_T-g.;-i ‘ _of

1

i _ _

1. l

.3 .»-.""‘ _ ..___¥ '_ I. ;_- .f\\"

.__._-$7

53-;» 2-‘ji l-ll;

._~, Ja. 1:(

i + fc- ,_ J `~¢ ,‘f~ `1;»il'l'-. i'> l.-_(.1 st *N2 tl’ ".1 /"5:

r ,.~.,-

3_6?

iii _

V5",

-l~,;`

I s., _ -ht . 'Jr , -<-

* 415-; . hi- ts- _

1_, ___ 1; fl __ = _

-‘1 . , . .

.¢.

._'

~`i_._‘.'_ ____ __

_\_

5.- -3' -

_ \

\

I '»

,_

A.

_ I

l

ltlllioiniill

' - ».-r *'

Pr Billie. Bild accumulated interest, which il0il`l Tllei' Di‘6pared them and Dill `

-_ - would have amounted' then to probnb- them on the `Juurnals ot the House. ’ i - ~; ly nearly the value of the land. Fol- it is trite that the claims, as set out' , j _ l°WIhl! tho contention of the Leader in the Journals there. made_up the - -

-fi('ontlnued from Page 'l`en_l

_. __',.. ., , [_ _ ._

__ s- _

»

l sliali not read thc 'original as it lip

pears lu French. but siiall read translation of the article. This what “lie Moniteur says:

D0

nlins-ii . sitscirii -Fil-olli ull-s_ was-sis nrwsf For-nit _eu:illnlii_irs_ _ __ _

"“» ' _ e -never have coffee a

The Moriiteur wishes to warn il_'_ I it

of the Opposition. that furmor's son skeleton of the claim, but if the hon. ll\Ight_very weili say: It is all my gentleman has ever worked up a brief compatriots against tho ap als fatliers fault. lie- left me the farm he knows it is not what goes in a- ' ,lyrojndtw which fm- nolneilllle _

1

___\ _

v3-'

that _\‘ei\r was lluzluiicu all t`..;.-_ wp... ¢°ll<,s~li\i»i0 01' that sci-1,000, and still lllilfii relmillied 3103.000. Now. the header of the Opposithon knows we ntarleil' out with a debt on our i-ihoul; ilcrniof $108,000 and ended at the close of the year with the debt ro- duced to $108000. 'l`l\at is. we had l\aiil`-oll‘_ their dc-ilcit nt $83,000 and liabilities' of 385.000, to thi- extent | hiivtjnn»ntiqaell_ leaving $108,000. 'rind wasltho s_Ituatlon_on the Iltst day el' lkiceiubor. 1912. I think that.-is per- fcctlv plain to anyone who wishes lo lio fillr. ’l`hls_hua continiled' frolii ¥<'~\\‘ to ycyr. it is ti-no that ut the “iid bf every ycai' thoro are debts ow- lllir by the provllui-.e and debts duo te the province. \vhicl\ wo call assets. Wo ure more liouest thull thc late iiovernlueni. -At the cud of every iiscaf ycar during their period. on the :filth Scpteinber. the Provincial Audit- or's report- showed that during thc .\'ear l-t l-.crlatn amount _of money had beeil _L'orcived_ by the prov-iiuce and u ccrtalii amount of money had beeli paid out.--AND THAT WAS ABSO- LUT_E_LV ALL IT ~SHOWED! it did uotfslioiy what the province owed, and

no ixllount of questioning oil our part whi wo were in ._-pposerlon could elicit the information and place be- l°l‘0_ ill" Di*-"Dio of the province- the exact sltuatioii_ We demanded me ststeniollt year after year. and tlioso who sat in the places we new occupy rcfiisolii us' the liiformation. and it was not until wo came into power that the pi'ovinco knew just where it stood. On thc' other hand, we have not olily shown year lifter year- what we 'have rc-ceiivetl ltild paid out, but we also show to the people of the province what wo owc;` so that to- day you can pick up the External Au- tIltor‘s report and ascertain exactly to a cent how the province stands; and this is one oi' the circumstances that told in our favor when we had i.o go to the market for money. It liclpell: us--because. fliiimcial ilistltu- tions said to us. "You have placed bc- fore- 'us the precise situation ol' your province. Never before could we ob- tain such a statement. \f`v`e never kllew just what your province ow- ed." It might be $100 or $100,000. and as a matter of fact. on the 2nd De- cember, 1911. the amount duo by this province and unpaid was some $85,- 000, and this had been going on year lifter year. I need not labor tllat point. any further. It is not _neces- sary; and"I think il have made- it pluin that _our system of book-koep- ing is the only proper one,-a system that readily commends itself to ally- one wlio is accustomed to using fig- ures. Tile last report from the ex- ternal auditor shows that the debt ot' the pljgyi_ne_e_l_s $1,002.000 as against $1.072,000 on the 2nd of December; 1911,. or an improvement of $10,000;

and the"llssets lying io the credit oi` the prov ice amount to $52,000. This is the statement of a Bank llialxagei-, -an i:lid‘t-peiidelit outside ‘man whose only concern is to give the correct fig- ures. The financial critic oif the Opposition says: if the debt is as high as it is. it is due to the Coiiser- vutivo Party' ot' the Prev-lncc. When wn ciiuie to power a grt-at many years

