snsiwiiav _

_»@==§- 13 1.909, 'PHE LA'rss'r Naws THE CHARLOTTETOWN GUARDIAN rms-r or Ani.

" R ' - PAGE FIVE

The mporiant ews of the Week for the Saturday Subscriber”

¢_, O

T110 3P°&k¢l' took the chair at 4 ard”

'both nero.. 1 0

fi ° 11°°\1f° 0111' rights in .tili th G ' ' - - _ *_ _ lthis matter 1-1 ii e °V°1"-10111 511601211 is replled|Dominion would in due time be P10' mm had been "1-‘9W¢1'ed at a previ-513 Yvnrv. and what had they done ? just

` _ ~ e new that our claims t

hdd been pressed hy both i °' - lsented to th H

parties, for i Mn Min-HI . . e olise and he would cus session. ‘Wh h li li '

5. ._ _ . EBON c tend d th y a t ey not made an estimate - _ __ °111` éllelles elelme_ our railway iw” unprecedented anghwoufd ___o_i_i:_gsecslggntlx-u;h_th_§;1__°r1;ea__i::§gv:1____ 3: ;s__i;_l;.______li;la_t_ai_§e:;»_ii said this was not gland called for senders ? When he (Mr. riilietlm Tunnel "‘"'1y v-eo ri Logue

M01-£1111) was at Ottawa he follnd .ue made

1.. Claims, and go on

.< He criiogieed thfi the work or the House. in which we h d ' ‘

of A - it V e ate commissioner PREMIER 1~iAszAno continued the|thnt it would ntlioi-ltifiitgdhrcilyllil-,lil-t tiling lnllollfugfiz Hou” had 5 right M’ "’°l"‘°"*""*‘ *"0"* 001" Provinces cater tion,

11 “°W- Ifor information and to have the ’l"uu- nstly

' " ‘ `-"`~ - ._ _.`

dues evidently dr, not V,-um ___

V-‘hy wus not is genuine some 7 He reviewed the Bcdeiuuo gin; “'|11f`11 he nffirlricd was ciolo~ d5€`l1|£“1l by the retliriiz ._' \_illl;i,i

°r W at 0310?. Hon. Mr. Rich- cc t dit

a practical farmer and stock ll-I ep( c ation ‘mm the Opposition. terested and they must act to 'ethe ' i ' _ ‘ -

_ d 1 , _ 5 r. sloulil not be asked. t t g _ _ _

e re erre eclfngly to the death of With ebls matter settled ir. might be mation already olfcialtlywtlpvelfilablleor iwtltllegusgjdlklllledqattllllrin ._ __ h°“°""`ly b“’l"' hm lf -“J 11 use

- - uc oc to- fflfleption to the _-\;;yiun|_ me _._ __

0'clock. ' fF11S€1‘. an able and practical map

1 i the late Speaker d th. _

d BD 1. lute Ser hoped that the tax act should be re l Mil ARBENAU

' ~ LT McKinnon und nlorrliw i-niiii.

A0. and the Sulliziif-rsiiia Llotlll

Mn. MA'1‘H1EsoN ii ,i i, rom ourable the Leader of tfieBGo;e:n§1IZll1t,““d

debt of this Province? Have- any ____d‘exh

men ed the work of the institutes' f

the short course at 'rr 11-1111111 M Arms- The wuntry had nun- Denied or the burdin reduced. All tn M L ' ' -

what progress has been made during “Poke of the good work of gg; #lf ';;ie';*;dg1;D_Te\:_l_;¢_¢_ kgs’ i_n_th_;t death of i__>,.(,vince,i had L_. _und t__x_ much mg; M; '3,‘:m__‘i__e__’_’:;1§rx___ tgeghasmrzndutlor; 1-\ii,ll)AY_ lliiusl-. Si-ill-rt-ly n _ioiiar “__” _________

' ' . in ' . . _ ' ' o li ii _ _ _ 1 ~

the pan year 'in conwudating U10 FiE?;ftf:_&_;);;:_w;§o};_I;dt:°;§2§- 30111111; ppositfon leader inlocofnpllvrlitellitllllg :lllilil]<i]l;al)iltll:s.m\l\l'lillitt lllidlllllgica ‘i:.i(i)hetll1‘_, f)<:lli?r'eI`§_e had answered ilie qlleriliuir '|‘llie ill-lil-il-_ opened iltI‘ll'lx4l(lMo"7cl]¢£ok_ llllrifuw rom” un summur tm WSL D”

_ ay 0 he mover and second?s of the address. ler it is paid to the county coiiiiuiii Ori ,______Y _1:___fit_1;€o.w______ ____r__ d_- il HUN. .l<ii~lEi-__ _____A__ _,m___,_m_.,i __ ri-in-o

ici' sells' ~ . ., _ _ . , _ _ _ ,_

“-01 petitioli to ilicoipiilnil thi (eiltr ti lL lnokill _.1i..piLioli>.. llic county ex

the election. ’l`hcn new roucig iipeiii-ll and olrl our-5 i-iipiiiimi

""0" °"°"° been 111111111 '-0 negotiate dividing “"1 111P11°¥- The D001 indrm- lic and never iinte ed itil 1

n w more p ea- -tho Government 'I Iby Messrs Amo f . _ .. _ _ _ _ _ _ . .

‘ 'nall|t, Mth. _ .___ V . __ . .

_ _ ii inson Litduilil Hall. A bill flrr this oliiclt lill-il.lon.~. lia.li.- ii, igooll thing, but Lili..

the Provincial Debentures and with ary ut Falconwood was a great all

- ' to speakers pcrformln that l' '

Ce in our cure for the-paor 'iihelgure g Poceeding, he referred to the In Culnmlskly Prowse 1 w Lg -

_ _ . _ u;_y_ He complimented the Speaker m_______.y new mmm ted __ _ _ _ | - -_ . __ uni ya _ \\'it.~a llri.i‘oillll-ed. in-.-ll

' e an °“ "'"°h' Mn' WWW" 010111111* “P 111° 1111--l~' Mil itle-1.1-:AN re.-uuied ine .i.»i»»r.- was

son 0 the telephone was the oi, his

- promotion and expressed full hc thought thc G - - _

overmnent entitled hlon of farm students sent io Truro oil. thi- iiiiiirpe., 4., U, mi, i.‘i.,i,,.i-_. u-,iii

what result and at what cost? Had Va” any odors been received by the Gov- en

fi.-i‘_u1-il .lil lhi: tion-iciiiiii-_;ii_ \-_i,,(_~_»_ eiitlilod to no i.-redit. 'i`lie some 1»‘.£l`ii".llflll'.-li c-lliluitluii. We si-n_i

` TUESDAY use gl-lieu tam' and Welcamed his B116- deoate on the address He would not settlement Oth P

_ . er rovinces were in-| Hon. Mr Cummlekey said that they nel built Iie still hoped the Preniier He hoped thc iniirlliary had _,c__

en

ernment for the purchase of dellen mme dimdillt here than in otha* Pro

' ` tidence in hill ca acit d fit -‘ - - tures and what were we prices cnet vinces becaugg we have no cmmtyicun - D Y an ness to credit. We had not man oor L t H N ‘ - ' ‘ ~ .

