-lllnllruze to spend the same amount -wil-

The Paper Thais ww,

-- -_-_.

I suiiia, M _ I

Ulldlilll ll RD

\\

°°PI95_P5P9f » ---W. Read byEverybody \ is W.. tt...

owen Prince Edward _ i 1" _ _

Island __ ~- __ I _ ' _ 1 ' ‘ _ - I ”"g'tiQ_ All The News

Like The Dew -_ -‘ I _ "* , _ //W _ _ It » _ _ / Worth Reading '

'_ / The _ _ t _ ,..,_. _ .,,,-_“___ QW _ we \\\\\\ _ » an me au. - td ' f 9 0 n Prm

I

.si

`

l tt town Gulrdiun. Thule Centl.

U." 0 Q nllnn Founded 1881

biornlnl Gun r _

’ ..¢':.‘::l. t.':.';'.°..'::":n.'.."°”.:.°'.:‘.,

ii

lf

A ALY1‘lcALlu:vlEw or 'rl-ll; BELL GOVER E T

lln the debate on the Budget, va-cated off' 1

which begun on April Sth. Hon. we left belil|ll>tIIs':ie§l‘:>li:e¢;1i}l;‘;;Ii A. E_ Arsenanit slpoke as follows: We knotw how that __er_c__.wa_;

lit is not my intention to con- made up at the time-it was sim-

tlnuo this debate to any great ply image length this evening, especially as titrggquurters byof ta_i_&_i1_1_§ the my hon. fléieliii. tl1ii_leadia_li_of the and ` yea’ Gavel-nunen_ Hs een e the remalni » month, gentle bee-he ilns flitted from prl1cticallll&y all the Eipgntitxfr WIN” one thin! to another and then lhaok the year had .been ineurregs for ng,-tin and then off again. so that it paid and -when practl-cali ii (H111 has iliecn hard to lfollow him local revenue was still to Iéoae ide

and Y-

‘ nero, uro rather _of a disjointed 1919-20 are interesting to look at

:Cutting it off f .

l‘Dm the gentlemen of the Pullllic Acc-0im;_-i

lvl' was ill: 11,, - . li;

time. they gh 11 i into the mattcll)-Il( iiaiv:_,§if;'":_Ii:§: my llon. friend tile Attorney (101,.

;l_i_.il yeal'_after the cvent, looking

_ “ €"°“H@ 10 Justlfy lrlmrrll,

lights llpoll this alleged tml`~l‘takt=

he said because it was not I M “""" "

' moved 'W

119 all amendment. lt"u.~l nl n `

fliiftntl t‘llo Attorlley (‘elle' I Il on' On Wedllesilay cveniilg

' - _ - - - (A il 1 .. - _

thc stuiemeni oi- im; P__I_;'i_cL f_1_I_I_I_'_5;i 1.ltill iiull. Mr. Arsellnlllt t-ollI)irl|- I/]liI]i?lllh(;l{liIl Ildlds of eww these highways that he ‘S gomg to

und iim _ieimie ____ _he ______g____ ____ _________ .______ ___ _ _ll o_rm<-ll that build. to the Amlian Way in Rome. iuiiy __ “.B___k hui] ______He__ ________€_ _____ ______ _ L eil ol twelve tllous- ~a ili hwa that has outlived the

,_ _ _ _ _ _ _ s y .yards llllolc befolc the work is traffic not of centuries but of

lm-1.-9-1 1

_ adjournment oi the dfihate ' i

¢ » _ lt was doni-

Uolllnlittee on thi - i t ' A I I M I . . | necessary for him to go _,ver _. _ ' _ tilollsunds of years! Well, they

s Do n at tile o E. tg ni’ the Kroullll t'ovul'cd in ilis§(i"ilt;- niiilsslillllc-rm)f h1'>ml|:,iifI.iend .the Com' Wm "°t. hem 'm“'“'h I`eSembI"‘“Ce t°

vi,i,_`_ ___i_i_.eSs_ __________ ____ _“__ __r_e___ ____»_ . o ll L Works oil a the Apirlull Way. though they might

Lit us come now to thc Agrltlli Wy

h d " ~ _y_ __ __ _ _ _ 'mer ot-casioll that the work oi witll ren.oll be cailled tl CROSS. t e . G IE" mm Hued' _ ;_f_;‘_l{I£__i‘O:_1_sii'ltl_-_tion should have been Bl/\1\' VV;y_ 1 um very lnilsgii afi-aid

- - ~ - i~°*IILfllI- llllll liropcr sur- that. \\'.ll‘ile the roads of Rome

turnl nm] '1',3(.iiiii(.ui S__i_____i__ w_.___s sllollld have llc:-ll matic. l hrou-gilt credit to their builder, the

Government! and shows the which le, indeetl, it técllllllfnlscncrl 'I I"I‘I' I"’“"”"@l'- Ullll lllese Hlli- seller-lllons which are to come will

vets had bcell made in everv case not bless .my hon. frIend's name in

nature. To tako them up as 1 in this iight Th - _ _

_ ~ ey Show painly 1 did t ‘I "

nnvo llloln would be to follow the that though our friends charged usiwould II; tailxllwollwlllaiglillii tilvldencf ' - l.H.'it in nu Smme-Im ugriclmuml ' Il tl' ` - ' '

. . . e mee - _ -fi 100i. Many ot the studs-llts \vllo “III I_°II i’II’I1‘°-\' llluc prlllis had the some way. If his name is only

y iiil-Sllil do not follou' any eillhjcct MIG" I’I‘”'II“I`°‘I IIII` IIIII “'IlI`k- Wllftll to be -relllembcred so long ns tthese

in notes, nsl have them down The Pulblic Accounts of the yea,

cxzllll-illc of my hon.i'riend;nnd that with

criili-islll oi' the affairs of tllls pro- the gave us c_.e_iii_ i.

or absolutely time tlley met, I suggested to the *"**"~'

. y

vlncc. .noi one _ ‘I “`I`II I‘I“"""‘"`--“WI erllans lion t’rien‘?leI;;lr?iIrk;?lx£IIl'e

»ill<mll:l.ltl1lllte my ilon friend tllxes, our in tilt- Pit-lllit-r on thc wav tiltlt he has That is axugaiixilaxaiggé ‘h;’_§r‘”f' lllllldicii what might be consider- rev nue so hi-gli 8 en

