DECEMBER 18. 1951

jileatli In lirandview

i name of , Grzindviewi

of Miss Mat:Plierson

death occurred at the Mrs. D. A. Gillls in on Monday. December lf)5l. after a lengthy illness of

The

l7 A s. tliivnic. in tier 69th year. Miss MacPherson was the dauglller of the late Catherine and Donald MacPherson formerly nt Cardigan. She leaves to mourn hpr passing three brothers. Archie and Samuel of New Perth and in lvoodland. Maine, U.S.A.

Alex and three sisters. Annie. Mrs. Alex McKay. Cape Breton: Kate.

ll

, John Williams, Provincetown. 31 ; Sadie, Mrs. Malcolm Mac- K01 e, Albcrry Plains.

The funeral will he held Wed- nFStli'l)' afternoon from the Pros- hi-tpi-ian Church. Cardigan, inter- ntllnl. will be in tho church ceme-

ler)'.

CBC Criticized. Detended In Senate Debate”

0'l'rAWA. Den: 1'1 -(CP)- The CBC was critlczied and de- leiitied in the senate today as the upper chamber spent most of a busy day considering legislation to streamline the act under which the broadcasting system operates.

senator John T. Haig. Progress- ire Conservative leader. said there had been some "rotten opinion" liioailcast on the CBC without Anj-Wtlllllll comment. He would not charge the CBC with political bias. but it could be used by any gov- errment. which wanted to use it for that purpose.

Senator Cyi-ilie Valllancourt (L -QHOIJEC) said some programs on the CBC and other stations were ”absol1itely immoral."

5

Senator Gordon Pogo, tL-Ont- nilni. president or the Natlcmal Liberal Federation. said he had a

lot in do with political broadcast- lli,', but had never round an indi- ciii.oii of political propaganda over the CBC.

Senator Arthur Roebuck Ontario: said the airways were a "llfll. al monopoly" which should b" controlled by the government. He held no brief for those who trained a free hand. He did not illll:k a separate regulatory body wniiiil be a benefit,

senator J. G. 'iurgcon IL- Biitish Columblnisuggcsted estab- iz:-liirciit of an "independent" a-.itlio:iiy of three to five members to lF..'lJlHl.e private stations in Caiiada. lie indicated he will for- iiinliy move the suggestion at the i-.ei.t session of parliament and Said the chairman of the CBC iioiirri of governors-A D. Dun- uiii-shmiltl be a member.

The deliiite occtipicd the senate during the morning and part of the afternoon sett.ing.Tl1e legis. 131101 liroviding for a statutory 111'-W101 86.250000 9. year to the CBC for five years and making other changes. finally was sent to a committee for further study.

Senator G. H. Barbour (L- Princo Edward Island) through the CDC performed a vital ser- virc for fishermen and those in Nut areas. Many of them still had battery radios. If the cur- "-"il 52.50 fees were to be chang- ed these people should not be Iskrd to pay more.

(L-

Senator J. J. Kinlcy (L-Nova sent in said he believed news- more influence

lulu rs still had i

radio which did not stick

I:-in mind like the printed Word. a-XE.-at EXPLORER. st while men on record to

Lake Ontario was Etienne 5.

RIRTHS. MARRIAGES DEATHS 50: per lnsoition

BIRTHS

-.:.. )lscDONALl')-At the P. E. Island lloimial on December 9th. 1951. in Mr. and Mrs. Daniel MacDonald of .l3Pl'-il0l'1'S Mills a daughter. Sadie Savilah, 8 lbs. 1 oz.

Inuit)--At the Ix'lng's County Jlcinurial llospital. Montague, De- lfnlbff 15. 1951, to Mr. and Mrs. Chester Lake. a son, Robert Mox- "Fll. 7 lbs. 8 ozs. DEAEE

Tl:-lLLY - At. Borden on Dec. l7th. -ill. Miss Maul Kelly. Funeral notice later.

WOOD - At Govaii. Saak.. on iJecember 1st. 1951, John N. Wood, 0"m'I'ly of Pownal. P. E. 1., in his 3'iili year.

Mrl'lIERSON -- At, the home of ME D. A. Gilli.-i. Grandvlew, Miss - iniiic Mt-Phcrson, age 68, form- Bllil of St. Peters Road. Cardigan.