_ _ _‘Or his present high position, AS to we s_____ had ___Ume not Y_P . ll O . MR. RILHARl)S silid £1 state' Awilirll if flip (iii w (- .. . - ii il f . ._ .. .

_ provided f0r_ menu is being p__e_m___ed ________ . _ .it ii._ rolirnlniill 1;. _ 1.1 1; rlililclli iii _ii-______ be ___ ____ O __

` ' ' H in du ll:-i ilirztlcc-_ wily iii-elf iii-rluliilll-.~¢ til-_-5' fol1lil_~i1y luii A

ed 1 what price did the Governruen muuicipalitice Rural telephones ,,,,,i__

he attitude of the leader af the Op- not adapted tn the poorhryus

tnei MR ii/lcooNAi.o A 1 un c 1 , ,

1 ‘ -nrtiill flir-

t e

ask? most desirable and he hinted at in- ' B '

Dositfon he- held it to be one of faiult- asylum or the hos ' ' ( - - ~) UIQ I' il wc se -ure til cf » - ‘

pit l_ Th l _ _ _ _ . 1 li, rl ii if _

B BSB lad to for information and papers about the other i"ovini-_ou T Nova .141-..ip__ .

EMI cor ti _

PR ER HASZARD' sam the ps? ‘;\l:B(lyt(x7`l>ll~xliIll11;ll:rl:1‘allM'l‘i1?:ve'ill1;frnd-lnlldillz and _“Blair criticism from be' be cared 1°’ i" .‘P1°iV11t¢ houses Some Thom sou R l I t 1 ‘ - I ml: M

he spoke of the o___ec__Ons t__e__e_ i_1_i_1;i_n§c._r’1;i1i;1u_;s__;l_l;i_ts__tthc time_ nor of them had incurable diseases: Somei H01? MR °f,i‘li'i,ilvl)1‘;lg;]i!gi",;1olb1i1' the llle int,"-_._ _bare liitthu _iiollnlir-_~i it-ull liil H. It had given the Island a bwd (hum ion 0 our plgge ought to be provided for thee ,____'m_ -___ _ _ is coli eil or mu ers li ri-liliiili 11

_ _ ___ The hay c_____,__B and the H_______ ____ the _“ture but _D th ei ma on would be supplied. they are. He hop.-ii wc ailouirl

dun] _ _ _ . . ii..

1 ’ 9 mea el MR- MCDONALD asked for similar have to walt. We have otlii-r rluin.

- tl ld 11111 1:::..:";.‘;i.i ...°.:.::::'.:.'_°“ --= Mn. MA'rH.1EsoN inquired. ol the t°'

if 1-:\`iV;_\`l_\~-;; siissiois.

lin loii/‘i-i' 1-_\li>.¢._

tl 1»'1'lo<'k Ili- llouoo ii.1_i._,__.-

lil illit-

Comm-issioner of Public Works if an name' we want' the g°°d will °' the boro brid e claims h d b ttled 1 ' -

ublic man _ 7 travellers. Pubic accounts were brief- g ` a een se ` ith” 99°’ ““d ‘he 111811118 have better i i ti I ‘ ' ' - . - " V » . . _ leading frog Pgalsggrgdggngrllg mad ly touched upon' permanent bridges _‘mf _;"°110Y__irl1proper1y taiwn. from ____ p__ov____on made for them than ever “puog-_§n¢:he0r:__o:_i_,;_,_l;i_D;_;1__rdi_ga_i;l__ol;;di._o, which ou.';llt to have been .s-1»i_ill»\i _5_l_1<- Nl' l\l.\.'\.fi\ ri-sunicli ti.

E0 to nd lar een re lllned. Two years interest bofoi-e_ is” _ P 0 Se 0_1:-ni: ago. lie lilscussr--l the 1_i-1tu_:i»i.i- 'I""‘h' ‘ll "“`f‘1'115 our rliiiilirl for 1,;-,_

' .tation iuestion at lcnirth, 1ii~i:uilii_ '11 and -b-_-_-tin-l- 1i`ri.l.\iorl,,.ii,.___ .____

Southport between the lst day oi I1

January, 1908 and 31s-t day of D, mDl'0ve'ments to our road sysfbm- correspondence ten months interest ~

-th P - i

hich had been well min-,,i_ain¢d_ ple was __ep______ as the p__0____e dm not v_;_en1_‘;m_:_1;_B_pto§i;yoi__tl;1;_e81;¢;1:t _;:on_- _ors books and receipts for Lots 13 point on the island as tliorl-is at 1"'-'

” °““ “nd 14- 11>ictou and Point du <'.lit~nc_ lic dui T-_-i-;1_-_inul io 1.u._t inc .~;..i..r.._¢@,,.,,,,,

cember, 1908. If so _ how much mono ‘W

Y

was expended to whom was the same °10°°d with 11 P1011 that 110 time 0*? possess the full use of the bridge and the desir

~ ~ 1-iblllt f th .

was y n e Govern | HON. Mn. RICHARDS said null re-‘not think the sourin or vi-ruon im..

concrete culverts were important h d be ded t d __

ii t ii t 1 ~ . PP Y .

u an uc B B rs u 8 ter Coming tu the telephone exwnsionl MR DOBIE asked for ta* °0\l‘~‘Cf--Itlisi. tlic-llc slmlild he il iliraiiwbiitilik' U'Uwr""“`"1 l‘=1l'fy had in .~-l-<1 iii.; it

i-ll\_l`!. i-iiviiiwi ui llio.1igre_ 'iii J.

