11 i- il
I
’¢. 1.
`f
." (___:
.,v.... a. _I _.-5
3
t
._ '
i - 1
“mi
‘it
~ |
H*
t
».
,It
»
g-l ta
t t
l
-
t i
if t .
__ t i~"1
-.
THE CHARLOTTETOWN GUARDIAN
_ APRIL 9, 1927
~iiAGEFoUit __ . _ _-_ _ -' - I ` ' 1 ” 1*
L
. .o lnnceti rcllow just out ot eel- _ rt nt. ' ’ ' lnoe,aud -we have
° ° h B et ~- -Y .t1.‘:."‘.:...‘.2°:.:..r1..l:::."‘r::;.2°:.‘:... -.
Brilhant peec 011 ll ~ "-:. °":.::..‘:‘"'::: l..1:;.::‘;;::: .......
' long enouq \° 9°
.\‘
Now we will take the report oflfphey have been growing these al- _ /_,__ _...N , » f ;__
t» . _ _._ / _-_ .
0 » is-:ati :ntnn mvi 1 ‘ '
_ - .w rid W . (Applause). to hav” 111° 1'9" ' ‘Wh th Bell Government _ _ - .
By Drl WO JO ° Ir ‘are entitled to full credit for \\1111__'i. en B went astray
» v
(00n4»lnut~d llrfiii D139 3) t__`_h_____ _“___ most benendal to mis!
~ -' - tl which thc Leader oft
In regard to the Department ot Pr1\111L€- 1111 _ d
: h 0 sition and I are agree
3?ll:\ug|r‘et;l1le:hl;1lli nb: ?:§t1’tl‘ltI:llil)>l;'.lipi>|i. r')l`pll)a|_ is'Women's Institutes. the people ot the Province that fot"l' tio _not think theire _i_S__1: ¢’11;13__;_f_1_l um balance of the year it was not :iss-octattoiin that s 0 8
_ Returned soldiers and Mr Salmderl_
. l
I
experimental fat-xn. \\'h:~‘ S11"“1f1` My hon. friend the leaderof the: this Prt..-iitce iuaiiztaiu an expert- Oppgsitioii never lost an oppo1"1ll~1 me-irtai latin witch ll1<=‘1'@ 15 3 D°`1nity when addressing this Housel
minion Experimental Stazlon rlshl tr a publ.lc meeting no eoudemlll out-:ide the clzy limits? Surely 1119 the conduct of the Stewart Govern- tlomiztiott Goterninent can <10 1118i ment towards the returned men oil
much tor the Provittce. _ this Province. He holds out those.
no very necessary tbutthei-c should W1>_1”1i 1`\11'_111°T1)"‘f"1"°°f dumb '_h§§§‘ ‘Bu that was not all. I 11115.;-xnuiples of terrirbe cruel!yWhl0l1'
. s utcs. ie) now llulll E1
.-::e:`ma?0;t ykgsehgyllt-uiothfagépiltll lllebltlgboiit t|ie_country; there have;
' ,' -0 ,mp oeen between fifty and sixty orgair;
words of the Léaggl. utinte l’\l'he~i ized since wc c-sine into l10W01'.°l1€' sznhgidmgelaygilslel-b01?0L;l-iculturt-, cause we appreciated their_ value,
a` man whom we believe 'wus a \'0l‘.\‘ 111111 ‘11‘1 “hm “e' "°“,§.1lI,_ whqs.?h:h:¥K1E‘ line Minister (applaust-i the Lontlt-.~ 1~1\¢1l111°1¥“ '1‘.‘fm', I, ,e ,eil .buff of the Opllositinn toitl it.-; ht- wat .iboiit_tli».-:xi _lb 1_'°__f‘_L:_ 1_5 Edu___u'_. only an oritanient, that lic was not iakc sul-it dtt-p i_n ci_t. _ I of any use at n11_ Apparciitly it tit.-ti, and they shun that lnteres? .tn er we had a.l\liiiister of Agrlctlltur-.» .\§1$1}111ll_r 111 _tl ’j‘1_-1_1 “_ __ l________ 9|- not- we could not hope to pit-a>'t~ lie iall_\ __\\ iilcli .lit ot so intit i __ the Leader of the Opposition: he 11'. 10 1111’ \‘11l1<11"~’11- 11011 1“1"'3' °“11_
would gay he was nu good anyway, to loul_: at tli_t.-ir rei_ior_t __lt_ see__tlic_ Bug we hear no complaints from <planti_itI itorl. they .irc _o ng .i ing the farmers and those interested in 11111! 11110- 11 “"’111‘1 111110 111° 191111 -1 1- \mp°"am:c (D this G°ve,.,,m¢n¢_ 1| .\t_ai.tllii€,_ f.itt__l_> li_.l_ _usd ,$30 000 was quite dmerem m me da)-S of \\omcil> _lnsti-.ities t_alsc_ , » the Bell Government, when llieru 111111 _$111-WU “_1 1_11_a1P“_“’f_ "1’e111T___‘;:f were intligiitition nic--tiiitts tIit-on-,~l;- tht- _-t-hools or tits _ t_ott_nte._ ____ out the country and not tt \vet-lt liavc _put ;:_oot_i t_c_ii_t_us .ll;1_:1_1;l__ :hz pusedibut, a~ d,cle.g::,l;i:i5-:mf_\§;1 ailllflutlgathey' have protest ng dgambl W I A ' put iii liartlwoo'.l flool':<Z the-.\` 11211? Please.) Those were days when tt _ __ _ __ _ ___________ was not difficult to stir up a rtpplc, 11111 ‘1f’“ 11 1-‘_11"11“" 1‘_'~`1_ "'_‘ "_p'_ __k_ as The Patriot says cannot be stir- H1 I11C1'~11`¢‘f~ 81111 111»1I1>- »1_11_l __ 1_9-1 red up n°w_ “Not a ripple of publp; anti other things necessaty tot tht interest” in the work of the Gov- -5_'~‘11U11_1”`-_1"11C‘5' 11_1f";’_‘11’11C_“__1"°_1111'3_" ernmum says the edimr of tha; itll worlt, and i_. is :\__l>_c.istiic o paper! R was' dinerent in mos, say somt-liitiig tn their tt>ninieiida_- days, (Laugmum tion. I lizxtl tht- privilege tt yt-ar
` 'leo ot'. ;ttltire~:sint.: their aiiiiuai cott-
Fairs and Exhibitions. '.‘t»ntioii in the place of the Preiiiiei'
_ _ who wn~s abnieiit oil llttsifiess coil-
The 1‘9‘“1e" of 111° U1'11f’S11"’1.'h"5 ncrteti with fur claims. :ind it was