:0llAlx('l.iE-At Bench Grove. De- "lllwr lath, 1951. Oliver Fran- PIS of Lady Fnne. age 82 years. iinernl notice later.

Aiuinnw-at the P. E. I. Hos- F lbundny, Dec. 16th. 1951. Y"fllCl:ick W. Andrew in his 74th -”-"2 Hosting at tile MiicLean Tlrinerni llomc. Funeral from WJNLV United Church tomorrow 1' eiinesrlny). Interment Central lllllril Cemetery. Dunstaffnage.

ll.Il. Maclean

UNDEITTAIHJB

EMRALMER Charlottetown and North Wlllohlro

PHONE In

-4 Minnie MucPherson of Mary

ieilrnnt euiiniiiiiii

This column is reserved for news of local Interest. but advertising of a newly nature may be inserted at five cents a word. strictly pay- ablo in advance.

NEW REVISED hockey sched- ules at Jack Cameron's.

MRS. JOHNSTON'S LADlES' WEAR.-December Specials.

DACK's SHOES FOR. MEN by Canada's finest craftsmen, 518.93. Henderson 6; Cudmore.

ALPHA IIEBEKAH Lodge No. 10, regular meeting tonight 8 p.m. Christmas entertainment.

CASHMERE SWEATERS from Scotland. 321.96 at Henderson do Cudmorc.

CHRISTMAS MARKETS will be held on Friday. Zlst and Monday, 24th. in Charlottetown.

ENGLISH VIYELIA DRESSING GOWNS in Authentic Tartans. 527.50 at Henderson an Cudmore.

THE 1952 ,MuslcaI Festival Syllabus is available at Peplcr's Jewellery, Montague, Taylor's Drug Co., Kensington. Art Rog-

ers', Summcrside and Mrs. Pike's. Alberton.

PROMOTIONS ANNOUNCED - Lt.-Col. A. W. Rogers. Officer Commanding the P. E. I. Regi- ment. t17tih Reece), reported yes- terday the promotion of Second Lieutenant Walter LePage to Lieutenant, and Sergeant John Richard to Officer Cadet. Officer Cadet Richard will take his train- ing here and at. Aldcrshot

CARS DAMAGED-A car was slightly damaged about the right rear door and fender when it col- lided with attack at the inter- section of Grafton and Prince yes- terday. The right front fender and bumper of a car was damaged when it slid into the rear of a truck on Kent Street. and a car travelling West on Gerald received damage to the left front fender after colliding with a car proceed- ing south on Elm Avenue.

G O U N T Y MAGlSTltATE”S COURT - Convicted on a charge of failing to stop after an ac- cident, a resident of Charlotte- town was fined s25 and costs or 30 days by Magisti-ate Gilbert A. Gaudet in the Queen's County Magistrate's Court yestci-day. A Charlottetown resident. charged with drunken driving was re- manded until Dec. 24. and the case of a resident of Charlotte- town Royalty. charged with creat- ing a disturbance. was adjourned until Dec. 22.

CITY POLICE COURT - Two men charged with being drunk and incapable were each sen- tenced to 20 days in jail by the Stipend-lat-y Magistrate yesterday morning. and a man appearing on 3 drunk and disorderly charge received ten days. A man charg- ed with carrying a concealed wea- pon was remanded un.tll today. with ball set at S100. and B. wo- manvcharged with drunken driv- ing was further remanded for one week.

QUALIFYING COURSES -- D. B. MacBeth, Charlottetown. H. B. Curr, Hunter River and C. L. Fitz- Patrick, Summerside, Officer Cad-

ets, P. E. I. Regiment. (17th. Reece), are taking qualifying courses at t-he Royal Canadian

Armoured Corps School, at Camp Borden, Ont. Officer Cadet M. I.

O'Brien. Charlottetown, recently completed his course at Camp Borden.

APPEAL DISMISSED - Word was received from Ottawa yes- herday that the appeal of a local barrister from it Provincial Su- preme Court ruling. upholciing the action of the P.E.l. Law So- ciety in suspending him from practice for A year. had been dis- missed in the.Suprcme Court of Canada. The Attorney General and the P.E.I. Law Society ap- peared as respondents in the ap- peal proceedings.

