If It's Good For The Island The Guardian Is For It

“Covers Prince Edward Island Like The Dew”

@1119 @umdism

WEATHER

Sunny, a few snowflurries in evening; light winds. Low-high 8 and 20. Wed. nesday: intermittent snow; very cold.

the Poet om

Authorised as second Clan Hall by cc of poet-[e ta cub

Department. Ottawa. Ind for payment

VOL. LXXVII. N0. 301 CHARLOTTETOWN, CANADA TUESDAY, DECEMBER 8, 1964.

“an” SEVEN CENTS 18 PAGES

flRlOTTE DEFEATED Upset Victory ls Scored “In Ottawa Civic Voting

OTTAWA (CP) -— Controller With more. than half the polls:brother - in - law, radio station: Don Reid. a handsome 38-year- reported. Mr. Reid had piled‘owner Frank Ryan. old furniture dealer. scored a;up a commanding lead of 10.-l Before the election many ob-.

the indomitable Charlotte Whit-tponent in the five-way race. yan would split the anti-

PC House Leader Says

Unsuitable

surprising upset victory overlooo votes over his nearest op—‘servers predicted Mr. Reid andl . r ‘

[on Monday in Ottawa's mayor-lI Miss Whitton at that point Whitton vote and allow the 68- glty election. was running third behind herlyear-old mayor to win another.

iiilifiziifiiztear-rue;JQueen Charlotte Transfer

:on city council, the last four as. ;

Ia member of the board of con- 15 l

itrol. Last spring he ran cityl By FARMER TISSINGTON led by the department of nation- and wharf facilities at HMCSK

‘council for about a month as deputy mayor while Miss Whit- The Guardian ,al defence that these provisions Queen Charlotte, which wcre us- that

ton was on an extended over- ,Iseas trip. ' lCapital Bureau. y . ‘HER FIRST DEFEAT , OTTAWA — The building and ihave been made and

It was the first civ1c election} (.i defeal for Mm whmon Who has Ilotte will be turned over to the operate as in the past. I |been may" for "me Of the 13” iCanadian (militia) on 321150 been assured that the jetty 13 years' She campaigned on 15 and, at the same time, l—“"—"‘-“— .519’23" of mme o the “a.” the naval reserve division will IWllh her symbol a broomstick—«be closed down Jnhn Mullanv suggesting a clean sweep on the 'Mp for Kings “announced hm“; polls. . on a ' '

. . . . . y.

I Mr. Reid said in his campaign . , 'he would restore “dignity and 1. Mr- Mullhhy sa‘d he hall he“ lefficiency“ to the mayor's office in touch With Defence Minister and complained Miss Whitton ’Paul Hellyer regarding the musing Monday 0“ the east coast .ed by its new occupants to the bieyhnungb Emailifo'operme ‘rangements for Queen Charlotte lof Cape Breton with five men fullest extent, be explained.

llie ahilohaerd mi thec work done a" had been “him that thefilmrd- "Personally. I deeply regret ‘bv council during the period he lbUlldlng alld laCilitieS would be RCAF 5’93th and rescue that the naval reserve division' lfi-ned in {or the absent mayor lcomplelely occupied by the mll- headquarters 53” the 82 "l‘lmhas been discontinued. especially 1 Far“, returns in the electio'n :i-tia units and certain elements fine Catale out 0f the Magda‘ in view of the distinguished re. a“; ifidicated voter approval of :of the regular army. Howeverylell lSIEDdS. Qlleu has "0t been cord of this division over the 1fluoridation—defeated two cars some faculties M“ have m helhi‘ard from inn“ DH“ 1' She .Veal‘s allfl the fact our province lagkand Sundh); sport y Ire-arrangfll 80d ll- l5 expected‘d'FaPPeahe‘l "1 lhe 53"“? W'h‘l has always maintained a long . Mrs Frances baldwin Miss'fl‘“ milllla “hits Will “(ll lllllwwmd and Shh‘” 5‘0"“ WhWh hi and honorable Maritime tradi- \itihmh'n'Q hafipaign ma'nagelrl IOCCUPY the bUIldlhg Ulltll abflut‘hhe area.“’hlle the 13340” sea tion." Mr. Mullally said. “Dur- ham r-itllmks like a victory {mi IMarch 15 after refurnislling and HaWk-v Wlth 15 0F 15 me“ aboard ing the several months this mat- irohx," Innovations are completed 1W35 “Sllmg- ter was under review I urged

have of public works.

