l

. MAXIMS or A

MERCHANT

__._-

.

T°~dl¢ "Tlng to do something worth while. is not to have lived In

llt

The P

MAXIMS

017A

MERCHANT

_-_-q

'l‘llr-re can he no cnordlllltlﬂll n

vain’ _ without authority, confidence, or lmill. —"—"—-————————- (lovers PrllrceEdward Island Like the Dew ﬁllmsszigru-z? 3"5-"57""'5 CHARLOTTETOiWN, CANADA, SATURDAY, APRIL 21,1928 gg;;l$-~>;;_,g;;;e=-;__g;

ransom , I iEEIlISIIIIIIIE ASSEMBLY

Liberal and Conserve In Debate 0n Budg tions Asked by Op

I Continued) April 18th

llon. Mr. Maelntyre continued

ms speech. He ,.said that befortl llr-A. A. Macnonald- In this

ordering the machinery hEhad Con. suited every member oi‘ the Gov- crnnlent also private members as tlley came into thc office. And all were agreed that the machinery should be procured. He had tin. tflllsﬁlll. of the Government and the, private members to the ratification of the purchase. The purchase has been ratified and payment author», ized and everylfling is all right. l

Mr. MacIntyrc went on to dis- pute some of Hon. J. D. Stewart's figures, as given in his speech he claimed thero was a discrepancy be- tlvccrl The Guardian and Mr. Stew- art ill this matter. He then said "The Grlardian newspaper says that Government Control is still a policy of tllc Corlscrvativc party, and nrv: hon. frielld says it is a closedI hook-who are we to believe?"

'l‘lle Minister" of Public Works then went on lc- quote further :ztrltistits ill support of his conten- tion that the Conservatives spent more money than did he and hrs party witnout receiving proper authorization. '

lie went on to ask for leniency on the part of the pppositlon for young members of the house who were not conversant with the rules of prozeedure. It ill becomes my Hon. friends to twit the young members for not knowing the proccedure.

llon. Mr. Stewart- They seem t0 know the rules of proceedure bett- er than a great many of the older CD055.

llon. Mr. Maclntyre said 1119i evidently the leader of the opposit- ion couldn't know the rules-so well.

cor he would not have interrupted

'/

I

the Minister of Agriculture in his speech inthe way he dld, referring to matters in a previous debate.

llon. Mr. Stewart denied this, and some amusing cross firing ensued. He went on further to defend his converse in ordering the road ma- chinery without oi the Legislature: He expected that in a month~ they would have the main roads, ,which were ill o. worse stoic this spring than ever before. fir for travelling.

After twitting Dr. MacMillan on the length of his last speech, Mt‘. Maclntyre brought his address to a elosr.

Mr. Russel Clarke, referring 10 lIle lobster industry, was of the opinion tllat it would be better for the packers if the season were‘ ".0 open earlier. He also thought that thc standard weight of the can wlls set too hlzh. and 811V‘? 518111“ to support his contention.

lie approved of the oyster grounds being turned over to the Govern- ment. Mussels were a menace to the oysters, and it would be a good thine! if they could be removed. _

Referring to the migratory bli"_l law ho thought that in enacting this treaty. the United States pub things over on us. The act W0" hibits spring shooting—s0methinf! that comes very hard on our b00019- He criticized the attitude of the Federal Government in the matter- the late Government as well as the present one.

Mr. Scuily began by defehdl-‘IZ the Bell Governments record on the matter of debt. and criticized M1‘. Arsenaulfls statement that the B011 Government had "Manufactured surpluses."

lle went on to conEfBI-"Iaw m” nrenlier for his frank and straight- forward presentation of the budget. He was proud that the P1911119“ would come out and 8W9 B m“ “ml square presentation of the fin- ancial condition of the countrv. e"- t-n if ho did budget for a deficit.

lle claimed that the reason wily it was necessary to refill“ m“

Georgetown-Newport ferry W118 °*\

account of the ship (which We‘ built twelve years ago) hevlns bee" constructed of green lip-Belem?“ timber.

Recommended the, new road MI- llnd condemned the old system of statute labour. He was of the cpl"- Ion that the new machinery would do the work on the roads much cheaper and MIMI‘. The old system should have been abandoned yell" nan.

Dealing with the lnwr-prevllwlel conferencepho felt that we had from it the practical assurance thTt 0111i: subsidy of slump-W We" d s ol-tly be i used.

_' He did nomlnk it was right. that the opposition loader should ridi- culo the members ct the house whﬂ attend“ m; lnggglngs of the Tent- Derenee Alli-nth.‘ .

