__£p——---'

' 'illwl llllllllll.

runnau r unison llQIerr-u gd per no: (‘K514i In adinqit ll all“

liven!) In advance--

(in undid-IO to [LS-A-

uk .' Q inn mum nun-anne- cu Charles n-mn. P: Lat "can" I i

r, .

sbytheW

THURSDAY, MARCH 22, 1923

IMPQIITTANT ruoaatznie;

Two important Judgments given by the Supreme Cour!

uge in abusing the critic and an peallngjo the public for symdill-hyf This mu ‘a: thing will not so

‘Guardian. One deals with our Pro-

dawn with our peublk- Les-rims"

are given in __ yesterday‘! criticism o! the government's acts

must ba met by lexitlmate orall- Whcre the criticism is wrong. if it be wrong, it ls an easy matter to point out the (.l'l".7l‘.)'1'1l@ public will readily understand this, bu; the interpretation the public will give to a whine or to is

bfbltion Act, the other with The ‘Taxation Act. ‘The two are a rcv- elation his w the powers d! 11w provincial legislature which are by many regarded as unlimited. According to lllcsa judgments the 1103131011110 '10" 5° 50 131'; "he" calling the critic ugly names, it undertakes to go beyond this, ammply m,“ the "menu, w“ “my. 11181101‘ 0011“ 110100110115 110011 "0 lied and that it struck home. any; "no further,“ During the present session the Much as we might otherwise public will he anxious to know "the wish‘, it, ‘appears that the Iegislg- tflllll. the Wilhif.’ truth lilld K101111113 ture in enacting that it is unlaw- but the truth" and this they 110W ful to have in possession lmoxi- a right, to. Naturally the govern- cnting liquors procured elsewhere ment will try to make the best of than from the Vendor. such enact- its case. This lt has a rlflht to do ment Was bevsnd the powers of bu! 11°1a111l8EHp€rl3e of the truth the legislature and section 52, o! or by misleading figures or be- "IFAQR 15 111111 81"! V0111-1101W1f1l- wildering transpositions oi’ figures. The opposition. which differs wide- ly on many points front the gov undcltake to show

lnent.

standing subsequent amendments.

The other was the case oi‘ the hovluclal Treasurer versus the James C. Tuplin Company, an ac- tion to recover a taxation account of 0200. The mixed up condition of the Taxation Act is indicated

crnlnent, will where and why it differs. This cannot be regarded as abuse" as it is so often called. The pedpila will understand it and no critic- ism of the government that is not merited, will injure the Liberal party. The governments weak points are generally indicated by

in the following extract from the Court's judgment:

“The tax imposed for the your 1821 is declared by sections 92 and 93 ‘to be duo on tho 2m] any of January of that some year before

the volume of its squeal when hit in a weak

We look

spot. " for a fair presentation

Note

ay l __ ‘~00 Th. spud, p“, m; Throne at u‘; opening of the Ueglslnturs ill- diuates but a Lari" 111“ °1 m‘ for the 00min! 8055M“- s°m° may inquire whether it is WNW "0110 to ring the dinner boll when thcrw is so little on the table. But this seems to ‘be a.caae in which use prlncgpal feature of the menu card is the toast/list cream‘! 1° ‘"1’ ply subjects for posbprandlfll 0" tory, it now becomes evident that the example s91 10 11"" Prevmq“ sessions is inieild0l1 l0 110 1911*" 2L] in this fourth scselvn- Trim"? three texts are 811901100 111 “s many paragraphs as thcnl08 101' "the feast of reason and the 110W ‘oi soul."

The festive board l: therefore IpfOld, the Sllests are seated thercat, the orchestra in tune as in pastycars. all ready once again to render the political orator-lo of self laudatlon and mutual admira- tion. The nlusic will be chiefly vocal, a series of $0105 1011 by 1119 mover of the address in reply. To him will follow n second nnd a third oi; percbance to the number of twenty or twenty-five with an accompaniment of cheers and thumping of dealt lids. Music with its voluptuous swell will th-rlll and vibrate in the upper air while rills of oily eloquence will trickle doivo ward from the table. and thence meandering lubricate the course they take along the floor.

In such high festival where each of the select company z-f zludltorte is himself presently to be a performer, none can fall to ap- plaud. To be silent would he ta invite a like silence when he bim- self should rise to sing. The cheers and plaudits are thus guaranteed

{We crosses

The Public

‘lilo column In open (or (‘q discussion by correspondents of questions o! Interest. The Charlottetown Guardian loss

necessarily endorse the onion expressed by It: con respondents-

l§1..,.'“'~ng": s. w- ~ - , . , ,5. infib; ‘place of C and ‘a v v t and glorious dead. —

l arn, Sir, etc“ TRAVELLER.