ELECTS SPEEDY TRIAL-Carl Power, city, who was committed to the Supreme Court for trial, yes- terday appeared before His Hon- our Judgc C. St. Clair Trainer and elected speedy trial in the county Court. The charge is breaking and

theft and is understood to be in connection with a break in a den- tal office Dec. 2. The case was set down for hearing Wednesday at 2 p.m. Counsel for the accused is Mr. M. A. Farmer. for the crown Mr. J. P. Nicholson . .

PRIZE TVINNEIIS - The fol- lowing were the prize winners in a drawing in aid of the st. Dun- stIn's Basilica Altar Society. held lasynigiht in the Holy Name Hall; 1st. Miss Jean Mclnnls. 84 Kent St; 2nd. J. E. Gallant. 319 Euston St.: 3rd. Miss Cecily Daley, Char- lottetown Hospital; -ith. L. F. MacDonald, 200 Hillsboro St.: 5th. Mrs. L. A. MacDonald. 131 water 5b.: 6th. Mrs. Frank MacAulay. 100 King St.; 7th. Miss Helen Lartcr. J39 Kent St.: 8th. Philip Murphy. 276 Sydney St: 9th. Mrs. L. Con- don. 82 Weymouth St.: 10th. Mrs. N. Nicholson. 70 Pownal St.

ARE TRANSFERRED - R. C. M. P. Constables H. R. llumphrcys.

Montague Detachment. H. E. Brooks, summerside Detachment, and O. M. Maebean. Charlotte-

town Detachment. will leave the Province in the near future for

British Columbia, on transfer Countable Brooks. a native of Omemoe. Ont.. and Constable

llumphreys. a native of Dlgby. N. 5. have each served three years in the Force. Constable MacLean joined the Marine section of the

regular force in 1947.

ROTARY CLUB ASSEMIILY .. District Governor Edwin Johnstono paid his official visit to the char- l:ii.tetown Rotary Club at a special ii.-imiiliiy held in the i2'li:irlollctmvii

entering with intent to commit 5

Force in 1946. transferring to the '

THE) GUARDIAN. CHARLOTTETOWN

Lessons From Europe Continued-From page 4

only acts as a device for equaliz- lng returns to primary producers and stabilizing prices. but it is the lie! l-0 Orderly and economic dis- Wbullon. hlifh clmss merchandis- ing. and effective consumer pro- tcction.

Under this system. there would be still greater need for a sound cooperative movement. Cooperative distribution of goods and materials to consumers would be as essential as cooperative credit. insurance. housing. and other services thmucvh which further savings might be effected for those who wish to co- operate.

0 O I

This system would tend to de- velop a competitive spirit for ef- ficiency between different groups in our economy and between dif- ferent individuals or firms spec- ializing in any particular line of products. It would leave each group free and responsible unto themselves. thereby freelnit the Government. as such. from the re- srnnsiblllties that socialist nlanners (ijvould have the Government shoul- er.

It one group would not accent the dcciaiori of the "overall commis- sion". there might be a general strike to bring all the facts before the public who would see that. lus- tice prevailed. The strength of any one group would not be greater than the combined strength of.all the others; and if this izeneral strike were to occur in a particular iitdtislry, primary producers and workers would undertake precinc- tip" of the commodity themselves.

This system of controls wniilr' attain necessitate. in most fields of ii:-ncessing and manufacture. hav- ing cooperative or producer-nwnnd i'iYl(l prndiircr-controlled plants at least for the purpose of determin- ing standard costs of production Provision would have to be made bv the National Price weniilntlnc Commission for a neutral board of arbitration or mediation to brim! the facts of any dlsvuvle with labor or industry before the nubile and have the differences settled iust'v iincler pr:-satire from informed pith- lle nniiiioii. '

Each industry would. throtwh it- inarkeiintr board. accrue enough IIIOIIPV to finance research and ex- pansion when necessary and to S-Pt up a nrice stabllivetion fund ihrnutzh which the-ycould Slll3Sl""7P lhN1'l50lV"R as producers for any losses, The Government could aieii in, in times of surnlivii prnriiir-tlnn and. to A certain extent. distribute those surplus goods to the people withiri their own country through the media of existing local secur- itv agencies.

For instance. instead of issuirirv a family allowance cheque the Government mlcht i.-iuie a coupon for the equivalent Value. in hounds of butter coal. bread. flour. or other basic product. which.because of uriforseen circumstances. was in surplus suunlv. There would al- ways he. always is. either :1 small s,:irnlus or a small shortage. It would be impossible to supnly the exact consumer demand-no more or no less-tinder this scheme of planned distribution and pricing but many economists believe it v.-ouid produce more satisfaction than any other attempted scheme of planned production.