4-tl :ls :l very had rn-se. Ile lla, Now, \vi r '» . ’ _ _- j ' ' ’ D ` l-i»l'iailli_r lllallle the best pf it, iii; taxes `l:oll<;I|:teZ1v'i;l‘3fi~2iio¢.l"e of. tiliose itbimhlwly mrmm' .The CUIIIIIIII' ifi :l vc|'_v fluent. tl co-nvin-clng tile Public Accounts lljllldagalin lx; i§‘i:H(i "QL, chose. w 1"ve“m"“t“ III' silc.'ll<ol°_ vvcn when llc docs not Vffllilily calculated. lll the e r solve IIIOII-MINI 'Hwy mmm not IO t.i0,-<'i_v slick to facts. Ot course 1920 they coiieuied ____r________ _ _'y Ll _ _ ._ l_r l lollllts. it they had ally; it is an vllsy matter to dllnln your IIBIOHEIYILT 10 the your 1010 i1lIlI<(‘llPli'I;Il0'fl?llllEl' Iwrllllii slmllenllmt was 'lililllll"llI»<.` vspecialiiy \vilcnAyiiii ing to $87,000. In the IL; init' .- .»‘_ - If "I y II’ PI'°‘ _i__,_,,_ ii,,.ii_ wi,_i_ i___i_._i__,_ ___u____\'. tim), _,__ii_,_,i__i i . _ - y_ ur __ . .l .\llll_l.ll_l\ui|ltor__it. lllust llc assulllcll ,sl-I nil, first, il :1tl':l.w lll-'tn and lllglli $7.028: ill liillltl tI'llxcl=l';“I$II':1‘7‘i4}dxIe|II lL‘IIcbIlll(il(lHl:)l`l'lt.ilt>|hm riomml Ii`Ih(iwM’

_ . ,__ _ _ ' ._ _ _ _ __ ‘_" "1 ~ r- » - _ . |ll'tl\' ili'il til 12:. _itll itloliitl to dt-nlollsll billl. "IX 1-Web- $0.4-lil, and from tilt- iilst. 1019. to_bc $1,246,082. U

'i‘|ll~.»w tilt-tics are not at oil now, l’roilll>itioll Conllllissioll $114.13-

. mem-l tl; ' .

in - t D ' iloll-Iltutliiat fillet rlef rI°lte'y had 'my §IIudI~,k the School report must benhn' ills ls .ln lnnovu lon in this House ment collected last year two yours' l\Ir M(.Lr-od \v'tsmilrlc0)lrl?:etnte(tIl by Sigh( ilwiitil Swim wonderful Umm-.ij

_ _ ` they should have sent for him l|lPl'f‘ used to Ile?':JI4(t:tII:llltentpli‘idiI’ [lei

- _ . ‘ ' ‘ ‘ ‘ ~ - it l

e fo_l Nil. Allilersoll. I’ersollaily, I lished froln year to year. silowillg`¢1m

was (ollvillteli tiltlt the lc olt was I-illf lllllmhcr oif srilnois til lt had \

‘ ' ' ‘ ~ i 1. ll

09011 0l>@l1 for so nlally days in the iii year. as wcli as the llllinniiii- iiiai ____ .wore closed nltogctllcr. I cull iii! .well imagine that wllcll t‘llIs state- dw' ,lllellt was prepared and sllblllltted iioi £0 Y-|10 l>2ll'lY ill Uilllngn of cdllvutitlll d-ii I

---~l thillk iuollitlliy ho is the t?o:lll~ i'_,i,i -- lllil-i.-lirlllnl' oi' A;:,’l‘it'llltlllrc-» llc would .iii I

stliillliilliztl sulllrllllillif alftol' this-__A

fas-lllioll: “Wo sluicl tilt-re wwe

N.~ ., _ '-- -- '--lllc

ll\\. ill tllttl leport. illc .Lsscts onl_v twenty srflloois closed; we 111,.

nts. 'I‘tlrl tl' 1 ,iii _<;' .` ' . __ _ _ .

“WIFIIIIIOI "II‘I I0 illlrds oi the crctl-li, ll t-rf-dlt. ls duo I' __________S “TO ________ M______ORv 4

i..i_i___ ____O____ ____ _ tctowll, :lild follow courses that -I°I’_ _ _mood for tlllom; 3;t_,k_:_I_?_;‘___:_"II_‘_I_f i_ill_vc llotilllli; tt_l_ do with ngrictlltllre gt’-;II_:“____IIiIiI_ II_I‘_“_ll l_>I=_1i‘P<I Ull ll_lilr~l- of (iovernment grants my hon. _iimi i_i(__ (_______________ ,______y __________ __s _to _ills__.l£:_llcllitlll'aI llrancilcs ___________»l_1__l_ _\\_sl_e_i__li._sc hiuc prints. i’l-inllds have been especially foi-tu. use ot'1lll.\"sii'I but it dowll their ill? k‘u'l Wim' taught [Iwm why' I tot;f-ill;\l~ il-" ('Milu-die-d‘mlm3 nl' "uw They Seem to have had mis: __ _“___ ____ ________ g_________ ll_ll_ lt uollld be very nlllc-ll hot- ____ f -l> lllllt-. ll dlbll-lllrli ll0 t

11 Si, iii” (i___,_,_.__________i __m_________;__ tcl lor the yollilg nlcll fuilowlllt: _t.. i,_.F,______._, __ ________ _`______. ____%_'_" ;____ til_s-nl to no I-isviviill-ri._ nt no lll_orir _ sic, tiiiii i_ii.{_v ___._,_ _"___, '__________g i:_ii\_ollsc_, _llc _ta1lgil_t tilt- .~;llll_il.-ct ______ lil*/0llIl".~l llost-_-l alll-ii lllzlliillg the-lll ,1Irfl.‘iI~h :A "mn".m `, _ Silili __i_i____, __ _vi__________ ________ _______ ___ ____ _ _ ii. is llli.lil-ell lll_t.l_I lost of opr=,_l-- _“___

..i______,__ _“___ i_(________________ _______________ iltllli-, till: scllool lol ill-xt your ls ___ _

.__ _____ ________________ ___ _____ _________r_ .l_bolli 5_S_l..,0i_l0._ Out of this sulll _ __

...

I lc luvi-,l~l|.|llt-ll » I .- " , ' ' ' ' ‘ "

_\,__i ____ ___ ii___ ____f___f_l_I__l3::.' alice ls heillié llilid by llll~ l<`l~dol':li II"

, ‘ *- ' tilivt-rlllllellt; atllil tilt-l'i-i`<ll't-. two __

:lllli it-I lllc soy in rollnociion with #lil of wil-ich t'lxc-l rightly bel

' ff ' I - ‘ -_ .ollgell .were nlncll llllticl'-cstilll'ltod be-'1"lll`l tfive lilo gimt uw-1

1 . . . _ - _y now by ____

thi-' iiltlt llnyoni' colllpal-in to us be-' - 1

~ ' El lily " I"IIIh‘f Ulcy accrued fills calls-1- ill the li'it i’ 1 ~

lloli. i`l‘ivllll’-l f-pop(-ii im 11,9 Bud 'llld helm- l ` ' I‘I 0 “II’”e‘III“I't ~ -

I ~1 ~ get ‘ lget to the year 1910 'intl evcllts we iilld tilat l‘t-velltle toilet were close ` OI' '

‘ I ' ' - - - _ - ' 2-- _ tl for lllully -lnolltlls il .- ‘ ' . ,

ll .lllti you ulil not dart- to do otillir- ________ _______ _.________________y _____e________ ___ _ in

“`IIII III” -*lil*-6011 on the Address III” I‘III" Y‘°'1I`S llllilkillir t Lot.li -lllin ttii llllloullt '

