-, h»..- w-w-r ADJ. .1

n~iti1#'

THE CHARLOTTETOWN GUARDIAN

i. "'3

’ D

"i?"

MRS‘. Li)!

stern .. Bill. .\.\'l) ‘\l~!1l \ - -

I:

F171}?

Flu-m idrmxislil

11111! 1:11:11!

\.\'(I

lion-Audit‘: ‘

Perso

l.'11-_.,1-

\-1. l. \ ill h1- solil in two’

mils

11110-1 :1.o11 .11 110:“ pliysu-nl dir-

1 c. 1, lllhli- v.' rel-cs.

P1.

YJ.111':1.11:

‘l5 WRIGHT

Guardian

111-‘ runny 1). f

'1>:..'¢ 1h ls-Gfllfl-Sl-fl-ll.‘

SLiiLE

1g of onu liundrcd '1 re‘ - sitnlltt-ti in »-_ 1.11 1111- 1112,11-

“usgh state of 1-ul- i 11111i1-r hard and new du-r-Iling outbuildings. ’f'l1roe - An idr-al

in bimk. i 1'5 ,\I.‘1'fflE§O.\'. ! i

1.5‘ I

0111- 111‘ 1111 Hill“)! built din-lungs,‘ l1.:.1u.1.1~ll_\ ‘ [ppm- i 1'l1l1't‘ t , - llurti- . vocli 1..11.,\ 1 111111 :in1! fin- i ‘1- 1 1n llun - >1-\-|-|1 rooms‘- :1='-1l 11.1111. l ‘. ~.\.1--.1- lie-ailing, 111-1111- ' 1.111! sun 1111111, 1111-1-1- 1111 11ml gur-

1140. I 111i! sell v

-1- in l"1'l!1'1il!

p111». my I11'.'.,l1lu11

r-ry imisonablg- 11nd ,

mgr for 51.111111 111' tho purr-linsc

11x :1 rlfkl mort-

l 1111.11 olfvr :11 11 \1-r_\ r<-.1.-111\.1hl1:‘

r coltugl- at (‘i111 rioitctlnvll,

fUllalUflltf o1‘ four licdrooms, large

li-riiil; r-mxn v. and 1111-1 '1' .-‘

, 1

.1 '1 t! -l 1'11! lu- r111; _ 1.~1-r l1 _\-1 (\\1'1l:\' to 111-111 :1 suinmvr 111111 11111111111 r1111 ii‘ prin-atcly- 111111111

fPn-ti for n31- ni nut-lion by J.

3241-01111. 4!. our 1111-111 in 11 )1.

L-IiT-‘l ll-fl-‘i;

T00 1.4110

v . I,U-1'i‘—~' b.

‘ \('('('..‘l."1()l)-\'I‘|-I

'ANTI-'.f7—.-\T

Gunr-ll-iii . -, c: 1 , 1 f’, WANTFH—YUIY

w

duh firm-my '

1-1~:111*111 o, i111-

rrr-pi riirs 1

(IYY ., l,

r"f"il‘lllt"fi maid. Apply “M". 0.0.

1 fzri- piflff‘. lint

-_ b.1511 “i111 shou-rr. :1 ~'.-|1':

-- l1.

. purl-h. Thu ]ll‘l>]l('li_‘y' is 11s .111 inve-tmt-ni 4~1l,1-r-.‘11r|1i111,; the 1!)- filYifiPflfi from "—|l\l' 111-1-1-1-111. As sllunlinn m)‘. hr» licziteil.

111- 111.1 both sold 11 “wk uill b1- oi‘- .~\. iioiu- ,\1l\-1-rt1sc- . 1.111113 Apply to ‘

ht. Phone 212. ‘ Rcsldr-ncr phnno 107G.

1 , .. -._.... . -1 '10 (liusify 5 PATH HF RI\Y_

- .-.»1..-, l“ 11-1 .1 1

1 .111" '.’1._’1

\11.->1:.\:111>\'1"1:r1 ‘

Two,‘ I01

p.

. \Vri‘o 1 ll*'if{:,fi* '

.'1-"|-3! 1

1

0x411, AN EX-

T1-6f132

TO “TPRK 1\T

groovy storr. Apply Dcvcrcauxs

11-6330

111,; y-dlyvauf 111e-

PEKOE TEA

I i i 1 i 1 i

4

'. riazo of Mr.

u-rronftffis of tho home.

limmodintcl}; ‘ '.'11l.1ll1.111c , "'11! t111-11ty- ’

. m-vil

1 . The B-antral Guardian \__ thin column In icu-ru-o for 111 lmnl intern-It bu! aural-lining

1 u unuy nulure lnuy be Inn-rim] 4 c0111: u won! ntrlclly playable

nun ul u! In

lt-

(‘UNFEDEIL-‘ATIUN LIFE I. .-\I\'(‘E.