` " H“ll"'~`11)' ‘~\'1ll.l Lili- i'ts.1lf. tlliii.

paid and when. When was the work Mted' The Province got all and perhapsment further assisting the w ir E _

01' - X"- r t e iv ‘ ' ~ p i ttcrs of cun'ratlil.i- 111' \\'=i>'/ ioniinlio-l ill oilivc :uid hi_.i

let 'I When was it done? Was it let

work? By whom was it let? Is my amount due thereon? To whom and an how much in each case ? Also to lay ti

ports, returns, contracts, letters s/nd

papers in respect to said work. °_g

R. LAIRD seconded the motion more than it W ~ t

_ _ . as _mtitied “__ Th h. _ urns we o no yet r ce sd. B d

by D1_;b%1___ competition or how other- ;l_f;_‘:H1_i_;_gofDi;rheDDear:_e ar_i_ddDl_;1sDerity Ottawa Government had shown s dis? i{l¢l)il11i;.]tl1sf<l:erl,;al~a§t;ii~cl1dn!:>liow°;‘£‘01`i1 MR, DOBIE inquired about the'¢_i;ln_ui-1;vcp:0¢;;g,, U, ¢,,,,,.,i_,;L ___,____ salary im-=.._ _.mi i-___._____i ____ _,______ wid at was the nature of the ' ° 'mg as 3 ee" P0' position to be fair and this f ve‘ ° rf* inadequacy of thc Grand River Ferry th- r ` d x't ' 111" V I V ' M _

pular with the people" Major Hooper ho e _or our ___ _ _- he fair, but the county exhibitions had, HON Mn CU-VIMISK ‘ ~ ' L I' “pw” C msmn ° the t"l"` .'

’ her mabcers. ii iv ked . - 1 EY ddlllltted pllone and the nipeal of thc travel- -*1""1~»

excellent omcer. It was a genera- Thi; uesuou Tn; mrror' 1 . 5 ° n mar g'°'WU1 111111 imi7l`0V¢- the fir . ' _

- , fou in- 1, rl h d ' - - . e ry was not “E B°°d aSl1°WUU1d lers’ tax and next took lil tho <-lcr-- llllbu

gpuoe gh ii ii d. _ q 0 e mme 111911 . an a abundantly iustifleo ' . - -_ _ _ ' I ._ _

° “ "Y “W” ‘“`°°" stance. was o cneetion ol prncticahi~_tkemueiveo. 1-ie i,-elieved the Agricul- 22%. bill”nl,§;(tri»elIfd`§ride?;dm?,\t“ret'E U0" 111 Bedvuun- _The Oni-Us-o--n lcir. 1--“ret 1--_lg-_-1--1--.; ~n-...- ir _cui--_

5 9 Y 50 they had been un]uh'tly depriivi-il of MW li-X-\l'l` br mi '..il_!l it i;i’.-t--if-fill

\\':ili_iiol1i-_ \\r; limi Um-,_. ii _i__i0___ii_i

l<..l'lli_ It \\'il:1iiliowcrl to riiii li- .'i mill. _»'t.-if.il_ii|_ ;iii.i 1_,¢,~(_ and

transportation service and the need thin

g was to have a proper survey- would et d '

more branch raflw _ A d - Y ° a 57°” WGN* 111 P110- V n - . _ _

ails ozen_n0ta bogus one as had been made_ moting the we_____re of this sp_en___d lw;:Rt~ai\_1I;I_§i|_1;_§i_-_§_inc__Y_irs_;ic;_vhaiil aei_1011 some length the circumstances under iii sonic. 11:11-_...eil-iii by r.»1t~i1lli»: it

0 P69900 U11! which Hon Josleph lleild was de<~liil‘o:1 11011'-*li-if-ci' r in-lit iii ni l1.ei-ling at

HON- MR~ CUMMISKEY-A state- B eamgm °°“1d not keep “P °°“ti““`|If it wan to cost tens or-hundreds of provinge of om-,i_ 1 _ _ _

`°y9'"` nshm"e“~ - »elul:te<l_ It was getting in by the Mi-roll :lt uliiill .\li'_ lox now 1;.,

ment Will be prepared and laid on °“B the table. It will take considerable'

work. F2"

c

nel 'Lobe the only solution. _l.eae.maKnit__de such as had not _

. . yet aide and/ commended their silence.-

it

MR. MA'rl-1IEsoN oeked the com-1 .°""’) W” “V” “Y "“'"““g7 thelbéen undertaken. The bnrinsn mad-> 'roo often they talked ad nianseam

missioner of Publ c Works to lay on

farms feed the citieis and towns. The by Ml. Palmer were not Bumcwnm He pr ceeded __ __ t

` ' 0 0P11ya rbuetotbe

communication. How to remedy minions it would ___ b, bl

it we do not kn .but n fit til ' ~ ”° '“ '°”5°”“ " HON- JOSEPH “EAD f¢"1d111'd .' 'f _ -

ow e e e t0 9111903 lt- It WBB 8 W01'k Of Very iippm im one rising on the OppO__i_L__;__ M_R' HAELARD An HUBW91' back door, and if ho had us iiilich 0111111110111 lil I-lo il--i1.l_v_ lm-l ziiomii ;,

wi. me plepaled. honest as he had 1isrllll‘i1n<-.e he l‘l-si-l_llti~.ll to the ellie-1 iii.-,L i_ii._._

MR' AHSENAULT asked nl’0“t the would-y take himself out thc ~:‘inic me-‘fins lv --1 n f 1--iiiplitiil Li \i1li 4

.. _ 1. - s if-.' '-4.

mud "Um Urbamvule '50 M0113” CBT' way :lil oiiini- ll 1 ii ihi- .iii only :im ii,"

- V _~ .. ‘- 1 _

1 \ l

mel' l MR. AGNEW followed, disclissilii; (Mr. f`<-x .I ilii--1 t.=:ll. 1.11:; hiol ..1-.-ul'-

on

on the table of the House all re- He spoke also of the “n“uBfa°t'°rV lity and reatonable cost. The first Lurai Depargmenei had done and _