= ‘ - s to $88 000 while tllclc, the year." Alld so this stalutlncllt -

. . W,

rilllllot fllii to be struck wiiii ii wlliull this (‘ovel-nlnlellt il ' ‘~ 'A I - ` . `, .' . . . i-ti‘i|iiiiii_ii1,i_-, .iiimiii___.iiy-_ _imiweelg t,u_l¢en in-er||i1'0i»_ mid fm. _I;,__"_§_l_l_i. ill ullcollectcd levellllc, was sllilprcsscll. It mgilt be nil _i__i\__._,i-. __________ __-_____ _________-___________ _ - _- . . _ ____

' " ' ‘ ' ' " ‘ I' ' -~ . chill' of music ill _’

II’"III~ III* 'WIIUIS Sileech tonight gave III’ “IlS0lllt0ly no credit of

Wilztl strikes me alhout the pro

sent lllldirct is its extraordinary

<~il;ll';lrtcl'lstic in the wily ol` ex- I wish m go 9' II*-U0 fllrther. 1 .we \vcl‘_e never given credit. Today foil' lllysellf I foulld th' t I `

~“'IhIl to show yon, Mr. Snellkcr. the Gill/@l‘llln0llt is setting $3.000 a the yenr 1919-1020 tlln llllllll>(el;m:>I

Slll'\‘l'il on tie lltldress_ I

_ _ . won

t

it*-li|lit,ill'os thai. the Governlllent ., l|l'lil\rl.~r\ to make tlurlng the ¢.n5___ _not _t_illlt.e as black ns ycill' for the use of this -nlacilillcry scllools llilcrarinlg for lo-ss than 120 i

' 2' " o lc Govcrlllncnt lllulnl' the liliglrlvuys (‘rullt. I ii ~ ii--1 . _ _ » II

' tlyh l.. it...» tilail ftilt, il.lii__|____

-I".l1‘ .\"‘1ll'_ Our friends ftl _ (‘ - . .

0 W "IW ‘W°l\I(i ily to paint us. i think 1

'rl - t, r 1 . I "mn “mn any wwe on this “"“II SIIIISIY YOU. Mr. Speaker, tliut oi' rcvcllue rt~cei\'elI belonging to to thc t\ve=rlty scllools not oilelntillg _he

lilo previous Liboi-111 Goya,-im -t , hall, and tllilt we wer i le" 'what ‘"3 Defiwiis the the most, -were entitled we have the follow- by the_(~‘ovcl-nim g .cr lnllnU.VfIV'H\‘7‘~'5ttiliv|lke:¢iu8`. ugl\It:\5"§i‘gL§icH‘,l1§fe°¥'I°:_I ofiits ili.svory._ We llls cstiinlatojof the Proviinclai debt' 'l\’c'i`v,` let us t‘:Tl\<c* the year '19i8- III”

o o this and to comm at the elld of the tlscnl year 1010:-‘J019_._0__r ie__m_ ___ that time po

fro

» Y

ll docs not require u 1| fi.

m 0 Sllrins out. at the end of our term, with mi

adllnlttlllz illai at 1.:'l'c:l't nlllllv lngi-ii _J

____ uocldelltal om-issioll, but to me it W.,-

\v:t.< lll'll.ct,i<::1lly tl reiletition of his _$169,706. 'Pills would reduce the o l‘ii;'(l}l¥tLtit; ill:Ulxltihlittimflwrigcillluts g(t(il(esn veiytisulilmclmlliz' The only d"i'm'I "UL mo Ahudlv Let II” cm"

‘" -" . ' ' l._‘= len law h .- ._ ,. ‘ ` t' ~:i~il th .' ,»'z.'

l deficit by n <.tlllsdefrll.ble mnlollnt, -’Illls ls the road nlacllinery, cost- tile truth oi tile glliltfter-.a*I;€;___`_“;I__(z_‘hI_'; l\~l_l9 U19 1L`-*III*--S lll`ll_fIilU0l1 by U16 git, ilregixiti_1pI;_(.iiE__Sdm‘iii; lifor? am

f Luo lllcillods of rzllslllg .sz-upiyln. _' _ __'____ '___ _'_ __ _ot oi S151 S

lllfflillllfr “\'oll arc 'lllli pa " 1 » _ . . tl llrll slr-i»i»it-rll.»il-ts to tilt- f‘.If_‘f,I_'_I_.If___§'f___gII"II I" III” D‘"“’"'°" ollfi 'rlln llo.\',"rlm l.l~:.-\l>l»:n or ; \\'t~ will 'illilkv vnu iluy lnorc, `fi.i___ im" `ie,_d_.__, of _iw (i0_,(______ 'I`IIl-I iI()\'l<Jl{.\'MldN’I‘." it is said

` I Il

D Umm VU" I"`IIg‘“I" .llllltilt-l llmilel collllci-ted \vlt'il ellll IV I* 1.

'l` I’ , l I 4 'uvunmgnh' 0°( duw" me I-ZR! iiulllglltel' alld llilplallse.) My

ld it not’ in _

' - E $-34.000 purchased bv us alld cd' lit mleant 1 little mo e

' - ~ - - - ~ . . ' k . . fliclltls tl 5: 1;

ghitrged up io u-,_ _ii f . _ _ _ _ “III” » nlellis. ill 19.40 ill_c ilcopic voicti _ _ _ __ - _ _ __ _ me

s a t ol which ls I had to make out the statement $_.ii_377_iiii_ i__ _film $__4____5_ ___ s-ylllp._ltil5, alld vely il_ttlt. fist., Thr. ____

0 _____i(,_. tip _ _ ___ _ I’relll~lcl' s_llid some tulle ago that _ _ ~- _ _ __l_-___i_illlll -ll_.V >-.\>»l'-lll- _.___qi_.__i _,_ii__.u_i____ “.._._. _i_,__i_i__i____ ovel and llilovc what had been Y \‘ll rl -_ J.,.!. . 'l‘li.~i nlaulls ‘ ` . ' ‘.` ' im.-

I tl.- ' i:.I-lxs'-_f -I--

:lt voilllli:l.ill_\ _thu ilnoplt-, llnldo __I:____:_Ii`;__{;mv ‘gsm (.__(__ Ii___:_:i‘i`; _;::“i__Iil also '.~‘ho\\ed that uiliic the to .1

_ ’I‘adcillg_illto account the amount year, was iiity-six Pills addr.__ __________________S___ ___ ______s______i.i»l"I’”ImI "I ton iltllllr- toiily ill this '1ll‘ovill¢-i- III‘II"IIIII'~III`I‘ III IIIII I°I` I‘I‘III"‘ItI‘III silt; of iim i_im_s_,_ were ____i_i for (__ _ ’ ' ~" ' _,L A00; \\' lille unter conlpulsioll ‘ _‘__ _ _ __ L ____ _ ii-_,_ ""'llll.V~~io-l' cllltim.: down 0Xp;n_ ;?v(_I__II‘i____¢;Il§lit years the Colllservn- 1010 _over and above the amount at nil, makes a total of seventy-six II lnm_0w5ed mm” by 0"1y$w’000 \rli‘c,}llt]L1)»li 000 lr.; to rt lllinimlllll. ‘They sillo 101 'QW' 9 n__p0y\er-from 1011 to estimated by the I’rov.Illciztl auditor schools closed for tho grcllitcr 1>urt‘TIII"' I5 ”"f’III"r I"I”I‘I'I’I` II"Im “'III"II vifliin lllaildolin guitar, gralna- 561