Also he reﬁtted Mr. Stewart-e critic-ionic! the employment e1 M“ leith Poole u auditor. There was no reason why be should cut reflec- lions on him because he wu l1 prominent member of narty. alluding to the 0P I°ldcrs remarks re oollltioui much- Ines. he thcom ma. u» R91» member should bothink hllnulf 0f

the authorization ,

tive ‘members heard ‘et- _I111P01‘tant ques- posltlon Members.

lthe Government Control machine, Egld the avalanche it brought upon I m.

Blouse we see just now Mr. Speaker, the ministers of the Government loekeying and holding back. I am m‘ 8°11"! 1° held you long. we will have been a month llere tomorrow, and there ls mllcll legislation to be blollght down still. Much of tllc slowness with which things al-e moving is uueto the incompetence 0f the Govermrlent legislators in dfpftins their bills. We don't criti- Cliﬁ the younger members. They are 1101118 better than the older ones- men who have had a long" experi- enco in this house.

This session will long be rememb- ered on account of the expense l0 which the country has been conn nlltted. This gravel will not be per-J nutrient-rt has to be constantly rc_I newed. Has the Minister of PubllcI Works counted the cost? ‘ _It takes about $4,000.00 to gravel a road. If we gravel only 500 nlllot; 1L ‘Will cost ‘about $3,000,000.00. I think the Mlntslcr of Public Works lad better go a little slowly.

H‘? 11115 bought some machinery. There was no order ill council pa:- sed. But he says you can't spend money by order in council. Verv true. But an individual member 011M spend the money. And rho mallhmefy wears out very fast. Will we. in‘ three years time, have a lot of old junk on our hands-junk that had cost $90,000.00.

Our friend the Minister of Agri- culture hns made some rmearks

mbout our discussion of the Aus- ltrallan Treaty. »

' M. Horace Wright il00klng up from reading the "Patriot“l W35;

the honygentlenlan referring to mo’? ILHUEhECFJ

Dr. MacDonald-ll’ you are tn. Minister of Agriculture, I am referr- "18 t0 you. The‘ speaker- then went 0Y1 f0 Elve a list of solne of the many dairy organizations which had protested." against tllc Austral‘ rTreaty. As for the Hon, member fronl Bedequc‘ there was a time when he railed against the manu- factoring industries. This was when he was a progressive, but since then he has changed his tunc.

lHere Mr. Wright protested that he had said ‘that it was his Conser- vative friends who had changed [their view point).

Prohibition-It is prohibition, said the speaker, who has put you where you are. and us where we are. Bllt when a man tells me he is a prohib- ltlonist my hand almost voluntarily Eoes to my pocket book. It is ‘my ex- perience that most of them are hyprocritical. There was a. great prohibitionist who came to me and asked for a script.

llon. Dr. MacNelll-If you are re. fcrring to me. I deny it! (Great laughter).

We had a most bewildering array of figures here in the last few days. I tllink tllc speech which was de-- livercd here the other night by tllc leader of the Government which was the most bewildering affair l have ever listened to iapropos of this the speaker went on to tell a humorous storyl. I will give him credit for this, that he only arrived at. cne deficit-quite enough for this country.

There is always a great amount of money spent in an election year be- callsc the people get very active. and, ask for things they wouldn't get at other times. Then too the representatives are more proud to grant them. But the Conservatives are far from being alone in this characteristic.

D . MacDonald went on to denv tha the bridges in his district were in he delapidated condition des- cribed by the Minister of Public Wcrks.

We have been twitted, he said. with having no farmers on this side of the house. But we were sent here by farmers; they were satisfied with us. and they will be more than satisfied after this session is over.

llltsllllll GIRL ls A WINNER,

lCanadlan Press.)

VANCOUVER, B. 0., April 20.- An inspiring story of the brilliant success of a Vancouver girl was told at the annual meeting of the Wo- men's Musical Club. Slngled out four years ago as the winner oi‘ the scholarship \offered. by the cluh, Miss Barbara Custance was given an opportunity to continue hel- studies in a broader environment. There she won thc scholarshipol the Associated ‘Boards of the Royal Academy and Royal College of Lon- don. being the first Canadian to re- ceivn such an honor. At the end of thc two years. Miss Custance will be offered another scholarship which will take her to Vienna to continue her studies in that famous musical centre.

T0 VISIT PEMIE RIVER

(Canadian Press) EDMONTON, Alta. April 20.- “Pm looking forward with keen in- terest tcl lny trip through the Peace River country this summer." suzd His Excellency, Lord Willingdorl. who, with Lady Wlllingdon. spent half an hour in the city en route to Vancouver Island. ,

His Excellency will take in the Calgary Stampede lil July, and im- mediately thereafter will head north for Edmonton and the Peace River. .