(‘ALLBELIVS August 9th. L-6337

MISS HELEN plllflO elltss reopens Lesson 50 cents.

111v t-n-cuiztg. CM 13A. llnll, Vcrnon L-6338-9-9-21

OPEIV-The enrol!-

1\.1- as foliows; Pflllfjg S11 ‘"‘ : Qu-rcn orhfortl Square.

ENGAGEMENT ANNOUNCED- Mr. and Mrs. John B. Andrew an- nounce 1l-.-.- cngiigi-iiieiii of thvir dsughter, l bell Georgina. lo Mr.

Mrs". Waltz-1- G. Patton of Am- lu-rs-l. Nova Scolln. The mar- finer‘ will 111140 place m1 SIlZtllTilLY. 51lll"l!ll)(‘l' 1hr- nincteenth. 11-6328

FIT!’ SCHOOLS OPEN-Tint!‘ v»- ovrr, more thanglflfifl

u-zdlv starting a new term. The <-;i1‘1‘l"l-f: (lr1_v's vnrollmcnt \\'.'1> rot:- . "1-1-1 1i to be just slightly abovo rnue. Prince Strcer. School's ms $1111; Que-Tn Square, 611i; Rochford Square. 540; and West Kent, 11n- available.

D E C O R 1\ T E l’) GR.-\\'ES—O11 Sunday morning the Sons of En;- lillld deoorzitcd ihc grave-s of 1h": dot-cased brethzvn, The mombci- motored. in a bod)‘. to 1111- People's Ccmetcrv

Roads. Sherwood Cemeteries. Scrvice at the Peo- ple's Ccmclcry- ivns coudilclcd by Mr. H. H. King. President. nsr-ist- ed by .\fr. H. Pcatvyour, Chaplain

and St. Pol-Prs

11v’ Councillor Lapthornc, Secre- tnrv. WEDDING JHZLLS-Jfhe mar-

Frederick Cordwclf, DOlFPilVP Corporal of the R. C. M. P., Clmrlottclovrn, to Olga E1111- lond. daurzhtcr of Mr. and Mrs. Robs-rt Eric-land. Spring-field West, P. E. I.. took pIIICO at the home of tho bride on Wednesday last. The 11-1-1111111: sorvico was read by Rcv. Mr. Phillips. and the wedding took the form of a lawn wedding on the Follow-lug a ,hricf irccptlon at the bride's homo offer the cr-rcmonv. 1h‘- nr-irtv-urds loft for Bots-on on :1 honeymoon trip. '

Personals

Mrs. Frank Riqqs left y-tstcrday 111111111111; for Saint John. N. B.. win-re she v.11! attend the Exhibi- lion.

Mrs. G. E. Full returned yesterday mining to Brookllne, Mass, ac- ccnipuiiietl by her son, Licut. Col. (i. Elliot Full.

Mr. Lemuel Prowsc roturncd Monday evening f1-om the Military

- Collcac‘ at st. John's. Qucbrc. whore

11c has boon attcndlnz a class for

‘ cav-ifrv officers.

.\!;1.~11~r Nfvron Ling o1’ Nciv Wilt-- shire is. visiting his grandparents, Mr. r1111] Airs. T. D. Ling, Char- lottctottnn.

"s Calder, Sh, ls visitinf.’ 111s. Mrs. C. B. Mcftrie W. l»! Melisa. New Gins- S. S111- is accompanied by htor, Mrs. Joan Richards.

Airs, W. l-l. McR-ie and son. Har- vcv 3111-» rr-furnorl 1'1 Now Glasgow,

N. S. having spent the summrr 11111114; hcr mother, Mrs. James Calder, Sr.

Miss Mound C. R1101‘ of Ottawa :1r1-1-.--d in tho Ciiv Srfurdzty even- ing to s-ionrl hr-r v ailon.

1 Black *9 John.

lr-ft on N, B. to

.\'l1.-.. Afar-gait" Monday Lol- S1 cuter '11!- Genera‘.

tcohnit-inn.

