. he 531d, it was a case of “none but

,ment for putting throush the!

contemplate taxing the farmers r :cgulatlon.

. “his year as it did last it would be.

MARCH Z3. 1933

THE CHARLOTTETOWN

- can!“ f

.a..|\. l

ES ATTITUDE “"- r- “We "who l- , SGOR . the dim of that?"

h f‘ . m" “alum! "My hon. fri nd

t (Continued 339m PF”. 9 i110" lilo date of that very wzll,"

-. -. 1- m. J. A. McDonald: “Might 1

in. J. r. ifliihlt that document be tabled."

"* Mr- Mcmiyre: "1 will table it if

Ml‘- Mclniyre- Wh° mm“ i" you want to but it wouldn't do you

lcbatc when incl-louse met after (PM, fit a o'clock. criticised who manner of‘ 01991151118 Ill!- hmployffléflt relief moneys. which

my good."

. NI‘- Iflitfit is not n. document. ~11‘ h" no rizht to interrupt on...

7°“ "9 W“!!! your speech."

he deslglllied "P0119351 W‘ Mr. MacDonald: "1 have the lief." He referred to‘ worll right w rise to a point of order, done in Low/er Montgaue where, and 1 55k “m; my hum friend

table that document."

gonservatives need apply." | Mr. McIntyre: “no you mm, h, non. Dr. MacMillanz "You clil- deliver my speech?"

not prove that." Mr. MacDonald: "I am asking Mr- McIntyre maintained that he you to table that document." ‘

could show that the Liberals had Mr. McIntyre: “That 15 my

not received work "for one hour" speech." (Laughter).

on this project. Proceeding, Mr. McIntyre mam Continuing .119 “Wilma- F“'°1 lioned three prisoners who had been

pxpefldltilfe! in Prince‘ County a8 ‘sentenced to the Georgetowndall

being out oi’ 11100011105 W the during the present year. In the

ni-iall amount ca, nded in King's lower windows of one qg the cells

county. He also twitted Mr. strong, the bars were o“ so that one o,

c resident of Summerside, on coln- these prisoners could escape if he

ing to the Fourth District of wgpled m

Prillilfl W59 Blectfd- Voice: "They were that way in The ex-Mlnister read e all}: your time,"

from the Montreal Gazette alfeg-l My, Mcmgyl-e; “w” 1h you that

lng abuses of the unemploymcd re- gut one?"

lief money in Qllcbeil- At that time. continued Mr. Mc- Rcferi-lng to Prince of Wales 001-, Intyrg, me present Mihisw, o,

logo plans. he charged clitravas- Public Works llacl not assumed inc

slice by the Government in paying portfolio. Therefore it ems not

i

ihc architects s'x per cent of the his fault, but somebody was \cost. to blame for the bar being Hon. Dr. MacMiilan; "The usual of; end these prisoners used to get rate." lout, "like pigeons out of a cage."

Mr. Mcllltyfo maintained that in On one occasion a. prisoner got out Quebec the architects’ rate was and broke into Pooles, at Lower locally fixed at 5 m» cent. Montague, stored the goodshe had

Dealing with ilw bonding oi stolen and “went back to jail and overdraft last yearby the Govern- l,“ a gleepp 0h another occasion nieiit, Mr. McIntyre insisted that he was captured by the R. C. M, p, ll W“ 11°‘ 3°“! ‘mancm? m b°TT°W and on the following night he cs- mollcy at 8 cent. when they pgpefl agaln and 119d sum," oh were only payllls 6 per cent on some chicken he had pfiviously

ducing an amendment to gm“ Prosecutors‘ Act which gives the rlsbt to any lawyer member o; m, lksislature to act as Crown Prqsg.

,cutor. This was only class legflla- U0". Mr. McIntyre coniendgd, Why should not the same pfgvjslgn flllillll to general merchants and 9v. "l! member of the Legislature?

Thole Road Machineg

Mr. McIntyre insisted that tend. ers should be called for all Gov_ eminent purchases. That. he said, was what the Liberals had dong when in office.

Hon. Dr. MacMillan: “How about the trucks and road machines."

MP- Malnl-yre: “We called for tenders for them too."

Mr. J. Augustine McDonald; "Over the phone!" (Laughter),

Mr. McIntyre: you called on me to produce that tender at the Vernon River meet. ing."

Hon. Dr. MacMillan: couldn't produce it."

