. . . , --....... _¢-...~_ an," _.- ..

=- > cuss‘

ttmtmwusui 1111

" v-OOO-Q-OOOOO-OOOOQOOQ-OOOQOOI ll‘ f 10' 1923' Referring to the poll tax and thel The "msmng manner in which it ha: been ad ‘dean '0 the 6mm o‘ Dr’

. -, miniotorod by the Government it ought perhaps to be noted that the Premier and Ccznntls-sloner Lea imade u lair show in the district we“; . _ which they represent. That district on pa’ be “kw l! may, 1920 to reduce the citizens‘ . 1 l. 1 - _ ‘m, guarantee “m! the Con’ l l h I t it: the l-‘oltairthi Dstlr céh o] Pit-lace‘ 1...... .. w " s" " t3.";:".'.:~....:z.:.;r..". ...::.".t:.:";:.--»»-iy u ~-w m Wm been implemented. The Patriot ex-

Fmll? I

n" Liberals, _ lplains that, a few days alter Mr.‘ I

, ' . _ . ii it ' - dlt bl to th m ab’ when" members, lndivldual- m“: assured ‘he indignant cm l-julethe Bedgqllise Ltllestrizlt elt mist. “m” men or at least averageizens that he had the governments

have been di-scrediiuble to thcm to “t, "d honour before they promise to reduce the tax, it was have “mm l“ charlolx,.lown_

THAT POLL TAX AGAIN l

The Patriot comes to the rescue o! Hr. Higgs whose promise iu

HAT GUARANTEE a primitive and pure version New Testament in pits and

do any better!

Dr. Walter S. Cook of ‘Prin

. . . d '._\1 _ Mir l'es in Mr. Lea’: department. i0 slower on false pretenceslno’ be ‘xemmed an r “d... in Charlottetown that the

iTax Act was enacted into law. -it

».‘, and there ‘S mcnnlrovemyble proof generously. ftr the sake o1’ the re.

hm“ they have Since framed fie} turned soldiers agreed to let his ‘Llgmuuy flimsy excuses mr meirlCltaiiottettnvn constituents pay 1t bNQQh of mm‘) so as to let the soldiers go irce.

lmthere any valid reason then loilice. it is the richest. tho most Why ‘We should expec: the Carmel-Jule "mall "ll M‘ “lggl ls "m qulllipopulous, aIu-u the best tax-paying vafive party‘ individually and cob c1112. We could uutlcrstaittl it as an o)!’ all the electoral districts iu the lectively. to retain their integrityfwl “l genmsily “m! even or ‘ilnolgglslgolllujtllrnlllf mica they have “tuned w oflicemfldllfilii, hud .\l1'. Iiiggs tborne this Over $23000 or mcomé tax Mona: ']l|-mk1y we “mg; ma; any asfbllldell llllllsell- lllll- lll-‘llher lhelu regard to all other taxes than ' _' wq-waice. “mien might be given m generosity nor the patriotism looksuhe poll tax it was by no means ‘m’! rupee‘ is subject m the objeolso conflpmuous when he explams neglected by .\lr. Lea. But Cliflp,

no trace of the obliterated

{tax tnoueya an; brought when thcy are collected. The city is, all around Mr. Lea when ho i-s in his

sun-h text. ampoi n t-meu t,

not only

Just bow this is to redouutl to mum's contentions but becaus indications that. Dr.‘ Bushanan ltoaxed himself to an lncredibi tcut before he hoaxed the publ

Blank ‘Page Photographed.

This was in connection wit

‘ewauve pa"), now seeking [he tax out of the 1659 citizens whozww muflemd w" “ma” more

mung” of the people The lead” Paid their ClYlC D011 illX and “Tfevlranchlas votes than Mr. Lee's elec-

lie ~ - -. ~ --t |'t't d~ t1 11 -.~- _ o‘ the puny’ M“: l D_ Stewart‘ Kflditherthore liable tor the provincial era dis rtc an yet 1P)’ =1 6

through lit. then compa

. - .. . _ numben", four times as many tarm- 'due primarily to his lntrioiaible res-fur‘ mg“ and ‘he Palm)‘ ad l

era In the Bedeque district as of poet for his word. In his public llro- unll- ll they wan! to be honest‘ ‘haLmItizens in Charlottetown paid poll