5111911 113 11 111113 ‘1°5'~'1`11’11`”‘ "1 1110 ti ploztstirc to tell tlioso ladies per- Seed Fa11`5 111111 "’“"1 1" 1'” hpm. "1 fzotially how inurli tlie (iu\'é-riinicnt the agricultural hall in Sumn_\erstti~_-. M- mis. }.,_U‘.im.0 m,pl_(,(.imL.‘| ,hp where people 11-"-¢‘1'<1'*1“'11‘11 111 1111"' tn.:-.tl work they wort: doiutz. (Ap- dfedsf 11111 111 111"‘1*1’"'1"" 1" 1""k 111 plati.~'e.l It is soinetbiiig wliiclt I 1119 1111191951 5"°"1‘ 111111 5111115' 111111 lwliwt- any tiovcriimciil, Liberal l':1T1lia1;'_¢_ 1s1;@1é1éedT1_;;_:;"a_;‘_g‘€ or t‘oii>'ci'\‘ativt-, will help along. a ou o . - . of so much benefit to the poevlnce, Fawonwood Herd_ _ is that they were cut out by thc . Government. of which my hon- In tlcaliiiti wltll :t_i;rit'ttlltlrc titc frlend was a follower. l.\l111l11\1S"»1'Leatlcr ot' ine Opposition inciition- \\’hat was thc rt-asoii of flint? ll' ctl several other things. in ordter to those were of such ittcalt~uial>lt: Qulogize the late C0m11llSS1011€1' 01 benefit that we haw suvli culotlie-S Agriculture in :lic Bcll tiovernnlciit. concerning them nt-tv bl' the l.-_-ml-‘_\tr_ \\'. i\l. Lea. I believe that .\Ir. er of thc 0pD0S11lf\11» Wh?-1! 511 ¢1¢‘Lca was :sincere in what lic did; world actuated T-he Govcfrlfflctll I do not think wc ltttvc cvcr tried when they discontinued them. 1.\l'- to tit-tract troiii any t:i` his work. plauiie.l Ilut the Leaticr of thc Opptisitioll
There are other fztirs. liowt-\’t‘-'. comes back cvcry time to that I-`ttl-
whlch we bcllevc :irc of bein-ii’. ronwood lic-rd; that is tht- ct-nlre of We believe the School I-‘airs are 't'_tcri<~tilttirc in this Province so far good thins. and this Go\'eruni+-ui n.-.~ tit- is t~ottcerit»_-tl; the greatest has 0ll<lea\'Ul'0<l ill 01-'\=1`.\` 111111*-il»l1‘ at-iiitvtfiiieiit in agrit-itltttre was the Way t0 foster them uufl io iii\'r0=\r~'_imrotlttctioii of the llolstc-in cattle their usefulness. ` Ol' courtzc. wt- ut-t 11| 1.‘al¢¢|1\t-ood that were put there no benefit for that-that was ollf? by .\lr. Lea. llc al\vt-tys holds that of the things that the Iiell Govern- up as the great pattern of what meilt initiated, anti wc had only to should be tloiic. Now, .\lr. Speaker, follow suit. \Ve are prcparetl "iron probably know a little about credit the Bell (io\'ot‘nn|t-ni with that institution; I pr-rsonally know aiiylhliit; tlitfy :lid that was licnoli- soiitolltiittf about it, too; and I stty. cial, and to t`ollo\\' still it' we tiiiitlt pg 1 ltuvt; ttlwuyn said in tlvaiitll.: it is the l1F0per ibiiili to tio. 'witli this inzittvr, that when thc
We believe that our itlxltibitions 1,il,(~|~;1|g t-nntp into power tlp_~y
are very valuable. lttifat-t. we :ti-t- 1'. und it herd of ggotl ordinary gm. going to start another I-Ixiiibltiott tit- :ii lfztlt-ntlwtiod farm. The Load- in western .l’l'inc'¢' Vounty to st-i;\'c or of tho Oppositioii nays they we-i‘t:
the interests of those inlcrt-sled _ill sci-itll t-mile. I tlo not know what agriculture iii that part of 1 ffhc nit,-att.; by thc _wortl ‘st-rub." I 18181111- 1196311110 1-1101’ arc iiilllll' ltiiiea know that they '.vcrc- very satisfact- from a centre where Exliibitioiix ory trqltle, that tlicy \\'crc serving
have bgen héid 2revi_;liisl_\‘.h D0 F01; the purposes of tl_ie institution very remern er. . r. t D68 61'. l e Stull( well. They. in tieir wisdom, saw the Leader of the Opposition has Ft; to get clear of that herd and put illkell time llrlll 358111 011 Exhllil- iii ct lilnit class herd of Holntcliis. tions, that Exhibitions were no -.vhit-lt lic says have been uf vast good, that he hadn't any faith in ht-nt-lit to the institution and to our them? pr,-opic generally. I claim tliatthcy
Mr. SAUNDERS: I ditln't sity were ot' no more bent-lit there than
81134111115 Of 1110 klllll- l -"H111 111610 the liortl tlizit they rcplncetl._ The were other things that wr.-rc better. milk of the other hcrtl was per-
H0ll. DY. -\l01\llLLA~\'1 H0 SU-Y11 https just as ricli in butter ful, just
he said nothing of the kind. Very as ,zooti for the purposes of the in- well: Ishall hnve to lzet the Bible stittition, as the Holstein cattle
again. {_._\it;:r _looking ilii_0_i_lt:i_i D311- that are thcro now. Tho only thiin.: ers on t-i tes _ catiiio n iv at in they not a grantor iiicreasc ln I am lookin: for here: it io 11 "ci'~ milk; they got more Ilolrtleln milk, tain issue ol' The l’uti'lt»l. lbul they divi not gt-l. mlik of nli_\'1
Mr. SAUNDERS: You said lbcltcr uttulily. l do not nay lhlsl
Blllil l-llelt' wer" 11° Hood. I said I nu my own ttuiitorily. I liavc bcrc| didn't 811)' thai. the opinion ot the Superiiitcudciit
H011- DF- l\lCMlLL/1-\'I l l>0.’='_ol' Faltzonwood, from tlic allnuaire-l
your pardon. tporv of tiizit imilitulion fo rtho your]
Mr. S/tl`Ni)EllS: Yotir .-'laltv lift!-1:* 1
ment. was that I said lin.-_v were noj »'Th¢ objem in s_¢¢u|~i|1g tml good. I didnt say anytiilill; 1»ltllL‘_ farm, when the Agricultural De- kind. I said th'-rr were other; partment were about to dispose ‘things that were better; that was uf it, sum.; yur; ago, Wagga pro. 111)' 513191116111. l vide healtlrful occupation for male
lion. Dr. I\lc_\lll,I.i\N: I :iiitlook», pa¢i¢ms_ to assist wwa,-d exhab.