- - 6 slltiessfuily mrtvleil on and also taking into account this o the year ‘This is vlly tl‘lffer-IIIIII I I We

that we had $200,000 ' 9 3 " 4 ` _ f _ __ . . ,_ _ lloll. fricllils cull tal'c :lll tile' _-.. , _ 1 1 i 'i iii 1(

mole than me amIII`s “I "IIS Ilrovin-ce during -"1iWIl`iil€l'y ll-‘l un asset to which we cllt iroim thc half--tl‘ll.tl1 itivcn ollt|I`° \ I' HU” m “kc cle' (Im I II my Dui iiiai in the ye-_“_ iiiiii me _movie l

llsoittti-lil pos:-liI>ie. 'i`ill:'~/ :urls i_._.__ i-_,im__i___ _“___ miie (__-_“iii _ _ tratftilli; sllll-bcalns from cucllnl- im. iii-L, iam iimi _,e_mie_vollllltarlly and wltilout any pres-

lo sectllflt, our fi-1 i i

~ em” ‘“’I”F *IW Illffeilsr ln debt or only $53,000. . _

t

‘fllllllllr ycal' intend to

:ll-nl of $889,000 nf »Proviellc0)l?l!l1dli1,Illll? Hiwhgzel glllhlitsnthtili gut? ' _ Debt of Province as of Dec 31st 1919 per An nl g

. . , . . ____

'xv ‘ilcsitlos :ln extra ox (iii u we are ou

________________ __________ys to t_il_;:nex__1_l_l;¢;;_$_i_;l9_i)_0t_J___ill revenue rightly belong. derson statement $1.246,082.5

` I' Wm' `B“I- I ‘l1lll'i§0lllg I-GSS revenue due and revenue collected, rc-vc. in

$30000, nlllkiu 1 i ti lltrllrly 11 llliiliog Ilol‘Ia‘ll‘s.BIu:I"0etlls?of 0(l.s‘lake the dem as “Ulm Decembm'

III"_`r’ ill'0ll0se to nearly double that province wild

_ , ' 't was the cx'tt~t 1.11 ~

llnlollnt._.l`hi-s in 1,1 1 ` ' I" "~

our friends cnlli ecoggglby?-\Y'haIvI1lII; ?lrlI)yl'lIl(Il>lit£;v§ISlII;(lllllilc-li' umki lymlmle IlIl(0i0ll110;01)erson smmmem (See external 3;]

' ~ -_ lcwlell . ‘

. . . . . ..............$27,454.73

i‘f I ‘ i' - . ' 'I 0| 0 the lGovelnmcnt mean; did they get out the audit? when L

when ho said that h -- ~ . ' 1 _

ml the treasury." I Il2ill'i;w1'gn;:vtiiiigiitili-?Ttl‘tt;lIIIi(;ll‘iI:IveII.P101SWE" llil tv Conservative Administration \l'll0t|lc1‘ llc uses il shot gun or n -fore the lillhlic Al'-l'tllllIt‘s IIN' pw 23'545`27 W lllln lzlln, ibut ho reminds .ms very tee. we asked the l’IrovillicilfiHXTiiil ` at llillnil oi' tho lute Alexander Mc- tor to make up a statement i th $51,000.00 51,000.00 tr- .i\<-,llzio who had to stand gun;-ii -assets and liabilities of tho P G a- I-`Il` over the treasury of Canada in vince to December 31'si,191n,e\i-higii N til

keep his friends from tt' he acc rdf 1

it. i alll inclined to thlmiiretlixtgrrll; prevlolizx tough); Zlilikzimifgtsisl tgn days hon. friend will not use n shot gun -The Committee had a'mpi5e5tE‘l-igoyz' L BIII- ll DOD gun, as the intention is I°°I‘ II"-0 it, and they oi‘i'el'edIaI1so(?

-VI‘I0lltiy a peacealble one. and one IUWIY 110 Objection ‘to th - II“‘1'\‘illl permit his friends l ill ment. l need lc in e mm' A III’-Ui) In the Provincial strongolloxp *Ile bllliget last yeslfninsiwfch em . IW” Wonder \vhat .is the neoess: "°I' °°”II”I"dI°t9d- 'If-IW8-(S DIlrlV‘c1>I`A ily ful' this extraordinary eim-emi the records fo the Public Acc l t itln'c. We ure told that in 1919 W.. Committee and it should hnvaom S iixpcnlietl $739_000_ This may bg illto t'hose records. I asked utgii: _l_l_li._ -but. iiie,-E were __ _great _muy time tlllat lt be included in the re- I' cxllt llllitures necessary tllen which cords' and I “IIIIeI`SI0'0‘d from what I* , _ ~.

lul iliends .were noi mimi upon-my hon frends said til t this

4 twbled this statem nt h d

llnil tile war expenditures; omllttted. Ai'tel-wllrds aemilldlritgefliq - _cunt ng to $6,000_ in meet____i_e por was prepllred by us and we

<‘1nr~nsc>s of t-he Prince of Waieg' 'we

visit, iiiiiqiiliiing ____ about $_300_ sented this as all :lmelldlmsnt to

. _ - ft lt/ nl-lkc hu-it yellr, though they (iiii -would :be done. When the report N

n

lille due and other assets per Alldorsou

_ t, 1919, _» . ‘ . , .l vernllmllm- i,i_m__e_ _ms ___ “___ _me ___ uomi_l§_?_1_i_ll;»_e al; _l_?et;l_i-z_ei_1iii_y_' statement net de-bt Dec., 1919 _ 124,645.73,-LII,

itiilily "going 5 _ll _ _ said that wo w(;‘lI‘e1everyOui;`xI.Ii1?v‘:ldgs~ t1lIlu;’iitd‘:1IeeaLh()lI,l§aiI`imwde lim on ___°€_*`IaIl ont. illtleeti wilcll we were spend walliieii ii, i_ . rams' they ii. _ _ -_ _-1 1 _._ $11214a'1.s:l- 1

ilu, till-_ sum ol’ $500,000 nnd now lwallted to sliimgutshc gs-t;I1;'le1fll’itill1eiIs; Less revemles I’@I0ll§ing to 1919 collected and I I Ile

‘ til

uncollected over and above amount estima

css road machinery purchased and cllarged

t ll e f balmy °“ Dec. sm, 1019 as corrected

‘ro/m external audit 1920

' llllt "Mori f°.'..'TI‘I`.'I.'f°.‘f..I).'e.'..If“dI° °f D°°' 2”"

dd undiscovered liabilities on that date aft I

' ' ' er-

‘vllfds paid

dd Lady Wood Estate li biiit vlotle to 1911 a Y accruing me'

l

ability Dec. 2nd., 1911 (co_.recie_i) _ ess “Sets as ner llnlllt 1011 ' `

et liability De¢_ 1911 et liability, above .. crease liiiiiiiiiy i-mm i§ec_

re 10111 111111 ii-_,_ ,,i,.0__i_i have ____e_ Permsnen-t Public Works iluilt inotlI1):;c'i_1:r?19"i