111111 l\Ir:; Robert Balboock and lltilc drnizhtrr Harriet Ann lmvl- rr-turncrl to their home in All-don, .\lns=., after sponding ih-ur ' notion 111th Mrs. Balxvockls r, Mrs, John A Nicholson of Wood l.‘~'.illlt’i.'-‘.

Hr.

Air Alhr-ri Kin: of Roxburv, -tv11.— has :1 7d in tho city on ,=1 . t. t1 111.. moth-Pr, Mrs. Mary

. '17 lli-rhlniiri Avc. Mr. Kim? ~11! will} Ills Worship

- --r 111 111'- shor- huslnrss “~- l.~1\=-:~ h-‘fr- thirtcon wars

Mr. and Mrs. I-"rnnk lfornn, RffiilTWIi. N. B, motorcd to the cit-v to sncntl thr- “vok-cnd with thr- lattci-‘s moth-or. Mrs. Regina. Atkm . (‘m rrturn they will be ac-

Mirrcs Baden and Rita Champion o1‘ R-dhoad, N. B.

1

mm- wnumn rum m ,

L~6798-7-!2-312. ENTl-IIKTAINAIE?!‘ by Dramatic,

' ‘ Club of lloly llcdvruu-r Parish Fr:-

uxous schools ycs r- '

John R. P111011, son of lvlr. and’,

iiictoivn children yrcnt back- inus schools in the ci1_v yes-

whilc individual mPm-- bers motored to Mnrshfield. Cross.

Hospital there, for furthcr tfninillg as laboratory"

rowipnnlod from Kenslngton by‘ 1

i Thursday at 2 o'clock. I . ;WRfGH'f‘—At Montague Hospital.

Coroners Jury Hears‘ Evidence In Horgan Case

Investigation Tip-ens Before Cor- oner Dr. I. J. Yeo Into Circum- stances Of Recent Highway

Fatality At ‘Covehead.

; An inquiry into the circumstan- res of the death of Michael Hor- gnn, 23, ofiStanliopc. l-ullcd in a highivziy accident on the night. of S2111. 1, opened _vc.-;1c1'fl-_\' aflfrnwfl in the City Polio-r- Court rOOm bf.’- forc Coroner Dr. I. J. Yco and the following jurors: F. P. Bell (fore- nmm, Jns. M. HFllllPixfifiy, Arthur King. Bruce Wonllltcolt, Carl Kelly, James D. Campbrll. James Fuller- ton. Mr. D. Ediir Shaw appeared as Crown prosecutor. Aftcrsittlng yesterday nftcrnoon and evening, 1 and hsaring some twenty witnesses. 'thc inquiry tvas adjourned until 3 low-lock 111.; afternoon.

Summary 0f Evldcucc

Dr, R. J. Ledwell, Charlottetown. tho first witness, testified to having sf-L-ll ihr- deceased in the Charlotte- lou-n Hospital shortly after he died 0.1 the evening of Sept. 1. Immedi- 1111- cause of death was cerebral ilf‘lll0l‘l'llilllf‘. Injuries were 11 frac- ture of tho log, cxtcnsive laceration i-xtriidiiig from part of the leg 10 iv-zu- tlic hip, and a depressed frac- .

tll"f‘ of the 11211-101211, and temporal‘ 1111110.: of the head. The victim had, boon 1-011sci011s, but not for a long 111-11011. lle had spoken to his? clr-ruymnn. Witness knew nothing,‘ of l1ow 1111* injuries were received. l

Dr. G. L. Smith, Charlottetown,- trsnfied to seeing deceased 011 11101 night 0f the accident, first in the 111k scat of Dr. Blanchardls car outside witness’ door. He later ex- amined the. victim at the Charlotte- town Hospital. Hemorrhage, shock and loss of blood were the causes of death. There was a. fractured leg , 11nd a fracture of the skull at the 1 base of the scalp wound. He was » in grout agony when brought to the I hospital and ivas immediately given I

a hypodermic of morphine. I-Ie was also given intravenous transfusion of 51111111: and :1 general anaesthetic.

A Juror: "Did he talk to you?"

Witness: "No, he was in such n. condition that I didn't ask him any- thing. His family were 13-1111 him, his father and two or thrcc of his brothers."

