1 `/.

_Challenges Statements A . A j

;0f -G'o~ve-‘rn ment Leader

Senior Conservative Member For Charlottetown Deals

Trenchantly W1th<Sub' ect jMatters = In 'S eech 'F rom Throne And Reviews Inactzon Anclincompetence Of

~ i

(Continued) '

Provincial Le8l81lt\u'e. March 13. pebatc on Draft Address. Dr. W.J.P. McMillan (continued from yester- dayfs Guardian):

’ sums, as trauma,

Even yesterday. in dealing -with

this matter, the Premier referred to ms .audit Board as beins "appointed by the Government." If he wantsd ,D egplaln the neu so that more would be no misunderstanding, he might have said that the Finance Department of the Federal Gcvam- ment referred the matter to an Aud- it Board which was a standing insti- tution, appointed several years ago. His statement yesterday was confus- lng, and there was no reason for making it, because it was a very rimple transaction and could have been explained clearly in a few words. Perhaps Use most important mis- rtatement wa.s‘the one which refer- red to the auditors' work as in the nature of a "final adjustment." I hope the Premier can explain how that expression came to be used in the Patriot's interview. He made no reference to that statement in his speech yesterday, but the House and ite country in general is surely en- titled to some explanation.

surrncmawrsuy 'CLAIM

The Premier says he flied a suppla- mentary claim while at- Ottawa.

Fresh Vegetables `

For Little Money

Growing of Crisp Vegetables in your garden not only saves monsy and reduces cost oi’ living-but pro- vides healthful employment and fur- nishes liberal supplies of Fresh Food for the Table.

Write Wm. Rennie Co.. Limit/ed.

Toronto, Canada for copy of new Catalogue. THE' VERY BEST SEEDS THAT GROW ABE RENNIES

ul", Grill

f P Q J-

.a13t4§“ oéq %,_;‘_O,o

" $0; ’o%`f° %“'¥°.5-2;# X

'¢»;~:‘o»

rf’ .=&,.e';°.~<.>`_b __ . \'» ei

Wesiingilouse

._l._-.___.>....1._-».___.-

,ALL 'Ill ll'i'¢!ll1| U'lDl'lll-I

Alwallasotbaritsmsin

rcdtirltou

.i ici Eiis iiigii. slialti

uswheoyoummg

Ti” ‘Rvws ‘f Hefdwew Co..

u-iauuual,au

-. if _\/j1cto1°-Rad

ELECTRDLA

Thai. I presume, is the document which appeared in the Patriot of Jan. 29th. bolus "a memorial nied with the Federal Govemmentby the Government of Prince Edward Island on January 21st." According tothat 111911101111. there’was a~b`als.ucs in our favor of $5,915,980.” at Ottawa. Take that away from the $800,000 which we borrowed, and we have a bill-D¢° 0! $8,1'l5.93l.l8 arrears of subsidy in lieu of public lands. and for this tlie Province should get an additional annual payment of_t408,- 796.94. which, together with the an- nual subsidy now received of $163,- 617. makes a total of $512,413, which is the amount of land ‘subsidy to which Prince Edward Island is en- titled to in future. .Well, let us hope that we are going to get it._ r But I understand there was anoth- er mamorlal prepa_red..I-' wonder if they Premier filed this one It ap- pears in the Patriot of `Jl.u. 21. 1030. and it is issued under the-authority of the Hon. W. M. Lea." "Acting Pre. mier." (That was one tim; he got ahead of the hon. member from Rusticoil This memorial is describ- ed as a "ps.n1ph1et" purporting to give the correct amount of our claims' against the Dominion Government.

(Dr. MacMillan _then read the

claims set forth in detail in the lat- ter memorial, which made a total claim for annual subsidy against the Dominion Government of $3,812,160.- 57). .

In addition to that, according to l-Nl Damphltt. there is also a claim for cash payment as follows: Darn- ages arising out of expropriation of Banatorium, $100,000. Maintenance of public bulldinll. $100,000. Amount- ing to another 8200.000.

I suppose that is a serious claim?

From what I was told, it was pre- pared by way of a joke. Probably the "Acting Premier" at that Mme, when he has the opportunity, will explain it.Butifourela.ln1snowarefor ss,s‘:z,xsss1. it is going is make the Premier’s clsim look rather small.

