NOVEMBER 1- 1935. me i.H/iizi.o1"rl:'rowN ruaanlaiu _ ,AU ' 5,_v,._,.,

_ __A ___ , , , , .. V... --el .~ -. -_-_ ., ,,»,,., »;.-. »- nf f -~""»" '1-';-svn, --,- ~',»,,," 7 4' 1, '»,'.'.'-,.‘/1,.” '4.'.-1,-'-;:»

' ve ~»»;..,»,- ,pr .;'.- 1. ~~ f other .gr -“ffl-"i-~.. " -5 'et-f*¢"y "' ` -_.L '. 1#"".. :.j’-."‘i‘»;f;;-. ‘ 1 ,-L-f,'.",~‘~..-.=»'f -=.'.~.--. "‘.i'.-.r.. ,,_ ,.,f,~.¢-f.='_l'~ 1. , .,. . ~ '.11 ,f. . , '_», . -,f-.’.= ‘».“_.,'...

"" 'I ' ` ` 5'* fi' '»"“"~.» - ’ - ' 5' -‘€{1>.""-’~.`-`7"~". ""3:7`lf>"'rf;...-riff,~‘Ff*ff'i5--’f1‘1if‘=f. .rf'»"1:?.”?<'7'.'%ff”;';"} »":-‘r‘»l'/ fi' ’ '~"" "' "'"1'-`!!ff°r'-fi""?Zi‘-3”#T'¢7!”‘-§€5“=’?"‘fv ii/-‘ 3"” 9"; by",

- 1 r ~ - -,.', '» .. l- » . ',f 1 1-; , ~,‘-~»-_,'<' __ , ;.--,;»_-_ .-.'.' ey' 4.,

4 . , . _ _ ____../,_,~_ ._,_-,f.,V.__,, i .off

' ' 1

r

4-e' ' f '[471' ,;_,~4 ’

, , . _/.._

1 _ /,.~ -

/f,'. »»¢~:.

., ,

'ht

wi

-1*- ' I .I H *°"'-=""i'. "~'.“"~ -- _~°:.-..'.' 19

W -g -'i-ia:

StrangeA

Qjf 1917 Elections ,

ig? | T *

fte rmath

l 'rem oouivr: You so not have ' with any people on the mens lu re- itil Wh° l°ii the feet. and I Under- ‘ " I HAMPTDN PASTOML CHARGE W0!-.1-0 BAY *ND VWINWY

ren” to mi ' - stand his chin-go was $154100 and ‘ -The services for Sunday, Nov. 2nd ' _-

A__Pouib]y I mu, hut Vg;-my he was paid by M,-_ Ma,-¢f_n_ 1 lore; vicwria at 11; Bonshaw at 3; We regret to learn oi the serious Q y y , _ . land Hampton at 7. Rev. Geo. Ayers, illness of Mies Annie Doucette Nev

_ ' - were? Mr- Sinclair, who won the seat and AT mDAY’3 mx SHOW- TUE Minister. Zealand, and hope for her speedy le- ! MR. .lou-nwrou: surely 1 have 'ri-ns comer: Does that melee e,s°t his nrst entry into Parliament" Ch”"“"°" ‘"4 “"5 ¢""“‘°‘°“ “U” -- oovery.

the risht lo :sir the question? difference-i continuing. so-. Johnston stereo "°“-‘ will he P*°°¢- DW* ml” this 'ms aarrlsr crwlwn-or. vin- - ,

;_ . 11 . 'nm ooUa'r;- not the wiinm lim .loHNs'roN: Yee. I think it is . that he. Mr. Sinclair and oihers had “fe” “Um 3002"* wit lakes as his "willing Buble", M6551* Wm" D°°8lf and 1"\"“=‘ ' Xlbcd not lnswel-_ tha question, not fmP0l‘¢l-l\U- ‘met 4-‘WT 9110 1\1d8D'l¢Ii¢ WM dnliv- A "‘Mi.ssionary motives." The evening E. l\i:cDorlaId ar'-‘.ed liollle !3’t

- '11i~1E COURT: 1 dmfg 5” lg, ered. One of the party sent out for Fm! ‘u‘Al‘M*T'1“°m`°”\°“ *W1 Bn! semlon. the sixth in a series on the | we -K from Rhode I.~ler.d. where th'l?'

to answer that question. witness. The fe

whole question is the issue here. There are no pleadings on that count

Former Liberal Attorney General ;‘§§,,Z‘” ‘°"’“° ‘”°°"' Y” “’°“” “"°"

' S1168 LOCa1 Liberal SGIIEIIOI' F01' leneillu wr roi- yn, for “sinner which 1 intend is brine sue.

Professignal Services Rendered worlr for anybody rm-‘ n.,¢hi,,g_ I l to somebody in Neve seotle or on-

But Is meQ_fj:pi?;;hh:;ght be reasons whypresent when the :conversation took

lllothiig but I am sskinbodbou oilfl COURT: Y°u might "mke

ii Work for you fm, nothing? Ishow its relevancy if you had said CmMi,__ “/num was iq, befmep _ A'>__N3_ -I-hae! ,S why I went b that in tha first place. .