‘ e ou

°I °I`¢IIlllll‘)’ revenue

rr

$1.072,000.o0 _C

11,000.00 w

8,500.00 H

\vllo originated the lllovenlent? I

ho is pzlyillg this you-ng lady’-;-l ve vl-hrs lor the purpose of Orcf

.sa-l'a_l'y here? is it not t-lle Red i

(Il'os_s? A-llll wllen this society went to the lezttler of thc Govern cnt for it -grunt of mollcy for their nevoiellt olljcct, did not _tilci emiler say: “tio away! You boi'l'o\\' t<_ »- _ _ ve m lllewir and my svrllpn-Iordillllry clr<~lllnst_allccs t'il_ilsc_l_lriii_

1.001`.500.00 \\"

11027500.00 nl

- 1.070.-437.110 lit-

43.000.00 l’l'

___' ' ll

IIIIIIIW I I tl I i ` 'the H121-Ill report. I tllill-k the hon. "

e lat l 1

hi solllc $5,500,eilgsltlesoriinetgzgzllé me llB_l’mnnent ‘Dnlbllc works 0 _ _ __ s 0 $6l_000. what dlil

'Ill illends lost year expend-l 0 "lm un- first ulrcc items they ex end H 'Wa' :lim--lltcly not. one cent' pn sd all- I.""""III_ llllllllc works( tlleyp snllanrt "D ktlllt-tiling like $5,000. Here is :tn Se

mber for Georgetoivll (Mr JD

'rll .~ _ ' _ -

ls ‘-'hows lm increase ol' llelil lwellly-eigllt

€\V=l-lit-) has sllowll that it would fl'0m Dec., 1011 - I '. ‘ » - ere closed ‘I ~ - -

ve been _m____S________ ___ _______g un 00_ As ___ga_________til___I?_;el__.._1_5‘-111, $43,. iiilrillgi six motllths oil’ the year and urn-mont nligilt. help and llay hali- e___ime___ _O _______________ ____ ________m ____b____ works _O ____ e-l wo lluiit _lI_<_> schools closed for the your-_ tile youlrg Iudy`s office rent. 'i`ltllt s made to adopt the main report $240,000 out of tlrllihurcyxliélb , of Ilxgitiiilzif it mm! nf thII't~""`I9"""I' “S Is an hp dm' and mm is an “wi mm Y I B t' ln the nrt-s-t.l\t tl there icinf ti- l’n' ‘ . CIIIQ- ' ‘ ‘ -‘“"W*llly-Six ill -Ll -.1 - 1-rtzdit ili.- ('ovcnnnl:llt call take ill `li ‘I ` t movo alll ilLlll’tl;(l)lllIlll(l)cell)tIT we could 00| IIIIIIIE Illusmlzhslltoftopllbnu ‘vows Pio' IINOW "IV hon. i'l~ic1lll’lis Il(-tlllll III" "I“'Iil:‘l'-I '|`lle‘R1-tl i‘_ross (cull cast' .\"II ‘WI iiil cr stool We never even llnd il t-ll'lllcn to -nlullev. just ' lorrow the n e rl the credit they like for the Splvnil live or six illollslllld doilzlrs l I" I""`I I ' e that celellmictl ri-lmrtkllt all. .ill _vnllr so-cuafl-lgiiu me dm” Iolluy Ht-ltelment they lla.vc mnde. but l ll l'f1¢ll‘ Lowllrils tllv lll'llll'll oi the l

ilnllmullcilt mini would advise tlleinl -not wgniii to pnoilie 0-I’ til'|.~l 1ll‘o\'llll‘r-_ --t,o\vltl‘<ls dru.lllli:t'» - ‘ _

llut vnu kllow what. hull-

$1'070'437'83 as s-he is carlyillg it on now.

I want to ask the leader of the ro\v. . ____ Goverllinlcllt, Mr. Speaker, to mollilagc this situation. _H2 lvhclm is thc credit duc for t-llc pro- I tu' lllotiolrl of nlcdiczll illspcctioll ill il i _ _ _

llo-oi-3? Why was the l‘l'cm1lel' really no better than »l1tli.l.tl_3_

not honest enough to give credit roads. Now, this Provlllcc cnluoliy

here crodit is due? Is ii. not to l ne' OI'

the Reid Cross Society tllut the the credit is due? Is it not to Judge wi

ntszarti ami Dr. Jenkins, t'he nlcn the loan is colltrac _- _ _Wm-____

lla y 1 .g ._ . illy." But not a cent! At last

c ovpra»ncd his hoart to the cxtcllt

i' promising tilrti ilrlrilnps thc tiov- lny hon. l _________ ___ v__________

rg' “nd WIIQII they “Im II" IIIIII are seckilll; education along *II rllaps they can extract comfort m___,iC__i ii___,_,_ mme iiimi _wer im. the anlollllt voted for suilpiemeutf m the iigllrcs that I have quoted. _»___._, what my im___ i-_.i,_,ii_iS Malo tile tcnvilers’ salaries over the _ Alwlllcl' "-m0llllltlll” we not to- _i_,i,,'__ -___,,,i i c,,mm_.,,,i ii 5,, ,~,__,. __, lrmcinlt slnliliil-ly vctctl in 1018 oi _ In was I" LII” effect I'II"‘t “III it goes ~is simply this, that tilcy' 'I IIIII “II*‘l"‘-I* III I'I2II ‘III‘I9I`

at case, the y'ollll-g in y wio clt _,iii-nu., _- t _

re for the purpose of collduvting iiiiipi-_ iiigy have .'lct-ompllsll0il- iii;

ese illsilcctiolls. can say of the '|‘illl glol_l._l.c-.irli1_i~ ti_i__iIi_l_c_(_i_<i:ii>_l;i_i-i_____(______ ______ __________________ ______ ___e__ vcrnmellt, ill the words nf_ thc ment s nl' er ou in - l - -1 _ ' _‘_ ' __ _ _. i _______ _ by _.ei-e_._.i__g io iiia _,mid ¢_,.iimiiL._i_\_i_loie stllellle oliallliltetl ultil the

“Ml l got \v:ls sympathy tioil. 'I‘ile_arllollllt llltellded _to__ lT_____

Arid it wllsll’t any use to mc." spent by this provillce ill _so-cl _c<_i__e

gi, 11,111.1-_ii ii was in im, 1-ii_si»__ pcrlnillle-llt roads lssolncthllliz u\_el i____ itllout tho (Im/ct'll.'lllcllt’s say-so $1,:'l00.00‘I~ of UNH lH_ll_ll\‘I’._ $01 --:____ all, _illld with thc consent oi' lilo t)00»-~i‘0l'l_V _II9I`_ I'I'IIII'"`_I” "m“_mI" ___ lllstccs, sllc troultl ilnvo gollll frolll the lirlllllllitlll (love_l'illl_ll-.l_t_i _

-.,, -. , .. il l*1i\ilo _ _

I il sthool dlstliits just '1‘.lthi-. \\ili lltvt in >t lt _t_r ___ ______________ _____ ___)___________ “________ _“__ __

roupl lc ." . ,_ _ »

. .. .. . ,_ ' " i'-.l tie rov - _

e same .tlld tallied ml hcl wolk siluil (il_iv._§;i_i_t_)_ii__i)eii_il___iv5ii__i__)sii__ _O _______ ___ for __0__________ ________0_______.. Ami so

‘ ' r , . .