3851mm] and private me Ms wordlit would ibe very lIlllCll "w" m-llll? taxes last year! And this under‘ - ~ - ' h » .- ' l Bel d

_ h“ ever been Ms bond and n hasiand more fair to abolish the v-hotelgoemtzitgygizyli: (Jliellrcm gflrewl ‘ ' ' ll t , ‘ .\l . Stew rt is going to { - - ‘ . ever tbeen said of him that in l” m‘ ‘l’ ' l‘ Ought no, so to my we menu“

it here and now‘ in ortlerthai these " I lathe? client or memi ls h not raw pay ‘it and let the other 134.3 cquttllylltonorable gentlemen may have

= -. 1 timely notice to make the best de- onalble to expect that, with his Lame go Scot “eel

, , lfence or explanation they can be- rofessionai career still before hlm,l FEDERAL SYMPATHY “ope the glgghjon lakes plapg,

bowing tihe steps by which he has. i

identical. Aitcr this exposure

ed 011 other serious discrepansi lie said that, pttttin-g aside t quctstion 0i” invisible writing, Buchanan had committed

om m, deed m; has dhanwlnled do. than to have 314 of the.- -:itizens

Latin text, of the Vulgate. ,paring one passage of the transcribed by Dr. Buchanan wi

-thc text itself in the tnnnuscript

ltnthed to his present success. hel "id mil‘ .

ii- l '

We note that when our provin-I We have frfliiwiilly to raisolui; Liberals are "up liiluinst lt" alxhlarrlzg‘ m“? “:9 “hi”; lgllrftluchunah omitted whole words _ . _ . _ _ _ y 4_ so epopua one e ro-"_,_,___ , h ._ promises ior the sake 0t political they lllvilflflbl} PQCEHC at least the Vince and consequently pay "WWII ll-lnee ililil iiineflul 01 9P“ access? in his first pulblic specchcympathy 0t their friends at 0:-

‘flftho oi thepoli tax. But that docs theopening otf the present cam-‘tnwa. it will be remembered thntnot tell half the story. The four

3n he assured his hearers that on the eve 0t‘ the byeelectlons last Pllllcllléll‘ towns, Charlottetown, _ _ x t mSummersuie, Souris and Zlxensing- _woruitl not meet them tour year! Autumn, the Liberal candltn e -Lon Dam in a" on“, $1.725 m m], 99 l0 a-llllloglle tax last year out oi‘ a total 0f $26,- 775. That is less than one-fifteenth and Irilihklytforming him that the permanent 93"“ This ls “l” l“ which Messrs. Bell and Lea contend perfectly fair and ‘just, and must ibcrmalntalnetl and that they must it nuts no doubt valuable news be left to enforce it in the future he province and its ‘needs “mi for the Liberal candidate and he "e iliei’ “"9 l" ‘he im“ Th“ l“ [the tax w-hlch the Leader of the wit; no reason to doubt that ho made the most oi‘ it, but. the [JET- opposition gays ‘must he repeal“, s I ' ' a-ithfuiliy follow the patll lie mancnt work has not yet tbecn be-

‘ I \Vl1at' say the farmers vin Messrs. _ mwpsti out and that this P-"iili gun. The Patriot afterwards as- Bell and was district? reasonably sure of’

Bllccllsll-sured us that whenever Mr. Sin- oreover, he is surrounded by llielllclalr made an "absolute promise" snitch more than ordinary prom- h won“; be fu,|n11ed_

W ld scorn to descend

tires and rewriting occasional

l'0l' ibfilkeil Summerslde,’ received a telegram’ mics. He publicly illlllollllfiedjrom the Hon. John E. Sinclair in- I platform, openly ‘Tl-milled the 901W)’ he llllelliled lQI/work on Water Street was to begin ollow and his reasons for l-t. lie is at Onca

_‘ shrewd, keen business mart knows

manuscripts where the lerased his own work and rewro i." .