!n the County Court on Thursday :crore I-Us Honcur Judge Duffy the] :asc of James J. Johluton. vs. tl-Ion.) lonn E. Sinclair, action for profes- lional services, was tried, the plain- zift being 'ion-suited with costa, thc :ourt citing the Statute of Limita- tion as ground for judgment. ' _ The action was entered to recover

a total sum of $300 on two accounts. the first, dated March, 1918, being $150 for, legal services in the matter of an application of Aleziallder Mar- tin for recount of the civilian and soldiers' votes in the Federal election ef 1917 when the application was dis- missed and Mr. Sinclair retained his scat in the House of Commons. The second account, also for $150 dated Feb. 1923, was for expenses incurred in going to Boston, Mass-, at defen- iant's request and interviewing Bk’

Cbarlw Dalton with a view to ob-I

taining the la»tt'.-:r`s interest ln thcwgmt

Guardian newspaper. is Mr. Johnston opened his case by '

.ll

A.-~Bef:i'e the County Court Judge

Q.-Who was that?

but I would have to refresh my memory oil that.

acting for Mr. Martin on that re- count?

of

Q.-Do you recall who were act-

ing for yourself? ~

A.-Yes, I remember that. War-

b

m .,

Q.-Did anybody else act for you? A.-Yes, yourself.

reoo

was

e recount didnt proceed That

my recollection of it. _ Q.-I will give you all the time you

Q.-You mean. I suppose, that the

HU-H5 UF-‘il the d2‘fe“¢*“l' W “K5 ,recount was disallowed by the Judge.

:he stand. _

THE COURT: Isn‘t is ratiher`un~- m

usual for the plaintiff to prove his

ease by the defendant? the

MR. JOHNSTON: But perfectly

right. I submit. I subpoened him here. ed

HON. JOHN E. SINCLAIR. wus duly

A.~I suppose that might be the

Q.-And the result was you got

seat, I believe.

A.-After the recount was finish-

A.-I think it was Judge Stewart,.`

A.-Offhand I couldn't, Just say. ,I

| Q-Is there any reason why I

A-No reason why you should

would'nt ask anybody to work for

I wou work for some f

, 8 Y lthere is any reason why I should

vnur office before I paid the other

Q\1¢€I\`5 COUDW- A Ilull, to make sure of my standing. I

, Q.-I _gave you notice. to produce 3 letter, date Sept. 8. 1924?

l A.-Yes.

i Q.-Have you git that letter?

Q--D0 YOU remclnbcr l\’n0 W8-Si A-I havent got that letter. I

.cnuldn't find that letter in my files.

Q.--Will you lock at this copy. Will

you examine it and see if it is a ‘copy cf the letter to which I refer.

A.-There are sixteen foolscap pgg-

,eil in this. Possibly a general answer

urtcrn and Shaw were the prirnelwould be sufficient for the purpose, overs in my case. lwithout reading the letter. I remem-l

,ber receiving a long letter from ynu. lwhctller this was the letter and the

Q.-Do you remember what the cleie I weuld have to read it over to result of that application for the know. S:me years ago I remembered'

unt was? fleceiving the letter. |

A-Putting it briefly, the reoounti Q._1 would like you to ten “sl

not proreecled with on some whether your impression is or is noti that was raised by my attor- _that that is a copy of the letter, I

Guardia" Publishin! C°mP°“Y "ld neys. It was allowed by the Judge; a._-it would he hen-l for me to' acquiring the ownership oif the ,md gh - _ '

| swear that.

,want to examine it. | A.-I would require to get the leg- fel' I 1'9Cf.‘iV€d before I could swear

ore proper way to state it. to lt. i

I Q.-I was not asking you to swear ;to it positively. I said your impre5-`_case. If this took place in your

l sion,

in the Old Country and in France. A.-Well; i

Q.-And after the recount was Q.-Perhaps you never read the'

sworn. Ehramlhatlon by Mr- Jilllii- thrown out hom .letter

lton: .

Q.-Where do you live, Mr. Sin- h

:ia,;r.‘l

ETC

A.-At Summerfield, Prince Ed- entered me House of c5mm¢~m57

ward Island.

Q.-You are a member of the

Senate of Canada?

A.-At present, yes.

Q.-Did you get an account from

A,-Yes?

work that I did for you at that time?

ine. sent to you by registered letter. paid the other lawyers, and you told

for $300. The account is dated Aug. m

I8. 1930. _

A.- Yes. (Account tcnclcred in evidence.)

Q-Did you answer that letter? _ re

A.-No. Q-When were you first elected to Parliament?

A.-‘In 1917. Q.-Do you remember who the

candidates were at that election?

A.-In the riding of Queens? I :hinlr A. ls. wel-hui-mn, panels Nich- olson, Alex. Martin and myself.

Q-I believe there was a general

returning cfilcer for Canada at that time, was there not?

A.-I am not sure of what the

.nw required at that time with regard to a general retuming oillcer.

Q.-lvos that the eie:t1:n at which

the soldiers voted overseas?

A.-That was during the War, yes. le).-Do you remember now, after

recallfllg that fact, whether or not there was a general returning of- ficer lol' Canada?

A.-I havervt refreshed my mem Dry or looked that up. I am not pre- pared to say until I wzuld make sure.

'Ji--fi-lil: were declared elected

that tlme, do you remember?

A.-I think the declaration was

for Donald Nicholson and myself, tits final dcc‘ari\tlcn. ,

Q-.~-Do you resell what your maj-

ority west'

A.--On the final count I think it

was four, but I wouldnt say wheth- er it was three or`folli‘.

at

Q.-Was there s .recount held orln-:uid be fair. l

thetl

&ked f:r in connection with

election?

A.-There was.

Q--Do you remember who

for ii recount?

A--I think il, was Alex. Martin. Q----As against you or Mr. War-

blu-lon. wllieh?

li.-Well. if it was directed at any

DM particularly. it would be at me.