ago \\'tr_§q\_fq§,_lhu’t tho lfebt .Of ‘the Dl‘0‘ vinco was 1,000, alld besides that they liadllrawn $20\.dir0 from Ottawa. lnakinga total of $371,000. Now, I cannot sea tho analogy between draw- ing $200,000. from Otzawa and the deb of thu roviilce. However. he

t. D _

starts out w-'str his debt of $371,000

and says there has been interest -on that amount running ever since. so that ii\,»]_011 when they gave' up power that debt- ef $371,000 would have am- oulitedito $700,000. which the ()on~ servatives are responsible for. That is what -he says. Let us seo how that works dut. We. ourselves, found the debt `at}§1,072,000. and when in twen- ty-four years’ time when we comb to give up'_-'the reiuis. of power in this proviiicor-‘anti il have ncl dobut we shall remain lll power so I-ong-we were to leuvo a debt ol' $3,500,000, accord- ilig to the Leader' of the Opposition's argument we could turli round and say: "Why, that is all your fault. You loft us a debt of ii lriillion dollars. and that compounded for twenty years has amounted to threif; and a half inllllions. lt would be analagous to the case of the farmers' son who might bn left it $10,000 farm with a small mortgage on it of $300 and. af-

ter lilhad kegt it for a great many ypars, would e obliged to seo the /farm sold in order to pay off the mort-

ii mortgage oi $300 on lt, and brief that constitutes the work. Ile- - ll ili0i‘iiiiti§e. with com ound inter- knows you have to look up a great' r ' est added to itiroui your ‘to year, has number of cases. and that perhaps ol Mn' gym' consumed the whole farm. 'Phat it every dozen cases you look up only E- llklllllll CIC” 0

the argument of the Leader of the one applies, and he knows that o brief Her

appeared ulruost daily. in the _Trans criiit. 'l`hcse appeals to the 'lowtsi

gratuit

and meanest passion. are a ous insult to the Acadian race.

we feel assured will uotfbn dccuivod

makegood coffee

who

Have you fever started -_ right -

Opposition. and 1 leave it to House to c.:tliuate its value.

the -liter all does not bogiu to- represent . .

the work that has been spent on it. D“nn¢chan¢¢°fL\f9»

There is another so»callod "argu- l~‘or two strenuous weeks we labour- :I ,An t ki

llleilt" used by-the Opposition, li sam- ed at it. Besides the work that had Rl°lll\l°'°°¢ *° ”' "' * 0_3 plc of their cherished stock-lin-trade. been do-no in Prince Edward island laveu b0$i`-l¢l.°f I-Yil-li\ E- Plillilllilll pl-omming the yllg lllwmllu Tliey ally that we have been getting preparatory to going to Ottawa. we; _ n $200,000 a year more than the Liber- spent two weeks in the Library there, _l ` '

__ I

als got when they were in power

the last four years:

ln1913 ._ ln1914...... . lnlil15....... . lil 1916 .. All average of __

482.534.

will take tho last four years tho_l.ib- looking over our ground, making sure Ullllll Will” lll ll0WDr Their orulnar\ of every pollit ami studying up the lovenuo for the following wats was casa, in older that when we went be

lil 1903 $166001 I5 roio the Privy Council any objections In 1900 _. __ 375,374.40 that might then be put up to us we, In 1910 ... £l75.151:32 would be ready to meet and over-l in 1011 .. __ 374,707.82 como; and as a matter of fact, when Au average revenue of 372,981.18 ive did go before the Privy Council Our ordinary revenue has been,

506,553.39 525,555.10 470,729.80

01

490,345.22

l ln thc archives and in other places

in every nienlbcr~r.~f the Council raised

objections of one k‘ind or another whifh had 0 bc nnsvvelell nn( I

Vegetable Cem-

Wllliil 1 f°¢l lil'l° I const'-tlilcd itself the iriouth piece MW Weiilln lll l “Let us not 'be' deceived; thc wlylhadaheadache sell;-ss and ridiculous articles

during the Change .lished by the Transcript are not in-

b ed “_ l'lll’L` -- ._ _CHASE Gt SANBO

troul with

hd “slings oemx no entenlcl the goon will preva m tm" tim°__ liotwtcil the different races livin

' ~csuit " .

‘ F’ You would have thought, hir. Speak il0lll' er that the natural thing my

friend would have done under the circulnstances would have bcc_ii to

1

W I 1. _ .

dinyqnun' nenmu' IH al ptlllliy i;r(:~l‘t=l;l(li'| feelmzl Iilil lle°‘ crfrd and to endeavour to derive

a“h”- NW' l‘m ical advantage therefrom."