Mr. McIntyre: -"I~ produced it and you said, what right had 1 to lake a document out of the Legislature?" l

Hon. Dr. MacMlllarl: "As a mat- ter of fact we couldn't get those 1000011 on the floor of the House."

MY- Mililltyl-c: "I produced those, papers on the floor of the i-iouscl and I produced them later at the public meeting at Vernon River."

Hon. Dr. MacMillan: "That was not a lender at all; it W55 only a, statement."

Mr. J. A. MacDonald: “There was no tender because they were bought over the phone."

Mr. McIntyre: "Accepted over tne i phone."

Hon. Dr. MneMillan: tabled a statement."

Mr. McIntyre insisted that he had tabled the actual tenders.

"And you

"You only

blink overdraft. Wily did not the stolen, Government borrow on short time Ho“ m; McMillan; i-Ih w," lam? The Premier It the lull time the jailer hadtolockthémout legislative session, had stated l; may wenft hack lh Mme;- m" 11° did m‘ PT°P°9° *0 Wm" Mr. McIntyre: ‘There is no need ioo much money until the market o; locklhg them out how because would improve. In all- the Govern- they can get 1h ahd out as they ment had borrowed $1,400,000 and want to,» - they had waited until the market went to the highest peak and bor- rowed at 6 per cent, thereby in- llllll"! l 1°58 5° the "will" ‘l! Mr. McIntyre severely condemn- ovcr $200000- Ho W55 5"" u“ ed the arch of the span that was Bank of Montreal would not have h“; m Mg Stewart hh|dge_ He er Pressed them °n “I959 Wm“- u plained the value of these marsh they didipress them there were lands the", Whlch w” hmdmh other banks that would be glad to me h; good hhy chohh A meeting it'll.“ ti“! G°V°Y""l°"l'$ B°°°"11t' of the farmers hiid been called pro- 'H°W miwhl" 55k?“ M“ Mcmtyn- testing against building the span. fill! E119 bE-nk’ 88k V01] t0 fCdLlCG He, NIL McIntyre, had persona“!

at ilvtldlfli?" Igoiie about getting petitions against

Hm- m- Mwmnam "me" w“ the construction of the span and “° Pflflmlll" "limb" bud presented this petition to the

M“ McIntyre‘ "I mi“ it that u Government. Another petition was you had borrowed $100,000 the bank gotten up sighed by M,“ shevhhfl would have been satisfied?" lpeople’ “king ‘m. the sham The

Hm- m- MacMmam "hm m” span was installed at a cost of "'4 1" h“ °° b° ""‘~i°"l‘“l' "' $3,000 the old abattis prdtecting “may - the land was done away with ‘and

The" w” m’ remm why t,“ it was not long before the marsh Government could not have sat s- w“ "hm floodmh The people are "ed m” bank’ by b°n°wmg ‘me °r now asking that the arch be taken two hundred thousand dollars. Nil‘. out and we old system reverted m McIntyre insisted‘ which had been in use for iast 37

The Gmmmment’ he commued’ years. The foreman who had con- iould thank the late Lea. Govern-lam,“ this m“ hhd been taken from Summerslde and did not Domiciled Companies Act. uhderlknow his job’ M“ McIntyre 1mm“ which the Province is estimating ed“ The same man had receive-d l value of $40,000 this year. “s83 (or the Hillsboro Bridge work

The Government is now budget- and amther sum of m," who ‘m, [n3 w’ ‘£00300 “m” the “mum the Morris Bridge, just because he lax which must mean that they was h consewmva

Hon. Dr. MacMiilan: "D0 you say he was not qualified?"

Mr. McIntyre: "I will say he is not, and I will back that from my own experience."

Mt. Stewart Bridge

and fishermen under the new‘.

If the Government goes behind

forgotten you."

criticised for spending $26,000 on a mile of paved road on the McIn- tyre Highway.

quarters of a mile."

Millan Highway" christened. He did not think any member of the Government would‘ want that little piece of highway called after them. It was an or- phan.

wide?"

Continuing Mr. McIntyre coin- plained that the Crown Prosecutors, bill should have been “broadened out" to include every member. Why I couldn't he, Mr. McIntyre, be priv- ileged to sell a case of lobsters to‘ the Government just 3,3 well n5 lawyers could sell their services? Mr. J. A. McDonald: “To tell the l-rlllh. I forgot about my hon. friend." Mr. McIntyre: "I wouldn't have

McIntyre Highway

The Liberals, he continued, were

Hon. Dr. MacMillan: “Three Mr. McIntyre asked if the "Mac-

had yet been

Hon. Dr. MacMillan: better adopt lt."