Q-»-Mr. Warburton was not el-

asked

e .

anything of it afterwards till the Ist

Q.-Was that after Judge Stewart

A.-Yes, I think it was.- Q.-Afwr the work was done?

the other lawyers.

Q.-Are you uitc sure that that

lr:

A.-I remember- tltat. Continuing. Mr. Johnston asked

witness if he recalled a meeting be- tween himself, the witness and other parties after the Judge had givcn his decision. Witness replied that hc had no recollection of such a meet- ing, but would not swear that it had not taken place.

Q.~Did you pay Mr. Snaw or Mr.

Waiiburt-on for their wok?

A.-I paid Mr. Warburton. °Q.--You never paid me for it., though? . .

A.-No sir. I went t.o your office;

before I paid the account from the' other lawyers and spoke to you and you told me that Mr, Shaw would be entitled to that.

Q.-Did you offer to pay thc mon- `

ey?

A.-No.

Q.-How much mcney was it?

A.-That I paid Mr. Warburton? Q.-How much money were your

going to pay me?

A.-I dldn't tender any money tor

you.

Q.-Did you ask me what it was? A.-I asked you what you thought

Q.-That took place on what,

date after the judgment was de-‘ Ilvlercd?

A.-I oouldn’t give the date for

that. -

A.-Not to my knowledge; not

Q.-Anybody present? ,

A.-Yee. it was not proceeded withl' Q.-'I rather think I did.

Q-You \vouldn‘t like to sa

. I _ . y

Q.-Was that the first time you llvhethcr _vcll read the letter or not?

, A.-If it was addressed to me and VI received it, then I have no doubt

Q.-Did you ever pay me for the`that I would read it, no matter who

.signed lt.

A.-No slr. I went to your office; Q-Do you remember receiving a and asked you about it before I 4 letter from me of the 22nd of April,!

‘192ar

i

,wt to mind lg 1 never hem-d A.-I don’t remember that letter.'

Was that written in Ionghand?

of September. _ , Q-~No_. it would be a typewrittcni

i letter. .

nde,-ed his daemon? l A.-I couldnt find a letter of that`

kind in my .flle.

it is dated April 26, _1923.

A-That is my signature Yes;

ii 1 ' -

mnect’ Mr_ sinclsvhq l there is no doubt about that letter. I

fhavelft got the letter I received, however. to which that is a reply. , (The letter. afterwards admitted fin evidence, read as follows):

Privy Council of Canada.

Ottawa. April 26, 1923.

I-lon. J. J. Jollnston,

Charlottetown.

“My dear Mr. Johnston:

"I have your personal letter of

the 22nd lust. with enclosure and I am astounded with the develop- ments described therein. One thing I want to impress you personally with is to be particularly careful tllat you do nothing that '-vill in any way estrange you with the Lib- eral party. no matter what the provocation may be. The position you occupy in your profession and in the Liberal party is a very prominent one: in fact you are at the top in both.and any hasty ac- tion that would imperll your posi- tion ln this regard would be plny- ing into the hands of those who wish your downfall. Your ambi- tions are well known to me and _voll know my att'tude ln regard tllereto. Your ambitions may not

been anticipating. but do nothing that will prevent their being real- ized in arv other ways at n later date. I krrr and believe your provocation will be great during the next few months and I know you are big enough to over- come it successfully. I have nothing more to add to what I told you when I saw you at Easter about the fourth Judgeshin. I will say nothing further until I see you here Mav 7th

that I remember of.

Q.-'I’ha.t is your oath is it? A.-That is my recollection.

THE COURT:-Mr. Johnston, that

tried?

A.-Nntthen. no. There was no

declaration at that time. Q--Do you remember who that re-

count came _up before? V

A.~’Ihe recount in Prince Edward unfair. If he were an illiterate man _

Island? '

Q--Yes. between Mr. Martin and

yourself? A.-There was a recount here and

lint/ther in England. The one on‘h

the Island came before the Countyi

Q-Was it after the recount in simply your recollection?

Ehifllnd that you were found to bo,

four votes ahead of Mr. Martin? 'tn _ A-The declaration was made af ,already answered that question. l

lm- ine re-ount in England, yea. .

is hardly fair to your own witness.

MR. JOHNSTON-He happens to be the defendant too, your Honor. i THE COURT:-You cannot cross

examine your own witness; it is very ;

I might let it go: 'if he were ini doubt as to the nature of an oath.

lm. .lol-lNs'roN.-I should thlnkj

if he were an illiterate man e might demand the Protection of*

tile Court: but he isn‘t.

THE COURT:-You do not have aiswer that, witness. You havel

Q.-At any rate, as a matter of`

Q-'Ilia declaration to the effect_fsct, you have never paid me?

diet y°\i has a lneloriiy or four vot-| is ever Mr. Martin? _ l A.-Yes, that I was elected. , ‘I-The recount thee :ook him

Court Judge for Queen‘s County. Q.-Ls that your oath or is it

Th

A.-No, I have never paid you, at _is correct. = Q.-Are you claiming the privil- Ols of the Statute of Limitation?

on _ .

"I saw Andrew Hayden yester-

day. 1-Ie wlui enoulring about our huslnefr. with Dalton. Was any- thing further done?

" Yours truiyf

fsgdi John E. Sinclair."

Q.-Have you any other letters

there?

A.-No. that lathe only letter. . Q.-We have now dealt with the

first item of that account. Now for the eeeona item. nhl yvii have anv- thing to do, in the year 1923. with an attempt to Pll\'¢\ll3° 5”' Uh“]°' Ds.lton’s interest in the Guardian newspaper? A.-pid r have anything to dv with

an attempt to purchase?