.: t . . , 1 in better health

have no hesitation in saying that it pun I ever was and recommend your New, Sir, l nlay my iurtlicr was the thorougil way in which the “meal”w3|lmyffl,nd|_"_Ml-LLENA the Acadlans of this province d Premier of the province .lnswcred ww” 2812 E_0 Sung Rlcl.lm°nd_V‘_ wish to be pntronlseil and they <li.- not hav" \~ve mp" to help R mn" those objections that guvc him the while clung. of Lin la ‘ mo" crib wish to be_toiidicd to. __ 'i‘hcy ha ' ‘ '

fl-he avcmgu diffcrmum lol. lhd l-om ntntns he held before the i'rIv_v Colin- lal “od of "°mm,. sximmce um i'-.iivliewcil 'their way. unassisted. _ years is $123,000, not $200,000. Wim' ‘lll~ (ADIlliliiB0.) I want to- say I mpwml which “°°m'.n '“`“"l "lim" lmlll “~°‘;.“m“u band ° did we do with it?-they ask. I haw in this connection that this province sxsng cgntmuod md no hslldl ll‘l_l`_l(’*l °x.llf’“t";':.“‘)"i'l’i" ?‘”h°u'l"_

'nm r\)(‘ (01320 I l'lili§l\ I0

by tho too transparent game of u newspaper. will--h in the past has.antl' today continues to play a supremely

FD

i

small political clique of who it

of uf, md ynalw lspircd by love for the I-‘re-ncli

nof by ii desire to strengthen (ln

odious role with the -oil; pu oso of

U um lie .anvtliing i`or lliin_ \\'hat

ton. lie allowed ilo pariv f

__ lor premillee io weigh in ‘thc in

of ii has

sen-' V pub~

bort- Elini

-with Chase 8:- Sanborns SEAL BRAND’ COFFEE?

In if I and 2 pound tina. \Vhole-ground-pulvoriled-Ilan

(ine ground for Percoiators. Never sold ln bulk is

RN. MONTREAL.

g in

#

gi-.417

I ski" \\ ell.» his friends wcul

“H and judged of the situation o

hon

rigit

_ uhosc

"lf famiy have opposed us?" ilut no'

mr' My lion. friend took nn such

up showing thu; we pnpl _y-early on 5,, work that he then did and for many

of cxtravaganee.

There is auotlier matter I wan

n statement lll-_.ye wlllcll l have malls will never repay the Prefmier for the I _ ' - f ll' _ =_ ‘.'.

restored by the dmelyiueof Lydia E. nagging zeal, their tin-lit, and. above mum He saw dll von ,hmk tl or ,our ,wmnch

average. during the last live' Years. for ‘llller llilllem-“ ll” Obmlned for the Pinkhur' vfgd'-me C°mp°“nd` au' their grim “ml mlnllnlme tellllcill' man equal to the Dositiou. then lus I education in the mvlnce $39317 om province. There was ant.-tlier case Such Warning lymptloms lrealensa of inirprec. they have sin-ceetlcll iu tue must be (lone_.. And jusmcl 13.- ,llelll li Clear up l“5l,le to

D .

of the ordinary revenue, more than in lll \"lil(`ll ll lll`l9l' WHS illlllllilililil- flllil bf !\lf0¢\i-\°ll» ll°¢ llB5_ll¢l» ll¢ld\°l'\¢_l» “gill” nmllg _fhelf l“"‘fl"l _lllglc ““'°“l3 was (lone, Now, 1 Conn] go the las; flve ywl-3 the Llbe,-llls were that is where reiel'ence has been bulnchag' ann) 9( lml-,ending evll' lliclr_felloiv-tltizeus ol _lie __lar In pow r. Tl t i _ ~\ in 4 __ iilade to research ill reg- rl to -tie Uni- ~ ° ' - ~ ~ t- 'rovnces ani comlnil'nl nl-I lil 000 a year olia ans n‘\Y;'i'alg\<;minll>:l‘e tshgn ted States. That wal; (the \ lands' ;\;!‘;li\?yh¢:;lt?d:l;I¥l'il:°l:¢:`:Jarep‘t`)lil;m:yl;):: Dect of all. My position in this -the Liberals paid during the last ave claim, and the strongest precedent - lnegululdm Wampum” _unable “_ tor is _tao_-_well known _to requii Years thee’ were in power. We have we had in support of that claim was eme wuk' md lnqlnawde and Dll\lli\ilil'll»_ My illlll' llfl ll lllelllll exlienried on an ave-rage $50000 a year found in the United States after some Emilia °°°°__ _C __ :lifeCl3"all"“al;l___l:lll__=l_*__ll___ll‘>_ll_f§;

in permanent ublic works. in those research. Tile Leader of the ODD0' - -- ~ two items wephave spent $90,000 a eition said: "An amount of credit is Fm' “"5" “Wm” °_°”dll7l°ll' il? ll°l interest and welfare ol' the Prev year of excess revenue-_ The bal- due yc-u, but there are others entitled flil *Dull* LY\l5\E- Pml‘ll\lll\ l'°¢°' lll Eellitiilli S0if0llillY illv llllill`ilS alice can be easily accounted for. It to credit as well.” Yes. Mr. Speak- ill>l°C°ll\9°°-L . “lv °""" “°'l“ll“°“l’*3 “llil lll” lll has gono to good purpose ami con- cr. I ilgrhl that there are other melt U0 'llli‘-Hhs least tile iiiic-\'0-at slats of small items which I will not ln this province who are entitled to _ ' W4 lll-" Alllillell ”‘llllPllll`l‘ll-`l~ 'l`ll°5 go into. And another thing which we credit, and from the floor of this man and had been placed in <‘0i\i'll\<l- rious interests l shall i\lWil.\'-il Si dill was: We killed tho average de- ilouse they have obtained credit. Al- _mont in the jail until such time as as I have strlvcn lu the past. to iicit of $45,000 a year which they had though Qiey were politically opposed his temper would- rcsunie its normal' ict-t niid_ maintain; and think I all except in one year. 'l‘hat is where to us, vie recognised what they had state. ills wife. aftelf llc ll'-‘il ' ` ' `

more of the money wont, and yet our done for the province, and recognis- lil Ill`lH0ll fill' Slllllfl lllllc- l°““ friends ot' thc' Opposition accuse us ing. we gave them credit. I referl more than shc_could do I0 R000

to Senators Yeo and Prowse. Tha fnmily» llllil all Hi”ri\lil;'2\\lil'l\l WHS*

t to Leader of the Opposition thinks we and bonds were given fl.-r his good be-, were lll is seat-I regret that h