G°"°r“m°“t~ lone of their men. Hediscllsst-<1 iii, coliiiiliml-nt lo ilu- _-iii--elif-r. lb- cront-

se

the table of the House a. statclnent of all moneys expended by Wm. Lav-

pre

EPB. Road Inspector on public roadsf °“ or other public works between the yea 30t-h day of Hep embsr. and the 31st day of December, 1908. Pm Were the said moneys expended by “.1” public competition or h'ow otherwise? mon State how much of the said money trod _has been pn d, when and to whom re- ‘md speccively. Are any and what amounts mf still owinig in respect to such work ‘Cin and to whom respect vsly~. When was (ul the work done in each case‘? Also all “"1 reports, returns, letters, correspon- yea dence between the said Inspector and ph” the Commissioner oi Public Works `or tn"

_ _ ____

“me answer as to the previous ques' said. He agreed with what had been

nt Government created the De-

_partment ____ Ag_____u___t____e w_____h ___ad_;l;1:_ia_t;ec;i1_::_ebo;`i_i;g)s_gf_;>r _<;<;_a__lO_;i;1td_ 3_1; into Speaker Douglas. A Toronto d e great good in the past eight 'che necessity of further inlformattl ‘paper hed quoted-a statement of the

_.___ Proceeding be spoke of we _Ie had talked mth man eu __ 011- Opposltionnleaders idea of our claims

__ A D 1908 sheep industry which had -been _“__ _who a__ 8 reed th t th Y___m511;€1_31‘S at about S.-§.ll00,000. This was reduc-

~ - ved_ B0 that our sheep take prizes iW0___d be var re :H fa 1_1 C211 IES lug; our position to absurdity. l-io

ond. He e/nloglsed the Comimis- ‘Government goildah' ethe “we L ° ,C°“t°”ded fhat _0‘1_1` 1lSh_01`Y _C16-11111 isa el. of Public wm.kB_ who had “__ 5 _urve ade d Bstveth 0 11055591113' [good one. l‘he iurisdictlon is divided, uced road machines. steel bridges |_”____s__ ye ni ah 8 ma er at “.5 _f_;h‘f_1';’_“ bf meh pnvg _?°““°il deci- concrete culverts that would lasti` ' _ ‘"0 ' e ,oses °"° S "Wil 11910118 ases-. With the horns shovel wel _Corning to the matter M the pllce tu the Provmcesf and U19 11W111`11

turn the- hills into hollows. 0 £0 8.6¢; he dmmted the PHC” shuuld 5° to"-hem- The 11011113-109 P11111

ears) He eniogised Prem er H.as,__ ‘_i.}l°__°d _IDN OSVB 350213- 501110 SP11'Cial _thc fishermen are not the interest on who had done well during his m 3 so ~ _ ~ D0 11 068 might com- _ the award_ The _Dominion would Proh- r of Power. The Door. the tele- 5‘_:n__o_t ce? E per buihil' Infany case-lnuly pay Downes as. they “ow do- ne extension the repeal of the Island” Old rgnspx 3 103 mm th‘;i‘f th? “Ward was _Pala OV" 710 thu* ellen. tax an received attention d______an_ceW<;1;__ gain; ii) ;‘;_1;S0 _sail rovinccs. The claim for damageow-

any officer of his Department in rc- ;lnM‘;V_all`I___'_’_‘;gf§‘_1El§_;`;;’ds'__u“ __ t___a______ straits. We all agree tliat the cost il-i

‘ g H ` too great T-he straitswould always

spect to such work. ' _ _

HON MR- CUMMTSKEY. gave the moggi “;g__e_;1e°0_‘:_'_1€_§ !‘;_f___!°_§]et;_;l__ be there and involved extra cost. He

' tl t th Provincial

denied, however ia e

1-1011- Government was responsible for this.

MR. MCLEAN asked the Commis- saidthm 13:' Douglass’ “go lfoughf to As to sending our young- farmer-S

sioner of Public Works was the Bridge Fair _art g1_l;;'____;’::_d_v8__I_’°V___._§e(°i _ug ali? to Truro, he felt it was a. high privi-

le e to be lililc to do no uf. liiodorati-i

ing to the non fulfilment of the terms of union' is_a very difficult one. One element is that wc have to throw our products on the market in the fall of the year. In this and other ways the amount cannot be computed, The interruption of cable service was like

HON~ MR- CUMMISKEY Said thi! our claims. The trouble is wc lil-o rcd.i Mi; \\\:iit. _--1.-iiil thi- ii..m,i»-,-,i,.

° would be 0 911011 U fillmd f-U 119 united s we should be If liniiid lil'-iiilirl' ii--ii -ii-iiiii-iiili' ll -1 hi- ,,i,.

r ad P ' ` not af ‘. ._ _~ ._ _._ __ in the pllbuc interest- “nd `\"“ i“f"1" wi- could not lie turncil clown. our iii~»l'v ill--ilu luiih l-rl iii.»<l1-ep matifm asked 1"" W0“l'-I '10 S“l’l"`-"*l~ tl'unspi-rtatiolii must be iiriiirovcd. Wo 1l.,ilii_llii~li .\.f|<-i- .ii .~ nl. iii-Y ii..~

HON' JOB' HEAD """"""“‘l~ i-ll" "‘l‘ ilf-1-iivii thi- 'l‘unni-l Proceellini; hc- li il in *iii 1- ll l ll A

_ _ _ _ . - . V 1' . 1.1:-2;-... 1-_ iii uliii-li liiiii-ii.;

liqbllrllltglg ‘lli'Iell)‘liLi?'il)c[1llttllitatulltlrdfklrsllvl1~1Il¥? rhmflght' un.d‘.`r. l'c`Vmw the school ul lmlml Mr- \\.\`11'i riliiii- lil llio 'l`:llinr'-l. to make thc llcoplc <l`il~i’ciillti-iitcil ill; hm.n’ féxmbvmons ml1ld tht; “md mr Iihl “’_"‘ ""Vl""”"‘l “‘ “"4 th” l"`*"1"11‘1` the opllosltion sought to do and pclmmllel Bod ll ‘do alr` 0i'r0u‘d- nfm. ."HU\H_H`x: CM \"m'T '"1 Um “rm-“`"‘ quoted from the icfrufederwtion iloilnt- nc( v-mb “pen e m Us Umrkt M A-H`|.1l‘mm :ls ml' "l]"l"l“`l" "I UW es to show that __________t _uxmion was political purposes. He approved of I-1-\l-iiiiiiviii. _if 1ii_r.i\\-in 11,. ,.__,.d Hi, than co__temp__1te__ He __e___w____ the the vxllorlllion of the _telephone riyi- lhiiiiglil.-l l'_.-1-' ri-i-...f ,ii,,| giii. _,mir Agricultural Department had door i lem “Didoc0n9l3dmt“vlll) some um- llimminf I l I ll Mm" "ui 1” lm’ ""1""

