMOQ lb Chill' Wllbll- img", gn; 5

Scott’s Emulsion

isspositiveltclp. _

lsualsswm.1\mms.ou\.- In-U

eonneenos with tile minority n.

iii

tllD6itllUr

-A uuvviion has been raised -is ,vp uw ,_ th

'iiu_t:e uric; feoorau

W wilson-was submitted hero “_ “y.osr. I vu not s member st that was sid, passes’ ei §i‘.*..“i‘.°ii‘¢.’l‘ .i ...H ‘ii'i..'°.-..‘.i"

ll ’ . 10

Accounts' Com-mittee -1| without

l »

‘pri-su_ed. 'Ni I lttdcatauvu iswryini we tBfY\\Bl$l .heptoiftlmlo

fail

ham pits

they-kept itlfrscc

‘und br uma

~ I

. -A

wished to see. it nhdoould not get neue, n_m,ma|

-runnin

other ll. finances dealt

WM!

at each other

we find?

spoken of, a. h guruted financ the Dominion G stone crushing

e ler f the

--the voice of voice of God."- then' my- frieu ment benches n verse, very hes' lc.-ts lot, beciiuf

playing- and te;

is sounding f province to them. in tones

he definitely _ champion in NW 2nd_ Carpcntie Enziand nad o box in an éxh

the K an

with a badly ed in an exlii

-.\~-

""7- 5%*

_ ___'.-f _rt his `