Mr. McIntyre: “I think I will call it the MacMillan Highway. It is a little over half a mile of road."

Hon. Dr. MacMillan: "How

"You had

Mr. MacIntyre: “Sixteen feet, I think; and nothing in the middle. And this little half mile of road cost over $29,000."

Hon. Dr. MacMillan: "What is it built of?"

Mr. McIntyre: “Concrete? The road, he contended should have|

l-lon. Dr. McMillan: "It is twice‘

/ “You remember '

I capital expenditures

till-red. The Education Minister when

t. nie jail under the Iiiberals. What

The improvement, Mr. Mclntyrm

' ‘four or five or six hundred thous- and dollars" behind, he protested.

Criflclses Jail Conditions Conditions in the jails, Mr. Mc-

. Intyre continued, had not been

satisfactory. He did not lay‘ partlc-; ulnr blame on the Governmcnti The Liberals have had experience

‘ of the jails but the disturbances _ under their regime were "only a

I hegetelle" to what had since oc-

ln opposition had criticised the "song and laughter" going on in‘

iild he think about it new?"

Hon. Dr. McMillan: "It is much improved now". .

Mr. InPage: "Its grand opera. uow."

laid, had been in the wrong direction. Ho quoted a statement about the , lfllls which‘ he . attributed to the h iicf Justice. lion. Dr. MsMiilan asked for the ,,l|lla of the statement. l; Mr. McIntyre could not tell the

t wllat did that‘ {chattel-hi ,1 i-lon. m. McMillan: "rhiijynis in ,> r time}: ' h . v . f-llir. McIntyre: "‘No,=l'i0.". - .,, 1 "Hon. Dr. McMillan: "Of course ' ii was." (I-iaughtcr.)

Continuinl. W. McIntyre quoted liaicments of William storey. an in- Jlllte of the Queen's county Jail in which it was alleged that lhero h. ind been attempted um. that a Incline torch was frequently used iii the lilil and that there was no fiiiicuity for prisoners to obtain ‘w:

Hon. Mr. Sharp: "Didn't he do a lot of work under your Govern- ment ln the P559?"

Mr. McIntyre: “Oi-i Mount Stew- art Bridge?”

Hon, Mr. Sharp: "No, but 861l- orally."

Mr, McIntyre: "He did a lot oi, work, yes. He built a bit o! B 5¢°W for Grand River, by tender.

Hon. Mr. Sharp: “Didn't he build the Gough Bridifi?"

Mr. McIntyre: "By tender."

Hon. Dr. Macmillan: "Didn't hi! work for you every year?"

Mr. Mcrntyw “By icmltr- l1 h" put in the lowest bid. We always gave it to the lowest tenderer."

Mr, J, Augustine MacDonald: "I! he was not qualified he shouldn't have got lt."

vplceg; "He shouldn't have 8°‘ paid for it."

Mr. McIntyre: “Wcll-fl"

Hon. Dr, MncMillan: "So he was qullified?"

as wide as yours."

The material, Mr. McIntyre in- sisted, was not as good. It was “the worst extravagance that was per- petrated on the people of this Province," and this was what was called “rlgld economy" by the Gov- | crnmcllt now in power. I

Tlls Government had followed the Liberal Road Act, though they had stacked it severely when in opposition, Mr. McIntyre continu- cd. Proceeding, llc charflvd 80110115 neglect of road maintenance by, the present Government. Despite‘ their denunciation of Liberals pur- chasing road machines they bought $10,000 or $15,000 new machheryl and another $19,000 worth last’ year in addition in their expense of government garage. He was ill-v formed that 16 of the old Liberal machines are still ready to be put on the roads.

Mr. McIntyre thanked the act- ing loader of the House for his

ie. He did not have, thqdetc; '

fairness and courtesy in the House:

but this would not save him from]

receiving Oppostion criticism. I f-‘nlclmwood

The pulling dqwn 0f the

Mr. McIntyre: "l-lo wasn't qllflll‘ fled for that particular work at Mount Stewart."

Hon, Dr. MiicMlllali: “Ail?! be‘ in: four years willi you he. should bedlialifisd for imyihmlz!’ lt.-cush- tefl- -.