The Kings‘ MP said there ap-. . ,peared to some misunder-. istanding to the effect that the‘ Second vessel ihuliding and facilities would be!

, . . :closed down completely. How- ever. this is not the case since only the naval reserve division

HALIFAX tCPl — A secondiwill be discontinued while llhei fishing vessel was reported mis. building will continue to be us-i

i “In addition in the militia and Searchers worked in good the minister and the department

DUST SPeCk Seen SCRATCHED BY CAT lregular army use, ample provI-‘weather monday after the Mar- to retain it but my efforts were a I Felix is the mayor's “L It lsions will be maintained for the. .itimes third big snowstom over ,not successful. I am pleased the POSSIble Cause lsrratched her on one ankle iSea Cadet Corps and the Navy the. weekend. but failed to find Ifacilities will be used by the. mi- laboul a weak 8&0 and Caused League Cadet Corps," Mr. Mul- any trace of the SSS-ton Sea ‘litia and the two sea cadet corps

lin Charlottetown. ,

infection that put the mayor f I

Of Mariner Erroran . . out f campaign action or :1

WASHINGTON tsp) .— The Celia}? 0th?“-

- . a “ c .ius united States Spat? agency ham 1 from those lost few days." Mrs. Monday the Mann" IV MM":Baldwin said with an air of res-i spacecraft lost contact with theiizhaliom ‘ star that was guiding it, poss- ibly because of a speck of space dust.

The National Aeronautics andl Space Administration said a dust particle no larger than one- fifth of an inch in' diameter, passing within two feet of Mar iner’s sensor, could have caused the loss of contact with the tracking star Canopus.

The agency said it plans to signal the spacecraft to reac- quire Canopus soon. It also re- ported signals from Mariner IV

lally said. "I have been assur-uHawk.

Queens MP Is Queried

never recovered '

. N.S. Planning

Fine, New Park

HALIFAX (CPI —- 'l-‘h‘eIpro- vincial government is to pay .1. for privately owned land in western Nova Scotia and turn over a total of 93.600 acres 0 the federal government for a national park, it was an- nounced Monday.

.. D. Haliburton. lands and forests minister, said the 146-

BUREAU ‘ some truth in-it. 1 would be sur- {been sent to Africa as a semi-of-

CAPITAL OF THE GUARDIAvarlse-d if it was true. It‘soundsr‘ficial ambassador. OTTAWA * There is nothingimgl‘e initially a pipe drelamf' “ - . . l e sai la some peope in to be gamed by format!” at althird and fourth parties might, new political party in Canada, the willing to join a broadly bay. no matter what the party may ed Conservative Party which

called. Heath Macquarrie. opened’its doors to all people MP for Queens and a political who were of am all “c” and scientist. said here Monday in.small “p” persuasion. He said a new party,

parties. We have survived andl

in strengthening Canada who, defects from our party to try tol form a coalition with others in; " Mr. Macquarriej

MAYOR CHARLOTTE Whit-

' - ' ' l e meant conservative and pro-Ideclared. ton conceded defeat by Con- indicate one of the eight seienti. square-mile area will be known all lnteYVleW- . . . . . . . 5 .. ..k National park. He was commenting on a re-vg-ressive. , 'troller Don Reid onday fic experiments aboard. a solar a Kf‘llmquli I Queens. Mp said that two}

port in a Montreal newspaper. The that there is a move. on foot tolmembers of the Social Credit: establish a Confederation Party lParty had already left that par-i . . which would include Conserva- ty and joined the Conservatives: Dle‘s WIrndsor

tives who are dissatisfied with and there were several other‘ ‘ Will b? returned many times the present leadership of .Iobnlmembers of the Social Credit: WINDSOR. N.S. 'CP) -— How-I over as the. result of increased Diefenbaker and Robert Thump-,who would make very goodiard Wane, Smiley. 33. whose:

mér‘lfitcérgdtl‘idl‘n thzllilxlBrlignOlfighs son and some members of thelmembers of the Conservative;work in development of Gunml

he transfer to Meral au‘ thorin was authorized several weeks ago by an order in coun-