Citi

it is no use tryllli-Z I0 “ii”

nlolley is to bc_hol‘rowcd__ol; __ llrlose of building roads .lil ilie

ie justified ill horrowilllg mo

construction of such w_<>l‘l€___li_>i

lll outlast the DETIUII f°I “‘ I*

ted When \'l»ll

lorrow money PIIYHDIS ln _Li ll ., _ _ _

-f ' hlriidillg. for lustallcc. DON

'\\`Q "\()l'1l y _ ‘ - < -riod of youl

. ini: will olltlust thc UL ______`

bond Ill tho build-illl»I UI S' iii-iili;l»~i again, you are ill-“FIIIIQII III

In lllnnt-v llcvil-use unrl--l"

.~ ~' tl .t your hon

llxilhllllmiiltlzulciiltl llf llrillgc til-li

A 1"iolld thc (lonlnllissillll of

I’ul>lic Works c‘.' _ ltivi-,r, the piers of which fell Inio

iver a icw months ztftcl tlul

~ llll . _ WITH ,I . _. iiormwillit lllllllcy li I ' t ltlsiiilii " ' Hum' no 'tludsi. ‘Tho

liillgrts, but silllply dirt l _ _ ) 1 tlt' r'olll'~w, will he oi sollli-

Willllitlltllro, mimi.

. necessarily by

How then could we move nll lvln work illd

I '~‘II- W0 hllil .nlolc 1 1 .supplefis ‘titono litil ~ .' lilo welll-fare of tllrlso pool' clrillirt-ll built-lit. . _

tl is country \\'i\f'lf

'la lnd wilicll our friends d

» id not l- L

"itullo to n k endlmellt to it ill Onnrnlittcc as ti . I0 illil'l`o\' I" 0 hidwlllllllia

l 1 Im 0' of over $70300' Attorney General says wc sllolllfl yc:\l'>i i'1lrIt};T)::,(;_I:__,°I'veI` ll term 01' willtrll have 'appcrlrell in iii1i,.,- for whom my lloll. friontl nearly

' » 6 were d0iiig|yelll\s in the srllool report '[‘1ii._ l-ried; while the iiovorllllllollt t-all

I nloi me i.ii,ghwRyB ____

L 5 “I ‘I have done? A-s my hon fri:-i 1 than voll l ~ . ' ' ' - -

lt _ lavo .llld had wc done su Year the sudden tlisn-pimurmir-Q 1,1' :liford to give only its syrllpnilly.

.. _.

""" 'I"’I"y Blffienditllres th

I “I have knows I left at the time tl - '- t -W0 lfh - -

’ I” I"I"II" - “II” I IIJV0 llldllced the debt UN! 'IIHUFBS refturdillg the _-111110018 'l`ili- sylllqlatily of my hon. fllc-nd

polls drilills ill l .' _f ___ '_ _ you hllvt- at dirt r_o.l<l,- l`I_l_-i‘__ . ith; into thc dltlin nl -

uasl . _ . _ I- _ lin-_ Slvrins “lvl "YI‘_‘fI"

llille-l _ _ -` _ . -ws tllc rllllk l.:i.lsr~l~l

I""ll mario heretofore in the

nr i “'“¥ was bein _ . l » -

il IZ lirellurwd till. lllelnllers LV ll¢‘lllly $.!00,000, partly closed pro-iidpii my ._-ii.,i,i_ for the poor tlllildrell is lrll .l il.ll'iirost,- .lllti tha . __ _________ ______

ln ding permanent .bridges nnd

clllvorls ale saved t _ of the committed on thc (iovcrn- 'I`ilis is the recor -_ . _. ‘ ' - - __

_______ nndbtn ord¢int_i1_;iz_i<_;;ii6§i__i;;y Tn______i _tide __e________ S____we__ _____ ___________ ________ __________ "___ _e___<_i___i>f__il__i_._i_ltii;_:ii_ i-_I_i_l_l_l.~.___ _i_be§1lll_lio illvcstigrltc and‘i;\__li_ii__Li__i2__t-sylllllatlly for the leon.

were id tb the iend ' was . rowll on tile table. crllment now paints in black c ` ` 0 ms" " T-II” I"”I'“0I ` I » ' ', _ , ,,.

_ent on Iihe __c____B__‘;’:`_ gg I-low thell collld an amendment be No honest man who lllvcgtigxgé iiarinl would bel iirom about 0,_iOi__,_. _\\e not .l rcvtlluc i.t,.i_ yellr _of

_S-_mach on the Add__“______nd _ made to it? Thi; miimi-iiy i-_,pm-,_ 1111, i~,iii,ii_, __c,_,m______ Wm d________ _ - 9. till Ju-ly, 1020; and ypii know 3-»0.000flo_-nl1Ii|_llnr .sold fill lncdic.li_

im repented __ __m_¢________a_ was presented io i1ieii_o,_,_e by M_._ im,__:_,_. tim-i_ that __ov_______me_'__ hon. friends were elected illi‘illll'pose~s, i‘llo(.ovel-.llmcllt wtlsalsli-I mmite ____ e__De_________e of Mc-Lenn_.~wa5_ i~ecei,,mi _,mi i-icii _,ii ,___C_,e_____f__iiy t,_________g__ __ very i__ey_-wo__I_elll;Ko no dou-llt tllilt. when etl to Rive only ll small llortloll of over nnd above what we im(.on‘_;I;dl-\,ml1tie by llim and rliiiiclllt. pcniod, llnilt $240,000 worth they got so dilrvctlmr "lends Ummm: this mvmmc mIm`mS the ‘Wwmm

__ expended, on educnf.lon_ CC_" _O y e hon. -member for of ponmnllellt public works, and all the scllo l "raged they closed I" me svhnol Uhimmn' Nm Nm ,ln-uullon n»louL-tl mia we had t fe wn (Mr. stewart.) we intl left only nn lm-,reuse or l1t.~ll't or 'rl\erc`l os' “II” "9"" THAT ‘“‘*‘ “ “’I“"I”II*

no ave an opportunity to eeeonly $51000 at the end of their ardin 1;; another Smtamonlt re' UML was momy yn" `““m WE Ima

e ucation I w i iltt take That wills money

€|'Il|

Drovitletl for th t ., _ _

_Mi “_ a‘m°I"II- what was done ‘about it because term. is not that a record to be gui* friend I mnchauenge' lm r g 0 ` `

s take great credit for which you had no hesitation in

R. SEN

1|-i AR _ ‘AULT My 00"- the minutes of thc last meeting of prolud of? ___ _dm

° 5 I* 5310! -Elm ul? to the ilol-kctillg yourselves, however, nndi

"lid I I I

w____ _ n is address said that that the session are never reall ill the l will tako up for il few nlinutes 1-icnooi ii

" ~ 'I“I`I°I'I'* *md ieiiills the which you are figuring on next!