copying. was of the fourth, iiftlt or olxl

nnau. were certain that the vellum itse lid not go back to tho fourth. fit‘! or sixth centuries. but, was

according to .Dr. Lake. "l<‘ron1 th

The two‘ gentlemen we have named were equally responsible for Th!‘ ill-Willa the enactment of the Tax Act. Mr.

the grouping of

_ odor in mall)’ Yea-TB l" ellllel‘ PM‘ cnt contest. We observe that the they have been ma‘ friends’ or

1 kl t . ffid- “¢*‘r- v- v v vvrvv‘ m“ had 5,3 promising a foll0W- Hum qf $7 500 was iplnced in tltc on y ma m; a me ewe o r e“ have been shown lu single file be- ' ' ship? Would it be lsctter for the _ I i t‘ L m u Md D THE SHADOW g as the men who are nownsupwementary estlmmes for a farmer m M“! ‘he m“ m)‘ Com Lore)‘ t’: lllidlli f-trtsti,’ 211p r. i , . 1 . _"—‘ 11113-8 8.5 candidates riot‘ the wharf at Beach palm, hm] a gehxtinued. an Messrs. ‘Bell and Lea no 0 rpe mm“ l o ope l

lnservatlve IPBTIY- “t would have it, or that lt be rcpcttl-

L ctl as Mr. -.I. I). Stewart proposes? Gmrgemwn‘ The” “l course flmilThls is a matter for which in vlcw

011i)’ "BSllm-IIIQSY’ "Ebillllllelol the facts we have stated it fprgmlgeg" and may ‘veil he pldccdwould be well for the oicniors in m the same category as M‘. smuall the farming districts to tronsiti- Cl&il"8 pro-election promise albout or’ th'e Sutnmerside street. The ciec- Put it another way. la it deslr- m“ Wm do we" 1O see to u, from able to continue a tax which is so

_ obnoxious and unpopular that “°“' ll" Gleam“ day’ m“ a" “mm four-fifths oi those liable thereto ises by lllberals

everywhere "rein certain large districts oi the

erous amount for a wharf

the ilottrishcs autl other details show tho manuscript to be fourteenth century Spanish under titulian and French-Flemish iniittcnce, according to Dr. Cook.

Ifhero is therefore ever)’ realm" .. "qgpect that the coming 0095"‘: tive regime will in every Will’ o l the hope of its friends and be Y bloating to the province.

not

Think He Fooled Himself. The view is taken ny Dr. Lake that Dr. Buchanan had not engag- ed in- a conscious deception, but that he was a vlstlm of autosug-

“litter the experience of the D651 " Q1..." t: is extremely imnrdn . in“ ‘new shall the any zmore

m, many ygarg to come "absolute" whatever that may Province make default or refuse to llpllllml- Dr- I'll“ Plevlllllllll’ llail r " _ ‘l pay "7 This was the ca“ l“, suggested that Dr, Buchanan, the- political Dflflle! cllmbhlg n mean’ b year. list it fair or tit-com “ca” scholarly quality of whose early m. other way,» making prom- Preelection promises are n. 1mm" w mode who ‘my ‘o perm“ work is acknowledged generally,

which they do not intend to oolutely worthless as well as dis-

had worked himself into a chronic state 0f self-deception tin which his theories appeared ‘before ‘his eyes in the disguise of half-visible writ- lug. in a. dictated interview Dr. Lake said: “With regard to the question of underwriting, there are

others who are equally liable under Therein alwlys the safeguard appointing. Be sure you ask ferrite law not to pay? That is the

_ . .. n, _treatmcnt that the lBcll (‘over - "P917?" “we flecewed. The m it“ ‘absolute and m“ no 0 er ment has given them. Thelbublllc . - omttlfid: l-llllmghlml" the a.‘ lent don‘ vole for my on!“ M accounts of the Province prove Illllfl the Liberals Blww- even the ‘Patriot 86ml" llley are this to be the case. The Govern- hmd ‘nu-h; their first BH- nott to ‘be relied on. tment candidates who are commit» t -. - j ___ . g“ a“ “holy to be forgotten. (1%

stand up for the tax. Messrs. Duffy

" wu eusnnmu**l M '4'