l\1I§__fli'S'1_`xliH\l_’;1_l1_l_0`1- Y __ l itating them. and at the same
. r. '.' I .`: ou wi get time help to kee down the ex-
Wl\°1'.¢ l Said that l had very llillf-1 pense of the Hoszital. The idea1 faith in them. but I didn't say lllcy. seems to prevail that it is still a WGN 11° 9004- ll-H\ll.'llU.’1'.) 1 government experimental sta-
I-Ion. Dr. .\lc.\III.I..\N: I will find! gtg", and sink farm, lg is well
that reference later; we will leave- to bg up.g°.d;¢¢ ln gm- meghgds,
li Bi 11181. 1-‘\pplausc.| | and breed good stock, but there' _ Tribute to Women's Institutes. t In a tendency to saddle on the_
I Want to_comc for a few mom-_ Hospital and its under-paid staff.
ents to one group of associations work of that naw,-C, with this ** idea continuing to influence its
operations there Is less regard. for l-tospital‘ economy although
_ probably beneficial to the Pro-
_ vince at large."
\! _ llc does not say that it is cf
Q J -such paratiloiint importance so far \_\_"-*qt
,nn Falconwood is concerned. Andi
1
. vii. . -lf
l' P _ I '1 1
.\
I, f
. . A,
ithat ls exactly the stand which I take. You know that years ako tliorc was a stock farm out there. and that ti disease which fortunate- ly wc cuii iiow l-lay is eradicated from our cultIe-t-iiberctilosio-be- tzamo raiiiplliit to such an cntont that on two occasion-.i they had to he slaughtered. The buildings there were unfit for cattle until they were removed -to their pres- ent potvltion and renovated, tuml- gated and put in santiary condition. ln replacing the herd with high class I-Iolstelns the Bell Govern- ment simply added to the expense of the upkeep or the farm. -because a pure tbred cow is like a machine, it you wan-L to get good results you must put in more feed. If you take the report of Falconwood you
meal and oil cake $6-I3. In 1924,
oil cake and meal, $2,666. That Io
n herd
required about 82.000 more to keep
orally in bu;.__1 -mid It is the of the
will notice that year after year the e expense has gone'up. For instance ‘I1 in ‘N18 there was paid for bran, t
there was paid for the same bran. 0
worse than that whtn the Liberals have been perpetrated on innocent* came in. accorditlg to the 1-19111191 otiiclals by this Government. Hej of the Opposition. .\ly ll011- 5Tl@11<1 never forgets it. He has got one. sa-,-S that when Hou. .\Ir. .Lea -:ook case in particular which is his peti charge he was able to increase tbe=and which be cries over everyi root lJ1’0‘111<‘11011 1111 10 111-0011 1111511' time; and he says that when hc_ els, Now that iiilg11‘~ be an "gm trcts into power every position ln_ to tell some people but I belive" inc Province is going lo 'be fllled_ to have here the repel". 01 F81'-‘°11‘ by returned mea,-certainly every woctl llospitnl tor 1917. and at that ponitim in this House ut least. time tiicre \\'a~' a man by the name But, Mr. Speaker, you remember. of W. J. .\lt=.\lilltin nctillg sup01‘111' that when they were in power the zelitlt-nt. I find ou page 13 111111 positions in this House were not ;ht-ro was t;,lt»0 bushels of roots. filled by returned men, and that 3.300 buslit-ls of potatoes, and 2'J_‘wh¢n motions were made to ap- tons of lm-._-it feed. <‘i'0lll>€\_l 1111110 point returned men to those poll- \-wp 1911 In 1918 there was 7,000 tions. right in thi; House, the bits-lit-is ot roots. 3.600 bushels 01 leader of the Opposition was one rotator.-_ .l;.tl 39 .ass of green lv_¢<1- of the men who voted those mo- So they increased root production non, d°wn_ | w°m1¢|- ¢°_ ‘whgt at Falconwood from 10.030 11“51‘°15 lengths of hypocrisy a public man in 1917 and about ‘$000 bushels can 9° in safety? (Laudapplaule). in 1918 to 10,00.) in 1944-W°'1¢l°1”' Probably a leader cf a p' rty has ful! more leeway in that respict thalll
Dalfy 111111-‘$11! anyone else! He says we disniistr
_ etl rettirnetl men from some posi-
l.et_ as go a liztle further on ilu! tions. Certainly we did. And we
quo-tion uf llgflclllillrc. My 11011- will do it again, ii’ necessary. We n-lend had n great deal to Sal' have always said that that was omit: butter and cheese pl'0d11<-’° our policy. It the leader of the tion and the mistake that -11111 Opposition wants to go into ape Goverllincnt made lil closing 1111 cial cases. the information is quite the 'l`cchnioalScliooi and that won- 1-ea._1y_ 1-1;; will find ou; why 3 derful dairy plant there. .»\i1d lic gg,,¢|,.mauy of [hose rem;-ned men says the Dairy Supel‘iiiteuden‘. .\Ii'. were dismissed, if be wants to but .l. _-\. ..\iuD.mald whom we 1101-1' he says we did not -fill their have, knows very littlc about but- places with other return- l~2l‘l lit* is It ciiccsc-‘tinker tl" cd incll. There have been one 01' right. but hc knows' little abou; bill- two rxceptitns wlic-re a returned for This man was clllployed 11! man was dismissed and someone the Dominion Dopnrtinent of .»\t.<i‘i~‘ t-lsc not thc place, but the riile hits t-ulture for twel"lt'_»' _\'ear=, :intl titii‘-- been otlierivisc. ing that liiiic I silpposc lic \va.<til>le -1 l111nk_ _\1|-_ Speaker 1 have just to acquire quite tt kitotvlcdilc tiotlas liiucii coiisltleratioii for returned only ol’ cllcesc but oi butter. llc i:ic‘l ti# 'the lvatlur of the Opposi- catnt- ltcrc from Moiitrcaii \\‘iici'L’ titzn. I certainly lltive c\'cry‘syni- he was tile Official grader ot' dairy paliiy for tiiclii. ` Pcrsoiially, I products. ot' which butter in one. -know just how iuiicli this war cos' and i'_ is a strange thing that dill". tho country. I had two brothers ing the years that he luis been vrlioin I have not any longer on ac- herc. in which hc as been demon- count cf the war. Tltnt is the kiiitl stratlng and trarellintz arounil of t-xaiuple that ln~i;igs it hoiiic to from tactory to factory tillil gi\’lllE’ont‘ llcisonally. ilu( if thc Ieatlur iir~'t-littlitl inforiliatloii oil iilt: $1101. ol' tlir- Opposition waiits to bc lair. that the quality of our butter haS in discussing this ttucslioii, lit- gone up until last year it was first. wottld .say ii.