_ 1 cisin li piiiuil lon nc_lci~i. ll-. 'l‘l-i:;i1-i- ,~h 1111.1 ri- i-P..-nt -,___

t tl Cl, .'lll_l.t - ~ .. ,. ‘. '_ éiilnsltiniirdll-Ei`l'l>llicrOfo€‘ol)1i»' I\)\l_<i‘iIl`ie(1\llile itll? _MR1 1`_1c1.)(1)NALD (A` JR) fouovwd .mlm-l ',l" 'U ulmlm' mlm' “"1 resent C0mm___s_On»e__ ___ ____ ___-___ speaking, til recess. \\i.i ._ 1.1- :ll-ir--1-.i _-,L i,.,,.Viii UN. wi gunlidcallions He ful"lliLci‘ illlscll-islill AFTERNOON SESSION- -“nt” (ig UU`_'|" ‘V 'xl “Wim "VH" ‘V "ll the telephone scrvY<'l thi- tril\'.l-firm At 430 o'clock Mr McDo-nllld rc- mu uf 1.1"' t‘”l“`1`i' 1411111- llv ff-' --~.l---1 tax and the triinsiioltation lille-stiull_ sliineri the adjoulzn-:ll debate. infer- .\iHS"l‘m`UH H"`w.ll' Hd" "M" l-Iehbcliaved if thc Steam Naviuation-rlliV~ to the fact that maui’ llecii -lla _l“_""' "ml "1 'Nfl mf" 1”' ‘ "` "` iompmiy wwe pi-Opp;-ly iip|,\~,`ia(-_ii@,i'w1~_rl\. hel`d_ throughout fllzlvrif-t null __i_H___l_:_`:_ ___‘_’_“_ bel’ Wolllid see that the 'l`linliel wuulil `_1111111)f (-'0_V€1`1111'19'1ltS ‘VT-"3 f"1>"-11»111"l- f,__:__ ]___,_i ,__ __ ___ _____.__,_,__ ___‘_`_'____ '

e to their advantage Fivo iliollsillid DHL 111 3115 1’1`0V‘11~'*"- U10” “'11” 01; gin. ,,w_~,.-,i_ ii.. _,.ii,.,i_ _i f,.., _.i ._

at Souri-s West constructed under who' k___e'w mm He hoped their ____c g ' _ 5.

contract? 11 no who wee th - ' .` t. N B 'ck 1 _ . “lift I _ _ nrniiice and tie r n - - - 1 _ ..

c con _ _ _ cos cw runswi n so sent stu 1`he cons ltutlon of Canada is an- _or a n__mi,qi~ of years would lnoko' _the free and independent voters ____ _________ ___ ____._____ ___.___ ________ _

_ ’ ht be equally success u in

tractor? If built by day's work cesbors mig dents there. It would cost too inucll _ who was the Inspector ? Who were s';°‘;;_m'gHthe_ apgmval °! boltgmfgdei for us to establish and maintain an ;?7_;);lt"lf]dwal;§uIid_§tyd “is 3_pp1é°d‘ to increased business _for the stoanl_ers.11r1 0Pl11'1S1f-1011. Char ottet-i\\ii 1.1- _,___ ________ _____, ________ ______ __.» _ __ ,__Q _

io e ouse s leo our ca n _mu good __c__0___ here ,I,o_________g _ di; _hs ugh. n me ___f_;_a_§_1;_s He brought under r¢;vi_.-_“_ _the 3_m¥i.mi;1_r_Jti c§n_stituen_c_y; iill_§i_d_x__t~_.ls oi ___________ _____ _________ ____________r ____ -_

) anne un” c e ec O S Bing un 0 D i`-f.i'i'll fri-iii ii‘l'i"1 1- il 1 <

employed on the work ? At what rate _` _ eq y _ V ~

igainst the Dominion what had been _ Rhode Isa as s sa e 'n V -

f wa es 'I How much was paid to ’ . ~ Itlie Vernon River bridge a mistake . . T11‘11`11@l- the P10180 0

1 did “W1 ' Of 59111100111 HS New Yufk Of P¢1111‘SY1- Mi The only di-irici-ity wnuiri be fromltile Dominion Government We do not

‘ '. fi.-liiiii "1-ll--1 io iw .i` 1-] -'H

i lt hila ()tt.t\\ i

0 K

. . settled? The hay calm _ _ _ _

fic:tggrxswgfg?1;?:;x__;s:_{0:_;dw:_?:_;lamount to much, if ehlit was all. _$131__l;e;n__§;_‘:d_f____‘ih:__";_d1inB't'°’; m_:’_et_; vania._ Our constitution-. makes no water wmmz in_ He had _._ ietiefimve provincial rg; 9 w _ - ~; _ _ __ _ _ _

- .What about our great- clalluii 'I The- =‘ .”“ 5 e 59° W ‘C provision for the protection of pro- 'S- D I F ._ t- th img this control 1119 held that tilt- M H” 'l"" “f ~“‘- ‘ 11" "

prices were pmd for each class 0' `I-Iolise is yet in the ditrk. The Oppo- he and Mr' Cummlskey.°'ttend°d' The vinciul rights. The unit of represen~ from U iolig as Oi: B H mg Tt subsidy settlement was altogether in- HH' H"""" “""" i“' "" ' "0"" ` material' what was the total c°st?lsition had joined with the Govern-fiend” of tha Opposition was there' U1*-1011 15 0110 S1Xl¢Y‘5ff1h Of the P0P11~ any 'ltmub 6 m)rll‘l tsm Source-lcolld ndoliliate but considered the f'lsllcl‘y N!'.“v1]i‘\m" in ""' "` "`l1"1‘ . Also to lay on the table ofthe House ment to Press our clai S, but nlotb-land _When the matter Wm’ threshed lation of Quebec under which Drovi- madly be met' le Lwcmdnm Oth; bounties’ while liuito unfairly dfstrr V"“l"'-"» \\'~"'<- i-.---1--’ 'IV' " if .