' of not-I would tell hilu'somc thin

i

been claim with touildeuic. S.r. that I

the mv dull- in this respect. if the

d itlnot been remiss in the dlscharg

made: junior member for the First Dis

u_'_'3'; cite other cases, where, i'or inst ' the i’reuiier. knowing that there

_fuatf li position in the Normal Schoo '“ ext a _rouug lady teacher, suggested' t or 0 that as there were ni;-t many

mm' lions held b Acadlens in the

rlvc

mm. populaltion in New Brunsiviuk

KEEP IIVIR AIIIIVII ANI] BUWIIS UIIAN

WIIH IIISIIIRIIS

post

eellng -‘-‘“ mlm Best when bihaua, sick headaehy ,l nt, constipated, or for had breath

0,, to night and feel fine 'luke Cascalots to

am; liven iour liici and clean the bowels

“ns .ind -iiop lieudechcs. a bail led 1 10|- lilliouslless. offensive breath. coatcil U me tongue, suliowness, soul' stomach and posi- gases. 'I`o-night take Cascalcts and pl-0. enjoy tho ui<-c'_~it, gentlest liver and

me vinro i slloiiltl have the right to name ll0“'0l Plililll-'~'lHi§ l'0\l €‘V¢`l' WD*-’-fl*

Elma: some person i'or thc position in l

“_ tion. I llladc enquiries ami i`

ll' ‘gr the best person available. That ' _ son was li young lady from my

B W' frielld’s district.

l“ntl_ our-od, Wake up feclhig grand- omld l-}ver_vliolly's doing it, ifascarets best lnyy. laxatlve for children also.

hon.

prol l ‘l"l`-'l lll1°“' “'ll°ll“"l` llllf /\‘~`“‘ll“" am not in the habit ofrerlsing or icuii-

“""‘ Ing my own speeches, if I wus so rc-

lm,,`(,_ against proliibitlon o='_ for _proliil_iitluu_ n0|.l(,_,l l “.55 ‘.Cnm.l(,(l “.|.0ngl_\._ lll-lml

~. of 3 ' ’ lm“_ province and some lutlain trlcl spool-lies were made in the in

, l know it wus il political issue lil the

atory utter.

C ls ami l know that English as well as gs l_l~`|-inch representatives were retiilu-

l did say was: “AFTER the car ferl'_v began opcl‘utl0us." I may say that in speaking this way l ani giving my own opinion merely' and .not voic- ing tho opinion of any

that in the adjustment that tookp in 1010 the asscss'ors had worke

or. I don't kliow what authority' Leadel- of the Opposition had

was no co-operation among them

mad-e ll proper adjustment.

not founded on fact. The facts that the adjustors did meet;

their work on the borders of

der to get at the staridard' valu

notes. and when it is said in I-louse that such it thin did not

fact. I allowed' also that the s

position that he knew one school trict in his own district where

statement ill my hand showing

electoral district. comprising th

crease was only $278, or an ave

of approximately $8.50 per school- trlct, and there is not one single

claimed it was. What confidence the public at large have in a man would make such wile statement

I now como to the subject of

that is well known. and I do think lt. needs to he dwelt on at grant length. The hon. gentle started out with the assertion

nlent had' been prepared before

it. I-le said that the statement

has been readln the oiirnals of

found those claims very shortly

made them up? Who was it put them on tho .louriials of

l

peter tg, and that is mls; The Lead should also give credit to Sir Wilfrid l\2\Vl0\ll'. and at the importuillt 'cr of the glllyosillon made ,l ella,-ge Laurier. In a moment I shall come lllfl Wlfe illlil (lll llle l`9lli‘0S€‘iliil_ll0

Counties and worked together in

- E

pen. the statement is notioiliided

,increase in taxes had amounted

soma $400 was not cm-l-¢,c¢_ l llavea THIB QUESTION. Lot nie say to want twc- bottles of whiskey." l

mal my lion. friend tiiat he is turning over plied: "Well, I have no whiskey." _

mfs an important page in the history of ills retort was: “It you don't give it ills salary was increascdto $350.