, DALTON SANATORIUM

There ls one item in this ruatlsr

to- which I might direct attention at the present time. That is for damag- es arising-from the expropriation of me muon susmr-rm, simian. Here is one mausr wnienthe mau- ier of`Agricultura can explain to this l-louse, because he is the responsible party., Two years ago, on the iloor of this House. I drew his attention to it. I did not'get any answer.-Last year. unfortunately, he was, unablé to be present. Now he puts it in a statement of our claimsfpublishad in the Government organ under his authority. so he evidently realises that I was right when l ill him about this matter. I wonder if he realises that he was negligent in his duty when he attended as the repre- sentative of -the Government of Prince Edward Island, the confer- ence at which this matter was ilnall! disposed of? At that conference, when questions were asked of this Province as to what amount of mon- ey we would take as a cash settle- ment, my hon. friend was uuabla,to answer. l-le came home'for further consultation with the Premier, and that, so far as the recordi show, was the and of lt. lt was a tnost unfor- tunate thing that ws did no have at that time mcn_who were capable `of grasping the situation. Men who rc- preaanted the Government of the rroviaes ohms have mo sais _io make a bargain that would have saved the Province many thousands of dollars which have ,since como out of the pocketi of nearly everynaau. mam sos sans is mos. umm mana. aecausclast year. _when thlt splendid Banatorium campaign, was on. every clttaen responded as well as he or sbs could iri"order‘thst a necessary institution abouldbe' built to combat the spread of that dread disease, tuberculosis. lt was'anfar- inns than the meh of--tau ru- vinee were sallpallal to do thai. N- esasa msn repnasaiius pegs, yous |g»,ha|l|a|naaagsdaad bangle(-tlaa'situa‘tisu.' (Applause). ‘

'no question is. whether Nl WI be able to get that uiattar-adjusted nov. 'mere is cults adlilucncs of opinion on -that point. louis ilill 0015100! aretothsalsctthstaolaimofthat ami' never aspires undef- staul, main

.V+ 'E iii iii?- sill? lite

Minister - of Agriculture more than any other individual, to seo that this claim is pushed to the limit. And we hope that~you will be able to realize on it. (Loud Conservative applause).

. Announcement Not so Pleasant

At the end of the Premiers dis-

course on our subsidy claims, he ex- pressed tho hope that he would have a pleasant announcement in make next year. Ist us hope so. It will be something that this House will ra- celve with very much pleasure and gratitude. lt will be an announce- ment that will be received with very much more grace than the announce- ment which the Premier had to make yesterday. M I said' before, it is surc- ly. time the question was settled;

surely time i.hat the rights of this Province were recognized. lt does not make for better feeling. for co- operation and unanimity to see cer- tain parts of this country treated so generously, and other parts, espec- ially the Maritime Provinces, treated so mlseriy..

'Ihc Premier went on to deal with the

Maritime Winter Fair at which he de- livered the opening address. And would you believe it, Mr. Speaker. at that Exhibition he again got into trouble. ills tongue got him into dil- lcuitiea again. His statements were quoted aiiover the Maritime Provinc- U, all over Canada in fact; and they were taken tonxaan that he was ad- vocating Maritime Union.

HON. MR- LEA: They were mls-

quoted. '

HON. M11. STIZTWART: How do

you know?

HON. MIR. LEA: I was there and

listening to him, and I have read the report, and they were certainly mis- uuoted. Misquoted or misinterpreted.

DR. MMMILLAN: That is differ-

ent. Ware they lnisquoted, or were they misinterpreted. which?

HON. MR. LEA: You can take

either end of the dilemma you wish. They were certainly not as they were printed.

DR.. MacM1LLAN: ln the Canada

Press?

tened to his remarks and I read what _was stated; and they were not whatrhs said at the time. DR.. Mac.M1LLAN: Why did not the

Minister of -Agriculture make that sawdust is the emu, at the umev

You know, it is not very diillcult to get my hon. friend in write letters. in tho_pr¢`s.` That is one of the things that he has been criticised for. Even my hon. 'friend from New Haven <‘Mr. Angus McPhee) says that the Minis- ter likes to be in the limelight. well. he had a glivrlous opportunity had he tried to correct the l'rem!sr's re- ported'-statenaenta at the Maritime Fair! (Applause). But he failed to do so, and it leaves us in this situ- ation, that we cannot rely on the Canadian Press reports; they either misquote or they mlsinterpret the Premier when he speaks.

HON. MR. LEA: That is correct. DR.. McMILLAN: I refuse to be-

lieve that the canadian Press either misquoted cr misinterpreted him.

HON. `MR. LEA: Well, he didn`t

make that statement, you can take my word for lt, and I ask you to ac- cept it; because 1 heard him and l read what was reported the next day.