0i New Testament

stroke has been

Buchanan that he ‘has discovered

on the margins and between the lines of a Spanish manuscript own- ed by Archer M. Huntington and now in the Museum of the Hispanic

five-t, and here the collection 01.5"“)! was studied ‘by Dr‘ Klrsollp p0" taxes was a remrkame [flip-Lake of Harvard, who was named by Dr. iBuchanan as the moet com- petent scholar in this fleld in Am- erica. Dr. Lake brought with him a

tht- work. The two scholars found

is to Charlottetown that all thellexl reported by Dr’ Buchanulhulld ' mut-b evidence that there was no Dr. Lake expressed dis-l because "Kalli

the text oi‘ page 314 showed clearly

Dr. lBuchnntttfs best evidence t-he-wlllllll llllll he?" “Tl-Slim! Dill.’ Harvard professor went on m stud). souid not rcad any of this. but the page after page and he soon light» lmllresslllll o" "l-V liliilil “'86 illfli

Dr‘ ‘tipnc-r writing. gl-eaq-tltc mistaken use of e page in the fattits in transcribing the visible-‘lclllllolllllll which

[pointed out instances where Dnlllllmlll llllll lllill Oil 80MB

Belongs to Fourteenth Century. ‘lmlal l" hlll-flfmllllelll- Changes ‘ll. Dr. iLake found instances of eras-fills lllllll “TF0 "W19 b)’ sorllles to

throttghout the manuscript, buthelswllll“ ‘"6 “llllloiil i .

said these are to be found in aiiflllfi kllld~

scribe-ally

ii. after he had made a mistake in The alleged early tc-xt

centuries, according to Dr. Buch- iBoth scholars yesterday

of about tho fourteenth ccniu-rytype,

costumes, the school 0i painting, the figured and other details of iconography from

_ _ the miniature‘ paintings, Dr. Cook l men of ‘known and recoglliled with this promise was that it was Lea lo specially rwliwllilllle l°" "8 fixed me (late u! we numuscrlp, "*“*¢ v‘ 44000000004 lity in their own ceilings, farm- not-uwbsolutein n was plum pre_ rnforcemgnt. They! thiier at the fourteenth cenmry. In an D _ S . lawyers, doctors, merchants,elecnm_ Gun” a e p Se ‘ illumination of the Adoration of ' t posing as the pilfllcllllll‘ “lends of [he Wiagl one of the wise men FOR . .9" °l Blallllml l“ mall‘ leilwchv“ Such pro-election promises ma)’ the farmers. Does their admdnis- k1 ‘d m , ‘ ' uh . mmunitles. in fact no political be expected on the eve 0f the 1ires- tratiou oi‘ the -poll tax show that w‘ h a" imo er pm!‘ l‘ o“ e , l star of the hast io a. tiurti. At an

earlier dale the wise men would

in another picture, tile tlgltt-iittlng stocking-s in another, tho trolors, innumerable

The Public Forum

This column is open for the discussion‘ by vorrolpoitdonto oi questions of interest. The totown Guardian does not Mount-ll, endorse the

E. S.

t. . "u:

OHM Opinion, expressed by ite cor- ,- , f‘. U" C" din“ p m;*m*m on sale 700 yards of natural shade

An Election Opinion

Sir,—l see that

manu- 9c

to our taxes. tBut, They fooled us before. fool us again.

The -Patriot says the report that higher rate 0t‘ taxation will be hem" imposed is "a ntcati, false and

I _ : _, ____ I i lmueiess Insiuuatlon." Yet, as we H ,_ ‘banded wgemer a I discovered that .1 this FEJULLIOII! — "l" lllrvllfll» will) Examined "lea" know‘ me 1am“), was. before - “j d‘ ,1 b.5011," r5 1‘ m; Quult] - h . [Orly Small plmnlug“ l“ ‘gold and the la-st general election equally . '17- .7916)’ admit that they at-lmls ma at L e p0“ Th‘ °°"°°l"°" °l a" l e ‘axe’ brilliant colors which illuminate ' _‘ . ‘NIH!

emphatic against tint-reused taxa- tiom-declaring it to be then too high. Now, after the taxes have been applied to (almost) everything tangible and intangible, it declar- es, ltt effect, that “everything is lovely,"~—bt1t the taxes won't increased.