Dllt

'how m

y hon. friend built u hi t l

csg9_ He cllim. _“_ D s o gve the reason why this was of the truth has been told An - '

_ 'Mn W, done: the _.eport “__ _ _ - y a matter of fact my hun. friend the

"BW lf. body who has taken the time to Commissioner of Agriculture says

' , II - iI _ _

5 I .

_."' i ' _ _ iv" i _ ‘ . - ' . i 2 ___ _

ilo EXPMWDITURE they had 1-1

____ m __ _ __ ouse. Aherwards we found that the question of the publi- ;h l _

now. w,t;Il onlin] rI‘°;‘_;I__ tlkxl; ii thi minority report was -thrown _nnd when I have dealt w‘lthntil)I(l)18I Kgolilg tr.; dance' Im mmm” me year to "II mm" gm“I'°I` "“I"°“‘"I'

of fact our ____°__d! dm ou_ on a motion made by the Pre- will ask,penmiminll that the debate the yi/lestonli Oli tm tendenoot In NIM' my hon' mend "Im "Ike

___i____t year on E____c____o__ our _|_i1s<_s_;.r_i1_econ_?;¢;yb_;i’°t_il;_dv Aigorney ile_aiiJo_1lrnell. i was l-other as- pleasure -_,lv the acdoiivo 0101;]-in i?l§1tI'lIi° flll the credit he likes from this n nve the amount of th; pre- iii ' dn ge o ons e at some of the statements when -th _ ,mn - '

me Bum ___ .2______0_ w_i1_i;'__i;_c;s_iti_i>;lvei_o__e;I_i1doli_ti_rl'i¢:_i.lii_ii§ m_ade_tiln tilts s\lllJ_ect hy our friends came into °p0£;r thliy g:I;‘?Tn-Tsglll lizflhooo more than Hence before. You will nnd such ?lIlg°i<llir;l:l»rmg ;g:;t“haestn°ri'i)eggm' y°“"° had ““ “Ay ““‘° n axes and they record in the Journals of an ' e II “ I-T19 DBS!! y0n‘vu pam no taxes' ”tm_ _ y ses- a year ago there were fifty schools lint now w ‘i 1 ' ..... .... ..._ :.221 .l';'°,§:..ti..";";‘:is.;i:.; :ia -----”’°-‘-53 "-‘f--1°-El?-I” "I2

___ few _wm_dl__ Wig _i_\_l:tHpol;i; minority report. My hnll. friend tylrsrctiilgoolg I:-slfnctltfsiatlr onlhlitizolls =?i,;;eyIP IX_*:dKoirui__t0 make

on on n previous occasion att td th ' ° 9° 9 MODIS

Univ e nllo er matter in which only halt have had to do the dancing All

too. I would sllggest, when my hon. friend again wan-ts to pamde round like a julckdaw in borrowed feathers, that he make sure the feathers cover him completely. Oililerwiso (ms in'this case) they only cover him in part and we easily discover, through them, tho fact that he is only lx jackdaw gf. ter all.

At. 11.30 Mr. Arsenalllt moved

the adjournment of thc debate-_

__ ,_ i',\w vtnlrs thu dlaill hilt remade. 'i`llc llrllills, its -Ill porllry works, arc all vcr.V “"I___- bllt thc nluncy’ -*ll’9I‘I III II“`"f “fl Ilulllollbtt-diy have to llc sD<‘I\i 'I5“_ II and again. 'I`hc only llilfl OI I-Ie work that 'has any ilcrlnnllcllt-_v ls. u-, l said before, then-,lllverts and bridges that ‘will have io he hniii on the various projects and thest;

n

,. . - ~. V i' 1 f‘m.“ UVM `:m(.\ m_" -~ ' l tn hc l _ _ _ _ ___ _

we have heretofore llullt out “___ orllillnry revenue and have ne _ borrowed one cent for this `Iillr_D0-‘I“-

lt has -hcoll snitl that thcro wel‘0

I t miles of road built last year.

is x y »- ' little scelptical on th-is point,

I am a __ imcallse I know that the larseli

project the western road one is put down lltftwelve n'l'iles.-tllld 99 a .matter ot fact. there were only five miles of it ooilstmlntcd. Speak-ing about this pr0]9<‘l. It’-I me tell you, Mr. Speaker how woil prepared the Klommissiollel' of Public Works was to undel'i-like this _work. He estimated the yardage on that work at 10,000 yards. 'i`ilc project is not 'hy any means completed and already there

IS 1.( y ' , .‘.' - .

f"~"’"l (iflVl‘l'll`lll‘-’-lil 18 ¢|0illi-I Sl>If‘ll- ii,-9 _,i_i,,_n__,ii__p__ in i_e____,_i_ s____g_,_g iii 1-tilllilllisioll, tile_total ill<'rs>usc vo-

lil_d t_ilil1;:s ill pro-nlotlllg llllctlival _iw ___.i___(_i____ fi~iii_<_ iii,.n_ as iiiiiy toil by till- districts was only $16,-

SIIWHOII in I`I“II°"I5' WIIII II" tfolitillllillg the \vtll'k \vilil'il has

air of ilnvilllir i)l.tl'i'<llnlleil ,solllotililly i_______ __,__i__g ____ i~___. y_,_u__,_i _"Ni iiiigi _ _ _ _

ll‘i1ui`lIilI2Ll’i’. lll.V Illlll- ffifillii »~‘-'iyfi §,,ii~.i__ii,i__ii,,,i _,ii ii", im,-i iii' i1i,,_wilit-il the tlovcrlllllclli. ls taking __

hy' vm are giving that movenwm Pmmyim. mr II .Hunter .Ut “iii to tho llolllillioll (lovcrllnlelli.

the sympathy ipo\ss'iblc!" Ill sllolvs llo\v ll.lld pressed tlc I _ _ _

d l me ii 1., ,|111 wuut little of inlpo:-_ I rt-ici' now to the Higilwavs- pro- C

Itilill. I llllt lilero is illloiilvl' llliltier for

he folllld that al llunlhcr of clli-

I

crlillll-ut is l'l-|lol'tcil lu have _

l'v~isell that tilt-so rilzlllr-l were _ lc ll lllolllllnl-llt ill his lm--lllol‘_\'. _ lltltwsiillltl that in-oillo ill one '

-ilcillit' 1ll‘at'Ii<-ally llll1l:lszs‘iilil~- illlli

y stllrk up a sign llcsidc ont- of

t sonic good Salnlltritllll, ilasslllg ,_ and Ile-ill' iriclldiy inclined to'

tcnl, ilci\\'cvcl', the people were ;'_‘l_§I(_)_II-i_(_&_];c wifi-hi i__,i__g _.ned sign

.l,.I: S. s s _ ua' ‘ ' im

I crntment boasted last fall of the

have already dealt with the ollnt of contrillutioll made for

llt. I have slltzwll tha-t. the to- colltrihlltioll made last year,

ldv: tile year bcll`ol'e. was $2-1,000.