Q.-Yes. ' A.-Well. I was informed about the

possibllty of_ purchasing in 1923. Q._nia you have enythlns to da

with it? » A.-Not as between Mr. Dalton Bild

.Q.-Perhaps you might look at this.;

A.~Arter I received the hill ll-om, ‘P"’d“°l"g leiiffi- Thai was in relilyrl

bc realized in the way we have I

MR. JOHNSTON: Your Honour, of

course, is not cognisant of the facts

'I'HECOUFtT: Suppose he spoke

tario, how does that help me?

MR JOHNSTON I happened to be

place

your questions plainer. It would

Q.-Do you remember? A.-’I‘he only conversation I recall

at the time was s. conversation I had I with Senator 'Hayden at Otawa.

Q.-Didn't you have a conversation

lwlzh senator nerdy et ottawa in rny presence? l

I A.-I don’t remember that. - Q.”-Did you bring me to Senator

I Hardy? Is there a Senator 'Hoi-dy?

, A.-There is now. . Q.-Was there then?

A.-I couldn‘t say. Q.-Well, a man by the name of

Hardy? .. , A.-I don’t remember that circllni- _ stance' at all. l Q.-Was it arranged. in your pres- ence arld mine, that Senator Hardy was to furnish the money to piu'- chese this interest. of Mr. Da.lton’s?

A.-Not that I have any recollec-

tion of_

Q.---In Senator Hardy's office.

A.-With me?

A.-Yes. A.-Notthat I remember. That is

entirely news to me. i Q.-You say your memory is pretty good?

THE COURT: It seems to me ‘hat

,you are gcirlg backwards witll this

presence you are the man to give thc evidence.

WITNESS: I don’t remember vllat

he refers to at all. ‘

THE COURT: 'I'h’s is very much in

the nature of a cross erlminfltion, you must, ccvnlt, Mr. Johnston, f Q.-'Dc you l<li.ll whether I left _Ottawa ffr' B- ‘ r. after seeing Sen- ator I-Iariifr? _ ; A.-No, I didn‘t know anything I about that.

Q.-I want to put this question to

you: Did you there and then 'ask me to go to Boston and interview S.r Charles Dalton with a view to get- ting his interest in the Guardian. arid that Senator Hardy was the lnrm that was going to provide the money for you?

A.-No, I don’t remember anything

about it. I don’t know what date you are referring to. Q.--In Ottawa?

A.-No.

Q.-Did you. in Ottawa, request me

to go to Boston, there and then, and did I go to Boston and mme back to Ottawa?

A.-Not that I ani aware of. THE COURT: This is going back-

wards. If this took place you are the man to give the evidence, Mr John- ston, anrl why don’t you do lt?

MR. JOHNSTON: We will see

about my part of the cvuleiice later. your Honour.

Q.-You say you iid consult Sena-

tor Hayden about it?

A.-I talked the matter over with him after you had talked ti me about it.

Q._-Do you recall if vol and Selin-

tor Hayden and I met in Ottawa?

A.-No, I don’t recall that. The

fact of the matter is I don’t recall that you had cver taken a matter of that kind up at Ottawa at all. My recollection is of a discussion with you in Charlottetown, in your own

office.

Q.-Do you recall if you asked Mr.

J. J. Hughes. now Senator Hughes. to

write me about this Dalton matter?

A.-No. I don’t recall that. I don’t

remember of discussing it with Sena-

tor Hughes.

Q.-That you were expecting a wire

from me about it?

A.-I don’t remember that.

Q.-Did you have any talk with,

Senator Hardy, or Mr, Hardy about. this matter at em l A.-Not to my recollection. In fact

I don’t recollect of ever having any busines talks with Mr. I-fairly ou any

matter.

Plaintiffs Statement

MR. J. J. JOHNSTON, sworn on

his own behalf, stated:

“In connection with the recount.

in the application of Aleir. Martin against John E. Sinclair for is re- count, I acted in the matter as chief counsel for Mr_ Sinclair at :lis special request. There were many points in- volved in the application, a large number of grounds, asking the County Court Judge ‘to rescind his order for recount."

THE COURT: "Did he make an or-

der for recount and rescind it after- wards?"

MR. JOHNSTON: "Yes, he reserv-

ed Judgment for some days and fin- ally rescinded it. Mr. Sinclair was not present when the application was

myself, no. I never had any con-, versatinn with anyone except your-I self, on the Island. Q.-Dia you have any onnvsivilivh

argued but on theday appointed by

.-no ou remember who the am making the same charge usenet

that I had not chavgerl lrlm for that

that I ever told Mr. Snclalr that I did not intend to charge him for lt.

nothing, at any time, is undoubtedly

n ° l tevc ith a s stio

it

treal, because I was on my way com- ing home. But at anv rate the ar- rangement and the request was macle in Ottawa by Mr. Sinclair' that I should go. That is tile second item of the charge I have there. I. spent at least two days in Boston and paid my railway fare and travelling ex- penses, and I went thel'e. at the solic- itation of Mr. Sinclair. At i‘i'sl Ml'. Sinclair was a little doubtful rbout me going; he thought that I ought to find out definitely .from Mr. Dal- ton by correspondenoe; but nite: the interview with Senator 1-lardy, with the lrospect of getting the mom-y to purchase the interest, Mr. Sinclair then asked me to go to Boston. and I went there. 4

HON. MR. SINCLAIR: Have you

the date of that?

MR. JOHNSTON: I haven't got

the exact date. I was on some other business at Ottawa and I could eas- ily locate the other business I was on. It was in the winter time.

submit, is a reasonable charge for

THE COURT: Is this the first ac-

count you ever rendered to Mr. Sin-

clair?