au reports' and returns and cones' ing was done. Last session a com- ‘out the people were satisfied' The sion we may cease to have any repre- er Tunnel; well; dgeptllr “SP ll” wa er liutell wliro given in lieu df the inter- *"`""" "i'f<-l'-1--l i.. .-1 .ii--.\-_

pondwnce relating to thiswwol-k' lmittec was Hppointed to Prepare our Governmenm corrected the mistake' sentation in the Commons at all. than Ours- Wou be' t 6" Y “ey and est on the award The bounties nli 'lit Mlm D"H‘l`: A 3"’ V-"`° -11

' The c “tract was not let to the 1°W` ' dl ' - _ We rc M.a-mm mines are matny tlmeiietilis bc continued if thc award were ditviil- 'U |`"" “' 1"" l"~` """ fi- -

_ olvts .t iillliii-ii 1' lilrs. i `

HON. MR. CUMMISKEY-thc same . _ _ o

__ ve claims, which were enumeiate<.‘_. What est ___mde__er_ because the ____nd____e__ at Quebec is rapi y' growing a_ _ijousands of fee Oompa _ _

3° “mt of 1051115 0111' l`€D1`@5€171t9-t10U- Quebec 15 150 the depth of 'the Islandi ’f`umie\ cd hut. as we get only a simall shuic ____ _ ____ _ _ _ 'vu .il.._

- _ _ ___ _pt but 1 ii ii_,.`l- .llsf if r

answer as a o .

. is the amount claimed on a l

I ll ot 8 higher azure was more competent being enlarged' NOW is the time M’ Welshould urge the moral obligation_l<>f U10 l1011htid-S. WL H111-<1 1.. __ ______ S __ ___ __ _ _ _

' tn. -le ‘ -‘ "ii"-`~ --

MR. ARSENAULT asked the (om-

.if_e_i11 _iiiézt thgdloas cannot be accur- men _mg__gc_i in u,e'__,'_,rk with -rhiiiriiiimost equal division of |_\_ic__ii-1.1 ________________________ _______ _ __ __ _ __ ______

I el ttil lnlluetl'llo'vOtr Ho helieveda. large mliioiityoi .________ _____________ ___________ _‘____ _ ____

winter communication, the fai ure and wo___d p__Dbab_y complete _,he

asked our clam' to our farmer repro' the treaty obligation arid* the finun illtue of the aW”'°‘1~ A5 to " m‘“ 1 ,mn -ii___ ._.________' __ __ ___

missioner of Public Works to lay on-

. the telegraph cable, the fishery a- _ _ _ -

the table a statement in respect to . work in time. A teniporar lirld e - f - ' . »

- _ _ wi-rd? 'lhese Should have been Dre- _ Y g entntlon in-fore the next ccusun re- - _ - -ti -. _tt Lett - 1 ~ t ti- - _ - -~ »-

H ldlmand Buds” showing' Wham" - 1 r forcible, terms. had to be Put “p_ L0 Prevent tramc duces us to three members of the gxzsgbgguséggl gile\‘l(i;l»lallli(llal,i!d‘<;e tillrli c\l'imcflc§t‘i<ill?KTlislipllh; 0i,~,._l;_ The third siiniillel- c..u.~i ui.: :V -

n ' ~ l ' ~ " t _f. votes imil' filo iwliills pl“"" "f UH' 'I` I1-ffl \'»`f- it.-cw o _'_

11

ted in cea

tho contract was let by public com- Hen. ' __ _ being stopped. This was one of the

__e____t_on or how 0__he__w_Se_ H by tem |C_lairns on account of the vals expteai ex__l_a___ The work when taken on the onimons. Proceeding Mr. Read pmciation on B m_i|_.o__ d._)iim.S w0__i__i;ii,,iii u_i_¢- _ _ _ ___ _______ ____ _ _ __

idituie on railways and cana s on e cm_t__ac__os_s hands was be____v°d to _be touched upon the difficulties of mar- of winter steamem _md the _oss O__w___.e sp___i0__i_ H0 ___v____._._i me _u_i_,.__ ____________ _;i __ _i_>lll__1 1 _ 1. it. _

_ k t Our mduce to advaniugel 0 1' tin Fic steanlcr:i."‘“-"' “"t°n”“’n Ur um uxlcphnnc lui-ni. tohiliyc-Hf'~_lil'Ll’1llllfllildlflll o

der, how many tenders were received., _ _ ___ ____ u_____t_O___ed also ___ re from whom and for what amount r=~`"‘“ " R" we i _.1 i’ _ _,___ all right, out tue front nhowed later E "lg D . $100.00 011 Ove 11 H , _ _ -1 1-- ”°“U°“" °' the “id w°'k 'md an r°`|c1nvrue were to be preps-red Wi1=11°\1'¢ '“ix°d‘ Th” was mad” g°°d by the and are destroyed hy freezing. H0 nn- ii) d V ',, L ii, 5" ti -tire iirovince. New it in to or-_ ahoiiol-

,. _ __ contractors at ii ¢_-,ogg of $300 or $g00_ _ _J _ wnuf earn an sa e mt c _ a_n ie _ _ __ _ _

o , . urged upon t e importance and ne in t SL It woiim donnie tii_,_ci\. Lust year vie welt tolll it lu-ulil

1 ' . _ ` _ _

ports, letters and correspondence in respect to the same. Was any and C what amount paid for extras ? Was P the work performed according to 2

HON. MR. CUMMISKEY-Would be _

l too happy to supply the infor- mation but the inqu ry was _

t o outside the Pwvmee

/

st but one man was P1111 $259 0- ' inim 1-ind tneee and The 11111111111 P'°P“'°‘1 “€“i“"1* 111° ceeity for the 'rnnne1_With that S

reparlng one c ____ __ __ A __

ther claims been is v ce s o iwork completed we would have the » -

ricultlire we *-r_';~_-:_-_-.___-_1 same advantages as Nova Senna and _which would be worth a million and.

in ___ D? he prosperity of our ag _ ,

spec ca 0 B0*-' 16119 thai half U10 Pri” Which the [New Brunswick. We can- produce sixty se

f Nova 300511- I`00f11V°d f°1` ‘ imilliou bushels of potatoes as easy A

rs o

°" y pllstelliltfloes. This could not be satisfac- V. '§'.j,.,- -. las we now grow six millions, if’ we i __ i “°° dw ory. 11-nd Wduld new' 11° 1°__1;1°‘11°=‘_1_1 had the market which the 'runneiwi1lVf_e lim M Krmiou ked tn o nnnile- “H W” get emchmt tmnsporta aiu at =__~fJ§'-..'.--_.- ' f 0*" 11”- _ he