Deceased hud been admitted to hospital at 10 o'clock on the evening of the accident. _

1 Thomas Horgan, Junior, 204 Cum- ,» herlnnd St, Charlottetown, a. broth- 1 or o! lhc deceased, testified that he 1 u-nrked “"1111 L. M. Poole and Com- p: y. He W115 at his brother's bed- sizlc 11-11011 he died in the ward of the City Hospital about 3:30 a. m. Sop? 2. They had left the scene of the accident about 25 to 10 the previous rvening. Witness drove 111th his brother to hospital accom- ipmzied by his fother, his brother Jul-k, and Dr. Blanchard. Mr. Shaw: "Will you tell us what . you know about the accident?" Witness: "I 11-115 driving with my family from S1. Eugenes Church, Cove-head, that cvcnuig, Sept. 1. We loft the church about 9:15 or 9:10. We turned at Marshall's Mill and drove on about twenty-five yards when I noticed lights coming over s1 slight incline ahead. I just pro- ceeded on very slow about twenty- five y-zu-(ls and pulled over very close to the ditch. I noticed thc car coming over the top of the hill. He nuidc u turn on the top 0f the hill. He came straight down towards us. l-fo didn't, in my Pstlmatlon-and I

POLICE COURT~At thc police Court ycstcrday- morning two drunk and lncapablcs cach had their $5 bml cstrcatecl. A drunk and dis- ordcrly had his $20 bail ostreaicd. A vagrant was given 3O days. while a man charged with operating a motor vehicle under the influence of liquor was remanded.

rxmrns

ilnvc-.Yl1iifc'ifi{e<i17fvl=.i(v. sl-Bfaf-iof}

to M1- 11nd Mrs Fxirlc Ling, a son.

1 WOOIL-At the Prince Edward 15-‘ inllfi Hospital cm Scpt. 8. 1936. to Mr. and Mrs. Wendel Wood, Cen- tral Royalfy, a daughter.

SHERRY-In tho Prince County Hoopltnl, Septomber 5. I936, to Mr. and Mrs. Ray Sherry of Borden, a daughter.

GALIPITMAL Summerstdo. Auc- - 11:11. 30. i936. to Mr. and Mrs. Hor- bic Gnllnnt, 11 son, 9 1-2 pounds.

1 ivmour-At 11101111111111 1111-1111111, 1 Septcmbcr 7. i936, to Mr. and Mrs. fllmuis Wright, twins, a. son and ‘ miter.

Dl-IATIIS

WRfGfIT~At Montague Hospital, September V, 1936. infant son of Mr. and Mrs. Louis Wright.

OMAHA-At. AibPfillfl, Sept. 8. 1036. Mrs. John O'Mara, aged 85" years.

DICKIESON -- At ‘New Glasgow. Tuesdl-iy, Bcpwmbwr 8, 1936, Arthur B. Dickicson. age-d 86 years. F11-

‘nc-ral from his late rcsidcnc’!

Septcmber, '1. 1936, Mrs. 1101.115, , Wrinht, aged x1 years. y MONAGIIAN - At Kelly's Cross

Sunday, Sept. B, 1936, James R. Monaghan, aged 72 years. Funeral took place from his home Tues- dny, Sept. l, m Kelly's Cross church.

was watching him all the way from the top of the hill-change his car at‘. all. He came directly straight for me." r '

"Where was your car?’-

"My car was right a1. the shoulder of the road, on my right side.

“Which direction would that be?"

"I would say I would be going about northeast.

"You were on what side 0f the road?

"On the right hand aide. It wu only an interval of seconds from the time he came over the hill until he ran into us. I immediately jumped om. of the car whenever I got my bearings, and looked around and saw my brother lying on the road.

"Had your brother been right on the car with you?"

"Ycs."

.'Whcre was he?"

"standing on the running board on my side-the left-hand side of the cnr." -

“Who else was in the car?"

“My father was 1n the front with me. My mother and my two sisters

1 Helena 11nd Mary and brother Pat-

rick 11-011; in the back seat. My brother John was on the right-band runuiiig board. I went right back on the road 1o my brother Michael.

, When I found out he was breath-

1111: I jumped up and looked 1n Judge Duffy's car door, recognized 115111 and asked him what he was trying to do. He never answ-ered mc in any shape or form. Just then Dr. Blanchard drove up and came to'mc and told me to take off my shirt. All that time Judge Duffy was sitting in his car. I took off my coat and vest and tie and threw them on Judge Duffy's engine hood. My brother was lying just opposite his motor. Ho still sat. 1n the car, He didn't appear to know what he was dOlng or realize ft. I tied up my brother's head with the assist- ancc of Dr. Blanchard. I never looked back, I was disgusted with the condition he was in. We got my brother over to Dr. Blanchard?! car and left for Charlottcwwn. I 511W Mr. James Gesner. He. was at the back of Judge Duffy's car with his hand on the back tire. He was still there tho last time I saw him.