MR. JOHNSTON: This is the first

tlmation he had that you were going ‘

capable, was fined $5 and costs.

KOPS BROS. founda.tio~. garm-

Y

3010-ll-l-'Zi

Fox Show will take place this ev-

enant Governor Frank R. Heartz wnl

800" ll

some refreshments; “And my share el'-"Y G-ll YHWIUI-U l|1l7l'l1-U18 f°f l|Beatitudes, will be “The Poor in or the refreshments," Mr. Johnston f’“° fl” °°‘ °""“°“' SW" mi- :heart-" At 0445 o- in.. Miss Spencer declared, “is all I ever got for my igives B11 Oflliirl Prelude- The musk work in connection with that ye- i lcf the day will include "O Taste arid count. The statement made by sen- THE FORMAL CLOSING Of l’fh¢‘,See", iGossl “The Radiant Mom" atm- gimglair here may he and I had Fox wow will take place this eve.:-; lwwdwardi, "Hymn in the Night," any gonvgrsatlgn gg any time in ing at B o'clock. His Honor Governor' J llzrovmi. Sunday School at 2.30 in- whlch I told him that I did not ln- Heli-itz will present the championship. vires all.

tend to charge him, is absolutely un- l2Y'JDl'll€S and MHUCPS L0 f/lie ‘Vin-F --- »true. Such it conversation never took DCIS- ' ' 8007 YORK PASTORAL i"HAR(.=E. pls/sg, Wi-|1151; I will candidly say mg; --- United Church of Canada, services on 1 did nor, intend to che,-ge h1m_ at AT TODAY'S FOX SHOW. THE sunday as follows: York Church that time, I never expressed lego My-_ Champion and Grand Champion rib-_ school at ln n. m.. servcie at ll a. lSlnciail'.” _ boils will be placed. D:n't miss thls`m,; Plenzant Grnvv Cllilrcll School;

THECOURT: You made no charge great sight. 8002-li only at 2 li. r|i.C l‘3r=‘f‘<7f‘y Cl\’~"'C“

at the time in your books? -i lSclloui nt 2 p. m., Fr-r\'ire. 3 P- "li

MR. JOHNSTON: I made no POLICE COURT-At the Pollce_ Central Church. MzirshflcId-Dun-

charge at the time in :ny books. And Court yesterday morning, a man.' stsffnage, Church School at i0 a. m., I wrote him afterlvards to the effect charged with being drunk and in- Service at 7 p. m_ instead of 7.30 ll-

R1.

work. -_ - ----~ 'THE COURT1 That is not very woon lsl.ANn--Rev. Dr. Ash-I nlccanrni'-s'rl3\'~'An.'r Norri- CUff€l'€!\l5 "Um th! Omer Ufanmentf dozvll will Pféach in the Presbytefr- ALS-A vcry pretty/ wedding was sol- ¢X'¢EP5 that if WHS by letter- 'ia ~_ Church Sunday, Nov. 2 at ll a. m. emni:e:l at St. Amis Church. Dor-

MR- JOHNSTON5 MF- SINCIQU” and and Wood Island Ea-st at 3 o'cloc!:. , chester, Sllllfley, Oct. Zlifii, :it 4 p. m..

I never had any L‘fin\'ci'f:ziti<»-.i at all (patrioe Plame Cgmgy ‘\.vllell T‘.li:rz l\inl'y MCC-”\I‘ll1l'. Of A511' about the matter. I :lc-vel' agicell not ____ ` mont l`ior':'ll':,i:\:‘. iirrnnlc thc DD Charge him- T0DAY'g F07( §}|()W, THE bl'lg‘.c of Dlincrlll .'Zi.~\'.'al'i. Slllitll St..

'l'fH’E COURT: Did I ilndel'st1ll.d‘C‘;T.m,on and Grand Ohamplon rib. l=l;;xl;rir~y, son of Mr. and Mrs. Nell

you to say that you \vi'»it<~ lilm afwr- bong Wm be pi_,,ced_ Dm-t mg; eh;-, sieu-ali. former-l_v of inn city. The \\'l‘.1‘dS that yO_\l \’-'CYS 1195 i;'>lIl.! l-Ulzmat sign," 3033.1; bride was nitrczi in ivol'_\' sfliiii and cl':irge him? ,__ ;'.‘fil und cill'l'icti ii Ilfiiflivi of iiriclzil

roses nnri ivzls nitclldcsl bf' iw' slr.-

MR- JOHNSTON? 1 WTO” ‘him ,ents “ned and demgnsh-ated by “_ I ter, Miss l\’ial';:ztref. ivllo wore night-

milhy Years afterward-5 that I had `n°t !,.,,.t from New york Monday 3,-5 and 5 illgale pan velvet with hai to matcrl. charged him, lvllicll is quite true. But|;I,l_esda ma M09” 8: M(_LeDds' and C_~_,.,.i,,d H bC,,,,,,,,, of P-al.; ,-0 ee

wllilc thc s'l‘or~:\l wa'-‘ :xtivztclofl iw his cousin. Mr. l`.l:ilii.~l i"1‘i'i'.~. of Han-

nr ever agreed to do the work for ,nm FORMAL CLOSING of thc'ovcr. After tile ccl'clllr'rif', a ividdillg

` supper was scrvcd at thc hclnc of the

and absolutely incorrect- Mr. Sill- , - mid- io the linu;c:ll;~i~ rrinfl~-.~~, The