M". McIntyre maintained that m, w, h“ lo be stopped at this hhhoghnd um mic man was not had told him that if these were hung“; h, did not know how to left a roof could be put on the

go about the work, whereas thel-elilgyliim for $100,000. In their haste

w" mm m Mount Stewart wholths Govcfllmfllll h“ -bmn4"‘d~

l,“ g mic work several years They had started before they In"

ago, and should have been given'what they were dolnl- Ti!!! illd

the Job. Ihald $10,000 for the architects

The “n; member froln Third pllins and they had to return the lquemg (My, J, A. McDonald) llad tenders bascd on thesc Pllnl-

shown "poor ludlliltfl

west

Mr. McIntyre declared. The peril-l

Simms bulldinf Md Falconwood the sum of 010,000 and the Gov- emment did not yet know whether "W? were going to rebuild.

Mr. McIntyre advised against the bllildilis c! an expensive new cs- tablishmen at Filoonwood when peopEe "were starving." The pat- ients were well taken care of in the Sims building end the Infirmary. The east wing of the old building . should be roofed over and wlthi this accommodation the Govern- ment should be able to get along. Wily spend three-quarters of a million dollars more in these d'ffl-

‘cult times?

Summing up alleged Government cxtravagances he declared that there was $172,000 more in the

i103!) budget than last year despite ‘the Government's nomy pledges. Hon. Dr- MacMlllan: "Where is ; the cutting down to be made?" i Mr. McIntyre insisted that thls' i was‘ a. problem for the Government to deal with, They had promised rigid economy and everything was cheaper now than it was when the Liberals went out of office.

Compéring increase of debt under both party Governments, he said if the Liberals had increased the debt more than their predeces- , it was because they had to build lnclal Sanatorium and make other

which the Conservatives in 1923-2’! had neglected to make.

If the Government did not use more gravel ln the low-lying sec- tions the Liberais would have the, same problem on their hands when they came into power again.

Referring again to the eonstruc-' ~tTon of Prince of Wales College, Mr. i McIntyre said the Stewart Con-I structlon Company"; tender price for brick had been $35 per thous- and. He asked if the brick had not been purchased from L. E. Shaw, of Avonport, N. S, at $15 per thousand. -

Hon. Dr. MscMillan: "Some of lt."

ivuylldcmtym: "Did the Stewart Construction Company refund the difference between $35 and $15 per thousand on the brick they got from Mr» Shaw?"

Hon. Dr. MacMlllan: Wes."

Mr. lvlcmtyre: "1 am proud c! that. But the brick must be infer- ior brlck or you couldn't buy it It that price?" |

Hon. Dr. MacMillan: "What. makes you think so?"

Mr. McIntyre said the Admiral Beatty Hotel in St. John. N. 3.. was faced with‘ brick brought from the same Nova Sootian firm and it proved inferior and a whole storey had to be coppered as a result.

He asked if Bruce Stewart or the Stewart Construction company

t 115d lllsifliled “w 119M311? syswm “t flection on the credit of the coun-

the College .

Hon. Dr. MacMlllan: "Bruce Stewart and company!‘ ,

Mr. McIntyre: “Dld you make a! present, of $7,200 to the Stewart construction Compnn"

Hon- Dr. MacMillan: "No."

Mr. McIntyre: “According l0 the contract the,Stewart Construction Company should have built that furnace." ,

Hon. Dr. MacMillan: “Not when we took it out of the contract and gave it to Bruce Stewart und Com- pany."

Mr. McIntyre; "Then I must be having an optical 1111181003’

been built at a cheaper rate than them often," (Laughter). the McIntyre Highway. Instead, it v cost at the rate of $78,000 a mile tract and insisted that if the Stew- more cxpclwcf’ Hc mfllnialllcd that compared with $26,000 for the mile ‘ art construction Company had not the contractors should have been

. M Mlllan: You have pleted- Hm Dr ac Hon. m, Mnch/illlun; "$30,000." BOI-GER-Ai Hove Rival’. March Mr McIntyre read from the Con“ Mn McIntyre, "we", that was 26th, Gerald Bolgcr, age 6 years,

done the work the Government must have made "a Div-Will" w them of the cost 9Y1"-

Hon. Dr. MacMlllan: "The C00- tract for the boiler was taken out! of the general contract and given to Bruce Stewart and Company. Surely that is clear."