early

e of had taxes will not again be incrensetl, Be» the Patriot quotes a tspeech of the ._ Leader of the Government, in ll" which it is slated that "this Gov- ernment docs not intend to impose additional taxation." iBut. as we all know. the Leader of the Gov- ernment is just as deep in the

h a

I am, Sir, etc, i d AN INTERESTED ELECTOR. l‘? -——-_-__-_____._

l reaped ‘having no“ mx hm 376‘ page Ill-l, as tsecu throttglt page M fir‘ "H t I “ ' ‘I l Thus "- you are going m‘ gob-ill V’ Parties having goods arrive in this Province from ii a lawyer who. although cvm- m‘? Wvhite over a thousand neighbors. ‘m’ “uh u‘? photograph he"; 0m wrltinsg snail illlzxlfgffizinllfyllllsliléljllt good me in twill‘ lhgtlltseyrtllllllrtlllll] t‘ ' abr°all l" damag“ °°"dl“°" ‘l‘°“'d "wry ‘h’ “d” putatively young. has worked his ‘v35 the“? a fingering susplhcionjfarmers and constituents tin lied Zizizlélctgllllfhlnz: mlggfiiegf ielrle of these resolved hthgmszlvesninrig illegal: larlli cl lltlyOtldllfllllLLilllwly signed immediately and have the necessai’)! survey and ' 17w’), m,“ very high place in msdn .\ir. Higgs’ mind that none Ofieque district felt obliged to liil)’ The [gxt of me photograph and the. offsets front the opposite paged)"; Similarly with Viltc Vhca-titiig ‘of if M-appraisemcnt before packages are broken or distributed. ‘ {profession “is success m“ been them should pay it? Will not bothit. That is. l11 proportion to their ha" ob§¢uretl tcXt 0i’ Page llllweredn some use“ ll your lbody, you “ant good tic. .

tippearcd that genuine underwriting, I

of there was

this underwriting was not early, .bttt probably of the some datc as the lit tmay be due t0

cs.’ he i

di

the Patriot outs the idea trhat the present Government, if re-elected, will add whtxknows?

They may

he coal-ashes-ls then

“rho-s m w“ irout the furnace.

, _ , _ , whether the Patriot anti its party

““~",‘""" not me hugmest "me are not equally insincere, equally Hill ilikv T0011

cl Mldmme l“ ‘Mo’ of DR Buch‘ false to their tireseut. declaration? W In support of its contention that by the lungs, and the hea

blood or heating fluid along is nolt as strong as it ntlght be. pump is your heart.

iootk-and a. good draught—thai l good air into the lungs.

even 1r he does little work. sets - is food well burned tlili b)’ llle Kllllll supply oi‘ all‘.

tivaste matter in the body llllll H] forego saying

have a heating system uncqxtttlltni _'l'0l‘ efficiency in that thody of .\'<illl'n'-

,1

JULY 1o, i923.

<—\~»-__

__'_Silk 98c yd____

This morning at 9 o’cl0ck we place

pongee silk at

98c

._.______ ________.____

Like A HOUSE-YOUR HEATING! PLANT i

l g plant ‘.

Ever)’ house ‘has’ a heatin

ois kitLtlt 1b -' _;- , , , 1.0.03? mint-e.“laiulteiuilzvitd, ThlS 1s a remarkable value, 36 m. “(ICE 0i‘ evtlll

5163i".

lioctns in the case 0t‘ hot air, or by;

You know 1...». u... heating isl wide. Telephone orders will be ac- done. The flre is built, air is alio\v-'

ed to get to it, and it ‘burns ztwttyql

the heat going direvt-(Lv to tltul cepted,

lmcnns of l10i. watt-r cdrrivtl to ilwt ~asbcs~is then taken away from.’ radiators. The waste or lburflet] out] taken away;

Similarly ltt that ibody of yours. into your lilch burns in the air brcathctl ini t is lltttsf created l'or the needs of the sys-

S. A. McDonald

Queen Street

tcm. i

Now what type of heating is your] body system? You can gticss all right because you know it is the hot liquid blood coursing through your blood vessels that carries