"And I'm going along, too, of course," added Lady Willlngdon. “I'm just as anxious to see the wonderful north country as any- body else.“

smuggling. They were putting on extra force, but that will never sic") it. That law is (treating a great Idisregard for the oath. In every prohibition case wecee perjury day after day. Prohibition is not the only thing to be considered. We must consider agriculture. .oduc-.l- tign and other matters. and we silculd drop this fanaticism. Bu! Prohibition is a closed book. and cur friends have control of the plebiscite.

I No man ever went to the prov- ince with such a Janus faced lmliP-IVI as Premier Saunders. said thcl speaker, who went on to state that nine tenth of the liquor got today

1

llllollzlllllsllllll. w. I. P. llcllllllll “ HIR looms SPEAKS 0N nun lllnlllss

lb wmrvirarsc. Mara, April 20.—T\VOIHe RBVlGWS Th9 Work Of the GOVGI’ l1‘ , t‘ e t. e a er ‘ . - will... "$‘§..?..,‘"....'.i‘ n1 ﬁnféltlffr merit During The Past Year Ill The Dif-

erine Booth, sent from London,‘ And

England. to the new Salvation Army; ktralning college were unveiled at a;

public ceremony on April l0. Thisl date is the 99th anniversary of the birth of th l f l, .- f - e a e genera m‘ mm Continued 0r two ago. when lu- was Leader of

der of the organization which has, now become world wide. Tile busts; ;WlllCIl are life size and executed in lthe finest style of this art; are the Sift oi‘ the present general to the lcollege in Winnipeg. '

‘BIIY KING

Rt. Hon. W. L. Mackenzie King fright.) prime minister of Canada. . and Hon. n. B. Bennett, leader of the oppesil’ at Ottawa. are lull- rons of this year's Canadian and In ternational Oratorical Contests. _ The Canadian championship will be held at the Arena. Tﬂfﬂlllll. 011 ‘Wednesday evening, May l6. with competitors from British Columbia, Anmmh phnlgobﬂ’ Qngm-lo aml Prince Edward Island. The free trip to Europe and the right to real Contest in Washington on Octrl present Canada at the Internation- represented. The Ontario champi bcr l3, when ten countries will beOntario at tllc Canadian finals, will unsllip. to decide who will representon Wednesday evﬂllnﬁ. May Z. Wil-h be held in I\Ias:.e_v' llall, Torontmparts oi’ tllc province competing. (lislrlct champions from various

§this nlcrnlng to show just how ex- w“ m“ “"0"” “"0"”! W0 M?" travngant the Stewart Government ‘Icurd ‘““‘.°"°" I" “051101150-1100"! had been irl its road policy. Never- m? Emds “YIPYOVIW; WW1 “lle- The tireless, the challenge was lllade on Mmlste" of liubnc works rerun“ lsereral occasions in this House and to Pnc road mus ‘Iwnlmgl that W011- was never accepted, and the figures ‘lam! Wnistbl“ Rmd "m" 51111111191‘- dmve new‘. been disprove“ that the side to Tlgrllsh.’ which was in such roads bum by the smwart Gwen“ nllcndld condition under the Boll mo," cost the Province Something Goverlunctlt. Docs the lvlllnlrlter m“. ha" the cost o‘. “m” hum by claim that the Bell (iovernmont V"... B?" GovcmmcnL Now I submit bullt that road from Slllnlnerside to

V

from the Vendors was drunk for beverage purposes. Surely thc Tenn‘ perance Alliance must know that. Now, I have had the honour of having been assigned to the Public

Accounts‘ Conlmittee. ,And mv| friend. Mr, Harry MacLeall. was. put on‘ the Agricultural Com-

mittee. I don't sec why Twas put on, and I don‘t see why he wasn't put on the Public Accounts Com- mittee. The speaker was of the op- inion that the leader of the oppos-I ition might well have been on that committee.

Reverting to the matter of roads, the speaker thought it would be well if the Minister would go sloll, and keep an eye on tho finances.

Dr. Grant. who followed thought that the fact that the oppositioll members were sober men was a good argument for prohibition. as otherwise they would not have been elected.

Although the member from the Third district of Prince criticized us for inept legislation. he had to have a clause struck out in a bill which he introduced. ‘

Dr. Grant went on to charge tllc Conservatives with having used tar:- ation for political expediency ever since the days of Sir Louis H. Davies-putting taxes on and tak- ing them off as seemed politically advantageous. He charged them with opposing progress in oppos- Iing the new road act. and ln vari- ous other matters. They wcrc. he said. pmpagarldists. both in and out of office, playing up the loyalty cry when it suited their purposes.

