Mr

get Debate.

Folmwlng 15 the speech clellvc.c.l

we BurlgSt (RUM/Q by Di‘. W. J. P. ‘who seiner Conservative mem- “Xor p.511. Queens. Dr. MzMillan “ﬂowed non. Dr. McNeili in the cl:- m m ocean his arldrcws ol1 Thurs- “. g\'('ll1l“.. APT“ 37513

Mr. slwalzrri I do not ixtend to b1 n“. pun friend fron1 Summer- lm Aim“ two and a half hours a- eoehe lntnmtcd that l1e was going w be 111ml. that llo man should take mm U...“ 1311)’ minutes to address m’ Home I do not Lltind to be- a". ma; as in; l'l'ill1llSC(l i0 be. Ilc sakl he w“ will; to be ill‘ cf. and he was not brim/l which is very typical of

l; t; rm": lmrd to say anything to mm‘ bgcﬂllfC whenever he makes a ma“ Cymially when ,hc says ‘mining lildl. should b: anrlercd. he very collrenle ‘til’ K175491115 him‘ . “my. i5 probably his wisest

me K011. gentleman talked this “ﬂing abut a diatcbe thﬂl appeal- pd lgalnst him in The Guardian. Well lf ll" b.1125 on example of n ﬂlltf-bt’. he need only consult his M11019... I do not know wllctllcl- b; expzmdrrl lhcm or elaborated on them as he 703d along; I am incliicd lobellrvc that hc stuck to tllem very gmly. l-lc illls. the reputation, Mr. speaker that \\'llCl.llCl‘ he speaks on the Draft address or on the budget. hi: remark. arc the least in keep- ing math each. The 11011. gentleman likes to fall: Dolnlniol politics, He went bark ill-S evening to i922. b11911 he 15d a privy from the progressive 11mm of Sumnlcrside to Otawa, and by his influence succeeded in gettlqr; lg $10,000 wharf f:r the Prnce County mpilal. ll" silvuid have told us af- terwards (‘not he 1mm largely Insi- ‘fllmflﬁﬁl 1:1 providing :1 vacancy f0.- lh.» pm» ‘t. Premier of Canada

Econ! Of Fail

Ancllncogzpetency

Trenchant Review Of Saunders Governments Mismanagement. By Dr. W. J. McMillan lnBud-

and in gcttng hiln a fne safe Lb- cral scat for a time. After that. when there was a vac-

friend

rslstcnt ‘that

til: Senator for

l

are

should be given to him. was sadly disappointed. Mr. Speaker. because there was a smarter rnan tllrn llc in SulnmersId:-—fhe gentle- man who used to rncupy the scat that I nmv occupy. and who is 1101: Cau -‘._v.

Va. n Rehenrsfng

My hen. friend lnust have groomed yhimsclf for that position. because on we hm guliiﬂlllilll. He is Qellﬂfﬂlli’ ‘every occasion.‘ wllcn he begins to “m; our» tiling ad dong another. its“: i;l tl1's Hilse. hs whole subjcctmmn rgsvJltf-g h an action 0g Crlm.

The hon. gentlemlu talked about the tariff. Ho compared the rcls n; and the lowering of the tariff to

the motions of

says that if the

the tariff. Well. rick down there

l.l this country.

But. the chief

than he was a he used 0x111‘

i tl1e sanctity of

the derrick that is

rais 11g steel girders on the site 0f the new hotel in Charlottetown. l-lc

Co". servatives come

into povrcr they will raise the tar- iff Just lke that derrick; but the proper way is not to do that but to adopt the Liberal method and lower

If they use the der- on the Liberal plan

they will never get the structure er- ected very hgh.

The hon. mcznbel- from Summer- sde made another remarkable state- ment. that there was no hard coal

( Applause.)

He likes also. to gel:

at the millionaires il1 the Conserv- ative party, "Me and Bennett." he says. The peculiar st-ylc of grammar that L‘: used on that side of the all‘? h‘ the Red Chamber’ my hm” |liousc is evidently affecting the hon. fr:n1 Sulnznerslrle was \'ery-ge.,.u._,nm,1_ and

red scat l And he

probably we shall

pref. nlore expressions of that sort from them before the session is over.