"Had you any conversation with Mr. Gesner?"

“He said when I got out ‘You had om.- llght.’ I answered him and said I had two. That is all the con. versatlon we had.

"Then you lcft the scene of the accident?"

“YES. as quickly as possible."

“Regarding your lights, what do you say about them?

"When I left the church I had two lights. I noticed n0 change all the way down the road. I would almost surely have noticed f! one had gone out."

"CM You tell us about the 1m- pact?"

“from my left front wheel I would say he was coming right for the bearing at my left hand side of the windshield. That is where hg 5p. neared to be steering for. I was moving probably eight miles an hour.

"when You say ‘about’ that is not very definite."

"I v-vuld say eight miles 1111 1111111.

"Would you any you wcru going any faster than eight miles an hour?"

"No sir. no faster."

A Juror, "What would you say of the other car's time?

"Witness: "It ls a. very hard thing to say, because his lights were glar- lnr: in my face. But I would judge not lcss than thirty-five.

M1-. Shaw: "Did he dim his lights?" Witness: "No sir, not to my know-

ledge."

“Can you tell us about any injury done to your car?

"Both mudguards and rimnlng board were badly damaged. The front axle was bent in two places. my lights bent back and dlnted. my bllmlber all bent, my front Wheels and tires are both useless, door glass broken 11nd the handle off tho door on the left hand side."

"Which side is the bumper on?"

"On the right-hand side, on the back "

"Where did your car go after the accident?"

"RiBht into the ditch."

"were there any other; injured besides your brother Michael?"

"No. he was the only one."

"How was your car running?"

"Running good."

"was there any defect that you know of?"

"None whatever."

"How were you, yourself?"

“I was in perfect condition, I would say."

"were you sober?"

"Yea sir."

"You mentioned yourself and fath- er in the front out, your mother and two sisters and Patrick in the back. and your brother John on the right hand running board."

"And Michael on the left."

"Howwere they holding on?"

“I don't know how Jack wu hold lng on. Michael had his bond in my window behind my hem. My

window was down about six inches.

"Where were you 301118 at u"? tlma?"

"To our home at Covet-lead."

“Is there anything further that you feel like stating?"

"Not that I know of."

A Juror: "Was there onymdy else 1n the car besides Mr. 0881181‘ and Judge Duffy?"

Witness: "Not that I noticed.”

"Was your brother mchael knock- ed ofl’, or did he fall off?"-

"I would say he was wiped off."

Mr. Shaw: "Anyflllw 551d by anyone in your car?"

Witness: "My sister in the "back said ‘Jesus, Mary 811d J°59Phr We are going to be killed!" My father said, ‘Look out, we are B01118 t0 b9

hit.’ Michael shouted ‘look "out. look out!’ That is the last words he sold.

“How was Judge Duffy's car w; w the centre of the road?"

young mB-n 114118 "Y! m.‘ x- frumodlltely ‘wooed my w"- "if" new continued. "1 I"? m" “d 1111mm um. tho boy was surround- ed by hi; funily. I examined him on the roadway, found that the M! leg was brolncn about the knee, and the head 1111a 1 11m min wwnd- I inmiedlately tied up the held ll well as I could with what I had; had the man placed in my 6B1‘; ,.X06GOd9d to the hospital. On the way I picked up Dr. smith. Then I think one of the boys, or the father, phoned for Dr. Ledwell, who arrived shortly after. Prom there tbs boy was taken to the ward and examined. ,Then to the operating room where the two doctors worked on him. assisted by myself. I left the hospital about 12:30.

m». Show: "What was his condi- tion at that time?"

Witness: "Very bod. In fact his condition was bad from the start. The boy had loot an mw-ful lot of

"1 mind gay his car was, if any- thing, over on my side of the mad!

when I got out. But I didn't take; particular stock at that moment be- - cause I was interested in my bmih- ,- er more than Judge Duffy and his - car. Whether those cars were mov- ed after I left or not, I don't lmow. The standing of those cars on the road afterwards may 110$ be "Id are likely not the same as they were when the accident occurred.

"You don't know what hllYPflWd after that?"

“N03.

"What position were they !n?"

"Judge Duffy's car was over to my side. His motor was atlll run- ning when I got out. Mine stalled on the impact.

A Juror: "Was Judge Duffy’! M!‘ heading directly on the road or on an angle?"

Witness: “After the accident 11¢ was facing down the road."