N.S. Cattleman

night about two and a half hours after polls closed.

stop ed

plasma probe. has p nformation.

transmitting useful i

Toronto Mayor

Cl . “We hope this his; investment

the ,ed by the naval reserve. will be .. fa lities at H‘MCS Queen Char- two cadet corps will continue to.maintained by the departmentle-

:On Rumors Of New Party *‘m

e are only two nationall

we are still strong in all parts of! advantage or benefit to the country. No one will succeedl value in excess of $3000 arising destroy the. Canadian Red

Tories Continue 'Plebiscite CaII

OTTAWA vCPl—Conservative'mendation. An explanation was House Leader Gordon Churchill necessary because months ago . said Monday the red maple leaf‘the prime minister had called should be reserved to represent lfor adoption of the three-leaf de— the sacrifice of Canadians ‘ ' . the First World War and ex-E "If he is now prepared to m. lcluded from any national flag. ‘ject the three-maple leaf design

. Churchill told the Com-719' him Publicly say 50-"

the former Diefenbaker He “Is” sald he had been mis- Lgovennmem was mmed in“, taken that inclusion of the Helm 5changing m red from green the de-lis would satisfy French-Ca- ‘three maple leaves on the Cana- had'ahs thal the “well “adj” dian coat of arms and the mis- lhhh “'33 represent“ 0" th. take should be corrected. 'flag'

The red leaf in the lion's paw vWANTs CANAniAN FLAG on the coat of arms repreSents “We want something Cana- "blood sacrifice" of Cana~ dian." shouted Gilles Gregoire dians and should be restricted rCreditiste—Lapointe). to that use, he said. Mr. Churchill said Mr. Greg-

Urging acceptance of his OII‘P. who last week distributed party's demand for a national .parly hats to NIva making their plebiscite on the flag issue, he third flag speech. should have said if the public is informed of conferred on him the "order of what the red ]eaf represents itlthe eviscerated chicken" unless would reject its use on a flag. he entered the debate.

The debate on a committee ll 3‘35 a H disappoml' recommendation of a single red menl that the {leur‘de'hs “’39 maple leaf on a white field with .“0‘ “NP-Pm“? ‘0 French Can- red panels at each side entered ida. and he had been under 3 its sixth day. The original gov-. m'safiprehmsm" ‘3” these ernment proposal of three ma~ yeam' Mr' .Churcmn shld‘ He J, g lple leaves on white with blue had “ever “bled” to “5‘38 th‘

as discussed 1maple leaf as a symbol of Can-

ada. but it should never be used

gs the main part of a national at!

BRIG. J. B. ALLAN

Retired Officer Charged

OTTAWA tCPl —~ Brig . Allan. 50, recently retired vice lbars at each Slde w quartermaster - general of the lfor 22 days last summer before Canadian Army. was charged 31: issne was referred to the Monda with briber and con- mmons committee. - ‘ V spiracyll in the alleged accept—l Frank F3"? lPC—Vegl'fllllel an“ of benefits [Man-mg more iMOVED AMENDMENT said everyone knows that when than $3900 between 1957 ; The Conservatives moved an 1maple leaves are. red. they are

‘ iamendment to refer the report.almost dead. It would be. better The charge was laid by that-back to committee with a rec—if the leaf was green to show

0 :l' m

Royal Canadian Mounted Policezommendation for a plebiscite. Canada as a young. dynamic

in city magistrate's court. Brig: Mr. Churchill said the special country with a great future. Allan ' free 0 $4,000 cash :flag committee failed because Edward N a s s e r d e 11 'PC :han. ILiberal members did not deal —Rosthernl raised the Ire of

thatlwith a "compromise" involvinggovernmenf supporters by say- re_ a flag incorporating the Unioniing Prime Minister Pearson the fleur-de-lis and the .lhadn't been in his seat for most ,of the flag debate.

M. earson had given the from the payment of hotel burs sign. he said. debate such priority Parliament and transfer of preferred and plebiscite was necessary was at a standstill. Yet be common Shares of Levy Induhqbecause Mr. Pearson had not didn't even consider the debate. tries Limited_” explained in the Commons his important enough to attend the

Brig. Allan, still on his retire-linews on the committee recom-gsittings.