0 0 0

Our fourth proposal: in the mist. the economy of Canada depended to a izrcat. extent on exports but the situation is changing rapidly. Wzth olir vast resources today and the tremendous influx of immi- grants. this situation may well be transformed in ten years time. The iilans set forth above would there- fore have to be carried through in the international level if an nr- rlerlv dLstribution of the world's fqnd and resources is to be effect- ei.

All nations are partners in pros- llcrilv an ariversitv but the Al- nifehty provided sufficient. resour- ces and comforts for all if we are Smslble 9l'l0llS!ll to distribute them and use them properly. Ordcrlv distribution. not increased produc- tion is our basic problem and on the local. national or international level, it is tiuite annarent that an orderly system of distribution can- not be worked out until the or- zinnizcd groups in our economy get together and agree on a basic for- iiuala that will result in a fair deal to each and all.

Recommended Reading Belloc. Hlllaire: The Servile tale.

Cahlll. Rev. E: The Framework of a Christian State.

Gibson. J. Douglas: Canada's Economv in a Chanting World.

Leo XIII. Pope: "The Christian Constitution of States".

Little. J. M. D.: A Critique of Welfare Economics.

Rorty and Norman: Tomorrow's Pond. Veblen: The story of the Grant

American Fortunes. (To be continued)

Receives Award

gwing Commander J. Angus Mai.-Lean. D.F.C.. M.P., who was among I53 R.C.A.F. officers iinti airmen awarded the Canadian Forces Decoration this week. ac- cording to an announcement from Ottawa. The award is given for twelve year's service in either the Pernizincnt. or Reserve Forces and is the first purely Canadian

award of its type. 'Another Is- land airman to receive the (le- coration is Sgt. J. A. Jiit-kmiin.

of Lower Montague.

Grocer Puts I Hunting Men To Shanie

By GEORGE BISHOP LONDON. Dec. 17 - (Reuters) -Hun-ting men reached for their brandy flasks today when a non- hunting Welsh grocer outbid the horsey world to carry off John

Peel's born for E600 - all in a minute. Peel's horn. immortalized in the

”D'ye Ken John 1833 letter from his son declaring it the real thing, was almost in the grasp of a ycomanry colonel when the grocer oullbid him.

Sotherby's salesrooin was packed today with open-air types star- ing entrant-cri at the single hoop of copper iie;-tling on :1 cushion of blue vclvct.

Peel's hcirii was for sale be- cause the brewers who owned the Lion Hotel in Guildford, Surrey, where it had hung for 50 years, have gone out of business.

Every master of hounds in the country was ready to pay ti good price for it. But Col. J. A. M. Phillops, commanding the Riding Yoemanry. particularly wanted it because "D'ye Ken John Peel" is his regimental march. Ile intended going up to 2500 but actually went to 33580.

Titty all knew the history of the horn. John Peel's son sold it to a John Rigg. who in turn sold it to the proprietor of Best's Brewing Company Limited.

Phillips went to 12580 and the hunting folk smiled then a hand shot up at the back at f6c0

rollicking song Peel". with an

and W. N. John: Powell, 69. a Cardiff grocer, was the new owner.

Beaming. Johns Powell said

when asked what he would do with the horn: "Why, take it home. of course. I have not real- ly hunted myself. but my son does and I am delighted I have secured it."

Sabre Jet llas Margin Over Mlg-15

WASHINGTON. Dec. 7 -(AP) -The ll. S. Air Force said today the F-86 Sabre jet has a margin of 10 to l in victories over the Communist. Mtg-15 in Korea.

Noting that today is the anni- versary of the Sabre Jet's first combat use, an air fcrce spokes- man said the Far East Command reported that through Dec. 14 the Fourth Fighter Wing destroyed 130 Migs. prcihubiy destroyed 20 and damaged 143.

The air force offirer said only 14 Sabre jets were lost. n

In addition ,the Fourth Wing is credited with hiigging Ii. Coni- munist planes of other types- eight Tu-2 twin-engine jet homb- ers and three La-9 fighters.

Womdo TCHuHtsgMT:in's Throat With Axe

BRIDGEWATI-IR. N.S.. Dec. 17 -(CP)' Bevcry Smith. 29. of nearby Stanley Station. told po- lice tonight an enraged woman nearly cut his jugular vein with her axe during an argument about a strip of timberland.