' ° as ° ° fair rates. Our y0’l111g men' Oug _"0 _'._-‘-.‘._‘._L\\té He was sorry to find the Pppositlon tr

. ""'=’=‘ 'L_-‘~'-`* T ‘- still "chewing hay." He never hand-

sioner of Public Works to lay on the to have 0 g _ ______ __ _ __ _ _

table all petitions and correspondswcolto complete their agricultur;ai_e§_l;c_i;- ~ _ __ ___ __0__ar ___ the _my mO__ey_ 0___

1 er 0 g ' `“‘5‘“- 7”” Dt' B d°u“" 01 lt' He. had “°°’in°_ed vlonsspeakefr, said' the latter iHon._¢,, Him in-ierring to the lute Siicukci-

re nurvey between Lots 61 and- 55). “om The Commieg on _ _`__

ffl 8 8153*? ` is busineis- interests in that matter J0s_ Read) evidently thmlght this __

HON. MR. CUM'MISKEY--the same tum could make his 0 cg _.__ _ _ _ ________

""‘ tii nil ood. He felt that ne

t 1 u“m_m the pam' ' 6 A " tor 8 pu ° 3 about t'bo last chance of addressing

teros on co _ __ ___ __ _ _ land S pwuiiitiqn in Eve year” bc retained H1- was g ri t 1 _,owin-

lnicnt had sccn the error of tlicir \\‘l\Ys

l tter He discllssetl otlirr

- ~ V' tii' ina _ - .

half to the Dominion. It woulii_1“ 1° __ _ ___ T__m____ ___________

fu

rve New Brunswick, Nova Scotiaitwicl* l“°l“‘m‘l~ 8 ' '_ '

mi the whom 0( Unniidm W0 had ,iiwlls _no otlicr means _l-y_wl1ir_h__ tlil; ght to press for _,_ sm~V0y_ wiii-oi, iiefDoniillioii_ c:ili1_ fulfil its ¢.ontr_.ir _ iieved would lead tn me 'punm-i they dont liullll it wc_1illi.~.f. iii__i ii-ig biii1¢_ It would (imibic ami_e1|l1_ivillt‘nt. _'lilo (rovcliiniult .~.il-111

lu f ever acrs of our-111*`1*i U" UH"-

eble the vn e o y - - rm lands. » iiill. cox reid tile dl-irate iuui t..k<-u MTL MCLEAN. 1`f‘f01'1`111f-I UT U10 DW' much time, Lili. he had ii few wol'il.~i

g hoped be is now in better volii

han when lo was lil-rv

fmswer “B mst ab°v°' success or a 51°” 5 -' f=:.=.;=:.. ~. _

f 11 9 The Ex' 0 if 6 '”’*=‘5’5~- was doirll; B- Publi” d\ltY~ He lwped the House. The Premier sin-cl Mr- wllliiflhteri He had heliril iliiicli 'of

Mn. ivlA'rH=Iias0N for Mr- Wyatt it nad been cnleily e nr _ -_ _ ..._,__.._

101111111511 in ‘ to see double the entries at the R

asked the Comm ssione'I of Agricul- per entai Fai-m was p _ _ _ 5*,

~ ‘ ’ " 'Prince County exhibition this year

ture to lay on the taule li- return of 1907 and ig0g_ Why iigghinig about it _ _ .;§.___ _ - _ _ __

lt s well for members 0119101 ` »-iff V |'f‘hc seed fairs were of prime imfport- f

Odd did HOU RZTW- B091 911105 S\1U11ld our clainis---it is time we knew whiit ct together' to get H rdusdunl-1@‘tiley ure- worth. it would be wi-li not eight ri-te Ontario fa-rmern get =1 to build on 1-_lainie-cure niiouid in-_

the names of the farmers' sons who now? wa _______ __ _

attended the Short Course 01 Iustruu- ther side that Laurier- had been sun- -~ - _ ._ =nnce. our need oatc nent to Manitoba ' . _ . _ . _ -- -1 ~ -f i§:...::’;

- 11 ' /*£1 ` / _ - _ _ ‘ rudence and judgment were exercised

'i-rum last session. The amount paid __ _,___ been left at home He ag-ree __ _ _ /

| 5 . .= /-,1/z A ._ _ /

iuldent and the meumd °r 'WB' th t this ought to be a uusiness ses- _ ___ 1/ _/ff ur trade in seed grain would become

s _ ' -' _“V

' /1 I

11“1d°“t5 basis of fair play. Le e GP

orought down and full information _ n’clock when the House adjourned 0

' - 'till 3 o'clock tomorrow.

Hou Mn 111o1lAnns-A etetc

ment- Wm be P"°9“"`°d' iven let the public accounts com

n

H se at to work on B / // ery large and Promame' Preniier, however gave us little liopeir

THURSDAY

miles. He ave other instances. The 9

st on both sides in many years. l-lo

s

Government should take this un- Theiiuui not naked lor u dollar ou tin-

position would be only tool glad ii

cforc the election Trilllsiilir

igb. Let both sidcs get toilcthcr

P 11') 11811195- AS F0 U16 T111111€1 the P10111* and have these matters iliiilmvi-ll. A

il'1` Have no hoP0~ Wh0 M0 fn blame? cold lltorage warellollse wits gri-ntly

‘ach _

tem employed in thc' selection of such _ _on Let the 0,, g

_ A _ _ ads b » < » ~

° _ _ t th r "ts he //-W CAPT' ‘EAD °°°"‘““°d tm Bi* that they would' take any action--'Pho tlltiou in inarlcuuutc lrcigiite to..

m

itted get to work it reete with the

2

Government. Let lie have theJerpor'_t

on claims, the report on 0611118 011 11

February I.