'_ .1-ri H 3 L c- ~ - ~

CIM’ never “PPr°“°hed me in any ming at 8 ocock S on T leuv _\'oulli¥ ccllplc loft for New York on

ma Y‘--1’ “'13 \‘ W UQQB. n .. -.i .4 ` n lloircvnloon. .

that I ought to be paid, from the day present me championship t`°r"1'c` ...___

that I did the WOI'k down £0 the pres- and banners to the winners' . _]['\'|0R RWD Cgoeg on \\/0d_ i

1 .. .. r.. _ .

fl ti . H - v - -

en me e never offered to Day AT TODAPS Fox SHOW, .1."E`llc.cia_1 aftclilocil, October 29th. the Insmmc mom at Smms _ ,est ow me' Those are ab5°]uf‘e1Y the fans champion and Grand champim rib_ pupils of Albion Focllool. lillcil' thc F _dav “Mt lat _nv ‘N al goo( ofthecaseandMr.Sl.la` kno _` .4 ' - f.~.'~_#l' .A.. - rl' "1 S' " ` ‘

pc r ws bcns will be l9|il°€d- DJIW m'-V; UTS gmdame Q H cn lndcmlf D Mac ,music was filvnlslicd and till- at'.eru`-

Cormac. lrcld a nlcctillp in thc

spent the past few years and are via- lting relatives- and friends in I-'ice River Ss‘_'th.

A very enjoyable da')ce 'ms mat hi

in Gowan Brae cheese factory sir( Wednesday night, Oct. 22nd. by the Gowan Brae Womens Institute. A

large crowd rin-i grind millic ful'n.is‘.i-| led by Messrs. P1-.‘.".' C"/llssrn :inc Dolphic Burke, Bear River. and

others made the time pass all ton, quickly. A number of baskets werll auctioned off by Mr. N. H. Ricll'-lrds, ]‘ Sour.s. and broufllit a ,Hood sum, VC! ulldcrstand another of these tlanceli will be held in the near future. '_

,__.o

'l l

l

Miss Helen Donahce. teacher at

Rollo Bay west, spent the .vrek Und at her home in Rosericath. !

_-_ l

An enioyehle whlsi -ienrtv WHS hvid i5

at _the home of Mr. and Mrs. John _-

Campbell, Bear River. on Wczlncsdav 1 night, Oct. 22nd. T\'.'vl\.n tables \\.'l"'e ' llI:l_vcd. The prizes \'.'crc won \>.'» ' Mrs. Mary C. MacEacilcl‘n, 171 Syl'-i ney St.. Charlottctowri, and l\'r I James Whalen, Bear River South. A cake was rafflcrl and WHS WON by f/fl' -'

Peter J. M:icGn\lgh. The slim of t\vr\l~.ty-illrce dollars wtls reo!izccl_ l

Among the social events of the,

week ivas the Conllllillliiy Club dlrlcel in the hall at St. C'l1:~.ries. -l\’iil=if' was furllislicd by l\icssl'.=. -lnnlrri G.1`l&l.t»

violin: F. G. Cllailzsnll, Bac.: River, Mcmdoliri; and the li/L.=.scs l\l".`SH-‘Elf Pctcrfi. Rollo Bay. and Iinelcili Claris-. son. Bear River, crffailists. 'T' e sum. cf fifty-.<e\'en doilcrr- v.':l.". rch ilell- l i . , *__

Under' the auspices of thc ‘V'orz\,cn_'si

Institute, a dance was llcld in the'

“That has reference to the first gm” sight “_ V 1 f‘chooll‘oolll and ol‘l::inl:e:l-‘ a Junior' anne van not as Frm T ugnbll mm- With regard to the secondl lifted ci-css soeiev.-. Much interest °""”" "' “'35 “ea-.y 9" "7" 5' ‘E item, I discussed with Mr. Sinclair,|` ST' JOHNS CHURCH' Milton! and elithusasnl vas nlzinlfcstcrl bv present and B “dy sum Wa: realized"

' : . . ._ M- - ' ` ` ' ‘ M '

and I think I CHU K0 50 far B5 tfiislmday' Nw' znd 19 30 A m 'tm lbcth boys and girls, :incl \.vllci'c two'

ing Prayer and Holy C0rl'illlllnl0i1.` 'vii' Dove Cliarlofteiovrn, B in,

ig gqizilisiylx,aTyT1;;s;s,F:,§s::l;n;oiDedic:\tion of a memorial to the late ?i';:Pm;"(;i:l<;'; 2°::F“?l§{lC,f;"Lii§n 3: Rollo Ba; at present *installing 1'~s

- - i _ , - ., ', ' 'l ers S' . ' ll - . _ :_

ex-est be pumhasei- Mr_ Sinclair took _ Mrs. H. Horne, 2.30 p. m., St, Mark s_| d` Th _ _ heating apparatus ln ill. new chlrch.

ERUSMCO Holy Communion ,mop m sue c teacher will act as Mo-

University of London, London, Eng- land, from which institution he will graduate at the end of his two years.

DOGS ON HILLSBORO STREET-

A correspondent complains about the number of dogs congregating on Hillsboro street and creating a nvi- sance. Yesterday hc counted no fow- er than fifteen at one spot. and won- dered lf licenses had been paid on them all. In his opinion the only satisfactory way to rcdu-lc lhe num- ber of unnecessary dogs, is to in-

knowledgement of this account.

MR. JCIHNBTON: No. T,l-IE COURT: No acknowledg-

ment of indebtedness from Mr. Sirl- clalr in any way?