>\v, ‘Tito Stewart Gov- and the quality cf our cheese has ernniciit in entitled to some credit 90I1e up until last year It was sec- lbecause the most important ap- ond in the whole Dominion of Carl--pointnient that they had in their ada. (Applause). I: sc-eins sirailgc glfr. was given to a rettiriicd mnn, that tlic effect of those coui'Sc5._tIte position of .Lssistulit Proviii-; given in the Technical School dur- cial 'l`reasttrer." Ile iiiiglit go a Ili-I ing the time ol' the Bell Govern- tle further and say. ‘This young,! liient was never realized .until Mr. inexperienced lawyer, the Minis. t\loDonaId becainc dairy stillerln- ter of Public Works, is another rc- lendellt under this Government! 'turned mall; tho' (invornmcnt int
.\Iy hon. friend spoke about Cul-'tliititictl to <-retlil. for filiiiu: this-tl
ttirc cans. 'l`iiat int-tlitztl wats; used ltiiportalit position willi a rcturiitftl very little in this Province until .'iia,:i_" Those arotlic tivo most iir- abottt two years ago. when .it was -portant positions which the (lov-E iiiirotlttcetl in Kcnsingtoii tiic ccii- erniiielit halve had to deal with dur-1 tijt- of tho t-lifeesu lactorivs, anti it ing the time that we have bot-ti itil
has liter.-ii distrlbiitt-tl from thai t‘cll- power, and we filled them both( ire c-vor since. with returned men. (Applause).
‘in rt-gartl to that \voi|dcrl`iil tiairy _
plant at tho ’I`ot-linical Scliuol that What about the Senatorship? , iny hon, fricntl refer; to so :rt-~ _ _ _ _ qiiently, I wonder does he know B111 1'9" C311 take 1he_1l`°1d§;L§l that -about the only vat of milk 1129 1°“d°1` °‘ 1he_ 01)1’(;”_1mn lfuwt that was destroyed in this Prov- d-301311111 'hem D1 “ear ;1mC;1€ re,_` ince was destroyed there? Docs he 111911 l1°1`_C_9111_ 111111 ymf I If (1) _‘__ know that the Govcrilinciit of the ll'112f11‘11_S11l~119°“11SL e 13° ea . tint nod to nay o mit or $91.00 mr '“'1111 1108111011-‘1» 111111 1’“1’°"“”‘ 1’°`l
' . _ ` sltloiis without ti thought to :he-
tlie iuiik that was destloyed by 1 this iaiiioits oxperiiiiental plimi? 1'€1“me‘1 5°1d1erS‘ when ‘hge “ggi lie ought to acquaint hiiiisclf with 3 "“°“"°Y 1" 111° Sena” °f 5"” 11':
_ ._ ' . and he and the Hon. Mr. Slnclalrt
the facl.~. before ho 'begins to make , . _ ~ _ _ _ _ _~ - , .- had the appointment in their own| .sutli sweeping,deiitiiiciations vvnen , tht- restilzs arc tip to the very acmel 1131111" ‘"1‘Y dm '1°t 111” "°°°"": of perfection, He is like Rip Van` m°",f1 a "°wr"°d man °f that p2°|'_ Winkle,-he wants to get back to f1°"' .1App1a“°°) was there "° a' N d f th B H Gb n gl returned man ln Prince County 1° ays ° e e V" me" iwho was fit to be elevated to the when everything that was doll¢1
t Senate. lf he wanted to show how
was perfect. it does not matter_ h __ M __ et med mm whether results have improved or "°'"°1‘ ° 1 °"'9 " r U b H" t whether conditions have become my h°"`.'r|e"d had °n-°. 1' an better; it cannot/be right because °Pl’°"1_“"'1y th"°’_'1"a°t'°a"y he tha Be" Government was doing had fifty per_ cent of that Senate
. - - his own hands. But
something different. I might refer apf°1""11°"t "1 __ _ _ _ h 1 ltltii to llaziliiton fttctury, wiilcli "°' I1, “"5 n1‘1.'°`1"m‘d men L enl
_ , who were considered. The-rc WHS,
tlticc _\cars ago had practically 100 . _ in __ I. _(__ ____ per cent ‘.'lltl grade. For the past some mu? qua] '“‘i_mn` L ur two years they have had 57 pe, ed men d.d not haw the proper
_ _ . - , he
cent No_ 1_ wth the same man In t_|ua_lifit.ation_ tor ti poixi_tion__lii_t_ charge, the same equipment. andIbe“"1e_°f _[““.“"‘1"' “°_1f‘.“"" H1; me “mc shippe_,s_ tho Leatlci ol thc _ppo.~itton;
This course at tht: Tcciiiilcai w°"1d 5°°"" app°'"t §°m"°"°
S. .. _ _ . . else. And come down to this House
Lltool ua- a slior. course, anti l b » th C _ b _,_ nl _h _.C-new and tell us 'what he would do
3" "m, ,M 111,." U 3 1 1 Mb Ifor returned men. Why doesn't makers .irc gct.tng just as good
ittstructloii as they ever got in tho 1"’ 1°" what 11° dw d° when 11° had days of tho Ilell Govettlinieut. nntl.1h° °1°1’°"'""1ty' °".d wh.” ° ___ ___ ___ _ twguld do again. Heels talkin for
is S proven by the better re~_ 9
suits they are gc_tilig today. Tw'0_;°111|:::;°)°"°°¢’ 'hav' am (L°"d
years ago buyeh were very shyl Pgou' I am going to tical with the (t)(Ed;l;,1.d_?_:,1 maizjdepartnient that has a rcttirned brougltt tip to the very iicigill. of man urns head’ R ma" whom we perfection it is not all done l>y1“r° proud °1‘h Hui is a g°°d lawyer' _ ,' ' , , ‘and ti good 2 us css man. We are t§_t;c_lt.liit§ l1_0“_ 1° "1;*_11_°_ buiuer elfldrsuro his record will cvniiimrc at 31m1;;'| l§¢'l10‘¢,u|ncy0|fle("(¢;¥y lI|l,ea|,1;:;unY time with the record of their est troubles iii connection witl\lC°m"‘1Ss1°’"" °1 Pubnc wmks' .| _ , _ and we will not ask “that the man- c iecsc uns the question oi inonld._"° M charity be thmwn over Mm ,, the spore formation where labor '
it was not sold and marketed nt.’claim made by the leader of the the right limo. 'rhu it some oi opposition. uint the Bon novem- tlte work that Mr. McDonald hasf ment built over 500 miles ot lm- donc in the past two years-thelproved road-ways. I am, quoting man who does not know very much that atonement and' I will ask the
I do not wish to cast any re- flection on the present Oom- xulssioner of Public Works. but I will say as a. result of the work oi' hfls predecessor his took will not be arduous as the Liberals laltl a good ioundation, l tl we
of be;ttlful
r, A l
Government had at the] the Dominion Publlcl have new!"
