UNE itili“

Trenchant Revie

Governmenfs Mismanagement By Dr. W. J. McMillan InBud-

get Debate.

_ ), rcowrnvuev)

SITUATION NOT BOPEEUL

1d,, not think I need pursue this tter further. I am sorry for the mlwys because frankly I do not see m dgsllirght for them. I believe it my have been otherwise had this ma“ ndopted the proposal that was fiby my leader, Mr. Stewart. to- wn amended the Referendum l" by putting In it something defin ‘fin; the people the oppur- “mm, o; “lung lt over. Perhaps it ‘mm have been possible to put “mowing were on which the mem- r this Legislature could be un- befi five know, a; any rate that the m‘ y Wu ere going to satisfy the onlihw; is by giving them more n” go not askl“! I"? wuqénv but money. Now where mnpau ‘éoing to get it? Your Com- m l‘; m “men you seem to have 1533.“; 131th, says that it must come 06in Ottawa. or frmii the taxmayers a’ m5 province. The thing is to m. m persuade the tax PHYGYS that ‘My mg; pay this increase, l am rJN-ld. If $08 Put that proposal in u“ “not a, short time before an el- uuom you will get very unsatisfact- m, results, I am afraid the teachers‘ increase in salary 15 I ""5 l"? “n ' n; And I am, afraid that the P7911- mmn o; this Referendum Act is m ‘mission by the Government um may have not got very great he”; of obtaining any additional "way from the Dominion Govern- nmeni. If they were quite sure m“ they were going to get that pest increase which we have been lialrins about for the last tzvo years. “We would be a different stofy- The first year, it was almost within their "an; my, year it was still com- lng, I dont know w-hat is 80mg 9° happen next year. I would like to sec on; great big “egg? that the Illin- ister oi Agriculture has been hatch- mg roll-out of the basket, with its three 0r four yolks: 011B 0f ‘Mm m‘ m; the $100,000 cash settlement for the Dalton Sanatorium. I vfluld 11KB to see that yolk spilt across the} mo,» n1 this Chamber. ‘Wouldn't theI‘ miisici- of Agriculture be a Proud nsn trim" He would hall‘- luii-f-ed iiiirseli. But let them set this mm‘ sy from Ottawa, and then this Act . yin not be necessary.

Federal Grants Withdrawn

m only ray oi hope from Ottawa. it seems, l5 that there is a 200d Gm Government in this Province, be- muse if there was a Toll’ G°\'°Y"' merit m Dower, according to the lat- rst pronouncement of the Prime Min- ister of Canada, we-\vouldn‘t 09f» h“? cents. You know, after all, they life pretty well tied up at Ottawa. They

._.______

Recoil-Y) Failure Andlncompetency

w ‘Of Saunders

Zzalarid 133,000 pounds of butter- How much do you thing we imported last year? 33,000,000 pounds. 0f, course it is not very safe for me t0 discuss this, because, according to the Minister of Agriculture, I d0 not know anything about farming. But on the face of it I fall to see how the importation of 33,000,000 pounds of butter from New Zealand in the past year helps the dairy and cheese industry of Canada. I have yet to see the economist who can explain that successfully.

Do you know that we are sending to Great Britain 60,000,000 pounds of cheese less than we sent before the

war? Does that mean that the cheese and butter industry of Canada is flourishing? Do you

know that in the same time New Zealand has increased her shipments of cheese to Great Britain from 5i,- 000,000 pounds to 174,000,000 pounds a your? Which country do you think is making progress in the dairy in- dustry, Canada or New Zealand?

Do you know that a. few years ago we were sending 10,000,000 pounds of butter to the United States? Last year we sent 20,000 pounds. D0 you know that a few years ago we sent 240,000,000 pounds of bacon to Great Britain? Last year we sent 34,000,000 pounds. Do you know that our milch cows are going to the United States at the rate of 2,000 a month? Does that look like progress, so far as Can- adian industry is concerned? Do you know that. there were 102,000 less milking cows in Canada for the years 1927-28? That looks like progress in the Canadian dairy industry-but not in the right direction. Those are mat- ters which should be dealt with by an agrlculturlst. A plain medical man cannot deal with them; all he can do ls ask the questions.