MR. PALMER moved the House in-

to committee to consider the draft

address. I-Is spoke of the return of the Liberal party to power at the late elections in the Dominion and ln! tho province. regretted the losses by death and was pleased that some new lilood was infused. which would bring new ideas. He couizrrstulatedthe- Premier and leader oi the 0911091'-l°“ who he hoped would long be spared to hold their present positions. Can- ada had survived the financial storm with little loss. Our own Province hall good good crol1B» He 890118 1151] lngiy or the death ol sneaker D011!-_ lass and' of Maiar HooP91‘- Th°i1'_ placee had been lilled by °111°1°'11t 111111 _ ciipabig mm, He proceeded to speak of the historic celebration at Q11°b¢°~ which was attended by the Prince of Wales, representatives of all parts of tho Empire and other nations. with

h b 1 e shi s ofthe British navy-

t e c o c p

He congratulated the Governn_l_t:n_§

on the claims so far recovered. W1 C were mi; 5 gmail part of what is duc us. The Halifax award should -have _ been eectled long ago. The money 18- in the Canadian treasurY`» W9 Kei' some bounties-a mere trifle. A fell'

morally ours and should be P1110- A Privy Council decision makes the fisheries the property' of the Provin- cer. He hoped-for joint action of

f

d _ The work was frail;

taken od. The land tax was edu-al\Y

D At .6 o'clock the House adjournedi

Iwo - i Before the orders of the day some/

shore of the award is legally 11114 conversation took place with rezerd 4

tn answering inquiries of the minis- try before the address is passed, the

_Premier contending that the psaeticc

once. As to public works what was_ he clasil of work done on Vernon. River Bri ge the ex1trs,s paid the contractors and added to the debt was the only per- manent thing about it. The loud hllr- rah over the travellers’ tax is follow- V ed by another hurrah when the tax is 1

unwarrantabie. George Brown. C01- Gray, Laurier himself, were all com- _ mitted to the principle that the Pro- - vinces should receive sufficient reven- -V ue witbour direct taxatiofa. Money] was expended by wholesale ofa t‘ie| roads just before election to buy‘ votes. In conclusion he urged that the business of the House should bo

ressed forward

till 3 tomorrow afternoon.

WEDNESDAY

February 9. ‘

The House opened at 3.45 o'cloclr. ._

Mr. McDovnal»d‘ Councillor elect for 'the i Cardigan district was introduced by Mr. Matliieson- and Mr. Morson. WMV

rn and took his seat

was not to supply the information

Pinkhir.m’s Vegetable Compound

ved hen life. Mme. Emma Chatel,_ Valleyfleld,

Belleriver, Quebec, writes to Mrs. Ptukham:

“I want to tell you that without

Lydia E. Pinkham'a Vegetable Com- pound, I would not be alive. For months I suffered with painful and irregular periods and inflammation of the feminine organs. Doctors could -do nothing for me, and said I must sub- zmit to an operation as I had A tumor. 'One of my cousins advised me to italic Lydia E. Plnl|ham’| Vegetable

Oomiponnd as it had cared her.

“ did so and now I have no pain

and am entirely cured. Your remedy ls deserving of great poise.” FACTS FUR SICK WOMEN.

For thirty gears Lydia E. Pink.

ham’s Vegeta le Comgolmd, made from roots and herbs, as been the .standard remedy for female ills :and has positively cured thousands of *women who have been troubled with

tlispliwementc, inflammation,__l_1lcem- tion, flbroid tumors, ine_$u rities, periodic pains, backache, at bear- ing-down feelmg, flatulericydndiqes- tion, dizziness or nervous prostrat on VV___l?'don’t you try lt?

rs. Piifklmm Invites all sich

women to write bel' for advice.

sho ha|Af5llldsd thousands to health. dress, Lynn, Mau.

This woman says that Lydlil E.

” .

February 10.

The Speaker took the chair at 4.10

'signed by Meeere Agnew, A. J. ivlc- Donald, (2) Haszard, (2) Mc'Nei)L, 'McLean, Doble (3), Alueaaalit (2). | Mr. Matheson called attention to the questions on the order paper and asked whether the Premier adhered ho his decision of yesterday not to an- swer questions till the address- is passed 7

Pnemier Hlnizard said this had been

the almost lnvariable practice and was due in courtesy to the Governor. - Mr. Mathleson said that this was 'mfsleadlng. Why did the Speaker lcall for "questions" if they could not be answered 'I He quoted from pro- ceedings in the Parliament of Can- ada, and from May and Bouriuot in support of his contention that it is unusual to ask questions before the address 'passed This right had never been disputed before. _ Mr. McLean asked for papers ro- spcctfng the road from Baltic to 'Fafrfleld.

Hon. -Mr. Gummiskey said the fn- ormatlon would be furnished as lllckly as possible. Mr. Arsenauit inquired about Hal-

dfmaad Brfd-ge ln Lot 15. l I-Ion. Mr. Cummiskey said. the _ques-

The Conservative party called in Sl'r_nccdcd at Georgetown for the fresh

Ilnuglaii Fox, who had borings miide ii

th cores sent ho Ottawa Liber io

sh trade. Novli. Scotia hilll :ii lrcttcr lai-is of potatoes, batter sllippilli;

I

' E.rlnbl1'.r/im' 1879

Wilooplng Cough. Crollli. Brolic'iit|s .CougIl. Grip, Astlliila, Diphtlleria

Xen la take lhe rsmadylyllelhe illomcch _

ir cure: lne_auu the ur rendered worlgfy ann _

septic li curled over lbs diseased lurflm will.

br ivlrl mio rl and cuaulult \ml1~|

'c1ck. 'rue rdr uw iii 1“"“_ " ' ` , _ lgncsiries and 0 n:;ticp;l_)e re::ec;_\ive{)y'nls ul powcr hero and at Ottawa forlchancce and got bcttcr prices. “.-

's

' He proceeded to speak of thu l~`i_<lici‘y

award, the Inflrnlary, the tcleplloni- service and the trnvcl\cl'.~i' tux.

huuld have a direct stcllnicr also.

The latter he had always op posed. He thought n. bii; lllunlll-i ind been made in our roprl-sontittioli

i _ _ He wanted to see the Tllnncl. l‘r‘l'-

hapu the new steamer and it better port than Picton nn_the other side might do something. If stcivnicrs can'!. do the work we must insist. on thc Tunnel. He did not think Doniin- ion influence counted for much in elections outside- of Charlottetown. He enlogiaed Premier Hazzard in

Cresolclle ll s boon to Asiiullatlcs ¢ioeiug_

Dc°sil not seen) more efeciive to breathe ii-'le I NON m rked ii _,ni medy lu cure dlseue_of lhe hresthln’ orgvin 1 MR. M`CKI_f_*1t___ refufgal sito gwo Dm,