rem N80- They will 'Mr. aid
new :But
NIMH'
. -_ _ mer t, you know, Mr. Speaker. I' - 2 nk that is the stale
atory work was liectled. One of.°'t11°"1 1A1'p1°u"') will tell tltc Gentleman an incident; 111531 11° made 111 l-11114 'HUUSG yes-1 thc greatest troubles In deallnip _M,._ Slunden °°,,.ected_ that happened on the Western Ry. I wonder would lic make` with cheese was that it was ltopt__ ~ tRoad. I am not going to speak “1 5111101110111 888111? Would hc 100 10115 111 1110 01111111; 100111, limi ` I want to rcfcr specifically to n about tliroken car-springs -'iic"1111`“ 199931- l-'110 Silllome t.
- . . . - -liLA'N: What has
about butter!-until our butterlhon. gentleman to correct mo it I HON. Dr. .-MfONI~IUI.u1.'N: lt han--’D°1`1119Y 3114180 Bot to do -with it? and cheese how stand ar the tonnm wmns. -ls that the statement potted up in .Prince county. it SAUlNtDlERs: tl doin. know of the Canadian market. one ln. he made? _ was necessary to convey a patient W 91' 111! DI1'11l0¥ BrId8e; ltls urn plow. and the other in seo-I om. nnuxmdrost oo attend with from beyond Atherton to the 1"‘°2l°°¢ N0- 09- I tc-nd. These are some of the ways; your speech. :Prince County hospital where 119011- Dr- WUMUJAN: You wot-ei ln whch Agriculture ls served ln_ HON. MR. : I have these doctors charged such enor- M1111* *1’°111 Dl1`111°?'Bl‘ld89. Youl this _Province In the days of thethls words -here: 'What have the mous :bills for two operations, ac- 55111 111919 WU 1101 I ¢1'¢0!ot pile Stmgrt Government. (AppIau|e)."Llberal Government; 110 ahdwy Ac. cot-ding to' my hon. friend. This 111 171111110? 3114139 01' within 11 l
o m e
me touch .briefly upon anoth lcording to the Conservatives' own patient was being brought down ln °1 11- 1 811llD°le he thought my hon, Pl’0VCd S3f¢ by
er department or the Govei-nment.| figures 585 miles ot improved a Ford car, suffering from a very 1f1‘l¢11d iMr. Mdlutt had taken them
--that ol' Public Works. I d n tl d , . . _ »
D6
0 o roa s and over 500 concrete cul serious trouble, tt condtlon ol stron "9 111°" 11° 11111111 I Dltllouae or _
impose I should go into this de-_ vents and bnidsee that will lest kuleted hernia They were com W11‘°1`-11111K ('l4\1‘lht8r) I wonder- - (mms Headmhe` Ncurltis artment at all, only for the fact, lor ages and are worth over a mil 1115 alone quite fast because speed ‘1°°‘- 111° 1°“1°1‘ Of ll
bat we have such a “yoirng inex-5 lion dollars," And 5 llttlg further was a consideration. They
rienced man" at the head! Ao-__ on he says: -to nhis part of the road which
ordiug to the Leader of the Oppo- "
eltlon he should not be .ln that po-
tho difference: the Holetel Bltiou at all. That ls no place tor
is lawyer. We should have a mllier,_
up. The change ho.; prdbably been probably, as the Bell Government; mod so for as .tho pmvlnces had! We might have a Doclo s
leader of the Opposition has crlbed and they went into a fI‘liey were Boing hit said. and the
stretcher
struck the roof ol
better! The lump
h accomplished ull '-0 111° e_“ - l - ` flfeiszz: not tt there is “"1 1’°"’°“~ -My non. friend says we f°111“'°‘1 `/ . ` ln the Province .wlw ‘*'°“:1a_; 'fl the very name policy of the 130111. _ - ' /
that me Bell Gonerninent ~ _ _ _ e
Government A11 H511" 101- 11| 1311 _ , .