Dairy Superintendent's Report

I want to refer-for a few minutes to the report of the Department of Agriculture. ‘This is the report of the late Mr. J. A. MacDonald, dairy superintendent. You‘ all know that unfortunately that splendid man has been called to a higher life; but ric loaves behind in this Province e re- read first S‘. will ‘s: vary alt to duplicate. He leaves the record of having placed the butter and cheese indsutry of Prince Edward Island at the top 0f Canada; a splendid man in every respect. His death has been a very great loss to this Province. T1136 I; é. ‘ti-Elie? an Whirl Frieze can be no controversy; and I think that every member of this Legislature shares the sentiment I have express- ed in this regard. iApplause).

Very recently this Dominion lost another man to whom Prince Edward Island owed a debt of deep gratitude. 1 refer to theh late Dr. James W. Robertson, who came here many years ago. and who was looked upon as the father of the cheese industry

cutoff the agricultural grant; they] cut on the technical grant; they cut) off the highways grant, and some of} the Liberal representatives of this Hovince voted against its continu- i. in? ti! Utter grant wouldi have meant so much to my hnn.1' friend, the big Minister of Public! Works. If he could only get some help frcin Ottawa, what wouldn't he d0! Bu: it is all cut off, and the Prime Alinister of Canada says, not) one five cent piece m a Tory G0v-| ernrnent. I do not believe that even] tbtt threat will keep the people oiE his Province from voting the wit. administration out of ofllcc.

Australian Treaty , The Minister of Agriculture tried "TY hard the other night tn tell us Whit a splendid thing this Australian “my was for Prince Edward Island. There are just one or two facts in this connection to which I would like to draw attention. The first. is this. l-hlt the dairy industry of Canada is "M11 between $250,000,000 and $000.- M-WO in revenue. To my mind, an. u"?! so important to the revenue I ‘i clfllda is worth protecting and l- (Applause. The favorable e balance of that industry a few W" W05 $50,000,000; and our l friends Will tell us that the l Govemment at Ottawa has I Wonderful thing beca they l treaty which permits zfllland butter to enter this Pflfitlflally free of duty. u“! '41"? came into effect. flanker, our favorable trade bsl- flwnned from 850,000,000 to "m- ""1 li- the rote it is going °° °l “I40 in this industry l» wiped an. "Pillar reusi-iicoic fact. A

1.10 from new’

would prevent the foreign product

in this Canada. Through his efforts) the first cheese factories were estab- lished in this Province. Dr. Robert- son also took a great interest in Red Cross work and in public health. It is remarkable that those two splendid men, whose services meant so much to the dairy industry in this Province, passed away at practically the same lime.

In his Dairy R/sport for 1029 the late Mr. McDonald stated:

"On Oct. 1B and 20 I attended the annual meetng of the Nation- al Dairy Council at Ottawa. This meeting was a good deal more in- terestlng from the standpoint of the producer than meetings held in former years. The price of cheese averaged about three cents lowcr than last year, and the same as two years ago, and was lower than it should be according to the price of butter. This was caused no doubt by the heavy shipments nf New Zealand cheese on the British markets. Cheese was assembled every two weeks and shipped direct to the Old Country via Halifax."

A TARIFF ANOMOLY

That bears out just what I have been stating, that the Old Country market is no longer favorable to us on account of the heavy shipments of New Zealand cheese. And why? Be- cause they am able to produce their butter and cheese very much more economically than we can in Canada. Wouldn't you naturally think that a Canadian Government, recognizing the handicap under which the dairy industry of this country is laboring,

from coming in at such a rats of duty as to place an additional handi- cap on our dairymen? It is as sim- ple as s. b, c. Canada f: the only

are CHARLOTTETOWN GUARDIAJ!

T onighfs Game

try in the civilized world is raisin; their tulfls. Another can of our be- ing right and the rest of the world wrong, l suppose. Csnula stands in the same relation to the‘ rest of the, world on the tlrlfl question as Prince Edward Island stands in relation to the rest of Canada on the Prohibition question. Canada is right on the ta:- ifl question and. the world is wrong. Prince Edward Island is right on the Prohibition question, and Canada ts wrong. That is a wonderful philoso- phy, but. I do not think it has much logic to support it.

Rovers And C. N. R. Recreation Club to Clash In Second Game Of City League

i ' "Puddy" Connors, stellar moundh‘ McInnis at third commands respect- man may do the twirling for the‘ As outer garden help.