Mr. McIntyre: "Why was this done after the plans had been made and the tenders were let? why should you pay tile Stewart Construction $7,200 when Bruce

O d'd tho H l1. D . Ma lMlllilill “D0 Yo“ gait??? and ompany I Ohio; ti, A sbhhhhhhside High his late residence and from thence Hon m, Mhcmhhn. “we than‘ school?" to the United Church at i‘.

pay the Stewart Construction Com- pany for installing the boiler equpment. We took the contract from the Stewart Construction Company and made a. scillillllfi l!" rangement with Bruce Stewart and company because they were local’ manufacturers and because they were abletodo the work. We gave it to them with the idea of helping out unemployment in thc city of Char- lottetown and the Province gener- ally." (Applause). l Mr. McIntyre: "'I‘hat is the very‘ thing Lam telling you. The Stew-l art Construction Company tcildcY-l

wing of Fifcoriwood was "a. crime”. ed on that plan f0!‘ $239.99‘? “m1 m” "m? l‘ “llwflml °I “S "°xh‘“va'

hggflng system was included in the

tions were three or four ply o! specifications and they rcccivcdhments, Prince of Wales College. he brick‘ and a prominent contractor; the amount of their tender. didn't ‘ admitted. was built for future gon-

they?"

Horl, Dr. MacMlllan: "They did not."

m, minty"; "You deducted that from the tender?"

Hon. Dr. MacMillan: "Allyilllv with common sense would do that.”

l Continuing. Mr. Mcluiyrt will‘

h. m ‘mm. m gll they had spent for the plalncd that 840,000 additional had appear later-

inlcnt. If it llad the power already

,MilNllliY8AiVAT|0N? ul:il"llinuullomuvl

0F I.___U.II.E.;‘MUCH’EUUYEIJ,

A much enjoyed and well at-f il-lldcd concert was given last wening in the Salvation Arm; Citadel. The Army band of four- zcen instruments contributed many numbers to the well balanced pro- gramme and stirred the audience at every appearance. Councillor, Samuel Keiluedy presided. f

Following were the numbers of i the programme:

The regular monthly meeting of: the independent Order of the Daughters of the Empire was llel: yesterday afternoon with the Rt gent, Mrs. J. A. Mathieeon presid lng. Arrangements were make is llavc ealcnders disposed of, rooms renovated, card tables purchased. roses ordered for the regular sale of Alexandra Roses. Weekly bridges and the celebration of Si. George's i Day were also discussed. March, the Band "Ever Loyal."

Two new members, Mrs. H. J., Duet, "Larboard Watch," Harry Gordon, Brighton. and Mrs. E, G. I Chandler and Russell Carr.

Saunders were welcomed. Vocal duet, "My Aine Country," . l '

——- Ina and Betty Meeney. l Cornet solo, “l-iosanna," hemp! | cliit Kimmins. l

i

| l I Harmonica solo. Wm. MeEaclici-i.

aecitclicn. “The Last Hymllfll Florence Carr. l Band selection, "My Desire." intermission. l . GOl/ern- h Cornet solo, “He Pardoned s. R1:- bcl,” by Adjutant Klmmins. 1n e n t P 0 w e r To, ....,,.,,,,,., u. S,,,.,,,,,,, Suspend Payment: ace" 1M Memo»-

Marcli, the Band, “Simeon? Band selection, “CoIpi-la." 0f Notes I11 Gold.

Euphoniuln solo, "Silver Threads." March, the Band, "The Great

l Russell Carr. Vocal duet, selected.

Ina nilrll Betty Meency. i

Army

| Call (Canadian Press) l Doxology‘ OTTAWA March 27_..we Mei Mrs. Jean Richards was lllt,‘ ac- companlst.

only doing what has been done in‘ (lrcat Britain and in the United; States." said Hon, E. N. Rhodes. hfiriister of Finance, as he moved second reading of the Government bill amending the Dominion Notes

‘BENTRAL GUARDIAN '

__.,,

‘ PAGE vulutl!

FERTILIZERS.

We are now in e position to book orders for Fertilizer ' for the coming season, as follows: "

CHEMICALS- SUPEBPHOSPHATE .. .. 1001b. bugs MUBXATE or POTASII .. 20o -- -- SULPIIATE or AMMONIA zoo -' -~ NITRATE or sons 10o " '- l MIXED GOODS— i-s-r i-e-lo 44-1:

All in 100 lb. bags

On I1] of which we cm make IMMEDIATE delivery or shipment from the Island Fertilizer Plant.

All the above Chemicals and Mixed Goods will hi: freshly ground and bagged as delivered or shipped frnni ihe Plant, which guarantees perfect nrechanicul condition with bags in good order,