A second Car Perry

3lr,--Wi'th the exception of your editorial couture-at l regret there has bcctl no reply in your columns to Captain Road's onslaught on tho gecolld Car Ferry project: the Tfgugpofléillioll Committee 0r coun

An Explanation

Slrr-lu a rel-eat issue it was rs-

cesslty of toacliingo

hlwould seem to inanim-

fear or any lqt the ne- good, Chris~ tian morals in schools is an old.

l . l , , y‘ 1 " nfimlfiifi-lliwfl

time honored subject, althotlsh ll

may possibly be Just dawning up- on the minds of some. l remember it was the very first utrinciples which were instilled into my mind when l ‘began my education in thlfl 01W. when l was anrere child. r1110 as l am no spring chicken n0W.—- that was lrgood many years ago. There is, no "dawning" upon it

ported that the assistant superin- tendent. seamstress and laundress walked out of the Protestant 0r- phanltge on strike for higher wages. This is incorrect; the reason these enlployccs lcft their positions was of an altogetllq- different nature,

cll of the Board '0! Trade should have lniniedldtelyt joined issue w-lth the gallant. Caption. and showed as they easily could have done, lite fallacies in his spnlagle for mouth vrc have these stats-meats.

now avail. Luckily we have in our midst. some schools which always think of the moral side of the 1711111108. and I was fortunate enough to have received mly edu-

, (COPYRIGHT) emu m THE ABDOMEN

There are so many thing's that

tllc C. N. ll... Out of his own

"L351 ivinter we never missed ‘a trip nnd everyone had about made‘ up their miwds that the Car-ferry‘

l am, Sir, etc, leiit. nothing to be desired except

ADA NlCHOLSON- that a duplicate boa!- be hull-t. bill ____..<¢> " this willlcl‘ has proven lhharshe

_ s ' p; pm, at all suitable to esp up

The cm“ B" ~lu‘i the service on a really hard wint-

- __ . - . l i t er, and l for one am not satisfied sélsérnaliiigiiiseillicaigiowfghhrdliailresé "1111 1'1"’ g" “he ‘has, “snakes: this convenient and cheap method 9118.110 “"1 he‘ power r“ glhvel “had 0f Improving winter locomotion. ffifildfllh ~11‘ 1:131:11“? 9m 9' “Eal

When l came lo Harcourt, N. 8., 5110 110911 411101” e l e r hr in '89 i found the need and great Grdy 11-111“ the except on 0m er benefit of the cross-bur. especially bow and ulth more power, ere on roads in which double teams would 11"" bee" 1* ‘11“$"°"1 5'0"’ wcre driven. Far out in the heart of N. B. forests visiting lumber

t0 tell. "1 was about three years camps this rig was quite the thing. 0n the "Grey" hilt! in 811 it is so simple, cheap and easily removed. that ii needed-the horse

that time l never saw

her s0 that she could not back up can be ill central track or on the right, hard wcll trolldell runners

and fillili. due to her rounded side (JOIJFSG.

W-hGTOZIS this boat was stuck ‘al-

most every day since the first 0!

While driving with Mrs. McLeod January so that we could- no!

from Upper Mnsquodoboit to Silent budge bur. some days for hourB Harbor. Halifax County, in 1911, we struck a double team track in

at a time.

"This round side would also e1- lleavy snow, on an eighteen mile forest road. Wllcli we arrived eta house ill the WOOUS. I secured an axe, cut down a small birch tree and with only hay wire to match soon bud an outstanding evidence of tllc benefit 0f the douhlc cross- bar. if the sliliWilft steed i at an earlier dale purchased ill Crapaud, on this occasion could speak. he would excloim: “What a boon to the patient. intelligent, oft over- worked horse is the double cross- hnr!" ,

l amfSir. etc, WILLIAM McLEOD.