PUBLIC HIGHWAYS

I would not like the Minister of Public Works to think that I am_

good deal of driving, both on the part2 of the City Baseball 1858M. bfiflilfl!‘ Z18. “B3113” Murley and Whitlock. v of the Opposition and the public together the Northenders and the! "Whackie“ McEachern stellar short

press. w set the Minister to do his, c. N. n. Recreation Club teams.‘ stop with the Rovers for three years,

work right. Hon members on the. which succumbed after ten innings’ wont; to play ‘that position for the

other side of the House have said on Monday night m the galloping Railway team, whether “Whackie" that it was the first time in the his- Sears tory of the Province that the Public

being derived from that Department

under the present Minister ma“ ever , two. Connors is the natural selection‘ preference.

bcmre‘ Bu‘ we know it ‘eqlmes a» yet the other pair could do very well‘ satisfaction ls being voiced by the lot o! educating w get the hon‘ gemi with the experience, before the race fans over the class of ball served up. $22?“ ‘tail: 111552;” magfilstregard’, gets too riot. in the opener. It was 1005B in SPOKE

the, U ,, . Tho the Rovers hsve in Connors,‘ but viewed in the- light oi a first; boulevards that have been built un- i I showed flashes u! better ;

oer hi5 administration. The senior; an ace m the hole’ they must season game

‘member from Summerside went so: the other pa“ against the time‘ things to come‘ ‘m, as to say that every mad m M51 when reserve hurling strength will‘ The C, N. R., club has evervtblnz, District was a boulevard. I wonder: count‘ w mom a‘ ‘staunch ban team Iromr what m‘ idea of a boulevard ‘s? I Champions of the circuit last year‘ and though beaten out by the belat- momred to sunlmerside quite onmi the Rovers look just as formidable ed onset of the Stars was top d0! last summela and I did not find ‘mu for the 1930 drive. Behind the plate‘ four-fifths of the W3)‘.

the roads were any better than mtthey have “Shono" Francis, cageyl Because of their acknowledged: any 0mm. pa“ o; the Provjnca-rherel from a dozen years in harness and class, the Rovers are expfilited w: is one mad from Ives Point to theiwielding a hefty bat. Their infield‘ draw a packed stand this evening. yvestem Road ma; is certainly not with the smart-fielding Urban BIBIPCNOW that the Recreation club has e, bonlevm-(L 1f you 5° on; from. chard on first, Johnny Williams atlshown a strong front, the question gnmrnerside on me western Reed. seecnid, Whelan at short and Percyqof supremacy is pretty well on the you will find many other examples. iknees of the god-S.

Go up past the stand-pipe to St. Eleanors and Travellers. Rest, and

5.33.03. 33.3313‘; $222.70.‘) Salient Facts About Speaker, should be better in this ' o Sharkey-Schmeling “G0”

Province than they are. Look at the. x

vast amount of money that has been}

expended. During the very first ses-i

sion of this Government they propos-l PrlllCiplii5—\I9.Ck Shaxkey, United States of America, Vs. Max Schmel- ed to borrow half a million dollars,ing, Germany.

for road purposes. We succeeded in: ‘Pitle at Stake-World's heavyweight championship.

cutting that amount down to $300.1 Length of Bout-Fifteen rounds to decision.

000; but they were bound to get that; Scene of Bonk-Yankee Stadium, 161st street and River Road. New half million, and the next year they iYork City.

borrowed an additional $200,000 in? Date.—'f‘l'iursday, June 12,

Shite of us. Referee and Judges-To be selected by Boxing Commission on day of

(T0 be continued) bout.

Time of Bout-ll o’elock (Atlantic daylight time.)

Probable Gate Receipts-—$l.000.000.

Probable Atte:'.dance-—8~i,000 people.

B l G l E A G u El Price of Seats—22,000 admissions at $2.10; reserved ‘seats, $5 25 t: $13.65; ,:ind ringside. $20.25.