' mall was not ii supporter of mine,

when i hecainc il iluember of the l

in the whole of the hon. gentlem _

ll-ly. the country IF WE ARE T0 REVERT - lu lilo 1 won’t vote for you." I said: ln. TO THE CONDITION OF ,FORMER “All right; that is your own privi- Qge TIMES* WHEN PROVINCES WERE lcge. You can vote for whomsoevcrl sent Government I laid his cas (113- COMING AGAIN AND AGAIN TO you please." lie went off, seeing (lla. THE FEDERAL POWER AND ASK- that there was no prospect of getting een ING FOR BETTER TERMS. llow- his order filled in the quarter he was

le- ti-ict. the Government- ret-ogniscll

tlircc school districts, :no total

trict in which the increase has b

oncttenth 01' what the lynn gentleman over, l will not insist upon this matter applying to, but before going he

gnu today. I would like tu know where, relied this Parthiau shot at lac: “li who in that speech, tile Leader of the Op- you don't give it to me I can get it 9 position can find any tzbnsolatioli or from the other party;-and I know

the claim wo made did not roqu

very much resoarch._that the state- provinces come back what will you known. There is only one pl

and do?" Does the hon. member recall ill Sulnmerside where such is thing

lieon prepared by others. Well. am thinking that the hon. gentlem

out there. The question is: W

me to that point, but l will any now tn-.it hcl- olersynlaii- the l\\\-‘llwilll MS

tliellisctves. had not consulted togeth l`l®r' liiltl With his followers in the sq. milar circumstances; *mt neither

the nate was exercised against us rather iliC'il\ hell eiiytlllllié \ lHU3V0l` lil for than fc-r us. and had it not been for Wltli iil'0llllllll<»'ll- 'l`lle L°3ll‘ll` Of

making such a statement,-that the;-Q the unremitting work of Senators Yeo 0l>ll0Slil°ll lllllcf lleilll lll Sllnle 1°"

and and Prowse nnd their influence with on the llappeiilngs of a certain tl

that therefore they could not have lllell Lllleiill friends. the measure Sl-0l'0 lll the “'eHl°l`ll Dart "f the l __ _

flilllg would have been defeated in the Se. vincc, and reiated_ all _that was go_ilig| $.l00. That inspector ci;»utluued

statement, like a great many more, is nate at the instigation of Sir Wilfrid 0_ll-"il Elflai deal lll ms °“'“ l‘“'"‘g__““` “'°"k fu" ‘“““5‘ years' A ma"

nl-9 Laurier. Perhaps the hon. member ll“ll- Bl" he ‘lm “lll mu M “

_V usof_ found when I bccueme a memlie libc- the present Goverliuieilt. I l`

l t i fl r tzl Tire other case was under si~ that many years ago there was _ _ _

bl W ‘a evar n “ence Sir ‘mmm La" a 'l polll-`s"“5 “'l‘l' all _al’l"“"“" nmlollll' of policy to advocate leaving on the

then 3 the Acadians oi New Brunswick popu-

of Acadien inspector of schools ap do. ted for this province. l-Ils duty the was simply to visit the i<`rcucii sch gth once every year. 'l`hese sch

rugl were also visited by the Eligllslr l - . : ~ -

'l. ol- cd to oppose prohibition. It is not a o“ml;i\lz\tter of our concern, and if the

member of the Govern-

_ _ ment or the (iovcrnulclit its at whole.

an Uliiirlllilil- -*alll 'hm ml” °f ‘he "cl" I said I thought it was a short-sighted

boats between tha i`hai'lottctowl\- Picton and Sumnic'rs-ide-Point du Cherie routes after the l-ar ferry went into operation. I said ' further that

wlS.laiion voted against the Govoruiucnt 0(,l,.1vi'a:i because they were opposed to ln piohibltloii, the “Guardiali" is right

ro speitoi and the salary uns fixed atllo the “Xml” um" il, ‘vas “ l’-Omlcnl when it was decided to accept the

lat ca occup' that position ill this

ll )

llml for tha second dint;-lg; of Quecnvs wlll went on in a certain law office lil pro- viuce must have the ability of

they tliirconsult: that thev started out rlllpveeiate what I am about to read xlmity to the said drug store on

` tlw These are llw words of slr Wlllrlll lninntiou day. 1915. On that day rough knowledge of French. and s

or- Laurier: 'iliose-living across the street obscrv- also he intimately acquainted

9 gf __ _ cd a great stream of people gol

lm-ms lmrllorlng on the c0umles_ -l-hey The only thing I was anxious to ` l-V one door into that law office a _

mel l-l-Om llme lu llmc and conmared know to-day was, upon what ground coming out by the back door; and in_ When l _becaine ii inelnbcr of -

ucli‘ llouse eight. years ago I brought

'elthe atlcntic-n of `thc Leader of

tllls my'hon. friend ls, taking the very ab- the place where the pocket of e

me from the practice that has been fol inaii it was stated we-nt in on 17

t - _ » -- .

ment made by' the Leader of -the Op- l0\V0il- ‘ I thought that in 1907 when ferent occasions, anti on as many di

dis. We revised the subsidies of the pro- ferent occasions he carrie out urlll i

hw, normal action he proposes. \Ve are individual was supposed to bc, ther

on in this instance departing altogether was ii significant protrusion. 0iio‘Goveruinent the -fact that this

no- ordinary men. lie must have a

diff could not. live on the small salu

me vinces. and established a new scale arm with Sir ltodcrick. A man froiu and that hc was doing work

r

the justification for his statement that whoin to vote for, don't fear.” l _' ,

Increased Subsidy. This is a ma ter Sir Wilfrid Laurier is entitled to any_ did ro, and he did get it --and lic

I III

not credit . Does the' hon. member re- it from the- same aw o ce.

any call what happened in 1007 when at Mr. lil-JLI.: What is the name?

man the time of the re-adjustment ol' Pro- .-\N HON. MEMBER: Tell us that- vlneial subsidies, on the iieor of the other name. ,

all that we» had to do was to present the answer Sir Wilfrid made? "THIS happened. It is adjacent to

had SETTLEMENT IS FINAL AND UN- “certain drug store" of which

the Mr. BELL: 'That is not what Ile can tell the rest of the story.