He gave certain instances of poli- tical propngandizillg that had come within his own experience. Dr. Grant complained that The Guard-

I I

The speaker, alludhg to a bill considered at the morning session saidtht the membes were not fopd to vote for measures which gave an unfair monopoly or ad- vantage. He hoped they would not do it in the future.

Dr._MacDonald said that it had been put on by the Stewart Go".- ernmcnt to help keep rip tile roads. They have raised it ,2 cents, and they figure on getting t00.000.fl0 from it. There are only 4,000 odd cars in the province. Someone will have to do some joy riding to d0

thi.. ,

(Mr. Allen rose. and 0x01111119‘! that they planned to raise a large osrt of it from foreign carol. Dr. MacDonald. ICSUIHlDBv 0101111" that the tourist rlrjntlleiwzruld herd- l be iI n ug o 0 ~-

y $11.: oto Prohibition. Dr.

aid Blld that Prohibition who the cauro of a great deal of name ‘brewing. moonshinlng and

I

Dealing with thc Gasoline Tax.|

Ian in an editorial had dLstortcd ll. statement of his re Government. ,‘Control, leaving out the words "u-.1-' ﬂcrtunate“ and "unlikely". ln,l923. lne said the Conservatives were go- Iing to spread lnud over the prov- ince. but instead of that they! spread The Guardian. He also told- a story of a calf which had died. A iman had said. "he must have been poisoned because he had eaten The ' Guardian." , Dr. Grant went on to express the ' hope that the Government would do ‘Sﬂléthlllﬂ to fulfil the plank in he platform re old age pensions.

I The speaker then went on to crlti- I

rive the lPrince of Wales College. because children went into Prince ,nf Wales College. with failures in three or follr subjects who then ,were sent home at Christmas dis- couraged and demoralized. Hisi Conservative friends in crltlclzinlt the premier for meeting the Tem-

perance Alliance delegates in h.‘ home on Sunday night reminded l

wiaicl was. that alcohol was a nur-Ior to stay here, we must, make our,

lthnt if the Minister of Public Works Tigms“? HON. MR. Mc-INTYRE: c.-

DR. McMILLAN: The Mil Agriculture knows Irerter. only built ill part by lhCIlL

HON. MR. Mcnrrvnl-z; Tile Bell overnment built i tl l alder swam“ l lloulzll the

DR. McMlLLAN; Oil. v tllc Saunders alder sulam didn't build it front Stu Tlgrlislr.

rtninly. lisler of If was

es; through D: but they

""0"" wmk“ Deparlmcn" the afinisrer cl‘ Public Works under 18109 M11050?!‘ 0f Public Works. w“ late Conllllissionerol Public Works 419 l5 I1 big mﬂn- We "~11 K110“ ma‘ Crosby should llavl- hull a proper ‘hlm. I suppose he knows that iu-sl nligllt work uul Well, but nothing" ins. and from some statements he Railwa ; divide lln- lrurk up ma. - (Canadian Pres“ IEIBEIIUOH I0 SOHIEIhiDB 8158- It lS crnment. Ml‘. Saunders admitted. .89]! the boy king of Rnumamal eh“ in possession of the Government url- to the late (ruinous-sinner. Mr. firm- they would remember the lvords oi‘ he had so nlany of these improved Dr. Grant again referred to thc i1 trol was not a good way to false a ‘Hldﬂl Terdiman, of Jassy, Roll- desperate results of Government by Bell Government, was inntltulnltlug feel very strongly. ,ure the revenue. “Michael has gripped the hearts Council in connection with those, (Mr. Saunders) had no doubt bul. must m the end come from our ‘people; of Rgumgnjg do “or “rant going to inaugurate a new road pol- no reason for it that he could under- Dr. llIacNeill. after extending hislsanle basis as in British Columbiaslwﬂs Vlewed Eenerﬂlly 8S 9- 511M “m” “I the present “me? we Wm up i" "m" ""5090? H0 boiled they ceased menlbers. dealt with tll-Hwhere they cotlld get tllc money t0 ‘ushe came home and mm "5 Wm“ ‘Perhaps when “w House meets again Liberal NWUW‘ "l. Ilnﬂds‘ referred to the material appearinglNeill stated that no tangible or con- ‘the People 0f this Cﬂhtiﬂehf." Ill‘ damn mmrovelnent or not‘ crial." in Mollcton. between PremiersIROHmania greater." Spccuws “m! m‘: “S” °f hea-"Y lwwul tmuo“ And I mmk m“ crmclsﬁ‘ one on this side of the llouséFl-leito bringing in Government Coll- Iecmmmy "will"? Pfﬂcf-leed in what durmg‘ m" whm" "1"" ""5 they nrent Ccntrolin all the provinceslgiven out that they were held to m“ Duncan cmnmisslon evidence or dealing with tllc traffic. He went on crease in thc population of the pro-I UIIII-ed sums “mud be bemEﬁCMLI ed from Government Control storeai On this question of emigration, _ "med 83am“ the "eclmocity treal‘ l‘ He proceeded to say that he lllllllellb? Simply because they think theyl m“? “"" 39E it again And in the Australian Trude Treaty — D1‘- 01- the Mayo Cum“ These men “w; can me boys and girls of this that a nation could not live to it- regard to that. But he attempted‘ cricn, and when they say that alco-Iencl-off the farm? What can we do‘,ig‘§§f1fuf;“§§,m‘hhemﬂﬁugh. lllea road project running from lvlnlmq Ht- also quoted Dr. Grcnfells tesll- look about for wider markets. Vpressed himself as being aﬂhamgdlperldltbll? on that road yem- age,- nmonld‘ t.