Mr. Show: “You say your brother was lying opposite Judge Duffy's motor. Which way was he 1311118?"

Witness: "With his head towards my car, slightly bent in the bod)’-

"Where did your car land in the ditch as a result of the other car?"

“I would say about fifteen feet up the wad.

A Juror: "You seem to think those cars were moved. Can you substantiate that?"

Witness: "Well, I have been told that the motor was started after we left the scene." ‘

Mr. Shaw: "I think you had bet- ter not tell us what you have been told."

The Coroner: "Your car when it was struck was on the shoulder of the road pointing north or north- east? '

Witness: "Yes."

"How close was Judge Duffy's ca: to you when you got out of your car?"

"Between ten and fifteen feet."

"How do you account for it being that far away?"

"Well, I would judge lt that dis- tance."

“That is, it was separated from you, out towards the centre 0f the road, by ten feet?"

"No, down the road."

"Charlottetown way, or the other way?"

“Charlottetown way."

"In other words, do you think that Judge Duffy's car had carried

on for ten feet or so?"

"Yes sir."

“How far removed from the side of your car would that be?"

"Probably five feet."

A Juror: "How fnr did your ca: proceed after it was struck?"

Witness: “It didn't seem to pm- occd any distance. It just seemed to slam right into the gutter."

"f-Iow far did the other car pro- coed?"

“As I said, ten or fifteen feet down the road, towards Charlotte- town."

Mr. Shaw: "You say your brother was lying near Judge Duffy's car. How do you account for that?"

Witness: "Well, that is pretty hard to account for. He might have brcn driven there by the blow. He might have been carried so far on Judge Duffy's car."

A shoe was produced which wit- neus identified as one of his dcceu- ed brother's. Michael had only one shoe on after the accident.

Asked by a juror if he knew how many feet a car would travel in a second at the rate of thirty-fly: miles an hour, witness replied that he had not figured it out.

Juror: "If he struck you about your front wheel going thirty-five miles an hour. what do you suppose would happen?"

Witness: "Wcll. just what did happen; we would be slammed into tho gutter.

Juror: "I am afraid you would have been overturned."

The Coroner: “we w!!! not have 11o discuss what might or might not have happened. If you have any

questions to ask. just ask‘ them in the regular way.”

Mr. Blmw: “When you stated the distance between your car and Judge Duffy's car, what did you mean. Do you mean the distance measured across the road or up Ind down the road?"

Witness: "Up and down."

“Or do you mean both together?"

“No sir, I mean five feet across the mad and ten or fifteen feet up and down the road.

“You spoke of Judge Duffy's on- glno being running."

"Yes, when I got out of my car. Ha seemed to have a job to stop it. The engine was going at quite a rate of speed.

"What do you mean by that?"

"Well, it: is just the tenn you use when an engine is going fut."

"It stopped before you left?"

"Yes sir."

Question“! again as to the words he had used to.Judge Duffy. wit- ness stated: “I am not, sure whether I used profane language or not. I probably said ‘What ths hell an you trying to do?‘ or ‘What are you try- ing to do.’ I am not. sure.

"When did you any that?"

"when I got up from my broth- or.‘

Dr. Bluebird‘. Testimony

Dr. J. E. Blanchard. dantlst, Ohcr- lottetown, testified thlt he left. It. Eugeneb Church, Omrehead, about

1....

0:20 on the night of the accident. fie arrived in front of Ruslellls gar-

age about 9:30 and came to where accident Bo llw I

blood before I picked him up, Ind nlotfntlzeouoonungin. _

"Did you see the other car at the wce-ne of the lccldent?"

"I never saw my car. I never went to examine the car but picked up the boy and went right on.

"Who was with you 1n your oar?

"My wife, my nurse, Miss lieBlanc, 11nd Joseph Roblson and his wife.

“You left some of your passen- gers there?"

"I had to."

"You didn't see the accident?"

"No, no. I would say the occid- ent hoppaned shout five nunutes bcfom I got there.

Coroner: “When you approached the accident were the lights of the other ca: off?"

Witness: "Tho only light I had to work on was my own."

Mr. Shaw: "You didn't see the occupants of the other car?"