An Expert in Dlafrlbc

sublcct of the hon.

winter's address scorned to be The Guardian. He was very violent in bis comments. but lot more violent

fcw years ago, when ions about one of

the writers ol1 that paper which only

his House prevented

lis Dominion politics. He has not ev- filmy 1M1’ 3c wqund up his d5-

,:"n the modesty of my hon. friend imursc this evening by saying mag

from Montague.

cuss the

Di‘. Grant)

l i

they v. ere

I f am ous svsteln

republic

to the

‘The Guardian probably caters to the who had the honor of lacing nomfn- ‘ tastes o; i“ Customers‘ He. rather zit/ed to contest a riding in this prov- illce in the interests of Llberalsm; or of my hon. colleague from the city of Charlottetown. (Mr. McLurel who also had had the honor c011- ffilTed "P011 11ml and U105‘? B"! spoke about those dksturbances in’ honors. Mr. Speaker. in being select-

ed to contest a Domnlon seat in

the interests of either party. My hol.

friend from Montague, ill sizenking- the other day. said he was not lzo-l iug to talk Donllirorl politics. bﬂ-lally the same thing in Toronto; so muplaupe) cause he didn't know oouzh about lwhy shouldn't} it_bc s: in Prince Erl- ‘ tllclrl. But no such fer-Yup of modesty lwm-d I5lm1d?“ 11191-3 “w, m; ygagon, deterred my hon. f-"cnd from Sum- nlcrnlde. He never got a nomination in a Dominion election: quite willing to come l1ere and dis- record of the MacKenzlc Kill: Gﬂvﬂlllllilll- Perhaps. M!" u" ition. should l1ot b: as prominent as the is wise ‘n doing so. bcnuse the the llﬁlllli‘ tiary towns of the great ‘record of‘ the GOvernmcnt of which! he ls a member ls so barren that helm-ought in Toronto, of course, be- cou‘rl (‘mi llttlc excuse for prnlong- cause Toronto is under Government inc h’: remarks: and by taking ‘l\'.'.CDl1l.l'0l.‘Tl‘l€ detectves in that city coursc that he adopted his mm dls- l1nve arrest/ed all but one of the part-

corrlplilnrntcd the readers of that newspaper, in my op'n‘o:1.

0f course, the hon. member from Sllmlncrside could not keel) from this subject 0f Prohibition. He

fl. way

the fails in a way that would imply ordinary "\Vl1_\".' he said. "in Auburn Pen- itentiary‘. il1 the Ullitcd Slates. they llnrl a revolution; they had practic-

OCCUITE"CCS.

so far as the hon. gentleman could sec. why Prisca Edward Island and bul- 119 15 cspcc'c.lly' the

progressive town of

Sumlnersidc. the brhplace of this,

of Saunders Prohib-

South of us. He

‘crrpancfcs arc more likely to pars ics concerned in that escapade; so lit seems that they succeeded ll little

i unnoticed.

,~ i >1- Ftf?‘ \"‘

.\__ . Q

AlQuick “SNACK” for Everybody OU don't even need to break your journey——“Quick Lunch”

touches the spot wherever you are -it’s a 5c package of real energy.

Ch 000

roll. THAT RdNlD-AFTEIENOON "sna0'k "'i

TMAKVE BMS_(_)F

Em

l H l‘; (IMAM H"

better than the detective that was' brought down here by the Govern-

ment of which the hon. gentleman‘ is a member, and paid $1400 for serv-

ces which did not result in the ar- l rest of any one. nor even in finding | out the cause of the fire for which he was speilfically engaged. The orr- i 1y thing it resulted ‘n was the ar-l rest of the agent himself. He got ln-l to trouble. but the other fellows es-' coped. '

SCORES DIISSTATEMENT The hon. member declared. among other tllfngs. that the Attorney Gen- eral has been doing his work so well that there are no lorger any crim- inal cases in this Province. He said that at the recent sittings of the Supreme Court white gloves vrcrc presented to the presiding Judge. and that the papers found fault with this, I suppose he was referritg a- szarl to The Guardian. _Well. 110w. d‘d it? I do not know what column| of The Guardian he found that in.l I read The Guardian myself. and Ii know that, they found no fault with the fact. that gloves were presented to the judge; but 1' do know that there was a letter written by an ex‘- Judge. complaining tltat it was rot right. that the Sheriff should be put to the expense of buying white gloves for the Supreme Court judg- ‘es. If the hon. gentleman will go and italk over the matter of white gloves and their expense will the gemtle- man who has retired from the Queens County Court Judgeshlp probably he aill be better mroi-lnea the next time he endeavors to criticise The Guard- Elan for mak ng such a stateme t. .

HON. DR. MONEILL: I didn't say it. was The Guardian.

DR. MCMILLAN: What did you say? l _

nos". on. MCNElLL: l said ‘s ilaper. I didn't mention any papers i

-DR. MCMILLAN: 'What. paper vras t. then? 1N0 alum-er.)