ti.led to anything 011 11111 1’1”;‘;2';i. iz nl. that. We followed 1111111' I1011' ' 1 ' ' road improvement in the your __~ cy and during the years that suc~ 0 1
l - uid like to see him. A1 1 fi ded-w bulls roads just as ¢00d~ _ ; -' 1 enlluln the year 1911'-1» 11“’1',1"‘d' 3°: ggetitelrs fvlth one great dlfterenoe~-- ‘ _ __ , f - __ 1 coming to the Pnimo works re that they eo" ivlt lbw* 11111' "~ - K/ ‘ '
P01'-;:A __e______ ___ _he work done ;nt£i;°°We _\_lvt;r:fabIe___ln 134 to 6:1 . _ , Q)./._.` _§ - '.34 Q
‘sa ‘ 1 vim ron wo _m°l'_ t \ . " - - ou 1118-r°°¢15_ ‘1“"1“g ‘he p:€f‘ithan'th¢y ever did, at an one
three years in connection ll I n f ooo | th n
|n_ _ ..._ __
_ ' .~eern|| oo 0 $5 N* 5 " Q 1 rite canada nsgnwavs M1- “‘°_‘,§i mln. tAnn1w»e.l'wo always wok- . ~ ’ 111311 500 wwde” bridge? abvlt.-h'e ground that their road work . ~ Q- ,_. ' _
culverts have been replaced lfwas costing leo much, thi!! 1-1101 structures of-vpgafletaidoitxd Kreatsr part ot the ell-l1e111111“1`“£ and \lPW=N'l‘ ° 1" oln into the pockets of the mv* 111111011111* '°‘“1’ 0' '1‘°lZ?:trioto§n and that ne engineer- Provlnce _thouopghlg ___<1{_“1"_‘;_‘;' tug work was too expensive: 81111. ‘t‘11‘11d@<1 “"1 51"' “"9 ' .w have proved it. That is the- llesf 11133911111 1"°a"y. ;‘a1'1a"al;l§f- llriat difference between our pollcyi i11‘0¢1111'1113 3 road w"_ B sn. ‘as carried out and the policy oft 0111>' 1111111100 admirably the -Bell Government. l automobile and ligllthtra c_ “___ But wha imuated this _p0Hcy7_ me greater pan of I 0 seaw '_ i It was not the Bell Governmatil
_ - _ it was Premier Anenault. p-_ 1"b°'a1 Rnd P°|'°y _plauee). And If the* Bell Govern-1
Now M S ke d n,t °u_ment had stuck to the policy h¢»
1 1 1°" "' ° 1' tllutetnleoeomr ld have* .
think mat any reasonable man lf' lr '_: ‘ y 11.11°" be;
_ een ar better off. \\e have
public life, if he wanted _to state, _ ____ th _ on morei ____ _ _ _ _ _ _ 111° '“""b°" °f "mes °f 'mpr°ved1Ell>l;el§'.' liwaovhlaveapaltl) atgiitlcn to 1 Y'
hi hways that the Bell Govern-
| - , -.‘ . v_~_.:'.<- - '°
9 _ “ned go _:mm font the swamps and low lying places, REVELATION awaits you |n__ _ int r1Cl¢_|-ll
men Wes ¢" _ _ K," -the __e_. to drainage, and so forth. That ls_ A h New and pina. p¢m¢i3¢ Sqmfrevelluon of ' :°°:1d__;“1t‘_:e°=,mCm¢i:| 'e¥g|ne°__'__the reason that though our roads 1 e -' -
_ _ lmgg of power, of that
it 1 , .tt i ti :_ in omfon of smoot ._ _ .
out of the .Public works Depart-I 0‘;1;;sf3z; §2`:_n0_e“u?1';,§:a;)d me. ;,ou MJ". dl-ea,-Md attainable in _any car of oompar. _ Ttsplgtlhihsilg fllaeys y;};l11 'But we have 11°1 ‘"°1’1’°‘1 at 11131' able price. And the reason is evident. In the New
".1110
1’ All that the non Government and Finer pcmiacsix (;¢,,¢,¢|Mo¢or, turned theirvast
I l b ‘_ Th .’
_he __0u___v they pursued was tol'l`hat was ther soc o ject e\ f _ md
. ' eat advantages o purchasing
came 'o those wooden bridges they Th ‘» grounds their gl' _
lse-just to build good roads.
tl nt go ~ii without repair until-e ' _
le L _ _ S 1. bcfnrc been available at anywhere near so low 3 pfloe.
is :hc reason thc question has been. d , ` ' ‘ ` ‘ ' `
that thc-re is work done on somef Mr DE5"'l'S: we did it wo' exquisite design and coloring, of the latest l>0dy_StY1¢9r '
_ _ anan'ow’s flight qutclcas a Hash torespo
many wooden bridges that lhou|d| xr' SAUADERS' F"'o._t0 1°", fm-mnnceas ’ _ _ attended to and had tc.be.replaced~ °" made a'°1"°'°- °°11'a"y “tempt six p€rf01111@111C0 1° 111'! W1'11¢51 ¢`11'¢1° °f ¢31"1’“Y"“
ftfarmer thuylng one of those hi h- '
tion in whit-lt :he BellGovei'nn1entfp cw “"1" and 1°°v'"9 't °m
. . , - CHARLOTTETOWN‘
work dotio. You have only to tn'kc the" policy' EWU 11"' lender U1 `
- _ _ . .. , . . . _: ` ` C.-
.1‘)U,fk` De1M\lL`m51m’ A1' hi S"1dhbe'aiid ho said that time poanll
_ . .
.1 _ _ _ _ _ _ DEALERS FOR PRINCE EDW .
Demon which we _“USL not loswgomethlng foi ro.td_n_ialnte-iiante. ARD ISLAND
__i__l _ _ - __ _ . ., _ nt that lie could nc-iei get hlin to
_I-_>2; I . ' ll complet- _ .
all ____“_:'__‘1_1;_';f___;:_a;“_?_1;11_0__e years- thought of “as to build the roads. reS°urces_ theh._ sw,-¢sd_;f dshu’ she
. .- _ .pinned their faith to that; they facilities of their mat ess a ra proving
lmliu tltett-ro-ad\v2>'-*111‘1 “he” meyi nailed “Good Roads" to th mast. v k f .. f .
_ ` _ at was their goal. and nothing ct' all to the tas o pr0Vl€l111gl\YP¢° 11191' did not replace them. tlieY letl P::i1_u i<;;_cY__nde__ aumn_0bH__ such 8 had nw”
= Mr_I]ENN‘llS: \‘\'e done It too. q ty’ `
some ol’ tlicin fell to pieces. 'I`hut_ _Hou Dr WO,`m__LA\, Be _“__ f
_ _ I _ - I ceful lin o \
asked in this House: Vlfliy is tt: gn' ' . » The result is a car of long, ow, gri Gs
of tho;o earlier projects? That ls; bu§]{f);`1h'e}?1r`a§\l:1Cf\,;:l;I1;;}\,‘ 15505' WH of the utmost completeness-.-a car as smooth ui per `
the reason, that a good' _ _ . _ _ ~ ' _
A - damrthatbrinsquallif'
have been replaced were left un-, ON Dr’ M0M1m‘A“\" Th” "ev 1° Y°“' demands an g
b Us .to maintain them after they were _ _ h . ..
