Mrs. W.E. Cotton Wins Simpson Golf Trophy

The final round for the Dr. -1- Mrs. W. R. MacNelli 107 109 210 o. oimpeon trophy. emblematic of Mrs. G. G. Wood .... .. 114 the Ladie's' Provincial Champlon- M", A, J, Hgglgm , ship. waa played at the Belvedere Mu, wm, Bggr ,, , Golf Course Saturday with Mrs. Mrs M, McLeod W. E. CMWD. CHITIOEWWWH. the Mrs. J. P. Clarke 112 120 232 winner and Mrs. Emma Holman, Mrs. G. H. Buntaln .. 120 112 232 Summerside. the runner-lllh Irene Godkin . . . . .. 112 121 233 Mrs. T. W. L. Prowse. NHL 9301- Blanche I-Iogg . 122 115 237 ioent. Charlottetown LId1eI' 601! Marg. Macwiliiama .. 117 122 239 club. graciously presented the Mrs. N. MacLeod 114 125 also prizes to the following winners: Miss Iris McLellan 117 139 Mrs. W. E. Cation-Winner. Miss sally Euler 132 254 Mrs, Emma Holman-Runner-up. Mrs, McKay , L L Mrs. Murray Melilsh-Winner Mrs, MacAlplne , . 130 .. .. isl. Division. 1st Division Miss Marjorie Stewart-Runner s c Tu up int Division. Mrs. Murray Mellieh 114 102 316 MM. A10! HUFHO-Winner 1-OW Miss Mari. Stewart 120 114 234 Net Summerside. Mrs. H. J. Brown .. 117 120 246 Mrs. Murray Mellish-Winner Mrs, Ron Parker 121 251 Low Net Charlottetown. Mrs. Stuart Weir 137 121 2511 Miss Jane Pett - Summerside Mrs. Ron Norman .. 120 134 260 Winner Sealed 1-Iole. Mrs. S. MacDonald 173 129 266 Following is the finals score for Mrs. A. 1-Iowan 135 132 237 the rounds in Summerside and Miss .1:-an MacD,enn,,125 142 357 Charlottetown and , Summerside. Mrs, Edythg Dada; H 121 143 259 in the legend 5 indicates the Mrs. Jean Lldstone ...126 148 27-1 Summerside score and C the score Mrs. J. Cerry . 131 I45 216 anfthe Charlottetown course. Miss Jean Nicholson 138 138 276 Championship Flight Miss Marian Howatt. 146 152 298 S C Ttl. Mrs. F. Henthorn 155 155 310 Mrs. W. E. Cotton . . 102 93 195 Miss Connie Enman 160 162 322 Mrs. Emma Holman I02 94 190 Miss Jane Pett 168 100 334 Mrs. Alex 1-Iorne 00 101 107 Mrs. Earl Baker . 119 - -

BFC Lowers

In Abbreviated Card

Bonnie Frisco Can, a bay mare rlriven by George Sobey of Sum- merside lowered her track record by one and three fifth seconds here Saturday night in a racing meet that was called off at the end of lhe fourth dash on account of rain.

Sobey drove Bonnie Frisco Can over the mile in 2.14. 3-5. The I-'risco mare was forced to her rec- ord breaking mile by Bessie Bud- lrvfig and Lassie Lucille who fin- Ewrl a close second and third.

Bessie Budlong set the pace and led almost. to the wire. Bessie open- ed a good lead at the five eights pole but Bonnie Frisco and Lassie Lucille. gained on the back stretcr and upper turn. Both horses camc nn in the stretch with Bonnie Frisco winning by a half length and a photo being needed to decide second place between Bessie Bud- lnng and Lassie Lucille.

Norine Grattan. Wait N'See and Mllldale were the other heat win- ners. Wait N'see. who has been a winner in his three trips to the gate. trotted his way to victory with I stretch drive Saturday night. Len 0'Mesra drove the bay gelding on the outside most of the mile but the old warrior showed plenty 'of stamina in coming home to win in 2.18.

Milldale was an easy winner in the fourth race as Willard Kelly took her to the top at the five eights mark. Carl Aubrey finished second and Frankie Budlong a close third.

Norina Grattan led from pole to pole in winning the opening dash.

First Base

Norino Grattan (Smith) Ramona Peters (MacNelli) . 1-Iardroad Bill (Stead) . . Kitty MaoKay (Fit.z.Pat1-ick) Miss Hazel Grove (E. Smith) Glenda Mae '(McGuigan) . Anita. Budlong (Moi-eside) .