MR. JOHNSTON: In fact he nev-

cr answered me

These are the two amounts. $150. I HON. MR. SINCLAIR: There was Toifil , . . . . . . . . . . . .._

no need; the receipt was ncknowledl-

both these items. ed by theregiatration. R. T. li0L.\lA

MR. JOHNSTON: Just one more

point. Suppose your Honor believes

the statement of Mr. Sinclair tl-rat after the work was done I told him

account ll would not charge him anything. H. Mecnilum

THE COURT: Is that the f.rst in- That would not be binding at ali. I R.. Johnson

would still have the right to charge

intimation he had from me. But

work for Mr. Sinclair for nothing.' He is perhaps very much better able to pay it today than he was then. I think Mr. Sinclair, if hc was to do a favor for me. would expect to get compensat’on for it. I have no doubt

livery of his decision, Mr. Sinclair came to Charlottetown. Mr. Bentley was actin! as council for Mr. Mor-

that he looks for his c’lm'iensa.tlon when he does work ' ~~`on‘c. T1-IE COURT: You have no aa-

to make any charge? _him. There was no compensation

MR. JOHNSTON: That is the first _ and I would have the right to collect. i Total ._ . . . ...

He admits I did the work. It is a

able charge or not, and the only ground upon which Mr. Sinclair can escape liability is by invoking the Statute of Limitation.

Tl-IE COURT: The Statute of Lim-

itation comcs into the case, and you haven't overcome it. I have nothing else to do except non-silit you, and I wul therefore non-suit with costs.

crease the licrnse io S5 rririlmum. ,

110111 01' lt. wrote me letters about it . ' ` ` " ` derator of the sociétv. The cicctioni . _ when he Went to Otmwm and asked ' Evening Prayer. Preacher, Rev. | or officers resulted follows: Presi_ 4 'Miss Eulallzl Mullriiy. teacha' at

I ‘ is l, .

me how I was getting along with “_ - George Westbrook, L.T,H. !dent‘ Lloyd Lleweumz Vim_Pl_cs_ l§\.whAcaclleIi. sgenti i.§;~7ev.‘cek end at

' ’ lei* n o r . s .

MY- Sm¢l“lT'5 1etl~@1` 00 me Of ADYU 25- , . | Ivan M:1cKinnoll: Scc'v-Tl'c:=.s. Ber- om’ H g 1923. saysi “I saw Andrew Hayden; P0_“"`:‘“‘ UN'-‘nm CHUM" ._ ‘ the Llewellyn: circulation rilanager, "k `

r .. : -' Mr. James Dcllzlhoe Rioaength f

yeste,.d,w_ He was H b Services on Sunday, Nov. "nd Clif _ _ V , ,

enqu l ng a out i 2 I Isabel Moore, Com cnor of Program motorcd to Rong B,_ , 8 d hm

our business with Dalton. Was any- ltfm' 11 3' md Mt' Herbert’ ‘S9 p' m`; Scott Fraser: Conv:-nor of Hz-:l‘th‘ "3 on un ay

thing further done?" I was receiving fpowml’ 7 P' m' Rev' T' A' Wllson of ‘ and Cleanliness, Rfivmond Dunn.- another wmmlmlcation thmugh 0th_ Cove Head will be the preacher at all (Patriot P10159 cop\‘)~ Ms-ssl-:_ Peter l\larC<lrnicc and Ed. er parties. whieh is not in evlriente. Services. l ` ‘ ` ' “ffl Mniieir Jl'-- Hello l3-"~."- mv cred

However, _I _happened to be 1,, Qi, " -* -iw-._--_ .. W M°"H°eH°' _ ' tawa in connection with anotller ATTENDING FUNERAL”M" WU' ?" matter while this thing we.; vending ’»'i’°“t M°C““’”1° °f Ki'-li<°f*l» ffcelvad rsasowliis I Mi” G“°"¥'~’ E- M“°‘-"°“"¢ 5111** and this correspondence between Mr. W01’d Of the dwlh 011 Tllesday °f his --~- L?‘ke` motmed 1° RGB” B37 reffnny

lion in Boston bcforc c"lll1`w to tl~'~

gard to the Purchase cf his interest. I `1ot,e_ewm-,_ Mr_ M¢N,m_ L, at present Nam] ' ' " ` " . Went from were W B°5"’" ‘Wd T9' ‘the holder' of the same scholarship _ ` __ V turned. I thlllk I name oack tc Mon- for 1929-30 and is a student at the

Rev. A. E. Cllupllian. of

River, P. E. I.. was ia visitor' to I’-il‘~ _

cocliac on li/ffonday. hir. Cllapmnn nc- compnzliccl izy I/£l'.~1. Cllnpzllall, are rc'-| iul'n'filg from Pzillgfvr. Mc.. \vllr\i'c| they spoilt n fclv dflys \'.'l‘il Mi':.` Chnpman's sister. Mrs. Calvin Webb. and Mr. Webb. Mr, Cl‘..'lplllzil1_ who will join Mrs. Cll:ipin:‘.n lil Mnllctoll. are en l'olltr~ liorllo. Mr_ Cllailman was a formal' |ln.='f»r nf liin I‘lril~o dist Cllllrrll lil Pvi‘i~¢:!‘ri:'. .".t. John

’-I`c!r"r.'ipll Joilriml

BOWLING

'rl-;l,i;~r°rlosl-2 co. l

J- E. Moore W. Wakciin

Smith

W. Gas: M:l\'s-".11

160 200 lil? 212 91

850

124 152 l.`i9 l25 l67

727

in isa 154 153 189 “_ l 823 2400

P1537'

F

N Lin.