“No.1

Anthon Reunion, civil engineer with the Provincial Public Works Department, produced a plan of the

' position of the Stanhope Road cov-

ering the scene of the accident, with measurements and approxim- ate position of the cars. The road opposite the garage, he stated", is 31 feet wide from gutter to gutter. The Chevrolet (I-Iorgan) car he found with the rear wheel in the-gutter, the front wheels on the road. The other car, a Hudson, was 15 feet west of the out gutter. The east- ern side of the Hudson car was about in the centre line of the mad, the front wheals being inclined slightly toward the out. Witness also gave evidence of posltcn of wheel marks, blood stains, broken glass and- broken car parts. His in- vestigation had. been made about 10:30 on the morning of Sept, 2. Asked if he saw any marks where the Horgan car had gone into the ditch, witness replied in the nega- tlve.

Helena. Horgan. Mary l-Iorgan, and John Horgan, sister: and brother of the deceased, testified, in large part corroborating the evi- dence of their brother ‘Thomas as to how the accident occurred.

John I-Iorgan in his evidence sta- ted they were going "not more than ten miles an hour" while the other car was coming "fairly fast," on an angle straight tovlards them. They were on their right hand, side of the road, right up to the shoulder of the gutter. "It seemed to me." he said, "as 1f the other car never saw us, and 1f we hadn't been there ha would have gone into tho bank. I saw Papa talking to Mr. Duffy af- ter the accident. Mr. Duffy seemed to be stupifted, in n. kind of a daze. Ho wasn't answering anything Papa said to him."

Mr. Show: "Could you tell what your father mid to him?"

Witness: "He said something about ‘You are a nice Judge to be hitting people on the road-J "

"Did you say thatrJudgo Duffy didn't answer him?"

"No sir, 1 never heard Mr. Duffy say anything,

"Was there anything else said?"

"Just u I was coming around the car I saw ‘Thomas run over to Mr. Duffy's car and ask him what he was "T1118 to do."

“Do you know anything about your lights?"

"I didn't notice anything wrong with the lights."

The Coroner: "Were you thrown on the car W the unpact?

Witness: "I guess I must have been. I jun don't know. I was off the car when I got up, anywly. 80 I must have been thrown."

Witness described the relative position of the can after the im- pact. His brother Michael was lylns near Mr. Dufly’; cor, five or six feet from the ditch.

Patrick Borg-an, 16, thc next wit- ness. stated he was the last to Eek out. of the Hui-gun car gfter the pc- cident. He heard his father any to Mir. Duffy that ‘he was a nice man for a Judge, to be killing people on the mad!"

Mr. Shaw: "Dld you hear Judge Duffy say anything?"

Witness: "No sir."

"Did Mr. Gamer my mp1?’

"I thought I heard him uyfn Thornu we hid Jlllt one lilht."

"Do you know anything about the lights?"

"No sir."

Mr. Horlm. Senior

Thoma Borg-an, senior, father of the deceased. stated howls 1n the from sent on the rfglvtlund aide. f-fe saw the other car on top of the hill, near the forge. "The lights went right for us all the time. My son said it was going right into us. and we llid ‘We will all be killed.’ The next thing he ran right into us." Their own cor, he testified. was on the shoulder of the road I-nd going slowly. After the impact someone ahoutcd that Michael was killed. "Then I turned to Mr. Duffy and I laid, ‘You are a. nice Judge to kill b00910 on the road.’ "

Mr, show: "Did you ask him any questions?"

Witness: "No lir. When I spoke he made hardly any attempt to apensortoheipmyboylnsny

my.

Asklnl porrnlulon to make n. fur- ther stoma-rent, witness continued: "Judge Duffy oamo to my- house yesterdly evening to no what my lcleu were, tn sea whot I fclt about it. He started to work nyfng it was our fault for going with one llsht.

nndl-Iltbotkfnddtfatng. Invent

On in that way. Ind 01 6°11!" l‘

man coming l1-1 to my b01150. We would try to be very nice to hlm; 11111-1111 moved from when ho WB and came over and sat nut m0 M1 uld, ‘Mr. Horgan, I will tellyo: tho law in this case. In all prol: ability.’ he said, ‘the jury will 81v s ’ ‘ ‘ of ar- accident-acciden- ta! death. The.- ln the case of youi boy Thomas, 11' liable to be tmke1 up for mnnslr tar-not mo, be- cause your son na-d been standing on the running board and he was driving with on light.’ I uld ‘Yes sir. We put, yor in the Bench. You killed one of m" pays; you nflsht 1w well klll thcm l."

A Juror: "V. at was the purpose of the Judge quoting that law to you?"

Witness "I don't know what pur- pose it would be. I suppose he meant it more of n friendly call, by the way. But that is what he said to me at the house. Ha also wrote a. letter before that. a couple of days ahead of that-a message of lym- pathy, at the same time hinting he was not the sole causc of the ac- cident."