Time: 2.19 3-5: Norlne Grattan owned by Arnett Bell and driven by Cyril smith: psri-mutuels: :9.- I0, 5.50. 3.80; 08.70, 4.20; 53.00.

leoond Race

Walt N'Ses (O'Meara) .. Judy Kalmuck (W. Kelly) Joandale (Cudmore) Jimmie A; (Reeves) .. April Bud (L. Kelly) Winnie's Last (Shea) Billy Aubrey (C. Smith) Time 2:16; Wait N'see owned by George Gregory and driven by Len 0lMc,ara: pari-mutueL9: 08.50, 5.80. 2.90; 57.00, 3.40; 52.70.

Third Race Bonnie Frisco Can (Sobey) . Bcssln. Budlong (Collins) . l.as.:le. Lucille. (O'Brien) Marion l-1. (Kelly) ..

.19-.-Auto...

.:ac:-guess.-

Record

Belwin Budlong (Ogeara) . 0 Belle Budlong (MacDonald) . 7 Time: 2.14 3-5; Bonnie, Frisco Can owned by Messrs. Clarke and Home and driven by George Sobey; pari-mutuels: 012.50, 5.20. 2.70; 54.50, 2.90; 03.20. Fourth Race Milldale (W. Kelly) . Carl Aubrey (Kennedy) Frankie Eudlong (Lowery Lily Marlene (Campbell) . Face Cloth (Sobey) Guy llarvester (Reeves) Lady Abner (C. Smith) . . . Miss Commando (Llewellyn) . Time: 2.15 3-5: Mllldale owne and driven by Willard Kelly.

High Quality Racing Seen in Fulurilies

..,.. The high quality of the annual Futuritiea was pointed up last year by the record breaking perform- ance of Dr. J. A., Truro owned entry which set a new Maritime- bred record for three-year-old pac- ers. of 2:12 1-5.

There are a number of colts this year which are capable of giv- ing the records a scare.

The trotting record for two- year-olds, 2:22 1-4 was made at Charlottetovvn on Sept. 7. 1936 by Guy Kalmuck, owned by Mr. Geo. B. Lewis, Charlottetown, and driv- en by Willard Kelly. Guy Kalmuck was by Kalmuck, dam Ima Guy.

Royal Bank by Federal. dam Volo Ray, and owned by Frank A. Ryder of Moncton. established the two-year-old pacing record 2:19 1-5, at Charlottetown on Sept. 13, 1951. Royal Bank was driven by Harley Harrison.

The three-year-old record was written into Charlottetown track history, Sept. 12 last year by Dr. J. A.. which clicked off the mile in 2:12 1-5. Dr. J. A. is owned by Doctor J. A. Donahue of Truro, and was driven by Ray O'Brien. Dr. J. A. is by Slmcoe Harvester out of a Calumet Budlong mare.

Hillside Scott by Bellini Scott. dam Nessie. set up the three-year- old trotting record at New Glas- gow, Nova Scotia. on Sept. 13, 1930. Hillside Scott was driven by Johnny Conroy.

SNAP SHOT FINISHING

Rolls of Film developed and printed. 24 hour service. Double size prints. Any roll of 0 ex- posure only 40 cents. R4-print! 4 cents each. Mail Film Service,

D.:.o.:cxq.a:.as:..-

claunu

Bnh Canuck (Gregory) .

Charlottetown.

SEPT 11 0150.00 -- 0175.00

Rcjcciion and draw for

. Draw for Tuesday

1

OODWILL RACES

THURS. & SAT. NIGHTS

Classification will appear in this paper Wednesday

l Wednesday 10:00 am.

, 1 MATINEE RAGE

MAPLE LEAF SPEEDWAY Mu:NElLL'8 MILLS

WEDNESDAY, SEPTEMBER. 10th A! 2:00 O'CLOCl( SHARP

oooa Canteen -- Loud Speaker

MIcNelIk Mills

and 13th. - 5200.00 DASHES '

Thursday and Saturday

Colt Races

10:00 am. e

- ROY MURPHY

1Il1'rLE SPORT. W.

PAGE six Sports Forum

BASEBALL CONTBOVEBSY

Sir.-If the present controversy over the Junior Baseball Game is to be cleared up, it is felt by many that the suggestion advanced by Freddie Maccabe is the best solut- ion to the present yak-yak by all woncemed.