-‘ l (I

the Opposition. lle is talking about This morning we had quite a nice m‘. m.“ Govcnnnclluaa discourse from our hon. friend the “ML Snunderb ncvvl. ‘hxc‘)5‘ld m‘. Ella‘!!! b91911 101d by 11151110515 W!“ for the delay during the last two lspoke on the Government side the» years of tllc mu (iovl-rlllncllt. Mr. 11B 1'5 i1 hi8 nlﬂn; and I want to tell working s_vstenl. Mr. Saunders llflfl him U111! he 11115 11 01E 10b M16110 0f su ested ll svslenl wllllrll he tlluu ill. I 8f; . i! Ias well as I do: but from some ﬂs- was done. We sllmlltl llllvv had u s P UPlEIUFGS he Submitted here "115 "IOFII- system similar to that l‘lll'l‘It'(l nll mlr ‘Imade, I really believe that his time sections," 01,1; ‘would be better occupied in paying “One fault 0i the late Bell (inv- . 1d {hill bet-Ween 875.000 811d $100.- was in regard in lIli" nlaulteI l r TORONTO, o r., ,_ _ s“ , _ . , _ . . . - -"‘ 1" me hem“ of his Zounggﬁenfllzmcﬁflﬂlw worth o1 lend ruaehlnely is new 0i our public Fllfifls‘ Ht" hnrl spoken . der the Department of Public Works. by tlmc and lune ‘l’ i M- l , _ I _ _ _ _ . ' . . . plnnl. nlu I. Evie ‘jxféggsrged t tfxflgrlllzf‘! 2‘ “$183213; You would think, Mr. Speaker, that Crcsbys answer invariably was that j fume bee“ mellllmled as a PBTW 1° their 01d leader. the Hon. Mr. Bell, FOHGS to do that hc hadn't time m him of the Scribes and Pharisees. ‘the opinion that uovernmtnt Con- "llrlgues w T5811!!! 1t. lwcﬂrdmg 0) who preached so often against ihecorlsidcl- the others. Iluter on the failures in Ill-inc‘. u; wales 301.18g,“ ll-evennn, as so much money would imﬂlllﬂ. a privite banker, who_.isvin Order-in-Council. I do not know a policy oi‘ maintenance, but unfor- un which subjech hewappcared ‘.0 lhnve to be Spent on “Qum- m Sea. [the city. P" whether there were any Orders-my tunately that. time didn't come. Ho . (At 0 p. m. the debate’ was all-i He held that the revenue from 1o!‘ his people." said Mr. ‘Terdiman. road tractors or not;; at ally rate I that the late COlIImISSlOHCT had the joumed m 8 l, m, ‘such a source was illusory, as it He wlll make a good km; The believe they are here. and they arc-very best intentions, but therc was EVENING SESSION basic industries. He estimated that." 9am‘ I° “me ‘Mk-f . my‘ m” m“ ‘m “mbmws 1’r°"s'.““d' Th” D“"‘"“'“"“ ‘mm’ “l” . if they spemm this province on the, Queen Mule-s mp to Amerwa gram, which we will not say mucrllitliscnt Government needs backing congratulations to the speaker. and,‘ they would pay out $1,200,000.00 for 51106055 811d ll dlﬁllﬂcl- hfll) l0 the glilgsnézetyglxgwaygalgmtgic wwkz“ xgtllugollﬁfnsfliay, l." m“ “m” 01d "I"; his tribute to tile memories of de-lalcollolic beverages, and WOIldCYCCLCOI-lntry In M13 Terdlmans ‘mlnlml-l e m“ o" ‘ "u" ' it will be time enough to judge h‘ f _.T ., Am d _ d _ _ she saw-the resourcefulness. the . . ._ _ " , , tlllslrnrlllbtjigﬁlein qlzlgctlogleazglttl oFzﬁvincial Conference-DI‘. MQCVPYDEEeSSIVQ-"ess and me enerlll’ "f m whether ms pohcy 1s ‘Such a “Ion- 011K115‘ , , ' - . to th . c .. ' _ in The Guardian “Notes by tile'crctc results had flowed fromisﬂld- ‘She Wishes 118 t0 8110M the?!thitéiéuilftfléglige(gysiéﬁuggrgoalgkﬁﬂ llc will;“InaJImSILSRQKIII($2.21? way", as "rot" and "decayed mat-various provincial conferences held.