Dn. McM1'Ll-AN: limi you had I

great opportunity to correct it, and you dldu'ti (Applausei. You see how -much harm it has done since.

HON. Milt. LEA: It has not done

any harm. .

HON. MR.. B'1‘l.'WAR.'l`; what do

you know about lt?

DR. McMl'LLAN: It is just anoth-

er oase of a man talking iirst and thinking afterwards. It is a pity you didn't make the suggestion to him

-HON. MB- LEA: I don't care. I lis-|

"` ' “"“ I = M : m

Tb: fsmour RE-45 - Mui: from air or record: with equally wonderful tons! qual- ity. Prirs - complete will: tube: $575.

library of Virtor Rerordr wi/bout additional r/urge.

VICTOR TALKING MACHINE COMPANY OF CANADA LIMITED, MONTREAL

Saunders Administration °

ui C1 g.

Q D

EVERY purchaser of :lie famous RE-'45 Victor

Radio with Electrola now receives the instru-

ment compiete, not only with all tubes, but wich record compartments equipped with a library of .Victor Records, at no increase in price. You too, may now enjoy this marvelous musical reproduc- tion . . . free . . . both from air and from records.

Think of enjoying the latest hits and popular dance music, classical selections too, and a wealth of ,vocal offerings by the greatest soloists of today.

_Victor is willing to give you a $25.00 free "taste" of records universally loved and enjoyed, to prove to you how good Victor Radio with Eiectroia really is. Sec this marvelous collection of records. Hear this splendid instrument. play records one moment - and radio broadcasts the next - a radio and an Elecuola in one. Always music, _whether there is something on the air or not.

with a LIBRARY 0

9”'- -ea __ N *_g_ _N f _ _ g .gr-nc cnagwrrgroww-Gpagpvnm _ I,AGE,§§§é‘-3

._.______T_

l .- 1-.--.

»~.

# fe

g-as-,

5 A ..

., -7..

r r -»_'.l

e a-a'~

VICTOR ECC DS

. l

. ,E

AT NO INCREASE _ IN PRICE - - - -

r 1 ,

Know the amazing truth about Victor's latest development, know it at our xpense, but listen to the living voice of Victor and then you, too, will say "Here at last is the finest radio record instru ~ ment in the world.”

, ,. | N .J

Your Victor Dealer will pu: :lie RE-'45 into your F b ` ' I .V home today for a small down payment. Bc sure .

you ask for the free retard collection, as this .ffer

--the only one of its kind-is limited

. i-

nf.

from your Victor Dealer how you also may

To prment RE-45 and 46 owners: Find out T `

acquire the free record library. ,

l _*__ ,_ H ___

V 525 free Victor Record offer went into Dominion wide force in this cilu,

February /Sth lfitlrout public announcement. Purchasers liked if so well that ue now giie it the widest possible publicity

/ I.

119

. , ~ / ,rf \

_ _

._ __\`

~ ,» r

J. __. /`

..... ,.M..e§.r€‘=_.-<<..v.<>,'.ff-/--'“

‘ any objection taken to it, only by --~ i the loc., newspapers' eanor Gulton of Milo spent Sunday' ` 1 ith lati ' in 'icin '_

Mr. Norman McLean and Miss Ei

DR. McMtL1.AN: what do you AND VICINHY W ft we this\ it:

‘mean by the local newspapers. The _ , '__- Pli»l‘|0i? Mrs. Neil A. Boulter is at Dresentl Mrs- Blamhe G°"m h” "°l'“"“'

“smug in summemdc' mo guest M1 ed home. after an extended visit with

HON. MR. LEA: No; there is an- th M" Elizabeth sem" mend, in Monckwn’ N' B_

other local press. mr m° er' ' ' DR" MWMILLANZ And th" W” mm' Miss Ruth Bouiter, of Glenwood, lm ‘mly pn” th” -l’°°k °b'l°°u°m D A_ mphemn who has spent the past winter with

. Mr. and Mrs. .

ggN'Ml;{;;1?IEAqN°.Ce::;n]l;},¢ pn” were visitors to Haliburtnn on Sun- ll" B"°“d"‘\°lh°i'~ Mrs- E““b°"‘ throughout the Maritime Provinces 5lY» WM” U10! W¢i'0` N10 0195*! ‘lf schxnnbz' °f B“t';“°"l;.l°‘r(Tb°:M;: md Cmadg wok M ob_|¢C|,|°n-; Mr .and Mrs. James Rix. 0011 Y I1 BCCM’ B8 V

in C ty Hospital. and ex-

x-torr. Ma. Las; 1 cient see any- ---' " ‘“ P' °° °““

Dm MCMILLAN, And H they “_ Mn gm,-¢¢,|, ,nd mu Dorothy Mo- pects to enter upon her duties there