DR. MCMILLAN: That's one in-

sinuztion that we have nailed down.’

He m. also that m‘ members of the Opposition were the chief aiders and abettors of the law violators ‘In tilis Province.

HON. DR. MCNEILL: I didn't say "cite like.

DR. MCMILLAN: I took your words! d0"! as you said them. You said they l were aiding and abetting the law vio- ' Iatcrs of the Procnee and that thelrl press was doing the same.

HON. DR. MCNEITL: I didn't say‘ the like‘; I said tl1€_5ll}7p0ﬂ!l'5—I didn't. say the members.

DR. MCMILLAN: What is the ﬁll- fcrenee between the “supporterﬂ of the Opposition and (he member! (h: Opposition? " ' ' _

now. D-R. MCNEIIL: ﬁlm is c glot of dlfferercic. DR. MCMlblANz, So on this aide of the House we had better close Bur mouths and not nuke any criticism because. if we do. we are "aid n; and abetting the vlolafcrs of the law in fir‘: province, accordlng- to my hon. friend from Summerslde! Well. I want to tell the hon. gentleman this. that we are not trying lo lid and u- bet the worst law violators in this Prov nce. 1n other words we Ire not trying to aid and abet the Govern- ment of this hovlnee. v.10 are the chief violators of the law. Those gentlemen who are sitting on the Government benches are vlolatill the lawn of this Province; they have laws on the styltute books which they violate every day. And we are not saying anything to add and abet them. you may be sure! But we are trying to give honest criticism, In order to point our where the trouble lies, and to assist in carrying out the laws o! the Province. (Applause) The hon. membe from Summer- side was not content to attack the Opposition press. l-Iehad to reflect on members of previous Legislatur- cr. in this Province. He has been sit- ti ~g there. i1:- said. for four weeks. and during the t‘me tl-lat thisJ-louse ltas been In session he has not seen anyone under the i fluence of liquor. ml‘: that. a wonderful thing? He was surprscd that we were not drunk. Did he think we were like the Inmates in the Summersld: jail? But he sad. you couldn't say that about the members of this legislature if you went back one hundred years. nor even ff you went back a few years . . . . ..'l‘hat is pretty high class criticism, isn't it? If‘ he wanted .to reflect oll the persmul habits of the members of the Legislature. he might have confined himself to the pres- ent generation.

The hon. member talked about leg- alized beer sales in other provinces how they had to legalize the bus- lrless iz1 order to compete with-the bootleggers; and he got. back. at last to the Summer-side "underworld." That was what he called It. It would be a good thing for the hon. gentle- man if he could legalize that, "speak- easy" in Summerslde. that we have heard so much about in this House. HON. DR. MCNEILL: It is closed up.

17R. MmﬂlhbMlzi It was closed up on the day that the Premier de- livered ble budget speech, probably lo u special tr but: to the Prohibit- ion law: and It 1m opened the next moraine. Chad for one My. and e0- opened?

lifrulvly uuAKlll/xw

"FG": NINE

HON. DR. MCNEILL: No 5.x‘. DR. MCMILLAN: Yes air. So much for the sneak-easy in Summersidc. My hon. friend professed to know someth ng about the poor fellow that was dismissed from lllc Sum- merslde Police Force and was taken on as a Prohibition Inspector. Th: hon. gentleman wouidnt rccemmetcl this man to the Prohibtion Com- miss‘on, he says. because he never interfered with anytili g like that. Well, there are some stories to the cﬁutrary. that he has been very fond of ‘Interfering and telling officers of the la". lf they do such a thing. whlf. i! liable to happen.

There ls no better way fa maintain file health of your family than by varying the diet. Serve a variety of the best foods during these bright Spring Days. You will find the fin- est of well known Foods In file EATON GROOETERIA

at Prices HARD T0 EQUAL.

roceries

At Economical “Prices on Specials effective May I6, I7 and 1.9

Special for Friday, Saturday and Monday LLondon Corn Starch- 3 .1... 25C l

AYLIIEH CHOICE QUALITY gatoniazorrslz, 60c

DODG ING THE ISSUE

Sunflower

We all know something about ill:- IOMATUES‘ P" u" -- --

Prohib tion Act, under the lures: o’ M,‘ 2 ‘m’ Each " w“. FRY"$ COCOA

Government. w. rm us, how: KELLOGG‘S cum: Brand y, 111.1111, ’ 2 much i: is enforced, My hon. friend‘ FLAKES, _ Per tin .. .. .. .. from Rustico (Hon. Mr. lzePagel; 3 pkgs, ,_ __ ,_ _, c PALAWAN BLE

spent a lot of time o1 this subject. TwKl-ERS ENGLISH BLACK ND TEA

Salmon ~

tlfs afternoon. He took us to Brit-

‘sh Columbia. to Saskatchewan. to gnAlvﬁaEr MARMALADE‘ Ontario. to Quebec, to New Bruns- ma ’

l llJ. fin wick and Nova Social lo all those Each " " " " " ASSURTED BISCUITS. provinces that are going to Hell iusti JAPAN RICE,