Promoters—Milk Fund, conducted by Ivfi-s. William Randolph Hearst and (Canadian Pass)

I | l .

l Madison Square Garden Commotion. ‘ First bout of Evening-Ralph Ficucello Vs. Piet Brandt. six rouztds to ,:.tart at 9 o'clock. (Atlantic Daylight time.) l Second Bout-Paul Bianchi of Cuba. Vs. City, six rounds. Third Bout-Henry Lam“ of ITAIIIDNAL LEAGUE ‘ten rounds, _ i Semi-Final-Ai Fay of Louisville, Ky, Vs, Walter Cobb, of Baltimore. icri rounds. bout to go on after Sharkey-Schmelirig contest, Probable Betting—-Sharkey an a to 5 gnome | .. ‘_ '5 ‘Principals-Johnny Buckley, of Boston for Sharkey. Joe Melrie. Jones and B001; ' Hubbell Jacobs of New York for schmeling. and Howl. ' ‘Veishlfls-In-Tlme-Au fighters to wcigri in at Yankee Sadium at 2 [rrclock on the day of contest. In Event of Rah-Contest to be held next d

Stanley Parada, of Jersey

WBS-‘uneton. Vs. Mateo Osa, of Spain

"u"

Pittsburgh .... .. 2 B I.‘ New York ..... ...... .. 916 2

Cincinnati .. . . . Brooklyn

by, weather permitting,

u.- calls;

hibltion were: Prince Edward Island: Keith Bos- well, Victoria: E. H. Monkley, Sum.

x1 .124 r a Sukeiorth; viii-ice ' andgbeg§jl a" _ Foxes To Feature

Should Ilraw Big‘

I I

they can‘ neglecting him. 1t has required alRovei-s tonight in the second Same, “ll on Frank Cronin, Gus McKen-t

I l i is allowed to transfer his nimble self , “Puddy" Connors is one of three, to the new club ls a qufibiflll- Mm, Ww“ Dwlmmem W" "lnlmmlmir pitchers the Rovers can shoot IIVcertainly, the older team ls not iii-j pr°peflm m“ the" w“ "w" bend“ against the Recreation club, ‘Smack’: cliried m let him go, unless they get; iJohnson and Ford beins the bthfliflsomebody in return. 11 Pit-Pb" W.‘

. ‘ PAGE SEVEN

Tonightls Night!

SHAFEKEY o2 SCHMELING ~WHICH NAME WILL as

ENGRAVED ON THE CHAMPlONSl-HP TROPHY? SPORT eve. - . ' r Y

r

. @1930 King Future! Sy-sdimle, inc, Gm; Britain right‘ risen-ml.

If fair weather pr: mg, New York City's 111132 Yankce ; gtmium-“The House That Babe rimnicns, Jeffries, Ruth BuilV-should be packed 01th one of the most tremendous crowd; ever drawn to a boxing show when ::'.'a

- ~ e c zen jgjiesfg"gjl,hi“fmj‘jt jglilmsffféi cm i ,_ ed by the cool, calculating ‘Schlager; dulecl lS-round bout for the world's. Tough‘. Sharkey. of course. will ’ and that he will swing wild as he heavyweight championship, i try to perpetuate the American tra- . did aflflinsl- Phil 5mm 91' 51°“ “P as

Sharkey is the American cham- rlirion of that championship. Jack 1 h? did lifter Y-humpm! Dempsey m" pion; Schmeling is Europe's lie-auras born iri Binghamton. N. Y“ W° ‘minds- heavyweight. Boxing authorities t'.“0nfy-sc\'en years agO, about tvi-o’ ‘The SP9" Bu!» 11°“"9"°T- figures have agreed that the “inner Wm b; t-p; beforp a gggd German gtoyk‘ Shttrkey will make gO0d his thrfidt the ofilcial succeu’. to Gene Tun- tifiivcred Max as a fledgling Ham- and We“ Th” German 35 he d‘? ney who retired n5 world} champ- burger. The latter naturally has Tflmm)‘ T-Puéhran» If Jack does?“ ion two years ago ms summer. litrong support from nearly every- 510i) MEX 10,113.’ "m5 he “Wind 5W6

Since that time, Tunney,‘ and C116 with a trace of Teiifon in the‘ him a thorough bowls 165500. 5h"- “Billy” Muidoon. ileztor of the New" ‘olccd. “Der Moxie" is the Hinclen- K511 l5 =1 m0" Sure be” ma“ Dem?‘ York State Athletic Cbmmisslon, rin- burg of the hOlll‘ and the hembarnse" "5 “lam” T“‘“‘°-" l“ the“ nated a trophy upon which the name auare ivhsrever our German pals fir“ 5311i and-YT)" mo“ “h” ha?‘ of tonight's champion will be l‘.l-_ iii}; sport. Further schmeling has a P6119’?

dour facial resemblinw w 33¢!‘ Dempsey. and that doesn't hurt at Burns, Johnson, all Ln popular estlmfltlml.