The majority of leagues through- out Canada have in some way. an overall executive to which com- plaints and protests are submitted for final decisions. These com- plaints are given 9. hearing and the decision is binding to all players or teams. If P. E. I. is to have some body to which complaints and pro- tests are heard it is suggested that the Department of Physical Fit- ness take the initiative in setting up this governing body through the various ball clubs throughout the Island. With each club sub- mittlng four or five names of per- sons interested in ball, have these men brought together and form a governing body of three or five persons to examine complaints and protests which are presented to them. Had such a. body been in existance 'the present hostility be- tween'Charlottetown and Sum- merside would have been subdued by the action and decision taken as to the eligibility of the persons concerned participating in future baseball.

As to Mr. Clark's suggestion (Saturday's Guardian) that Sum- merside take the initiative and for- bid any inter-city sport, this would practically wipe out sport on the island. I am sure we would not want to see a wholesaler in ()n- tario or Quebec refusing to buy 05,000 bags of potatoes because he found one or two bad ones. Let us be sensible now, rather than be sorry later.

I am. Sir, etc. D. R. Rll-IODENI-IIZER Charlottetown.

T00 SELF-RIGHTEOUS

Sir.-During the past week, it would seem the most important sport news has been the "so-called" baseball scandal at Memorial Field I say "so called". because the more I think of it the more I begin to wonder if the people responsible for all the talk are thinking serlouslv

Iouaal

THE GUARDIAN. CHARLOTTETOWN

Indians Gain Ground On. Yanks; Dodgers Win

Cleveland Indiana gained ground on New York Yankeesin the Amer- ican League pennant rsce Sunday while Brooklyn Dodgers enlarged their lead over New York Giantsin the national to five games.

Husky Mike Garcia and Steve Gromek pitched tip Indians to 4-0 and 3-1 victories over St. Louis Browns to cut the Yanks' advant- age to two games. The Yanks de- feated Washlngton 5-1 behind the eight-hit pitching of Ed Lopat and n g1-and-slam pinch-hit home run by Johnny Mlze.

Preacher Roe, a. surprise starter backed by four home runs, hurled the Dodgers to it 4-1 victory over the Giants in the third game of their live game series which will be completed Monday with a day- night doubleheader.

Other American League games saw Boston Red Sox trounce Phil- adelphia Athletics 12-5 and De- troit nip Chicago White Sox 4-2. In remaining National League games, St. Louis nosed out Pitts- burgh. 4-3.

Chicago Cubs tripped Cincinnati 3-1. and Philadelphia Phlllies edged Boston Braves 2-1, after the Braves completed Saturday night's suspended game by posting er 3-1 triumph.

Garcia blanked the Browns on six hits in posting hLs 19th victory and fifth shutout in the opener at Cleveland. The Indians solved for- mer teammate Gene Bearden for only four hit.s but bunched two of them along with two walks to score three runs in the first inning. Luke Easter tripled in the first run and Harry Simpson the next two with a double.

The Indians also were outhlt in the second game 8-5 but the Tribe won out in the third when Wally Westlake's easy fly to centerfield

with the bases loaded was blown out of J. W. Porter's reach for a three-run double.

Mlzc's game-winning homer was his first in Washington's Griffith Stadium. The blow gave Mice the distinction of hitting a homer in 15 major league parks including Baker Bowl, former home of the Phillies. The blow also was the Big Cat's 354th of his career.

The Red Sox continued to plast- er the friendly left field wall at Fenway Park in smashing the A's Boston's 12-hit attack included homers by Dom DiMaggio and Hoot Evers and a three-run double by Johnny Lipon. Llpon's two-bugger featured a seven-run eighth inning rally that snapped a 5-5 draw.

Lefty Ted Gray gained his 12th victory for the tail-end Tigers in turning back Chicago. He scored twice himself on a pair of singles Johnny Groth drove home two runs.

Roe limited the New Yorkers to three hits, one after the first in- nlng, in taking the measure of Sal Maglie, an old Brooklyn nemesis. Home runs by Gil Hodges. Pee Wee Reese. George Shubn and Billy Cox cooked Maglle's goose.

The Giants. who swept a twin bill from the Brooks Saturday started off as though they would make it three straight. Al Dork doubled and Whitney Lockman singled for a run in the first. After that Roe slammed the door until the ninth when Monte Irvin doubled with two out.

The victory was Rae's first over New York since July 4. 1951.

Emos (Country) slaughter was the big gun in the Cards' triumph over Pittsburgh. Slaughter. tripled home three runs in the eighth and singled with the bases loaded in the ninth to give relief pitcher Al Blazle the victory.