18c . . as fast as they can go. according to‘ PEI‘ lb. . . .. .. .. ‘Ealgll . . .. his ideas; but when it came to Libby’s Home Style Pickles ".2? 23¢

Prnce Ed ‘till Island. why, the llon. gentleman never even landed at ldxLMEﬂs CHOICE PEACHES KRAFT CHEESE, LIBBY’S PORK AND eavy yrup) ' Plain or Pimento. BEANS. V, lb. Each . .. ..

Perlh. .. .. ..

MARVEWS DELECTA

utly alone. He was not as successful in landing here as many of the rum cargoes were that landed right In his own district. (Applause)

Rustic». Ho left the Island absol~ Per tin .. Large Tins .. .. ..

‘The hon. mel11b2l~ from Summer- SPEC|ALI ' __‘_~'l{l:‘z"“~" PEKO TE“ _ side boasted of the progress we were ‘ H uh l ‘xkub.

makng ulld-tr Prohibition. l-le made Alﬁhli- JUlb ‘L’ .' ‘I 1

a comparison. also, with reference to i - ROBIN HOOD 31'A\NANA§

the Opposil iol1 which I could not . Qm "RF-WU" ROI-LED 1' Doz. quite catch: it was something about D02‘ _' gAii

a. child that. was not recogﬁzrd b1.‘ . a” a“ """"""" "

either its father or mother; some- t lllllAbfﬂ - _ SWEET POTNIOES - NEW “HUBARB

thing unusual in his experience. l P" Head - - - - ~ - - - ~ - . . . . .. 18c 73 U15 - - - - - - - - - - - - . - ZLbs. . . . . . . .............. think it. was Governmenl: ¢ontro‘. (‘HOICE (YREl-ZZHERY __ q-RAVEFRL-IT

that he was referrhg to. It obi-nu» ffUTTER Foolish HAM 55c slirsnuiss 29 ly was not. Prohilftion. btrkause if i‘ ‘c’ m” ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ' ‘ ' " or ' . . . . .. c

3 for . . . . . . . . . . . . . . was Prohibition the child wou‘ ~ ' surely make tor the hon, gentlcma from Summersde as its falher. or ‘ would make to the l1ol1. gcntleln" fron1 Rustico as the mother. (Laught- er) Aw] I am sure neither the fath- er nor the mother of the; Prohibit- ion child would repudizlc it.

That is the mytifcal child. But I will fell the», hon. mr-mbﬂ- from ‘n homes where lhr fatbc" rntl 1rd:- Summersidc about children that he or are taken t: .ia‘l nndcr lilo ' :1 d“, no‘ know anything_not myth 59,53 pl-M-fhiggm, Ace pm», ‘i... y”; . ' 11s about real children as he of small children. Those officers un- icll children but reaL-flesh-and-blwa gentleman from Summersidi- l. z :b°=:i mfliu-cll l" 1111115311?! ohll- der the Prohib tuon Act are so zeal- chlldren. Those are the children that anything about. thorn and what h-m- .G:e:1: and that ‘s one of the ways in \ are left. helpless and uncﬁmforted. pens to them’! He need n°t talk a- lwllich the Prohlhlton Act ls doing

. lo‘. h'm'=‘ hlfdjhip In this Provnce, because 1 ‘n reality. HQ s neg 50 f‘. mczm the neglect and suffcrirg

Domfnued on Pate 11

WHIPP ET 6 Four Door Sedan

$1000

DeLuxe Sedan (6 wire wheels) M125, (leach. $935. Coupe and Roadster (with rumble seats) $9.35.

\x/ H I P P E T4 Four Door Sedan

$885

C°a°h {mm CW3"! (with rumble Raf) $800. Roadster (with rumbk 59-11) $785. Touring. $7.15”

ii desired.

Convenient terms

COMFLETELY EQUIPPED

Taxes Paid . . . Delivered in Charlottetown F, R, 186 Grafton Street, Charlottetown

p, y, N91, mmtu- mm, column’ altos. Somme ..:.*.=. Bunsen. CLARKE. m. Stewart. KING'S COUNTY GARAGE

iii- rum-xi

Manta-nu.

1 iii