¢l1111‘5¢t9l‘l5u°5 0E YWYS and ma“ ' ' " . . . Jnachines is quite a transformation “m ‘Wm’ JIII-“Ilrmd- IWPHIIM. so for There 11¢ nothing in that. pledgwRllodes. 130K191‘ and stewﬂﬂ. when» n _ f t t ,' as road maintenance ' - . . inconsistent with the belief of ahy-wonferences were held with regardIﬁznsgﬁdrgiblgiitvaﬁgs tfgénoPgfyg means’ o marsh’ h“ ‘he utmost “a ronvernm‘ . c ~ . '- ~ _ . ,is k the l, - _. We e In power no slnzle. stated that he had seen Govern- trol, so it was said, though it was Ceeded t” read 0°11? the "P0" °~ Danger; i‘)? "n, arlgerzgnegfin‘ £129 mile. The rondsuwercasilnply “l- and expressed his conoiction thatldecide on an emigration policy.vI“fIt“°55°5 1° the cue“ tllatv?‘ trad: prohibition was the best way of The speaker wondered wllat in- Ineaty m pulp and papa‘ “m1 m‘ to read an article from "Notes bl,‘ vincc had flolved fronl these COH-‘This policy was ravfmlwzd .by 1g?‘ tllc way" dealing with revenues rai"- =, fererlccs. same Premier Baxter. who in l ... -. - - =,. , .. . ' ‘ty priv- and expressed his disagreement with I vlhy do people move from tllls pro-. Bu‘ We lost m“ remproc‘ it. ‘vince to other parts of the contin-I "e39 “m! n Wm be I‘ long time b” been lnisquoted when he said that can better their condition. To irl- meantim" the ‘.*"."‘°‘_'~“ gfdugs Conn“ alcohol was "no good“. What llc had duce people to colne to this country. "Y have 1”‘ "muons ° ° Us‘ I . _ . . . . 1 . hewanted to ive l‘ . . coile and not a stlnlulant-state-‘baslc industries ifarming and fixll- MacNeln wen‘ ‘m I'° defmd t g g "5 501118011115 new “mus ‘nude by D1.’ Charles Mayﬂling) profitabm s lAustrllllall trade treaty. He thougllthe nlight have told us something in among the leading surgeons in Am—-pl'ovincc makc wages and a dividq Se“ 91°” and that it’ Shoullgndgi:‘zclglilwllolvlloag Dggsiloslrllefwgillllg 15.231001. G hol is a narcotic. and not a stimu- I to‘ make these industries nlore prof- s, . . lant. their words must carry weightzl’ itable? The logical thing to do is to. llgﬁzgcsgctfledvi¥geY°$§p£:}{°ér°“§;.. ieigellti-Iall ‘Igllgarglfgxll-eafglgtlfli; or‘: nlony in favour of Prohibition. Dur- Dr. MacNcill claimed ‘hat the . we - m ' _ inlt the regime of the late Govern- farmer and fisherman ‘of this that m9 province was doing w“ m u“ n came up m mm $50"

l _ ' r000: dh ~id," ~’ ._ mom Imople ‘Vere discouraged with Country had a ﬁght to Ship the“ “tllc “Ir fpuzlﬁtlilllgaltglxf‘ wllsgrilmulllll Oncnllncf tfresnstewarrrltleéleollzrllllselﬁll' HON’ MR‘ SAUNDEIH‘): 7'1"‘! the prohlbltion law. as the Attorney products lo me- mo“, proﬁtable, élavcalﬁoic l1)“ this hrovmce m pry “@000 spam on one project!" e bullt all bllt about six miles of 1l_