1/,Th__' Edi_m_ 0|. um Pamm also lbullt. it was something like a Sec the car--mvestlgatct c prices.
in sumthing up the splendid ccndl _ rl _ _ 9
left this Proviilce, says that there|L" ggsdyzid °"t1';_g_11 3_1: A. & C0.
was 580 miles of improved road-- 9` -
/
:lit.\~i't~port ti' their own Publicl§;°d3l1)ZZ2;n;';;___gQT o1f°H":._‘_1_1_"1t Nm' '
‘ " ' 1° gm' 0 mn or ol er'1again -lie tirged on ‘he Coin- I SUMMERSIDE 1
wise oft at statement. _ _ . ` _
There is somemm, in mis c0n_imissioner ot' Puhllt \\ork<~ to do
;;,`f.,‘,c 3.lé;u2$`.ori'§0I.£Ldt gikggtio it. ,Thcsc ure hié \voi‘tl.<:"0ne _.fc . 1 1. “Qs _he Storm in _N131 _by “,mch_fat.|lt of the Bell Government was ' M _ I 3;; _§*;;1_;_G3”f_§_;'g§§_§,,§a-dgg;_;';;,°IL"...'§?.‘i.ii1 $2.52.' ."`1'It`°.'I.."i.'it‘°.°. fl - ____ S ____ S
1 ._ . _ ' _ _ ._. '_t_~- 43, _ I ¢ , __
The second was the storm in iheftu;|“;|c°m_Tg';;°";r__f;°f§y “me C1115: C_)` 1,1511 -,.31-L_. T ,
.fall which destroyed so many cfj; _n'v1;___:'b_a wasnthat shg' h_i";'s;` "Qi
our britlgcc along with the t'oads.'many af "Jae impraved roads to L 111- ________n__;'i.-¢~_
11 "10 1011101' <11 111° ~01’1'°S111°” - - ' onucr 0'-‘C.1:`~';':~.~.t:.:;:;UitsC:=c.~.v:.\D.\ -L: .. ~
wants to know why wc had to d° 1:” had ';_f’ttt'm° 111°°"Bs'd_` PR A H `
spt-iid more inaiicy iii the Public er 1° ° ers' a e" °" 11° °1 . - -
. . ~ . Government was inauqurating a po- . . V 'ft `"
Works tlepatttiten. that yc.tr, sure- lp 1)- tl llrtdgc got to do with , ll' his memory will carry hint back L13; °1;h'"°_1_"'¢°11i11¢°» buf Ullfvlfurl- i'_'.,`1 ‘H1 oy °`***‘**'°***‘*°'°****°‘*°°°°
to that tm-.tt .stoop tn ulnctt nearly Y ° '"‘° ""1 "°' °°"‘°' - .\tt- s.it':\"r>uRs: 1 snul in that
cvcry one ot' tlic large bridges of‘ (Lsauwlner and applause). brojrut Ile ti iiiatl now and any `
0.0¢-eo-oo-to-+0-0-s
.- '- n` .'
“.m.k had to be do H :f ll nlfbeader of the Opposition admits H05” 11)" WCMILLAN T e
_ _ _ . . .
.me Province 5“f_.emd and Hmm- - 0 tint was their policyo; r_o.itl ____ _ _ _CL , “.h.i(.h an cnormons amount of nialiitenance, ...N0'l`Hl\t. I`lic» 1” "1 L01" , - AND
110 121 8 8 1. _ _ _ . _ statement made by my hon. friend Gunn fitted by lolentlflo 1
1-1111 V681” 1'0ll0Wl118. And l-11811 Mr-I 1ta1i1ln1'nSe2';,$h;°lhefy §_f__}€;ad:;1 “Wh was that there was not a oreoeoted mgumqg,
lSpeaker. if he would look over the fg' th tl Y ° “_ W nite in Da,.,,|ey "tune 0,- w|¢|,|n I:
bridge picture of the Province, he 1" "°'" . ° ""° “"° "11°"1l’°°1 1° mi -
would my to himself -it " had not °'° ="¥¢”1“9 1118 SUS 11°* 111111 W0 1° °1 't' 1 E' W'
-1 . ~ ' :Tit --1,
been for those steel brldgcs that“11f1 1101 11° anything either; that \'o“l10 Edit lI`3rl:d ]el'Oj(eill‘ - AND
, . _ . . ‘ `g 3 Y g - ‘I
were bum by me _Matheson Govyour policy was all a -failure, that c__eaS0_l mu h,_e____
ernment we would have been il1`“'e are 11051601111-g the good roads ]{()_\'_ Dt-.g .\I.Q.\llLL_-\.\’: In the- J' S’ an aw-ful way, because those steel_Wh1Ch111eY 1111111 ‘md “`h1°1‘ 1111111011' Public W-crks Report of 1923. l- R°Ill¢0I‘¢\‘l °Pf°”1°11'|’”'
structures which were build so eg 1111111 “Kej That is 1' °“r1°1’5 find this statenieui:-“ln 1915 the- 142 Rlehmond 81130*
strongly and firmly \\'¢1`0 1110 01115' D mm 1° “be 1" °°”“e°11°“ with bridge at this piece had been dos-1 ones that wltlistootl the storm." '°“‘1“~""1‘“1 11181' 1"‘1”°"°‘1 111111 troyed by n storm almost equal ln- °**°+°****“ . lAhd he would suv to himself: “11 “§°' He may 11"” bee" 11‘1“1‘1“1‘ violence to that of lm year. ln. . `*'°°"”"""' was a prelil' -good policy that Fred; some “E 111°” brand" "1 hom" rebuilding it the arch was extend-1 J-ION Dr. l\il”(}MllthbA‘1\': But ml' mier Mathiescli introduced after 'trew 3161" 'are “id tohaw’ that V11" ed to provide a waterway of 5201hon. -friend said, llld il. will bf! 1‘1ll» W11011 llc 110241111 11181- E103! ue' 1 ug ten' ` lfeet auppored on creoeoted pile ‘ spread' through tho -P1655- 1-1131
work." it was estimated that. the Tll01l lily lion. i`i'ioiid cultic;-t to bumhes wi", slut ,-31| ‘pa,,»lhm.e was “-50 chi? ut un. 011' storm oi’ 1915, which was very; this I10luL in his arguilicnl, tbut beamsgf glneer fnrvidolng wer "on Dlirnley »»- rm"-
11311111190 111111 Ddl up n this House and sa e there ll` 3.51 1-'F118 9¢111°'|11'°` '
000 It le safe to any that the sturmtrol simply replaced ang her mx "M13 creowted He nf' Da," 'Mr
of i923 caused an expenditure evenl which we repealed. Now Mr. B,-11191,, t P 'yt Dr. .?lfl(h\lllILAlN: He said exceeding that amount, that th_le_St1eaker.v-‘cnialilttiin,am1the pu),__ _“R s_\Ux,D,__-.RS_ I Sm. project Mmm' ab ~ I pmjnt; ha paid _- Government had to look after in llc Accounts bear ' ‘ '
_ f _ ns out, th-t t _' Qi 'eh ed to anion- .