Hotel last evening. President Ster- ling Giddiiigs occupied the chair. assisted by Vice-President Gor- don Award and Secretary 3. Gra- ham Rogers. Reports from chair- ntcn of the various committees were received and discussed by Governor Jobnctone. At the con- rlitsinn of the reports ll riisciisaion on the position of'the club com- pared to other clubs of the district was started by the Governor's an- praisal and it most interesting even- ing was spent as the membe - gave their views as to how the Char- lottetown Club carried out its ob- ligiitlons. At the conclusion votes of thanks were tendered District Governor Jurnstone and Rotarian Gordon Foster.

..

. --Personals

I

The many friends of Mrs. Stephen Doyle. Orleoar Street. will be glad to hear she has suf- ficiently recovered from her re- cent operation at the City Hos- pital. in i-einrn to her lioine.

Smith slashed from chin to car and in serious condition in hospital hci-e, said ilie argument

started when the woman disput-

pf.'l'ily near Stanley section.

An arrest is expected Police have not identified W0l'niilll.

SOOH . the

Smith said the woman started swinginz her double-bitted axe. The blade hit him on the jaw.

Then he walked for more than I. mile to medical assistance. He said the woman promptly left the scene.

IN MEMORIAM In land and loving memory of my dear Father, Frank Godfrey

who tiled llee. IUNI, 1944. the

Sm-et. arr memories that.

linger. Dear la the one that is gone. In memory I'll hold you dear Father.

As long on tho yearn roll along.

IMNNWV ll! Mfwfl). J. Mne- grtlmr, ('ormvnll.

East

ed his cutting rights to a pro-;

OTTAWA, Dec. 17 - (CP) - Major role of the R..C.N. under the North Atlantic Treaty Organ- ization is anti-submarine war- fare, Vice-Admiral E. R. Mainguy said today.

The Admiral. who this month took over command of the R.C.N.' and who two years ago wrote the "Mainguy Report" on the nevy's internal problems. said at a con- ference in the Parliamentary Press Gallery that he, as chief of the naval staff, is ”against" any R.C. N. activity or development which does not have to do with anti-4 submarine work or the defence of; harbors. I i He said the navy, now about'

2.000 strong. plans to expand to -about 21.000. and that the pace will be geared with the produc- tion of 14 anti-submarine escort vessels. first of which was launch- ed recently near Montreal.

The recruiting rate is being stepped up from around 275 a month to 335. The navy's parti- cilar shortages were in aero-en- gine mechanics and in the elec- trical branch. 5

Reviewing the navy's needs and plans for 1662. the Admiral said:

i. The navy will seek to bor- row submarines from either Bri- tain orthe United States and carry out exercises with anti-Sub pescor-t vessels and the carrier Magnificent and her aircraft, pre- ferably with forces of other N.A. T.O. nations.

2. More exercises will be carried out on minesweeping operations as the navy gets delivery of new mincsweepers. with a view to studying the most up-to-dale form of port defence.

3. Shipbuilding programs start- ed in Previous years will bring fruit. with four more of the new anti-sub escort. vessels being launched and the coastal mine- swecper program,of 14 vessels ibeing completed. In addition, t-he navy's Arctic patrol vessel, H.M. iC.S. Labrador. will be complet-I Ied. Equipped with helicopters, itl Its the first ship of its type to be! ordered by the R.C.N.

4. In addition. a number of small auxiliary craft are being completed. and older ships are being "modernized" in line with

the an-ti-sub policy.

5. I-I.M.C.S. Quebec will be com- missioncd early in the New Year as Canada's second cruiser. main- ly for training purposes. The other cruiser. H.M.C.S. Ontario. will continue to be based at E5-

quimalt, B.C., and also be used for training. j . 6. The reserve recruiting pro-

gram will be intensified. with spe- cial emphasis on a summer train- ing program. .

7. The R.C.N. "will continue to make its conti-ibutlon to the Un- ited Nations forces operating 1" Korea so long as it is necessary to do so...."

Order New Trial In Libel Action

OTTAWA. Dec. IT--(CF) -The Supreme Court of Canada today orderetl a new trial in the 5100.- 000 slander and libel action launched against Premier Douglas of Saskatchewan by Walter Tuck- er, the Provincc's Liberal leader.