DR. McMlLLAN: n correct, either. No 17991111512 you are mistake. It is l.

o. tllnt is not lvclorrl. interrupt,

liable tn umkg n lore- than six "HIPS

General claimed it could not be en-lmal-kelg mere we“; 1n 1911 LaLu-lm-l forced. Now times have change-Lltried to get such markets throughi Dr. MacNeill claimed. He said thatIthe reciprocity agreement. The doc-I he had never seen a drunk in this‘

t o ulation than ill gEElte?“pro‘I/ir?cles.prlie thought 9111"‘ u 10°“ prom’ bad‘ d.°es“l It‘ m" mp5 some time m the futu-relilllllﬁfldltllli? on those eighteen nlilcs

ltor at this point proceeded to give Per l“ T0110? I might refer him. ilow-

' f '1 . city 3mm me Session bllunn‘ 1., 1mm “st of the products» which’ some buildin! for thepurlwsea 0 ‘ 1a,". to some of the proje t, m‘ froln Bloomfield in 'l‘igm,~.n_ H0 “WW 110i 0f the Olllhiun that} under it would get admission to sanmmum mum be1p‘°‘1f'~éifa:$3g_ were built under the Bell cGsoverrllf - HQN‘ MR" llﬁlwryREf T llllltllt alcohol should be permitted to be United States markets. where mfhe ‘mm '4' ° Iment. when he was a nlember of mum“ 1hr‘ llon. Dot-tor that on.

nlllers are not then: now,

DR. McMILLAN: ll I'.V 1n throw out he Bell Govern did boulevard i‘

I llright refer to pro- and say to hinl that it t i1 800d thing the Bell Govern- t ,mcnt went out of power when they »did. because that. project he nlcn.

Such, he went on to s y. " the» wwn" -, , - Fm“ HWSQ» Drcducts which we could ‘Ilavzelghirl- I In Concluding 1m addless. "Jens 12 or 14

pod mm the United slates undenMacNeill praised the Premier for hishvas

. . . ~ . did t'. t ent o" the finances '15! tllc reciprocity agreement. But It 3:: c°.":£-::Tn hislbudget speech.

sold. Its sale should be prohibited. just as tllc sale of morphine and cocaine is prohibited. He went on to criticive the Conservative leadrrl

ut why llo you the inlprcssion that mcnt left a splm- rom Summersidl- l0

and his press froln Il1~1Vlfl_' switched. was clefe t t \ - ‘es, , - _ _ from the support of larohllbition tojwho went: lgrgllglllbthfrlgriﬁilvilitrl‘ #1110815" wmlmy °°§mQfinﬂ§§r tllsgéillcned ﬁllured out on the rate oi‘ 3"?" ‘my “"‘"l "Ill of advocacy of Govm-nnmnt Conlmlpcnmpnlgn 6r “no truck “m. mule .Minlster of l".blir lilo! w - ‘their expenditures on them, insteadIpmm ' n p“? lml W" “WI l5 1111-‘ He then laroeeedl-d to quote figurcsl with the Yankees". Tilis argument. Pmﬂesslve 7°“ 0904- id that the 0f Costing $50000 would have Cnsnislm, ‘to bU-‘slllbl-Ills well I01" a Ml“- to tllc effect that British Columbiajlle went on to develop and enlarge Mr‘ w‘ EL Dennis 5a l B 10370000‘ ‘last lrnj‘ dculldu.‘ w‘. hm" m“ spends $25.00 p/‘l’ canita per annum’ on, quoting from n speech by Hoil. grejglrlrfmfxffeﬁg§eatglglltzo‘tllc "f!" Road F I ‘ IIIOIN l

< - , . o . ; s l.‘ 1 ' 1-1 olcor- ior alcoholic bLJPIHIlPS. He was of R. B. Bennett. as quoted from bumes o‘ the province through‘ _ pendlture. Vmnwd m" bundling or ‘mm. w!"