' Party’s Rank And File Would End Flag Debate

The charge specifies Brig. llan, compulsorin tired in October, accepted “an JECR- , _ I e maple leaf. Liberal policy is to

E

n.

' ment leave from the army after‘

being retired nearly four years before normal retirement age. was second in command of the banch responsible for procure- ment of equipment for the army. He was appointed to ‘his. position in October, 1151. By KEN KELLY

Before that time. Brig. Allan ()TTAWA UCPI_Thp harhg. (film'de 0“ hag“ 3 COL 7) mentarv wing of the Progrcs«

instructed to advise Mr. Die!- enhakcr the executive was still overwhelmineg In favor of end-

‘ Social Credit party. caucus. . . , l" a Statement ” e ave too many parties In? "I would be surprised, how-they Pal“? W0“ hlm 8 Me mem‘ [sive Conservative party i5 m1. mg .

S- e-e , The “93 "wowed ll lochted Canada now. we. don't want any‘ever. at any formal move on thelbership in the Canadian (hero I. ‘der strong pressure from t e, A number of the party‘s MP9 "1 Queens County 3"" con-“Sis more." Mr. Macquarrie said.lpart of Mr. Thompson to jolnlsey Breeders Association. died party's national executive tolhave gone on record publicly 2g acres oédcgzwntsvfi' describing himSEIf as a two-{our part " Macquarrlelin hospital here Monday. He will wind up the flag debate in tho'alon: the salrne line, including

TORONTO _.. ' r . i “ "es .ow." ' party man. “I neverlsaid. referring to recent events be buried Thursday at nearby A A JCommons. reliable sources said all but one o the Quebec MPs.

Philip Givens (‘53:) “tumllggyttl; prommyG Statues. moat lgxyfal: ers Mersey lelleftli. 2a; golgp and heard of this movement untill' where Mr. Thom n has SUP-{Brooklyn His Smile-a-wihile t Monday“ ‘ 'th latest move in lihls dim.

office Monday night, thrusting soclate of his opponent in the gfpeg‘fglrfiggfi' an ‘ acres MW and While there may "beiporled the governmenl and h8fl,Guernsey farm was foun t ‘ OppoSition Leader Dicfcn- lion came Monday in a slate-

back the comebark attempt of insurance business had col. p ' s“ - lNewpoi‘l. N'.S. 50 years ago. By Tm: CANAmAN pRESS ‘haker was reported to have mm“. by Gerald Baldwm, MP w‘ Mr. Smiley was honorary pre- been informed by President for Peace River.

once-unbeatable Allan Lamport. Mr port. mayor in 1952- 53-54 and a turbulent figure in mi] politics for three decades. steadily slipped behind In the counting of the vote from Mon- day's biennial civic balloting

For the. incumbent mayor. it was the first time he was elec- ted to the office. He led the polls in election for controller in I962. an last year was ap- Domted to the mayoralty on the sudden death of Mayor Donald Summervi-lle.

in the mayoralty race. the “l‘year-old former mayor and his 42-year-old opponent waged an unexcitlng campaign until

lected for a $100-a-plate fund- raising dinner for Mr. Lamport. He attacked Mr. Lamport‘s “holier than thou" altitude.

n civic business issues. the former mayor campaigned es- sentially on promises to hold the line on tales in connection with Toronto’s $100.000,000 - a - year budget.

Mayor Givens pledged ‘tbusl- ness-Iike team leadership" in contrast to Mr. Lamport's noted faculty for keeping municipal affairs in a tempest. wo other mayoralty candl- dates were on the ballot-—Ross Dawson. representing the

3.

Charles Mahoney. a rcsort op-

, erator. both previous polHraii- era.

: Slated To End Sailings Today

gue for Socialist Action. andl They also stated if the weath.

‘Dalton Camp that the party cx- ecutive is 2-10-1 in favor of MPs IdIscontinuing their fight against the single-maple leaf fin: de- ‘sign proposed by a Common! Committee. Debate on

sident of the Hants County Ex- hibition at the time of his death and had served on various local lmunicipal agencies.