Mr. Show: "Perhapg you might produce that letter. Have you got. it here?"

Witness: "No air."

"Can you tcll us anything with regard to the light: on your cu?" .

‘The lights were on no for u 1

ow. ~

Jflloph Robina, Btnnhopo, “m. fled m hlvlnl boon with Dr. Blwchard. After driving 200 or 800 yards down the road with hi: wife and family be returned to the scene 31th the mldent with .1. w. MoClbo.

ere was some dispute 1n lbouf; calling the Mountedprlm: He went tg telephone for them.

Mr. Juror: “About what 1.1m w” that?"

Witness: "That would be between 9:30 and 10 o'clock. About half an hour after the accident.

" you mean to body thought of calling thrymairitcd Police before?"

"Well- they mlxht have been thlnklne about u. but they didn't."

Witness bud spoken to Mr.’ Gas. ner after the boy was removed, and agso after he (witness) had return. E .

Mr. Show: “ era h d J 4 Duffs‘ there together?” m u u

Witness: "Not at that time."

"How did they seem to be, m,“ parties?"

"How do you mean?"

"Were they sober?"

"Apparerglttlz. to me. I 111-1 not swear ng t m; 1 mnkwmfl Y were drunk,

A JWWI "Wfluld you know when a mm has s drink or two. usually?"

Witness: "1 would think n»

“Would you tn been drinklngffay o“ men Md

“Well. I smelt 1 not saying who 1 1m 11°? PHD-Nd to swear. when I smelt the liqum- 1 w“ ‘puking to James Gesncr and Judgg Duffy W" ‘W153i! very close to mo.

Asked by a juror ff anyone had suggested moving tho Duffy a,’ "line's II-ld. "Yes. Judge Duffy said he would 11kg m n; m, u, offthemadJ-Ipwuu m], 80.1fm t0 be run into?" o w“

W“ 1b. to your knowledge,

moved?" howl-due a was

111110: but I am smelt it off. I

“Yes, w my moved. I om not saying 11 "Mimi "Y. front or gt???“ "Back." "You ar n1 what dlstaiweg_ PYQPINd to state "No sir." "Was 1t. m pqweg?" Wind undtr its own ‘B e moved d _ £1‘. H for u a“ pow "W110 did the moving?" frfvwont. swel-r." ' as there an on 15¢ with V011 when they ca: $11.1 1111x152 "I can't say that." MY- sill-W; "when was thq c51- wed- Y0" 817 you cune back m4 n went to tel - ‘ came back "unfiphone, then you Wltnguggfgg I left the ti» 11m 1.1111,." m’ ‘mu’ The Coroner:

"Who 1mg when the our w“ t

was moved?"

Wltnesu’ "Well. I would any 131-, m-“nmard! P¢0Dle would be there, I don't know how close to thg W116- My wife was thug; my fill-chm and mam. mo»? 1m "wt I can't soy."

“You didn't move the car?"

“No sir."

"Did Dr. Blanchard:

'"‘ ‘°“'""

' any of the ladle: 1mg in the moving?" y.“

"No air."

Asked if Judge Duffy. b0 hi! knowledge, had moved the ear. wit. 11885 replied: “I cm not swearing that Judge Duffy started that our. I mncmber asking n11 the qua. tlmi, ‘Judge, why not leave the car when £1 iifi-I suppose it was Judgo Duffy that was 1n the front-‘until this thing is investigated?”

“He was sitting at the wheel?"

"That f can't be positive. I sup. poo, ft was him. Jim Gamer told me that the Judie Wu driving the m. Jrhereforc I suppose it wls

I- W- M000!» testified that on "PM"! It the coeno of the accl- dent be found Mr. Gen-inf and Judie Duffy standing behind their car. He asked them about it and Judgo Duffy said ‘Thnt cor run fntc me.’ "I said is them anyone hurt? He said yes. the boy in that other ca: was hurt but he was taken to the hospital."

htcr witneu uld he returned when he hoard f1: was the Hor- Ilffl car and asked Judge Duffy, "What aboif. calling the Mounties? He llld ‘I don't think the Mount- iel will come.‘ Another man. whom witncu did not lmow. "batted in and had o. lot to uyfllle hen/v Judge Duffy romark "different times" tint he wanted in tlke his w- to town. I-fe did not no either of tho can mend while he was there. vrvlmesiage-nld ho smelled liquor o r .111 mrty.