. . . . . i.i li

-1 $izls.000, li. wits, in lslifl, $187,- '

----all illtwezlsc, lllade ily ns, of ,(100, and that without ally ‘in- ase of taxes. I illrtlley pointed

t

rc \\'ilaicvt-.lr made ill inrreltse in

uh J' il 1-t>l'ta‘Ill that tzllnt hlliiti-

ie-'i aulllnrities. It was part II

glvtell for this was that they

there is any nlerit in tllc proposi-

tion tllell my lloll. friends sllollld

eral (iovcrlllmcllt credit. because _ without the aid they offered any '_ hon. fr-lends would never have cn- I tered upon this project.

1 mav say here, that when we I

the Federal grant, our friends who

it ill no llllimcasllrcd terms as all *

tion time to scare the electors.

s

\vt~,l't- to ilu llorl'il\vt.-tl alld that lt, \\‘ol|i|l nli-all l:ll'i,:t-ly illi'l'r~'.lso(l taxa- I' tion. And we l'\\|llr=llllll'r tile ilozld

the i`:l:'lllr‘l'.~: :llld to \\'ill'll thorn that

wlllllll Ill' vt-l'_v ilcilvily iilxvll.

\Vi-il. of vollrstl. thc people are I

lieillg Ilollvllly taxed. Very he-:lvily I` illllot-il not by us. inllt by tho very I llll-ll \\'hrl llllllililllootl talxlltioll :lildII who sl'nl'vil lilo ilotlillc into \'<ltilli:_!"

for tht-nl tlll this vt-ry qllc.-stioll. il

'I`ll<~ Imiltlol' ill lilo (lnvol'lvlllcllt_»"

.

said that t‘ilr-sc iliighw-nys wcreifi

.. _ 1

bilcso ruzllis. Ilui ill-, e~..l_\_~l iht=_\i

ti.

prllpriniiili: tht- nlolleys (somt- iiliriy or illirty-five tiloustlnd doi- lllrsl dl»l'ivell from alllto-lnohile ii- vcllsos to pay ollr silllrn oi’ the l'lln<ls`," How is he to rccllllcile thc-sc strllielmcllts?

l’Ri<11\iiFZR l'iEl.If-Tllat is not

what I sllid.

MR. AIISIGNAIILT: l have my

hon. friends very words. _He sxlid "lille road:-1 llrc going iio bo for farmers llnd not. for automollile.-1."

l’ltl~1MlI-JR BELL: Well, so they

art- to hc.

MR. ARSENAU-LT: l don‘t

think my ilon. friend will prolllhit them? Ile was. it is trlle, :tt one time vcry much opposed to them, becllllsn hc thollglllt he was reficct- lng the sentiment in his own dis- trici and in-:lllsn he though; lle could make politirnll capital by op positioll. But he woke up later to ilnd that 80 per cent of the resi- dents in his district were in favor of automobiles.

Ile honest enough to give the l~cd- _I-

IIII the 0X'Denditures »

_-___ _mi _.,m_i,u(,iv9 m an inieiilgem ____m_ __mu_ made, ln_t, of the Public A-ccollnts cotmlnit.

gh it was our fiscal year tee this I °

» . year-'tl il .. _ , . .- .___

le rst and only lllntillls in aglltllliulc. l`llc larger I}I‘§“_ I)I‘lf’» ll'llliS ‘lt-lt- t~lullll|l@li_t0 roads last then 1 fear he will not

.llllmber of tilrlnl are froln (,‘llal‘lot- II" ‘°IIII"II'IIII` 0" ‘IIB lf0\lStl'lllftl0l1 i

ive long ill lllstory. lt see-'ns to me that in the matter

he Iltrmillioll (iovcrnmexlt. as a

milk cow, and they have mllkcd

hut cow very sil-cccssfuiiy.` Not

wlil . - . __ I 'ml mom] II" IQIIIPI "I me olllv arc tilcv milking the cow for

1-cllllilrai educatioll, for zlgrlcllltllr-

at solllo ill ti 'I' 1 ~

eu II" “IIRII II" :ll edll~t~aiioll alld other purposes io

llc 1-xtcllt of some iillrty-live or ilil‘t_\'-,~'ix tilouslllld dollars, -hut they l‘l~ lllilkilli,; it to till- extent of six

.i' - . .' ,_ , ..-L”T..III..'03,-.¥”§I?Jii`.l .....§fIIl1ii2lIi "°"“f=“ '"°"°-""° "°"='= I" ‘°="‘S»

' _-\lld apart i'ronl that they have had

llrllrilt-iali willdfaiis -fro-ln the same

ollrtw-. IIUN. Mit. LEA: You Should

have ivllrllotl to milk.

Mit. l\l{Sl'II\'AUI.'I`: N0 dollhtl `Iilf-rc is one tiling about me ilow- vcr, I halve lll-vcr been a SUCK-

ll. friend the leader of the Gov-

aving that he made in the pur-

mol Innllmes by the Govern' chase oi coal-i for the public build-

ings. Again the Federal Govern- mf-nt lllld llccn the benevolent-god father who sccmcd to have adopted

llese poor llllfortllllatc orphans for

svt-rviloiiv ol:-ie had repudiated

ilrllll. 'l\ large quantity of coal

was ohlaillcll last full at a nominal price tram the Dalton Sanatorium and from the Convalescent _Home.

do not blame my hon. friends for n ln' .ttiullltage oi the Federal

lr 1., ' - -

aid in .this way, but they should ad-mit tile far-t. If lt were not

or the Dominion Government cum- llg to their rescue last year, to, he extent of some seventy-five

or cigllty tllousalld dollars, I really doll't know whcrc they would have been.

My llon. friends nlailltained that here is no "-i’lu\v" ill their system i iaxaitioll. Ihlt, iilero evidently

l-tilt wilt-ll thc <~l-t-tilt rightly lle- w_______ ___ ______ _-____w__ ___ _he _“___ _“__

ausc we had to have a remedial Ii passed this session ill order

CL we know' Iwhatevexz merit In tal le the Goselllnltnt to make

. ~ , o cl' l . . ' ‘ 1 .

me N In Um wqrk my h(.m` lle people dance the tulle of taxa-

ion. And so all additional wea- oll was provided-or rather adi- ollzll ammunition.

I ia

the pliltiorlll oi' Sir Robert Bor- I'I _ _ __ _ _ on ll ill 1011. The proposition was “I” II‘IV"' SEE" °“' mem mrs t. up to parlialmcnt ill 1013. and IIIIB "ther SIIII3 UI UI" HIIIISQ' durmg e Ilillorili Si-lliltlr tllcll iiltfczltell IIII’ III"I"I '______ _'_ _ ' __ _ _“__ 0 ilrojt-t‘t. 'l`llc only l'<\ll<nll III_I" fIIIfIII"° II” III I’ ‘I mII,‘Ia