Dairymen Even Softball

Play Offs Wi

before letting off steam.

Let us remember that these teams are Junior teams and are, made up of boys in their teensi This was a series for the Island Junior Baseball Championship and all members of both teams were; keyed up to the highest pitch. so the strain was too much for two of the boys and ihey lost thc' heads - and pushed the umpl around. I will be the first to admit, that they did the wrong thing, but, that in itself is not a scandal or a. spectacle. The scandal and spect-' acle occurred when our sport fansl ran on the field and caused sucnl confusion that the game had to be called. Remember Umpire Jim 1-Iogan did not award the game to Summerside because of the action of the two players, but because the, fans would not leave. ihe field.

The Abbie coach was given ten minutes to clear the field and had the field Just about cleared when two fans started fighting and be- fore you could say "You're Out," the field was once again packed with the same fans who are now going around shaking their heads and saying, "Wasn't that a dis. graceful exhibition." Yes, the same fans who run when they see the collection can coming. or who put five or ten cents in it to see a bunch of boys play their hearts out for nothing but the self-satis. faction that comes with winning I game. Yet, these fans pay as much as 51.60 two nights a week in see hibhly paid athletes fight. push. and punch referees around the ice and actually stand up and cheer them on.

We've all seen it. Yet when two boys lose their tempers for a few minutes these same fans want them barred from sport for from one year to life. Do they honestly think that would be a fair thing to do to, these boys?

our sport writers are saying that somelhing should be done, and rightly so. But surely nothing so severe as one or two years sus. pension as some would have it. That would mean the end at ,1 baseball career to a junior player as this is the time in his life that he learns the game. What would we think if in our courts the judges sentenced first offenders on minor charges to from one yen- to life ? Sounds unreasonable. doesn't it? But its no more unreasonable than some so-called sport ran, are asking for in this case. I think. as many others do, that we should have I. baseball commission to deal with the players and such incidents as this. As for the fans. no one can deal with them but themselves.

I honestly think the reprimand these boys have taken apart writers will have a much more lasting effect than a sus- pension which will do no one any

I .

In all fairness to all concerned let us stop being so, self-rightous and start being the true sport fans we think we are.

I am. sir, etc. i E. S. H. Charlottetown.

CANADIAN TOBACCO

The total farm value of Can-

adale 1901 tobacco crops was goo, 21300 '

1 POPULAI STYLE

The single. detached house in the predominant type of dwelling

from the 3'"

The John Kelly coached Sun- shine lsland Dairy clmbed hack mm the running for the City Lea- gue Softball title yesterday after- noon by defeating the Liguorian Youth Club 21-17 in a game play- ed on (he old Diamond.

For the Dairymen it was their second straight vvin over the L Y C and their victory tied the series at two games each. The fifth and deciding game will be played Tue- sday evening possibly on Memorial Field.

The milkmen won the game in the middle innings by scoring 18 of their 21 runs in the third. fourth filth frames. The L Y C scored in all but the fourth inning. Their best inning was the fifih when they they came up with seven runs. '

Charlie Ballem went the, dis- tance for the winners. He struck out three and walked seven in picking up his first win of the ser- ies.

Jimmy Gauthier started on the mound for (he 1.. Y C but retired in the fifth inning. Gauthier was in- jured in a collision at the plate in the second inning and the effects showed in his hurling. will Shep- hard finished the game and held the Dairymen to one run in the last four frames.

Cliff Jackson locked the

Baseball Results

SATURDAY National league

First Gomez- Brooklyn 000 001. MI. I I 4 New York .-. 010 102 01: 0 9 I

Erskine, Moore. (5) Lablne (7) King (R) and Campanella; Con- nelly, Wilhelm (6) Corwln (8) and Westrum.

only

second game:- Brooklyn . 010 200000 I 4 1 New York 801 101 01! 7 12 2 Rutherford, Wade (7) and Walker; Henrn and Wutrum. illnclnnatl 002 000010 I 0 0 Chicago 0l000000l 1 N 0 Podhielan and Roui: Klipp- lleln, Minner (9) and Atwell. First game - Bosfan ..... .. 0 10 1 Philadelphia (17 innings .