Toonlos .... ._ :los zen 233! Scnmcn 145 130 103, Affleck

?’?"f-7

iss, lal I

22a` 929 2872

167 120 219

D66

'J59 181 184

977

there was no reason why I ehoiildlquestlon of whether it is n reason- a0\vl.|Nc roslcilr

GAME ENDED IN DRAW’

IIALIFAX N.S. Ort 31.-Kings

University and St. F.':mc‘s Xzivle:

played f. three ell drew this silo:-L

- station on (hs ccvn':r`,

rooms for a local oar deal..-

il

\ .

noon ill ii regular fixture of the in uloollogiate rugby league. -

on a bu°‘ri"ss trip.

Sincla’r and myself wasigoillg oil. and ,Sl-'Si€i‘» MTS- Daniel EWS' at MY 1101116 THE I-`Ult.\l.il. (‘l.0.'~'lNl2 `ol thc " " Mr. Sinclair ll I IGM 'fhff l'l'lRUi€l‘ UP in EVSWU9 M555- The deceflseli W9-5 Fox Show will take p`a:e t'."ls ev- ,_-mm ` `8-Sain and told me that the man that ,the daughter of the late Mfr. a.l1d}m;ng at 8 0~C|0:k_ His Hmm. Gow; _N£"' R'°5'm“'d Mafnom .- QW" he thought would put up the money ,Mrs. James McCa.rville of Kinkora. lerlzor Hcartz will present the cham- ! Pm" momma t° 5'5"” M055!!--*E

E; pérchlze Mr. Dalton'a interest in She leaves tohrgollm btesides hell- husé pgmship t-,-0;-|,;e_-_ A H bmmcys to t-ni., Y "__l”*'

e uar an was Mr. Hardy, who, I band, four c dren, hree grs an mmm-s_ 8007

understood at the time, was Senator one boy. Mr. Mwltrviile left cn Wed- i _ ___ '”"_

Hardy. Mr. Sinclair brought me up nwday for Everett to attend the fun-F Du He-C. H meL$ch€,. of Mankato LONDON* Oct' 31""P1'!"°e c°°’5°' to Sena,” Hard” omce and We d;s_ lem! which took place on Thursday :Mun Wag' ha; [ren “mn her Sim' I foul-in and youngest son of me Rini! cussed the matter there. Up to this , i.. ‘ter Jclmhe 1; mg B`Cdgfo1. nil i and QM” °f Englfmd' 15 5°” '9 9° time W had 11° ‘l»=-filialice that Mal scilouiirsrrlr Aw'anpan-Thehiece lvirs' .l A }c.rlr'm.n one ioflln-me 'L Duke' nccgrmz 1° “nm

Da‘.I'.'in would transfer his 'iriln ilp'r1 D h me Em 1 escas .L , ` , ‘. Y _' M Times'

the Guardian. an.l liir. Slitclar in ‘p;%t;;sateo!schoi.a.rsh£'irefol'0vP;ince l;h.L.1;da`\ lon mlmu to l.m home' Tm H is Enticipawd' Judghw “Dm th' L-m",._ on ,this 0c¢a5mn_ :hen m_ ;Edwud Island mr 1931-32 has been iofmwg ‘Y/;;l°iE'§P}`i:" $323 Drecedellt of his tlzrcc rider brothers,

td .- af -l ' .‘ “ B

foellreisl e me t_o ee to ,ston aid in ‘awarded to Mr. W. Stewart McNutt Legmm ,,m,,.,d,,_., the ,TCP ,t w,“.en_

ew S.: charles Dalton with le- 50,., of Major -1-_ E_ Mcrqutt of Cher.

PRINCE GEORGE T0 BE A DUKE

that the nncuncemeni will be made on the Pr-ince's twenty-eight birth- day. December 20.'

No ci:-felllifi kncsfnrlrfe as to the

flllr- that will be given him is yet rvnllahle, but it is forecast that ii will hc n Scottish nllc--the D'li-redom of Erilnburfth--vvlllch l1'i= been in zlbryrincv since Pr-lilrv .'~i.’.~d. second sell nf Qlxcfn Vlric:'i:i. lirlid ii.

“li is possible that :ln ‘larld nn and

ri Barony wil also hc colfereri on thc Prlzlcc as in ti'.~ rr c of hlf br'iill:~rs.

Til” rlllfizilriii of in=iki'~" 'lie ap-

}1'\illt::‘cl:‘ |irZxm:'l?\' ict' \'.th th! liillu. zlitllmigll he lllilsi. ob lin ap. provcl ff his liIi~,i'i~"= :rid Farliill ment. There are no ‘fil¢."'i iases G' this rvcr l:~‘.r:_z rc’il=c'l.

SAYS UNION \`»'lLL ET LP FISIZITZT-ZEN

Hnnnlxscovlv N s. o~+.: '. -out ~

lill‘ilg growill of ihn iill.io1 :lritim`i‘y'.,;

‘ 1

fi:.llcl‘mc:l Dr. Rlr‘il.".r<l I-la tral .srcrctnry of the o'.~<:~1r. thc I-Icrringcovc ln::l ilnl

'i', een' :on told .liar-:ner

of the Mlriillncs \\'<>i..;l i::'z extent of more ill:-ll ii ni. Q before the cllcl of 1031 bg' the newly folrner o=,i.oci; union is urging the fcdc: ment to invc-_t‘gnlc tllc I tivrcn prices paid tile i‘:.1l paid by the uollsulllcr. /it I Dr. Hamer declared fizhc' bein; paid eight-cents for l: crei which cost the ocnslz cents and four cont: for s: c:':l which retollcsi nt