8 I

years 1900 and 1907, and if he did said: 'Mit BELL: That is pretty small at look up those journals he will have ‘ HON. Mr. ARSENAULT: That is politics. '

s

t what he said when ho was In power IION' Mr AltSLlNAUL'1` I ull

th tlw unalterable there coui he no ellaii e an _ There is an old adage

1 I1 g » .D Y

l‘l0\illil'~’ -Wllll li- ll0i- tile illifii 0Dl>0Bl~ and it was useless to come back. _Of `l~‘rancli which says that when you

course, when we went there tho situa- with the wolves you have to eat, with W0

tion was changed. He was out 01411,, w°lye,l_ on lll plalll English inc "°“'"' ““‘ ”““ “° °°“"‘ “°‘ '°"““""‘“‘°"‘ ‘“ "°"‘°' “° “° “°‘“° “°°“"' W"

from the statement more injurious' it ‘ls extremely regrettable that we f0\l

'_' V 1 I ' than beneficial, that'it was a strange 'should be under the necessity of fol- the

_precede'nt, that he thought when the lowing hon. members in this strain, 000

\

\Veak, run-down, nervous men and

- women need Vinol

because it contains

the most famous reconstructive tonics

in an agreeable and easily digested

form :-Beef and Cod Liver Peptones,

Iron and Manganese Peptonates, Gly- .cerophosphates, etc.

l

-~ -O ~

- s .

= it '

;-. _»:.

/ 1-. ' > - - _ '-

|` r . '

would have left that subject the House. in view of the fact t _severely alone; but it seems the Leader oi I-lie 0Dl>0Sll-l0il llllil to .be one of .the points that supporters have endeavoured _to pl have an alluring attraction for him. me in a-false position, however,

ire- House, Sir Wilfrid was asked "lf the IION Mr. AIISENAULTZ It is well I

I ALTERABLE." Those were his Loader of the Opposltic-u spoke. Those a _ an words. who are acquainted with Summersido wards avllillllieil to it li0Sll10

Prince of Wales. Part of his duti

0 - _ . _ t : ho_ai_ld controlled the purse strings. He lt is sinall politics, but unfortunate- Se Ht’ said the seltlenielrt was final and xii- we have fallen ilito very bad conl- li-

r.

0 ` _assure the hon. member that there tasteful though it is to us. in other _ - will be nothing on record to the ere- words, tc- use another aphorlsni: You i"*_ "" "

dit of eit_her Sir Wilfrid or those ro- have to tight the devil with his own

presentaltives -who went to Quebec weapon.

at that time. Now. tho hon. Leader of the Oppo-

The hon. Leader of the Opposition sitlon, in his odious personalities. lu-

also refer d o he D nam into a vindictive .

re t t apartment of troduced my e \

Agriculture which he made the sub- discussion on a certain article which ' ¢» _ “illustrated ject ol' extreme eriticisrii. I am notl appeared some time ago in the “Guar Q I '~ 5 ~ going to interfere with the Depart-l diau_" lie and the hon. junior mefm- , , %_ _ 3°f0l"2 C4

ment. of my hen. friend the Commis- ‘be for the First District of Prince. - ‘- ` _ sivner of Asrieuiture- _ He is quite trnlntea me on that article and songln are Davis cigars ‘ ‘ _ _ ” " l09iJill>le‘0f l00lililE ali" li, Hilti l llilvill I-0 define ni attitude, as they profess- ~ ~- - ~‘ ' P rf tl n “Str”

_ y _ - t GC 0

no doubt if he has the occasion to|~ed to understand lt, on the` subillill never raw ar’ _ _ Q* :

speak he will take up the challenge oi the article in questi_on; and the 9 9 ____~_`\ = 3,f°r.25c_

_thrown out by the Leader of the Op-lnewspapers of the province have , ‘l ‘

I dc~'n't know whetherit is because of think I owe it as a duty to myself and _:-

familiarity with one Roderick Dhu those of lmy.race whpm I l-eprlllllant ln_ f .»;_ I t t t h of whom e spoke 'some days ago; but this House. irre-spect ve o po ce, o_ ~‘s:~\L m _ - whatever the reason may be. he is on say a few v_v_lirds_ on the subject. lil_ clga'rs° n a I e 1 as

. s a er common

to -ol'- Day. WE HAD PUT AN -END T0 my district camc<to me atid said: “I with the other inspectors and

` rc- therforc entitled to the same sal

My representation had some e

fore them. and tu the credit o

the senior mclnlier for the First

claim oi' this lllull and placed hi an equal footing with the Othcl pectors. (Applausc_) I found