Islarted lIll‘lll ‘lllfl Will mm“ ‘ ~ . led _ 1111111. ’i‘hnl ls all vol ll H past follr year; I . ~ ,' ‘ ‘L he general criticsisllllllllélfl‘ MUIHLLAN: PM“ "n

monies spent on Highway improve-i ment, but in no other way. He lvent, on to quote phrases from the public’

We have heard . roads during me a great deal about

this Hctlse. and t we

accounts to show that the ﬁnancial of my hon, friends wa th t ‘ condition was not so bad as the opq Steam-l Government GIGSIIOY/Ellllglgf? gg"M“lA'4‘I-L$A UNDISRS: Yes. position had painted. the roads. I submit, Mr. Slleakeltlnnclerrlt history-Ail" m“ reams m0

t he year they

He considered that. but for cer- that men w Those wonden

tain wind falls in the way of subsr-Ilng stateme dies, etc.. the late government woukhsclves ill a have had very large deﬁcits. As it< because no ‘was the net deficit for the threelhnt the St years 1924, i025 and 1926 was over nothing for ‘$50,000.00. ,

The speaker went on to answer V the question why the Stewart 80\'-;cr of the Bell ernment was defeated at thepolls behooves them

ho make such a sweep. nt as that place them. very unenviable position. m" m" 58y truthfully cwart Government dill

lwtini‘ cult of [loqgpp u )Olll.‘\‘lli'(l5. the d; - ..

"I"~‘Il°11—-.l‘0u are slllilllslllnlﬁgw gr.’ (‘filler you all renlenlbel" it! '11“, hcn. nrember frolrr the First Dlq

”/

It ill- to criticize anything

A FOUtth at Bridge He told the llollse ill the i‘ v ‘ l - OTEHUYII

in the last election. He thought iethat the Stewa t G > ACCIDENTS do hRPPQn. and all too law you was mainly because they had tie-resuming lmnrcrlved 1022151102‘ ghoul mp ponmuo" m“ “mm” "E ceived the electorate. One decep- maintenance; ‘ "MIC wmk‘ I010"! the brldggg l“

find you lack a fourth player.

Be on your uard. Decide to scrv

Pal:.Dr)'—t at gay l

tion they had practiced. he stated. was to tell the people that the late, maintenance w Bell Government had made up its ment, and on

c Evanylin:

refreshment that's ready as me He" Gm’

9711- Govcrnme ything is better than w; '

rs tho ﬂay after the election! u

in the pop ofawil ng cork. surpluses by depleting the sinklnaﬂlethlns. The Pre l ll - With Evan clinc as your standby You funds-that they had virtually stol- 1 can follow the trgllclr Qlmslfli‘ 15-05 3:23? Why. they didn't even m“, ﬁll in as a fgurth yourself, slipping out e" ‘he m°ney "° make I‘ Sh“ of marks‘ “m” S°m° "math" uponlh n road“ '""&“h"" They left their when dummy to fetch in eve thin surpluses. Later on. however. when the administration of the Prlblidllrmilnr contra’ “d "Mr ‘m’ "m w - k h, . k '7 8 people became acquainted with the Works Department under the lot n “d mum“ "KM then- qulc er t an qulc . And you score a true stale of affairs they saw that Mr Crosby and their attention C m“ “T00R11 everything “l; “h, grand slam when your guests regal: they had been fooled. the roads. He pleaded with Mt-O My Mm mend ‘m’ Mhhm’ l" M’; their thirst with He went on to defend, in detail, Crosby time and again he salq l~ riculturc remembers lt very ‘my ' the record of the Bell Governmentndo something for the ‘fflfllnl n ' to Mm, m“ schwmmy” m“ 5'45"" as regards taxation and other mat- cf the roads. I think the 1:. “mij-"hlrped! Now they come back and w“ Wm remember his wordy the emierisay the Stewart Govemmcnt never He claimed that the receipts of Spoken on different occasio y vlvereldid anything for mad Impmvmﬁlli the Stewart Government were $ll8,- _ln this House. The 88d his?’ lots The worst of it. was they dmppgﬂ m‘;

000.00 greater than those of the Bell § was that he coul

Government-that such were collec- lby d not s“ Mr‘ 0"“

“El six or seven weeks. I

1M . r l‘, t ted from t e pockets of the eo le. member a HQN- MR. McINTYRE: G . lCllQ x- LII, Md we M t surplus o! “£00300 icmmy besltcreclloélrllalgénzlxrjltle offif the Stewart Governmenltxm?" for our fclime while they had a de- Ister of Public Works heme “m? d°n° m’ "me "hm"

l l ﬂelt 0f 880000.00 The people rem- never made a sin le u" he" DR- M" : You wonder? . 12I .ember this. _ ;tempt at road nnﬁténiiltlm’ M” goN- MR. h! : You. _______;.__§____;___ , He" ls the gunmen‘ or km hon I ft. MciIlILLAN: You may keep

Continued on Page 7- lPremlerln the Budget Debotcayeal; . gnaw“ org; Tva ‘ ﬁ

Ihon. Minister went to some lellgtll lowed “l” “IIIIITWC ‘Vim 1180-" Tlmt i

work and still hung on w pow". for»