.___- c_m __. ____._.__. ‘uiittg to catch successivo 1111p. chaser a single rose. M. Founcs, or IParis, paid 2241 guinteas for thc lirsl

LDNDON, July 9—-At Christie's

. _ _ lzeat t0 every Dart of the body. on Wt-tlut-stiuy. Mr. W. ll. Autlc-r-.rost- from thc litlllillllll- Th" lilll" _ mm he placed the bumm on thetlottetown anti tho ‘Royalty for photograph of page 316 in the mud as the Patriot is 1n the mire. You See every b" of tissue right sou put up for auction a boutmh; 01mm, M u". p.51 mu- was .\i1-_ tion that other good men have fal- _ some reason or other. paid only tnauuut-ript which Dr, iBug-Imnu“ iiiu present intention nowuntu" or down m your “m, .1,“ u, M, nought" rust-s, gzttht-rt-il i11 tlw unrtit-uslvltilip ltillivllllllbll. or l'l1iittt1.-1p1|i,., 1gp from grace ehhm- through yheh-‘shoulders “l l“! °°llslll“‘“m"l' ‘md]$1,l2i§ in polltnxcs. And that was has circulated far anti witlc among 3:?’ illglnltlekilltfaled hlgfveileoii; iquq] and-warmed‘ and 1L mm Unlylttt Slllllliiilllllllillill ttutll rirustf-fttoii byltlrtlttl lliir; il-tisi- ("lii/Hllllilllgl ‘lloo aeulilut-uv, .. , ,,' , , ,- , , - . - , _ _ . ' ' ,.. ,. ,. -~ u‘: ‘a. A: .i'. lt- ii ll Kt" ' ll‘ m tut-t mhereme to party or the" love 0f more especially ditet he had [lTDllPlpJld by only .316 p? w-JDS, while in scholars as his foremost proof oi good mason m ma“, m] confluence be done by lite blood. ‘it rtdthts t» zsilllzidll“; ‘flrollllalll Urlllyw “m; £11m‘ as‘ . 1 ‘the sweets and we emolumpntfi mficed to roman. h, ithc Betledtio t lstrict. for irhlvlt Mr. an early obliterated writing. Paige l1t atty dcr-ittraiiolt of either the “liiqéfirills-l-milflllfga “l: swig-m Viv“ r-——-—»--—=___.. me f . Now ma, ‘n- II1(yg‘r h.“ exp-am‘ Lea holds a seat in the Legfttlnturc, 316 is blank and Dr, Jltlsliantmq; Zllitvriigt ‘of tiltgollettiitlix" Tlllfig m? the hctaigfor 31:‘; flmyzmm. ottnnl.‘ ‘ . V, . , , , , . o t _ ' ' '~‘ " ‘ I _ , , .1 -~ . . . : . . if‘ m. 1a we 1 ' " l, _ eor 0 m ronagc m] n or m‘) patriot for mm Wm hpmon, than’ 1.000 1n<n ildlil $71,081 1n photographs purported to show .1 know i“ we)‘ may (ipvpwp m “Sm ‘hm yo“ got from your mwL ma ¢)LDEST INSURANCE Aaalqcy [I Yet there are many reasons why i _ l‘! V} i" 3H _.U no“ HMS‘ w“ lfhm‘ h“ been llllflsllll‘ The Zlgillli. So we had better tnukti n Ntrw il‘ some put-ts oi‘ your tbod)’. IN ED%A / ye should ‘pin our ram‘ Wm] “m”: 0r i Hit-i ii ii l)’ Oil .1 ‘ (-1 ‘k ————— illilie l-i 0f iililliJ-“ll lPilll-‘lDflTiilli-Wlel- chétrvttgc. f I d l l Your feel |t)or IuIstznIuie-bttret1110f ‘as _- Kw-‘“',.. _—":_j t“, “Hum, .._. A’. . ‘ ‘gong of (jhgplqneiuwn {mid their‘ _ luhl. Dr. Lake pressed ‘page 316 ours or ttc goo o tie coun- warm as ttey s1ou.t e 1 s =10» , than ordinary assurance to the Con-I | Charlottetown at the election of down hard and pointed out ma, try,