MONDAY. Dec. 7. 1964 The Commons started its second week of the current debate on a red maple leaf . flag recommended by :1 Com- mons committee. Gordon Churchill [PC—Wm

W.I. Ferries

the recommenda-

Northumberland Ferries Ltd.

.‘ - ~ ° . hlpeg Shm'h Central said the ition went into its sixth day Mon- 3:“. "I; -"'s 1964 schedme With Are Dolng red leaf denotes Canada's L . ' ays rips. ' . t w M w d .day. The preVious flag debate Company officials announced ‘ m "r M GM and th . l . last night the regular four sail- PARIS (Relllersl*Th° “1”” Shm‘ld "M be "59d 0 9 g "V i m m P n r” in“ from Wood Islands and surviving Sambm quintupth of .Frank' Fane IPC—Vegrc. ommended design of three red Caribou would be made today. rs. Raymond Sam don \‘lIIe said red maple leaves .maple leaves lasted 22 days be-

fore the committee was handed the task of finding a design. One sources said that when the party exccutivc met during thc weekend reports from tlic provinces heavily favored end- ing the flag debate, now being ,carried almost exclusively by

ing well and should soon be off. the danger list. doctors said‘ Monday. The quintuplets wch born prematurely Nov. 23.

Black Africans,

if possible. with the last one of the season leaving at 3 p.m. The others are scheduled for B and 11 am. and 1 pm.

are almost dead and a green leaf should be used.

.Iack Blgg IPC—Athabascal said the flag issue had be- come a political football and lonly a plebiscite could re-

solve the issue.

Alvin Hamilton IPC-~Qu'Ap—

er d d not permit any trips to- day there would be no further sailings this year.

pJetIiner's Dive Was In Stages

MONTREAL tCP) ~— All Air Canada )etllner that crashed a year ago with 118 persons aboard plunged to earth in two serial-ale dives. Ottawa engineer Robert J. Templin said Monday

Mr. Templin. 41. a specialist in aerodynamics with the N tional Research Council. told an inquiry into Canada's worst sin- ple plane disaster that the huge aircraft "had almost recovered Horn an initial dive when it went soothe sudden nose over."

His testimony was based on computer calculations of the near: path in Its last 10 miles of before crashing near Ste Therese. so miles north of Montreal.

Known information about the flight was fed into the comput- ers and the machines produced some 2.400 possible flight paths. 0! these, "a very high fraction were well made the conditions ee .’I

we were trying to Mr. Templtn said one of the walla; things about the anal

Arabs In Clashes

IConservativc speakers.

, However. when the loo-odd lparty officers called on Oppo- sition Leader Dicfcnhaker. the national leader made a plea for

pellel said discarding the Red Ensign could set a precedent KHARTOUM (AP) H Black. for resolutions to tamper with Africans and Arabs clashed in other minority riflhls. I l TUESDAY. Dec. 3 The Commons meets at 2:30 p.m. to continue the. flag de- bate. be Senate stands ad- journed until Dec. I .

rah majority's - ion of south Sudan's Ne- , One source said that at a sub-

lsequent session Mr. (‘amp was

dominat gro belt

NEW ERA FORESEEN

III—mile stage of the the very short time aircraft to cover the distance— 46 to 76 secon

flight was it took the

do. that the only way

I

"It appeared . for the aircraft 'to do this was I e to descend." he said. I

“To re ch the crash site ill a single diVe we would have to By ARCH MacKENZIE {international stress such as ‘11.: scheduled visit to the United assume that the plane climbed WASHINGTON (CPL—Prime Western Alliance. East - West Nations. much longer and higher — far Minister Wilson and President tension and disarmament Wilson said he looks to the above t level where witnesses Johnson discussed global affairs Wilson will visit Ottawa Wed- working sessions to establish may expected to have seen for 90 ml Mile 5 Monday to nesday to talk with Prime. Miri- “guide lines" for future imm

launch two days of talks during which they will exchange viewsl

on NATO‘s n u c l o a r futuih,"

an action. He said problems within NATO and the Atlantic Bloc arc urgent. "For two years there have been growing stresses and strains which we cannot suffer

d hard it.

Flight paths fitting known con- mer Pearson but scrapped ' ditions were plotted on a graph. which showed the plane swoop- ing down from an initial altitude

INSIDE TODAY