He. ther case in I’i-ince ol' Wales (Zo gotl There was a young man who

the

the tcacller. and radually. bv stud

ng English; therefore he has of ne ud sity to be a mall above the coiun

that lsslle lii New Brunswick. lcar ferry us i1 solution of thn wiliter who' A fm' ‘l“l'*"' “go l Stalml that I dc" navigation proiilem we had pw, prccnted the agitation going oll to have not ln _ conlmnplallon llw mo the boats reialllcd between i.harlotte- subsllllcs ol lmnts ln llc,-_ lllogtoivli and Piciou and between Sum-l l-mm me gm.,.lce_ and l polnlcll ,ml

lliistllllcllllile llllil l’0l“l' il“ “helm alt" that the widening of thc gauge. was with l-llil Cul' l"°l`l`l' "ml “cc” l”`°V°‘l “ 5“""l not part of the (`onl‘edcrution con-

ces-l“"ll5- ll '“e°"‘e‘l that me ‘lf’“l"'hly tract. Captain Ilead takesissue with l01l-f K"ll'lm of l"`i'“’° Cnumy' Lalllal* me on that poilit. but I lhiiik that any- this -l‘ll*"~‘llll ll‘lil‘l~ has l“l“’" "‘“‘b"“‘g(’ "K one who reads the British North Ani-

go my reiuarkl! and has written a lcug- Grim All will agree wlm ml, llmy

-flu,

f-I $300, that it was impossible. I po ii eq out that his work had inure-a

`Govern1uclit and of my hon. l`i-le

started in life the sou of a pour f mer. Ile had received ii coiuln school education and had gratlua

icense as ,a_ second-class teacher.

ace had gone and 'taught st-hcol for

number of years as a second-cl

I. _ll

thei llll' lbllei “’lll"ll will “lllleal ‘“ mc the widening ol' the gauge of the rail- nlan,"l"ill‘llllll"` l0lll°"l`°“'- l °“'° the ml' wa»_v was not contemplated by that

of-"llllUe 11091’ l° lll” °°‘"`l'°sy “ml l wish contract. I have reason to know that int-lll) l\'~'lill0“'li‘illl‘> ll~ ‘ the fooling is gaining ground in Ot- setl‘ Tllil glllllllll (7“l’lal“ k°"'l)5 'ff' rc' tawa. that we are a hard people to sa-

cllnall iter-ating throughout his lr.-ttor. Docs ,lm-y_ that we lmhlly lmow wllm WU

' ‘lll ’\l`l“lllllllll lll‘0“'° Well- U‘”"° 5* want \'o sooner hailonc Dartoftlio Pro

nas- l - » ' ~ .. _ _ _ m.y__ one thing i\lr. Arsenault docs know. vllwc asked lm- mm l_h|llg_ lllan mm. fleet" iiilll lllilt lil llllll UW'-‘ -l°5°l’ll Rem' ls part wailts something altogether dif-

'rhall at prize-nt moving heaven and earth lcrclm We lwllcvu ln aSkl“g_ and “___

r

~ l

but' lll liln ilimlllill- lil ll¢°lll`“ the "°°lll"*` have not been remiss in that respect. ii~e~l ll0i\ l0i' l'l`lll'~'9- ('°““lY 'll th” "ext We have recei\'cil the car ferrv and

Q pc.: Fctleral Election aild this letter is only pmmlue of wlllcnlng nl- the gmlg" Dl-

lne one move in ills political game to llm ,.allway_ We lmvc had a'“lncl.ca§Ud nd, that i‘llil- l llllllellllfllld llllll 'lll' ml' siibsidy. We have had a four-cor# Dis. 1001008 i`l`0lll lll” Tllll`il ‘ll l’l”l"“° cable laid beiweeii the Capes- and -it the IMF- l\’lCl-flllll lll.V ll”lC‘llll lll” l““l°" twocore cable laid at the eastern

ln on rueniber for theiirstilistrict of Prince cml nl- ,llc lslaml; a large vow ful.

mal il\'Ir. Gallant) and my lriend from the ,.e_lmlldlng the luml lel,.§,.al,ll llll,_.;._

uno.; second ot' Prince (Mr. Saunders) are ,md 1, meal m,m_,. olhcy. hlngs W0 llege.l lll-“O il5Dll`lllll5 _l0l’ lllfl h°“°“l`~ 'lhc have had. Our reprcsclitatiou was liadl v0l'b0ii9 Ciliiilllll llll~‘l Ollllllllllll ll about to be cut down to three. and wo

'I\

ar- ‘f*i~'00il' UWT i-ll€lll- llllil ll`_ lll-V ll0'l°‘"' have succeeded in retaining It for all oil fllllil ll'l0llilS Willll “J ll” 1" l_l“‘ l`a"° time .at i'olir. Captain ltead has him- tcd T01” llle llolllllllll-l°ll lllC>’,C"ll`ll*llll-l' Wlll self stated that the Uar Ferry would

at Prince of Wales i'-ollege. taking his liiive '-0 lTll0Cli'llll1l° lll” C“Pl“lll~ lll iiicreilse the value of every acre of

lic 'land in this province aild would In- a fact I Ullil0i`-Sliillld llllll lllil Illllll°l` crease the traffic iliiliiclir-sly.-iirnl

ass lneinbcr for the second ol' llriuce has m,w_ what ,lo we ,mul-_i ll seems we nd llilil llll lll*lll'li1lll'fl -`l'L‘l'V0‘l ‘lll llllll llllll want the l)onilnion Governincnt to

g . .I -.

the pel'severencc,‘succeeded in obtaining uule-is he 0P0llS ilil lllll ll00‘l gal” operate three boats. I say the danger

tllat iilstitution was tuition

nlit continued his studies; attended

uid have been entitled to a y

en I canle to look into thing

les College was receiving

_ _subsidies of the province had been but when we are confronted with tae- W8 - -

` _ re-adjusted in 1907 the matter was tics' such as have been employed $700- i brwislit the case before t

or ung _eildcd. The occasion may arise in against us -in this debate by some Governmient. This man’s fllllilly ll

the future when \ve may have to deal 'members of the Opposition, we must lweil l-ll>2i'i\lf‘- Wl\0 were V01.”