A11 There 1;, a strcng impression a.- champ: were native Americans‘ mung Szhmelirlsi BUPWYIETB m“ qmi- and he beeame a U, 5, ' sharkey l5 too erratic. that hn nerves ,will play him false when confront-

Lil? names of these Sullivan, Corbett, Fit:-

Ll, 1111;, OTEII- ..

path of the plan in the face of dis-

10O Athletes Assured For The School Meet i

,track and field had fallen nito de- . cay. There ivas nothing to build on.

' _.____..__i-- ionly the tradition left b)‘ Island City schogls Held rz-hools to CClltlflllEJIXlfETlSlVE train-numbers of almost a decade ago. ' 1*’? iCourageously they mapped out their

lfllerside: G. E. Brown. Kensington. New Brunswick: f... T. Leeman, Salisbury: Dr. A. B. Teakles, Sussex:

l F‘. H. Copp. Port Elgin.

Chicago ,,,__, H," “H513 1: Mar. Winter

Philadelphia .... .... ...2 B 0

. . . _ V _ , ! Famous‘ hfapk h’ I imp; school meet even on a small scheme. maintaining an optimistic be lug Reqoudltlogled 3 ‘ ‘Til. been spoken of for lief that sthletcs still constitute an I Abegweits. Senior Ath- i

_ _ _ tile indications now are {U736 l0 1519-55 billi- I" letes Training Encour-

‘ilp ha; years. _ n, t e annnqgng pfggram project-l The: faith is being conclusively

Root and Hartriett, Collard and‘

Nichols and ltfeCurdy.

5t. Louis 0t Boston rain.

yfztponed,

INTERNATIONAL LEAGUE /

Buffalo .6 B ..ll i5

Baltimore

9

Russell. Mills, Buchanan and Mar- berry. Grube; M. Weaver, Schofl‘ and McMullen.

‘ AMHERST. U. 5.. Jlifle Ill-Space -for 400 foxes will be provided at the ,Ma.ritime Winter Fair for the first ' annual exhibition 0f black foxes that

will be held this season in conjunc-

tion with the Maritime Fair late in

the fall months. It was at first an- ‘ ticipated that only 225 foxes could ‘ be given room, but members of the ‘fox breeders‘ committee, in session ihere on Friday, made a thorough examination of the section allotted

the foxes and ascertained that a re-'

arrangement of the cages would per- ‘ mit nearly double the original num-

aged By Brighter Out-

Nova Scotla: Dr. Sproule, Spring-i _ look forRunningGai

hill. ‘ In the course of the consultation: '——-' between the officials of the Stock Tuesday afternoon the junior run- Breeders’ Association and the fox 1191's ‘mm Quite" square a“ “W: breeders, committee a pflzg 115; “'35 Kent Schools. held elinilnaliai: trial: drafted. Seven classes champions will be Qpgn gm- _ ‘standard bearers were pickcri l0 u?- petition. ‘hold school honors on June 1911i To Ribbons and cups wilt bs awarded ‘the long list of rural schools who to the prize-winning foxes and shave forwarded eiltrir-s A; trophy committee has been appoint- roiv subscribes. Mr Bfsv-rirse" r1’

com

details. The fox men were enthus- the Alexandra Community yester-

day.

gxgludjng ‘Scores of boys turned out. from which i

ed to decide upon these necessary Queen Square received the Pnlrics of.

rzi for Th‘. cu;- June 19th will be =1: imquaiifietl success trcin everj.‘ ‘uziglc. Flore iltnn twerty schools.

lwlinii inclurlc all the larger prepar- ‘nitrrv msiitiiiicis on the 1513001 811d flzini-n- rural lljlmlff’ schools are tak- r": arific p22‘?

In the _ before the we: a dual wack and f; cl SBUWYUTE “'35 34'- ' custmn between .~ and Watt Ken‘ SclioaLs. but "ivtiiiii: oi iiic lfaznitude ' of the "iiczil mic: "hoiasiic srorc 1'01" ‘i“.'j.’il'li2i|“;l zvas an unheard c.’ thing.

Queen f

'.'ustil‘ied. nct only bl‘ the hundred 0:- more names received for the card of events. but by the stimulat- ing influence felt among SELHOT run- ners long past school age.