Stone Haven, NB.

and the trustees kuuw this to beso. No nlonotury consideration caused us t0 leave our positions.

long straight side cannot do this. "To gct a better modelled boat at this time is out o! the arrest-ind

the present costly 1011081‘ W510i"

will be setting pretty ripe ma“ l,- wlien we should demand a larger and better boat with more beam. capable of having three

of twvlvc and with double the pOW er of this boat. and I think we should gcl it by showing the pow-

in advance. however dull or coul- mollplace the music of the mo- ment nnd whether tho voicc which semi; '1 forth be strident or mel-

lny of the nulncrous steps above ol facts at this session both from.

lifhtrtla S» voice after voice will talu- lm lilo song until its tender

——-—<+0~__._ impressions of a Traveller be lllatiil during the Fall and Win-

gs,- iyy [hv potverful boat carrylnil

Sin-Leaving Stiurls, that wide- awake and progressive litllc tmvn which may be termed the capital of tllc eastern section 0i the island, we passed through a place called

conouiy of running the

i

traffic is not heavy.“

Herc are all the requirments

as n ‘wum “man the scrapplng o; are very pleasant ones of

hracksaoctlrry twentyicarslnistead give the impression flint the time

ars "that bc the saving that could nary to

flecessarl‘ for a second Car Ferry; 1119 Rotary Club or this city.

tuition in one of‘ these. Thsfofoffi. l am in a position to know exact- ly and nppreciaftf the value oi‘ such training in schools, as l can spear from hctnnlexperlence. in the first- place the teachers were all mature in' age, and were not yflllnx girls of fourtcenpl; fifteen as we often. see tollay,_togohors who are littlghnorp‘ thqurohlldroil themselves, and who cannot have at heart the full significance of giving the child a good. moral "$111108, as well as teaching him his A. B. C.'s. Our teachers in the school which l attended had every attribute which would minke them ca-patble of being the guardians of the minds and nllorals of the coni- 1118 seneration. They were per- sons o-f culture, and refinement, whose characters were beyond re- proach, and the atmosphere of whose very presence gave an air of confidence to thc child, causing his little heart to become attach- ed to the nobler nnd better tnlngs of life. They were persons who

ltlaced-Gsd and Christian morals who, low U", "Earl Grey- “, m", quick. strove to inculcate into the mind ly in icc and allow he;- to follow 01 1110 011110 i111 the lculls While this boat with her Principles of

above all earthly dross, flnfl

those ibCflllfl-flli 200d citizenship ivhicli would menu so much to him whcn he would take his place in life later on. Yes, m-y recollection: those $9811! ill =l

-url_v (luvs which i

. , rm n e ,- they sChOOI where the mural training e, perhaps cons but m “W!” or Be y a s and of the child took precedence over ffistpconsiipation is n0!

the materialistic studies which‘

had to do simply with worldly prn-1 fit and gain. Yct l do not wish col

spent on moral training in any way lessened the iiiW/Giflplllfiill. of] those studies which arc so neces-

have ill orllcr to earn livelihood. Our teachers. WEN} ull of the very highest gratin,

rmrfs

..--—~ twoilty cell's of freight and the e- and some of them llatl been toaolt-jthc Erllllidiillllfl present mo’, for 3'00"’. nnd were not "bird-gulp u,“ it boat (lllFillK the summer- when theloi‘ passage", us Mr. (frockett Chllr‘ u; pom] 111011115

ucterlzcd our teachers of lollnyq in addressing n recent meeting of, in

Ifyuilg predominating.’ and bcn

sot forth had been taken to ascer-

ths governnicnt and from the up-s

liollo Bay. a good farming district

may cause that. pain, that I'm not going w try and tell you what is causing your particular pain. For instace a. pain down near _the right lower part of the abdomen ls often called inflamation of appendix 01w Just under your heart an ulcer af tbe stomach. one over to the right side opposite heart. inflarnatlou 01‘ thc bilc duct oi’ liver. and so forth. Now willie this may be all true. as a matter of fact most. of the pains in the abdomen are 41110 '0 the formation 0f 885- T139 P10851110 of gas in the intestine is very’ i101“ ful and you can hardly‘ 00 111011190 for imagining that all sorts of con- llltlons are exlstllli-Z within you; Now ltow can you straighten £1118 uratter out! . Just do a little quiet tcrIectinB, and observe yourself closely- While it is not consid-‘qed Wise to counsel people to examine them- selves. yet wily should you be d" fraid to consider that body yours for a moment- tlf that pain shoots from side to side. now in one. P1800 ""0 "ow in another and F011 have 11° fever’ nor vomiting. if the P0111 “m” on any old time instead of sa)'_ 011 hour or four hours after 8811118- ihat is no dlifinitc time, if the belcliing'of gas or passing 0f 3B5 o,- lituvemellt of the bowels 1'8- llnveg the pain then you have no un- usual condition in X0111 "1"1°m°n' tlpntlon. _N0l serious because it 1s. Bill llint. is a condi- Ilbll which your sand "d" m“ correct. ‘ Proper dict W

sass AND souuo m; l8 cosmos sense silly,"