..._ _ ~ 1 " '~¢.""~~»'=~»- mf/ " ‘

when he was speaking... lporecd mm U “lung ,bum Maw, Doug,” were visitors m‘ Bpri'rf§h'ejld"‘”"“*"'“"'"" ' " "N -/' ~ “A -~- --~ -- ~---Z-_--~

HON- MR- LEA! Thffe WB-5 Mi-h' time Union. it was all a blunder? on Sunday.

ing wrong with his address; nothing, 1-|0N_ M-R_ Lp;A‘,»Su,»¢_ ___

in me “'°"ld' ` DF-~ MCMILLAN1 And you were Plans are now being made for the

DR' M°Mn-'LAN Th” is ,y°“"lPrescnt at it? holding of an Easter concert in the

opinion! “ HON. MR. 1 Yes. ,-

HON MR LEA: Certainly' md DR. MCMIII:-QNZ And mn the unites church at Glenwood.

the people Wm listened to mm' fn" “I 7°" l“'°““°° ‘nd “°' 9"' Mrs. Charles _;vihgstone returned

DR~ MCMU-'I-'ANI Bill' ll Wi" “ill vent this egregious blunder from home on sunday after spending 8

the opinion of the reporters who lis- Mm' gpm," on me pu\,||¢_ (1-_,5ugh¢__ few da nh I' d h

tened to him. lt was not the opinion "L ya W 1" aug ter' Mrs'

I or the Pre” of Cl”-“_ (To be continued) David McDonald, Milo.

` Hou. Mn. nan: well, 1 didnt see - l |

her success in her chosen line of work.-0.

Professor Calligaris, of Rome, de-

clares that people suffering from loss of memory can be brought to a nor- mal state by a prolonged tickling of the forefinger with electricity.

Most of the crew of the R34, which

made a double crossing of the Atian-- tic 10 years ago, met recently at a dinner in Bedford, limgland, given by Major Scott, who piloted the alrship,

F. J. Chamberlain, who Joined the

Y. M. C. A. at Plymouth, England, on his sixteenth birthday 34 years ago, has just been appointed national secretary of the Y. M. C. A. in Eng- land.

A woman recently died in a hos-

pital at Zurich, Switzerland, just a

year alter a fete was held to mark

BRINGING UP FATHE

`».1

V _ , ,. , .....~_

; i-

- Tnouleaangu-cus

'e - .

K vo cava:

<:m\=.u.\.

'1'O§

-ii----i-im! _ ' ‘ -_ #__

3-Z” '“ '* '" ’*"""'

immediately. All unite in wisl-iing‘

I l

her* fortieth year in the lnstltutioa where she was confined becuuseoi a mysterious malady.

Because her party could not miss

the $750 deposit required from can- didates, Mrs. Liiy Ferguson.. _pros- pective Communist candidate .-for Parliament at Preston, England, has withdrawn from the race., . .

Has Your Horae“"‘ ‘

M §uLollen Teuclonsl

i' ind!-mod,

tmdcus. Imax” muscles: add' t s' pa lsmmeaa and Qin from a mmm” mg. hone spavin. o blistering pn rea-mv; and the hone can be worked during tapunua. £2.50 at druggins or general men-hasta.

Booklet on the horse sent free. 11

W.F.Yo1m¢.lm.Lyma.n 1- ,ldosamnl BSORBINE

lli'.|i~ (`\i'. .Hui \U|,~~

4 if ;_EyM(-Eeorge Mcllailaa

MUD BUD'

I . 1

.--/ we “ii e5* Q-\ _.ei \ H.=5;sf|l< _ `

1 '-`~~-"»""i‘ .‘ '/-f'i;fi§§fif.,:’ '__4;"'l\¢, JI f ._ li

0 lass. lan eurmsrmn. ilu- _

wean- | »4AvE»~i"r ~»-g MET A\.\.`r»-\E

Q beam.: on - `f°~\\°=» BQAT

l ;, “ I var?

-wir 1|'

ls-. ln:

’ -4 nf v ar

al .~.mA.‘

»:zs.~,$*1z mtl

" nsaiaiii

.44£~4'l

_ »

' '~ '1i.f- ~r .,._.... _ ___

».,_

-.-=._,_,.'¢;_._ _

.....\

».>..z; _.<

. f

, .. .

_ _,ef ,

.~».\u-1 r ,