that ear. :rn-t. -Mr. .s eanerlnutthe it -d “-e‘\"'60 "‘°l‘°»-_"'15 'N '
» -I - ~i- r '~-t :<.t;0 - n t n .never aio. Do you 1u1°“'
lbullding up a few culvet-ts, a little °v¢r revenue was derived from' f,~:,(.)t‘.`5» “ me mu O rum .ivan 111°., engineer ls? The late. M1* more than this wonderful Wcstomlthat tax was to no to road pap ln. ¢__\U\»Dh-RS. I _._ , wh__,l.e,_.m. Milford H, hu aven to go down :Road which ini rovcd with it e’1‘0l work; d'I`h' - - 1 ~` N A 1 "ln - 1 o 1 ts' the lift” 1° U01 3011191111119 I? .tcwn to 19.3. when the non oov-~ iavo Carre out: that is why wc* 1 .. '_ . - ' . `- _ t g istowm Government. .. .'.::'.1..; ly, from that day, began to dlsinte-. not part of the general revenue ot' 3016.1 put- in it 1 Q also to talk about than the salary igrnto and .fall to ruin; n_incs,t re-1lh° Province. as my hon, friend Ali' SPE-\K1"l1‘ T11 11011 110111- dr an ofxillleer who has plswl ` markable phenomenon! I dowticlalms lt ls. We enacted It for a ber front' Clint-ltvfzotovfii was deal- aweyl That 8118111061' 11141 "'°"k °“ know whether it was natural or! special purpose; it was apent whol- mg with the suttentunt you made t 9 project; be was paid for it and _ unnatural; but from the day the| ly On the roads, and it is doing this afternoon ` t=et`is 'till there id albou/t it.Tho|e . Bell Government went out of of-_D006 WOI'k- i Mr SA1_,\,D.`FRs_ Oh th _.B an .N in 'mul' pat-ty thinp which 11" 111° W°‘*°"‘ 1-1°““» ‘"‘° ‘ 1’°°' 5 rtéitt- i know fi t1 in ha - are rnked ue-Inline* 1111* °°"°""` dog mourning for its master, took. tMr. Saunders Recants t H0°\_ DI. “2,1_;1__.___{ t;:_')__ec_ ment Tha, .re .|m°.¢ tw ._mail "° "‘°"° 1"‘°"°“ 1" 111°’ "° "'°r°l Th - No. 6b aiid'i>rol/ect no Stlllesoaide to answer: 'but theY'W111 1” '"' lntertot lrlthg pubgf, tart b_enl;n t_° has c°____1_‘_"_*“_1f_1£ w?fh111_'_’ t_01’1’;’”111°11. bv side. ewered, every one of them. MP'
dleln ellra er ccor ug ot e ea 1 _ a o iertcsper-I 'IL ___ n “om ___ __ _ .b _ |.u")_
er 01 the Opposition in 1923 it was_i*~° Ulllllz about Public Works. Ile ` 1' ' “'_1 C1 5 011 ll 9 P _D&‘s: 3 1,13. blllfl like n boulevard, and lu 192-l__h__u_as[ :1_4;Y:1__:_h_<;_i;t_a___l_s__t:_i;__l_tein ln _gte repcrtf :,1,),,;)'1§,,g15?e1f.°' n“:,‘;f_1; 1:1512; _h;1§_r'ms"‘l“"i)E1 awweregf ,_h`1_.1g_.;_lte
like a Dlouzhed field. full o oes. ' ' ~ 1‘€iZH1' 11g Darn~l H I D _ _ ' . I W.
with alder -bushes growing ln them. 161' 3111188, of so much money fort '[111 a1°"'. 11151, F °1°"°°1 °"°r' °.“ Y | y' 1| gd on page 7)
(Laughter). Creoaoted p1|es_ and he Says _her t Mi. SAUl\Dl'..RS. Hn! hal 1 ,Con nu
el a- _ . ` ' A
'Even holes in a road have aonie;111 1101- 0- Creohoted pile »in 'Durnlcyi ' ' '"
i ttnrldge I hi -
1’ 3 tl 4111* 1110 P01105 111-*-I‘i‘oJct't \’u 60 i is fr n
o .
n thati
knows about that blmuelf, This is 11910 18 Doi. it creosotcd pile lui an-other story. It is about an em- 'D“1'111°Y5 311080. orgen-try case. , Mr: SA=UlN'IlERlS: Project No 60, ivir. smuutnnits; Lute :inn nr- 1111111111119-
ternoon' ` HON D1' WOW!
know who built Dei1nl°ey0ll>3ll'i°tl5n:ln1 Pain 1` utr. s.t~Uuvnms= .na prom; N.,_| I - I '
I d0n't care whether it to Dam-
Bridge.
_im
Bnt
where
he .fell buck he
is
_ i
Y -1 11 .. _ g‘“° "6 1” 011101 1 C01-l vto.\5. D-. Mc.\tii.in.\': il - i t v rwerk on namlev BWI* `
meant a im-to more than s~imi>1y|111m specific purpose that what-tt. I "LS le “M” °