The Companies m, -. make good your Eire Ibssfamn‘ not afford to take the chasm“ ' serious coniiagratlon. You c“ ‘ ford insurance and you can a

nothing but the best. Sea us,

Tbs Hub of incur-am, sank‘

ilylltlman 81C». Ltll.

rm Oldest insomnia Allllcy l,‘

t

_._.._ ,

Daily gellections

Guardian Readers.

From the W. 8. Louoon collection.

ith vegetables and dint! and twisting exercises will silnltb lute intestinal action.

Don't use pl“?! 0r 1111135- Oils. and alive. oil are useful.

Falcons

Failure is ll rocky hill;

Srdrle climb it! cums it with a iviil! p Failure is a broken bone;

1301110101109 '°“'~Sct it! Grill. and do not groan! l p; upon the fnrnlling - in thc mind of 1110 0mm that the gum] cifizenshll? o1 our coming Efilleratw" emhew de-

ponds.

Failure is a tangled string; Puzzle out the knotted thing!

Failure ls a river swift; editorial cribs 10111

pas-lion. as on a historic occasion. gen“; sloping m the south Wm, why not then ivalt twelve o;- iif- fact, aside from our moral tralil- m your "Swim it! Swim it, and do not drift"

58111 111B hereon or the property’

position and from their respective; newspapers. ‘Fllfs is what the peo- ple wllnt and they have a right tn ~it.

liable to taxation for the amount of tho tax. it does not help the case in the least to say that the basis of the tax of 1921 is the pro! Flirty which the ‘person proposed] to be taxed had in the year 1920."-BR'T“N's NAVAL "Eouc-‘WONS

The trouble appears to he that ‘ the framers of tho Taxation Ac; copied certain scctifins of the Bflt-lsh Columbia Act omitting cert,

—-—--¢a-¢i-—-

Even with all Brifains need for‘ economy nnd in face of the heavy tax burden on her people, the First Lord of the Admiralty} alpol- Osy for not further reducing the naval expenditure seems excess- |1V8.

Britain, from ltcr ilwo power standard. has already so far cut down hcr navy that it is now bare. 1y at a one power standard. With 00¢ "$111118 for the Washington TrflfiY to he ratified by the other “Bacteria. she carried out its provisions. Tllc other signatories have not yet done so. She has Ecfflllillcd l4 oi‘ her incst capital 5111118. lenlvirlls herself greatly in- 197101‘ 111 1175i: and second class ships ts both the United slim-c and Japan. She has reduced the personnel of the fleet by 22,009 and that of the dockyards by 10.~ 000.

With greater need of pawn prg tectlon than any other pflwey, win can so no further. Any plea from the Government for 01mm- sation of its refusal to furtherrlsk the security of the Empire seem; unnecessary.

sin sections which provided the ma. chinery for collecting the faxes

and decision was given against the Provincial Treasurer.

The powers of the legislature art,-

Widm they may prohibit much and‘, "lily tax much. but there is a-polnt beyond which they cannot go one there are rights which the). m“, 110i lsllorc. Much trouble and much BXTEIIEB misht bc avoided if our law makers knew what their pow- 0" T0011? are. Much of ths time 01' 1119 Present parliament has been spent in correcting errors 111B! had nrade inlprevious ses- 510119 611d it would flllillear they still have corrections to make or 10 bedlloth to their successors

CRITICISM

It is the inalienable right of all free, born citizens in a free coun- 11‘? 10 express their gpprqvd] or diurnal-oval oflhe public acts of the men whom they or the mayor. ilty of them, elected to do their Pllbllc business whether in feder-

al, nrovin lal__ f‘ murnjglpg] (mum ciis. atfi i3.- j

-—--—-¢o>_..___

BUT NOT TO CANADA

Official figures of British omi- gration indicate that the rush to the United States continues, and that long before July 1—the earl of the fiscal year—Britain will have supplied her quota. of 77,342 under the larw which limits ‘H19 immigration in any one year tn Masons of various notional origin to three per cent. of the number of immigrants of the same race already resident in the United. States. The number of British gifti- Qflhtl to the United States from July l, 1M2 till tlls end of Febru- ary, 1923. was almost fifty thon- nnll, no that if $8.000 seek all- mission daring March. Ann-ll Hay all! lone. the chief immigration smalls, t: will t» seesaw-y to pm

'11 111.1101 Ilwllyi a pleasant task 10 d1Bll>l1r0Y§,-',n0t_hiways an agree lids duty to "criticize; nor i5 it fllreaablc to=he;orifl_cized. Yer, em. 1015171 10 1B8ltlnfl¢o and necessary. The public lntsrestdemaadsuhat the acts. of pub; \,_'|_len be openly and ptlalicly _, ‘_ d. approving- ly when deserfid; disluprovinglv where nscsnssfgiin the public la- tlrblt.