Jester. Chipmnn (11) and Bur- ris; Roberts and Burgess. Secnnd game:- Bmlton .... 120 000 00 Philadelphia 000 100 0 (Game suspended in last 8th. curfew; to be completed Sunday) Johnson and Burris; Drewa and Burgers. Pittsburgh .. Louis (10 innings) Dickson and Garaglola; Brazie (8) and D. Rice. American League Flrxt gsme:-- Phllatlelphla 000 M0120 I I 0 Boston 001. 020 001 0 ll 1 Sch!-lb. Fricano (6) Mslarazzo (B) and Aatroth; Parnell and White. Second gamer- Phiiadelphia 000 110 000 3 0 0 Boston s.....-. 40! 10000110 11 1 Bishop, Keliner (5) and Muf- rriy; Nixon and Wilher. st. Louis ...-. 000000000 0 I 1 Cleveland 014 001 I0: I I0 I Cain, Stuart (3) Fannln (0) and Courtney; Lemon and Tipton. Chicago .. 00000010001 0 A 0 Detroit ... 00000000000 0 0'0 (11 innings). l

0010000000 4 I 0 0300001108 111 I

Haddix.

in all Canadian provinces except

Quebec.

Dohnon, Doriah (0) and Sheely. Continued on peg

th 2nd Win

homer in the free scoring game when he drove one of Gau(l1icr's offerings into deep left field. Len Arsenault of the Dairytncn hit two triples and Jack Hcnnesscy of the L Y C had four singles.

The game was handled by Mal- ,colm Maclilayden with M. Mono- 'ghan at first base and Ted Flan- ilgan at third.

Lineups: '

S. I. D. -- cheverie ab. Dunn c. Jackson ss, T. Moore rf, L. Arsen- lault cf. L. Gaudet 2b. R. Carroll lb. C. Bailem p, A. Carroll if Y. C. -- .l. Bradley ii. A. Shephard lh, W. Shephard lib. B. iLanna11 2b. F. Shcphard H. J. ll-iennessey c. J. Gauthier p, M. Peters as, A. MacDonald cf.

lid.

rLinescore: is. 1. n. .1... 1.-as 510 010--21 11.. Y. C. . 121 012 112--17

Sedgnhnwliihs Tennis grown

FOREST HILLS. N.Y.. Sept. 7 - (AP) -, Australia's Frank sedg- man, the world's No. 1 tennis play- er. stormed past 38-year-old Gard- nar Mulloy of Miami, 1713.. 6-1, 6-2. 8-3 today to win the United Stlwes men's singles championship for the second time.

It missed only by one game tying the all-time record for one-sided hidings in the final of the event. Bill Tilden gave up only five, games in trouncing Wallace 1". Johnson back in 1921.

Mullcy won six, half of them in I gallant third set. The time of the mis-match was 41 minutes flat, al- most certainly a modern record.

When he had recovered his breath. Mulloy apologized to the throng for having "ruined" the final. "Next year." he observed. "Sedgmsn will be It year older. and then I'll get him."

Maureen Connolly. the 17-year- nld from San Diego, retained her women's title almost as decisively as Sedgman did the men's. She dedeated Doris Hart of Coral Gab- les, Fla,. now Ii four-time loser in the finals, by scores of 0-3. 7-5. but it was not really close.

For Quality Miidness

(lXX.illX 5

WKIX.) I. l()ll)((.)

l,l.'tXI tl ('l(..ill?l i ll

Value

SEPTEMBER 8, 1952

Rifle" Shooi

Following are the results of the Rifle Match fired at Squaw Point on Saturday. Sept. 0.

Cst. R. Barwise .. 40 4'1 90 Capt. Roy Mccabe . 40 40 95 Major G. A. Macdonald 4'1 40 93 Mrs. G.J. Rogers . .. 50 45 93 Tpr. W. Gamble 40 92 Lt. Mary MacLennan .. 44 47 ill Capt. A.J. Mccabe .. 44 46 00 Sgt. I-'l.C. Younker .. 43 46 ill) OfC. L.V.A. MacDonald 46 43 iii? Gnr. W. E. Hardy .. 44 44 ill! Sgt. P. J. Landrigan . 47 41 E8 CPO. A. Costello 44 43 H7 Tpr. R. Andrews . 45 42 87 Lt. P. T. Hooper 45 42 B7 CPO. B. G. Bowles 46 41 87 Cadet W.D. MacDonald 42 44 as Tpr. M. Carver .... .. 44 41 83' Sgt. W.L. Crockett 40 43 B3 LfS. W. Judson .. 45 02 Major W.1-I. Poole 48 an Cadet P. Lanclrigan 41 82 Lt.-Col. W.J.