' ~ further with the matte and I can nicot tlielll oil their own ground, dis- against my hon. [riendl`roni’l`ignisl

first»class license. Ile was uit

French. Ile was not satisfied li

bool and succeeded in taking I A. degree. That man, although l

in had been teaching for several yen are and in the natural order of tliln

rease of $100 as other professor

nd he had started at $000, and

t time, although recognised to l of the host teachers in Prince

n

nig

¢r_ of his well known slogan in lleuuncla- llcs lll mln; may we may go just ll in tion oi tlw g0Vi=i'lllll0lll- ll” cillllllll ex' little too fur. Tlicre is n war on now es poet. t0 Kill lll” ililleiélllilfl f"~l‘lll lll” and inoncy is none too plentiful, and _nfl district and so I now warn the House ¢|wr,, is ii possibility that. by impor. ut and you. Ml". SIi0Hliill`- llllll illll`lllS lll” tuning thc Governnienl too lnucli, they ht lu.-xt few days this Assembly is may Hay: We wmv ready to [lo many ils threatclieq with the delivery of plil- l_hlng,,, lm. you that we were “ol oh. ici llipicg by these gentle-uwil lll Coll' liged todo. but ns- you seein incapable rs denluation of the Matlilesoli Govern- ,,l° ,lallsfllmlon Hml want |_00_mn¢;n, ss iuclit siirli as iiffvvr lleivrv ill"/il HW- we will give you just ll nine los.-i than

oarlv akened the echoes of these vencr- we pl-0ml5c¢|_ That ls un, llgngcl-_ 1

s. able halls. ' »'huve the assurance froui one ill ug;

it I C-illlielll Item mnkcg thc thoiiiy that until the car ferry has

nt following statement: Mr. Arscuault béen ploy-0,1 a gn(-was nn() given ns ic HHYK. "l`li0S0 Wllil are “OW llll"'0' the fullest measure oi' transportation of eating that until the car ferry is in op- laclllllen the innltn will ro-mnin on

only eration the boats be loft on the Sum- the olllgl- ,~0m¢3_ This 1 think nhunh)

lie.l\i€i'f|il0‘l"0llll illl Ullilllil lllil lll” satisfy any reasonable person. I am nd tloorgetowii-l’Ict0u r0\li0=~\ “ffl llllll" not hero pleading the cause of the rs injuring the province than bcnctlttlnir _._ _ _ - it" inevcrmade any suclis.-tateulellt_ _ I lllonllllucn on pngc 5lxt¢¢n_)

i. _ _

i>0Blll°ll- l;also referred to the matter. As a b 1 t t e r 0 r ° The Leader of the Opposition wax- rule, Mr. Speaker. I pay little atten- .

hat

_ E

is why? an E

Tgsgrni-gg #L " 1 li

ef/ iq.

Q

Perfection

\ f‘Perfection':

Actual Sine

D

L, a

= ` "‘ \ .__

. . \ ' `

ed eloquent and dealt at tedious tion to what the papers say, and if the 7 _ T _ _

'length on the question 'of prohibition. discussion of this matter had been .~ N' _ -`.\\ ffm-

N_ow, I had really thought that this confined to the newspapers I would _.é ¥\~ year tha- Leader of the Opposition deem it unnecessary to refer to it in \\

- ~{_` `\\\~

.§

dc, - _ for over 70 years the house

of Davis has been making good ‘ ’

‘ Q Q 0 t

as to read two letters written to the

_ ,_/.1 hu Furm u y e ' Jailor of Queen’s County, with the in- ll always sold with n definite glnrdntoe to return the purcllourh 'l_‘_’;‘sl_l;’:_lhl_ 02;; ‘;‘;°°l’;ll’|°m‘;“;‘l::'f)‘;-ug: money lfit fallsto give satisfaction. Vdyfew bottles on returned. nm mmf, ,men “had "mance to

_ i'-""'_""- prohibition offenders who were incar-

Bi A FOSTER, DRUGGIST, CHARLOTTBTUWN, reratedhin tile lail.__ __'rinns__¢wy _o_o

,- ~. f t I h l' a av a e

- vinci is .els is manage. sy ri. J. mm . ,§,‘}1,,,`§§ ,‘§, ,,,,°,,,,‘}, ,,,,,,,,,;‘{,,,,,,'f° “Oni » Also' the beetdmggist in all Prince Edvvarti Island towns. letter farmed to 1 man wlui it lami-

1 - ly of young children I-Ie had had

_ _ perhaps you a mo e § wmv dialafetmepi with his seed wir, English and perhaps in brew Gaviivf

‘Guardian' as said in reference to' `

,fr

Q t

i>`§`

the wnrpath once again on that en regard to L era new p p 1 w"`~ a »