The criticism that hurts most. an: which parathion; does the mm um. is that which ill-um at the most obgoos weakness 6r i" l0" mivdnodiaadl tit It!!! e bdran ltd

Fhfitflllllld llt/‘illkvdl whore»

shall rise, an anthem rich nnd strong in praise of the Bell (inv- ernment and of themselves for

supporting it.

of exuliatioil and mutual iandation was twice rendered. first in the

debate on the address, ‘and later; when the bildget tvas brought} down. Tltr're"'"""litrv‘e" livid doubts: even in the party ranks as to wllc-' thcr some more varied perform-i once should not be substituted tori it on the prescilt occasion. That it is rather too stale and 3110p- worn for repetition if hwthing ibettcr could be found to bc put on was generally admitted, Ibul nothing new or attractive being available. it has apparently been decided tn repeat the old chorus oi‘ adulatory rbapsodies once nlore. Should the cheering be in stifli- clent volume tllvro may 'bc even a second rendering along with this year's budget later on.

‘fills course of action ll now compwlsory. The party was float-

"11 P01111111’. and arrived at a place

in each previous session undcrlscttied audWIveli-cui {the Bell regime, the grand ohm-us part of Dulldas; thence westwardlnbsolute (ibiiglltlons to fulfill we

_tlle lilllc Waters ofilic gulf shinl.| fmPrirrg in the distance. 'l’assinz' 911110 79B?- We came i0 Dlngivellf-llmfly excm” Mills. all uld established mill site. llleaving Dingo-oil's 31111,- we pasged‘ar our absolute lill‘0llR1l a low lying vroodcd sectionillailvral‘ in 1101

pence in (tooling with other mailed Albion Cross; tlicncc tilrnlnpgilces- splrnllini! _ !soutii We passed ll;_rongl1p»we1).., cow-unfairly. on other Provtnc tlvated sectiotL-cil willie tiers Whore 1116"’ 1"“

is expense.

necessity’?

Prov-

Pa-ll =1 dvmvwry with its headstones and monuments pointing sky-wards. ayrdlfs‘ -El€l-,'Y comes to mind: 1w Proud-f: Thence westwardilotter it llppvars to me that the ihrlfiiiilf-ljllllllas c clltrc or Crossffnptainis pritlu- objection t0 11h Rom,“- At 11115 Illltce stands [DQ156630 Car Fcrry is that he him- 31191151? Chllrvh- which. for llrtrlli-fsolf uld not command 1W0 C81 tcciural beauty and artistic dcsignipepryd at one and the same time, 15 ‘W11 WOrV-by oi‘ favorable com-"But sirely there is a duplicate of mam‘ o“ h1g1‘ "°“'“110111000r11I§Capts§l Read stilncivllere about. stands the Pres teriun Church andlamt it not it is tmc one was in gelmelllry- which contains a bcauti-‘Mraynqg (or we have no more Iglenfloilrll, lglhlrcssive monument lni o of ‘Ciiplflin Road's con ins lltsirlittlilllisilfyoni Lh°,s"'r°"-"d'1""“ °’“"°“°” “d “Eemess Th’ l e in tie Viorld War, an e have of the Cm- Frry 1t I ls phase boasts of two stores and-salt m‘ seriously, a second Cal 3mg. mouse. Further W's-sit we cnmeip-e" is necessary "m [he winter; ‘age rongatgwg£ “my 111110 "11",", my mind in the summer Gram] mm,- (aie, hi?” . M 111011110 s it could be usefully and a‘ W)” Che-esp so, is a senor-wt“! My gmplnyivl between t¥ii.::';'.:"":':< l» mitt . . , 1 , us » . ' - , . __ - l,lcs- _ ,mc_ "'15 ‘M111’ 011 0 burn-Hille- Thunco I’ sfggggmorc on this subject